This is a lecture within a series that Sproul gave. This one introduces the difference between "existence" and "self existence." Humans exist. God is self-existent. Big difference. For further reading: "Not a Chance", by RC Sproul.
Most comments here are either by Christians who are upset by the title of the video before watching or properly understanding it....or atheists who are upset by the title of the video because they watched hoping for some good talking points that they can use as they troll through Christian YT videos but they either stopped watching or didnt properly understand it. Kind of funny.
Joshua Traffanstedt Yeah well, I'm 100% certain that you're wrong.....so, there's that. Your percentages mean as much to me as mine does to you. Have fun being an anti-theist. Hope you change your mind one day.
1 Peter 1:8New International Version (NIV): 8 Though you have not seen him, you love him; and even though you do not see him now, you believe in him and are filled with an inexpressible and glorious joy,
Nah... I’m an atheist but I just love listening to both sides of the argument. Your focus should definitely be on the Christians who are commenting before even listening to the video whatsoever. I’m open to all ideas and I’ve used all that I’ve heard, seen and experienced to make up my own mind. Seriously.... did you even read the comments??? Where are these “atheist trolls” you speak of??? Cuz the atheist Channels are OVERFLOWING with religious trolls. So I do believe you’ve gotten it backwards, my dear.
Christina Fidance It was a joke comment, quit taking it seriously big brain? Or did it offend you? A bunch of people who came clicking on this video are atheists with expectations which was betrayed. Same here, but I’m theist who like to listen to both sides of the argument. Read the comment properly, I didn’t mention atheist trolls, it’s “How to troll atheists” I assume English ain’t your first?
@@djperryboy Even more! Astronomers are sons of Satan because they believe that our planetary system is heliocentric. Which is derived from Hell'o centre.... I'm amazed how those people from classical Rome were so smart and created Latin with modern English in their minds... Outstanding ;-)
@minecraftkaas No God isn't fake. God is real and everyone knows it, even you. God has put it in all of our hearts and consciousness that He exists ( Ecclesiastes 3:11), that's why the bible says a fool has said in his heart that there is no God because they are choosing to be foolish and deny true knowledge and truth while full knowing that God exists, they chose to deny God because they want their sins and want to stay in their sins but it's a horrible choice to choose sin over God ( Psalms 14). when they chose sin over God, the devil takes hold of them and sin rules them but don't let the devil keep you blinded from the glorious Gospel of Jesus Christ ( 2 Corinthians 4:4), don't stay in your sins for sin leads to death ( James 1:17). remember We all will meet the one true and only God the Holy Creator one day ( Hebrews 9;27) and He's being merciful by giving us all time to get right with Him before judgement day, because when judgement day comes you get no second chances. God came as Jesus in the flesh to go and pay our sin debt on the cross, we deserve hell we deserve to take our punishment but in His great love and mercy He took our punishment and sins to the cross. He died and paid for our sin debt in full ( John 19:30) then God rose Jesus on the third day with glory and power and triumph and He conquered hell, sin, death, satan, the world. God broke down the wall that separated us from Him so we can come to Him and be saved and have a relationship with Him. believe and repent of your sins and God will forgive and cleanse you and make you born again by His Holy Spirit ( John 3). today is the day of salvation, you don't know what day or hour or minute or even the second you'll die. Heaven is eternal and hell is eternal as well. Jesus is the only way to Heaven He's the only way we can be saved from sin and from hell ( John 14, Romans 6:23, Romans 10:9-14). don't choose sin over the Holy loving God. come to Jesus! believe and repent ( 1 Cor 6:9-10, Romans 3:23, John 3:15-18, Rom 10:9-14, NKJV).
@@jesusfollowerswomenministries unfortunately u are wrong. It has been proven by physics and science that there is no possible way God is real or exists. We are literally just evolved forms of apes. We have been evolving for over 7 million years. Millions of years ago the first caveman was walking on earth. Then were more to come. There are evidence for this to back up my claim. How was earth created you may ask? Well when the solar system settled into its current lay out about 4.5 billion years ago earth formed when gravity pulled swirling gas and dust into the third planet from the sun. So yes God isn't real. Sorry for debunking this lol. Also no being could have ever seen and wrote about God. This is because paper didn't exist back then meaning, that someone made the whole thing up. You may believe that God, an impossible being that couldn't even exist is real, but you are denying yourself the truth. Let's just say God was real for a second. Would he like that you were forcing ur beliefs on others. If God was real why would he let 9/11 happen? God was born in the middle east means he is Jewish and he is black. So why would he let George Floyd die? Why would he racism be a thing? Why would he let innocent people of his own race that apparently "created" die? That's right he wouldn't. He would try and help them. So why didn't he? Because he's not real. DEBUNKED
@@pineapplepenumbra Yes, the video was sad in the traditional and technical sense, because the truth is truly sad as its the one thing we don't control and are entirely vulnerable to. This video is about the true meaning of "Exist" and it delivers
I just came to hear someone's perspective; see what their thoughts on the matter were. It's a shame people must take a topic so personally, regardless of your stance.
But is that not circular reasoning? You're saying that because the Bible says that God said "I will be what I will be," that God therefore is, but you are assuming the Bible is true. Why is it true? What Sproul is talking about has to do with Aristotle's potentials for change. Basically if anything has potential for change (occupies space, changes location, ages, etc.) then it is natural. If something occupies space then it has mass; if it has mass then it is subject to the passage of time. If God exists then he must occupy space, have mass, and therefore be subject to time which makes him a natural being, not supernatural. Hawking said that time did not exist before the Big Bang, so how could God, a natural being, set the Big Bang in motion? Therefore there cannot be a God.
Sag Bag that’s not what he was saying at all. He never claimed gods existence, or lack thereof, he simply pondered what he would think of a biblical quote. Chill out a lil man
Sag Bag also, god, by default, is a supernatural being. He “exists” outside of natural laws. Also, time “began” because experience began, and time is an experience. God is not an experience, and is not contingent on existence of others
Okay how about this - I make a robot that says that and now it is a person? Or now it is a god? You see it doesn’t make much sense and the Bible was written by psychopaths
Hes using word play and actual meanings. He believes in God. He's just saying exists is inaccurate word to speak of God. I get it but I'll still say he is. In our terms the word exists simply means to be
What you call "word play" is called philosophy among educated people, which is the foundation of all science. Without philosophy of science we wouldn't even be able to define what is true and what is not.
what you actually call philosophy is a word play, i can argue from anthropological point of view, other issues like the evolution of language, what we actually have now is the pragmatic understanding or meaning - existence, to come into being or not but can you actually tell what exist and what doesn't thus at the end we end up on a socially conditioned term and definition . i think the only sensible meaning is that God is real and he is existence himself.
@@Justanobodybro sure he is. It's not enough to believe in a goD. You have to pick the right goD out of all the available choices, and he chose the wrong imaginary friend. Poseidon did not look favorably on him for his life of blaspheming
Context is key in defining "existence" and, in fact, most words. As we learn in school context clues can help us define words For that reason, the context Sproul uses to define "exist" is completely right But since most people don't use the word "exist" in that way or understand it that way, it may still make sense to use it in "most" situations Still, very good teaching God bless him
All im gonna say is, in life there is always 2 sides to everything, good and bad, life and death, left and right, up and down, even and odd, they're the opposite, so if there is mortals, then there must be an immortal too,which is God.
Somethings are right even if nobody is right while other things are wrong even if everybody is wrong. *Seeking to be wise they become like fools. They exchange the truth of God for a lie.*
change your profile picture and turn away from such evil content, its not moral (don't say or think about how there are immoral things in the Bible because it contains things that actually happened, its not for entertainment)
@@lynnxpooh9024 "im just saying you shouldn’t be taking this risk." So you're suggesting that god doesn't have a sense of humour, or, possibly, has very little patience, compared to a mature human? *If* you're worried about people disrespecting god, that would mean that you should be worried about the 5 billion or so idiots on the planet who follow the torah, bible or qur'an, all of which *massively insult* any god that might exist, far beyond just, "you're gay"!
