John Deere Lawn Tractor Deck Pulley Repair

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 25. 07. 2019
  • John Deere Lawn Tractor Deck Pulley Repair
    In this video I show you how to repair a common problem on some John Deere lawn tractor mowing decks. If the idler pulley has snapped off your mowing deck you may have to do the same repair as I show in this video!
    Don’t forget to click the 🔔 to turn on Video Notifications for more money saving videos and tips, featuring all the brands like Stihl, Husky, Husqvarna, Honda, Echo, Kohler, Tecumseh, Dolmar, Makita, Poulan, Ariens, Powermore, Briggs and Stratton, Murray, John Deere, Craftsman, MTD, AYP, etc.
    Help me make videos or buy me a coffee!!
    / donyboy73
    Watch my video on how to fix a lawn tractor that clicks and won't start here;
    • Lawn Tractor Clicks Bu...
    Watch my video on how to fix a lawn tractor that won't start here;
    • Lawn Tractor Won't Sta...
    Watch my video on how to make your lawn tractor look new again here;
    • Make Your Lawn Tractor...
    Connect with me on these social media spaces (plus that's where I announce contest winners)
    Facebook: / donyboy73-the-small-en...
    Twitter: / donyboy73
    Instagram: / donyboy73
    If you enjoy my small engine repair videos make sure to comment, share, thumbs up and subscribe. Thanks for watching!
    Easy to follow and thorough step by step tutorials do it yourself (DIY) to help you with your broken lawn and garden equipment including snowblowers.
    I do my best to teach you how to easily diagnose problems the fastest, quickest and most efficient way with real repairs beyond just replacing a spark plug. These tips are for both the homeowner and shop owner.
    Whether it be a handheld, two stroke, two cycle engine like a chainsaw, weed eater, weed wacker, string trimmer, grass trimmer, line trimmer, hedge trimmer, strimmer, brush cutter, leaf blower, or four stroke, four cycle units like a lawnmower, wood splitter, lawn tractor, snowblower, pressure washer, generator or a ride on mower that needs parts installed or replaced, I’m your go-to guy.
    My favorite brands of spark plugs are NGK and Champion and are the ones I recommend.
    I’ve been a small engine mechanic for many decades and also run my own repair shop so my videos are loaded with tips and tricks that I have learned and want to share with you. You will also find many tool and product reviews from top brands on my channel as well.
    I have the largest Small Engine Repair Video Library on CZcams and the entire internet with over 1200 videos, just GOOGLE "DONYBOY73"!
    I want "DON THE SMALL ENGINE DOCTOR" on CZcams to save you time, frustration and most importantly, MONEY with my HOW-TO videos!
    Due to factors beyond the control of DONYBOY73 “The Small Engine Doctor”, it cannot guarantee against unauthorized modifications of this information, or improper use of this information. DONYBOY73 “The Small Engine Doctor” assumes no liability for property damage or injury incurred as a result of any of the information contained in this video. DONYBOY73 “The Small Engine Doctor” recommends safe practices when working with power tools, hand tools, lifting tools, jack stands, electrical equipment, blunt instruments, chemicals, lubricants, or any other tools or equipment seen or implied in this video. Due to factors beyond the control of DONYBOY73 “The Small Engine Doctor”, no information contained in this video shall create any express or implied warranty or guarantee of any particular result. Any injury, damage or loss that may result from improper use of these tools, equipment, or the information contained in this video is the sole responsibility of the user and not DONYBOY73 “The Small Engine Doctor".
    #donyboy73 #smallengine #johndeere
  • Jak na to + styl

Komentáře • 124

  • @Patrick4959
    @Patrick4959 Před 4 lety +4

    awesome as repair there donny mate well done and it looks like that 24 inch deck could use a coat of John Deere yellow paint too and removing the rust on there too from the owners usage on there for sure

  • @donyboy73
    @donyboy73  Před 5 lety +32

    Have a good weekend everyone!

    • @YourAwesomePhoto
      @YourAwesomePhoto Před 5 lety +1

      You also. What's your weekend weather look like Up north where you're at ?

    • @donyboy73
      @donyboy73  Před 5 lety +1

      @@YourAwesomePhotopossibly rain

  • @rob33873
    @rob33873 Před 7 dny

    I know this is a old video, but it saved me some major bucks on that pesky non serviceable part ...thanks.

