What does my DNA test say?? Am I BHUTANESE??
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 07. 2024
- To visit Bhutan, contact BHUTAN KARMAY TOURS
www.karmaytours.com/
Hotels:Hotel Ser-Nya Thimphu:
www.tripadvisor.ca/ShowUserRe...
Dhumra Farm House Punakha:
dhumrafarm.com/
Find me on social media: Instagram / jamyangcho
I often get asked where I'm from, so I wanted to share with the world about my country Bhutan. A small himalayan kingdom nestled in between two giants, China and India. In today's video, I'm sharing my DNA results and explore where the ancestors of Bhutanese people/race might be from.
The 4 main ethnic groups in Bhutan are:1. Ngalops (western and northern Bhutan)2. Sharchops (eastern Bhutan)3. Lhotsampa (southern Bhutan)4. Indigenous/ tribal people ( Doya, Merak Sakten, Layap. etc)
what does my DNA say? Am I really Bhutanese? Are there any Skeletons in my family's closet? OR am I adopted??What this till the end to find out..
Who am I :My name is jamjam, and I'm a Bhutanese vlogger. Check out my other videos on Bhutan.
Where do you think your ancestors are from?
Probably similar to yours azhim! Hehe
Thanks for the information💛✨
@@lodbk7497 👍🏼👍🏼
Bhutan is the motherland la. It's the cradle of ethno genesis and responsible for populating much of east and south east asia. All language and culture are original.
kuenselonline.com/ancestry-of-the-bhutanese-people/#:~:text=The%20O%20haplogroup%20ancestor%20which,and%20as%20far%20as%20Lappland.
All Mongol(Mongoloid race) people are indigenous of Asia..... We Gurung, Magar, Rai, Limbu, Tamang, Sunuwar, Pradhan of mongoloid origin bhutan are non hindu... Only aryan bahun chhetri are hindu.... By DNA analysis we all mongoloid race people are indigenous people of whole Asia
All Mongoloid race people are Asian origin and are indigenous people of Asia..... Asia is the origin place of we mongoloid/Mongol people.....
Enjoyed your content jamayang..keep it up with such great videos!!
Thanks so much 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
@Jam Jam
CONGRATULATIONS FOR OBTAINING YOUR DNA REPORT. I appreciate your time for analysis. you have explained it so well. Thank you for this informative presentation.
Good luck.
You look exactly like my people, the Nagas of Northeast India. Our ancestors are believed to have originated from China.
is it coincidence naga in malay language means dragon..i see similarity naga tribe with igorot in philippine and there's even naga city here.. it's interesting to 'feel' connection of human being
and i wonder if bhutan is hutan in malay means forest
But mostly yu people have somewhat less south asian than us.
Sir not China, originated from Tibet
@@Lhasa4642 The Nagas and the Tibetans have not much in common whereas the people of Yunnan province and the Nagas share so much in common.
I just read your story in facebook and came here to support your channel 😀
Very kind of you, thank you 🙏🏻
I have always been curious about Bhutanese DNA! Thank you for making one!
Thanks sheka, you should try one too
Bhutanese(Drukpas) DNA is native to Asian DNA.... All Mongoloid people are Asian origin.... So all Drukpas and Nepali origin mongoloid people of Bhutan are indigenous people of Bhutan
@Very Good See thehistory of Nepal.... Bahun chhetri entered in Nepal in 1495 A. D..... They were expelled by Mughol king Alaudhin Khilji from Rajasthan, India and other parts of India..... Nagaland, Meghalaya, Manipur had also expelked Aryan bahun chhetris..... Limbu indigenous people from eastern Nepal expelled bahun chhetri 71 years ago..... Bhutan expelled bahun chhetri in 1990.....If behaviour of bahun chhetri remain same then they will be expelled from Nepal...... Bahun chhetri are Eurasian origin, Caucasian.... They are non indigenous people..... Nepal is the land of indigenous Mongol/Mongoloid people..... Before 40 years American & Russian scientist team have proved the DNA of human fossil belong to Mongoloid people.... It was found in Nepal..... It is the fossil of ancestor of Mongolois people & it is the remain of 10.1 million years ago...... Bahun chhetru are foreigner......
@@indigenousgurung4105 didn't you just watch the video? It did not show Bhutan at all , Bhutan is just a place the people are mixed in Bhutan of various east and south east asian origin 😅
Very informative vlog jamyang!! 👍👍
Thank you Sedey 🙏🏻
Loved the content!
