Former FBI Agent Explains How to Detect Lying & Deception | Tradecraft | WIRED
Vložit
- čas přidán 26. 01. 2020
- There are a number of myths about detecting deception. Fidgeting, looking away, touching your mouth, all of these things are commonly thought to be practices that indicate deception. Jim Clemente, former Supervisory Special Agent for the FBI, explains why that isn't always the case and how people like him can decipher what these indicators really mean.
Clemente is a retired FBI criminal profiler, and co-host of "Real Crime Profile," a true crime podcast distributed by Wondery. For more information about his career, go to www.jimclemente.com, or follow him on twitter at / jimclemente
To learn more about the DC Sniper case check out the Audible Original Series ‘Call Me God’ on Audible: www.www.audible.com/p...
Still haven’t subscribed to WIRED on CZcams? ►► wrd.cm/15fP7B7
Listen to the Get WIRED podcast ►► link.chtbl.com/wired-ytc-desc
Get more incredible stories on science and tech with our daily newsletter: wrd.cm/DailyYT
Also, check out the free WIRED channel on Roku, Apple TV, Amazon Fire TV, and Android TV. Here you can find your favorite WIRED shows and new episodes of our latest hit series Tradecraft.
ABOUT WIRED
WIRED is where tomorrow is realized. Through thought-provoking stories and videos, WIRED explores the future of business, innovation, and culture.
Former FBI Agent Explains How to Detect Lying & Deception | Tradecraft | WIRED - Zábava
FBI: "Did you do it?"
*does handstand*
FBI: "We got 'em."
lmao!!!
"I don´t know partner, something about her just doesn´t seem right.......maybe it´s the way she´s standing on her head or........I don´t know. Guess we´ll just have to let her go."
🤣🤣🤣
Lmaooooo
Hahahahahaha
Tip #1: Don’t do a handstand in an interrogation room after murdering your boyfriend.
😂😂😂😂
Someone making notes then? 😜
But standing on one leg and barking like a dog...absolutely okay.
Just don’t murder your boyfriend 😆
Life Outside Fayston Childhood Bullshot He World Don't Think Be Sean
My father was a federal investigator for 30 years, he always said that the best liars were the investigators themselves. A good interrogator weaves a complex pattern of lies and truths, keeps track of them, and then used the ensuing confusion to trap the person being investigated. Here's the best tip; don't talk to investigators without your lawyer being present, ever!!!
You have the right to remain silent. ANYTHING you say CAN and WILL be used against you!
Yeah I’ve been interrogated before and for someone who easily be manipulated can also be brainwashed to believing a false narrative. Especially if the person is in a flight and fright mode. Confusion at its best.
Your dad must be scary you are pretty cool for the info
this tell us laywers are as good as investigators in lying, correct?
FACTS
15 years ago one of my 3 kids pooped on top of the toilet seat and left the evidence. To this day, they all categorically deny any guilt. I’m gonna re-open the investigation, thanks.
😂😂😂😂😂
It was ME! I DID IT!
Did you keep any DNA.
😂😂😂😂😂
Reopening a case is a crapshoot!
Fun fact: He is not actually sitting in a chair. He is just fantastically good at holding a squat position
😂😂
You killing me 😭😭😭
I laughed out loud! Where are the chair legs?
SophiaOnEarth
There’s no chair legs because there’s no chair.
Matrix detected
You know someone is lying when:
1. His palm are sweaty
2. Knees weak
3. Arms are heavy
4. There's vomit on his sweater already
5.Mom's spaghetti
6.He's nervous,
7.But on the surface he looks
8.Calm and ready
@Eric Cuevas smdh!
But he keep on fogetting what the agent wrote down
the whole crowd goes so loud
He opens his mouth
but the words won't come out
@Eric Cuevas Tupac?
The fact that people continue to talk without a lawyer is mind boggling.
Exactly. Never, ever talk to the cops without an attorney. Cops are professional interrogators.
if they are detained and they don't have an attorney they can afford, they would have to wait for one provided which can take weeks. Some of these people think they can defend themselves and are desperate enough to leave prison as soon as possible because of a "fight or flight" response.
Why so the investigator can instantly say that you're guilty because you asked for a lawyer
Any person who has clear understanding with law enforcement knows they cannot keep you for more than 72 hours if they don't plan to book you or plan to press charges that's the beautiful thing about due process when they question you like they do in this video they're just trying to scare you because they want you to slip up that's how you get Liars to expose themselves
@@simonjack9699 Not even remotely how the law works. The investigator can think anything he wants & it doesn't matter. The FACT is that every word you say "can and will be used AGAINST you" - it cannot help you. So never talk to the cops.
