The Country The World Says Doesn't Exist
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 07. 2018
- Update: As of September 2023, Artsakh has fallen. Consider this video a time capsule. A memory of a different era.
Patreon account, for those who care: / overview
Follow our Instagram: / rareearthseries
Follow Evan's twitter: / evan_hadfield
Follow Francesco's Instagram: / frapetitti
Ambiment, by Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
creativecommons.org/licenses/b...
This video was made possible thanks to our incredible Patreon subscribers Alejandro Fuentes Salazar, Bryden Kanngiesser, Nicholas Bottomley, Luca Varriale, Giulian Fava, Marzo, Jonathan Lonowski, Robert Velten, Sean Lavery, Dan Walker, Wilco Verweij, Matt, Travis Frazier, Aldus, Scott Willis, Alberto Daval Cordiero Araujo, Mathis Bicheyre, Matt Dykes, Michael Zare, Rob Awesome, Erik Ensing, Martin Esser, Jarod Hoffarth, Mike Pearce, Gavin Cross, Thomas Edwards, Sean McBain, Dan Demsky, f1r3w4rr10r, Edee Nackers, Linda KC, Marty Otzenberger, Matthew Hampton, Shayne Stride, Paul Bartholomew, Georgy Petukhov, Michael Teesdale, Tanner Hoyle, Mohamed Moustafa, Martin Faszinka, Cameron White, Alessandro, Krak, Eric Downes, Denise Lipscombe, Jonathan Web, Sven Erik Jonsson, Ben Carter, Pawel Wojciechowski, Daniel Worthington, Gilberto Hart, Christ K, Jaro Neko, MacFoxington, Chris Carrigan Brolly, Tristan Lambdin, Djof, Marek Slabicki, Jeremy Oldson, Earnest N Strong, Stephen C Strausbaugh, Sharpie660, John Alexander Goff, Joshua Clarke, Alan Chaess, Jacob Rebec, Phyronnaz, Kameho, Zan Markan, Nick Achatz, Tad Moore, Alan Biedenharn, Twisol, Darren Kames, David Badilotti, Sam C, Zachary Hall, Muncorn, Pippin, Henderson Moret, Elsilan, Leandro De Ste, Michael Loken, Wei Ern Tiong, Ossian, Anurag Pande, Jon C Scott, Ross Fletcher, Allen Setzer, Amay Khara, Josh Hoppes, John Cline, Ursus Canus, Michael Leers, M.F., Steven Fontinelle, Steve Martin de Souza, Thomas Paris, Blade Marcantel, Taylor Fussner, Penny Brown, Einar Holmedal, Audrey Brown, Katie Wadley, iwishiknew, Lukas Jackowski, Yoshi, Julian Fiander, Graham Otte, Paulina Jonušaitė, Vicki Allardice, natriums, Markus Sawinski, Scott Crawford, Fiona Mackintosh, Michael Wla, Peter Bjorvand, Lukaluke, LargeBilledDuck, Anina Keller, Kidd Mclayer, Mitchell Cage, Alex Van de Sande, Ruddy Arroliga, Nekkowe!, Akasha Yi, Aodhan Minney, Michael Hartnell, Henrik Rønning, and Araya. We love you guys. There are so many of you now!
Thanks for watching! You're clearly one of the good ones.
You allow us to tell these stories.
www.patreon.com/rareearth
Rare Earth , well, I've seen about a dozen or so videos from this channel, and I'll have to say this one got me. Subscribing, and getting my 23rd like in 10 years
Rare Earth next up Palestine.
Rare Earth It's a beautiful country...
Awesome!
Did you think about a vid about Kurdistan?
Not to worry. CZcams will take this down when told to.
Rest In Peace Artsakh
How miserable😢
Gone but not forgotten! Azat u ankakh Artsakh!
Swim in sewer !
It's Azerbaijan now. 🤩
Rest in peace Artsakh. I’m sad that I never got to visit, and in a few years the region is going to be a husk of its former self
Get you Azerbaijani visa and visit. We are waiting for tourists.
@@mullim9860 Will you resettle Stepanakert with Azeris? After all, those homes are free if they want it.
you can still go
God, me too. I visited Armenia, but did not have the time to visit this legendary region. RIP Artsakh.
@@user-dn9bk4pj1e I believe the government has stated they plan to start resetting the region within the next few years.
"They know history supports the Armenian,
so they destroy the history."
Oh my, this line.
Crazy I was reading this as it hit on video timing wow ...no I'm not about signs or what not but wow timing crazy ... Great line tho agreed
Like they did with Afrikaans history.
It's not just a line, it's the truth.
Great qoute.
Just like what Israel is doing with Palestine.
who is also coming back to this video because of the war that might starting on September 2020?
Unfortunately the war has been started by the Aliyev & Erdogan alliance on Sunday morning. Please help us spread the word by trending the hashtags #ArmeniaAgainstTerrorism #StopAliyev #StopErdogan #ArtsakhStrong
#ArmeniaAgainstTerrorism
@@lilitpetrosyan0708 #KimKardashianIsBabyKiller
System of a down sent me here.
gg hahaahah everybody got deserved
If Artsakh ever does get recognized as an independent country it will be because of eloquent supporters like this guy.
Artsakh 🇦🇲
And people with guns. 🇦🇲
I wish You are free and indenpendance happen, but I think this warmongoring video will not make things happening faster, not better.
@@MihaUcakar how is this a warmongering video?
@@AmirZarif47 I hope we watched the same video? Year of peace and tolerance made this land so happy and free ... it seems good idea to keep this working in the future too, right?
As an ethnic turk, what turkey and azerbajian has done and continues to do to armenians is disgraceful.
What they have done to themselves is just as bad.
I’m not Armenian but I’m also not sure that everyone appreciates how courageous & kind it is each time an ethnic Turk acknowledges what was done to the Armenians. Please allow me to respectfully ask a question. Although the massacres Armenians during WW1 were carried out by the Ottoman Empire & not the Turkish govt why does Turkey’s govt take such drastic action any time that another nation or the UN attempts to label it genocide that occurred 100 years ago? Is that because the Turks are offended that someone is possibly accusing their ancestors of genocide? Or is it to prevent a situation where Armenians are compensated or given land to return? Or is there another reason? Again, I ask this respectfully out of curiosity & understand if you don’t answer. Also, since the US committed genocide against the American Indians I’m not casting dispersions on any person or group & I even understand why some at the time saw Armenians as enemies of the State.
Nothing short of state sponsored ethnic cleansing.
The world would be a better place if there are more Turks who think like you do.
Turkey is the ass of the world
If it weren't for System Of A Down, I'd never thought to look into Armenia and it's history. I would love to visit this area of the world someday. So beautiful, so much history, and such wonderful people.
The Kardashian's should really do more to support their country - I'm sure they have enough power, money and influence to provide real change
@@TheAlps36 Kim won't even stop making her cheap crap clothing in Turkey.
Boy, what a band... I never knew anything about Armenians either, but they changed everything for me in that regard. Truly an influential group
@Thomas Wilson Not just a song, but just looking into the background of the band, that garnered me to look into learning about Armenia.
@@TheAlps36 Their country? They're American. The Kardashians may be (partly) descended from Armenia, but they make it clear with whom they ally themselves.... excuse me.. with what they ally themselves. Money and attention are their deities and they show no signs of ever being disloyal.