  • @rustyrepairs2565
    @rustyrepairs2565 Před 5 lety +6

    Thanks for the video! A little advise on drilling holes in metal. Start with a small drill. It's easier to drill a small hole and then easier to drill subsequent larger hole.

  • @johnasumaa8644
    @johnasumaa8644 Před 5 lety +5

    Great video. Over the years, I've learned a great deal from you, and you have saved me quite a bit of money, because I've been able to do my own repairs. Many thanks.

  • @jimstelljes3925
    @jimstelljes3925 Před 3 lety +1

    Excellent video. I followed your instructions and my John Deere tractor mower is now back in business. Thanks for sharing your knowledge and experience.

  • @jimclark9166
    @jimclark9166 Před 29 dny

    Thanks for the video. Had the same issue and the repair went silky smooth and worked like a charm. Cheers !!🎉👍👏

  • @butler386
    @butler386 Před 5 lety +2

    Looks like the simplest way to fix that problem. If it comes loose again you can always drill all the way through and go that way. Great idea for the fix.

  • @semco72057
    @semco72057 Před 5 lety +2

    I am glad that I saw this video and I have not had that problem yet, but will know what to do if it does happen to me. Thanks for sharing this tip with us, Dony, and I wish you, and your family a Blessed weekend.

  • @ristomattikolsi5711
    @ristomattikolsi5711 Před 5 lety +1

    It's more and more important to know how to fix stuff, instead always replacing it with a new one. Over consuming is the biggest enviromental problem there is.
    Once again, beautyful job donyboy73, you are an artist.

    • @donyboy73
      @donyboy73  Před 5 lety +1

      unfortunately most manufacturers today make stuff geared to not be worth fixing to keep the factories rolling

    • @ristomattikolsi5711
      @ristomattikolsi5711 Před 5 lety +1

      @@donyboy73 Or, you have to pay a big money if you want something stronger, But you're right, there's hardly anything on the market today that lasts longer than few years.

    • @paulh6587
      @paulh6587 Před 5 lety +1

      @@donyboy73 this is true. I've always bought Bosch tools etc but even they are crap these days. Hence the reason my new washing machine was the cheapest I could find. The last machine was Bosch and failed 3 months after the warranty was up. The bearings had gone, instead of being able to replace the bearings they are encased in a plastic case which covers the whole drum so only option was purchase a new drum from Bosch which was a fortune. So out of principle I binned it and bought the cheapest machine I could find as if it goes wrong and can't be fixed it's not a lot to loose so can just bin it and buy another if I can't fix it. I won't buy another Bosch product again.

    • @5roundsrapid263
      @5roundsrapid263 Před 4 lety +1

      I’ve had the same riding mower for a decade. Just replaced oil, plugs, battery, etc. It broke last week, and all it needed was a $7 spring!

    • @ristomattikolsi5711
      @ristomattikolsi5711 Před 4 lety +2

      @@5roundsrapid263 Well, there you go. All you have to do, is take good care of your equipments.

  • @YourAwesomePhoto
    @YourAwesomePhoto Před 5 lety +18

    Good job, typical John Deere deck, John Deere has the worst Paint ! You think they would've figured it out by now. Between all the paint peeling off and the plastic hoods breaking off. John Deere is really going downhill.

    • @droidrazor873
      @droidrazor873 Před 5 lety +2

      The older ones had paint that was a bear to get off

    • @davidandersen9186
      @davidandersen9186 Před 5 lety

      Nothing better than a Deere just cause you cant afford one doesnt make them bad......

  • @rodneybrand8521
    @rodneybrand8521 Před 5 lety +1

    Had the same problem on a JD 105 it was broken off too deep for tapping..so i drilled the rest out
    And ground it flush with the brackett..welded a square head bolt on it ..took about 30 minutes..good as new..
    I like the way you explain everything you do..Cheers 🍻🍻🍻🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸

  • @billymarshall4966
    @billymarshall4966 Před 4 lety +1

    Great video on the fix and was very helpful. I made one alteration and used a 3/8-16 x2" bolt instead of a 2/1/2. I was able to go in from the bottom of the bracket and place the lock nut on the top. Great amount of help again thanks donyboy73.

  • @catfishjenkem2226
    @catfishjenkem2226 Před 5 lety +5

    Great vid !! Been solving 1 problem after another on John Deere D100

  • @geneballay9590
    @geneballay9590 Před 5 lety +1

    Very timely, as I have been looking at my deck pulleys every time I have the deck off the mower, and wondering how long until I had this problem.