Thank you la 🙏🏻
Interesting topic.. DNA. Your facination with numbers and analytical subjects, has lived on thus resulting in this CZcams 😊
Yes, i always wondered where the bhutanese race might be from..
Interesting and Informative piece. Keep it up.
🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Interesting presentation. Especially the result of your DNA test - it put my mind over various region of the planet. Loved it. I am yet to test my DNA. I would be excited to see my result.😊
Thank you, my ancestors sure did move around alot. 😁
@@jamjamc yea, our ancestors moved around a bit and now we are moving more than they did. I am sure our descendants will be all over the places. 😁
@@travellerc5117 oh yes, the next generation will be a completely mixed gene pool. Share your dna results when you have them
@@jamjamc That is right. Surely, not sure when, but I will remember to share the result when I get mine tested.
Fun fact : Actually “Nepali” or “Lhotshampa” is a broad group name and actually aren’t “ethnic groups”. Nepali Ethnic groups in Bhutan include the Khas people (the one Nepali language comes from), Magar, rai, limbu, gurung, and tamang. There are also Sherpa and Newar and many others but I don’t think there are many of those in Bhutan. Regardless all of these ethnic groups have their own language, dress and culture. All the other expect the nepali language is related and closer to Dzongkha. Tamang and Sherpa specifically are the closest as they both come from old Tibetan. both tamang and Sherpa are written in Tibetan script.
nice research.. keep posting interesting videos like this (Y)
Thank you la 🙏🏻
It's normal. According to research, the Tibetans on the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau migrated from the Yellow River Basin, the Chinese also originated in the Yellow River Basin,The ancestors of the Bhutanese migrated from the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau.
Oh really, makes sense
While many young Bhutanese girls of your age are into Tik Tok, well, you are into some serious scholarly stuff. Keep it up and you will go far in life.
Thank you la 😊
MISS! EVERYTHING HAS GONE CHANGED NOW IN DRKBUT CORDIALLY THANK YOU!
Where I can connect with you to learn more about Dzongkha?
Hi beautiful results🤗 tashi delek. Can u upload your GEDmatch
Sure I'll 👍🏼👍🏼
That was so interesting, I think it would become more clear to you if you test both of your parents.
after getting my tests results I was shocked and confused
I agree, a whole family dna will paint a better picture. Why was your DNA test shocking
I am also planing to do this test since long time back,but currently I am staying in 🇨🇴Colombia which here is not the available region of 23and me and other companys..So you did a order online then they shipped that to Bhutan directly?And after that you shipped this back by internaional express?
Oh sorry to hear, have you tried other DNA testing companies such as ancestry and familytreedna? I live in canada as well as Bhutan so I ordered this kit in canada.
@@jamjamc I tried to search other comapanies but none of them ship that to Colombia,I might do it in the US or Canada because curentlly I plan to go back to the north in the summber(I HOPE THIS COVID SITUATION WILL GET BETTER IN THAT TIME😂)Thank you for this reply!
All the best to you. And will pray that covid situation gets better 🙏🏻 thank you for watching my videos
great job lots of love from druk CZcams studio
Nice results, are you considering uploading it to MyHeritage?
Hi! Jam, this ancestry tracing is real interesting. After seeing your video, I guess your father's side ancestor may be those Han Chinese elite from Southern Song dynasty who worked for the Yuan dynasty since Jiangsu province was the most prominent administrative and cultural capital of the Southern Song dynasty. When Yuan of Gengis Khan conquered Southern Song, they maintained the original government officers to serve the new regime. Who knows, then one day, your great great great grandpa was sent to Bhutan which was under the Yuan empire that time as expatriate and then he married local women and there the offspring flourished and lived in Bhutan.....
Oh that is very interesting, thanks for sharing.
There is a Chinese dna testing site and when i put my dna sample in there, it shows that I'm 50% Mongolian and the rest is a mix of minorities in china but not Han at all
During Yuan Dynasty Genghis Khan doesn’t even exist. He died centuries ago. It was his great grandson Kublai Khan who founded Yuan dynasty.
@@jamjamc can u post a vid about this)
Interesting... More videos pls :)
😁🙏🏻🙏🏻
Nice video from 🇵🇭
Love the Philippines & Jollibee 🙏🏻
What is cost of DND test
very informative
but can u @jamjamc give info about Y chromosome percentage among Bhutanese?
I am confused about the whole native American thing. Would you mind explaining it to me.
It’s amazing to know our ancestors of Bhutan. I’m curious to know mine.
