Samsung DEX Vs Motorola Ready For Android 12 Desktop Mode Comparison Showdown
Vložit
- čas přidán 24. 03. 2022
- The big showdown is here today we have the Samsung Dex Android desktop experience for Samsung smartphones versus the Motorola ready for a desktop experience both based on Android 12 desktop and both are very well developed and maintained ecosystems for using our smartphones like laptops. We will be testing gaming productivity multitasking as well as wired and wireless solutions for Motorola ready for versus Samsung text video challenge. This video is presented to you by TK Bay hope you enjoy it. Motorola edge+ 2022 Vs Samsung S22 Ultra desktop mode
Get Your Motorola Ready For Edge plus 2022 here:
Get it From @amazon amzn.to/3D88vkM
Get it From @Best Buy shop-links.co/cgTd6NMIO51
as well at @Motorola main site: shop-links.co/cgTd8PbveEi
Get your Samsung DEX supporting devices here:
Galaxy S22 bit.ly/3GFd4mS
Galaxy S22+bit.ly/3rAqr3p
Galaxy S22 Ultra bit.ly/3gED9Yo
Galaxy Tab S8 bit.ly/3BbmdSM
Galaxy Tab S8+ bit.ly/3HGxtcy
Galaxy Tab S8 Ultra bit.ly/3BgWCbh
Save 10% on your order from Samsung: shopsamsung.page.link/jgLD
Get the TK Cap here: etsy.me/39F5evJ
Use this code to get 1000 Free supercharging Miles: www.tesla.com/referral/tarek9...
I Buy and Sell On Swappa: swappa.com/?ref=tkbay
B&H Dealzone:
Http://bhpho.to/2ppW6Ty
Amazon Daily Deals:
amzn.to/2kLKo6i
BestBuy:
shop-links.co/cgv2yWRAvka
Samsung:
shop-links.co/cgv2zFIb2Oi
DBZ art is by Barrett Biggers
studiomuku.com/
amzn.to/2mYvkTk
Please Support the Channel by using my affiliate links : Amazon: amzn.to/29qkDl9
Gearbest: bit.ly/2APV5Kc
B&H Photo: bhpho.to/2ppW6Ty
"Music: www.bensound.com"
Thank you very much
Like and subscribe
Contact Info:
/ tkdsl8655
/ tkbay
/ tkdsl8655
/ tkdsl8655
Or on CZcams as well
#samsundex #motorolareadyfor #android12desktop #readyforvsdex #dex #readyfor #tkbay #tipsandtricks tk bay motorola ready for vs samsung dex - Věda a technologie
What not too many people know is that Motorola started this not Samsung. Motorola had the first Android desktop experience 10 years ago
Yes the Motorola atrix is a legend device for sure
@@TKBay Thank you for the Heart! Also, as an Arabic speaker I appreciate your Arabic content as well. Your videos deserve more attention for sure. Keep it up and Good luck!
That is correct. Heck, Motorola even started the lapdock ball rolling in the first place.
@@markwashington7731 what's his Arabic channel??
Sometimes it's not about who pioneers it, but who perfects it.
ReadyFor looks promising. I can already see some benefits over DeX. Hopefully this pushes Samsung to start showcasing DeX more and improving on the user experience than just resting on their laurels. Competition is always good.
Agreed. Dex seems to be neglected of late, which is disappointing, a waste of a promising idea
Is ReadyFor just working under another OS or it can do standalone?
Absolutely. I was looking for alternatives even though i live XeX as it is but it will depend on what i see from both of these. I'm glad i ran into this because I thought DeX was the only desktop experience on phones as of yet and was disappointed.
Motorola was the first. The Atrix was too far ahead of its time. The docks ended up on eBay and became Raspberry Pi docks in the end. . I think that business should be deploying these types of systems more often. This us all a lot of workers, especially those out of the office a lot, would need.
To have camera set as webcam function build-in in Ready For is really neat!
Thank you for this video!
I'm currently on a Pixel 6 Pro, which has a lot of both very good things going for it, as well as some pretty significantly bad things. And one of those bad things is that desktop mode functionality on it is disabled on purpose (presumably so that they can hopefully sell you a Chromebook too).
In any case, for this reason (among others), I was very seriously considering going for Samsung next round in order to have DeX. I already have USB-C docks around the house for the Steam Deck, which, as a Linux user in general already, I'm keeping on SteamOS and not installing Windows. And I have confirmed that these same docks that work with the Steam Deck also work with Samsung phones for DeX using a phone other than my personal device.