This story is made new again by the current conflict.
Which conflict?
@@masstv9052 Azerbaijian declared war on Armenia over the territory and after some weeks one a complete decisive victory. So now the place has been lost and no longer exists as an independent place any more.
Why doesn't this get as much support as Palestine?
@@Quickshot0 That's not quite true. Nagorno-Karabakh proper still exists and is still independant, but Azerbaijan has taken control of several neighbouring regions and displaced the Armenians who lived there.
The country is still alive, but only barely : it's surrounded by hostile forces on almost every side, with only a single road connecting it with Armenia, and a Russian peacekeeping force is all that stands between them and annihilation. Their survival is now completely dependant on Russia's whims.
@@loxodoncyclotis1823 I see, after reading a little further on that it does indeed seem to be another standard Russian solution. Freeze the conflict while making one of the actors dependent on Russia. Though in reality both sides now have more Russian issues to deal with.
I visited Armenia last year. It is a sad country with a sad history. Very friendly people and great landscapes.
And visiting Karabakh is no problem from then on, a 15 minutes stop and a 25 EUR visa at the Karabakh embassy in Yerevan is all you need to get there. Oh, and the will to go for a few hours through beautiful landscape.
Do they Cherish the memory of the Anzacs? Their second most important goal was to save Armenians.
+RickJames What are you talking about??
The ANZACs were a tool of England and I doubt that Churchill gave a toss about them except that they were a Christian minority in an Islamic Empire and opposed the Turks. They were entirely civilian and completely lacked weaponry.
This is what Hans Humann, the German naval attaché in Constantinople said to US Ambassador Henry Morgenthau:
I have lived in Turkey the larger part of my life ... and I know the Armenians. I also know that both Armenians and Turks cannot live together in this country. One of these races has got to go. And I don't blame the Turks for what they are doing to the Armenians. I think that they are entirely justified. The weaker nation must succumb. The Armenians desire to dismember Turkey; they are against the Turks and the Germans in this war, and they therefore have no right to exist here.
Does this sound just like the German attitude to Jews? Expendable nuisances of a different religion and culture.
And what did the Germans do about it? Nothing. They had their own selfish Empire-building going on.
I saw an old photo of a Turk teasing a small group of starving Armenians with a piece of bread. It was heart-breaking and I wish I could "un-see" the vision. At times like that I hate my species. Animals lack the sophistry of hatred we highly-evolved bipeds have developed.
Pieter I wouldnt say it's a sad country
Whow. I thought everybody had forgotten this already and nobody cares. Exceptional good work....thank you. Let there be peace for everyone.
I, From Canada, Had no idea! :(
@@russianqbot8587 You generally wouldn't if you don't have Armenian friends.
The Illuminati doing it's job. I am glad to have learned this.
I got emotional by watching this video. Armenians, i totally feel you.
I come from potnic greeks of Trapezounta (Trabzon), which were living there since 8th century BC.
They only way to survive as identity, is to maintain our language, traditions, etc.
Much love from Greece
Christ help you out someday!
Don't let non-believers & some bots smother your religion and identity
@Areg SARKISYAN Loosers pact!!! This is your fabricated story, Karabakh is Azerbaijan!!!
@Areg SARKISYAN You mean history of Karabakh, it is Azerbaijan. Armenians are lucky Azerbaijanis didn't take those lands back the way armeians took them in Khojali.
drone goes boom
@@markzandi7874 Respect for Azerbaijan for khojali. Human shields is a great move.
RIP Artsakh.
Man this story's heavy, especially for you to tell, and definitely for those living it.
Our appreciation for this series can't be overstated.
After 4 years there is only one video that has made me consider donating on patreon.
Edit: college student here, I'm poor
The Raff so the one about white virgins...?
no no the windy rock
Rajmund Csombordi why? I'd rather make sure people are informed. Good information and stories like this are hard to come by. Education is important. And I'm not donating to a war effort, no matter how righteous.
Join the club. I'm a proud member.
Satan
You don't control me! I have the power of God and anime on my side! AAAAAAAA!
The history of this nation brought me to tears. Great video! I'm Brazilian and have indigenous blood in my veins and these type of struggles resonates here, as in every point of the globe.
And it's more impressive due to the fact that we are one of the countries that Armenians chosen to live after trying to escape the brutality against they own land. This history is very intertwined with our own.
Ive often wondered about the struggles of native peoples in Brazil. The idea that someone like Bolsenaro can win the presidency because of neo nationalism resonates with me as an American. I truly want to visit Brazil though. Hopefully someday with my fiancee who is from Okinawa and knows all too well about American imperialism...
@@Oblivisci........ I wish you only the best.
@@Oblivisci........ Bolsonaro winning is way more complicated than a simple rise of nationalism. The left ruled the country for almost 20 years and they were trying to seize the power completely by corruption. The largest corruption in the world is still held by Brazil, meeting not only latin america countries, but african countries too. The leader of the Workers Party, Lula, was in prision for leading money laundering in the country and his party went on the elections. So, half of the population hated Workers Party and Lula for stealing our money and supporting dictatorships in latin america (like Venezuela) and voted in other people, but in the end, the elections were Bolsonaro against Lula's puppet, Haddad. Everyone agrees that, if the Workers Party stayed out of 2018's elections, Bolsonaro would never been elected... So, greed in politics.
Lots of love from an ethnic Assyrian with roots in Mardin that used to host a majority Assyrian and Armenian population, I wouldn't be surprised if I have some Armenian blood myself due to the common intermarriage between Assyrians and Armenians in the Middle East
My Kids are one of them. I'm an Ethnic Armenian married to a Syriac/Chaldean from Mardin. Our Hearts are being shattered due to this conflict
Where do you live now, if I may ask?
Respect to Armenia from an Irishman. Keep up the good fight against imperialism.
Giffy I don’t understand why...
Giffy that’s nice. Will we keep it up the top then?
Irish-American here, I second that. Respect and love. May there be peace on Earth someday, if only after the second coming of Christ.
FIGHT THE POWER !!!
Armenians have been at war ever since the beginning of time the red in our flag is meant for blood. Aryan gnov pahel en mer hoxera. (By the price of blood they’ve kept those lands) is the translation to what I wrote in Armenian. That’s a saying that’s been around forever and now Armenia’s surrounded by Muslims on all sides and they’re bloodthirsty. It’s a reality Armenians must deal with.
@@zainulzainul1880 :
That's because Armenia has been attacked from all directions all the time by much larger nations.
Initially, it was the Roman empire. Armenia was a vassal state which means it was partially independent and had its own army.
The Roman empire fell and the Byzantine empire took over.
That was eliminated by the turks.
Iran and turks were fighting each other. I don't know the details.
At some point, Russia joined in and Armenia was split between Russia (Eastern Armenia) and Turkey (Ottoman Empire) (Western Armenia).
Armenians/Assyrians/Greeks were killed off starting in 1890 up to a large scale killings of 1915.
So, at that point, the christian population fell to almost nothing and Turkey does not want to recognize what it did and does not want to return Western Armenia to present day Armenia.
By being prostitutes as you call it, there is an Armenia today while Assyria does not exist, which was one of the most powerful empires 3000 y ago. They also attacked Armenia multiple times.