Not even a fish would get caught if it just kept its mouth shut.
This is why I frequently do headstands during normal conversation. Sets the baseline. Can’t use it against me when I’m lying if I’m always doing it. /murders boyfriend
Lmao
Clever
💀 🤣
LOL
Voice of reason: “it’s all good, just act normal”
*_does a handstand_*
yoga
or sit on the floor and flip your whole head back abruptly
So anyone itching or scratching, or having any aches in the body and moving weirdly, or anyone who generally seems nervous due to pressure or authority, or has anxiety issues. Those are all your suspects🤣. This video is stupid.
@@cozmicarchitect How would you do it?
LOL
Imagine this guys children lying about their grades to him...
Biggie4 not possible 💀💀
Not impossible
😹😹😹
That's will not happen bro...
Niet!
She / he will do it ...
Whether it is because at a young age, he will try to feel the limits that are attributed to him or because in adolescence, he will question these famous limits and the whole world if necessary ... But ...
He will learn either by himself or even because with pedagogy I will let him believe in his lie ...
Either otherwise than each action, see words can have more or less devastating consequences ...
His children will be the best liars in the world
you know someone is lying when they do a handstand randomly in the middle of a room
its an example of stress release.
Namaste LOL!
I just assume everyone is lying. Rarely disappointed.
Hahaha
Yep. Same here dude.
So you just lied about everyone lying?
@@happytomato1135 well you’d be lying if you said you’re asking an intelligent question.
"Everyone lies." - me (and possibly Dr. House but mostly me)
I just wanna know which of my colleagues ate my croissant.
@Γιάννης Πετρόπουλος 🤣
Legend xD
😅😅😅😅
Lmfaoo
Look for the crumbs on their shirt...
This FBI guy looks like he’s sitting in the midair without a chair under him.
Cannot unsee!!
Lol you right...its the black hes wearing.
Ikr i saw that when i first saw him xd
He's just squatting haha
He’s sitting? I thought maybe his last name was squarepants and that was just thigh gap.
If you skip to 6:44 in the video, you’ll hear him say “if your writing something down while someone is talking to you, you can’t actively listen”. That’s so profound because it basically summarizes the school system and how they make it hard for us to understand.
I strongly agree. One tip that I suggest is writing down notes while the teacher is silent or pauses to do something.
@@kuromii2693 that’s almost never for me 💀 and they don’t write down everything they said. We have to note, listen and learn at the same time at a fast speed.
THIS.
I think this is why I performed well on tests and would recall the teacher actually saying the answer.
I could write notes well without looking down at my paper. I didn't worry about handwriting either. I would basically stay eyes locked on the teacher, trying to listen, and would just mindlessly copy and let my hand do its thing.
It felt like I devoted 1/3 of my attention to the actual note taking part, but 2/3 to just watching/listening to the teacher.
Even with this no look down method, I would just keep up. The amount of kids who would say, hold on! I'm still writing, as the teacher moved on....was a lot and worrying.
Notes are great for REVIEWING later but not active learning.
I always appreciated the few teachers who basically gave out printed notes, with a few fill in the blanks that they filled in with us.
Nice remark😂
The fact you used the wrong "your" really proves your point.
He fidgeted, he's guilty.
He showed no emotion, he's guilty.
He's nervous, he's guilty.
He's not nervous, he's guilty.
The real reason he is a expert and even got into the fbi is religion and ethnisity period.
@@billmaxwell3636 its really easy to sit in hindsight and point to this and that as the giveaway.. when in fact most of the time it would be very difficult unless one knew the person over time. the bill clinton segment is a good example. I bet literally no one in the world could tell he was lying if they saw that `performance` live and didn`t know the guy well
@@pettersaethre Yeah, people are complicated, but also predictable. But not everyone.
he stating here that everyone has different mannerisms. But you have to look at them as a whole. If they come in looking at everyone, making eye contact, feeling confident, but then suddenly start looking away when being asked questions, and stuttering, that's the nerves taking control trying to deflect truthful answering. And yet someone the opposite, who is meekish and looks away constantly at first but then remains absolutely still and changes their behavior during specific questioning is also hiding something.
