Justice MR Shah on collegium, PM Modi before retirement
Vložit
- čas přidán 13. 05. 2023
- Justice Mukeshkumar Rasikbhai Shah is perhaps one of the very few judges of the Supreme Court who witnessed the top court or entered one of its courtrooms only after being elevated as a Judge of the apex court.
Justice Shah who demits office tomorrow, has authored close to 712 judgments, making him the judge who has delivered the highest number of verdicts in their limited tenure.
However Justice Shah in this freewheeling interview with Bar & Bench’s Debayan Roy speaks on why he thinks heated exchanges in courtrooms are often a deliberate act on part of a counsel to achieve an oblique motive, to how there has been no deliberate delay on part of the government to clear judges names.
Stay Connected:
► Download the Bar & Bench App: onelink.to/t9agbr...
► Like us on Facebook: / barandbench. .
► Follow us on Twitter: / barandbench. .
► Follow us on Instagram: / barandbench. .
► Email: Info@barandbench.com
Hon'ble Justice MR Shah delivered very kind and good words. He is very polite humble and practical. May God bless him
Bar and Bench is doing a praiseworthy job! 👍
Collegium System adopted by Supreme Court must be scrapped now without further delay by Modi Govt!!! Let these Judges comes through competition and not through Collegium System!!!
Yeah lets make a system were the government can choose the judges and can start doing anything
@@sreeharie821
Then what's these Collegium Judges are doing now ?? They are not running Agenda of Anti National Elements???
No where in the World , Judges appoint themselves and in turn ensure their family members are also well placed in their evo system !!!
We, the citizens of this Nation, want judicial reforms and accountability. Let us have a referendum on those issues.
Lovely interview. Very Humble Judge. May God bless him.
Thank you so much Lordship.
From last 5 years.... without life partner....and now wanted to serve his parents 💓......... always be appreciated......sir and authority, both of you are mind-blowing.......i wanted to meet you sir.......
Thank you once again
BUT THE COURTS HAVE NO JUDGES FOR YEARS AND THE PENDENCY IS VERY VERY LARGE WITHOUT SOLUTION.
He is an inspiration Judge. Super Sir.
Nice to see & hear inner hearts of honourable Justice who is retiring.The experience of these type of genius persons must be utilized for our country.
Very useful interview.
Very Nice Interview 🙏💖
One of the worst judges after retired Justice Gogoi
We need such judjes in supreme court.
Nice interview 🙏
.
Life is an echo
.
.
15:00... beautiful
.
Justice should not only be done but appear to have been done.may goddess give him fullstrenghth in coming years
Very nice interview
Justice M R Sha he is a good human being
🙏❤🙏....
There is a need to make changes in the Indian legal system in that the Supreme Court judges should have a security of tenour and they should not be compelled to retire when they reach a certain age. The reason is that it is difficult to replace such experienced judges like Justice MR Shah.
A judge can be known by the judgements he delivers, not by the ways he speaks,nd philosophy he shows on media.
Sometimes the judgements given by such polite judges out of prejudice affects the life of many innocents.
And keeps on affecting when their judgements are used as citations.
सेवानिवृत्त दिल्ली हाईकोर्ट के चीफ जस्टिस एपी शाह भी बहुत ही बेहतरीन इंसान थे।
Politicians are appointed by people, IAS are appointed after completing exam and interview. How are judges appointed? Are they clearing any entrance exams for judge-ship?
Judges are appointed base on multi-recommendation by the bench....sometime the bar also involved .. Recommendation are base on the merit of condidates who are practicing in the courts of these judges.
Uncle judge syndrome.
"A model and a hero" How people on high pedestal of judicial chair such sweeping praises to political executives... Why should you publicly loud in praising? What is the background thought process?
Which law allows a SC judge to be airlifted at taxpayer cost from Himachal to Delhi
😮
He appears more a theocratic judge.what is required of a good judge is reading, knowledge of law and jurisprudence. He needs empathy , compassion sense of fairness , justice and passion for truth. People don't have faith in judicial system whe it take 15 to 20 years for conviction or exoneration. The justice system has no social balance, the system is dominated by manuvads.
Hindi medium ke Judge sahab Hindi mein interview Dena chahiye...Jis bhasha mein bolein, bhasha sahi honi chahiye😊
He is Gujarati by native language...
Lies lies lies! I couldn't watch more than 5 minutes of the interview; it was unbearable.
Bail will be granted according to perception where the law gone so according to judge the law can be change while bail hearing or equating someone
collegium system is the best process to achieve the soul purpose of Article 50 of the Indian constitution. separation of power is the ideal thing that our constitution has given to achieve the faith of the people. and as Consultation mentioned in Art. 124 has to be read as Concurrence.
Collegium system is one of many sources of corruption country is facing. I means SC literally become a chacha bhatija court without even iota of responsibility for the common man who actually feed these mfs.
He is role model for judges
He has enhanced the credibility and reputation of Judiciary
Ye interview sun kar judiciary mein vishwas😢
How was HH Verma spared? Because of someone’s dar
God forbid, how did he write the judgments through all the years in SC 😮😮. he speaks aloud of disposal rates, his judgements speaks of dictatorial tendencies supporting high handedness of state against common man.
If there was no collegium, then Congress would have made Rahul Gandhi as judge, and BJP would have made Jay Shah as Cheif Justice.
I accept that collegium is not perfect, but those who know the history of judiciary should not speak against it.
You appears to be more conscious
Judge govt ke critic ni hai inki baaton se lg gya
Gogai Gang ka yoddha...and a true Bhakt
Their poor English taken interview too long,
A merit based appointment should be bought as soon as possible.
mr.loya judge CBI 100 CRORE PAYMENT HOW TO MAKE MONEY
Very poor English language,
Really..!! What level of English do you speak that you feel you are entitled to criticise Justice Shah's English language skills..
Appointment of judges are not the basis of merit but recommendation that'reason not just behind this poor English but also poor judgment delivered by various judge.
@@kvpullu0137 well your english grammer skill is worse..At least Justice Shah speaks Proper English. And English not being his native language he can be forgiven his Indian accent .As far as recommendation and judgement of cases are concerned, that is subjective ..everybody has their own point of view and no one Point of. View is correct
Sir why are you making a common man fool? Everyone knows you are doing nothing for the common man. Not a signal common can afford SC advocates, you are biased towards money 🤑 people as you not allow common man.
Give me a single judgement which you pass for the common man (Don't tell it's affect the common man 😂 show me petition added by common man and you listen to him)
Hon'ble Justice MR Shah delivered very kind and good words. He is very polite humble and practical. May God bless him