Kurds? There are maybe 20 million of them and don't have a nation. There is no cultural material. No letters. No vases or castles or anything.
As for Turkey, how much of the ancient stuff there has been built by Armenians? Visit a musuem. According to turks, 0%.
Unbelievably high quality content. Informative, entertaining, and visually magnificent. Seriously impressive work man youre a top class documentarian, and absolutely one of the best channels on youtube.
dito
My new favorite. Subbed. Patreon supported.
On the other side of the coin, Americas people remain free from military and government take over because of the right to bear arms. From the millions of guns in America, there are 1.2 guns behind every American theoretically. One could argue that the American People aren't free and it is an illusion, and yes that might be true to a certain extent. But you don't see or Government attempting a coup d'état or other counties invading the soil where there is a rifle behind every blade of grass.
Our own Government has changed their tactics because of our militias that exist within the people and the overwhelming number of individuals who are willing to stop Tyranny.
GoreTorn16 Guns in the hands of citizens have close to 0 to do with America remaining 'free'. You're surrounded by an ocean far from any other military power, with a close ally sharing one border and what is essentially a puppet state sharing the other. Countries like that simply don't get invaded, the cost is too high to ship enough soldiers by sea, you see that with every nation that's geographically isolated from other powerful nations. Then theres your military spending, no other nation is close, it isn't your hunting rifles and magnums that keep away enemies, it's your billion dollar air forces and nukes.
The idea that some pissy guns are keeping your government at bay is seriously funny, we've seen how armed internal militias fare against the army from religious nut job groups, and the results are never surprising. The majority of money is in the states with the least guns and the most opposition to guns, only Texas stands out there, how do you really think that'll go in real life?
D Joseph albeit some missing facts. We have a gun blazer here, but guns have only bee around for a very short time in historic war.
The more I learn, the more I realize how little I know.
Thank you for this piece. Highly informative and well written.
we all write this so help us leave the weapons needed to wynn
you freeing yourself from the duning kruger effect Mama Marlanovits. Friendly, fromfrance Olive
That's called 'Valley of dispair'
How do you know you learn rights?
Lots of love and respect to the Armenians from a Kurd. We feel your suffering and really hope that you one day get Artsakh back. You have gone through too much and unfortunately we contributed to your suffering back then.
Thank you for your post, LeClerc.
With all that's going on right now (Russia attacking Ukraine and acting insane, Turkey and its puppet Azerbaijan screwing around with NATO and acting like its on the other side with Russia, Iran's protests, Iraq unapologetically hating us and perhaps for good reason, Syria in disarray), I wish we'd pull some 'strategery' and dump tons of funding into the Caucasus. Arm the Kurds who we let down so they can open up a full offensive on all sides to create Kurdistan from the several countries who either are our enemies or are screwing around with them. Arm the Georgians like the Ukrainians so they can drive the Russians from their lands and open up another front with Russia. Yes, arm the Armenians at home and in Artsakh to counter the victorious Azeris in their war; Biden already opened the wound by recognizing the Armenian Genocide, you might as well not go back. With Turks, there is no going back, they're insane, "you have to recognize the context, there was killing on both sides" (this would be like a Nazi saying there was "killing on both sides" of the Holocaust because Jews sometimes revolted and escaped the death camps). It's pretty undetermined as to who we exactly support, Armenian or Azerbaijan, but at some point we may have to pick a side. Turkey gave its drones to Ukraine, yes, but it's also a little TOO close with Putin and its screwing up NATO politics with its Kurd hate and refusing to let Sweden in. Arming the Caucasus during these times would cause chaos in Russia, Turkey, Iraq, Syria, Iran, Azerbaijan and certainly make them think twice before messing with the West.
Thank you kurds, for hiding our ancestors in your homes during the Genocide.
Alot of armenians killed kurds in WW1
Nope@@SAADOFFICIAL436
My country is home to generations of armenian immigrants. Super nice people. They have their own traditions, businesses and ways of doing things. But unlike other refugees, they dont bother people with them. They just adapted to our country while keeping their identity. I have upmost respect for them. Greetings from Bulgaria🇧🇬🇧🇬. We belive in you.
I'm a Serbian in America and Armenians are amazing people. I will always stand with them and fight against Turkish influence.
The way it should be.
They behave just like you described in sweden aswell, we are lucky to have them.
Peter Alexander yeah they’re some cool people. I grew up in Chicago and we were polish but the Armenians from what I remember didn’t say any racial slurs to me when I used to walk home. The poles tho...
As an Estonian agree. You can see them from far but they are kinda not pushing you to their mindset. Very likeable and hard working people. In soviet union many Armenians were top communists, inventors, cultural people. There is even a village in armenia where came.. 3 generals!!! xD . So dont worry about the armenians too much. Like the jews they will survive and go much further than we can ever imagine ).
Once again something serious I've never heard anything about. This really is a great channel.
Jong-un Kim zup kim. how's dictatorship going on? 😏
Sheep Gaming woah, okey...
Maybe you can be the first to recognize this place?
Then again, maybe that will not be very productive...
This is not the first yt video ive watched with a comment from kim
My family always said a prayer for the Armenians suffering here. Most people have no idea what they have suffered through. And they still suffer. God bless them all! Long Live Artsakh!
@@OGrandomunknownperson it's still called oppression if they're being oppressed you unintelligent knobhead.
Soviets could leave if they wanted too yet they were oppressed and propagandized to not do so
Thank you so much
Thank you
#ArtsakhStrong ❤🇦🇲
I am Bulgarian, we suffered under the Turkish genocide for 500 years and we survived. We understand your struggle and we don't forget! The whole Bulgarian nation is with you!
The same in Lebanon.
One day we'll retake Constantinople, untill that day keep the fight (in words of not guns) against Islam.
Being angry at Turks, it’s the government that is evil, same with a lot of countries
@123qwe456rty79uio 987dsa654hgf321lkj Tell that to all the religious folk who were murdered in the 20th century atheist states, and the Muslims, Buddhists, Christians and Taoists being killed off for their faith in modern day Atheist China.
Secular, that is non-committed, countries do well. Atheist States are murderous, totalitarian nightmares.
Thanks my brother, thanks!🇦🇲🇧🇬
My great aunt is Armenian they ripped out her eyes and tongue and defiled her in the worst way imaginable, she is the single bravest woman I have ever met, she escaped her sister wasn’t so lucky
Thank you for sharing that, and Im sure you have much more to say on those attrocities. I was just wondering who :THEY: are that you speak of?
FREA ATTLAST her family were persecuted by the Turks
Be sure to hug an Australian some day.
The Bogal song, “And the Band Played Waltzing Matilda” really bugs me when the crippled Veteran notes a boy asking about a parade of other Veterans, “‘What are they marching for?’, and I ask myself the same question.”
The Anzac tried valiantly to save them, whether they fully understood their mission or not. Not every soldier could, especially back then. Even if he heard about rescuing the Armenians, he never met one, and because of their failure to break the Turkish line, he never would. Just miles away, vast killing fields would have driven home why the Australians were there, but that was nothing more then a rumor, as far as the thwarted soldiers were concerned. The people of this country should reach out to Australia to recognize them. They couldn’t save them before, maybe they can now.
