A HATERS GUIDE to the 2024 NFL QB Draft Class (Every Players Biggest Red Flag)
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 06. 2024
- As we approach the 2024 NFL draft, I thought I would make a sattire video about the biggest flaw for each and every big time QB prospect, enjoy!
- Sport
What did I get right/wrong?
Vibes
Let’s pray this class doesn’t turn out like the 2021 or 2022 class.
With McCarthy, he actually ran the most difficult and pro-style offense out of the top QBs, with many tight sets and very few free yards (think Bo Nix.) His level of experience can certainly be viewed as a red flag, but I don’t think the style of offense he ran is a negative, and on the contrary, it raises his stock compared to the other QBs who ran college offenses that aren’t very similar to what they will be asked to do when they go pro.
You got Reed wrong, I truly think he can be a top 10 QB in the league.
JJ.
If the scouting combine had hand off drills, it would convince everyone McCarthy is QB1.
Lol
Tom Brady barely threw the ball in college and he did pretty well for himself
You are unoriginal and unfunny
@@LouieOcean.Tom Brady went in the 6th round lol, completely different prospects
You should do a video like this for the Running Backs in this draft.
As a patriot fan I love seeing videos like this all you ever hear about is the good and you wonder why there’s always a trubisky or Wilson drafted high
You could do this with every prospect. Some picks are dumber than others but when you need a franchise QB you have to take a big swing. Ex) Mahomes and Josh Allen. They were terrible prospects
@@Chrisd0ntmissnot terriblr
@@Worthyishim terrible is a stretch but they were not good or inspiring, both teams were laughed at
Pats should’ve kept Mac and drafted Marvin Harrison Jr
Great video, would love to see more like this. Not because I'm a 'hater' but draft coverage is full of analysts gushing about players and it is good to see the other side to get a fuller picture
Great work scott u would make a great villain lmao ild say most
Good video. You actually did a much better job than most of the analysts on networks.
I love this video hahaha Glass half empty approach!
Great video idea
Bo Nix being too old + Drake Maye being too young = Oxymoron
Different scenarios though Bo Nix has heaps of experience at the collegiate level but it’s the age that’s looks like a concern due to him being 24 at the start of the season which gives less time for him develop give 2-3 years of development he’ll already be 26-27
Maye on the other hand is 21 and has time to develop but he will penalty be going to a pretty bad team but he was only a starter for two years and that sweet spot is 3 years as a starter which is good because it gives you enough to work with and learn from but also allows for the draftee to be relatively young at 21-22 come time of the draft
Hope that helps
Oxnix mayeon
I respect you and your opinions
I don't know why people think being a game manager is a bad thing. That's literally the position of QB.
In the end you can have the most talented QB but if you don't have a team around them letting them ball out will only get you Dan Marino's career. A proper game manager can win super bowls with the right team around them.
QB is a PG
It doesn't usually win rings in the nfl ala kirk cousins. A good qb but wilts under the lights.
@@Denozo88that is absolutely Kirk. Just look at him hitting JJ for an insane 4th and forever catch in the regular season and than getting 2 drives to win the playoff game against the giants and deciding to dump the ball off for 3 yards on a 4th and 7. Absolutely mid
@@StraightCashHomie23ah yes because it was Kirk cousins who led up 400 yards and 31 points to Daniel jones at home
A great QB is a game manager AND a playmaker. You can win a lot of games with a game manager who can make some good throws. But you'll struggle in the postseason, because you will face top opponents and your QB will have to make some great plays to win the game.
Marino was just unfortunate in the era he played in. There were too many teams with dominant defensive front 4's and front 7's, and that's where his teams always fell short. They had very good team builds, but teams like Dallas, Washington and San Francisco were fielding teams with absolute mutants in the trenches, and there was nothing the AFC seemed able to do about it.
I think KC had the trenches figured out on the defensive side, so they could go toe-to-toe with, for instance, the O-Line that Dallas had in the early '90s, but KC just never had a QB or decent offensive tackles during the '90s. The best of that bunch was Joe Montana, while John Alt could still play decent.
Year after year, KC would be the team that could probably stand up to those NFC teams, but it was always defeated by teams with better quarterbacks, once Joe Cool had taken enough beatings (too many) behind that built-for-running offensive line.
Love it
Just put Penix behind a halfway decent offensive line and he will light the NFL up.. Also look for Joe Milton to go a lot higher than expected.. Teams are not going to keep passing on someone with his arm talent no matter how flawed he is..