  • @sweetsmd
    @sweetsmd Před 2 lety

    I got exactly the same issue. I wonder how John deere mechanical designers could not think about having a bolt holding the pulley. It would make clients life so much easier. Thanks a lot for the intelligent solution

  • @mikejones6974
    @mikejones6974 Před 5 lety +3

    Well played Dony! Saved customer money! Great fix!

  • @lendavidhart9710
    @lendavidhart9710 Před 4 lety +2

    Nice video, thanks for posting/sharing

  • @rolandpoliseno705
    @rolandpoliseno705 Před 4 lety +1

    That is a great idea. Just had that problem this week, thank you.

  • @zx8401ztv
    @zx8401ztv Před 5 lety +5

    Smashing repair don :-D
    And if the person is worried about the bolt coming loose, a drop of thread locker on the threads will fix that. (no need to overtighten).
    It may also help with threads created with cheap taps, a slightly loose fit.

  • @chrisjones4685
    @chrisjones4685 Před 8 měsíci

    Thank you so much for this video. I I just broke that bolt off and was wondering how to fix it.

  • @OldCavLT
    @OldCavLT Před 4 lety +1

    This worked to perfection. Thanks!

  • @user-ix4kq3cm1z
    @user-ix4kq3cm1z Před rokem

    Thank you so much this video saved me a lot of time and money! I completed myself in a reasonable time, everything was simple to understand and do!
    Great job!
    Thank you

  • @davem147
    @davem147 Před 5 lety +2

    Very useful tip, skillfully presented as always!

  • @watermanone7567
    @watermanone7567 Před 5 lety +1

    Excellent fix Donny, Many thanks

  • @holdemNE1
    @holdemNE1 Před 5 lety +5

    Great video....thanks for teaching me.
    Shame on John Deere for not designing it smarter.

  • @tonym6920
    @tonym6920 Před 5 lety +1

    Nice fix Dony! Have a great weekend!

  • @danielesilvaggi
    @danielesilvaggi Před 5 lety +1

    Great fix thanks Don.

  • @walterdillow8650
    @walterdillow8650 Před 5 lety +2

    That's a smart fix, good job.

  • @mercury629
    @mercury629 Před 5 lety +1

    Thanks again for a very informative video!

  • @christopherguy1217
    @christopherguy1217 Před 5 lety +1

    A great cost savings video, thanks.

  • @steved5153
    @steved5153 Před 5 lety +1

    Thanks. Great job, as always.

  • @peipaulT
    @peipaulT Před 5 lety +1

    Great video. Very helpful.

  • @jamesmullins3219
    @jamesmullins3219 Před 5 lety +1

    good video. good time to grease the spimdles (if so equipped)

  • @joncorklin
    @joncorklin Před 4 lety +3

    Good video. I do have one suggestion when it comes to drilling and tapping. If you use a smaller drill first, then use the proper tap drill, there will be less chance for the right drill to round out the hole during the drilling process, which can make the bolt slightly loose in some cases because a wandering drill will make the hole bigger than the actual size resulting in not so tight threads. Just my suggestion but whatever works for you.

  • @rodneyerdmann1545
    @rodneyerdmann1545 Před 5 lety +8

    Nice simple fix! I'm sure a John Deere dealer would cut off the whole bracket and charge an arm and leg!!!

  • @aleblanc3547
    @aleblanc3547 Před 5 lety +1

    Pretty slick, Don! Thanks man.

  • @rpavlik1
    @rpavlik1 Před 5 lety +3

    Well that's a lot quicker and cheaper than replacing the deck 😃 though that deck looked in pretty rough shape. (Which probably made the quick, easy, cheap repair even more of the right choice)

  • @enterprise0987
    @enterprise0987 Před 5 lety +1

    Nice work around!!

  • @jameslarsen3184
    @jameslarsen3184 Před 4 lety +1

    Great idea on thus fix!

  • @pookatim
    @pookatim Před 5 lety +6

    Just wondering, could one drill all the way through and then use a nut and bolt? Seems like it would be easier than using a tap. Also, would a lock nut be better than a lock washer? Lock washers are not optimal in high vibration applications. Keep up the good work!

  • @tomstepanowicz6191
    @tomstepanowicz6191 Před 5 lety +2

    That was excellent. Thanks.