Thousands of New Zealand soldiers died alongside their Australian cousins fighting the Turks also. We (ANZACs) took the high ground in the Dardenelles, but the useless British high command failed to capitalize on this. English people are decent. The British government is a total bastard.
The Rainblossoms
Only half the goal was to save Armenians; To be fair, there is some circumstantial evidence that the Czar’s intelligence network had been compromised by either a German or Turkish spy, as the other half was to support the Russians in a pincer to cut off Turkey from German support. Even if they didn’t know precisely when your great grandfathers were going to strike, they shouldn’t have been THAT prepared.
This is further exponentially tragic, because Lenin could never have returned from exile had Gallipoli been a success, and Russia would have been radically different place today.
Nicolas 1&2 had been phasing out the old feudal system in favor of a British style parliamentary democracy and perhaps constitutional monarchy. Assuming that communism in China could not have arisen without Soviet help, a generous estimate suggests that as as many as a Billion people are missing from the world (if you include all of the Chinese mandated infanticides) because of one wretched spy and several stupid British admirals.
“....but, for a nail”
Of course, Communism is so appealing on paper to a certain kind of passionate fool, that it was bound to be imposed somewhere eventually, but preferably in several small countries could have had minimum harm as a result.
I'm near 70, and my Grandfather served in US Navy after WW1, and told stories of the starving Armenians, and genocide in 1920s.
Coiled Steel you were told some history
So what have you done about it?
The old professor
Clan Robertson what have you done?
He's fake, he's clearly not 70.
@@clanrobertson7200 Tell everyone i know about it, including all media legislators, and now YOU!
What do you want me to do? At near 70, I'm too old to get a sign and protest!
NOW your turn - what are YOU doing except complaining?🤔
Coming back here today to again share this video to as many people as i can in light of the flare up in conflicts again today
“Defending whats theirs..with a gun” Damn right
Yep
I mean this is kinda why there is a second amendment in the US
@@jewey1894 it's sad that that's the way it is, but if guns are hard to get rid of them at least reserve them for killing people in war, rather than keeping death weapons in with civilians, you may not be able to get a lawyer if a neighbouring country encroached on your land, in that case I guess guns are ok, but you certainly can if your neighbour claims your garden shed
drone goes booom
Look at that beautiful landscape. Such splendor.
Thank you Dolores
SaTaNaMa stfu
Ew. Applebee's is awful. all that's gonna do is ruin it, even more so with those awful restaurants.
No wonder why those people don't wanna move
SaTaNaMa thats your own name you illiterate fuck
Wow , that's quality journalism.
osten/сыр /der Käse/the cheese/le fromage
It's lies.
What specifically is lies?
Journalism is not about one sided story telling, it should include all views and opinions. It is not journalism, it is propoganda of armenian view to the story
The stories from all other sides have already been told. we simply get to see the story from THIS side, this time.
This video needs to be seen everywhere
Or Rare Earth should make an update.
Too many people have died over this. There's understandable hatred from both sides. We're seeing tens of thousands if not more people evacuating, and from what I hear the Azerbaijani government even arrested some evacuating people? I have no stake in this fight, I only hope it ends... But it's not going to end, is it?
I learned about the Armenians in my freshman year in high school back in 1989. Have respected their culture ever since. Traveling to Armenia is in my bucket list.
May God Welcome you to my Armenia on a red carpet
This *isn't* about
Christian vs Muslim
Armenian vs Azeri
Right vs Left
It's simply about *a people's right to self determination and personal freedoms.*
It doesn't matter what race, religeon or ethnicity you are but you deserve these rights.
These rights were fought for,we were not born with it.These rights can be removed too if we take it for granted.
H X do you truly believe the Armenian people take their rights for granted?
Captain turbo splooge Of course not,my comment was meant for Lunar
@@hx5525 They were fought for, yes, but it seems you misunderstand why. They were not fought for so we could control who does or does not get them, they were fought for because of the belief that everyone on earth is entitled to these human rights apon birth. No human being in the world should have to suffer on through life without these rights. No human being in the world should have to trudge on through their lives knowing these rights can be taken away at any moment. People may have fought and died for access to these rights, but everyone on the planet deserves them. Hence why they are called HUMAN rights, and not whoever-is-deemed-worthy rights. Before you go on talking about sacrifice and fighting for what you believe, maybe you should put a little more effort into knowing just what these people were fighting for. This is meant with no disrespect, only genuine advice from one human being to another.
Too bad liberals don't want that.
I'm an American who visited Armenia and Artsakh in 2017 and had a great time. Beautiful country with wonderful people who have suffered much but are still strong. I learned a lot and encourage everyone to visit. Love from the USA to Armenia and Artsakh!
Make your representatives do something about it and inform others. ACT.
The old professor
Let everyone know how to get there and how to help them!
Lol i saw the title and i was like “hang on is that Karabach? Nah im probs just projecting my own culture onto stuff” but it actually is. Thats great
Maryam Mammadova half Armenian 👌
Maryam Mammadova it was actually armenian until stalin gave the land to azerbeijan. After the sovjet union fell, karabach was officially declared azerbeijan but in reality most of the people living there were armenian.
Maryam Mammadova Armenians live all over the world, but in this case its land that has been mostly populated by armenians for centuries and still now. Also dont forget that armenian and azeri culture is very similar, if you like it or not.
It's painful to watch this after the events and massacres in the last year and to this current day, but your words are empowering and much appreciated. Thank you for shedding some light on the indigenous Armenian struggle!
Oh so this is what The Young Turks denies happened.
Cenk has recanted on that. Like it was said in this video, the Turkish have a culture of denial when it comes to the armenian genocides. Cenk is turkish and was raised by people with those views. As a 20 something year old man he shared them and was vocal about the genocide having never happened.
He's apologised now, said he was young and ignorant, and has publically adopted a position that facts cannot be argued with and what happened happened.
I think the only reason he isn't more vocal than that is that he still has familial ties to traditional turks and you can't both accept the genocide and be accepted by the turkish.
@@jamham69 I saw the video, it is true statement. Ana led the monologue in that video.
And Ana is Armenian herself.
If he still has familial ties that prevent him from changing the name of his god damned show ("the young turks"? really?) Then, he has no business being a public figure, being on television, or otherwise making a living in the news industry. He has to choose, between being accepted by his fellow genocide deniers, or being accepted by the general public at large, the people who view his shows and buy products from companies that advertise with his shows. It's one or the other, he can't have it both ways. There is no reason for any of us to continue to do business with someone afflicted with his disease. People like him ought to die in obscurity, rejected by polite society, we owe them nothing and have nothing to gain from them.
mmysama "Turk" has become(wrongfully) a word used for a mischievous person. It's that meaning in "The Young Turks".
Just like we tarnish the Berbers by using "Barbaric" for anything we see cruel.
It wasn't just solders murdering, they starved the people like in the holodomor. The Armenian genocide was brutal.