@John barfneck whattt why do you comment on people you dont know is that apparantely a bad thing you can ask a goddamm stranger on the internet a question what the hells wrong with you lol
@John barfneck Bruh the video has nothing to do with God and people comment "I knew God was real" It's called common sense. Maybe try to use it someday.
I was going to because I'm not having a very good evening to begin with. Secondly, the title of the video is counterintuitive to logic. There's a billions worth of perspectives that call things/actions gods. So what is god? An omnipotent being or supernatural forces perhaps. The word is not that well defined as those that use it in terms to describe the thing they are calling it because when you distill it down to basic, god would be everything. And me..well I want to be nothing. Void being and void existence all together. That's what brought me here and wanting to comment before or after watching about 10 seconds worth after seeing the comments that this guy is lying in the first place. Just being honest, don't crucify me.
@@alejandroangel5908 Jeremiah 29:13 You will seek me and find me, when you seek me with all your heart. Hebrews 11:6 But without faith it is impossible to please Him, for he who comes to God must believe that He is, and that He is a rewarder of those who diligently seek Him.
Up until they showed the back of the old peoples' heads toward the end, for some reason I pictured a group of kindergarteners who had no idea what was going on.
Wowed, this is the one of the most powerful simple but very complex explanation of the Holy Trinity. Amen 🙏🏾😇🙏🏾 See you in Heaven Dr Sproul to give you a loving Hug brother!!
I love it! God is, was, and will always be. Non-believers ask, "where did God come from, or who created God?". Rather than describe God as merely existing leaving the question of how God came to exist, as Christians, we should be stating confidently and proudly reinforcing the fact that God is eternal. For those of us who know God, eternity is not a concept but a fact and a truth from God who is eternal.
+Ron Bozich "God is, was, and will always be." How can you possibly make such a claim? "Rather than describe God as merely existing leaving the question of how God came to exist" Because its much easier to ignore obvious logical errors. There is absolutely no reason for anyone to believe in an omniscient, omnipresent, omnipotent being, considering it is logically impossible for a single entity to possess all 3 said attributes.
+Larry Crabs There is absolutely no proof that human beings evolved from fish.... Are you an evolution (a potential cause to our reality) believer? If there is a debate here, I am on the side of God because He revealed Himself to me. I was a non-believer for the first 52 years of my life until God changed my mind. I can, and do, have a relationship with God. I know with great certainty that He exists. Do you know with great certainty why we experience reality? I would never tell you that I can prove God to you. But I will tell you that God can prove Himself to you. Shalom!
Ron Bozich "Are you an evolution (a potential cause to our reality) believer? " No, I accept evolution because it has mountains of evidence from various different disciplines of science. "He revealed Himself to me" That is called religious psychosis. There is help out there, if you choose to seek it. "I know with great certainty that He exists." No, you don't. You really want god to exist. You want it so bad that you imagine this non-existent deity appear before you.
+Larry Crabs Also your "mountains of evidence" for our reality is all from God, not from science. With your evidence, produce a species that was transitional into both a walking creature and a flying creature. Somewhere in your evolutionary record there must be a common land creature that mutated into both an erect walking creature and a flying creature with wings???
For me its simple. To look at EVERYTHING, how it works. The checks and balances. The shear complexity. The fact that planets do not crash into each other. The fact that we hang in space without falling into chaos. The fact that today, astronomy can tell you when you will see this comet or, that eclipse and that you can time the cycles down to the second. The fact that the simplest cell, must have all of its components present at the same time or it dies. The fact that the DNA is so awesomely complex with so much information in it, boggles the mind. When atheists deny the existence of God, they look at creation s components individually. But, when you look at ALL creation, and see how it all functions together, there is only one conclusion. We need to pray for people like Richard Dawkins because once they enter eternity, life, or summation will be final.
Atheists like me don't hate religious people because of what they think, it's because of what they do. Believing in god is fine but using it for money and fame isn't. I'm fine with christians if they don't use religion to disprove science. You can't prove god exist with science. You can use philosophy to prove it like this video and that's fine. Even though I am a atheist, I like christianity. It's a great way to teach morality. I believe that christianity doesn't help you physically but it helps you mentally.
Everyone knows that God exists. Because when they stand before Him on judgement day they will be without excuse. And as you quote that verse of scripture note that "there is" is in italics those are words that aren't understood to be in the Hebrew text it is put in there in an attempted help us understand the verse when it should read "the fool says in his heart no God" as if to say "no God" for me. The people who say there is no God are trying to lie to themselves when all of creation and the visible and the invisible shout God exists. Grace be with you brother/sister in Jesus Christ the savior who was God in flesh.
@@dustymar4341 Remember Those are not my Words. My friend in whom i know nothing about . However, Have you received The Holy Ghost since you believed ? Acts 19 Read it. How were you Baptized ?
@@deuteronomy6436 if you are talking about acts 19 :3-5 . Paul is asking a question about baptism and who they are baptized by. This where Paul refers to what is said in Luke 3:16 John answered, saying unto them all, I indeed baptize you with water; but one mightier than I cometh, the latchet of whose shoes I am not worthy to unloose: he shall baptize you with the Holy Ghost and with fire: So to answer your question I was baptized of the Holy Ghost into repentance and Faith that Jesus Christ is Lord so that I will made acceptable in the presence of the Father because of what Christ did on Calvary. But the commit on the fool verse was me going into further detail on the verse.
@@dustymar4341 No. The question was Whose name where they baptized in. You see next they were rebaptized in Jesus Name and Paul laid hands on them and they began to prophesy. Not baptized by but baptized in JESUS NAME just like Acts 2:38 By the Way, it is The REAl Baptism.
Well, yes, God does not exist as matter-energy. He is not some big old guy up in the sky with a long white beard, throwing thunderbolts at people He doesn't like. It's like the question, "Who created God?" God IS and is eternal so never needed to be created. He is not a created being.
Wow, it's quite hilarious reading these comments below. Half the people here didn't even watch the video. Here's a hint: the title is a BIT misleading. It's not what you think. Watch and find out..
Seeing the number of "thumbs down" responses on this video shows the unfortunate state of the viewers (or mere visitors to the link). One is either utterly ignorant of his point, has just taken a surface look and decided to make a response without even watching the video, is an atheist, or just hates RC Sproul and/or his reformed view. I suppose another option would be that it was hit in error. There should be no such reaction from any person professing to be a Christian. There was no greater professor for the "existence of God", as it is called, than RC Sproul.
The title reflects exactly what Sproul said in the video, just not in the way most modern English-speaking people understand it (that is, the term "existence"). Click bait is deception; this title doesn't qualify as deception.
The title was misleading, but he did not prove that god does is not there, because it can't be done. If something is not there, you can't prove that or it is unnecessary to think anyone could or should. Although this was also not proof of God being there either, but it was a good explanation of what he thinks humans mean when they talk about god. I know he is breaking down with the word "exist" like it didn't apply to god, but our language is for us to use to understand what we can know in our realm about anything so other humans will know what we mean. To say god doesn't exist because "exist" doesn't work on god, then we just have to make up another word to mean if god is there and we'd still be in the same position as before when using the word exist. If he's going to break down word this way and say they don't apply to where god is, as he does not exist in his own realm because existing means to become rather than always be, then one can probably say no words could be applied to god, like "real" because he would not be real where he is either. Real is a human word having meanings that use the word exist in it. I'm glad he proved god isn't creature like us since creature comes from creation. I suppose that means we are all not created in his image as it's been told, since he doesn't have the image of a creature like us. I think this man is helping prove god isn't there more than what he intended.
Imagine a situation, where, something can be found out. If one side tells a person who can get this information. Now 2 things occur. Either, that person simply believes the person telling them is just completely nuts, because there is no evidence then so be it. Then, that person then can just keep doing what they were doing in their own private sanctuary as they were before, living within their free rights. Or, that it is known, yet covered up to such a level--Where the person telling it will never be allowed to have access due to the other side being of a satanic realm. They, living by that faith (Knowing how real God is by doing just what they do) and for the lie & deceit by the nature of the beast they represent. And by default--Allows said person to retain their free rights by those means as well. Living, as a non criminal, only expressing themselves in a free society--Having not lost those rights. Either 2 gets back to that same place. How could such a thing be possible--Other than by God existing could it be so?
