Sheikh Ibn Baz and Ibn Uthaymeen Say "I Don't Know" When Asked for a Fatwa!
Vložit
- čas přidán 18. 12. 2020
- Sheikh Ibn Baz and Ibn Uthaymeen Say "I Don't Know" When Asked for a Fatwa!
The reason I uploaded this video was to show that there is no shame in saying "I don't know" when asked a question, especially in relation to the deen. If you were to answer, you could be lying upon Allah and his messenger. Allah says in the Quran:
ولا تقف ما ليس لك به علم إن السمع والبصر والفؤاد كل أولئك كان عنه مسؤولا
And do not follow that which you have no knowledge of. Indeed, the hearing, sight, and heart will all be asked about.
Please just take a second of your time to subscribe to our channel (make sure to click the notification button) and like the video, to receive a share of the reward, as we hope to spread the message of Islam by translating video clips of the scholars from Arabic into English, as we know the Muslims desperately need those who can convey the knowledge of the scholars to them.
Make sure to share this video with Friends and Relatives so they can also benefit.
They Thought This Boy Was the Dajjal (Antichrist)! Sh. Sulayman Ar Ruhaylee:
• They Thought This Boy ...
How to Deal With Annoying People Beautiful Advice Sh. Abdurrazzaq Al Badr:
• How to Deal With Annoy...
Story of the Buddhist Jinn with Ibn Baz:
• Story of the Buddhist ...
Support us on patreon:
www.patreon.com/subulassalam
Or support us via Paypal:
www.paypal.me/subulassalam
Translating a single video can be very time-consuming, which is why we are only currently able to upload short videos. Your donation will, by the permission of Allah, have a profound impact on the amount we translate, and will enable us to free up more of our time to upload longer videos/ more frequently.
There is a typo in the translation at 1:45 “Is the bedouin that has been mentioned in the second hadeeth the same bedouin that was mentioned in the second hadeeth” it should be “first hadeeth”
The reason I uploaded this video was to show that there is no shame in saying "I don't know" when asked a question, especially in relation to the deen. If you were to answer, you could be lying upon Allah and his messenger. Allah says in the Quran:
ولا تقف ما ليس لك به علم إن السمع والبصر والفؤاد كل أولئك كان عنه مسؤولا
And do not follow that which you have no knowledge of. Indeed, the hearing, sight, and heart will all be asked about.
Please just take a second of your time to subscribe to our channel (make sure to click the notification button) and like the video, to receive a share of the reward, as we hope to spread the message of Islam by translating video clips of the scholars from Arabic into English, as we know the Muslims desperately need those who can convey the knowledge of the scholars to them.
Make sure to share this video with Friends and Relatives so they can also benefit.
They Thought This Boy Was the Dajjal (Antichrist)! Sh. Sulayman Ar Ruhaylee:
czcams.com/video/Eia4xTm5QNA/video.html
How to Deal With Annoying People *Beautiful Advice* Sh. Abdurrazzaq Al Badr:
czcams.com/video/iH7ODBZNxe0/video.html
Story of the Buddhist Jinn with Ibn Baz:
czcams.com/video/weC_KrMYotk/video.html
Barak Allahu Feek Akhi, May Allah Reward you. There is a mistake in the translation at 1:45 “Is the bedouin that has been mentioned in the second hadeeth the same bedouin that was mentioned in the second hadeeth” it should be “first hadeeth” at the end there if I understood correctly , Allah Knows Best.
@@WantedGarden Jazak Allahu khayran for pointing that out, it seems that was just a typo. I will mention that in the pinned comment. Baarak Allahu feek.
barakAllaahu fiikum 🙏
@@zakirnaikahmaddeedat3651 Wa feek baarak Allah.
May Allaah save us from speaking without knowledge
Aameen
Ameen
Ameen
Aameen
Ameen
this video proves that these scholars are real scholars. they have the fear of allah in their hearts with their responses. may allah preserve them
May Allah bestow his mercy upon them
رحمه الله
Absolutely tru
True but write "Allah" with capital A
@@nufailanoon lol
nothing wrong with saying allah
Subhan Allah, you learn more from the Ulema saying 'I don't know' than many who speak much without any meaning
Ikr I was thinking the same
For real💯
He's not an angel nor Allah.