The holodomor is the most easily debunked myth in history. The Soviets drained their eastern grain reserves to save the Ukrainians putting the Union at risk of a Japanese invasion, the claim they starved Ukraine is not only idiotic, it’s an insult to actual genocide victims
JacatackLP the Holodomor was intentional. The Soviet government sent the army into Ukraine to seize food from the Ukrainians and divert it to many of the Russian and Byelorussian cities in the west. They went into houses and forced the peasants to give over everything they had. If a woman was found in an already harvested field trying to find any remnants of food left behind to feed her starving child, she would be shot for stealing from the state. Outside aid from the west was rejected to maintain the pride of the Soviet government that didn't care about its people despite claiming to be the vanguard of the workers. The Holodomor was intentional and killed millions, and rejecting it is just as bad as rejecting the Holocaust or the Armenian genocide. Volodymyr Shcherbytskyi, First Secretary of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of Ukraine, confirmed the Holodomor in 1987 under Glasnost. Even the Soviets, under Glasnost, recognised that the Holodomor was intentional. The evidence is immense
Jeanne-Marie Tchoumak also democide
Jeanne-Marie Tchoumak Never happened to begin with. There is no proof of a genocide.
@@JacatackLPIt is a common misconception that only the Ukrainians were starved, they also starved both the ukrainians and kazakhs
I dormed next to a girl who was Armenian and Jewish, her family history must be so sad :(
@@OGrandomunknownperson ?????
random unknown person antisemites never cease to amaze me
random unknown person look it up, and try to make your jokes clever next time instead of blatant
Lacy Yaris uh oh this is high level of edge im shaking
It is beautiful to see a people remain true to their culture and ancestors despite the odds against them.
This was the topic of the second to last episode of parts unknown that aired during Anthony Bourdains lifetime.
Yes, he stayed at the same guesthouse as us. The one mentioned in the description. We didn't know that until we arrived, though. Bourdain is an inspiration to me, and always will be.
_/bumping this thread/_
Stay safe, you’ve bothered some terrible people.
Clearly, his death was actually a murder by the Azeri.
+
I recognise them and their ancient rights completely. Bless these people
do you have guns ?
Thank you so much
@@mohit5496 No he has a Cat. He is oppressed.
With the conflict escalating lately, this video has aged very well
I worked in Armenia back in the 90's out of Yeravan. Good people, very well respected by all of them. Positive experience.
@@Vivere714 If you want me to come over n help fight for Armenia. I am a Combat Vet
*Azerbaijan wants to know your location*
Mom's basement
SKSKSKSKKSS
Does Azerbaijan also want to watch anime reciews?
i hear thats where they keep the bad wizards.
the Iron wolverine fuck Azerbaijan
Browsing through all the crap on CZcams it's rare to find gold... but this channel my friend is solid gold!
Thank you.
As such, expect it to be deplatformed eventually.
God help the Armenia! Regards from Croatia ✝❤
Help for Armenia, the world needs to hear Armenia's point of view. Love and Respect from India🇮🇳
Համերաշխություն հայ ժողովրդի նկատմամբ
@@zil1832 Haha nobody needs your support.
Sure...and which country are you from?
@user Thank you brother, we have old Armenian Church here in some cities of India... in Chennai and Kolkata, possibly in other cities too. We have long historical ties between us. I welcome you to visit one day.
THANK you for your comment...
I'm an Armenian now living in this beautiful country: Canada ... ... I call home
. . . A VERY proud Armenian+Canadian
... ... the representative of your country past week made a statement that it didn't make news here in Canada
... however: I have listened to it many times
... ...Mr. Kolakusic made a very STRONG statement against the present Canadian 'Dictator'
...I hope, as a Croatian, you are proud to have a such GREAT human in your government!
VIVA 🇭🇷 🇭🇷 🇭🇷 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🤍🤍🤍
... Ara
this documentary was totally awesome it really opened up my eyes to what's really going on in the world thank you so very much. I wish there was something here in the United States that I could do to help those people. If I was younger I would probably take up arms and fight alongside them for as long as I could or forever.
Dude you need to be on TV this was awesome, please give us more!!! THANKS!!!
SpinningDronez Photography no on the tel-lie-vision.. This is truth, never make it to the mainstream screen. The television is for control and propaganda not truth. Wish it wasn't though
TV is for imbeciles only.
No body needs to be on t.v. T.V. is for dumbed down mind controlled slaves.
@Paul Slevin send me your 75in. spy on the wall.
No
I like their flag, it has a retro 8-bit Atari vibe to it.
The flag uses a traditional Armenian carpet pattern defacing the Tricolour flag, symbolising the fact that Artsakh is (for geopolitical reasons) separated from the rest of Armenia, but part of the same nation.
Atari was not 8-bit Nintendo entertainment center was 8-bit I think Atari was 4 or 6 bit.
Atari made many different systems the 2600 is their most famous console, it's 8bit. They also made 16, 32 and 64(ish) bit machines.
The NES and the 2600 used practically the same processor
There are no mainstream consoles that had processors lower than 8bit.
Atatari
I do recognise Artsakh - when given a choice, at that foreign ministry in Stepanakert, I chose to have the visa put into my passport instead on a separate paper, which is an option. I liked the place and they're always happy when someone chooses to have their visa put in his or her passport. Proud to have it there and if I ever get to go to Azerbaijan, I'll just take another passport with me.
This aged well
Please help us spread the word by trending the hashtags #ArmeniaAgainstTerrorism #StopAliyev #StopErdogan #ArtsakhStrong - the world needs to know Armenia is desperate to defend this little piece of land and strives for peace in the region. We cannot afford this war, not now, not ever. We want peace
@@Vivere714 well u r loosing the war once sushi is taken astrakh is done for....we will know in the next few days
no it didnt age well
@@huehuehue7869 that's how the joke usually goes
DRONE GOES BOOOM
As usual, I've learned more about places that I'll be able to go in 13 minutes than I did in 3 years of high school. I've been to Turkey, so I know how weird their politics and history are, and I've about the Armenian genocide, very interesting series.
Charles Damery I am from Cyprus. Turkey invaded killed thousands and still occupies 1/2 cyprus
And it was the United Nations Peacekeeping Force that included Canadian troops that stopped a complete takeover by the American backed Turkish Forces. I was in Basic Training in 1974 when it happened.
just a psa, but the oh so 'progressive' hosts of The Young Turks here on youtube, are armenian genocide deniers.
In a similar manner, the land of Israel was part of ottoman turkey, so what , should Israel be part of turkey? (with most of midle east)?
See the reason why you "learned here more" is because half of it is propaganda that isn't true in any way. You guys live in a echochamber! All the guys squirting bullshit about Turkey and Cyprus or Turkey and the armenians have absolutely no idea. You just believe what you kinda want to. History is not that easy! Grow up you morons...
Support Armenia and Karabakh by visiting as tourists and bringing money into their economy.
just be careful of mines and bullets...
Would love to visit Armenia! How do they feel about Americans
Definitely that's on my to do list! Fascinating culture and part of the world! I hope Armenia and Artsakh unite some day soon.
Joe Al false
I will eat Turkish good here in the us
But I will not support a country which invaded Greece and committed crimes against humanity.
@@tony_5156 so you wont support germany, italy, turkey, Britain, russia, iraq or macedonia just to name a few?
This is history that isn't taught in schools. I didn't know any of this. Many millions more need to see this. I hope and pray they achieve the independence they deserve. Thank you.