Thank you for watching la 🙏🏻😁
Thank you for your very informative video. I had taken an Ancestry DNA test that told me I had Northern Chinese descent from the region of Bhutan. I am not sure how accurate this is because as you mentioned in your video, Bhutan is a very small country with a population of mixed heritages that is difficult to collect data on. I am surprised Ancestry DNA even has a Bhutan region in their results at all! Nonetheless, I appreciate learning about this country’s beautiful culture and people, especially considering I did not know Bhutan existed before seeing it in my DNA results.
Wow really, which dna site was it?
@@jamjamc It was the AncestryDNA test. I’m half Filipino, however, it showed I also had Chinese ancestry from Southern China, Northern China/Manchuria, and Bhutan.
I think I know what the issue is. AncestryDNA doesn't seem to have done a good job of breaking down their data when it comes to Asians. They have this group called "Northern China" which they have decided is a large area centered around Beijing and a smaller area that encompasses all of Bhutan. Therefore I am 100% Northern Chinese according to ancestry even though I am Bhutanese. 23 and me seemed much more more detailed and accurate.
@@Pureexhiliration Yes, to be precise, it is the population of the Yellow River Basin in Northwest China. The Bhutanese’s number pronunciation and first person and basic eyes, mouth, sun, and names can be understood by Chinese people, even though they are separated by more than 6,000 years. Haha I just live in People from Northwest China, the girl in the video looks very much like my neighbor’s sister when I was young. Her number pronunciation is very similar to our local dialect. Kind of mountain barrier
Buddhism and writing of Bhutan are from Tibet. From whole of Himalayas till gansu corridor was under Tibetan rule for many centuries. We taught you how to read and Write in Tibetan language. And Mongolian writing was create Tibetan Sakya Lama Dongon Choegyal phakpa on request of kublai khan.
🙏
Neither Buddhism nor Tibetan script of from Tibet. Buddhism originated in Southern-Nepal/Northern-India. Even Vajrayana Buddhism, the type of Buddhism practiced in Tibet and Bhutan originated in Nalanda school in Bihar, India in 6th century. Tibetan Script is Indian script, part of Gupta script of Brahmi script family. It was adopted by Tibet
Your culture have already been replaced by Nepalese/Indian culture but you guys got false worry about cultural replacement, so tortured and kicked out Bhutanese citizens Nepalese ethnic people, which the shameless so called government haven’t even apoloze yet but tries to hide it to the public.
@@wonderfullife737 Thoemi Sambhota, used deva nigiri script and some of the letters were invented by him like ཙ ཚ ཛ ཝ ཞ ཟ which are not in Indian alphabets. By the way Tibetan language was already existing as we have 4 thousand years of history, and modern Tibetan writing came to existence after going through lots of endeavors by Tibetan kings and scholars. Tibetan Buddhism and Tibetan writing didn’t came walking from Nalanda as Amazon delivery. Thousands of Tibetan scholars translated them to Tibetan languages by spending sweats and blood. Can you understand Buddhist scripture from Nalanda which are written in sanskrit or pali?
Not whole of Himalayas only Eastern part. Western Himalayans were always independent 💪. Kashmiri,Himanchal and Uttarakhandi people of India.
I’m mostly of Scottish descent some French German and Italian but I have trace amounts of central asian and siberian ancestry. I also have trace amounts of Northern Japanese ancestry
Ainuic ( Northern Japanese)
Lots of love from #nepal
Thank you
Good very informative
Thank you
Tibetans and Mongolians are not related people by Language & ethnic origin. Tibetans as an Tibeto-Burman origin with Mongol as a Mongolic origin. Though two major Inner Asian people were related culturally since the Mongols adoption of Tibetan Buddhism bringing Mongols under Tibetan sphere of Influence & Mongols military support to the Tibetan rulers.
As you mentioned in one of your video, “ I guess, the origin of Dongkha or Bhutanese language is Tibetan: The mother Language”. This tells a lot about the ethnic origin of majority of Bhutanese people.
nice and interesting video
Thanks marco 🙏🏻
The Chinese element in the data based may include Tibetans. The Tibetans and the Chinese do have centuries of exchange of genes or they only split some 5k yrs ago. The Tibetans were living in Amdo and Ningxia regiion for a thousand years . In NIngxia this is the border regions with the Mongolian Steppes. The Mixing on Mongolian or Proto Mongolian elements are possible. By 800 AD Tibetans are established a powerbase in Tibet and ruled the Amdo bordering Chine and Ning Xia before more Tibetan Tribes moving into todays Nepal Sikkim and Bhutan from 1 AD to 1200 AD. Remember these ancestry companies have to use modern naming convention for current population It does not mean you are Chinese of your ancestors were. It just means that you have genes similar to people who are called themselves Chinese and have been labelled as such in their data base. People move about through out history It could just mean that your ancestors from 3 k yrs ago were family with ancestors of some Chinese people today and family split to developed into their later ethnic names and cultural identity.