Pretty accurate, talking point, Scott.
I agree 100 percent with your analysis on Maye!!! Didn't show up in the Big Lights
Bad footwork misses layups and buckles under pressure
Can you do a haters guide on potential heisman candidates for next season lol
Penix has gone through at least 3 of 5 seasons healthy.
@Rysofly no he played 6 seasons in college and was only healthy his two years at washington
@@justinalley3399 I stand corrected.
❤❤Drew Brees was too small to 🎉🎉🎉
I hope you're wrong about Penix (that he's one knee injury away from career over).
Penix Jr is the best pocket passer in the draft with 500 passing yards.
Should wide receivers next
Does Jordan Travis have any draft capital? I get that he got injured but idk I feel like he should have some capital. Is there any chance he gets drafted?
yeah he's upposed to be in the 5th round
I've wanted a what's wrong with them film for ages. The highlights are a waste of time, it's what they can't do or do badly that's the issue and is it fixable or coachable. To quote a line from the film Draft Day, 'What's his thing; and can we live with it?'
Great video. Sam Hartman, Spencer Rattler, Bo Nix are gonna be late round draft steals Or at least one of them. I feel like one is gonna have that Dak Prescott rookie season.
Rattler is my pick of those three listed. Hartman looks like a spring league stud. I believe Bo goes in the first to ensure he has a 5th year option.
Yeah I'm gonna say Rattler is the pick from those three. Best chance if he starts to play well. Maybe Nix if he's in an absolutely loaded system but I doubt it.
Broncos will take Bo at 12,we're desperate for a QB
Hartman and nix college experience should helo
Can somebody explain to me why being 24 years old as a rookie is considered a downside? Scott mentioned that Bo Nix would be 28 or 29 when his rookie contract expires, isn't 24 -29 basically primer qb years? Why would the drafting team care about that? Is the idea that the team that drafts the player expects they can resign them after their rookie contract?
Well in sports today their is this imo nonsensical premium put on youth basically the younger you can get a dude the better because the thinkin is he will have more potential and hopefully more playing years I think this mentality is dumb and ignores the experience and extra reps you get from playing longer in college
Because that is 3 less years that he can potentially play for you. That is 3 extra years of picking up bad habits in college. When picking a qb early the hope is that they remain on your team for the better part of two decades. If two qbs carry the same grade teams will take the younger player.
Hartman i think if given the right system to grow in will be a boom. Hes a project QB. Not someone ready to start today or next year but give him time to grow hell be good. Not elite but he could be one of the better QBs from this draft in 10 years
When healthy, Penix can be great and a steal in the 2nd or 3rd round
i agree if he really falls to the 2nd round i hope my raiders can get him there.
i would be super hyped if that happens
Agreed I honestly like him more than Daniels
Penix to Las Vegas
Can people please stop calling QB’s game manager’s like it’s a bad thing. Y’all young people can’t even understand that ALL QUARTERBACK’S should be game manager’s….! Its their job to MANAGE THE GAME. They have to protect the football, run the offense, control the huddle, can’t turn it over, move the ball down field. The QB position is an extension of the head coach while he’s on the field… So YES that is EXACTLY what ANY QUARTERBACK’S job is, to mange everything and everyone on the field. People sound so clueless when they use this label. Give me a game manager all day… Y’all need to stop listening to Cam….🤔
#Clueless
Frank Gore was seen as a injury Prone player coming out of Miami…. Look what happened there. Sometimes it’s just bad luck that creates the narrative. Maybe Penix is actually injury prone though.
There is a difference between "injury prone" and a guy who had a couple of bad injuries. Injury prone usually refers to guys who aren't solidly built, or have other issues, and are constantly suffering various injuries to different parts of the body. They just don't hold up under the pounding.
Michael Penix had two serious knee injuries at Indiana when he was running the football a lot. At Washington he was still mobile when he had to be, but became a pocket passer first and foremost was not injured enough to miss even a game during his time there. Those were serious knee injuries to be sure, so there is a legitimate red flag with regard to them holding up over an NFL career. But Penix is definitely not "injury prone."
LOL at the age being a big factor when the guy is 24! Starting at QB in college for more than one season is a plus imo. No guarantees anywhere or with any player, but how many inexperienced college QBs excel with more complicated NFL offenses?
I think Spencer could be a starter. He has been constantly throwing in tight windows at SC. He was SC, and he has matured a lot while at SC.