I hadn't even really considered Motorola until I stumbled upon a review today for the 2023 top tier Edge device, and it sounds like an amazing phone, and with a "much closer to Google Pixel" UI and software experience on the handset itself - which I generally much prefer over Sammy's OneUI, that makes it an attractive option (even if I prefer how easy it is to get "ubiquitous black" dark mode in OneUI, and hope the Moto will offer a similar "actual black" mode - since Google in their infinite wisdom actually removed the capability from their own phones.)
The only remaining question for me besides the blackout dark mode question, and I suppose "how do the cameras compare" was "does Moto have a DeX equivalent and is it any good?
You answered both questions for me, and while I agree that they are remarkably comparable, with differences that less make one "better or worse" than the other per se, but just make comparing the two so much more interesting, at least on the first blush of watching your video, I once again think that the Moto iteration of "Ready For" is much more to my liking personally, even if much more "clunkily named"....
....and so barring some really shocking or truly unfortunate discovery (such as, the camera is absolute garbage, or whatever), I think I may now have a new "front runner candidate " for my Nov or Dec 2023 phone upgrade that is neither Google NOR Samsung!
I guess we'll see what happens, but I am legitimately excited by the discovery, and its implications!!!
So, again, thank you!!! 🎉
Both systems are usable. I've been using DEX now for the past couple of months to test the capabilities. From what I can tell neither of these companies really know what to do with this desktop experience. Samsung seems to promote it more for business presentation. They have stopped development of the DEX on Windows/Mac. So it kind of leaves the end user wondering what their game plan is. From a larger company point of view I know they would prefer customers to buy both a cell phone and a laptop/desktop, but I really think they are missing a huge segment and that is marketing it as an all in one set up for people that can't afford both. Samsung has the technology to bundle one of their monitors with a dock, keyboard, mouse and offer that as a solution to people. Motorola tried this years ago, Microsoft tried this, heck even Blackberry tried it with the WebOS tablet, and thus far Samsung seems to be the only one that has stayed with it, but still their management and marketing divisions don't seem to know what to do with this. I personally like unplugging my work laptop from the USB-C when I log off at night and then plugging in my Samsung phone and I have a larger screen to do more intense type of work. IF LumaFusion is able to run under DEX on the newer Samsung phones then that would be a great advantage that Samsung would have in marketing their product to the content creator market. Just my 2 1/2 cents of thoughts. LOL.
LumaFusion is there with limited capabilities comparing to iOS :/
Great review! thanks for your great effort!
Sweet. More videos like this, Android with desktop options in the future and thank you. Does the pixel 7 and pro have desktop mode?
I do appreciate your perspective on this but holy moly you can slow down when talking. It was kinda harder to get an understanding of "Ready For" when you just kept showing Dex. It would have been way better experience if you had a side by side showing each as you were talking about them. The start of the video was good but I think it was totally unscripted especially at the end when you were trying to show differences between the two on casting to a PC/laptop. Glad you are feeling the same way as I do when it comes to this feature. I have been trying to show my family and friends they should invest more in a phone that has this and avoid just getting a chrome book that will loose it's upgrade ability after a certain period of time.
We need more of this!
This is the best video I've seen about it. Thank you very much for the amazing work!
Great video. I am a big fan of Samsung Dex and I think is more error free than Ready for. For instance, if you are wirelessly projecting via Miracast, Netflix plays fine on a Samsung Dex while gives a black screen on a Moto Ready for. Please try as well and let me know if I am wrong. Thank you!
what Bluetooth game controller do you recommend to use with the ready for experience? Great video, thanks for posting.
Wow great comparisons.👍😍
Glad to see some real reviews of Ready For, and Dex. Thank you.
Wow, just in time after watching Juan Bagnell's unboxing stream of the Edge+ 2022. This is interesting.
Totally a coincidence I announced this video last night on our stream he happens to get the box right as I was editing the video. Stars have aligned
Ready For PC solution looks intriguing as you can use it wirelessly. If I have a latest powerful Windows laptop, I'll think very seriously about picking up the Motorola.
I love to have a desktop solution in my car, holding my touch monitor like a car entertainment system. TV mode in "ready for" take my attention. It's possible to use 2 apps in split screen with this mode? It's easy to return to menu with touch controls? Also, portrait mode it's a advantage comparing with dex. Some monitors include a orientation sensor. It will be magical that "ready for" take care of the monitor orientation sensor automatically.
The only lack it's that the two doesn't include a savescreen and unlimited screen power on so it could be use as digital frame.
Thank you for this video !
FYI:
- Wireless DeX communicates via Miracast Protocol. Wifi signal does not make that much of impact to performance of wireless DeX
- DeX for PC has wireless connectivity but is not reliable as wired connection.