But i know you know nothing about sh uthaymeen. So learn his story
Right
and there are those kids on social media who give fatwas out just like candy
I swear those guys are disgrace to our deen and to our scholar
Straight facts.
Iben Baz is the grandfather of one of my cousins, when he died I remember we prayed on him in Makkah, it feels like yesterday, time really flies by so fast. May Allah have mercy on both of them.
Wow ma sha Allah. Do you remember any incidents with the Sheikh, or what he was like?
Ameen
Tell us what your cousins know about the Sheikh
@@statixlaw5675 I can’t tell you much as we were very young at that time, but he was the grandfather of my cousins from their mother’s side, he lived mostly in Taif (city on mountains close to Makkah) and he has his mosque there were he use to give his lectures. My family lived in Makkah, so I remembered we got the news when he died, and he actually died in Taif but his will was to be buried in Makkah. This gave time to many of his student to come to Makkah and be part of his Janazah. Sorry I couldn’t give more details about him, as I said we were very young, may Allah have his mercy on him and on all of us.
@Idiris Allhamdulilah!! we are all fortunate to be Muslims, all praises to Allah, and we are all the same in front of Him my bother!
may Allah always guide us to do good deeds and have pure Intention.
If you were to ask them to the laymen, especially those of them that look righteous, most of them would answer most of these questions. Subhanallah! May Allah save us from speaking about his Deen without knowledge.
Ameen
Wow he made me realised how noble a scholar was ... The beauty of faith ...
Its sad that many people don't find these gems ...in this days
Oh how wonderful is the humbleness and humility of our scholars. Yet we the ignorant layman cannot say "I don't know" out of arrogance and wonder what will people think of me. They had so much knowledge yet was never ashamed to say they didn't know something and we have no knowledge yet we act like we are something. May Allah save us and pardon us. The best thing for a layman to do is to walk the footsteps of real scholars and follow them in all the good they bring to society. May Allah keep us on the straight path.
Well said Brother !
People are too afraid to say I don't know and so quick to jump into assumptions as an answer. When I say people that includes me. We really should learn from sheikh.
These are the great scholars who many of the modern daees claim they follow the footsteps of, yet if you look at the arrogance and the way they conduct themselves one can hardly believe their claims. The Deen has become so commercialised its all about Institute A vs Institute B (in the West mostly). May Allah rectify the affairs of the Ummah. Barakallah for this channel it really is a 💎 🙂
Baarak Allahu feekum. Yes, unfortunately many today have turned the deen into a way of making money and gaining fame, such that “I don’t know” is not an option for them. We ask Allah to rectify our affairs and guide as all to that which he loves and pleases, and to grant us sincerity in our actions.
Ameen. May Allah Cause Us All To Die On Islam And Iman.
Could have not said better, akhee. It has become a business. Yasir qadhi was at the forefront of this by discrediting the true scholars of Islam. Statements such as “ we don’t need outsource scholars “ the word outsource alone signifies the intent of what he started. Or these scholars don’t know the situation of the muslims of the west. May Allah preserve the true scholars of this deen who spread the dawah for Allah’s sake only.
@@mohammadsaeed1321 he didnt say that but hey. Allah swt knows best and did you know you have committed a sin? Backbiting? In this case slander? Look at yourself before talking about someone else. Ya Allah. People like you amaze me sometimes. Big mouth causes a lot of problems man.
@@VolatileHunter2 yassir Qadhi clearly said that muslims in the west should rely on their scholars snd not those from hijaz because they are not aware of their context.I even remember Sh Fawzan hafidhahuLlah was asked about it and replied he wasn’t aware of existance of ulamaa in the west
When you hear a scholar say "I don't know" in particular questions, you can assure they're confidence when they give fatwa in other questions. But when you never hear someone or da'i say "I don't know" and can answer all the questions you can't sure if they're actually answering in doubt or not.
Well-said
Or it means they know the answer ...
@@rehandelazamioHow could anyone know all the answers??
May Allah grant these great scholar's Jannatul Firdaus ❤
The fact they said I don't know is great of them it's a sign that their mostly not controlled by their ego but instead their humbleness
Wisdom shown here by scholars and they demonstrated Allah's greatness and all knowledge.
