Moscow (1947)
Vložit
- čas přidán 12. 04. 2014
- Full title reads: "Moscow".
Moscow, Russia / Soviet Union.
Field Marshal Viscount Bernard L. Montgomery visits Moscow.
LS of the snow clad Kremlin. MS Monty with Russian officer. MS The cupolas of St. Basil's Cathedral (presumably).
MS Monty with Russian officers walking through the snowy streets to the Kremlin and entering the building. LS A corridor inside the Kremlin.
MS Monty talking with Russian officer. LS Sparkling chandeliers inside the Kremlin.
CU Monty and Generalissimo Joseph Stalin, sitting on a settee. CU Stalin head shot, full face. CU Head shot, full face of Monty. MS They shake hands.
MS Monty, wearing Russian gift of fur hat and coat with Stalin. MS Stalin. CU Monty, in astrakhan hat and greatcoat with astrakhan collar.
FILM ID:1177.12
A VIDEO FROM BRITISH PATHÉ. EXPLORE OUR ONLINE CHANNEL, BRITISH PATHÉ TV. IT'S FULL OF GREAT DOCUMENTARIES, FASCINATING INTERVIEWS, AND CLASSIC MOVIES. www.britishpathe.tv/
FOR LICENSING ENQUIRIES VISIT www.britishpathe.com/
British Pathé also represents the Reuters historical collection, which includes more than 136,000 items from the news agencies Gaumont Graphic (1910-1932), Empire News Bulletin (1926-1930), British Paramount (1931-1957), and Gaumont British (1934-1959), as well as Visnews content from 1957 to the end of 1984. All footage can be viewed on the British Pathé website. www.britishpathe.com/
0:25 Soviet Elon Musk…😳
😂 LoL
Elonavich musk
More like Eloneer muskolov!
I guess that's how the soviets won the space race
@@kosovartupac9579 Ilya is the russian version of Elon, so Ilya Maskov fits better
I can't believe the camera quality is better than mine
I want your camera
Your one is digital, the filmed one, not. This is the reason. The definition of an analogical one is almost as small as the atomic particles.
I can't belive you write this
Better than the camera quality of the Khmer rouge in the 70s
android user be like 😂😂
75 years later: still hoping the relationships between our two countries get better
All the politics that the media show us is a staged show. I suspect that there is no real tension between the authorities in the West and in Russia. All this tension is for ordinary people to keep them under control. In any case, this is absolutely certain for Russia. On TV, they tell us every day what a terrible West is and how it shits Russia. But our state currency reserves are mostly in Western banks, in Western currencies and securities. All our elite have property in the West and their families live in the west and their children study in the West... Both Putin's children and grandchildren presumably live in the West and are citizens of Western states. Read Orwell 1984. Everything is written there - why and who needs all this enmity.
@@MarMar-nq9ii боже чел
@@MarMar-nq9ii and US doesn’t have the most aggressive foreign policy in the world with geopolitical goals built on their own exclusivity?
I mean, the politicians of my country, including the president himself, at least openly talk about dialogue, that solving problems in relations is necessary, and it should be based on the fact that the interests of both sides are taken into account. your government scolds us as if they are the main country, one nation under God, and rightly so - it is as they said. all their accusations sound hypocritical and from a position of superiority, in a tone like "what does this Russia allow itself".
at the same time, from your side, it really looks like the presence of an enemy to explain certain problems to citizens. and to receive huge amounts of money for military needs.
@@MarMar-nq9ii Comrade, your marry-world is too stiff.
Stalin's times are the best in USSR: gigachad based guy that was building real socialism based on Marxism-Leninizm was at those times, his surname is speaking about him quite openly: Steelman in English language. Yes, he made mistakes, but goverment was in agreement with that and sometimes our beloved comrade Stalin was against government. Stalin tried to build a good relationships with west based on just human interaction instead of Marxism-driven approach.
But time has demonstrated that dry theory works too well even for such a good thing as peace.
My hometown would be erased just because of plan "Dropship". What my relatives did wrong to US or their "Democracy" ?