Unfortunately the war has started and we're still unable to get Azerbaijan to cease fire and return to negotiations. The Aliyev & Erdogan alliance organized this attack on Artsakh Sunday morning. Please help us spread the word by trending the hashtags #ArmeniaAgainstTerrorism #StopAliyev #StopErdogan #ArtsakhStrong
@@Vivere714 DRONE GOES BOOOOM
I have never known of this before. I want to thank you, Rare Earth, for telling this story. I totally agree with you that these people should somehow soon be recognized and given the protection they deserve so that they can exist and show to the rest of the world what is really important about a people like this. No matter how powers-that-be characterize these people, the world should step up and demand that these people be protected against those who just want to kill them because they are different.
Rare Earth! I sincerely hope you realize that with this series on Artsakh you have contributed towards the development of peace in the region through communication and understanding! First of all, your research on the issue is so deep and elaborate. Second of all, your courage to stand for the truth despite its consequences is astounding! But most of all, I want to thank you for your involvement. Seeing positive even apologetic comments from Azeris is so rare that I dare say its unheard of! They comprehend their own suffering but are utterly incapable, from what I have witnessed, to see our suffering. Yet, scrolling through the comments I saw positive and sympathetic comments from Azeris despite the backlash that they received in response by their countrymen. To me this is a step in the right direction. I want to believe in the goodness of people despite the brutality of the reality in this region. I know there are good Azeris but reaching them seems to be impossible. A third, unaffiliated, party such as yourself brings a fresh perspective void of any accusations of lies and makes people actually listen. It's the communication that is missing because the hate that I have witnessed by the Azeris is frankly disturbing and scary. They don't even want to hear our side and meanwhile their government; headed by what most would consider nothing short from a dictator, fills their hearts and minds with hate for anything that stands Armenian. The propaganda is real. I have never been to Azerbaijan and as an Armenian I am not planning to set a foot in that country but I read about people who have visited (non-Armenians of course) who write that the main streets of their cities showcase billboards of casualties from the war with zero censorship and with severed bodies and then blame these atrocities on the Armenians. This is unbelievably disturbing! The maintenance of hate in the ordinary Azeri is state organized and it is delivered with such zeal that it's no wonder that Azeris behave the way they do. If Armenian government allowed itself to do such condemnable demonstrations on the streets of Yerevan then there are enough atrocities committed to our people to cover every wall of the city. Our government behaves like the head of a civilized nation like they should but on the other side we are faced with barbarism which is unheard of in this day and age. From what I have read and what I understand the motivation of the government to breed hate inside its Azeri citizens is nothing more than a tactic that the Aliyev regime has found to work in order for him to stay in power. He has been in power since 2003 and he has no intentions to step down. He has made presidential terms unlimited to retain his right to run for elections year after year. But in order to have the people vote for him he uses the conflict with the Armenians because as long as there is conceived threat by the 'bad' guys then he can act like the hero of his people and respond with aggression and war. By having the conflict fresh in the minds of its citizens the dictator can act like a hero in delivering what the people 'want' which is revenge. For them this region is just a sense of pride and for the Aliyev regime it is just a token to remain in power. Now, let me get back to my point. If only there's a fair discussion without toxic government involvement I think we can begin to resolve our differences and the comment section of your video has given me hope. I believe that an Azeri mother cares about the loss of life of her son or daughter as much as an Armenian mother does. I'm sure that the bloodshed is as heavily traumatizing to the Azeris as it is for us the Armenians. But to be able to see each other's sides we need communication and we need to actually listen and your video has delivered both of those things which is why I am grateful!
Marinè Avagyan Which part of Armenia are you from?
On another note: You good with radios and radio encryption? I hear the caucasus is very beautiful this time of year...
Love from Israel, keep on standing up to imperialism (I know I’m from Israel so it’s kinda ironic for me to say that but just to dispel any myths I fully condemn the annexation of the west bank, people deserve to be free and it’s an inalienable right).
welp
unfortunately that didn't age well
@@ihaveseverefrootsnackism this is sad
Peace? This video is too one-sided for that
this is pretty sad. wanted to say something funny but that feels out of place.
respect to these people. my country finally recognized the Armenian genocide this year.
officially that is, the people already are pretty synonymous on it, except the turkish immigrants ofc.
john pardon where are you from, the netherlands?
UltraSmurf yes
None Ya now go tattoo it on your left asscheek
Ive never met a single turk that didnt adamantly deny the armenian genocide.. the guilt runs deep
@Murat : You didn't kill them in the battlefield,you killed them after they lost the war,went to their homes,grabbed them,women and children alike,made them to face against the wall,and bang,muskets were off and all of them dropped,you did the same to Cyprus,rounded them up and bang while raping 15 yo Cypriots,Turkey has been left Unchecked,It's been enjoying the pointless cold war between the west and Iran,while Populating most of Europe With it's nationals,The new Europe will come for you guys
This was beautiful. Thank you, not everyone cares to even know about us but I see this has made a big difference.. thank you again.
I’m not even 4 minutes into this and this is already the BEST presentation of information that I have ever seen! WOW this guy is talented!
Unfortunately the war has started and we're still unable to get Azerbaijan to cease fire and return to negotiations. The Aliyev & Erdogan alliance organized this attack on Artsakh Sunday morning. Please help us spread the word by trending the hashtags #ArmeniaAgainstTerrorism #StopAliyev #StopErdogan #ArtsakhStrong
Omg.
Jesus - these people deserve peace. A life. I hope they get it.
I HAD TO KNOCK A KID INTO NEXT WEEK BUT I NEVER HAD A PROBLEM AFTER THAT
I GUESS THAT IS THE MANIFESTATION OF PEACE THROUGH STRENGTH
Oooooh! I get.
Noooooo I get it. Well said , touche said that he was hungry for his tongue and his hands someday might not know.
Kiore mongs I totally agree, but I’m stuck wondering why other nations don’t support them? Why doesn’t like America recognize them as a country? Because of some pissed off Turks?
That seems like a pretty minuscule reason to not do something as minor as just recognizing them.
@@petedeiler9066 P P P
Fun fact: Balkan Albania has a small Armenian community of 1,000 who came during the genocide.
Armenians who live in Albania are respected. We love learning about your culture. 🇦🇱🇦🇲❤️❤️
Illyrian king......you're not illyrian you brainwashed misinformed Donkey
@@robkit6681 but a donkey nonetheless. Like people from Artsakh :)
@@robkit6681 why can you just shut your mouth and ignore cultural divisions and your hate for one culture cause they just exist, maybe you're the brainwashed misinformed donkey
Armenians are not indigenous. Look at the Turkmenchay Treaty. Look at the Khojaly Massacre. There are problems in human rights in Azerbaijan, but it is not the bloody dictatorship. We are not a Muslim country. There is no official religion here and few women wear hijab, most probably fewer than your country. 1 million Azerbaijani refugees, killed women and children by Armenians and lost historical land (look at the Karabakh Khanate).
@@womenvalue9333 Khojaly is miniscule compared to the Shusha Massacreor the Maragha massacre.
Armenian presence in this region dates back to the BC era before the Turkic migrations.
Look to a map for evidence. The word "Azerbaijan" did not exist until the 19th century.
Rest in Peace Artsakh. It is so sad to see that what lasted so long is now coming to an end. By now, most of the armenian population has already fled, next year, the state will formally cease to exist. One last time, glory to Artsakh!