The Bible says in John 3:16-36 that whoever believes in the Lord Jesus Christ shall not perish but have everlasting life, the Bible also says in Romans 10:9 that those who declare with their mouth that Jesus Christ is their God, Lord, and Savior they shall be saved. Revelation 1:8 says that Jesus is the alpha and the omega. Luke and revelation is the ending times, and Jesus is returning back. So are you going to submit your life to him or no? Narrow is the path that leads to the gates of heaven, but only few people find it. The gates that is the path to destruction is where many people find it! Jesus loves you SO MUCH! That he died on the cross, and was resurrected from the dead 3 days later to give us eternal life..!.!..!..
Okay if he exist, what is God? If you ask a thousand believers you will have a thousand different stories of what God is. That is the truth that he only exist in your mind..
Romans 10:9 [9]That if thou shalt confess with thy mouth the Lord Jesus, and shalt believe in thine heart that God hath raised him from the dead, thou shalt be saved.
If God created everything that exist, there was a time when he commenced to create. Back of that commencement there must have been an eternity. In that eternity what was this God doing? Was God inactive prior to creation? He certainly did not think. There was nothing to think about. He did not remember. Nothing had ever happened. What did he do? Can you imagine anything more absurd that an infinite intelligence in infinite nothing wasting an eternity?
If god exist and he created the universe he had to create laws of physics. Before doing so, he was outside time because, indeed, he created time. Trying to understand this is just as ridiculous as to deny any posibility, the Universe as structred and perfect as it is it's just a proof there is an existance beyong it who was capable of putting all these atoms together.
@@salvadorteran3575 Time is a man made concept to determine past, present, and future. There is no such thing as the beginning of time. God could have not created time because it is logically impossible. As well as God can't make a triangle with four sides because a four sided triangle is a logical impossibilty. "The dividing line between past, present, and future is an illusion. So reality is ultimately TIMELESS." - Albert Einstein.
@@salvadorteran3575 "Before doing so, he was outside time because, indeed, he created time." What would that even mean? What does it mean for something to exist "outside" of time? "Outside" is a spacial orientation, that would require God to exist within space time.
Is this that much different from modalism? I’m not a modalist, but the way he describes the Trinity doesn’t seem to me as heavily contradicting of modalistic theology as it may seem. Or maybe modalism adds something that makes it heretical. Anybody takers?
The creative force behind all space, time, matter, and energy and not a shred of empirical evidence of his existence. That crushes my faith. I HATE having faith. I HATE having hope. I rather die a sinner and experiencing fun than die a saint, live a life of piety, and discover there is no afterlife.
We are not even a speck on the face of the whole universe and here we are trying to disprove god. It’s simple logic, we are a complicated species in a huge universe the signs are all around us. Something created this complicated species. Something more complicated than us.
Crypto Boner he still believes that there is a god he’s just stating how using the word exist is wrong when talking about god because of the words origins and what those origins mean. if you actually watched the video you’d know
Does your name mean your boner is hidden? Interesting choice for a name of someone who is hidden by the internet but your boner is never in the open, I would hope, even when boner is used to mean mistake. But your boner in that sense is that you are convinced that God does not exist. Big mistake...
Romans 10:9 [9]That if thou shalt confess with thy mouth the Lord Jesus, and shalt believe in thine heart that God hath raised him from the dead, thou shalt be saved. Its as easy as that and otherwise i would actually be more than happily to believe like he does because he is right
He just explained that God does not exist in the sense that the english language uses "exist". R.C. also noted that God's disposition is not createrly therefore he can not be becoming (exist in this context). His argument is contingent upon God being eternal and not subject to change (I.e. aging).
Jack Cassidy McCarthy every time you pray something good happens around you. God can’t control what you think cause it’s your mind. And he can’t control people around you. So it’s not his fault people do bad things around you but he can do something that can make someone change their mind on their own for example: Let’s say your hungry but you look in your fridge and there’s nothing for you to make or eat cause your missing ingredients, but you could’ve sworn yesterday you had enough food but you just shrug it off and decide to go get food once you start walking to the store you see a homeless man being mistreated by other people they are kicking him and punching him and the homeless man just tries to protect his head, these other people have minds of their own a gift God gave them and now you have to make a choice: A. Help the homeless man and tell them to stop. B. Don’t care it’s whatever he’s homeless for a reason, it’s his fault he should’ve studied. What will it be? Why did your food go missing all of a sudden? Why are you here in this position? Why you? Why now? What if they go as far as killing him? Why *DOES* it matter ?
@Supreme 12191 Psalms 14:1 : "The fool hath said in his heart, There is no God. They are corrupt, they have done abominable works, there is none that doeth good."
Keith Thompson Oh, sorry Keith, I just watched the beginning of the video and I got the idea that he is trying to deny the existence of God. Thank you for making me watch the video until the end and I got the truth. Please accept my apologies. May God bless you.
All he did was change the meaning of words from their accepted everyday use to come up with a pseudo clever argument that people who already believe in a god seem to like. note his argument is valid for ANY concept of a god. Thor, Yahweh, Allah, apollo the FSM. Not so clever really is it?
170221dn isn’t that what atheists also do tho? Come up with arguments to defend why they don’t believe in a God? Everyone does that. Everyone defends what they believe or don’t believe in. Of course they do.
Good gamblers do not make bad bets. Atheists get no lasting reward but if there is a God the ones seeking God get a reward. Being religious has a good chance of eternal blessing.
Why should you be punished simply for not believing in that one specific god? If everyone were to die right now, should 70% of the human population that either believes in different god(s) or no gods at all be sent to hell simply for not believing in that particular god?
No one can prove or disprove. Theists believe for personal reasons. Atheists don't believe for personal reasons. There could be a force such as God but until it is discovered or factually proven wrong, we're all just expressing opinions
U stupid dumshit u know humans wont listen until they see that with their own eyes so until they have proven evidence they stop believing but there is no proven evidence so they wont listen so ur are dumber then society
I’m extremely confused and want answers (don’t read if you don’t want to, I’m just ranting. Read if you’re interested in my existential crisis) I’ve been looking at every bit of evidence. I would really want for something to exist a “god”, but reality and our evidence proved that there is nothing. But our evidence also can’t prove nothing, at least not at the 4th dimension/ our “time” so is there something is there nothing or what is there, if there even is anything? I watched a video of a guy in a TED talk, who said that everything was random, extremely convincingly. That it was our “reality”. If it’s our reality than why does it seem impossible to prove it. Also, the god theory, if there is a god why can’t we find proof. Why is there zero, not even the most absurdly tiny amount of evidence of it being so? Why are there over a thousand Gods without proof or evidence. Scientist also say that religious humans have a tendency to place god as the factor for why we don’t understand something as opposed to understanding it. But they are talking general God’s what if God isn’t really the word god, but the whole universe itself. Now we change the word god and put the universe. The universe is physical... well somewhat. Time isn’t, but we know it’s there because it’s happening. The universe is somehow tho, still part of what we know and see. So what was the start of everything. Stephen Hawkins said that there was no time before the Big Bang. It was just an it, so what caused “it” alright I’m back in the same loophole.
@@BonQy no one can prove to you if God exists or not. Jesus said just before they crucified Him. If they do this to the tree when it's still green, imagine what they will do when its dry. The end is near and satan wants us confused. Either you believe or you don't. It's our love of sin that keeps us from accepting God's existence. It's up to you brother. Love.
Gert Scheper. Then very best i can do i pray for you that you allow the Lordin your life,before its too late..becouse there is no repentance in Hell..no not even hope!Christ is 👑.
I think I got sucked into another misleading title. I appreciate the logical assumptions and all Mr. Sprouls has definitely proven nothing. Better to be cold than luke warm though. There is always hope!
God is a game that is played with experience, the Devil is the opposition, and the goal is to understand and know God. This game is a game that is incredibly hard, so hard it grabs the time and effort and attention of the entire day. But the reward is far greater after winning the game.
By definition RC is very accurate. God is more than a gas or blob through the universe but a personal brilliant beyond our comprehension being. Blow your mind more, has 3 persons/each with personalities that Function totally in harmony as ONE.