May Allaah azza wa jalla have mercy on them, thank you for the video translation
Al Imam Malik ibn Anas, Imaam darul hijrah was one of the most respected scholars of fiqh who ever lived. Once a man came to Imam Malik from a very far distance and he asked him 40 questions. Imam Malik only answered four of them and for the rest of the 36 questions he replied, “I don’t know.”
The man was surprised and asked Imam Malik “what should I tell people about these 36 questions for which you said (I don’t know)?” Imam Malik replied that the man should tell the people that Malik says: “I don’t know,” “I don’t know,” “I don’t know.”
Saying I don't know is half of knowledge.
May Allah taalaa grant us ikhlaas
Subahan Allah
Jazaak Allahu khairan, ameen
no worries , now we have youtubers who knows everything about Islaam and even has the authority to pull people out of ...
May Allaah protect all of us !
Refrain from asking useless question” is one of commends of our beloved prophet Muhammad SAW
The one about "making up a story" and "may allahs face be upon you" were not useless questions, but the other ones I would agree.
Such a wisdom! We must learn from them and say we don't know what we don't know and teach our children to have the courage to say 'I don't know' and that there's nothing wrong in saying that.
Subhanallah..... How many lessons learnt in a simple i dont know..... Many a time its not the ilm its the adab which is impressive.. may Allah guide this ummah and forgive every muslim male and female the ones who have passed and the ones that remain...
One of the best videos I’ve seen
There's a mistranslation at 1:51 Akhī. It should say “... same bedouin mentioned in the FIRST Ḥadīth”. Can you correct it? Jazākumullāhu Khairan.
Mashallah thanks for making this kind of knowledge available in English language...this will be huge huge reward inshallah . May Allah give you goodness nd strength to continue doing it.
Ameen. May Allah also grant you tawfeeq to do that which pleases him.
Ameen
Ameen
Very honest with ilm, may Allah bless both of our beloved muslim scholars.
... Saying I don't know is wisdom.
These were truly the people of knowledge and they were truly humble.They spoke so clearly and honestly with out any arrogant. They always mentioned Allah first and my Allah bless their soul .
May Son Used To Ask Me To Tell Stories And I Used To Tell Him About Prophet's Lifes And Sahaba's Lifes Jannah And All The Resources In Jannah And Allah's Love For Us
One Day He Asked Me That He Wants To See Allah I Told Him When We Go To Jannah We Will See Him, He said I Want to Go To Jannah I Said when we die we go to Jannah and He wanted us both be dead And go to Jannah quickly 😅
I Said to It's Upto Allah When we will go to Jannah, so we used to make dua before sleep so that Allah shows us Jannah In Dream
😅😅😅
Isn’t it so amazing how beautiful this video means with such a shockingly simple and usually unfulfilling answer of “I don’t know”. SubhanAllah, this has got to be one of my favourite pieces of content I have ever seen in regards to Q&A on Islam, I love it.
I know, something about it is so humbling. You can tell they have taqwa and are giving dawah for the sake of Allah and not views/leadership.
@@allergictohumansnotanimals5671 People that see Daee's as people who can't say "I don't know" as arrogant are arrogant themselves as they do not know what they are even speaking about half of the time. A real Daee can be distinguished easily from a fake one and a real Scholar can be easily distinguished from a fake one. Though not everyone can make this distinction because they themselves are not well versed in human sciences and the Deen. May Allah guide us all and may he bestow upon us patience, fear, and taqwa.
@@therussianemirati i never said the rest were arrogant
نسأل الله أن يغفر لهم وأن يجزيهم عنا خير الجزاء..
They passed the hardest test from Allāh ﷻ to them probably 💓, Whole World Listen to them and they are considered to be the top of the imam from salafis and they said,“IDK, Will find the answer and reply next time.”
Like bro what did I just witnessed 🥺
True scholars admit.
Fake scholars pretend.
Ibn Baz and Ibn Uthaymein are one of the best scholars in the modern time. If they don’t know an answer they admit. God bless them and grant them paradise.
This is the character of true scholars..now days we see anyone with litle knowledge but gives fatwaa and people blindly follows them
Thanks for translation...