Wikipedia calls it occupied by Azerbaijan. And that's exactly what it is. Artsakh never was Azerbaijan and never will be! Hay Qajer!
Big strong bloke here....last time I cried when was when my mother died.....this story almost brought me to tears. I hope the Armeninian people win their fight and struggle !
What a story. There is so much in the history of this world that we know little about. I've heard of the Armenian genocide but I knew nothing of Garegin Nzhdeh Dude I can't believe you were wearing that t-shirt! What if some official saw you?
he was in armenian controlled land
The ideology of Nzhdeh called Tseghakronism can be generalized to all nations. He wrote many interesting things that make us think and help us to protect our values.
I believe one should separate patriotism from nationalism. One is good, the other very very bad.
patriotism is american nationalism
billiondollardan it is only in isolation that ideas and history can be contained and controlled. What does your modern history book omit?
Greetings from Finland. We can totally get it how a people goes to awakening of being a nation. We too thought we were Christians, and Swedes. And then by cultural confrontation, started the realization, that we have a different identity, culture and language, and awoke as Finns. Many nations have never been independent, yet they exist. And neighboring nations often try to annihilate their culture, assimilate them. Same happened to us Finns: we live as a minority in Sweden, Norway, Russia, and everywhere they killed Finns and persecuted our culture and language, telling you can't be a Finn, you must adobt our culture.
Sympathy and understanding.
Let people of the world enlighten and live in peace, tolerating their differences.
Amen-Amen-Amen(!!!), Auri!!!
This is very interesting. I want to learn more! I'm British but lived in Sweden for a few years and my daughter was born there but, I'm ashamed to admit know little about Scandinavian history apart from where it affected Britain. I plan to rectify this.
Just say no thank you to the finns
Try being scots Irish in the 17th to 21st century, bloody German Jewish English nobility!
It has been my dream for over 10 years now, to go to Finland. Love from Florida, USA
It's utterly heart-shattering to watch this after the fall of Artsakh. One of these days Artsakh will be free and its people will come home.
Very powerful message! It seems like such an obvious David vs. Goliath, good vs. evil story... and yet, Western media is almost universally afraid to tell it, and especially in such clear, full-throated terms as you. Bravo to you for this!
Yep this one was it, I just made a patreon account so I could pay you. Your work is incredible my man
And remember kids, Cenk Uygur from The Young Turks named his company The Young Turks after the Nationalist party Young Turks responsible for the genocide talked about in this video. Not only that, but he actively wrote essays and gave speeches before he became internet famous after which he realised he had to shut up about his views before people realized he was the Turkish equivalent of a neo-nazi denying the holocaust. He only very recently apologized half-heartedly after a lot of pressure from viewers for his statements and otherwise tried at every attempt to ignore the question for well over a decade. His co-host is an Armenian solely for the sake of making him look better, but she's viewed by the entire Armenian community as a traitor to her people because she also wouldn't own up to the genocide against her own people. It'd be like if a German guy made a news show called "The Nazis", denied that the holocaust ever happened, then hired a Jewish co-host and pretended he wasn't racist/anti-Semitic cause he has a Jewish co-host.
wow thats crazy. i never liked him anyway.
He denied it for decades and very clearly only recently rescinded his claims due to backlash from viewers. His first article denying it was in 1991, he didn't rescind his statements that it was fake and a conspiracy until 2016, saying he doesn't know enough about the matter to make a definite answer. He doesn't fully admit that a genocide happened until 2017. He denied it for decades and even when he rescinded his statements he didn't admit he was wrong for another year afterwards. It was clear he didn't have a change of heart, he's doing it cause he can't possibly present himself as a progressive liberal while being a genocide denier.
Ana is also seen as a traitor, that's undeniable. There are plenty of videos from TYT public events before 2016 where Armenians showed up to try and get her to talk about Cenk's denial and instead of saying anything about it she always ignores them or starts arguing in Armenian or doing anything she can to avoid the topic.
Cenk denied it for decades and only recently made an insincere redaction of his statements. Ana has been enough of a figure that Armenians bothered to show up and demand justice and truth. These are easily verified points, and there's documentation of all of it.
Davvy, Armenians accusing Ana of being a traitor isn't an opinion of mine, there's literal videos of that. Cenk making claims that the Armenian Genocide was fake and a conspiracy as early as 1991 isn't my opinion, it's fact. He wrote multiple articles on that. When he rescinded his claims that it was fake in 2016 but didn't apologize, that wasn't my opinion, it's fact. He used the excuse that he didn't know enough to talk about it (even though he apparently knew enough to write multiple articles on it). Him waiting another year before finally admitting a genocide happened is also a fact, not opinion.
The only opinion I stated is that his acceptance of the Armenian Genocide is disingenuous, which given the factual circumstances isn't an absurd speculation. If anybody else in the same situation did the same thing, you'd have every right to be skeptical.
I'm not a big fan of Cenk, but I don't think that the entire network should be dismissed because he's a doofus. Cenk was probably raised to believe the Armenian Genocide never really happened, just like a lot of other Turks are. Most of the world is pretty much completely oblivious to it.
The network shouldn't be dismissed, but it should be rebranded if he honestly has had a change of heart. And most Turks were raised to believe it never happened, but not believing it happened and writing articles about how it didn't happen are two different things, one is passive the other is proactive. There's no harm in ignorance, but there's harm in spreading it. Other than that, I don't watch anymore TYT but I like the other hosts.
Coming back to this video cause the conflict is renewed
Wow....I thought I was informed about Nagorno. Why does American media paint Nagorno as the "bad guys" in this? Horrible.
Thank you for informing me. I'd like to help these people. Heading right now to find out where I can send them some funding, if they need. Poignant. Thank you so much.
Because Armenia is a Russian ally and Azerbaijan and Turkey aren't.
Also, the US 🇺🇸 doesn't want to upset the Turkish lobby, that's why they don't recognize the Greek and Armenian genocide of 1920. And then Hitler copied the turks
Once again I'm watching one of these videos completely astounded with tears in my eyes. This series is amazing, keep making it. I'm heading to patreon right now.
They should be digging for oil. If you find oil the Americans will be there to help in a jiffy.
Speaking out of your ass again Mogglin It's a bad habit
@@bobcat1690 who even are you and wtf do you mean again...?
I think his point is, If by "help" u mean occupying, disorienting, and thieving the oil, then you're correct. They will "help" the resources and money come to the 50 richest Americans ever. Then they'd leave the country with a power void to be filled by once American backed assholes that are going to blow up buses and subways. Lots of help.
You act like we’ll be there to help. We’ll be there to take it.
Mogglin they will take the oil, rape the women, experiment with their people, pay a couple of pennies and then ask you to thank them. This has happened too many times in my country
A beautiful yet jarring tribute to a wonderful people. I wish I could go hug them all and find ways to serve them. They deserve recognition, support, and peace. At the very least, thanks to you and your sacrifices in telling their story, they have found a place in my prayers. May God protect, restore, and redeem these beautiful souls.
thankyou for this video i never new about the attrocities these people faced or the hardships they went and are still going through thankyou for informing me
Great information guys I never knew anything about these wonderful people.i hope they reach acknowledgment from the rest of the world ASAP.👍
Fucc aknowledgment, i hope they reach peace. Alot of countries are recognized but still at war
Your the only person on Earth that doesn't know arminian people exist
Trouble is, this territory is not only a home for Armenians from times before the Azeri arrived, it is simultaneously a cradle of traditional Azeri culture. The common factor that keeps letting people down is the modern ideal of the nation state, the idea that each ethnic group must own a territory as contiguous as possible and establish their traditional speech as the national language, by force of violence if necessary. Why this is a good idea is never really specified, especially when so many lives have to be sacrificed for the sake of poets' dreams. Organized culture is no less adept than organized religion in carrying out acts of genocide.