Do we exist because of the universe? or does the universe exist because of us (God created all this for us)? If we cease to exist, would the universe cease to exist too? if the universe ceases to exist, would we cease to exist? did the universe exist before us? would it exist after us?
A dialogue between myself and the Devil: The Devil: Do you believe in Jesus Christ? Do you believe he is your Lord and Savior? Me: Yes. The Devil: How can you? There is absolutely no conclusive historical evidence he ever existed! Evolutionary science has proven Creationism to be false. Furthermore, greater destruction and violence has been carried out on Earth in the name of Jesus Christ than anyone or anything else!Me: I agree, and that is how I know my faith has been purified from the influence of this world.
"The fool hath said in his heart, There is no God. They are corrupt, they have done abominable works, there is none that doeth good. The Lord looked down from heaven upon the children of men, to see if there were any that did understand, and seek God. They are all gone aside, they are all together become filthy: there is none that doeth good, no, not one. Have all the workers of iniquity no knowledge? who eat up my people as they eat bread, and call not upon the Lord . There were they in great fear: for God is in the generation of the righteous. Ye have shamed the counsel of the poor, because the Lord is his refuge." Psalms 14:1-6 KJV "For the wicked boasteth of his heart's desire, and blesseth the covetous, whom the Lord abhorreth. The wicked, through the pride of his countenance, will not seek after God: God is not in all his thoughts." Psalms 10:3-4 KJV
Yeshua Is My Shepherd The right hand of the LORD is exalted: the right hand of the LORD doeth valiantly. Psalm:118:16 I shall not die, but live, and declare the works of the LORD. Psalm:118:17 The LORD hath chastened me sore: but he hath not given me over unto death. Psalm:118:18 The Right hand of the lord is jesus!
Yeshua Is My Shepherd u didnt get my point! It is messianic psalm about jesus being saved from the cross! He was saved! He didnt die on cross! His substitute was crucified not him!
Ahmed Deedat We cannot sustain this affirmative just put one verse only out of context, but we have to know the all Scripture. And the Scripture says that Jesus was crucified and at the third day He rosen from the death by the power of God Almigthy. He is the Lord and He and the Father was one.
Nobody knows anything until it happens, every individual person does not know what is outside of life until they pass away, but there is no way of telling another being what happens, there is no reason to fear dieing because I would (ASSUME) that what is once something will never be nothing
I love this argument. I’ve heard the argument that the earth itself is personal. That’s another fun one. God always is and always has been. That’s one thing that makes him so wonderful. To live for Him is the greatest thing a person can ever do.
The Person who posted this video has used REVERSE PSYCHOLOGY on all of us
He didn't use anything, if he did then it didn't work, at least not for me
This is a lecture within a series that Sproul gave. This one introduces the difference between "existence" and "self existence." Humans exist. God is self-existent. Big difference.
For further reading: "Not a Chance", by RC Sproul.
Most comments here are either by Christians who are upset by the title of the video before watching or properly understanding it....or atheists who are upset by the title of the video because they watched hoping for some good talking points that they can use as they troll through Christian YT videos but they either stopped watching or didnt properly understand it.
Kind of funny.
Jason Mahurin I myself am neither theist or atheist. I'm an anti theist. I can say with 99.9% certainty that GOD DOES NOT EXIST.
There's always that .01% chance I'm wrong. I'll take those odds.
Joshua Traffanstedt Yeah well, I'm 100% certain that you're wrong.....so, there's that.
Your percentages mean as much to me as mine does to you.
Have fun being an anti-theist. Hope you change your mind one day.
1 Peter 1:8New International Version (NIV): 8 Though you have not seen him, you love him; and even though you do not see him now, you believe in him and are filled with an inexpressible and glorious joy,
How can u be 'anti' to something u acknowledge doesn't exist?
This is a huge “How to troll Atheists” video
Nah... I’m an atheist but I just love listening to both sides of the argument. Your focus should definitely be on the Christians who are commenting before even listening to the video whatsoever. I’m open to all ideas and I’ve used all that I’ve heard, seen and experienced to make up my own mind. Seriously.... did you even read the comments??? Where are these “atheist trolls” you speak of??? Cuz the atheist Channels are OVERFLOWING with religious trolls. So I do believe you’ve gotten it backwards, my dear.
Christina Fidance It was a joke comment, quit taking it seriously big brain? Or did it offend you? A bunch of people who came clicking on this video are atheists with expectations which was betrayed. Same here, but I’m theist who like to listen to both sides of the argument. Read the comment properly, I didn’t mention atheist trolls, it’s “How to troll atheists” I assume English ain’t your first?
Christina Fidance I’m curious, who do you like to listen to?
@@itzabhinav2220 Imagine believing in something that people made up
@@TeamFortressClassic Sure chief, what makes you sound smart and superior.
The title should be changed to
"The definition of the word exist"
Which is not even true because ex and exist are completely different words and have nothing to do with each other
@@djperryboy Even more! Astronomers are sons of Satan because they believe that our planetary system is heliocentric. Which is derived from Hell'o centre.... I'm amazed how those people from classical Rome were so smart and created Latin with modern English in their minds... Outstanding ;-)
@@tjblues01 so how many satans are you talking about
@@sic650 As many as angels in Honda...
tjblues01
Not at akl.not everybody every thing is satan.This one reason out of thousands I am am wicxan not a Christian
This is lowkey clickbait, and I love it.
Low key? I fell out of my chair!
It is not clickbait
@@krazo4Christ ~ Amen Cory! :D So did l.
@minecraftkaas No God isn't fake. God is real and everyone knows it, even you. God has put it in all of our hearts and consciousness that He exists ( Ecclesiastes 3:11), that's why the bible says a fool has said in his heart that there is no God because they are choosing to be foolish and deny true knowledge and truth while full knowing that God exists, they chose to deny God because they want their sins and want to stay in their sins but it's a horrible choice to choose sin over God ( Psalms 14). when they chose sin over God, the devil takes hold of them and sin rules them but don't let the devil keep you blinded from the glorious Gospel of Jesus Christ ( 2 Corinthians 4:4), don't stay in your sins for sin leads to death ( James 1:17). remember We all will meet the one true and only God the Holy Creator one day ( Hebrews 9;27) and He's being merciful by giving us all time to get right with Him before judgement day, because when judgement day comes you get no second chances. God came as Jesus in the flesh to go and pay our sin debt on the cross, we deserve hell we deserve to take our punishment but in His great love and mercy He took our punishment and sins to the cross. He died and paid for our sin debt in full ( John 19:30) then God rose Jesus on the third day with glory and power and triumph and He conquered hell, sin, death, satan, the world. God broke down the wall that separated us from Him so we can come to Him and be saved and have a relationship with Him. believe and repent of your sins and God will forgive and cleanse you and make you born again by His Holy Spirit ( John 3). today is the day of salvation, you don't know what day or hour or minute or even the second you'll die. Heaven is eternal and hell is eternal as well. Jesus is the only way to Heaven He's the only way we can be saved from sin and from hell ( John 14, Romans 6:23, Romans 10:9-14). don't choose sin over the Holy loving God. come to Jesus! believe and repent ( 1 Cor 6:9-10, Romans 3:23, John 3:15-18, Rom 10:9-14, NKJV).
@@jesusfollowerswomenministries unfortunately u are wrong. It has been proven by physics and science that there is no possible way God is real or exists. We are literally just evolved forms of apes. We have been evolving for over 7 million years. Millions of years ago the first caveman was walking on earth. Then were more to come. There are evidence for this to back up my claim. How was earth created you may ask? Well when the solar system settled into its current lay out about 4.5 billion years ago earth formed when gravity pulled swirling gas and dust into the third planet from the sun. So yes God isn't real. Sorry for debunking this lol. Also no being could have ever seen and wrote about God. This is because paper didn't exist back then meaning, that someone made the whole thing up. You may believe that God, an impossible being that couldn't even exist is real, but you are denying yourself the truth. Let's just say God was real for a second. Would he like that you were forcing ur beliefs on others. If God was real why would he let 9/11 happen? God was born in the middle east means he is Jewish and he is black. So why would he let George Floyd die? Why would he racism be a thing? Why would he let innocent people of his own race that apparently "created" die? That's right he wouldn't. He would try and help them. So why didn't he? Because he's not real. DEBUNKED
This Is The Saddest Comment Section I Have Ever Seen.
