Ultimate Nankang head-to-head tyre test - CR-S Vs AR-1

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 22. 08. 2024

Komentáře • 104

  • @RCRVids
    @RCRVids Před měsícem +94

    what we really want to know is A052 vs CR-S

    • @showxpony
      @showxpony Před měsícem +3

      Cutting to the point, what are lap times of the A052 on this car in similar conditions?

    • @bullwing
      @bullwing Před měsícem +16

      CR-S if you want to do more than a single Hot lap flyer in a session. A052 if you're doing time attack and only want to set a single fast lap for a session or doing auto-cross.
      A052s don't need a warm up lap - they get up to temp after the first 3 hard turns and a single hard braking zone if you're pushing 70%. That said, they drop off quick after 2 flying hotlaps pushing 10/10ths. They can't handle heat. They are not a good lapping tire. Purely a competition tire for time attach and auto-x. That said, even after they drop off, the break away characteristics and sliding predictability is top notch.
      CR-S - like the A052 characteristics and equally as fast, but can handle heat way way way better. You can get 4-5 flying hotlaps in before they start to drop off. That said, they need a full warm up lap to get up to operating temperature. They won't do well for auto-x, but they can work for time attack - you get more opportunities to set a fast lap in a session out.

    • @RCRVids
      @RCRVids Před měsícem +2

      @@bullwing well that clearly horse sht. A052 are very popular in just about all of the enduro/mini enduro series running ATM on 1A/1B/1C tires, hold up incredibly well and give solid consistent times across races between 45min and 2 hours

    • @SpyderRacing
      @SpyderRacing Před měsícem

      ​@bullwing not my experience. I've ran a052s back to back vs crs v2s and the crs is faster in time attack by about .4 seconds over a 1:33 lap.

    • @joshuaplemons527
      @joshuaplemons527 Před měsícem

      @@bullwing Great analysis, have had the same experience. Only thing I would say is that the CRS have overall seemed a bit faster to me than the A052, even in single lap performance. But you're right they do take about a lap to get some heat in em.

  • @daniilpechenev4014
    @daniilpechenev4014 Před měsícem +17

    Finally, someone tested them back to back. Thank you!

    • @tegiwa
      @tegiwa  Před měsícem +1

      We aim to please!

  • @yardspeed13
    @yardspeed13 Před měsícem +9

    Great video, I went from AR-1's to Yoko AO52's on my FN2. I loved the AR-1's but the AO52's are much better, it would be interesting to see or hear your thoughts on the new Nankang CR-s VS the Yoko AO52's. Thanks for uploading the review guys.

    • @tegiwa
      @tegiwa  Před měsícem

      Thank you for watching!

  • @mikar636
    @mikar636 Před 27 dny +1

    Amazing Video as always!! What is the toe of the front wheels?? Have you ever tried racing the FN2 with 18-inch wheels instead of 17-inch wheels?

  • @freakyfriday9370
    @freakyfriday9370 Před měsícem +5

    Should do a A052 vs CR-S

  • @stefanroseEP3
    @stefanroseEP3 Před měsícem +13

    Crs vs ao52 vs dz03g now then

  • @M2c_build
    @M2c_build Před měsícem +5

    Great video guys! 👏
    You need to try them on a heavier rwd car next! F8x e92
    I found the cr-s to go off very quickly! The cr-s wouldn’t do a full lap of the ring without going off! That is comparing to a direzza to bare in mind!
    Never the less it’s still a great tyre in its working window!

    • @nehok
      @nehok Před měsícem +2

      That's what I've heard about them, good time attack or sprint tire but not so good for doing a 30/40 min lapping session.

    • @RCRVids
      @RCRVids Před měsícem +1

      @@nehok 1100Kg 330Ci Endurance car using them to great affect over 45 minute races with no drop off and significant improvement over previous AR-1
      The AR-1 are a sprint tire, instant turn on but poor temp stability over a longer distance. If the CR-S is anything like the tire they copied (The A052) then the real advantage will be in non-perfect damp conditions

    • @M2c_build
      @M2c_build Před měsícem

      @@nehokit couldn’t even handle a low 7 min lap at the ring! Fell off after CZcams corner 🤦‍♂️

    • @M2c_build
      @M2c_build Před měsícem

      @@RCRVidsI suspect it’s the heavier cars it’s suffers! My m2 is 1600kg plus bud!

    • @daniglevelas98
      @daniglevelas98 Před měsícem +1

      I’ve seen a guy go low 7s in a G80 with Crs. He even told me that were better than the a052. You probably know him, the driver of 24/7s green g80

  • @HondaK20
    @HondaK20 Před měsícem +2

    A052 for me. On heat way is unbeliaveable tire. Car feels like a train 😊❤

  • @wastedpaal
    @wastedpaal Před měsícem +1

    Lovely video, thank you for the detailed testing!