That's why we have forgiven our comrade Stalin for his mistakes, usually position of old people that went through war was: Stalin did nothing wrong and there would be no victory without Stalin.
Younger generations that know history, that read documents, everyone who read Stalin's books-they are very Pro-Stalinist.
But your view is based on cliche of burguose-kind of society where politicians are just instruments of oligarchy will.
Best of us was in power and that's was his mistake: we relied too much on him, instead of relying on us and him at the same time because he was a part of us.
@@MarMar-nq9ii Не Оруэлла читать надо, а Ленина. Второй всё, написанное тобой, задолго до Оруэлла написал и пояснил, ну...
Stalin smoking a cigarette instead of his pipe.
That's how you know that it's fake.
😭
It’s a cigar
It's a joint
indeed
the kgb will watch him and he will send all of them to gulag
0:24 nice to see that Elon managed to invent time travel in the future as well
He longed to serve Stalin
Lol 🤣
i knew it someone commented first before me
@@insekta14 BRO THATS LITERALLY HIM
LOL
"the barriers between our 2 nations are coming down" that aged well
LOL, it aged like stale milk.
They did, for a while. Then Russia put up a wall which stood until 1989
@@BlatentlyFakeName no. The Truman doctrine was signed later that year. Then vommunism arose and usa declared them a threat.
Fact is the soviet union was admired by americans before propaganda
@@Commielover69 aint never liked them hope putin loses his corner on the schoolyard ...like a little kid ..then again biden is a Cuck so we all fked ..FJB
I’d love to have that hat and fur lined coat that Montgomery’s wearing (0:12, 1:24)!!
Story behind that fur coat is what was given as gift from Soviet leaders in during 1947 cold winter!
It is still available to buy.
The hat is a papakha, they can be bought on eBay and various Russian military surplus stores if you so desire
It was named after him
It is called bekesha and being sold in post soviet countries for 50-80usd.
Not the greatest coat, but ok for some occasions.
Props to cameraman to travel all the way in past to capture this!
0:25 He also invites Elon Musk on his trip
@@rhezarief 😂😂yoo
Did you know that cameras exist since the 1800s?
@@samuelcaloracan IKR
Bibek das this is getting out of hand with the cameraman
1:00 Stalin: look to the camera. Not to me
Haven't seen this clip before. The tone is hopeful and reconciliating. I wonder how Soviet media portrayed this meeting and the relationship with the west at this time?
положительно
just like any other time, much closer to reality than BBC or SNN do. In the end I heard Soviet narrator, he spoke positively
the soviets were the true and original "don't hate the people, hate the government". russians didn't demonize american workers like americans did with the russian and chinese
Великий Сталин! Всем смирно, равнение на вождя!
@@user-lo5fw8ri3e Ah well Larisa, oppression & murder does the trick!
1:12 damn Stalin really hooked the homie up with the drip 🥶🥶🥶
You are a white man. Speak like one.
LMAOAOAOAO
I decided to grow my mustache like stalin
Same there mate
Man, knowing about Stalin's disability, with his arm not being able to reach over his head, it's obvious that he's doing his best to conceal it, his dominant arm is clearly fine, but you can really tell how inflexible his disabled arm is; very stiff. When something is broken that badly in childhood, it just doesn't heal perfectly.
Don't worry about his arm but about his head !
man, knowing about stalin's ideas....idk if he needs sympathy
@@zap296 Ask Russian people about their sympathy for Stalin ! That is only their business.
Everybody feels like a kitty cat next to Joseph, even Royal fieldmarshals :)
Stalin was calmness personified. What a chill guy.
Until he took you out. Unfortunately looks even the observation of joy on him is pretty misleading.