The video, itself, was pretty sad, too.
pineapplepenumbra No you are sad
Yep
Lol you didn't even watch the video my man.
@@pineapplepenumbra Yes, the video was sad in the traditional and technical sense, because the truth is truly sad as its the one thing we don't control and are entirely vulnerable to. This video is about the true meaning of
"Exist" and it delivers
I just came to hear someone's perspective; see what their thoughts on the matter were. It's a shame people must take a topic so personally, regardless of your stance.
What is that thing he is writing on? It's like an Etch-a-Sketch but bigger. Is it new technology?
a chalk board?
Bruh are you for real??
I would like to hear R.C. Sproul apply Revelation 1:4,8, 4:8 and Exodus 3:14 to this talk.
"I will be what I will be".
But is that not circular reasoning? You're saying that because the Bible says that God said "I will be what I will be," that God therefore is, but you are assuming the Bible is true. Why is it true?
What Sproul is talking about has to do with Aristotle's potentials for change. Basically if anything has potential for change (occupies space, changes location, ages, etc.) then it is natural. If something occupies space then it has mass; if it has mass then it is subject to the passage of time. If God exists then he must occupy space, have mass, and therefore be subject to time which makes him a natural being, not supernatural. Hawking said that time did not exist before the Big Bang, so how could God, a natural being, set the Big Bang in motion? Therefore there cannot be a God.
Sag Bag that’s not what he was saying at all. He never claimed gods existence, or lack thereof, he simply pondered what he would think of a biblical quote. Chill out a lil man
Sag Bag also, god, by default, is a supernatural being. He “exists” outside of natural laws. Also, time “began” because experience began, and time is an experience. God is not an experience, and is not contingent on existence of others
Okay how about this - I make a robot that says that and now it is a person? Or now it is a god? You see it doesn’t make much sense and the Bible was written by psychopaths
Sag Bag gods fake
Well, that is one way to blow my mind.
Well done RC sproul in confusing me more than I already was.
Hes using word play and actual meanings. He believes in God. He's just saying exists is inaccurate word to speak of God. I get it but I'll still say he is. In our terms the word exists simply means to be
What you call "word play" is called philosophy among educated people, which is the foundation of all science.
Without philosophy of science we wouldn't even be able to define what is true and what is not.
Christine P THANK YOU
@@jaikee9477 Pretty much.
what you actually call philosophy is a word play, i can argue from anthropological point of view, other issues like the evolution of language, what we actually have now is the pragmatic understanding or meaning - existence, to come into being or not but can you actually tell what exist and what doesn't thus at the end we end up on a socially conditioned term and definition . i think the only sensible meaning is that God is real and he is existence himself.
@@loydteds3944 Interesting observation.
aaaarrrghhhhhh. i feel the Lord testing my resolve to forgive!!!!!!!!! he didnt wipe all the chalk off the board hahahahahaha.@1:08sec
Can someone make Eng subtitle please?
I'm bad in listening....
Where can I get the full video of this?
RIP R.C.Sproul. Now in the presence of his Lord.
Shane Kelly nah he’s in hell
NITEMARE no he’s not dumbfuck
@@Justanobodybro he has succeeded more than you ever will!
-**- did i say anything wrong u dumb fuck
@@Justanobodybro sure he is. It's not enough to believe in a goD. You have to pick the right goD out of all the available choices, and he chose the wrong imaginary friend. Poseidon did not look favorably on him for his life of blaspheming
Context is key in defining "existence" and, in fact, most words. As we learn in school context clues can help us define words
For that reason, the context Sproul uses to define "exist" is completely right
But since most people don't use the word "exist" in that way or understand it that way, it may still make sense to use it in "most" situations
Still, very good teaching
God bless him
All im gonna say is, in life there is always 2 sides to everything, good and bad, life and death, left and right, up and down, even and odd, they're the opposite, so if there is mortals, then there must be an immortal too,which is God.
Somethings are right even if nobody is right while other things are wrong even if everybody is wrong. *Seeking to be wise they become like fools. They exchange the truth of God for a lie.*
Same way for god believers there are non believers
Live with that sucka
change your profile picture and turn away from such evil content, its not moral (don't say or think about how there are immoral things in the Bible because it contains things that actually happened, its not for entertainment)
did you ever saw him???????
Beautiful,3 in one being.Oh the joy that fills my soul.Excelent concept.
"they will deny me, for they do not know who the father is"
dude, i just found my answer, thank you so much, I hope God works through u continuously
@@CobaltMongoose god is gay
@@mid5503 no u
@@ivanbrada9547 uno reverse card so still gay
@@lynnxpooh9024 "im just saying you shouldn’t be taking this risk."
So you're suggesting that god doesn't have a sense of humour, or, possibly, has very little patience, compared to a mature human?
*If* you're worried about people disrespecting god, that would mean that you should be worried about the 5 billion or so idiots on the planet who follow the torah, bible or qur'an, all of which *massively insult* any god that might exist, far beyond just, "you're gay"!
This was beautifully explained! Remarkable!
F*** you
@@komislattroblox1806 u wish
Why do these people comment before watching the video? 😣
Eli'Yah Busby
@John barfneck whattt why do you comment on people you dont know is that apparantely a bad thing you can ask a goddamm stranger on the internet a question what the hells wrong with you lol
@John barfneck Bruh the video has nothing to do with God and people comment
"I knew God was real"
It's called common sense. Maybe try to use it someday.
@Mario1611 LAZY AUDIENCE INCAPABLE OF UPLOADING THEIR OWN VIDEOS.
I was going to because I'm not having a very good evening to begin with. Secondly, the title of the video is counterintuitive to logic. There's a billions worth of perspectives that call things/actions gods. So what is god? An omnipotent being or supernatural forces perhaps. The word is not that well defined as those that use it in terms to describe the thing they are calling it because when you distill it down to basic, god would be everything. And me..well I want to be nothing. Void being and void existence all together. That's what brought me here and wanting to comment before or after watching about 10 seconds worth after seeing the comments that this guy is lying in the first place. Just being honest, don't crucify me.
God isn’t being, becoming, or any fucking thing. God is a concept in your head that makes you feel good about your life.
Praise be to YHWH! Praise be to I AM!
where is he though
@@alejandroangel5908 Jeremiah 29:13 You will seek me and find me, when you seek me with all your heart. Hebrews 11:6 But without faith it is impossible to please Him, for he who comes to God must believe that He is, and that He is a rewarder of those who diligently seek Him.
R.C. Sproul's teachings are so deep and it really opens up your mind and the heart.
Up until they showed the back of the old peoples' heads toward the end, for some reason I pictured a group of kindergarteners who had no idea what was going on.
Wowed, this is the one of the most powerful simple but very complex explanation of the Holy Trinity. Amen 🙏🏾😇🙏🏾 See you in Heaven Dr Sproul to give you a loving Hug brother!!
I love it! God is, was, and will always be. Non-believers ask, "where did God come from, or who created God?". Rather than describe God as merely existing leaving the question of how God came to exist, as Christians, we should be stating confidently and proudly reinforcing the fact that God is eternal. For those of us who know God, eternity is not a concept but a fact and a truth from God who is eternal.
+Ron Bozich "God is, was, and will always be." How can you possibly make such a claim?
"Rather than describe God as merely existing leaving the question of how God came to exist" Because its much easier to ignore obvious logical errors.
There is absolutely no reason for anyone to believe in an omniscient, omnipresent, omnipotent being, considering it is logically impossible for a single entity to possess all 3 said attributes.
+Larry Crabs There is absolutely no proof that human beings evolved from fish.... Are you an evolution (a potential cause to our reality) believer? If there is a debate here, I am on the side of God because He revealed Himself to me. I was a non-believer for the first 52 years of my life until God changed my mind. I can, and do, have a relationship with God. I know with great certainty that He exists. Do you know with great certainty why we experience reality? I would never tell you that I can prove God to you. But I will tell you that God can prove Himself to you. Shalom!