He has also really looked like dogshit more than a few times there as well. He absolutely has the talent, but he strikes me as a guy who will make a living as a great backup
@@StraightCashHomie23if Maye goes to Washington or New England. I'd bet Nix has a better nfl career
Williams red flag is diva behaviour 100%
😂True
How is he a diva? Stop following the hating trend. Its lame
@@DocNinini nope is a fact he has maturity issues
@justinalley3399 Literally has no character concerns lol goofies like you and most of you lame trolls are mainly yts for whatever odd reason. Never had any locker room issues, never heard anything from his coach just all speculation you mfs weird asl 😓
@@DocNinini he painted his nails "fuck nda" and "fuck Utah" and cried and didnt shake the Utah's teams hands when they lost 😂😂
A ton of QBs will be drafted this year. I am not certain if ANY will be starting in 4 years.
Drake Maye tried to carry his team when he didn't need to quite often.
It didn't help the defense was awful forcing him to play agressive.
@@Denozo88 I'll give you that one.
Drake maye has the lowest floor in this draft class imo
I kinda feel bad for Drake Maye. He really could've benefitted by staying at least one more year to hone his incredibly high potential and jump into what'll surely be a less QB heavy draft. He's still gonna be drafted high but in the future he's definitely gonna be compared to the rest of the QB's this year and when that includes a draft packed with 5th year seniors, 5 of whom were Heisman finalists and two of whom won it, who are also all incredibly skilled in their own right then he'd better be the next Mahomes or he'll fall off the map real quick. Oh well, his choice.
It could work for the best for him to go to a team (like the Vikings) who don’t need him to start right away with a QB minded HC
I don't understand why age is a concern for QB prospects, I understand for a RB it being a concern due to the shelf life of RBs, but QBs optimally last 10+ years in the league, what does it matter if after 10 years they are 32 or 35 years old? The value you get from a QB doesn't diminish tremendously after the 30 age mark
I completely agree. I think when people see a younger draft prospect they assume there is unrealized potential or something, but for some reason if you’re 24 or 25 what you see is what you get. It doesn’t really make sense to me
And no due respect to men, but they seem to take more time to mature, so being older might be better in the long term. 😊
what about jordan travis
As a Michigan fan you are absolutely correct about jj McCarthy
Asking honestly, do you think the Chargers would trade Herbert to the Vikings and just take JJ McCarthy with the 5th pick? If yes, how much would Minnesota need to send L.A. in exchange? Would it be both of this years first round picks, plus the next two seasons first as well? Would the Chargers insist on the deal including Justin Jefferson?
More?
Less?
Please let me know what you think, and thank you in advance. 🙂
Dead cap is like 100 mil. Definitely not happening.
I would take Penix any day!
Pause😭😭
Were here to talk about the NFL draft not your sex life
@@vitigaymer1053
It's like the pot calling the kettle black!
I just looked up some of your comments on the channel and talk about female vibes I'm getting from you!
One of your comments is..
"love the aesthetics of a quarterback wearing glasses" WTF!?! Yikes Bro!
Or shall I say Bra! 😅
@@-C.S.R If he actually said then truth! 😂🤦
I respect the skill of professional hating
All these QBs have issues, so the haters are right on this QB draft class.
Bears fans afraid we're looking at Leaf 2.0
It is going to be a interesting draft class no doubt
Sam Hartman has the best head of hair of any draft eligible QB, Bears should take a shot.
Fuck no
@@robma8559 that’s a pretty strong response for a not serious comment.
@@dirtybird311 all i said was fuck no😂 just two words. Its nothing against hartmans luscious locks.
@@robma8559 I know man. I’m just kidding. Tone doesn’t come across on these things.
I thought Daniel’s was taller than penix and nix
1. Your video isn’t too negative for CZcams
2. Spencer Rattler would be a great pick for the Dallas Cowboys. He’s got a great name.
I initially mistook this as a Urinitaing Tree video seeing hater's guide.
Honestly, I see Bo Nix age as a plus. He’s played a lot of football at a high level for the past 5 years. He’s still only 24 years old. At least you know you’re not getting someone year wonder who balled out his redshirt Junior year and now thinks he’s ready for the NFL.
Drew Brees was small ❤❤❤
Yea he was a hof under 6'0 trailblazer
Rattler was solid!?!? 🤣🤣 neverrr!! The Oklahoma and South Carolina film on him doesn’t lie. But I’ll give you credit for being nice.