Сталин был всегда хорошо информирован и всегда имел план действий. Он пришел к власти как человек, который подготовил СССР ко второй мировой войне, уравнял военный потенциал СССР с военным потенциалом Германии, и обеспечил тайную эвакуацию оборонных предприятий за Волгу, что нарушило планы нацистской Германии на блокаду оборонных предприятий СССР и быстрый разгром советской армии . Прежде, чем победить военные силы Германии, он победил немецкую разведку и немецкую военную промышленность. Можно сказать так, что Сталин спас СССР своим руководством. У него много других заслуг перед страной , но, прежде всего, он для нас, советских людей, полководец. Потому что в области организации обороны страны ему приходилось принимать решения очень часто единолично. И поэтому никто не помнит, что в СССР у главы государства не было больших полномочий, государственные решения принимались коллективно. Все это заслонил огромный авторитет данной исторической личности.
@@leejenkins7184 According to Soviet historian Robert Thurston, the ordinary Soviet citizens actually supported the purges, and it was only the elites who got caught up in the chaos. The purges were not some master plan devised by an all-powerful, omniscient dictator, they were chaotic and frantic responses to a real political crisis, even if it was based off of misinformation.
@@leejenkins7184 That is due to the tabloids you have been reading. Without Stalin's troops doing all dirty jobs no Western soldier would ever have touched European ground.
@@leejenkins7184no
love from India to Russia 🇮🇳🤝🇷🇺
👍🇷🇺🤝🇮🇳🤝🇨🇳🤝🇧🇾🤝🇦🇲🤝🇰🇿
Любовь из России в Индию❤️
With love from Russia 🇷🇺
Отличнвй ролик,спасибо,давайте еще такие же ролики.👏👏👏🤝🤝🤝👍👍
да роликов со сталинской показухой полно
@@зятьЗюганова в каком смысле "со сталинской показухой"?
@@user-pt2ru9fd1f да роликов со сталинскими парадами полно
у "сергея" переводчик дал сбой)))))))
Чистая сьемка
There goes a man who really thought he was greater than God Himself. And next to that man stands Stalin.
I dont know montegommery ( i dont know how to spell it) but did he really think like that?
@@Scourgeoftengri yeah
@@Scourgeoftengri and his people
@@JooWen00 ☭
Most awkward thing ever. They both look so uncomfortable..
Some of y'all still not over me, damn.
We need you daddy
Papa Stalin!!
Сталин!
Livin in their head rent free fr
Stalin rhymes with the word Sralin.
stalin looked like a chill dude
Такой как в обычной жизни-настоящий.
Easy to be chill when you killed or gulaged all your opponents and have half the world at your mercy.
@@thunderbird1921 when you have a bunch of men who argue and are too afraid to take action, you need a man like Staling to get things done. And when you get things done, every single one of those maggots will criticize you. This is when you put them in gulag, where they turn big rocks into small rocks and actually do something useful for the country.
Stalin was a man who knew how to get things done and did no waste time with traitors. Stalin was a man the country needed.
@@snowsnow4231 True
made orders to shoot people who retreated and caused the Ukrainian famine, and forced all civilians to stay in Stalingrad, he was not chill, quite the opposite.
This camera quality is somehow better than court cam quality
I love the comical presentation,the presenter had the gift of gap
Отличное видео. Спасибо!
PUTIN RUSLAND BANDIT
PUTIN HUILO
У всех одновременно это в рекомендации. Ютуб ты что-то странное и удивительное.
В день рождения его,скоро будет!
Yeah Montgomery really nailed this. Because of him the cold war will never happen.
The what?
Quite chilling seeing Stalin almost smile
@L yeah i know, but there is something about this particular footage for me that is off putting.
Everytime Stalin smiles somebody goes to the gulag
@@jonbarosa8692 Stalin wasn't a monster. Stop with that.
@@stealthy2375 What the hell...
@@carlosleva3417 and what?
When Joseph Stalin look at you 👀
You actually shocked
0:42
Why did yt recommend me this after 75 years?
0:26 - young Ilon Mask(at the left)
Супер качественное видео. Спасибо.
PUTIN BANDIT
Even this looks better than the quality of those bank security cameras
Настоящий мужик который всей страной победили против нацистов
Stalin is still the greatest leader Russia/USSR had in the last 200 years, and possibly the greatest it had of all time.
The Communist Party of the Russian Federation remains the #2 party in Russia today. Historically the world has not given the old Communist Party sufficient credit for defeating the Nazis and saving the world from fascist genocide.