Ron Bozich "Are you an evolution (a potential cause to our reality) believer? "
No, I accept evolution because it has mountains of evidence from various different disciplines of science.
"He revealed Himself to me"
That is called religious psychosis. There is help out there, if you choose to seek it.
"I know with great certainty that He exists."
No, you don't. You really want god to exist. You want it so bad that you imagine this non-existent deity appear before you.
+Larry Crabs Also your "mountains of evidence" for our reality is all from God, not from science. With your evidence, produce a species that was transitional into both a walking creature and a flying creature. Somewhere in your evolutionary record there must be a common land creature that mutated into both an erect walking creature and a flying creature with wings???
+Ron Bozich Amen.
For me its simple. To look at EVERYTHING, how it works. The checks and balances. The shear complexity. The fact that planets do not crash into each other. The fact that we hang in space without falling into chaos. The fact that today, astronomy can tell you when you will see this comet or, that eclipse and that you can time the cycles down to the second. The fact that the simplest cell, must have all of its components present at the same time or it dies. The fact that the DNA is so awesomely complex with so much information in it, boggles the mind. When atheists deny the existence of God, they look at creation s components individually. But, when you look at ALL creation, and see how it all functions together, there is only one conclusion. We need to pray for people like Richard Dawkins because once they enter eternity, life, or summation will be final.
Atheists like me don't hate religious people because of what they think, it's because of what they do. Believing in god is fine but using it for money and fame isn't. I'm fine with christians if they don't use religion to disprove science. You can't prove god exist with science. You can use philosophy to prove it like this video and that's fine. Even though I am a atheist, I like christianity. It's a great way to teach morality. I believe that christianity doesn't help you physically but it helps you mentally.
Only The fool has said in his heart There is no GOD
Everyone knows that God exists. Because when they stand before Him on judgement day they will be without excuse. And as you quote that verse of scripture note that "there is" is in italics those are words that aren't understood to be in the Hebrew text it is put in there in an attempted help us understand the verse when it should read "the fool says in his heart no God" as if to say "no God" for me. The people who say there is no God are trying to lie to themselves when all of creation and the visible and the invisible shout God exists. Grace be with you brother/sister in Jesus Christ the savior who was God in flesh.
@@dustymar4341 Remember Those are not my Words. My friend in whom i know nothing about . However, Have you received The Holy Ghost since you believed ? Acts 19 Read it. How were you Baptized ?
@@deuteronomy6436 if you are talking about acts 19 :3-5 . Paul is asking a question about baptism and who they are baptized by. This where Paul refers to what is said in Luke 3:16
John answered, saying unto them all, I indeed baptize you with water; but one mightier than I cometh, the latchet of whose shoes I am not worthy to unloose: he shall baptize you with the Holy Ghost and with fire:
So to answer your question I was baptized of the Holy Ghost into repentance and Faith that Jesus Christ is Lord so that I will made acceptable in the presence of the Father because of what Christ did on Calvary.
But the commit on the fool verse was me going into further detail on the verse.
@@dustymar4341 No. The question was Whose name where they baptized in. You see next they were rebaptized in Jesus Name and Paul laid hands on them and they began to prophesy. Not baptized by but baptized in JESUS NAME just like Acts 2:38 By the Way, it is The REAl Baptism.
@Deuteronomy 6:4 Shut up Muslim boy, you will go to hell
Yes there is being and we are, of being. The notion of becoming something has made us lose sight of our being. Amen.
It is so strange how JUST yesterday I started reading Dr Sproul's book "Discovering the God who is" which contains this. Blessing!
Did you end up learning who god is? I like reading mythology books too.
Well, yes, God does not exist as matter-energy. He is not some big old guy up in the sky with a long white beard, throwing thunderbolts at people He doesn't like. It's like the question, "Who created God?" God IS and is eternal so never needed to be created. He is not a created being.
Glen Kippel exactly
.
That’s what I’m talking about
AMEN!!
Wow, it's quite hilarious reading these comments below. Half the people here didn't even watch the video. Here's a hint: the title is a BIT misleading. It's not what you think. Watch and find out..
First!!!
Great lecture even if only a few mins...lots to think on...
You wrote this comment 7 years ago, has ur life changed since this comment? Like are u proud so far of the decisions you’ve made
Unspoken Truth: Just because you humans don't want to believe in God our creator doesn't mean that your consequence don't have actions.
God Bless R.C.
Daniel Bone What an intellectual, and kind soul. A rare combination.
Pun intended?
Bro all imma gonna say is this man doesn't know anything his talking about he doesn't no shit. Ok is he dead? No exactly end of discussion
@@DiZzY-oe7sp all I'm going to say is, learn how to spell then do your unnecessary comments.
Gods not real
Seeing the number of "thumbs down" responses on this video shows the unfortunate state of the viewers (or mere visitors to the link). One is either utterly ignorant of his point, has just taken a surface look and decided to make a response without even watching the video, is an atheist, or just hates RC Sproul and/or his reformed view. I suppose another option would be that it was hit in error. There should be no such reaction from any person professing to be a Christian. There was no greater professor for the "existence of God", as it is called, than RC Sproul.
You wouldn’t have to be a Christian to like this. Sufficient but not necessary.
The title reflects exactly what Sproul said in the video, just not in the way most modern English-speaking people understand it (that is, the term "existence"). Click bait is deception; this title doesn't qualify as deception.
The title was misleading, but he did not prove that god does is not there, because it can't be done. If something is not there, you can't prove that or it is unnecessary to think anyone could or should. Although this was also not proof of God being there either, but it was a good explanation of what he thinks humans mean when they talk about god.
I know he is breaking down with the word "exist" like it didn't apply to god, but our language is for us to use to understand what we can know in our realm about anything so other humans will know what we mean. To say god doesn't exist because "exist" doesn't work on god, then we just have to make up another word to mean if god is there and we'd still be in the same position as before when using the word exist. If he's going to break down word this way and say they don't apply to where god is, as he does not exist in his own realm because existing means to become rather than always be, then one can probably say no words could be applied to god, like "real" because he would not be real where he is either. Real is a human word having meanings that use the word exist in it. I'm glad he proved god isn't creature like us since creature comes from creation. I suppose that means we are all not created in his image as it's been told, since he doesn't have the image of a creature like us. I think this man is helping prove god isn't there more than what he intended.
Imagine a situation, where, something can be found out. If one side tells a person who can get this information. Now 2 things occur. Either, that person simply believes the person telling them is just completely nuts, because there is no evidence then so be it. Then, that person then can just keep doing what they were doing in their own private sanctuary as they were before, living within their free rights. Or, that it is known, yet covered up to such a level--Where the person telling it will never be allowed to have access due to the other side being of a satanic realm. They, living by that faith (Knowing how real God is by doing just what they do) and for the lie & deceit by the nature of the beast they represent. And by default--Allows said person to retain their free rights by those means as well. Living, as a non criminal, only expressing themselves in a free society--Having not lost those rights. Either 2 gets back to that same place. How could such a thing be possible--Other than by God existing could it be so?
Lol this is the greatest troll of all time
The Bible says in John 3:16-36 that whoever believes in the Lord Jesus Christ shall not perish but have everlasting life, the Bible also says in Romans 10:9 that those who declare with their mouth that Jesus Christ is their God, Lord, and Savior they shall be saved. Revelation 1:8 says that Jesus is the alpha and the omega. Luke and revelation is the ending times, and Jesus is returning back. So are you going to submit your life to him or no? Narrow is the path that leads to the gates of heaven, but only few people find it. The gates that is the path to destruction is where many people find it! Jesus loves you SO MUCH! That he died on the cross, and was resurrected from the dead 3 days later to give us eternal life..!.!..!..
@@poweroftruth9258 I tried but God wouldn’t help me so I couldn’t do it.
@@JoshuaTCoe wym?
Teach it Dr. Sproul!! I sure miss him!!
Can someone explain what he said about existence = stand + out = outstanding? How can existence = becoming? It's not clear.
What is a turnaround?
1:13 I thoght for a second there that he talked about Play Doh
🤣🤣🤣🤣
wait so what kinda play doh is he talking about 😂 ??
