Video není dostupné.
Omlouváme se.

Robert Price on Muhammad ﷺ as Paraclete

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 15. 02. 2023

Komentáře • 71

  • @Kimeikus
    @Kimeikus Před rokem +18

    The Prophet Muhammad’s legacy and influence and success (peace be upon him) eclipses all of those other guys.

  • @Dawahdude0
    @Dawahdude0 Před 3 měsíci +3

    Muhammad PBUH is more logical pick as compares to others

  • @KalimaTV
    @KalimaTV Před rokem +5

    Respect

  • @ozone2126
    @ozone2126 Před rokem +4

    😮😊 nice vid

  • @realszn
    @realszn Před rokem +10

    this is kinda cute

  • @falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543

    Original clip?

  • @LordYamcha666
    @LordYamcha666 Před rokem +4

    Awesome UwU

  • @ibraheemahmad7404
    @ibraheemahmad7404 Před rokem +2

    If there is no way to verify that, then what are you suggesting? God has failed the simple task of continuing His message?

    • @provingislam
      @provingislam  Před rokem +10

      Well he doesn’t believe in the bible .

  • @guineapigclips5205
    @guineapigclips5205 Před 3 měsíci

    Unfortunately for the muslim position, for every 1 church father that thought it was a man, 100 others thought it was the Holy Spirit. Not to mention the text litterally says its the Holy Spirit

    • @rollingknuckleball
      @rollingknuckleball Před 2 měsíci +3

      Jews dont need sacrifice to atone for sin

    • @ryuusuk33
      @ryuusuk33 Před 2 dny +1

      No. Few Early Christians church fathers are more valuable than later ones
      A “Paraclete” is someone who is called beside people to defend them like a lawyer in court. He will convict people (John 16:8) and testify (John 15:26). These are things someone does in court. How does the Holy Spirit fulfill this? He may inspire people to speak but he does not defend the people or speak for them or stand beside them. This description fits a *human individual* who will stand beside the people of God and defend them and be a spokesman for them. Some Muslims have argued that *the original word was “periklutos” which means “praised one” (the name of Prophet Muhammad PBUH)*

    • @guineapigclips5205
      @guineapigclips5205 Před 2 dny

      ​@@ryuusuk33 "No. Few Early Christians church fathers are more valuable than later ones"
      Even if we take this opinion, the vast majority of early Fathers say its the Holy Spirit.
      "A “Paraclete” is someone who is called beside people to defend them like a lawyer in court. He will convict people (John 16:8) and testify (John 15:26). These are things someone does in court. How does the Holy Spirit fulfill this?"
      In Acts 3, The Holy Spirit causes Peter to testify about Jesus. As for convicting people, this does not mean convict in the traditional way we would use the word, but rather something along the lines of 'expose.' Again in Acts 3, Peter exposes the Pharisees through the Holy Spirit.
      "He may inspire people to speak but he does not defend the people or speak for them or stand beside them. This description fits a human individual who will stand beside the people of God and defend them and be a spokesman for them."
      You forgot a crucial bit of the text that refutes the position that he must be a human individual who literally does all of these things. "The world cannot accept him, because it neither sees him nor knows him. But you know him, for he lives with you and will be in you." (John 14:17). This outlines 2 things. 1. He cannot be seen and thus cannot litterally testify. 2. He lives inside the disciples, and thus cannot be a human.
      "Some Muslims have argued that the original word was “periklutos” which means “praised one” (the name of Prophet Muhammad PBUH)"
      To put it simply, there is no evidence of this. Every single manuscript and church Father quote says Παρακλητος, not Περικλυτος.