I have a weird feeling coming from a bama fan. JJ is either gonna be a very good qb or a completely terrible one. Like for any player i think it depends on what team he goes too
I saw nix at Auburn. It wasn't pretty
John elway was 23 years old.Coming out of college wasn't delete until his late 30s.I think bonex is Byfar the right age
Joe Milton go vols and kamal hadden and Jaylen wright
Also all of the transfers don't have a shot in my book. They dont have tenure, complain, leave, trys to lead but always coached, and its a waste of time for the schools and fans.
Mike Leach said you cannot teach consistency, either you have it or you don't, so if you hear about a QB being inconsistent, it is a hard pass.
UrinatingTree
Bo Nix is going to the broncos. It's the most sure thing after Caleb to the bears
I do not get how people come to a conclusion whereas Caleb will be a bust because of supposedly leadership issues he has a good arm and can run I don't know what else you want from him
Sam Hartman ought to just be a spokesmodel after football like Jesse Palmer did or the way Jimmy Garapolo should go do (too much of a pretty boy to be in the NFL 😅)
You forgot Jordan Travis!
Why does age matter since when is 23-24 old huh....how is that a negative? Didn't we see how Zach Wilson played out and he was one of the youngest players in the league
Throwing motions lol the make or break of bs for the assimilation of cant find too much wrong but i dont' like the way they throw. Funny women say that about cars... I don't like that color. Well qbs without perfect motions, favre, tebow, even the greats aren't that perfect.
You have " Bo Nix " as { Bo Nicks } , maybe it can be edited to be " Bo Nix " instead like it should be. From time stamp 6:12 to 6:21 you can read his name ; at 6:21 it's a very up close view as well. I'm not sure how Bo Nix would feel about this but I might feel a little dispapointed if this had happended to me.
Williams is a bust
Being a Duck, of course I h8 all Toejams and Fuskys. However, how can all the scouts be that wrong about Caleb?? He's been a "can't miss" for two years now.
Explain
The reason Caleb Williams was playing hero ball is because he had no choice, his team sucked, horrible offensive line and probably one of the worst defenses in college. He had to play hero ball just to keep them in the game, but apparently you didn’t watch the games he played in.
The exact same applies to Rattler.. But Rattler had even less offensive weapons
Bo nix: not an accurate deep ball
Caleb is Kyler. Great talent, below average leader and team guy.
rattler gets rattled easily and only sees right side of the field when under pressure.
At the end of the day, your “subjective” opinion on all of these QBs matters not. What we have seen over the years is that y’all do not know what you’re talking about and you get all of these picks wrong! The fact that we have undrafted or late round picks have went to do miracles. And your first rounders have been busts! For example, Tom Brady being picked at pick number 199!
Just keep quiet and let these boys cook in peace!
Just watch Michigan vs Georgia and you'll get your answer
Williams has headspace issues. Massive concern to me.
You have to be a game manager at times when you’re a QB genius!
Caleb Williams will be thr first QB taken, but he shouldn't be because he's not a leader of men.
you sound like a younger and less corny version of five star vids
Caleb Williams is the next Jameis Winston. Please bookmark this comment and come back in 3 years.
Bookmarking now fam I believe it too
Along with being a great game manager and having all the tools to be successful, JJ McCarthy is *fast.* Like Lamar Jackson and Patrick Mahomes fast. I think he’s going to develop into an elite QB.
As a Michigan fan JJ has a lot of potential. But like he said in the video the right team needs to draft him or he’ll be a bust.
McCarthy shouldn’t be drafted within the first four rounds. No outstanding arm talent, panics easy, slow, ect.
How do you not cover Jordan Travis?
I've got Travis the 8th QB drafted. Late round steal.
I was wondering the same. He may be coming off of an injury, but he is a 4-6 rounder imo. I guess he just fell off the radar because of the injury.
Age thing is so stupid. Football teams should be looking to win now, not ten years later
No Jordan Travis is sad
They are all second to third round picks. Any team who will draft them for first round is gonna regret it
80 percent of QB's are over drafted. It is what it is.
@@cooldude7821but it dont matter if they are good so what
@@moalston4203 Exactly. If you need a QB. The guy you want is there. And you think there's no guarantee he'll be there next time around. Take him & don't look back.
@@cooldude7821 if im the falcons gm, i will only pick qb on the third or fourth round. Most qb left at that stage are not overhyped, hardworking, no pride and willing to be redshirt for a year to learn a system. But i will pick a running back or wide receiver on the first round. Most of the RB and WR from college transition better to the pros
@@stalker7028 Ok.