Hallo everyone here I am looking for egg donar from Bhutan,es we are similar.I am Tibetan lady 45,
as bataknese of north sumatra we believe our ancestor are mix of austronesian of natives aborigines indigenous taiwan and naga, mizoram, kuki-chin people
Thanks for the video. Just got my 23 and me result. Background : mother's side from Kurtoe Bhutan and My father side connections to Tsangla/Sharchop (Mongar) and Tibet. According to 23 and me , 81.5% of my DNA is Chinese and and 9.6% Manchurian Mongolian. Did not have any Myamar/Thai or South East Asian but I did have 1.4% North Indian and Pakistani ( Guru Rinpoche country , YES !!😃) . Strangely enough, it says among the regions in China, I have a stronger genetic connection to Guangdong , Hebei and Jiangsu province, and only then Tibet after that, even though my father's side is Tibetan.
Wow, if you import your 23&me results to wegene, i feel its more accurate. In there I'm 50% Mongolian, 20% from another minority in China similar to sharchop people and 15% tibetan
Update Aug 23-2022 . Looks like 23andme has updated their ancestry composition for Chinese ethnic groups. I am now 97.4 percent Northern Chinese and Tibetan, 1% central and 1.4% NorthEast Indian. Curious to know what your updated results are. I personally feel that this is far more accurate than the previous composion.
Bhutanese and Nepalese DNA Are same like Nepali Mongoliod Communities Rai,Limbu,Tamang,Magar,Gurung,Sherpa etc
Isn't the dragon on Bhutan's flag 3 claws? 4 Claw dragon is the prince level, but Bhutan was only the county king level in ancient times! Only the Chinese emperor is a 5-claw dragon.Don't make a mistake.
The DNA tests are very eurocentric, they don't document anything east of Iraq very well to begin with. DNA tests get very specific for european heritage and get very broad when it comes to east asian.
Agreed, i guess it's only fair as the database for American and European DNA must be more extensive as these countries have been doing DNA tests for a while. Hopefully, in the near future they have enough Asian sample to make these tests more accurate, esp a small country like Bhutan. Thanks for watching my video 🙏🏻
JamJam Choden you are not very native Bhutanese. I can feel it quite clearly. Just like the Tibetan singer Tserwang lhamo, very Chinese looking.
Great
Bhutan has a recorded existance from as early as 700 A.D which was a time when Guri Rinphoche arrived. It was a proof that Bhutan existed even before it. The cultural diversity in each region is also rich and different to each other. It may suggest that Himalayan region maybe home to early Asians. This is strongly supported by a Dutch Researcher who have done considerable research on Linguistics around Asia.He concluded that based on study of languages around Asia, the origin of early asians were from himalayan region around central or eastern Bhutan. From this region, they may have migrated to other direction and far, according to the Doctor.He also talked about it on BBS few years back. His finding is controversial to the history we know but linguistic studies are important tool used to identify early origins.We may as well be the ancestors rather than the descendants.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts la. Yes, i have mentioned in my video that the state of monyul may have existed between 500 bc and 600 ad.
Also, it is very much possible we could be the ancestors like you mentioned. However it will be difficult to know for sure as DNA testing can only tell you people who has similar DNA to bhutanese ppl live today, not necessarily where they came from . And China and india being very densely populated when compared to bhutan, they have better odds la.
kuenselonline.com/ancestry-of-the-bhutanese-people/#:~:text=The%20O%20haplogroup%20ancestor%20which,and%20as%20far%20as%20Lappland.
@@namgyal_Regy This was the research finding i was referring to. Thanks for sharing it.
I agree with you.
Bhutan existed from last billion years since the formation of Himalayas. It belongs to plants, animals, and other creatures, human is small part of it. You ngalongs should stop acting as if you invented Bhutan.
Hi! Jam, frankly speaking you look Chinese, different from those Bhutanese and Tibetan I met. Me too, I am Malaysian but my ancestry can be traced back to Henan China 1000 years ago. ..