Thank you the update. Glad you enjoyed the video
I prefer wired connection but it ends up 'over-charging' the phone. I wish there was a cable that will give Dex connection but not charge the phone.
@@sicebim1 What do you count as "over-charging"? If you open Settings -> Battery and Device Care -> Battery -> More battery settings, you'll see a "Protect battery" option that limits the maximum charge to 85%. It will then basically stay in the 84%-85% range as long as you have it plugged in.
Is this harmful to the battery? I don't know. I'm not a battery expert. But I think it's not.
What's *definitely* harmful to the battery is high temperatures, and in my personal experience I never found my S22+ even a little bit warm while using DeX. I only had light usage though, didn't run games or anything demanding like that.
@@NeatNit, thank you so much for this info. I did not know there was such a feature to protect the battery.
I prefer Dex using the cable as it is more stable. 👍🏽👍🏽
Great work as always TK.
Thank you, glad you checked it out 👍
Thanks for the video. I'm ready to buy the edge plus. ONE HUGE QUESTION??? Can I use ready for to cast Netflix into my TV while I'm searching Amazon on my phone like you can with Dex. Basically 2 different monitors running off 1 phone. Another question. Can I turn the screen off the Motorola watching Netflix while using ready for?
Great video buddy.
I got ready for myself, love it.
Is there a way or device (that is not the laptop you showed) that I can charge the phone while using ready for?
(I already have invested in screen and BT mouse keyboard)
I will apriciate an response
I have an Arzopa Mini 2K display and an Anker 45W USB-C plug. The display has 2 USB-C ports (and a mini HDMI that I don't use). I plug a cable from the charger into one USB-C port and connect my phone to the other. The Anker plug has more than enough power to support the display. The excess power passes through the display and charges my phone! [I also use a bluetooth keyboard and mouse]. I use this set up for travel. At my desk, I have a Lention USB C 9-port docking station that connects to a couple displays, USB sticks, ethernet, microSD card, Logitech Dongle, etc.
Which nextdock model did you purchase and where ? Cause I have read online that some haven't been working well with Motorola Edge 2022 Ready For
I bought the MotoG100 about 2 yrs ago and absolutely love ready for, it's an amazing feature I use a lot.
I'm surprised more phones don't have this as a standard feature.
Probably just a matter of time.
Very nice video!!! Ready for seems awesome.
I would like to see if Motorola phone works properly in ready for mode,
If you plug it to a usb C hub, with hdmi out for a ultra wide 34" monitor?, ethernet cable (does it connects to the internet vie ethernet??) and usb ports that have keyboard and mouse and usb flash memory. Does the hdmi out provides good sound??
Thanks again for your work!
Android 11 update has Ethernet options native. So if the adapter has a Ethernet port. Yes you can use Ethernet wired connection.
The Edge 2021 doesn't have wired hdmi out. Since it uses only usb 2.0 vs usb 3.1+ So you're stuck using wireless ready for.
I'm still in the process of looking at the nicpics of the Ready For desktop mode on my G100. But they are gonna make more improvements (as they have for Edge+ 2022 since it's native android 12.) to android 12 from android 11.
ready for supports 4k resolution while dex i think with latest updates supports 1440p
also be careful with ready for cause not all devices support video out over usb-c
I bought samsung s22 ultra because of Dex its awesome i have dex desktop application installed in my office pc i have double screen i use dex on one of those screen. the benefit is very good for me for 1 i dont need to sign my accounts in my office pc 2 i have everything ready just use it on bigger screen i can even watch movies on dex its soo smooth. Not to mention file transfer its awesome
Do they support active pen on a external touch display? The desktop mode from huawei doesn't.
Great video, i did not know of Ready 4. I will look to get a Motorola phone to test it as i use Dex alot.
Only few select Moto phones have it. The cheapest is their old edge 2021 (Wireless ONLY no wired.) and G100 (wired till android 12 update will unlock wireless mode.) and Edge+ 2019 (The one with the curved display.)
Though some with the Edge20's might also have it to. But i believe these are all international versions.
Cheapest is G100 and Edge 2021 at around 440$ right now.
@@KillerRaptorr thank you
@@KillerRaptorr I've been searching for an smart phone with desktop possibilities but I need with fingerprint scanner; do you know if any of those you mentioned have fingerprint...?
@@dcgo44r All have finger print unlocking. Normally on the power button side or the rear on the AA logo.
@@KillerRaptorr both Moto? You are a live saver! 👍
Can I use my A8 tablet as a wireless display for my phone s20u's DeX?