  • @stevefleck5892
    @stevefleck5892 Před 5 lety

    Sweet fix, thanks for doing the video.

  • @billmaxfield7831
    @billmaxfield7831 Před 5 lety +1

    Great job! Nice one Don..

  • @motoman5023
    @motoman5023 Před 5 lety

    nice repair I had one the other day the whole assembly was spinning bolt and all had to cut it off flush and put a Bolt & Nut on either side

  • @rrobertomondo5173
    @rrobertomondo5173 Před 5 lety +1

    Nice fix!

  • @mcarroll598
    @mcarroll598 Před 5 lety +1

    Smart idea, nice video!

  • @jeremiahmnjohnson
    @jeremiahmnjohnson Před 2 lety

    Great idea. This is a great solution.

  • @fire7765
    @fire7765 Před 5 lety +1

    Great video.

  • @dcharnas2592
    @dcharnas2592 Před 5 lety +1

    That was Brilliant!

  • @gordbaker896
    @gordbaker896 Před 3 lety

    Good fix Dony. Check depth carefully if you don't have a 'Bottoming tap'

  • @johnjude2685
    @johnjude2685 Před 4 lety

    Good fix , I would have drill all way there as to prevent tap bottom out
    Yes good idea and a money saver
    Thanks

  • @Patrick4959
    @Patrick4959 Před 4 lety +1

    smooth stuff there Donny mate hope you gave it a good paint job after this video that mower deck looked in a bad rusty shape

  • @coalitionofrob436
    @coalitionofrob436 Před 5 lety

    Great fix

  • @webchez69
    @webchez69 Před 4 lety +2

    Definitely a case needing BLUE LOCKTITE!!

  • @CopperCettle
    @CopperCettle Před 4 lety +4

    Great fix for the poor engineering from John Deere.

  • @Hubjeep
    @Hubjeep Před 5 lety

    Wow. I just went over my 20 year old 52" Exmark deck (should have years earlier... so much rust... homeowner used but untouched over that time besides sharpened blades), replaced all pulleys, but they all had grade 8 through-bolts, including one that looked very similar to the thick pulley you replaced.

  • @michaelcountryman3981
    @michaelcountryman3981 Před 4 lety

    Good info thanks.

  • @sailme2day
    @sailme2day Před 5 lety +2

    Nice quick and affordable fix :) That is how you get it done. How the heck did he snap the other one off ?

  • @fenceman95
    @fenceman95 Před 5 lety

    Very good.fix

  • @wysetech2000
    @wysetech2000 Před 5 lety

    Nice fix!!!

  • @wm005
    @wm005 Před 5 lety

    Great idea...

  • @mebcool
    @mebcool Před 5 lety +1

    Thanks DB 73
    I would suggest using a bit of thread lock to prevent the bolt from backing off.
    Great repair though 👍

    • @donyboy73
      @donyboy73  Před 5 lety

      yes for sure, but there is a lock washer

  • @Chasarbo
    @Chasarbo Před 5 lety +1

    Hi, great video as usual. I had a question about my lawnmower. I have a Toro 6.75 149cc that does not have a primer button. I pull the string about 4 times, smell gas then wait about 5 minutes. It usually cranks up then. Do you think I need a carburetor kit?

  • @BrucesShop
    @BrucesShop Před 5 lety +1

    Great imagination on that repair Don

  • @kjell-richardlvdal373
    @kjell-richardlvdal373 Před 5 lety +1

    great video, better to make that repair than by a new lawn tractor

  • @gonzgarr1592
    @gonzgarr1592 Před 5 lety

    nice fix

  • @derekbocock4609
    @derekbocock4609 Před 5 lety

    Awesome

  • @vetterfellow
    @vetterfellow Před 5 lety

    100 - excellent repair DB73

  • @unclebs4732
    @unclebs4732 Před 5 lety

    Great info, this is why I subscribed. The 3 thumbs downs were from John Deere engineers. Thanks for all of you videos.

    • @donyboy73
      @donyboy73  Před 5 lety

      thumbs down are usually from other shop owners who watch my videos lol

  • @Santiago-iv7oi
    @Santiago-iv7oi Před 5 lety

    Nice...👍👍👍👍👍👍

  • @philliphall5198
    @philliphall5198 Před měsícem

    Hey I did the same thing, jd didn’t have a replacement shaft for it 😢
    It’s a shame that it is made this way but was a easy fix anyway 😊

  • @cavinallen1768
    @cavinallen1768 Před 2 lety

    The part number for the fix is from John Deere M71682 .
    $4.21 .
    Cut the old part off and put a new bolt on with the new bushing no problem.