So you're saying they should coexist?
Kazi Siddiqui Gotta love religion and nationalism. /s
Well said
What is the other side of the coin? Multi culturalism?
Fuck that!!!
Look at what happened to EU/USA/Canada due to enforced multi culturalism.
We are violent either way. There is no perfect outcome. We humans are violent and want to dominate, period.
So, what exactly happened to Canada, eh? Mind spelling it out?
Thank you for the wonderful video and great explanation of the issues facing Artsax. Very well presented in a short video
From this statement onward, I recognize the Artsakh as a Sovereign Nation.
@Mr Kayhan only if you also take my wife.
@@colinlarson9656 Lol he deleted his comment
@@thesaddestdude3575 indeed, right after taking my wife.
Amazing what the public school system doesn't teach.
I went to a private school and this was never mentioned. No talk of this in no school.
I ask my kids all the time, just what are they teaching you? Its amazing and shameful what has been removed from our schools and what has replaced it.
Western education of minors has always been indoctrination first, teaching second. U.S. educational system of mandatory Grade 1-8 education was implemented following the Prussian model in the latter half of the 19th century.
The Prussian system was designed to support industrial society: identify and prepare managers for higher educational attainment, prepare the rest how to be good industrial cogs and obedient soldiers. Just like ours today, though the goal of the indoctrination is no longer to create an efficient industrial populace.
Read the works of John Taylor Gatto to learn what education was, and what it should become.
Students in the US today can’t even say who were the belligerents in WWII, let alone WWI when the Armenian and Pontianak Greek Genocides.
Only adults have the attention span to appreciate this type of education.
People who call themselves civilized continue to deny the Armenian genocide. It's shameful. Armenians are beautiful people and I wish you the best.
Thanks for another awesome video Rare Earth!
Treat people based on the individuals they are and you will no longer have a "problem" with Armenians.
zorbas091 maybe dealing with Semetic people's for thousands of years made Armenians like Jews/Arabs. Armenians fought these Semites and Mongoloids for a few centuries as vassals to Byzantium. Too bad because they could be a more honourable bunch
I mean that's what happens when people define any bloody suppression of an ethnic group as genocide
@@davethewave5896 well no ones perfect.
@@davethewave5896 that may well be the case. One mans aggrieved rebels might be anothers terrorists. Its sad what people do to each other, and have done, since the dawn of history.
I'm learning so much from this channel. Thank you.
Thank you for making this video. Never heard of this conflict and now I feel so much wiser about such issues and these people. Hope they get their land some day.
As a greek i almost cried cause of this video
I am Vietnamese and I totally support Armenian people. Very nice, hard working and successful people.
Aww
Oh my lad look, the enemy has taken Cyprus
Fight turkey!
Why
I felt sad but not cried
I never knew about these people & their struggles . Thank you for telling their story .
With no country acknowleding them, it makes you wonder that an entire country with peoples living in it could be... hidden from the rest of the world..
Kunushi Knows I m fairly familiar with this story but the only reason I am is because I am good friends with an Armenian family. As a whole the story is mostly ignored because America and the rest of the world doesn't want to anger turkey. It really is a terrible story
With the recent events between armenia and azerbaijan I fear what these horrors repeat again. I really pray for peace in this region and soon a recognized Karabakh State.
Thank you so much
#ArtsakhStrong
Thank you
Independent , free Artsakh
🇦🇲
Gorbagor oldu status, cəhənnəmə getdi status 😌
Artsakh will only truly be gone when no one remembers it. As long as it lives within hearts there is hope.
WOW. My eyes are open now. Thank you for that. I'll be road tripping this late summer/early fall to the area. Get to knowvthe people, and spend some money while I take in that breathtaking landscape! Might want to send my M4 ahead with my climbing gear?!
I am Vietnamese and I totally support Armenian people. Very nice, hard working and successful people.
Im aussie, I feel your pain and armenians. My country helped america pillage your country and the world recognizes your soldiers as some of the best soldiers in the world. Im ashamed and proud to be aussie.
successful? I'd say we can argue on that point
Respect Armenians from your brother
Love ya all
Peace from: Macedonia
Recent subscriber... I appreciate your forthright delivery of content. Well done. Looking forward to discovering more of your work, even when it takes us to some dark places.
VERY interesting. I hadn't known this. I also was very impressed with the narrator/journalist's in-depth reporting
except for his shirt.
Now we have to do something for these peoples.
The old professor
@jean neill Oh, like your reply to me?
And completely one sided. Now thats journalism.....
This video brought a tear to my eye... I am not even close to being Armenian, but those people have suffered way too much..
Im blown away by such perfection in journalisim i just watched!Im dissapointed in myself because I take pride in just random knowledge of history and coultures of the world and man i didnt know anything about this and this area,of course I knew the small things but your amazing storytelling of the terrible history here opened my eyes!!!You have accomplished what all great journalists do you brought us here and placed us in there lives like we were living it to and i thsnk you for that,ill be paying alot more attention to these great people
Love it, love it, love it! Thank you for bringing this matter to light.
This video not only shows true journalism but also true teaching and geography. Congratulations. Got surprised with their writings. They are very similar to what I've been searching for. I'll share it so people be aware. Thank you for the hard work.
All i can say is DEEP the things you learn
How can we think about living on Mars, when we haven't solved this possessive attitude?
It's such a mess, that we should make a back up on Mars, because as great a ape as we are we would look dumb if we woke a morning with a asteroid incoming and we didn't maintain our level of technologie and we can't nuke it out of the way because "we planned to fix problem that have lasted million of years before making a backup"
I do think we should let them have there country I think they fought enought for it I think but let Elon do his job in making sure we don't go extinct before fixing that problem or at all (he his upgrading efficiency on rocket not burning fuel for burning fuel)
We are seven billion, you won't tell me we can't do 2 things at the same time
That's why we should leave. That way the colony can grow into a powerful planet and declare war on us or something and all humanity is united and at the same time culturally destroyed.
@@brynf4377 that's the synopsis of TITAN Fall, isn't it?
Because they are done with this shot hole and ready for the next. Ps we are not invited.
You cannot solve it, there is no solution. All feuds in the world are inter-connected to some degree, creating a large complex. We tend to see most damaged side innocent in those feuds, but in hard reality, being killed does not make you right or innocent. I do not disregard who died. I respect them because most of who died didn't have a choice. But that does not mean I support or respect why they died. In the end, if you think about it, we came all the way here with those feuds still ongoing. We will advance with those feuds and in the end, we will go extinct with those feuds.
This nature of human, this is both bless and curse of homo homo sapiens. The thing, being able to think, that fuels us, that advances us; but in the meantime, it also makes us kill each other. You cannot have one without the other one, because both share the same root.
Thank you for this video. Much appreciated!