Stalin was just Ivan come back
Alexander I>>>
А Брежнев?
@@MB2.0it's like USA and UK is doing now
I like the 50s retro radio voice
Great picture
Great piece of record.
1:09 着膨れてモコモコになってるの可愛い
0:25 Elon Musk (Илон Маск) до того, как стал известен
Hahahaha yeah
Сталин любил шутить. Нас.генш. Англии при рукопожиятии , активно и внимательно смотрит Сталина от ног до головы а Сталин улыбкой лице показывает генерала смотреть камеру.
Пон,ашему ты траншея)))))
RUSLAND PUTIN BANDIT ............SLAVA UKRAINA
1:01 Stalins like "look at the camera you fool" 😂
0:24 офицер слева похож на Илона Маска)
Stalin seems such a nice guy.
And then...you read and hear the truth about him.
@@thunderbird1921
Everyone has done bad. Preach
@Ctg Возможно, по количеству населения их может быть больше (если это утверждение верно), но мы не морим их голодом и не работаем до тех пор, пока они не умрут от слабого здоровья или истощения (как в ГУЛАГе). Сталин был монстром, который жестоко создавал ложный образ себя как благодетеля, когда на самом деле уничтожал всех, кто ему не нравился или считался угрозой его собственной власти. Некоторых посадили в ГУЛАГ просто за критику правительства. Народ СССР был введен в заблуждение и обманут тираном и его союзниками.
@@thunderbird1921 ты лично присутствовал там,в этом гулаге или где то что то прочитал?Иди дальше продолжай смотреть голливудскую фантастику
@@thunderbird1921 As explained in J. Arch Getty’s 1993 paper on the gulags, the gulags had an average of 2M prisoners throughout the 30s, 40s and 50s, with less than 10% of gulag prisoners being political prisoners, around 20-40% of prisoners being released every year, and a death rate of only 2.5% (4% during WW2). Additionally, archival evidence in Edwin Bacon’s book “The Gulag at War” indicates that around 1/3 of the gulag prisoners were not even required to work. Now that we have access to all of this archival evidence, I highly doubt that the likes of Solzhenitsyn were telling the truth when writing books for a western anti-communist audience in the 70s. Furthermore, the assertion that Stalin built a cult of personality around himself is utterly devoid of evidence and originates from Khrushchev’s 1956 “Secret Speech”, which cites no sources, was politically motivated, and has been refuted to death ever since the opening of the archives. While a cult of personality did exist around Stalin, Stalin himself did not create it or even encourage it. In fact, multiple private letters and correspondences from Stalin show that he hated the cult and discouraged its propagation.
Muy bonito los camaradas que lucharon juntos en la 2 gerra mundial, Stalyn y Mariscal Mongomery
they chose specifically Montgomery to go meet Stalin because any other British high-ranking commander would have looked WAY TOO TALL next to Uncle Joe! :D
Super
Wonder how Monty felt when he was standing in that room with Stalin
He felt honoured.
I don’t know he felt but he looked like a complete idiot wearing that hat.
@@stevenyourke7901 That's what you think, perception of looks is subjective.
@@stevenyourke7901 He may be fear for his own life because during Stalin regime millions peoples were killed or tortured. 😬😬😬
@@shahrulamar5358 Ah yes, because Stalin would have a BRITISH FIELD MARSHAL executed. That TOTALLY wouldn't end up causing a war in which USSR would be obliterated since they had no nuclear weapons yet. He was TOTALLY afraid of Stalin, maybe he'd be too rough on his new coat, very scary.
The photos inside of the kremlin are genuinely fascinating
The camera quality back than better than cctv camera now.
Stalin, the original Kartvelian.
He is sooo cute 😘😘
თქვენი აზრით სტალინი რა ერის იყო?
strange to see a left hand shake
Как достойно держится Сталин,спокойный и уверенный! МОЩЬ !!! Умный и проницательный взгляд!
Гитлер тоже прекрасно держался на публике.