  • @warrenpeas
    @warrenpeas Před 5 lety

    i have a 38inch deere deck and i need to know if there are spacers that go under the idler pulley or on top or both. These spacers look like washer but are much thicker.

  • @smokestack9795
    @smokestack9795 Před 4 lety

    One of the pulleys that rotates the spindle on My John Deere S240 completely rounded out in the center. It was just spinning on the stem after 100hrs of uses. Do you know what causes a blade spindle pulley to go from square center that fits snug on spindle stem to completely round? Thanks

  • @dddddd2100
    @dddddd2100 Před 3 lety

    I wonder if the bolt broke off while removing the nut for Idler pulley replacement, I'm going to replace both Idler Pulleys on my John Deere 125. any advise to keep this bolt from breaking? maybe some penetrating oil first. mine are not corroded at all. anyone advise? Thanks.

  • @dennisfairlie7080
    @dennisfairlie7080 Před 5 lety

    Please do a video on the following:FS 45 Stihl String Trimmer.Pull start works easily with Spark Plug out, put plug in and pull start won’t pull or barely will pull....Why?

  • @philliphall5198
    @philliphall5198 Před rokem

    I drill out the ribits and bolt it back with new brging

  • @ramrodnj
    @ramrodnj Před 4 lety

    I have a 2017 John Deere 100. I took the screw off the pulley but the pulley won’t nose up so I can take the belt off what can I do. It’s so new that there is yellow spray paint on the threads. I have put an bar under it to try and get it out but it won’t budge. What do I do???

  • @TheOzthewiz
    @TheOzthewiz Před 3 lety +1

    Some "lock-tite" on the threads wouldn't hurt either!

  • @raymondcampbell2346
    @raymondcampbell2346 Před 5 lety

    Good fix Don and good alternative ideas from others. Thanks Don.

  • @animalcorvair
    @animalcorvair Před 5 lety

    time to pop the seal an grease up the bearing too

  • @Iowa599
    @Iowa599 Před 5 lety

    use a T-handle with the tap, not a ratchet. 'Push + Pull' will provide a rotary force, not bending, like 'pull' alone.
    Or use a cordless impact wrench, like I do. Tap FAST!!!

  • @jay9172
    @jay9172 Před 2 lety

    I need to be able to loosen the pulleys so I can put a new belt on but I can't loosen the nuts. What do I do?

  • @theeabster1983
    @theeabster1983 Před 3 lety

    there's hardly any videos out there about the spindle brakes or deck brake. can you replace just the brake pad of them or do you have to replace the whole arm? I'd imagine there would be different answers for different makers Craftsman John Deere and so on at least in some cases. then again John Deere and Craftsman share the same engine in some cases. anyway I was seeing sparks fly out from underneath my deck and I couldn't figure out what it was I searched the internet other people had the same questions never seen any answers couldn't find any information about sparks flying out from the deck on CZcams once I turn my deck over from the Craftsman lawn mower I seen where the spindles have worn through these little brake pads and into the metal I'm assuming that's where the Sparks are coming from. can I take the arms off or is the lawn mower unable to be used without the brakes being on it? it probably is a stupid question but I'm going to ask it anyway if anybody has any insight into this mess would be appreciated. the lawn mower is Craftsman ys4500 917.276642 42-in deck Briggs 20 hp single piston OHV it only has one bar from the front of the tractor to the deck the spindles are a four bolt. ordering what I believe to be the right ones from Amazon looks like they're going to take about 10 days or more to get here. and was trying to figure out a solution to cut the grass until then. thanks again

  • @philliphall5198
    @philliphall5198 Před rokem

    Heat them nuts first and water them
    Add antiz back

  • @hdrk59
    @hdrk59 Před 5 lety

    Use a tap handle...less chance you snap a tap.

  • @anthonyelectric6045
    @anthonyelectric6045 Před 5 lety

    Nice easy fix. Broken bolts are a bitch for sure. Just snapped one off holding on an engine to the deck. Have to do that drill out and retap method. Aluminum block steel screw.

  • @georgekernahan8622
    @georgekernahan8622 Před rokem

    Part # for pulley?