Very good initiative, BarakAllah feek
he is truly a student of the teaching of Rosulullah Saw, by ALLAH Swt,. All I can say is "what a great man"💖.. may ALLAH Swt reward my hero Sheikh Ibn Baz not less than Jannah Firdaus...
Ameen
Ameen
جزاكم الله خيرا
For this video i just subscribe this channel.
Good work brother..
لا ادرى
What an amazing reply
Jazakunullah Khair
It's truly admirable how scholars like Sheikh Abdulaziz bin Baz and Sheikh Saleh bin Othaimin exemplify the essence of humility and wisdom in their responses to Islamic questions. Their willingness to acknowledge when they don't have the answers and defer to Allah's knowledge is proof of their sincerity and commitment to the search for truth in Islam, matching with the Quranic guidance:
‘And Allah Knows, while you know not.’ (Surah Al Baqarah; part of ayah 216)
This verse if taken in its general sense can be applied to anything that we don’t know. Additionally, it brings to mind the Sahih Hadith of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him):
'Whoever humbles himself for Allah, Allah will elevate him.' (Sahih Muslim)
Sheikh Abdulaziz bin Baz and Sheikh Saleh bin Othaimin's approach reflects this teaching of the Prophet (PBUH), as they show humility for the sake of Allah's truth. May their example encourage us all to approach our own search for knowledge with humility and respect.
May Allaah azza wa jall grant them all highest rank in paradise, Aameen
Ameen
This Sheikh is very wise Marshallah, may Allah reward him for his work
Ameen
Your contents are so beautiful I love them
May Allah (SWT) bless them... Aameen
Subhan'Allah reminds me of the time a man came to Imam Malik Rahimahullah with 40 questions and he answered 4 and didn't answer 36. Then the man said "What am I going tell my people," Imam Malik answered "tell them I don't know." May Allah Azzawajal allow us to be humble and not ignorant to knowledge.
Truly it is from knowledge to say idk
SubhaAllah☝️So große Gelehrte mit so viel Wissen sagen : Allah weiß es besser! Die haben meinen größten Respekt, möge Allah Sie in die höchste Stufe des Paradieses einführen🤲
good translate my brother
I am from saudi
*"I don't know"* is safe side!
(قُلۡ *إِنَّمَا حَرَّمَ رَبِّیَ* ٱلۡفَوَ ٰحِشَ مَا ظَهَرَ مِنۡهَا وَمَا بَطَنَ وَٱلۡإِثۡمَ وَٱلۡبَغۡیَ بِغَیۡرِ ٱلۡحَقِّ وَأَن تُشۡرِكُوا۟ بِٱللَّهِ مَا لَمۡ یُنَزِّلۡ بِهِۦ سُلۡطَـٰنࣰا *وَأَن تَقُولُوا۟ عَلَى ٱللَّهِ مَا لَا تَعۡلَمُونَ* )
[Sourate Al-A'raf 33]
7:33
Say, *"My Lord has rather forbidden* immoralities - what is apparent of them and what is concealed - and sin, and oppression without right, and that you associate with Allah that for which He has not sent down authority, and *that you say about Allah that which you do not know."*
May Allah swt grant them Alfirdaws Alaala min Aljannah and unite us with them.. Ameen
A sign of a true knowledgeable scholar that benefits from his ilm is he knows his limits.😎👌👍💗☝️
Subhanallah, may Allah have mercy on them...
Is it in the first conversation the questioner is shaykh abdur razzaq al badr? The voice sounds so alhamdulillah
may Allah accept our scholars
SubhanAllah nowdays people of their couch will have answers to each and every question asked ..
They may not even understand arabic.
May Allah propect muhammed p.b.u.h ummah from ignorance
رزقنا الله بعلماء صادقين مع ربهم
Allah yerhamkum sheikh
Can you please tell the source of the audio
اللهم صل وسلم على نبينا محمد وعلى آله وصحبه وسلم تسليما كثيرا
Great scholars of our time
Alhamdulillah. They follow the steps of the 4 Imams. Today everyone knows everything, causing division
As Salamu Alaykum akhi, is it ok if I use this clip for my Islamic IG account. I will tag you and refer my followers to your CZcams account.
Wa alaykum as salam wa rahmatullah,
Of course akhi, no problem in sha Allah.