Wow..go Moto...now just get all the phone working well; would love to see Motorola stay a competitive player at a mid price (they are to some extent now) and even at a higher price with this sort of phone. Had Motorola phones back in the day. Currently Pixel (but have 2 phones, keeping my S10 per how it still performs as well). Thanks for this revealing info!
Very happy you enjoyed it
@@TKBay Just curious as I have a Pixel 6 and have a card my S10 as well, so DEX. This may sound dumb, but do I get a C to USB to my laptop HP, or, with an extra HDMI port would it be C to that? Or? I have of course enable in Dev Op USB, so I have run my phones from C to USB before...Is that okay for features per DEX? Anyway...I am trying to continue learning for best quality and DEX is something per travel that I am interested in taking full use of.
What you need is a USB c to HDMI MHL adapter that will allow your phone to project decks to the monitor or a TV via wire
@@TKBay I was thinking that, as I have the HDMI input on my laptop. Thanks!
Laptop HDMI is OUTPUT only. Not input.
Dex to PC requires Thunderbolt 3 or USB-C 3.2 which is 20mbps speed or more. Normal USB-C 3.1 gen 1 or USB 3.0 are only rated to 5mbps. Which will limit the screen to 30fps performance. Vs 60fps. (Won't notice it on videos like youtube. But in games you will see a difference.)
So best to use a USB-C to HDMI to a HDTV or Monitor on it's own.
Can I use the wifi on my ready phone to the monitor
Is there any way to set the enter key on the keyboard as the send button on WhatsApp and Messages?
I like how that ReadyFor™️ organizes the different modes based on what what you would like to do. Sometimes you just want to watch your content on a bigger screen and sometimes you actually need to get some work done on a laptop. Very neat I would to try it out.
i really dont see why you would need the UI to remove all apps that arent media based. How hard is it to just click the youtube or netflix app on your desktop in dex? This is a useless feature.
@@codmott286 remember that most of smart phone users aren't that techy... Moto is attracting the Joes and Janes to supposedly a new experience, thus to their phones! But yeah you are right!
@@codmott286 organizing the apps for you is a little bit of a bummer, but ready for(which is such a dumb name) gives you the option to navigate the UI easily with a controller. So if you're wanting to use a phone as a plug n play console or media consumption device, it's already notably more appealing than DEX. I don't need to get up off my couch and use the touch screen or have a trackpad/keyboard. I can just do it all with a controller in comfort
@@davidlane1248 I can do the sane with a ps4 controller since they have track pads lmao.
ReadyFor looks good. I like the option on it it gives you not just desktop when connected. It would have been amazing if it ran Android TV version of Netflix/CZcams when you select the video option when connected!
Meant TV option not video
Unless they improved it on Android 12 for the Edge+ 2022. The A11 version for Edge 2021/Edge+ curve 2019/G100 basically are useless on the other 3 options.
TV,Gaming,Video basically open the apps in mobile desktop mode at fullscreen. The 3 others aren't special. So you can put them in windowed and you're basically in mobile desktop mode. And if you launch a app in mobile desktop that does fullscreen. It basically is same deal as launching them in the other 3 modes. So nothing unique.
@@KillerRaptorr I think that Tv mode could be useful for car. It let's you put two apps side by side? You could return to menu easily? Also ,the portrait desktop mode seems amazing ,and this is not included in dex. The best doubt is if some monitors that include a orientation sensor could work automatic with ready for or not.
@@dexgamer0_055 Portrait desktop mode? (Aka changing to landscape/portrait mode while active) I don't think it has Portrait desktop. You're thinking of sizing aspect ratio correction. Which i think Ready-For does, Where if your aspect ratio is different then 16-9 or so. It'll probably fit to it. But i think Dex doesn't do this because they lock into a specific ratio system, instead of being flexible.
As for TV/Video/Game modes. No they are basically just a simplified version of Desktop mode by starting the app up in fullscreen. But you can still shrink it into windowed mode because it just boots it up into mobile desktop in fullscreen mode. So right now the 3 other modes aren't to unique. There aren't any special features to them yet to make them really stand out over just using the Mobile desktop and starting the app that way.
I mean you could do 2 different apps at same time. But you have to break off from fullscreen mode and then windowed mode them side-by-side like a PC. But you will have window bars on the edges, It's not like Phone splitscreen apping.
Is Lenovo legion Y90 able to use desktop mode?
In Samsung Dex I can have 16 camera feeds in Zoom. Does it works like that in ready for? Also, I can have zoom, a pdf document, a doc document and a library app at the same time. Can it be done also in Ready For?
do more vids about this topic
Has anybody noticed any major drops in performance on the Motorola when connecting it to an external display? When playing dolphin on the regular phone, it plays flawlessly. When connecting to an external display, it seems to play at 50% speed.