  • @deltaw.o.m.d5192
    @deltaw.o.m.d5192 Před rokem

    the dealer told me I would need to by a new deck the bastard..lol

  • @MRrwmac
    @MRrwmac Před 4 lety

    Donny, Good fix. Needs to be oiled every now and then doesn’t it?
    Could you please respond to the comment I left on the Ryobi 31cc trimmer carb fuel lines? Thank you.

    • @donyboy73
      @donyboy73  Před 4 lety

      i don't have a ryobi trimmer here to give u exact specs

    • @MRrwmac
      @MRrwmac Před 4 lety

      donyboy73 I didn’t ask for exact specs. I was commenting about how I never saw a carb that had to be a working carb before the plunger/siphon/pump would work. That question should have popped up a week or so ago from that old video.

  • @michaelspeakman8924
    @michaelspeakman8924 Před 4 lety

    Do you know they got a drill bit and tap together now all in one. So there's no mistakes but using the wrong tap

    • @donyboy73
      @donyboy73  Před 4 lety

      yes I just saw that, will be getting some

  • @GrampiesWorkshop
    @GrampiesWorkshop Před 5 lety

    How's she goin'? That's a money saver eh!!!

  • @johnkosheluk1041
    @johnkosheluk1041 Před 5 lety +2

    Good old pos John dear if you didn't do that thay would want you to reply the whole deck

  • @dddddd2100
    @dddddd2100 Před 3 lety

    The larger Idler pulley on my John Deere 125 is tilted or slightly angled or not perpendicular, the deck vibrates when the blades are engaged. could that be the cause? anyone with an answer?

    • @donyboy73
      @donyboy73  Před 3 lety

      that pulley will not cause that, check your blades for wear, belt and spindles

    • @dddddd2100
      @dddddd2100 Před 3 lety

      @@donyboy73 I think it's time for new blades, one is slightly bent upward on one end, also I replaced one spindle, both flat idler pulleys and the belt to engage the blades, I think the belt tension needs to be adjusted so the belt is tighter. I'm wondering if the slack in the belt could cause some vibration. Thanks

    • @dddddd2100
      @dddddd2100 Před 3 lety

      @@donyboy73 It still vibrates, I replaced both blades on this 42" cut John Deere I used brand new OEM JD blades, I have noticed when I have the cutting height at 2 1/2" it vibrates less and vibrates worse when the cutting height is set to 5" any Idea why? Thanks again

    • @dddddd2100
      @dddddd2100 Před 3 lety

      @@donyboy73 2 new balanced blades, 2 new spindles, both idler pulleys new, and a new blade belt. still have vibration from the deck. worse when cutting height is on 5, better on 2 but still there. could the new belt cause this? it's OEM John Deere brand.

    • @dddddd2100
      @dddddd2100 Před 3 lety

      @@donyboy73 I just replaced both spindles on my John Deere 125 with the 42" edge deck, also replaced both Idler pulleys, both blades and the belt. the deck has a vibration when blades are engaged. both my spindle pulleys looked worn where they fit down on the spindle shaft. they don't fit tight where they mate up with the top of the spindle shaft the (6 sided opening) is worn and you can rotate the pulley left and right its loose, but once the lock nut is tight the pulleys are secure and tight in place... I wonder if they could be causing my deck vibration problem? Thanks.

  • @lukehaubrick
    @lukehaubrick Před 5 lety

    Hey I tried the valves adjustments and it end up costing me 500 bucks

  • @tomdewey9907
    @tomdewey9907 Před 5 lety +4

    Why wouldn't you just do it via grinding/drilling out that stud and use a though hole nut & bolt with a proper bearing spacer? Not the best solution there IMO.

    • @fadetounforgiven
      @fadetounforgiven Před 5 lety +2

      "Best" is a relative concept here. For starters, he just had to basically make a hole for a new bolt and that was pretty much it. If you want to do it your way, which at first I also thought it would be the "right/adecuate" solution but then I think it isn't, you have to cut that off, make a hole, then find the proper bolt with the right spacer. That is, you are now in need of a spacer which Don's method isn't. That's a pretty good advantage if you ask me.
      And second but not least, when you put that new bolt, somehow it seems to me it will be easier to come un-screwed as time goes by than this way. Also, it's harder to tighten as the pulley must be in place in order to do that. And if the thing is not un-screwed with time and use, it will probably tend to rust or remain stuck if you ever want to take it apart for whatever reason.
      I think Don's method is not only simplier but also better in the long run.