This is the greatness of the Scholars. If you don’t know you can’t talk about religion ❤
Because Quran 5;96
Lawful to you is game from the sea and its food as provision for you and the travelers, but forbidden to you is game from the land as long as you are in the state of iúram. And fear Allah to whom you will be gathered.
Name the translator please?
Half of one's knowledge is saying I don't know.
I heared this phrase from someone, somewhere.
Imam malik Said it !
😎💓☝️
Most questions that they ask them are not beneficial nor Islamic knowledge.
The ulama have beneficial Islamic knowledge.
I disagree
I don't know is the half of knowledge...
Any1 knws who are the teachers of the 2 sheikhs?
Sheikh Ibn Baz was the teacher of Sheikh Ibn Uthaymeen.
@@issaahmed6415 teacher of sheikh bin baz leads up all the way to any imams?
@@muhammadabdulmateen8473 what do u mean
One of the most popular sheikh of ibn uthyamenn is Abdul Rahman Al sidi
Ibn baz had money including Muhammad ibn Ibrahim
Can see the faces of the people who are talking because I never saw a single Video in which we have left answered, Subhanallah
One after the other fake things when cannot prove their own religion. Allahu Akbar
May Allah guide us all
1:48. mistake in translation. second, then first
Please don't show/download pictures of the sheikhs rahimAllah in the internet they hadn't would that and/or do not use it as a thumbnail because they follow the opinion that pictures are Haram ( to make)
The one who asks Shaikh Uthaymeen, is Shaikh Salih al-Usaymi hafidhahullah.
I dont know!
❤
لا حول ولا حول ولا قوة إلا بالله العلي العظيم
Assalamualaikum warehmatullahi wabarakaatuh. To everyone who is actually talking about sheikhs saying they don't know. Well they are saying what they know and yes if they don't know and still answering anything which is not proven then this is the big sin which these shiekhs were away from it . Stop making it look like ooohh that Sheikh he said he don't know then how and all.
And the best thing they are doing is not claiming to know which they actually don't know and yeaaaa they said Allahu alam. Indeed Allah is the knower of everything.
الله اعلم اصل العلم وكل العلم وأفضل اجابه هدانا الله
Leave the speakers and come to the scholars. They should be our staple
We hear the so called scholars give fatwas left and right! Someone went to meet Imam Malik (R), apparently 2/3 of the questions he answered 'No' to the man.
What year
@@saadaden7769 thx
@@saadaden7769 im not an arab
@@saadaden7769 ok thx for reminder. jazakallah khair
The best answer if you don’t know .
And today youth comment Fatawa on social media like they(youth) are infallibles.
Better u say IDK thann give a false answer, or an answer which it seems like and answer but its not!respect
Ibn baaz ❤❤❤ also ibn uthaymeen but i love ibn baaz more.
Why?
@@sislam9633 Maybe he just likes Ibn Baaz teaching style more? Who knows.
@@alifbat1562 okay sufi calm down
@@alifbat1562 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 let me guess the sahaba we hanafis right????
@@alifbat1562 Can I know who are the person you are describing in your comment
So questioner rested in doubt about question
Guys why rabie almadhali ??
?
Unfortunately, all these questions HAVE BEEN ANSWERED a millenium ago !
The only true religion in the world …!!!
.
Fatwa? Only Allah & Prophet can give Fatwa
This been also from imam abu hanifah himself. So them dping the same is notthing new
our ulama are humans...they dont know automatically everything.
if they dont know for 100%....they fear allah before making any statement...even if they are 99% sure...this 1% they are not sure...they fear allah to make a fatwa.
the ayatoilets of qom , they ALWAYS make fatwa, they dont know how to read 1 vers of quran without making at least 10 mistakes....but still they are somehow able to ALWAYS give fatwa 😂😂😂
Problem is many times they didn't know yet did not abstain from answering falsely. especially in aqeedha when giving Allah 2 eyes and limbs.
Absolute blasphemy
Be silent oh ignoramus. Oh miskeen.
Notice that most of these question are non beneficial and pretty dumb and the esteemed ul lamas refused to answer them
I disagree
EVIL
Shaykh ibn baz retracted from his American fatwa as well later on accepting it was a mistake wrong fatwa too had saud did not learn anything from this