Диктаторы,они все актеры
Сталин доволен что в 1947 от голода в его стране умерло 1,5 млн чел
@@зятьЗюганова ну да, тебе же виднее от чего он доволен.
@@зятьЗюганова ты сам считал?😂
@@зятьЗюганова откуда эта бредовая информация?
Stalin looks like a nice old grandpa!
A nice old grandpa that massacred millions of his own people...
@@vmurda415 Yeah, just like they said about Saddam and Gaddafi. Western media always blows smoke about leaders who opposes them.
@@YoubTijani Then why did both Khrushchev AND Gorbachev call him a murderer? They certainly weren't western capitalists.
Its easy to be hyperfocused on the sins of the west/east and to downplay the sins of your own camp. Stalin was a monster. But so have been every US president in my entire lifetime.
Until he roast you alive
0:27 - the barriers of two nations are commig down . Over 75 years - the barriers are still coming down )
This original vedeo....?
0:25 is that Elon musk on the left
LOL
OMG LMAO
Stalin didn't need an interpreter! He spoke fluent English, a fact he hid from Churchill and FDR at the Tehran and Malta Conferences!
wait really? i never knew
@@shawnezekiel7727 , naive! This is, of course, a joke).
@@user-rf1qj6fw5i oh ok
@@user-rf1qj6fw5i Stalin speaks Russian with Georgian accent.
@@shahrulamar5358 , who would doubt that).
Excellent
Я думал в конце Монтгомери спляшет калинку для товарища Сталина )
Напрасно думал!
У меня тоже такой белый тулуп был в карауле.
Stalin seems very simpatic in this film.
Mikoyan, a member of the Polit Bureau, said that when you left after a meeting with Stalin, you never knew if you were going home or to prison....
So where did it all go wrong?
The camera quality of this is better than those from the Banks,
0:57 Сталин закурил, Монтгомери сказал - оставьте мне дунуть, а Сталин сказал - в камеру смотреть. 1:12 Кто-то за кадром сказал, что тоже хочет закурить
STALIN IDIOT BANDIT PUTIN PSYCHOL
ELON?!?!!👀 - 0:25
yes Elon Father hear 😂😂
Hahahah)
So comforting.
по взгляду видно, отец всех народов
У.пырь он, а не отец. И отцом, мужем был плохим.
@@user-ge4mg3wg1f у.пырь володя пупкин, а Сталин Отец народов!
@@user-jv3qt5gw4m Оба у.пыри))))
@@user-ge4mg3wg1f Это точно! Но джугашвили всё равно поупырестей. Навроде шикльгрубера.
Эх , сейчас бы его сюда, вы бы быстро успокоились
Everyone is gonna come today to this video 😂 23 Nov 2021
yeah, btw you aren't from 6 years.
Hey
This may be wrong, but is that a stalin double?... It does not look exactly how I remember. That would be so interesting if it was.
Depictions of him from western sources are inaccurate. He didn’t face the public too often (as the Soviet Union didn’t have ‘one leader’, according to the CIA it was collective, between those like Molotov, Stalin, Bulganin, and Malenkov) so depictions may always be a little inaccurate. Plus cameras distort faces anyway - they cannot show depth.
I see that Field Marshal Montgomery is wearing his Order of Victory medal. Can you pick it out on his uniform?
On the middle of his left side, the larger star of two.
Вернуть бы Сталина! Все боялись и уважали. Принял Россию с сохой, оставил с атомной бомбой...
Путин оставит без трусов..
@@user-nu9iu3km8e нет, Сталин был куда страшнее! Путин просто таракан который давно просит тапка..
@Anton Smirnov свои подарит что ли?
Дело не в страхе и уважении. Дело в таком, какой класса у власти.
@@mrcriminal2727 Вроде уже 30 лет раша ,как без своих трусов,все китайские.
Mongomery: The world's most chilling place on earth was not the Arctic or Antarctica but..... The Kremlin!
i thought it was Chile
Пусть так и думает. Сталин - это вершина, которую никакие монтгомери никогда не достигнут.