@@wanasilini9797 Plato 😂👌 the ancient greek philosopher.
This mans looks like Rev. Nelius---I actually mistook him! :o
Atheists just got triggered after they thought they won😂👌👍
Okay if he exist, what is God? If you ask a thousand believers you will have a thousand different stories of what God is. That is the truth that he only exist in your mind..
Who gave this man a mouth to talk, and ear to listen, and eye to see? Was it not “ I am, that I am” which we called GOD.
Peace be with you...
Sometimes I flush before im done peeing..and sometimes I flush too soon and im still peeing after the flush is complete.
ikr? I hate it!
I don't get what you're trying to say
He is saying the same thing in two different ways
Romans 10:9
[9]That if thou shalt confess with thy mouth the Lord Jesus, and shalt believe in thine heart that God hath raised him from the dead, thou shalt be saved.
I feel that.
you didn’t prove anything, you just gave me more reasons to believe in God
If you see the Bible,almost every prophecies of the Bible are fulfilled.
Sad
Pure Being... I AM that I AM ... who changes not... May I always walk humbly before you my LORD and my God...
Lol, that means God is saying I can BECOME who you want me to be. God is neither existent nor nonexistent in human vocabulary.
I love that😂 best video I’ve ever watched.
Ali Ali 😂 you need jesus✝️✝️
@@mr.stepdaddy2259 😂😂🤫🤫
If God created everything that exist, there was a time when he commenced to create. Back of that commencement there must have been an eternity. In that eternity what was this God doing? Was God inactive prior to creation? He certainly did not think. There was nothing to think about. He did not remember. Nothing had ever happened. What did he do? Can you imagine anything more absurd that an infinite intelligence in infinite nothing wasting an eternity?
If god exist and he created the universe he had to create laws of physics. Before doing so, he was outside time because, indeed, he created time. Trying to understand this is just as ridiculous as to deny any posibility, the Universe as structred and perfect as it is it's just a proof there is an existance beyong it who was capable of putting all these atoms together.
@@salvadorteran3575 Time is a man made concept to determine past, present, and future. There is no such thing as the beginning of time.
God could have not created time because it is logically impossible.
As well as God can't make a triangle with four sides because a four sided triangle is a logical impossibilty.
"The dividing line between past, present, and future is an illusion. So reality is ultimately TIMELESS."
- Albert Einstein.
@@salvadorteran3575 "Before doing so, he was outside time because, indeed, he created time."
What would that even mean? What does it mean for something to exist "outside" of time? "Outside" is a spacial orientation, that would require God to exist within space time.
@Honorato Hector Rivas you said i dont like the idea of being submitted to his law? waht do you mean by his law?
@Honorato Hector Rivas On what empirical basis have you determined that a god exist, and how do you know that it's eternal?
Is this that much different from modalism? I’m not a modalist, but the way he describes the Trinity doesn’t seem to me as heavily contradicting of modalistic theology as it may seem. Or maybe modalism adds something that makes it heretical. Anybody takers?
Wisdom begins with the fear of God. Seek God. Fear God. Repent. Put your faith and trust in Jesus Christ
He was playing with words to prove being? So we are trying to become being ? Because we are called human being? Bing bing! What he said? 😂
Think of what the word human mean...
Then think about what being means.
Then put em together
Why am I just now finding this man’s teachings!? Excellent!
Shut up, Your false god-_-
His teachings are fake, Bad comment
@@ruol7123 lol anime profile pic
@@ruol7123 The moment you're arrogant, you are close-minded
The creative force behind all space, time, matter, and energy and not a shred of empirical evidence of his existence. That crushes my faith. I HATE having faith. I HATE having hope. I rather die a sinner and experiencing fun than die a saint, live a life of piety, and discover there is no afterlife.
We are not even a speck on the face of the whole universe and here we are trying to disprove god. It’s simple logic, we are a complicated species in a huge universe the signs are all around us. Something created this complicated species. Something more complicated than us.
.1 seconded in this and I’m already convinced
Crypto Boner he still believes that there is a god he’s just stating how using the word exist is wrong when talking about god because of the words origins and what those origins mean. if you actually watched the video you’d know
Does your name mean your boner is hidden?
Interesting choice for a name of someone who is hidden by the internet but your boner is never in the open, I would hope, even when boner is used to mean mistake.
But your boner in that sense is that you are convinced that God does not exist. Big mistake...
Romans 10:9
[9]That if thou shalt confess with thy mouth the Lord Jesus, and shalt believe in thine heart that God hath raised him from the dead, thou shalt be saved. Its as easy as that and otherwise i would actually be more than happily to believe like he does because he is right
Still wating for the part that proves that god does'nt exist.
He just explained that God does not exist in the sense that the english language uses "exist". R.C. also noted that God's disposition is not createrly therefore he can not be becoming (exist in this context). His argument is contingent upon God being eternal and not subject to change (I.e. aging).
Jack Cassidy McCarthy every time you pray something good happens around you. God can’t control what you think cause it’s your mind. And he can’t control people around you. So it’s not his fault people do bad things around you but he can do something that can make someone change their mind on their own for example:
Let’s say your hungry but you look in your fridge and there’s nothing for you to make or eat cause your missing ingredients, but you could’ve sworn yesterday you had enough food but you just shrug it off and decide to go get food once you start walking to the store you see a homeless man being mistreated by other people they are kicking him and punching him and the homeless man just tries to protect his head, these other people have minds of their own a gift God gave them and now you have to make a choice: A. Help the homeless man and tell them to stop.
B. Don’t care it’s whatever he’s homeless for a reason, it’s his fault he should’ve studied.
What will it be? Why did your food go missing all of a sudden? Why are you here in this position? Why you? Why now? What if they go as far as killing him? Why *DOES* it matter ?
Jack Cassidy McCarthy yeh your not receiving the point here. I don’t blame u tho. Other people who read it got it.
Jack Cassidy McCarthy u haven’t even answered my question yet.
Jack Cassidy McCarthy u can scroll up and look for it, come on now 🤦♀️
In Christ God can exist, stand out and can be 'I'am Whom I will become"
okay, what does this mean for superman?
Caraca não acredito que te achei no YT kkkk
@@pedrorl42 kkkk. Anos 😂
@@pedrorl42 to em vários lugares 😉
This seems like clickbait, given that what it says is not what it means, according to common vernacular.
Yes and no
What a good vessel this man was. Enjoy your rest R.C. Sproul. God blessed many with you.
@Pfft Lmao yeah you didnt watch the vid did you
@Pfft Lmao he wasnt disproving
Pfft Lmao you definitely didnt watch the video
@Pfft Lmao ???
@Pfft Lmao you're a dumbass LOL. Get out of here troll
This is crazy it blow my mind away, tittle vs video makes it very contradictory but in the end the real true behind all of it. Amazing!
Amen, the people of knowledge know their God.
may God give us knowledge to be with them.
Glory to God!🔥🔥🔥❤
@Supreme 12191 Psalms 14:1 : "The fool hath said in his heart, There is no God. They are corrupt, they have done abominable works, there is none that doeth good."
Go to school. God don't exist
@@karma1506 I agree lol
@@karma1506 Agreed.
@@karma1506 If they went to school and got educated, they'd already know god is a myth.
bless his heart, lol
What does SOPHISTRY mean?
Well, that was odd...but profound!
logically it's a great way to prove the being of God. It really makes sense. Thanks
+Rustam Sohrab lol please take a moment and actually watch the video because it's quite clear you didn't.
Keith Thompson
Oh, sorry Keith, I just watched the beginning of the video and I got the idea that he is trying to deny the existence of God. Thank you for making me watch the video until the end and I got the truth. Please accept my apologies. May God bless you.
Rustam hey, thank you for this comment. I feel God in the way this was handled. may God bless you brother.
All he did was change the meaning of words from their accepted everyday use to come up with a pseudo clever argument that people who already believe in a god seem to like.
note his argument is valid for ANY concept of a god. Thor, Yahweh, Allah, apollo the FSM.
Not so clever really is it?
170221dn isn’t that what atheists also do tho? Come up with arguments to defend why they don’t believe in a God? Everyone does that. Everyone defends what they believe or don’t believe in. Of course they do.