Haha, i get that all the time even from Chinese ppl. Yes I have a really good friend who is Malaysian but his ancestors are Chinese too. Thank you for watching my videos 🙏🏻🙏🏻
Sichuan is in Tibet,U r of Tibetan descent,may be from amdo province of Tibet coz tall people are confined to this province of Tibet! Check whether u hv EPAS1 gene which is only found in Tibetans due to their adaptation to high altitude and your blood nitrous oxide and RBC levels and haemoglobin affinity of oxygen coz Tibetans have high levels of these two due to acclimatization or adaptation to high altitude unlike Chinese, Chinese don’t have that!
your clip was interesting
Whatever your origin is, you are extremely attractive young woman :) Btw, I am not an expert on DNA testing, but I think this is the science, not a matter of sample - they compare haplogroups, mitochondrial DNA etc, and it is possible that some of your ancestors came from China, hundreds or thousands years ago. I would say this is super super highly probably that some Chinese warrior (or slave or monk or merchant etc) was brought by winds of history near modern-day Bhutan and has spread his DNA one day.
I am from Poland, central Europe and we share some DNA with Ashkenazi Jews, German, Russians etc, even French or Scottish people. Many European ancestors came from modern East Ukraine or even Iran or Central Asia, nothing wrong with it. Btw, isnt the world amazing place, I can sit in the middle of Europe and watch Bhutanese girl talk about her country? What a fantastic world we live in today. Thank you for all your videos, this is super interesting.
Thank you :) yes, it makes a lot of sense that one of my ancestors must have come from china as china was the cradle of civilization, as was central asia.
And indeed it is very fascinating how connected our world has become now. I am honoured someone in Poland has found my video interesting. happy new year
Your are simply complicating it, doesn't have to be some fancy story about some fancy Chinese ancestor who went to Bhutan.
Chinese, Tibetians and Bhutanese, Northeast indians and some Koreans and Japanese all migrated out of China (the Qinghai Tibetian plateau) at some point of time. The migration most probably happened during the Neolithic age long before there was a proper Chinese civilization.
The admixture results are not haplogroup based. They're focused on the autosomes. Haplogroups are a minuscule minority of the genome.
You should upload your 23andme result to wegene, they are a Chinese company and specialize in Asian population, I think they can have a more accurate result.
I am not suprise at the 23andme result though, as both Bhutanese and Han Chinese are descendants of some same Sino-Tibetan tribes thousand years ago, when 23andme doesn't have enough data of Bhutanese alll they can do is to lump you into the most similar group.
I agree, i did try wegene and their site showed a completely different results. I felt it was more accurate. Planning to make a Video on the difference
I'v tested this, I'v got 60% Mongolian composition.
Oh really, where are you from
@@jamjamc Mongolia
@@Euas_proud ohh you're the real descendant of Genghis Khan
But no one says where these kheng people came from. Any one knows la?
😆bro it's the same for every Bhutanese be it north east west south although some portion of South is different... Regarding the ethnicity not much difference we r all inter mixed and have dominant Tibetan genes mostly..
You look very alike Han Chinese the first eye I saw you.
When her 18.5% kicks in she hop on a yak with a bow and arrow 😂
it's not 23andme fault lol, sichuan and tibet people's intermarriages are common throughout history, and sichuan itself isn't a closed-off provinces at all, so many people in sichuan share migrated ancestry from other provinces of china...
I think so too 👍
@@jamjamc can't help but say you are beautiful btw😄😄
❤️❤️❤️
🙏🏻😁❤️
i am from Nepal and have mongoloid and east asian traces, it does not mean i am from america europe or africa, i am proud of where i am from, DNA linkage may prove bhutan very close to nepalese ethnics, well that should be proved in DNA laboratory. anyway, i was really concerned about sound , what actually is wrong ? i all went through sub titles
I'm from manipur North East India
...Bhutan was inhibited,...not inhibited but inhabited, please correct
The tattooed ladies you showed were Zo people a tibeto burman speaking people’s 😊
I can't believe I choose not to visit Bhutan .
I'll never had a chance again.
wow this girl is so pretty
Lame 😜
Are you from Bhutan??
Yes she is
You had 71% Connection with Jiangsu province and 29% Sichuan Tibetan Area. That means you are pure Chinese 😂👌🏻💯
Sichuan and Jiangsu is Tibet. Bhutan used to be part of Tibet. Tibetan are not Chinese. Yes, currently China has occupied Tibet that doesn’t make Tibetan origins are Chinese.
@@mellowyellowlemon7270 Tibetan are Chinese.
@@TheBhujangi nah pro. We don’t even share same DNA 😅
@@faithfulshadow yes they do.
Wow I am intrested to gor for DNA. As people always mistake me for Chines specially in the International Airports.