Game manager for JJ? He would run for 1st downs, extend plays with his legs, throw bombs and small window passes. If you watched him day in day out. You would honestly see why harbaugh says he is the best qb in the draft.
Bo nix best in the draft no 🧢
Copying Urinating Tree hardcore I see
What about Jordan Travis and Taulia Tagovailoa
Sam has lived up to his hype since QB1. He's at least been a consistent winner.
sam hartman sucks
Gonna be another bunch of underperforming players and probably a bust or two depending on what a team does to trade up.
Caleb Williams has bust on him a major red flag.
Whats the red flag?
@@AC-py9dkthat's easy
1. Not a leader of men- niggas not respecting a grown ass man that paints his nails, idgaf how the media slices it
2. Was on an all star team this year and they went 8-4
3. Too loose with the ball, media wants the next Mahomes but Mahomes wasn't Mahomes until he sat behind Alex Smith and learned from one of the greatest head coaches ever for 2 years. Play style is more like Brett Favre
4. Already paid...takes a special person to be wealthy and still remain hungry, this is the benefit of having a young player, they have something to prove. He's already a millionaire, didn't play hungry this year. See reason #2
5. Bears are a terrible organization...He's going to a place that is notoriously hard on qb's, they just had a guy that was getting better each year, barely gave him a supporting cast and then got rid of him for the "next hot thing". He will feel pressure from fans/front office to perform immediately and it won't go well
Caleb Williams cant throw in the pocket and is inaccurate under pressure and turover machine agaisnt good defenses
@@justinalley3399 The fact about his leadership skills, crying for his mom during a loss and other red flags makes it seem like he is a bust. I don't want him on the Bears. He said that he wanted to be on the Washington team.
@@the1magageneral323as a Vikings fan, I hope he’s a bust for the Bears but I moreso hope the Vikings have figured out how to scout QBs after not having a legitimate franchise QB since Tarkenton
Can't wait to subscribe to the trash
You're 24yrs old? You're to old! Smh
Michael Penix Jr, Daniels or JJ McCarthy are the best QBs in the draft class.
McCarthy is a slightly more talented Mac Jones. Literally, what did he do, exactly to grant him a higher status over Caleb Williams and Drake Maye. And if you say he won the National Championship I'm gonna lose my fucking mind.
I want the Bears to draft Michael Penix Jr or JJ McCarthy.
@@the1magageneral323 I would absolutely adore them doing that just because of how hilariously funny and incompetent that would be
@@jcore0981 What would be funny about that? I don't want Caleb Williams on the Bears. Penix Jr has had 500 passing yards, Fields and Williams has not come close to that. Penix Jr is the best QB on the board.
@the1magageneral323 Holy fuck that is retarded. First of all, Williams has thrown for 400, so I'm not really sure how big of a distinction that really is. Second of all, he has had games with 500 combined yards. Third and most importantly, how many games has Williams been benched before the end of the 3rd quarter because it was a blowout? I'd say a good portion. Also, there's more than just pure passing numbers. There's decision-making, accuracy, arm talent, agility, health. All of which Williams has over Penix. And he's a year younger.
how is 24 old why do we use this stupid narrative when talking about athletes.😂😂😂
1. Daniels
2. Williams
3. Maye
4. Nix
5. Penix
6. McCarthy
I'm glad you're not the GM of my team. It would find itself in the basement in no time.
Lol
Skinny QBs don't survive the NFL.
Williams will be a bust mark my words
If so.. the team that drafted him failed him
No the team that drafts him picked the wrong qb
Drake Maye to the Bears
Caleb Williams hate comes from the wrong place. He is not and diva. He just doesn’t fit the stereotypical athlete. And thats fine 💁🏻♂️
He’s definitely a diva 😂
mccarthy is a typical "game manager"
and i mean that in a negative way.
he will look decent/great in games where everything goes well and hes just asked to throw 20-25 passes.
but in the nfl that wont cut it more often then not.
and there is sooo little data on how consistent he will/can be when he has to throw 30+ times when the team is down.
this guy to me looks like the next mitch trubisky or trey lance.
qbs that reached their ceiling in their short time as a starter already but draft scouts talked themselves into believing that they have a high ceiling cuz "his best football is ahead of him".
27-1
@@EthanDephouse ?
Chicago licking their chops waiting to ruin one of these guys careers.
You should do a video like this for the Running Backs in this draft.