Use Readyfor to stream a game on by big screen tv while still being use the phone to navigate other things while not interrupting streaming
That's very awesome
It seems like you suggest Dex for PC cannot operate wirelessly and must be used wired but the Samsung website page describes in detail using Dex wirelessly with a pc. I will test it.
I had a horrible experience with Ready For on the Motorola Edge (not the + version), the one with the Mediatek processor. It only connected to my Roku Streambar once then never again, always timing out. You could see it on the TV attempting to connect but it never did. I downloaded the Ready For application for Windows and could connect in Desktop mode via wireless but anything I could do was almost pointless since I was already on my PC. Looking at photos, can already do that online, searching I can do on my PC, it never played any video streaming apps on the PC, etc. I then tried a wired connection to the PC, thinking maybe I could game full screen. It did sense the USB connection and I did change the mode from No Data Transfer to Ready For mode...but the launching Desktop mode just made it connect wirelessly again. WTH? I finally tried the last option, connecting wired with USB C to HDMI. I tried both a monitor and a HiSense TV. I tried two different dongles, one a Tisofu multi-adaptor with HDMI and a straight USB C to HDMI dongle from Anker. Per the advertising and youtube videos on the Edge+ version, just plugging in to an HDMI source automatically launches Ready For...this was not the case on the regular Edge.
There are no hard requirements listed by Motorola and I've yet to see a CZcams video list the brand/model of USB C to HDMI connector they used. If Motorola's official Ready For dock is the only thing that works, they need to say that explicitly. When in the Ready For app within the phone, it is ambiguous what requirements may or may not work.
Also, when I connected to my PC, there were options I could NEVER get to highlight. App Streaming, Webcam and File Transfer were always greyed out.
Yeah Motorola has a "Moto Connect | Ready For Compatibility Chart" that I just found after realizing the edge 40 only has usb 2.0 without HDMI support...
Hello can you please make a video in English and focus on the TV function of the ready for app. Nobody has been doing it. The idea is to see the performance of the remote mode on the phone and see if it could simulate Android TV box experience. Can you add apps like Netflix, CZcams and other VOD application you can have, maybe even a tv app if you have.This way we can see how the apps display in full screen and see how the remote is responsive with the interface.
My plan for my next phone upgrade is to also upgrade my phone plan to a truly unthrottled 5G plan, and then also get a Nexdock. This will allow me to work from pretty much anywhere without having to rely on public hotspots. And, even better, I can leave my more powerful Windows PC at home and remote into it through Parsec/Moonlight. It will be the perfect all in one machine. I just wish that Nexdock would release a 14-16” 1600p model
Well most companies like ATT and Verizon only truly throttle you due to mainly tower hailing of people using it a lot. T-Mobile is more prickish on this and will throttling you after a point of using amount of GB. Then even MORE if the tower if filled up.
So don't really need to fork over for unthrottled on ATT/Verizon, Unless you live in a very active area with lots of users on a known tower. (Normally you can also force switch your phone to swipe from 5G down to 4G lte to switch towers likely and get less crowded.)
I'm Ready For it....
Being able to use my phones information & Storage with my Chromebook....
Dex already has wireless for PC, even with the Galaxy S20 fe.
Does the s22 get hotter while using dex mode?
Is it mac compatible?
TK Bay or anyone, do you know what is less laggy for a full screen desktop or gaming experience, a Ready For wired connection to the Nexdock 360 Lapdock, or a wired connection to a modern full function Intel laptop? My guess is that the Nexdock is slightly less laggy because it is simply an external display connection, while the full laptop connection is more involved with the remote terminal software, etc.
Sir next dock for mobile
Nice video
Thank you very much
Hii bro can airpods pro used to play games with no latency in Android
True wireless earphones will have delay worse then normal bluetooth. So you'll need to buy Non-true wireless buds for gaming to have no delay. So Airpods won't be great to use.
Has anyone figured out how to get spell check to work with a physical keyboard and DeX? I know there is a workaround with third party onscreen keyboards and using in conjunction with the physical keyboard, but that is not ideal, and does not work in DeX. This is a HUGE issue, that I'm surprised more people don't talk about.
I'm new to the android desktop experience and I think I'm liking it better than windows. I'm with you on this.. I love text prediction or predictive text, it saves me lots of time writing but I can't use with my physical keyboard! 😥😥
@@dcgo44r it's just bizarre that more people don't complain. It they fixed this, I would absolutely use my S7+ over a laptop. I think most people have no idea- I asked someone at work, they thought it worked, of course it didn't, and said they wonder how many docs shipped out with tons of spelling errors....