You must try la
Jamyang, your ancestors are Chinese. Embrace it!! Also thank you for sharing your story. Your DNA does not lie.
Your ancestors didn't necessarily migrate out of the places in China shown in your DNA test, it simply means people who live in those areas have similar DNA to your ancestors.
This is because Han Chinese, Bhutanese, Tibetians and northeast indians all originate from the same ancestor, you can include some Koreans and Japanese too. They all migrated out of the Qinghai Tibetian plateau into different directions thousands of years ago.
Yes but with the passage of time all of them have intermarried with other ethnic minorities they met in the place they migrated. But overall they are same genetically, the difference is cultural.
Btw I am from Arunachal Pradesh.
Hi there, I absolutely agree with your reasoning. I also believe DNA only tells you where ppl who has similar DNA to yours like today, not necessarily where they came from.
Arnachal is so close to Bhutan, are you native to this region?
@@jamjamc yes I belong to one of the native ethnic groups here in Arunachal. Our ancestors migrated from Tibet too (some of them still live there) but that was thousands of years ago. Our ancestors migrated out of Tibet to Arunachal long before the advent of mainstream Tibetian civilization, so our culture is more aboriginal and there is less influence of mainstream Tibetian culture.
Tibetans called us "lobha" or Southerners. We called ourselves "Tani" which further divided into different tribes like (Nyishi, Adi, Galo etc. )
More recent migrants to Arunachal from Tibet like Monpas and Menbas have more Tibetan cultural influence and are Buddhists. I also think that Bhutanese people are same as the Monpas and might have migrated out of Tibet first to the Tawang area in Arunachal and from there to Bhutan (correct me if I am wrong)
Oh very interesting, does your ethic group also practice buddhism? What language do you guys speak? I have met people from arnachal who speak Tsangla, the language spoken in Eastern part of bhutan. I think they call themselves pema kutpa or something like that
@@jamjamc Yes Members of our ethnic group that live in Tibet and near the Arunachal Tibet border practice budhhism and can speak mainstream Tibetian. As for those of us that live in Arunachal Pradesh, we did not have much influence of mainstream Tibetian culture, mainly because our ancestors migrated out of Tibet during the Neolithic age when mainstream Tibetian culture wasn't Fully formed and also because we lived in isolated geographical terrain we didn't have much contact with Tibetian culture other than through trade. We speak our own "Tani" languages which comes under Tibeto-Burman language group and has lot of similar words and vocabulary with Tibetian, but I think our language must have more in common with ancient pre Buddhist Tibetan language. Modern Tibetan language has lot of Indian, Mongol and Chinese influence which is not present in the language of my ethnic group.
The ethnic group in Arunachal in that I find similar to the Bhutanese are called the Monpas. en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monpa_people
There are around 3000 Monpas in eastern Bhutan too. I think Monpas and Bhutanese have the same origin, maybe the Bhutanese migrated out of Tibet into the Tawang area of Arunachal and from there to Bhutan and Monpas followed them later.
@@50nerds yes, i think monpas are similar to a tribal people in Bhutan living in a place called Merak Sakten.
You seem very well-versed in the geology of your people and neighboring states.
I did a quick read up on lhoba people and your culture is very beautiful. I could see some similarities to bhutanese culture such as animists beliefs, genital worships, making bamboo products and other cultural aspects. Even in Bhutan we practiced Bon religion before buddhism came to Bhutan and it is deep seated in our culture today, we still worship the forest deities, serpent deities and so on.
I would love to visit Arnachal pradesh one day. Thank you for the amazing lesson 🙏🏻
You seems prity much happy to learn that you are more from China or a Mongolians are you ?
And about that Archery, Horse riding sport we Tibetans are doing it since time immemorial ... , ...The list of places you have Showned in the report which is Sichuan ......it's in Tibet which means you must be either Amdo or Kham provinces ...
even the very language you speak and write is similar to Tibetans although a little prounounciation / accent differs but the scriptures 100 percent same as Tibetans , the religion, the dresses esp the tops , the rituals you performs , so in what ways you think you are more to Chinese origin or a Mongolian ??? .... .
The very roots and your origin is same as the Tibetans has and please don't act some kind of new breeds or hybrids or thinks of more Chinese or Mongolians otherwise ? Our DNA is a unique than the rest of World and that includes you too .....( Do the blood Test )
Yes percentage wise there may be some mixture of other related genes but over 80 or 90 percent it should be Tibetan Origin or genetics in you which of ofcourse they the test won't show it ........look up the Map properly
The Tibet plateau sits at the Top most ,
The migration in some cases might goes up and settle there but most cases it goes further down or strecthes to sideways ......only few countries or tribes have this unique genes which you and I have ....very rare in this planet .... .