    • @guineapigclips5205
      @guineapigclips5205 Před 2 dny

      @@ryuusuk33 "No. Few Early Christians church fathers are more valuable than later ones"
      Even if we take this opinion, the vast majority of early Fathers say its the Holy Spirit.
      "A “Paraclete” is someone who is called beside people to defend them like a lawyer in court. He will convict people (John 16:8) and testify (John 15:26). These are things someone does in court. How does the Holy Spirit fulfill this?"
      In Acts 3, The Holy Spirit causes Peter to testify about Jesus. As for convicting people, this does not mean convict in the traditional way we would use the word, but rather something along the lines of 'expose.' Again in Acts 3, Peter exposes the Pharisees through the Holy Spirit.
      "He may inspire people to speak but he does not defend the people or speak for them or stand beside them. This description fits a human individual who will stand beside the people of God and defend them and be a spokesman for them."
      You forgot a crucial bit of the text that refutes the position that he must be a human individual who literally does all of these things. "The world cannot accept him, because it neither sees him nor knows him. But you know him, for he lives with you and will be in you." (John 14:17). This outlines 2 things. 1. He cannot be seen and thus cannot litterally testify. 2. He lives inside the disciples, and thus cannot be a human.
      "Some Muslims have argued that the original word was “periklutos” which means “praised one” (the name of Prophet Muhammad PBUH)"
      To put it simply, there is no evidence of this. Every single manuscript and church Father quote says Παρακλητος, not Περικλυτος.

  • @IamTimOtheus
    @IamTimOtheus Před rokem +1

    It doesn’t make sense what other people say. The question is, what did Jesus say?
    16 And I will pray the Father, and He will give you another Helper, that He may abide with you forever-
    Jesus said to his disciple, there will be another helper that he may abide with you forever. Did Mohammed abide with Jesus’ disciples forever? The answer is no. Muslims are desperately trying to fit Islam in the Scriptures of the Bible. But the story of the Bible is complete, and Mohammed doesn’t fit in that story.

    • @Grancoupe2024
      @Grancoupe2024 Před rokem +13

      He clearly talks about the Quran that will abide with us forever bcz Allah promised to preserve it
      Btw are the disciples immortals that they will live forever ?
      Muhammad pbuh fits perfectly in the story
      1 - he is a descendant of Ishmael ✅
      2 - isaiah 42 : The chosen servant from mount Sela is in Medinah the exact location of Muhammad pbuh ✅
      3 - Deuteronomy 18:18
      “I (God) will raise them up a Prophet from among their brethren, like unto thee (Moses), and will put my words in his mouth; and he shall speak unto them all that I shall command him.” ✅

    • @STEWJO004
      @STEWJO004 Před rokem +12

      No need to try and "fit" anything because:
      1. God never sent the Bible, He sent the Law and Gospel
      2. There' a nice "chain" of prophecies for us in Daniel 2, John 1:19-28 and then to the Parable of the Tenets

    • @falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543
      @falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 Před rokem +6

      Jesus said keep following the law in john 14 :23 i think, and you won't be orphaned until the paraclete comes, paul removed the law in romans 10 :4 matches fake prophet of mathew 24 :11 and in acts 9 :3 saw deviI of luke 10 :18... in acts 3 :20 - 22 he says another Prophet is after Jesus like Musa... Isaiah 42 the Name Ahmad is found in the d. sea scrolls, the new covenant of mt selah Medina, paul in gal 1 :17 even went to Arabia. Duet 33 :2 Lord went from Mt sinai or Moses to Seir or Jesus to Mt. Paran or Mecca with 10k, this matches Solomon 5 :10 1-16 saying a man will lead 10k and describes him physically and in hebrew the name in verse 16 is Prophet MUHAMMAD-im peace and blessings be upon him. Game over!

    • @falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543
      @falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 Před rokem +3

      paul thought he was the very prophet that would correct him!
      Irony!

    • @IamTimOtheus
      @IamTimOtheus Před rokem

      @@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543
      John 14:23
      23 Jesus answered and said to him, “If anyone loves Me, he will keep My word; and *My Father will love him, and We will come to him and make Our home with him* 😳🤔😉