Does not connect to mi box 4k or Airtel (Android TV) STB.
After some searching i found that can mirror my phone but can't use Ready GO app on Android 9 plus TV.
Since 80% Android box or Smart TV above 6 version don't support MeraCast.
And Ready GO app need only meracast.
Lol.
اتمنى ينزل الفيديو بالقناة العربية 👍
The big question is how is linux/windows softwares support is on both platforms ? It the most important thing that is keeping most people out of dex. If I still use a PC today it's because I need softwares that are on windows.
Dex used to have a option for linux but it's been disabled. I'm sure Ready-For is same. So you can't twist it into a windows OS or etc.
@@KillerRaptorr that's a ready made solution. You can still run linux using Termux. Just check out Andronix.
Do either of these two give you a full desktop Chromium browser experience with extensions? If not, then they're miles away from being useful deskop offerings.
You can use Kiwi Browser on either phone. That is the only mobile browser that can allow you to use extensions.
@@farishanafiah8461 also firefox nightly
@@farishanafiah8461 thanks Faris. I'll check it out.
They can run everything, if you take the time to emulate Linux. Check out Andronix.
@@DeepteshLovesTECH thank you, I'll check it out too
Samsung's smart monitors are nice to use with these, wireless is just the way to go for a smartphone desktop ecosystem. Hopefully more monitors include wireless input options, preferably without the smart aspect to it, or at least allow me to disable them. Would really like to see more direct wireless display and dock connection features on things, no reason in the year 2022 we still need a cable for dead ass 1080p60hz outputs at least.
Wireless is still not the right solution as it possess latency under heavy use, even at 1080p60Hz. That is why I always use cable as it gives way more stability.
@@farishanafiah8461With Microsoft's 4k wireless display adapter i don't expect over 200ms of latency, which is fine by me for my use. Miracast is using wifi direct and an encoded video stream, but wireless tech that can handle much higher bw for a raw display connection doesn't seem far out of reach. It would probably be directional with LoS requirements but It should be achieveable with wireless tech we've used elsewhere.
Should any company want to seriously explore wireless displays, it should improve dramatically in a short order of time, which is why I applaud Samsung's monitor efforts, IMO it should be a solved problem in no time should they shove some R&D at it.
@@DSDSDS1235 I will have to also agree. Using Microsoft miracast hdmi adaptor compared to straight up casting to Samasung Smart Monitor (Or any Smart HDTV's) is WAY better. I don't got their 4k version. I got their gen 3 model and it is so much faster in response time then on a Smart TV/Monitor. Though the Resolution does take a bit of a impact. So normally you gotta have the adaptor kinda sticking infront of the TV vs hanging it behind. This gives it much more better signal to the device then hiding it behind the screen.
But for swifter response. You can surely do some decent gaming on the Miracast adaptor from Microsoft rather then straight up casting to a screen.
The straight up screen casting i would more so say is better for when you are watching movies rather then anything else. Since you aren't looking to much at latancy response and need that instant response. Plus If Bluetooth delay. It'll sync more better then on a faster response system like the adaptor.
Its Android 14 now , and we are now heading towards Android 15 .. still google hasn't even bothered to put a little bit something of desktop mode in its phones atleast 😢 that is saddening
What is the maximum supported resolution with refresh rate in Motorola Ready For PC experience? does it support 4k60fps? Or is it limited to some lower resolution/frame rate?
1080p. Resolution is limited to 1080p even if your monitor is 4k.
4k 60hz. On Ready For 3.0 which is what the Edge+ 2022 has. Other models like the G100/200 and Edge 2021 will get android 12 update with Ready For 3.0. Which should allow users to up it to 4k as the Edge+ 2022 allows. (Plus G100/200 will get wireless Ready For.)
Samsung is locked to 5apps up on the display and only 1440p 60hz. (1440p if you likely got their dock i believe and then you can also have more apps open.)
On ready for, can you watch hbomax? Also can you open simcity or uno? On samsung dex, i cant do that. I was wondering if anyone knew?
HBOmax runs on dex fine. It's Hulu for samsung dex that doesn't. But Motorola it runs fine in Ready-For mode. The other things i haven't heard of so i don't know. Uno is a game so i think it'd be fine.
@@KillerRaptorr hbomax doesnt run on dex fine for me?
@@421rc It's alittle fruity. But you can get it to run fine. But you'll have to fullscreen it. Windows mode doesn't scale correctly.
Basically Launch HBOMax. Then fullscreen it. Force close it by Alt/F4 on keyboard or go to the ::: icon and force close it on recent activaties. Then relaunch it and it'll relaunch as fullscreen and it will run fine without any problems. Just don't windowed mode it while after it is in fullscreen.