But hold on I had to check the list of your reports again just to make sure ...may be you were right you are not one of us ...if the list shows more Chinese Cities ...
Just kidding la 😄
But on a serious note Unlike this DNA test you did, there is another Test which is also a DNA test but more details in it ...Showing the percentage of chemical or genes in our blood has ......that will only tell the precise results ......these DNA test are not enough and I suggest not fully bliv in this .....
Best wishes 🙏
I am curious about your wegene result, I have roots in Bhutan, my parents are Pemako Tibetans, my result in 23andme is 77% Chinese, 11% Mongolians, 1.7 Koreans, 5 others, My Genes is closest to Chinese since it is the largest pool of DNA samples on 23andme, but on wegene I have got zero Han Chinese, instead I am 50% Naxi, 22% Mongols and 17% Tibetans 😂
my friend,wegene have more samples which is difficult for west countries to identify.you can use all kinds of tools to find out all kinds of results.but the gene distance is same.you are close to which group,this is the truth…
naxi纳西 is ethnic group living next to Tibetan in Yunnan province. So Take thw naxi part as Tibetan.
@@jedhuang3817 Naxi are closest to Tibetans and Qiangs which is why my result on Wegene identifies me as Naxi even though I clearly have no parental connection with this group
All came from homo sapien monkey of Africa and settled elsewhere as hunter gatherers. So it seems bhutan. First came the gongduks, monpas, and doyas encircling black mountain. Then came others with latest settlers being lhotshampas... my take
I think you look like a Japanese and Central Asian too. Not so much Chinese. Just an observation.
Oh really 😁
Wow I was also thinking she's much like japanese....
Han Chinese is quite ambiguous ethnic group. They're basically a cultural identity instead of actual ethnicity. I am not Han Chinese and my DNA came up 90% Chinese. If you understand DNA, it doesn't mean you're a Han Chinese. It just means you shared similarities with the samples that your DNA was compared to.
Han Chinese has it DNA headstream. most of them came from 6 male ancestors over7000 years ago
@@jedhuang3817 research?
Yes
Han is semi biological rrlated ethnic,all have high percentage of han paternal dna,han maternal dna is there too butmixed with ethnic minprities
I got 75% han Chinese measur e by wegene 23andme similar result.. But tracking back 2000years family tree ,my ancestors recorded are all Han Chinese. your 90％ han means similarity by measure DNA. same origin with modern Han people pre written history, which we may not trace back.
Mostly yu are east asian and less amount of south asian(northern india/pakistani).yu look great like a chinese with some what mixed with south and central asia.
Google Silver leaf culture by a Japanese professor. The lhotsampas came to Bhutan in the mid 1950s as laborers to work in the teak forests in the south. Later they were given citizenship but to only those who could prove their parents came to Bhutan around the time frame given above. Another good read is the “Bhutan and the British” by Peter Collister.
Thank you for the recommendation la. 🙏🏻
I am tibetan in China.tibetan language and Bhutanese language is very similar
Oh Happy to hear you can watch my youtube videos in china
你用的什么vpn
@JamJam Choden
Bhutan is very beautiful，I hope I can visit Bhutan one day.my hometown is in China and Bhutan border，China and Bhutan are friends.all tibetans in China love Bhutan，we have same culture and language.Because india don't want to china and Bhutan communicate with each other，we tibetans can't reach Bhutan，Bhutanese can't visit China，i hope china and Bhutan can become good friends one day，i love you，you are very beautiful，thanks.
@Yeshi Yangzom
我是商人，我本人经常去尼泊尔进货
tezin saladlam 我感觉你是藏族穆斯林。
Bhutan is kingdom of early Tibet. That’s it
13:15, I don't know why you have Central and South Asian DNA despite your fair skin.
miao-yao or hmong-mien have 76% - 90% east asia chinese and vietnam,
Hi friend so nice so beautiful.
Some of the Bhutanese vocabulary is same with Kuki in Manipur India.
I bet cuz we are close by
Kuki are difarent
Nepalese speaking people in Druk are aboriginal?? Bonkers. Try tracking them you will find them immigrated from Nepal.Drukpa's earliest inhabitants is traced in central part of Drukyul.
@Very Good The Doyaps are the aboriginals of Bhutan. Then comes the other ethnic groups like the Ngalongs, Sharchops, etc with the latest being Lhotshampas(Nepalese origin).