  • @wernergt3751
    @wernergt3751 Před 8 dny

    Great review thx

  • @EuropaSman
    @EuropaSman Před 7 dny

    It's really frustrating that the CR-S in the standard sizes for the Lotus Elise S2 & S3 (195/50 R16 & 225/45 R17) are not road legal due to the lack of EU labelling.
    The ultimate tyre choice for the Elise S2/S3 is the Yokohama AO52, but they are really expensive, can be tricky to source sometimes and the rears wear quickly apparently.
    The CR-S appears to be a direct competitor to the AO52, so it would be good to see a side by side comparison.
    I just wish the EU tyre testing red tape could be sorted.

  • @godzillastorm3967
    @godzillastorm3967 Před měsícem +1

    A052 vs AD09, the winner vs CR-S. Curious about Bridgestone potenza race vs CR-S

  • @atkins.8832
    @atkins.8832 Před měsícem +1

    Good tyre Test again.
    Looking at CR-S tyre is like looking at a trofeo. Look very similar in design. Also sound like act quite similar in way need a heat cycle first from new to scrub them in.
    Did get any times on AO52s

  • @jcadlols
    @jcadlols Před 23 dny

    For a mix of road and track, the understeer balance of the AR-1 and the fact it comes on quickly would mean it's a decent choice. Will be interesting to see how the CR-S tread behaves in the wet. I can't help but think the AR-1 compound with a CR-S pattern would be a good thing.

  • @k20ee96
    @k20ee96 Před měsícem

    Would be great to see a wet comparison and as others have mentioned an A052 comparison.
    Also the damping setup seems to be really holding the car back. I know the exit of the first chicane is difficult in FWD but that pogo effect you're getting looks really bad. With Miester GT1s on my Civic I can get the power down a lot smoother, granted with a better diff too

  • @OlavAlexanderMjelde
    @OlavAlexanderMjelde Před 9 dny

    I see that the newly fitted CR-S is supposed to be driven at least 3 laps at "not max", to wear them in.

  • @diogopinto7417
    @diogopinto7417 Před měsícem +1

    I love to see Cr-s vs ad09

  • @koshirgarage
    @koshirgarage Před měsícem +2

    good test , thumbs up, what pressure did you run then on CR-S, same as AR-1s ?

  • @csllover
    @csllover Před měsícem +1

    Thank you !

  • @solarpanel9310
    @solarpanel9310 Před měsícem

    Hi, love the testing you are doing , very helpful, are you able to test 500bhp rear wheel drive car with the CR-S and AR-1 ?

    • @tegiwa
      @tegiwa  Před měsícem

      Thanks for watching. It's something we can look into, for sure!

  • @jamietonksracing7367
    @jamietonksracing7367 Před měsícem +2

    Great review, thanks for taking the time and cost to do it…..At 50% more expensive than AR1 the results are as expected.
    I’d love to see a review of CRS / A052 / DZ03’s, all at a similar price point to understand 1 lap pace, long stint and tyre life.
    Thanks for the work you do 🤲🤲

    • @tegiwa
      @tegiwa  Před měsícem

      Thank you for watching!

  • @richmachin6741
    @richmachin6741 Před měsícem

    Great video.... I know it's probably a bit more niche... but will you be testing Nankang SL-1's any time soon? I'm interested to know how much of a step-up they are compared to road-legal tyres performance-wise, and what the heat tolerance and wear rate is like....?

    • @tegiwa
      @tegiwa  Před měsícem +1

      We have no plans to do this as of yet but stepping up to a slick tyre will be worlds apart from anything treaded. It will also put more strain on components like oil systems too, so we would only advice using them on full race/track cars.

  • @HidRomail
    @HidRomail Před měsícem

    Awesome reviews!!!
    AR1 and CRS vs Cup2 and Potenza Race, how would they compare??

  • @ZJE85
    @ZJE85 Před měsícem

    Great test! How does the CRS compare to nexen n fera R?

  • @ripptorr
    @ripptorr Před měsícem

    tell me you did not let the stickers on the ar1's when you left the pits...

  • @da1linkster280
    @da1linkster280 Před měsícem +1

    Awesome review, I run the AR-1 on my RS3 8Y, changed to square setup 265/35/18 all round, love the AR-1. I’m still new at this so the next tyre I will try is the Dunlop direzza. I also checked your site but I do not see the Dragy for sale, you only have the little one, not the one in the video. Where can I buy it?