HBOMax doesn't seem to like Windows mode while in Dex mode.
How is samsung dex complicated if it gives you a PC expereince with a layout exactly similar to the phone itself? That was a kinda halfbaked take on that tbh
if just look for "Ready For" functions, Motorola phone definitely are worth to buy, however other features like camera, UI experience are not as good as Samsung, and also Motorola are only offer 2 major update compare with Samsung offer 4 major update, Motorola still have a long way to improve
Hello sir family and friends
I like to ask you a question
I had cricket in North Carolina Is a good phone Motorola
I moved the Dugspur VA I have to go back to
US Cellular I had this phone about 3 years
Samsung I'd like to switch to Motorola
I made in China
Will the unlocked variant support all the 5G bands on TMO ?
These normally all come unlocked. Then you just sim inject.
But Motorola has some weird ordealo that they like T-mobile more then ATT or Verizon. Since on their website. T-mobile gets most of the best features for the phones. While ATT doesn't get wifi calling,etc and Verizon for this doesn't get SA band. Only NSA and MM.
I Luv the Dex on my Samsung Galaxy s22 Plus 💪
LG also has a desktop version, sadly the brand is not producing phones anymore
Yeah, it is a real shame. LG flagships are the best phone I ever experience to date. The built-in Quad DAC audio is something I will truly miss a lot since not even Sony put it on their phone.
IT WOULD BE GREAT IF.... As Motorola/Lenovo (and Samsung) are in the Windows PC environment anyway, that when you connect a 'Ready For' (or DEX) capable phone into a USB hub and to your TV etc, you could simply plug a PC/NTFS formatted external HDD/USB Key and the phone would instantly talk to the drive without having to faff around with Total Commander/NTFS utils etc...
I would love to get rid of my ancient Dell desktop pc and connect my 1Tb & 2Tb external HDDs to an Edge 20+ via a powered USB hub, and access my data, music, films etc on those drives without having to buy a 4Tb drive, format it to Fat32 (with many partitions etc) and then copy my entire 2.5Tb of data over JUST so that the Edge 20+ would be able to access/work with it...
It's the ONE bugbear I've had with Android for years! You can access/watch/listen to multiple formats of video/films/ multiple formats in music, multiple formats in documents and files, and yet, Android doesn't have baked in the ability to talk to NTFS. ESPECIALLY NOW when Google is working more with Microsoft!!! 🤦😒
Uh not sure why you had problems with HDD drives not working. But i had mine work fine. I have a Amazon basic usb 2.0 7port with external power also can be put into the port hub for extra power. When doing that the HDD drive (not self powered) Powers on and the phone senses it as a external drive like as if i used a SD or usb thumb drive.
If the HDD or SSD is self powered (has power going into it. Then a USB to plug into the usb hub,etc. It'll work. but if it's powered off the USB data. You'll need to power it off a powered USB hub on the usb hub's external power port. Then data port into your phone.)
@@KillerRaptorr it's NOT the powering of external HDDs is the point I'm making. It's about NTFS not natively working with Android. Maybe your device recognises your external drive because it's formatted in FAT/FAT32? This is why people like me need Total Commander/NTFS Utils.. its frustrating that as Google are working MORE with Microsoft, native NTFS compatibility is not had... 😒😒😒
@@thedarkknight1971 Hmm I don't know exact format. But it was a Seagate drive that was in a laptop used for internal drive. Then ripped out. So maybe it got reformated on the phone to so. But last i remember i think it was formated in NTFS.
@@KillerRaptorr If it was, and your phone/tablet accepted it, ie read/write to it, either you did have Total Commander app with NTFS Utils, or, maybe your Android device formatted it to Androids native (Fat/FAT32 possibly even EXFat... 🤔🤔
@@thedarkknight1971 I never heard of TC app. So might likely be the ladder. But i haven't checked for awhile.
I can't watch Netflix/Amazon on these???
Yes on dex I know you can.
Dex interface is superior
Looking at how the G100 is with A11. A12 might be impressive. There's some things that are alittle off right now with Ready-For on A11 (hand to wait till G100 gets A12 to confirm what Ready-For 3.0 is and how less buggy things are.)
But Ready-For is pretty close to being better then Dex.
Dex still has a large bug that prevents Chrome and Edge Browsers from noticing where the mouse icon is. So it only responses when you click at places. Then leaves it at that location till you click again. Motorola doesn't have this problame.