Yes true
@@dreamgirl-rx2hx👍
If I ever got chance to do dna n result shows my ancestors were from china then I would be devastated 😢.....anywhere will be okay but not china.....
Lepchas???
Not sure i understand, can you please repeat the question
@@jamjamc there are lepchas
Nepalis origin peoples
You look like our fellow Mongolian woman.
You guys are our ancestors 😁
The national flag of Bhutan is too domineering, I thought it was the flag of the Chinese Empire.
In my humble opinion, Bhutan should be divided into four countries according to their ethnic lines.
I think Chinese is “Tibetan Thts what they mean “
You are Tibetan :D
Nope, bhutanese 😁
@@jamjamc Bhutan, Naga, Tibet, Sherpas are tibetic nations.
@@jamjamc Sweety Bhutanese is Tibetic and Mongolian is Mongolic Xianbei
Hi
🙏🏻🙏🏻
Bhutan is bután, means something like "on a silly way of thinking" in the modern hungarian dictionary
bhutunese came from tibet
It might be likely that you belong to an elite Bhutanese family, simply by the fact that you have records if your lineages as far as 1700s. Only elite and powerful families, perhaps rich aristocratic families, in Bhutan keep written records of family genealogy.
Most of the Bhutanese aristocrats were recent immigrants from Tibet, like few centuries back, especially devout followers of Zhabdrung Repoche, and it might be likely that one of them could have been direct descendants of Han Chinese families stationed by Beijing in Tibet, who then likely intermarried with Tibetans, and then immigrated to Bhutan during formation of Bhutan by Zhabdrung Repoche.
Well, that could explain why your family members look different from average Bhutanese people.
Not an elite but definitely an old family. Your theory is a very interesting one, and quite plausible. I also think most ppl in Bhutan might have had some ancestors that came with zhabdrung Rinpoche.
The DNA company i did my test with showed other bhutanese DNA too and they had similar composition to mine. Definitely a mystery :)
Your are simply complicating it, doesn't have to be some fancy story about some fancy Chinese ancestor who went to Bhutan.
Chinese, Tibetians and Bhutanese, Northeast indians and some Koreans and Japanese all migrated out of China (the Qinghai Tibetian plateau) at some point of time. The migration most probably happened during the Neolithic age long before there was a proper Chinese civilization.
@@jamjamc @johnc the Quinghai province in China is part of Tibet and they are the Amdo/Kham province in Tibet. The people in Amdo and Kham are generally taller than the people from the rest of Tibet. 🙏
with a great sense of humor.
Often someone who is tan with brownish green eyes.
Likes to drive the boys wild
23 and me is not accurate for tibetic people. Try my heritage DNA, your Mongolian and central Asian will grow up and Chinese decrease
Oh really, i shall try it
Bhutan has so many similarities with Tibetans than Chinese. Tibetans are not Chinese and Tibetans did not mentioned in the list of the company's DNA test. All people of inner Mongolia are considered as Chinese too. So your DNA test result at the end became very blurred but interesting one. You are simply a Bhutanese and it really matters for you. It'll be remained unaltered. All the best for you.
Surprising I thought we Bhutanese would mostly be closer to Tibetans and Mongols
So did I 😁
We belongs to a larger East Asian group that are quite close genetically:)
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/East_Asian_people
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_history_of_East_Asians
Bhutanese are close to tibetans, but not close like you thought to mongols
@@barguttobed Guess I should have be specific what I meant to say was that Bhutanese would be closer to Mongols compared to Chinese. What you said is true, but there could possibly be just distant blood relations between Mongols and Bhutanese
@@Thinkofwhat that is not true. Tibetans are 60% brown/black people similar to that of Andaman island and only 40% East Asian. Sort of like modern day Mexicans who are majority mestizo
i think you are some kind of ancient hungarian!
bhutan flag look like China Qing Dynasty falg
Oh really, that's an interesting fact
@@jamjamc sister，i am from pakistan，i am a news editor，i often see many bhutan people comment on the godi （india）media，they say they hate china，because the Chinese army invaded bhutan territory，but i can not sure that they are real bhutan people or fake indian people，is it really exists？most of people dislike china？
@@PakistanChinaFriendship hi there, i don't believe so. I have many good friends who are from China. Our culture is very similar too. However our government is very close with India
@@jamjamc you are chinese，not real bhutan，lol
@@BharatMataKeJai And you are a troll trololol.
Your DNA says ur father is not ur dad... but the uncle who lives in jaigon
no finnish? im sorry you are not bhutanese.. :(