    • @EvoBeard
      @EvoBeard Před měsícem

      That little box is the one they used ib the video. In the first few laps you see it attached to the roof at the front of the car, right above the windscreen/driver.
      They've got magnetic backs so can be plonked anywhere metal.
      The DRG69 is the one they have listed on their site, you can obtain the DRG70 but from everything I saw online, there wasn't much of a difference in reality (I have the 70).
      The other tracking equipment they use, they mentioned what that was when first in the car with the dragy set up.

    • @da1linkster280
      @da1linkster280 Před měsícem

      @@EvoBeard thanks, I also have the 70, thought is was a different device, just discovered there is an additional app I can download to get the info on my phone.

    • @tegiwa
      @tegiwa  Před měsícem +1

      Thank you for watching! Here is the link to the Dragy that we used: www.tegiwa.com/products/dragy-gps-performance-monitoring-box

    • @da1linkster280
      @da1linkster280 Před měsícem

      @@tegiwa thank you! Which tyre do you think is faster between the direzza and the cr-s?

    • @tegiwa
      @tegiwa  Před měsícem

      @@da1linkster280 We tested both the CR-S (pre-production model) and Direzza in our RWD tyre test. You can check that out here: czcams.com/video/klSmFfLSReg/video.html

  • @zbeasty
    @zbeasty Před měsícem +1

    Would be interested to know how it goes against the AD09. Currently running the AD09 on a Toyota NCP13 (Yaris/Vitz/Echo) for endurance racing.

    • @gracebawden6856
      @gracebawden6856 Před měsícem

      AD09 vs NS2R would be very interesting... curious to see which one would lap faster over multiple (4) 20min session. And which one would last longer and be more consistent?

  • @alexstewart1212
    @alexstewart1212 Před měsícem +1

    I find A052 to be in a different category. 1,5 seconds faster at the Red Bull Ring vs CRS. And also on the wet they have more grip feels like a softer compound. Japan vs China 🤔

  • @OnTrackDetailing
    @OnTrackDetailing Před měsícem

    I have the same feeling of the AR1 with the first warm up lap. Very skiddy 😅
    Previously had AR1s on my 400hp Megane. Not bad really.
    I have CRS now, bought some used.
    I cannot justify the price of CRS for my normal track day use. Given the use I had of my car over 150 laps at Brands Hatch, 30-40 laps at Donny and around 1000 road miles. Ar1 lasted really well . I have very aggressive geo as well.
    As you summed up the AR1 is probably better for most of us who just do regular trackdays.
    The CRS price is silly, in my opinion. Its much closer to a Direzza which is a step above again - and I'm sure will last longer than either. So ££ per lap, Direzza seems better as well as faster. The E mark issue is not a concern Imo.
    Its a shame you didn't account for wear, unless I missed it.
    Thanks for the video.

    • @tegiwa
      @tegiwa  Před měsícem

      Thank you for watching!

  • @Mr1974tps
    @Mr1974tps Před měsícem

    useful info thanks, i run ar1 on my e36 race car and some of the lads are moving to cr-s, not sure the price difference still warrants moving to the cr-s over a season as i could bolt on another set of ar1 for the difference earlier in the season but good to know the cr-s is giving a performance difference over the previous test which wasn't as conclusive, keep up the good work, cheers.
    i run 2354017 square set up on 9j.

    • @tegiwa
      @tegiwa  Před měsícem

      Thanks for watching!

  • @swansmeister
    @swansmeister Před 24 dny

    1.7 bar is crazy imo, not gonna be good for the tyrewall even the nankang's having pretty solid tyrewalls.

  • @z06van21
    @z06van21 Před měsícem +1

    How is the sidewall stiffness of the CR-S compared to the AD09's?
    I have AD09's on my 718 GT4 and I love the stiff sidewall feel, but they are not the grippiest tire since they are an Endurance 200TW and not a Super 200TW like the CR-S is supposed to be.

    • @HondaExige1
      @HondaExige1 Před měsícem

      How have you found the Ad09 vs the stock Cup2s on the GT4? Looking for something stickier for mine and the Ad09 is about the only thing available right now in the correct sizes.

    • @TRZ0612
      @TRZ0612 Před 29 dny

      @@HondaExige1AD09’s are worlds better than the Cup 2’s.
      AD09’s have a wider operating window , do not fall off as fast or as much , and that stiffer sidewall really gives the car a more direct feel, especially laterally at high speeds.
      I also have MCS 2-way remote dampers , but I know they would be better even on a stock suspension car.

  • @stbeIX
    @stbeIX Před měsícem +2

    Why are you starting the CR-S test with the stickers on the tire?😂

    • @thedavidvarley1
      @thedavidvarley1 Před měsícem

      They literally come off before you even start the out lap.

    • @stbeIX
      @stbeIX Před měsícem +1

      @@thedavidvarley1 No, it's not that quick. That's also the reason why it had so little grip on the first few laps.
      I've already tested it.