F* Man... The quality and calibre of that Fur-lined Great-coat and Fur hat must have just been fantastic - not to mention the authentic craftsmanship... I bet that guy's family somewhere today they have those gifts still in England, (tucked in their attic somewhere 🤔😉
0:27 The grandfather of Ilon Mask was a Russian
Lol, why there are fewer comments?
The CZcams algorithm hasn't blessed many people yet. We were the chosen ones lmao.
Stalinists are bots paid by Russian government to rewrite the history and create a good image of stalin. And now is night in Russia so they sleep)
Many of the original comments were sent off to the Gulag.
That guy on the right looks familiar...
Maybe its just your imagination
@@ichbindynamit9919 yeah you're right
0:43 "Hum, i dont order some excuse for a long time"
Jadi kangen masa masa itu
Gw pernah naik mobil itu
0:24 Comrade Elon Musk
0:25 Didnt know Elon musk was there
❤️
0:23 left side guy is Elon Musk
A camera in 1947 outperforms my webcam
He seems to have charisma and charm
@John Titor Nope
Only Lenin was charismatic leader of USSR,rest are just leaders.
Lenin just a loser, Leonid Brezhnev brought USSR a golden age
@@jesusidiot7229 Brezhnev is the reason for economic stagnation.
who? stalin? yes he had some charisma, after all he was a dictator, no dictator worth their name isn't charismatic. but montgomery? he was an autistic idiot and his social skills on par with a broken vase.
Where can I get a winter jacket like Montgomery ‘s ??? I’d be warm all winter ❄️
Russia i presume!
0:24 Elon Musk soviético fds kkkkkkkk
Montgomery sitting next to Stalin looks like he wouldn't mind being somewhere else 😉 .
Дедушка Сталин 👍👍👍❤
Cant billive the cctv cameras are worse than cameras in 19s
Why is everyone being recommended this now.
only thing I like about that period is how leaders used to smoke openly without anyone caring
Why’s there only 5 comments on this video?
I don't know
Idk
The rest were undesirable and got wiped from history in typical Stalin's fashion
Because you cound't comment before
0:55 this is Stalin? he looks so much smaller that his paintings and photos??? is it a body double??
He was frail and weak
@@Atheneonyeah. According to Zhukov during the war he really slept, and would stay up all night stressing about his decision making, worried about the consequences.
Noice 🔥
Сталин - величайший государственный деятель, отец народов!
Наверное он твой отец,спроси у матери 😃
@@user-xc2fp9vj1d , не несите чушь, Сталин действительно великий человек и отец Советского народа. А Вы - злюка, не знающий историю. Могу Вам посоветовать ознакомиться с трудами российских историков Жукова и Спицына. Может, тогда Вы не будете оскорблять память великого вождя нашей страны.
@@user-uw8zr7mk5p Спицын это не историк, а агитатор, таких балоболов ценили в совке, не смешите "учёный"
@@kotofey70 , Спицын - автор пятитомника по истории России, книг ,, Осень патриарха", ,,Хрущёвская слякоть", ,,Брежневская партия". Евгений Юрьевич Спицын патриот и историк с большой буквы.
@@kotofey70 , плохо не уважать свою историю. Вы ведь не манкурт. Может, такие, как Вы, и ,,совки", но такие, как мы, считаем себя советскими людьми и гордимся тем, что родились и жили в этой прекрасной стране.
See happiness on his face comrade yes sir 😄😳 0:43
How are the camera man able to record this??? CZcams doesn't exist in 1947 or even phones
There were films and the ability to save them, dug up the archive and produced, or maybe they just took a new time and mounted it as if in 47
Is this comment a joke or something
@@thechekist2044 I understand, sorry
@@thechekist2044 dude I'm just asking relax!
Josh with the moustache
This is rare indeed. Clearly this was a British film crew. Not much footage exists of Stalin walking. Stalin had a bad hip and walked with an awkward gait. In Russia it was illegal to film him walking.
Source?
@@pedroguimaraes3113 Stephen Kotkin, a historian who’s written two books on Stalin
You can find a lot of footage with stalin walking even here on youtube.