Vložit
- čas přidán 5. 08. 2024
- Dr. Shantanu is someone who completed 5 years of BHMS before realizing it was a pseudoscience and doing his MBBS degree from scratch. Here's his advice.
Dr Shantanu: / @shantanuabhyankar3466
Support me at:
Buymeacoffee: buymeacoffee.com/scienceisdope
Patreon: / scienceisdope_
YT Membership: / @scienceisdope
UPI: scienceisdope@icici (QR Code available on www.scienceisdope.com/support )
Chapters
00:00 - Intro
04:25 - What was the course back then?
05:42 - What year was this?
06:16 - Why did you opt for this course?
08:10 - Thoughts while learning Homeopathy
12:45 - How alternative medicines "work"
13:21 - When did you first see a red flag?
15:54 - Why can't the modern medicine you learn in a homeopathy college be enough?
17:33 - Homeopathy degree. What next?
24:49 - Sex-Ratio. The Dark story.
28:03 - MBBS vs. BHMS
33:26 - Ayurveda & Nationalism
34:45 - Why is there a bridge course out of Homeopathy?
36:26 - There must be some logic behind Homeopathy
38:42 - The initial popularity of Homeopathy
40:26 - Options for alternative medicine graduates
43:17 - Modern Medicine can't treat thyroid issues?
45:21 - Anecdotal Evidence
47:27 - Indian Medical Students are becoming aware
48:24 - Lateral Entry
51:09 - Alternative medicine outside India
51:57 - Legality of practice
53:20 - Homeopathy can "cure"?
56:08 - Walnut for the brain & Ginseng for Virility
1:00:11 - Books for Skeptics
1:03:02 - The rising costs in medicine
1:04:36 - Convincing your parents
1:07:10 - Homeopathy in Germany
1:09:04 - Dr. Shantanu's youtube channel - Zábava
Homeopathy: proudly no side effects.
Rationalist: no main effect also.
Add fire emoji in the end it will make this more funny lmaoo
I realised homeopathy was a pseudoscience within the 1 month of joining the course. And i remember that entire class would disagree with me regarding it. For them i just become a guy who like to rebel , they did not care about the logic behind my argument. Jokes on them as i left the course after 1st year and got into MBBS. Currently doing my internship.
Good on you for having the time to comment on CZcams.
Happy for you, Nishit!
Great choice
Good for you bro
Now that’s what we call an epic comeback story
Sir i was a student of bams(2021-23) bt came to mbbs this yr due to same reason ,thanks for helping future students 😌from assam
You got MBBS?
Yes
@@dipanjandey6015 Can you please explain in detail why you left BAMS? Your response will be valuable for many
Because majority of the bams students will practice modern medicine,not ayurveda,
Secondly subjects like padartha vijnana and asthanga hridaya are really just part of scriptures and are not fully scientific
As a student of science stream who prepared for mbbs it is really tough to accept ayurveda as career,
you have to learn sanskrit and you will not find these subjects interesting
And one of the most important thing u will feel inferior compare to mbbs students as they will be studying only anatomy physio biochem but to a very understanding which u as bams student lack because u also have to study ayurvedic part,
if you lost mbbs seat by few marks,pls try again or u will regret taking bams in future🙂and it is my opinion 😅so take it with pinch of salt
@@dipanjandey6015 If you don't mind can you please answer the following points -
In your state (Assam) -
1) Given a choice between BDS and BAMS. Which one is preferred?
2) Are the BAMS doctor of Assam allowed to prescribe modern medicine? If yes, is it same like MBBS doctor or limitations are there?
3) What about the surgery part? What are the surgery that are allowed to perform in your state by BAMS graduates?
Please answer.
I argued hard against alternative medicine in my college just today, with special focus on homoeopathy (apparently they dont understand the basics of molecular interaction within the human body/organism).
Irony, it happened when we were discussing scientific temperament in class)
Lmfao
Rofl
Why do Ayurveda and Homeopathy medical degrees need students with science backgrounds when it does not follow the scientific method of questioning everything and seeking evidence. Since a lot of its concepts are based on beliefs, shouldn't it be part of theology?
Bcos part science, part pseudo-medicine mix
Because we are dumb when it comes to science
Key phrase: "There's this entire edifice..."
Two legends in one vdo.....
This guy shantanu is a phenomenal so passionate about medicine.....bloody inspiring
We would like to see a healthy debate between Dr. Shantanu, a homeopath turned allopath and Dr. Aadil Chimthanawala, an allopath specialist turned homeopath.
You are doing great pranav 👏👏
Thanks 🙏 for it
The biggest challenge is, how can we connect and understand the fact that there are people who have complete trust in such treatment. This population includes my parents, relatives, friends and a good chunk of scientists retired from DRDO, CFTRI etc.
He seems like a nice guy who got conned himself
Yup 👍🏻
Pranav this is the best vdo you have ever made, you cant better it ....impossible to improvise.....
Why is mike and audio fucked Up always ..,
Hey pranav, by any chance were you a teacher for byjus classes for jee and neet?
I was :) for JEE
@@scienceisdopeSo if this channel doesn't work for you
You can always start as a teacher like alakh Pandey
1:00:20 - Definitely read "Bad Science" by Ben Goldacre!
I was missing vimohs comment....and it came just now
Please make a video about bhangarh fort
51:07
I noticed tge pseudo science on the 1st day it self in induction programme of our cllg ( now a days they arrange a program in which they talk about how great ayurveda is )
Now i m in 2nd professional year and can't ran away from here !
Ya but in 1st prof year i runned away from my home , just beavuse i don't want to continue...i dis this beacuse i have no guts to say in front of them ...i returned home because my father getting High bp nd i feared that because of my actions my dad should fall ill ,
After that i told my problem nd why I don't eant to continue this course......they agreed but but here is the main problem
To leave that course in private ayurvedic College i have pay a bond fee that's is double the fee of all the 5 year
So i have to pay 7, 8 lakhs
And then i failed and continued my course 💔
Currently i m in 2 nd professional year
And i day by day is passing, i m feeling like ran away shalini...ran
Complete the course and leave the field or else try for NEET while continuing the course.
Hey why don't you invite people who left ayurveda, it will be helpful
Homoeopathy ko jalne wale us samai b te ab b he Homoeopathy ko jalne wale. Criticized to us samai b te aur ab b he.
59:36 ya exactly ayurveda believes that any thing which looks similar to our any body part will have effect on it
Example:( to increase muscle mass eat meat of xyz animals because our bodys meat or muscle is similar as sny animals meat )
Example 2 :( if you have less blood in your body , drink other animals blood its called "मांस रस"
legend man legend, doing mbbs after homeopathy...
Not doing, actually he completed the course and he is O&G specialist
@@neet6804 he didn't do mbbs you are saying
@@himanshuRamaani he isn't 'doing' MBBS, he 'completed' MBBS. That's what I want to say.
aree bhai 😂 that toh i know, grammar galat kar dia maine wanted to say 'did the mbbs after completing homeopathy'
Chapters would be Amazing
Done!
Pranav ......and shantanu ...... are jai and viru
He lives in a fools paradise and interviewer seems to be in the same boat.god bless thee ignorant souls.
You are the ignorant one here
Homoeopathy is best system of medicine
Yes ! Like Islam is the best religion in the. world 😂
@@coral6601 Yup, Analogy wise there's honestly not much difference.
@@N0Xa880iUL dats the point
@@atheanonymous5868 Yes, ik that my comment is redundant, like most comments on CZcams.
Homeopathy: proudly no side effects .
Logic: honestly no effect also.