You dont believe God exists. Do you believe you exist?
watch the video, idjit :p
Why wouldn't anyone believe they exist?
He believes God IS; above existence
Good gamblers do not make bad bets. Atheists get no lasting reward but if there is a God the ones seeking God get a reward. Being religious has a good chance of eternal blessing.
Why should you be punished simply for not believing in that one specific god? If everyone were to die right now, should 70% of the human population that either believes in different god(s) or no gods at all be sent to hell simply for not believing in that particular god?
How come even with proof that he does not exist people still believe in God. I don't think society can be any dumber. 🤦🏻♂️
No one can prove or disprove.
Theists believe for personal reasons.
Atheists don't believe for personal reasons.
There could be a force such as God but until it is discovered or factually proven wrong, we're all just expressing opinions
U stupid dumshit u know humans wont listen until they see that with their own eyes so until they have proven evidence they stop believing but there is no proven evidence so they wont listen so ur are dumber then society
I’m extremely confused and want answers (don’t read if you don’t want to, I’m just ranting. Read if you’re interested in my existential crisis) I’ve been looking at every bit of evidence. I would really want for something to exist a “god”, but reality and our evidence proved that there is nothing. But our evidence also can’t prove nothing, at least not at the 4th dimension/ our “time” so is there something is there nothing or what is there, if there even is anything? I watched a video of a guy in a TED talk, who said that everything was random, extremely convincingly. That it was our “reality”. If it’s our reality than why does it seem impossible to prove it. Also, the god theory, if there is a god why can’t we find proof. Why is there zero, not even the most absurdly tiny amount of evidence of it being so? Why are there over a thousand Gods without proof or evidence. Scientist also say that religious humans have a tendency to place god as the factor for why we don’t understand something as opposed to understanding it. But they are talking general God’s what if God isn’t really the word god, but the whole universe itself. Now we change the word god and put the universe. The universe is physical... well somewhat. Time isn’t, but we know it’s there because it’s happening. The universe is somehow tho, still part of what we know and see. So what was the start of everything. Stephen Hawkins said that there was no time before the Big Bang. It was just an it, so what caused “it” alright I’m back in the same loophole.
@@BonQy no one can prove to you if God exists or not. Jesus said just before they crucified Him. If they do this to the tree when it's still green, imagine what they will do when its dry. The end is near and satan wants us confused. Either you believe or you don't. It's our love of sin that keeps us from accepting God's existence. It's up to you brother. Love.
Every knee shall bow,and every tounge confess..Jesus Christ is Lord!🙌
Ramiro Jimenez Amen
Every man shall protest, everything shall obey the one and only, Allah
Ramiro Jimenez my knee will not bow, and my tounge will not confess.
Gert Scheper. Then very best i can do i pray for you that you allow the Lordin your life,before its too late..becouse there is no repentance in Hell..no not even hope!Christ is 👑.
Ramiro Jimenez pray to the mountain as much as you want , it never helped Anyone. But be my geust.
Guys. Please watch video first than comment what you want.
"God does not exist, he is eternal"
- Søren Kierkegaard -
The title... Is the most misleading thing I've read since I was a child and watched "A cars life: Sparky's Big adventure".
And I love it.
religion aside, what’s up with his handwriting
It's bad cursive.
I think I got sucked into another misleading title. I appreciate the logical assumptions and all Mr. Sprouls has definitely proven nothing. Better to be cold than luke warm though. There is always hope!
Yes he has told the definition of exist
God is a game that is played with experience, the Devil is the opposition, and the goal is to understand and know God. This game is a game that is incredibly hard, so hard it grabs the time and effort and attention of the entire day. But the reward is far greater after winning the game.
RIP RC Sproul
We shall meet you in glory ❤
Ugly girl,Go to hell
@@ruol7123 Shut your dang mouth fool.
By definition RC is very accurate. God is more than a gas or blob through the universe but a personal brilliant beyond our comprehension being. Blow your mind more, has 3 persons/each with personalities that Function totally in harmony as ONE.
I think you are wrong he is an amazing pasta being. ALl the evidence he presented completely supports the flying spaghetti monster do you not agree?
170221dn God is not defined by your imaginations
@@170221dn This Flying Spaghetti Monster satire has gotten old....
@@thomasecker8897
"This Flying Spaghetti Monster satire has gotten old...."
I think God myths from 3-4 thousand years ago are getting a bit tired.
@@170221dn Which ones?
Can you show me the pasage in the bible that says that God is father,son and holly ghost/spirit?
Do we exist because of the universe? or does the universe exist because of us (God created all this for us)? If we cease to exist, would the universe cease to exist too? if the universe ceases to exist, would we cease to exist? did the universe exist before us? would it exist after us?
God is a spirit ...
@minecraftkaas the truth triggers a lot of non believers GOD bless bro lol stay mad
Insert meme where head explodes, lol. Great stuff! Love it!
What do you think about evolution?
@@wehfgyuewaq833 Evolution contradicts itself
@@robdog4062 no
@@mid5503 Explain how it don't?
@@robdog4062 tell me first why you think it does ill debunk you
THIS is a great learning. Hallelujah!
RIP RC You were a great and intelligent man. This video, however, didn't clarify anything. It only confused me even more.
I’m a Christian and this is still funny 😆
Mind blown... awesome. Thanks RC. You were a great teacher. You will be missed.
very helpful explanation on 3 substances of 1 being of the trinity.
Subsistences
One simple question . Who is creator of energy .... Because as per science u can convert energy from one format to another but can't destroy energy
A dialogue between myself and the Devil:
The Devil: Do you believe in Jesus Christ? Do you believe he is your Lord and Savior?
Me: Yes.
The Devil: How can you? There is absolutely no conclusive historical evidence he ever existed! Evolutionary science has proven Creationism to be false. Furthermore, greater destruction
and violence has been carried out on Earth in the name of Jesus Christ than anyone or anything else!Me: I agree, and that is how I know my faith has been purified from the influence of this world.
Yes you had a dialogue with the devil
"The fool hath said in his heart, There is no God. They are corrupt, they have done abominable works, there is none that doeth good. The Lord looked down from heaven upon the children of men, to see if there were any that did understand, and seek God. They are all gone aside, they are all together become filthy: there is none that doeth good, no, not one. Have all the workers of iniquity no knowledge? who eat up my people as they eat bread, and call not upon the Lord . There were they in great fear: for God is in the generation of the righteous. Ye have shamed the counsel of the poor, because the Lord is his refuge."
Psalms 14:1-6 KJV
"For the wicked boasteth of his heart's desire, and blesseth the covetous, whom the Lord abhorreth. The wicked, through the pride of his countenance, will not seek after God: God is not in all his thoughts."
Psalms 10:3-4 KJV
Yeshua Is My Shepherd bla bla bla bla bla bla bla bla bla bla. Bull shit.
Yeshua Is My Shepherd
The right hand of the LORD is exalted: the right hand of the LORD doeth valiantly.
Psalm:118:16
I shall not die, but live, and declare the works of the LORD.
Psalm:118:17
The LORD hath chastened me sore: but he hath not given me over unto death.
Psalm:118:18
The Right hand of the lord is jesus!
Ahmed Deedat Amem. The Lord Jesus be always exalted.
Yeshua Is My Shepherd u didnt get my point! It is messianic psalm about jesus being saved from the cross! He was saved! He didnt die on cross! His substitute was crucified not him!
Ahmed Deedat We cannot sustain this affirmative just put one verse only out of context, but we have to know the all Scripture. And the Scripture says that Jesus was crucified and at the third day He rosen from the death by the power of God Almigthy. He is the Lord and He and the Father was one.
Nobody knows anything until it happens, every individual person does not know what is outside of life until they pass away, but there is no way of telling another being what happens, there is no reason to fear dieing because I would (ASSUME) that what is once something will never be nothing
How to blow my mind in 4 minutes. Thanks RC
I love this argument. I’ve heard the argument that the earth itself is personal. That’s another fun one. God always is and always has been. That’s one thing that makes him so wonderful. To live for Him is the greatest thing a person can ever do.