Also some games that have a invisiable top bar like Eve Echoes. On Dex you might end up clicking the close button, Because Dex doesn't remove it when in windowed mode. Motorola does and you won't end up clicking the top right area to close something ingame, And suddenly shutting the game down itself.
3440x1440 support for Motorola? 4K?
Dex only does 1920x1080 in windows pc connected mode, sadly; however, if plugged into a monitor, it does ultrawide resolutions up to 1440p.
Dex does 1440p with a dex station/pad.
Not sure if Motorola does 4k. It does do 1080. and HD+ (1600/900).
@@KillerRaptorr there's one video on CZcams showing desktop mode with a 4K option, but it isn't selected.
I have a 4k monitor and some ultrawides and I'm going to test the Motorola phone... My Huawei and LG phone all max out at 1080p, well Samsung Dex only supports specific resolutions it's highest being 3440 by 1440... Kind of sad that it doesn't support 3840x1600 or 4K
Motorola supports 4k desktop mode! But unsure about via windows PC. Might cap out t 1080
I dont have desktop , but i have Dex
Motorola🤝Samsung
Samsung needs to fix Dex lack of 4k resolution support on 4k monitors/TVs. Looks like the highest resolution Samsung allows is still 1440p. This is pathetic.
Not to mention locking their phones to only allow 5apps up on the display. Unless you fork for their retired Dex station/pad which unlocks it.
"Ready for WIRED" IS LIMITED ONLY TO VERY FEW AND EXPENSIVE MOTOROLA PHONES!!!
I stopped in the middle of the video, just to ask myself the simple question .. Does it really worth to change from Samsung to Motorola ??? for me, a Samsung user since Note-2, changing to unstable phone manufacture like Motorola just because they are copying DEX is not the right decision. YES, I'm using DEX heavily on daily bases to replace my laptop for home and at work, there are still some rough edges but it simply works. unless Moto phone costs half of Samsung flagships with similar specs, i don't see Moto nor even Microsoft a product to switch to.
I would honestly recommend you staying with Samsung. Honestly if you are enjoy the way images come out of the Samsung camera and you have been using them for some time and are happy. Motorola is competitive and offers you more for what you pay. But at the core experience if you are happy with Samsung and one ui then I recommend staying with the new galaxy lineup.
@@TKBay Thanks for you reply, however, This video is not about comparing Samsung phones or the quality of phone camera, I see you are specifically generated this media to talk about samsung DEX and replacing the laptop with a smart phone .. that's what the video title says .. right?
That said, Samsung DEX still the best industry practice for serious users who want to print to company network printer, connect USBs and hard drives storages to the phone (FAT, exFAT and NTFS) as well as link to company windows file servers. nothing can get even close except a phone provider who will imped some sort of Linux version into the phone.
Agree Motorola Can't Touch Samsung.
dex on pc is useless because of latency and quality
Ready for max external monitor resolution is limited to 1080p. Samsung Dex can do 1440p. So don't buy Motorola
It depends on the monitor. Juan Bagnell aka SomeGadgetGuy can get 4K resolution on his Edge+ 2022 unboxing livestream.
Ready for on Edge 20 pro can output 4k with hdr, It can play 4k hdr youtube videos on the external display in 4k resolution.
Anyone know what the max res is when connection to windows PC ?
This is not the case? I have an edge 30 pro and It can only output 1080p to my 4k TV over usbc to hdmi cable that supports 4k@60
@@Revels0k it's your cables, then. Ready for easily supports 4k
Portland, JAMAICA in The Building !!!!!!!!!
Why do 90% of tech reviewers have a Goku wallpaper?
Dex is better.
In a sense for now yes. There's a few nicpics on both systems i have found myself on all 3 of the common phones with Desktop modes.
Dex has pretty decent performance. But Chrome/Edge browsers are messed up with mouse detection.
Gaming on dex is fantastic. Windowed or fullscreen. (The one game like Eve Echoes has a invisible task bar on the top. So when clicking something on the top right. It'll close the game down.)
Screen+ (LG's version.) is pretty decent on browsing ability. But movie watching and gaming you can't fullscreen. It'll always have a task bar on the bottom and a window top on the top most times.
Ready For motorola's seems to be decent up to Dex levels. But right now on Android 11 (not 12 as the Edge+ 2022 version is on.) tends to flicker the screen whenever a bluetooth device shuts down (LG has this problem to or whenever the screen on the phone snaps on or off. it stutters the desktop mode for a moment on LG.)
But one pro to Motorola. Is when you X out of a window. It removes it completely. Vs Dex/Screen+ that drops it into the background.
motorola solution sucks lol
Sorry, but who cares about M_otorola ?
You just show Samsung dex and not Motorola system