    • @weedminer
      @weedminer Před měsícem +2

      @@stbeIX I agree, I've done that before and it's a mistake 100% !

  • @classicvin
    @classicvin Před měsícem

    Ace video and interesting to hear the geo setup you have on the fn2, is that 3mm total rear toe out or 3mm each side (6mm total!?) Sounds spicy indeed! Looks like I'll be ordering some shims to spice up the clio! Cheers 🍻

  • @TheEddysGarage
    @TheEddysGarage Před měsícem +1

    Could the CRS be less grippy from the start because you went out with the stickers still on them? 🤔 I went from ar1 to crs on my BMW M2 and it was 3-4 seconds a lap faster on my 2 track layouts?

  • @thebaguette172
    @thebaguette172 Před měsícem

    Fantastic job 👏

    • @tegiwa
      @tegiwa  Před měsícem

      Thanks very much!

  • @WasnClown
    @WasnClown Před měsícem

    Great video 🤞

    • @tegiwa
      @tegiwa  Před měsícem

      Thanks very much!

  • @servicepartsjapan2687
    @servicepartsjapan2687 Před 29 dny

    Really interested to know which one is better cold (first 2 to 3 minutes) AR1, CR-S or A052? Intending to used them on road/track but also at hill climb events as well, where cold performance is crucial.

    • @rhysrhysrhys
      @rhysrhysrhys Před 22 dny +1

      From personal experience, A052 is better than the CRS in the wet and cold conditions. CRS does need that first injection of heat to become grippy, A052 does not.
      I'm yet to drive the A052 properly in the dry just yet.
      (EK4 Civic used for hillclimbs and sprint track days)

  • @Wayne-uo9dk
    @Wayne-uo9dk Před měsícem

    @5:24 that is factory sticker?

  • @fkhothatchi
    @fkhothatchi Před měsícem +1

    HEROES!

  • @florian_montuzet
    @florian_montuzet Před měsícem

    Great test. Does the CRS last as long as the AR1 ?

    • @tegiwa
      @tegiwa  Před měsícem +1

      Thank you! We gave both tyres two sessions each so it's hard to comment on the longevity of each tyre. We used to use AR-1 on our endurance spec BMW M4 and they worked really well over the course of a 2 hour race.

  • @i30n_fb
    @i30n_fb Před 29 dny

    post up times showing all three best times

  • @descent8275
    @descent8275 Před měsícem

    i take the AR1, price is hot and i'm out there to have fun, no competition.

  • @Drifty325i
    @Drifty325i Před měsícem

    Would these be good for a fast road tire? I’ve got AD08r now and they have been great for the road

    • @Drifty325i
      @Drifty325i Před měsícem

      Turbo Lotus Elise

    • @tegiwa
      @tegiwa  Před měsícem

      It depends whether you drive the car in the wet or not. For a good all rounder that's perfect for the road and track, it's hard to look past the Yokohama AD09. You can see the review of these in our RWD tyre test which is live on our channel.

  • @fkhothatchi
    @fkhothatchi Před měsícem

    Now I wonder if it's faster than the dunlops

  • @081588101
    @081588101 Před měsícem +1

    I just ordered a set of CR-S´s for my RX-7 and im super excited to see how they will perform on the Nürburgring. :)

  • @DenfMotorsports
    @DenfMotorsports Před měsícem

    I tried the AR-1 on my 996 GT3 2 times. The first time in stock sizes (235/40/18 & 295/30/18), but they were just too bloody narrow compared to other tyres. THey didn't last long and I abosolutely shredded them on the rear.
    To compensate for size, I ended up using 245/40/18 & 315/30/18. While grip was good, the feeling of the car was absolute dog shit. Felt like floating around. Also, again, the rear just wears out way too fast (3x15min stint in Monza + 1 trackday ~270km in Tazio Nuvolari + 350Km road use too and from the track).
    I think the AR1 tyre is just not suited for a 911.
    Apparently the CRS is better so I might try them, but I really hope that they also don't wear out as quickly.

    • @magnus-thome
      @magnus-thome Před měsícem

      I did a same day track test of A052, AR-1, CR-S, and TrofeoR with my 996.1 GT3

    • @malymato8382
      @malymato8382 Před měsícem

      @@magnus-thomeand with what results or conclusions?

    • @DenfMotorsports
      @DenfMotorsports Před měsícem

      @@magnus-thome sure.. And what are your conclusions?

    • @gracebawden6856
      @gracebawden6856 Před měsícem

      If you want something that lasts longer you might need to compromise and go for AD09 or NS2R...

  • @Senninha1960
    @Senninha1960 Před měsícem

    Advan wheels??

    • @tegiwa
      @tegiwa  Před měsícem

      @@Senninha1960 they are Rota Force's