This is the same sht that tsa and homeland goes by in airports.Its custom made nonsence mandates for totaly incompatant tsa and homeland and other currupt pisano leprickcon daycare centers
Man, I'm so anxious, I get nervous when I'm telling the truth
police always look uncomfortable around me because I am really anxious no matter what 🧐
Same
I feel. Sometimes I'll get nervous because I think the person I'm going to talk to is going to think I'm lying. So I get so nervous and uncomfortable that I seem like I might be lying even though I'm telling the truth.
I got so nervous during a conversation with a lawyer about divorce, that I could not tell where I was living. I didn't know my address I swear to god. He was taking notes and recording the whole thing and that made me get anxious. I can't imagine being interviewed by the FBI, I woundn't be able to remember my name
In that case, that would be your baseline. The moment you stop being nervous and anxious, that's when they'd take note of you. The whole point of interrogation is to find a way to read you so when you're acting "out of character" that's when they'd know that they're on the right track.
Me: *breathes*
FBI: You’re lying.
True lol 😂
Hahahahaha
My favorite CZcams comment ever! I laughed out loud, thank you
Scott Scot lol I’ll be here all week....or I guess all month.
Basically eh🤦♂️
As a Lawyer, don't EVER take a polygraph test. There is no such thing as a "lie detector". Hence, they're not even allowed in court.
I completely agree, could you elaborate more for those of us with less knowledge?? Thanks!
Exactly
So you're telling me I'll be arrested as soon as I step into the room.
Pretty much condemned by being invited for the interview. Makes no sense, everything equals lying.
Ladies and gentlemen. We got him.
People who live with anxiety always feel guilty about everything and act accordingly.
Wait I just replied to someone else’s comment talking about how I do this. I explained it differently but that almost works bettet
Yes, but that's consistent in their behaviour. It won't raise red flags. It's rapid behavioural shifts that indicate deception. Did you comprehend what the video was saying?
Fun fact: He is not actually sitting in a chair. He is just fantastically good at holding a squat position
Yup
Anxious people feel survivor's guilt about everything, so they feel guilty about things they've never even done or had anything to do with, so you can't read too much into this stuff it can only be used as indicators to make speculations.
that girl who did a handstand out of nowhere 😂💀
shes a murderer
Completly random😂
Jodi Azaria...she killed her ex boyfriend cause he dumped her.
@@landofthelivingskies3318 Arias*
I was like what the😂😂
My ex lied about hitting on certain women and I could always tell because he would say something like I don't even talk to "that person" when we had been using their name the whole time and that refusal to say it trying to distance himself and make them seem like a stranger always gave it away.
How did you prove he was lying?
Or thingy 😂 i heard that
You are a true fan of JCS if you recognise those people being interrogated in the introduction.
JSC is the best!
YUP
The Casey Anthony one was just a whole lot of "was the Jury completely brainless, blind, and deaf during the trial?"
sellcyanidecrackdfposdifjudsipof
Eyyy! I rep JSC community. Funniest comments, hands down.
Plot Twist: The former FBI agent is lying to us the entire time.
Dun dun DUNNN
Gabriel Mercer oh god, That’s right. He fidget with he’s hand all the time!
Yeah fr. Wait 🙄😬
Talks on and on. Lol 😂
I actually burst out laughing 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
When i clicked on this video i wanted to learn how to spot a liar. But 1 minute in my brain switched me into "how do i lie" mode. xD
Ok den
4:21
me, a person who says "like" 24 times in a single sentence: 👉👈👀
I can see how a lot of this can make sense and could lead to a discovery of lies, but I also can see how these same things could lead to an innocent person being falsely accused.
More than likely, BOTH.
Mental note... Don't do handstands when being interrogated.
the guy has a unique face and should be in a movie
he should be but unfortunately he's your on-line FBI agent investigating you but he smiled when you wrote this since he's watching you via your camera.
@@HeliPadUSA Seems a nice enough fellow so I don't mind
Not to mention his voice.
He Position Be In 37 Gone Years Come Back He Share It With You He Shitteed You He Grimmy Too Black Hood
Looks like a combination of Adrien Brody and Voldermort
“If you’re writing something down when somebody’s talking to you, you can’t actively listen”
Wait so does that mean notetaking in class is ineffective?
He was meant that because he was taking notes he had no clue on what the guy's body movement was and did not focus on his tails!
honestly when i notetake in class i hace no idea whats going on 😀
Actually yes. Get Recorder.
Yeah that's why good teachers that I had let us copy the writings on the board first before discussing or gives the ppt before or after classes so no need for note taking in class.
Yes
5:30 As someone who does music as their main hobby, hearing “their voice may go up a few octaves” in the context of regular conversation triggered *my* fight or flight response lol
"You're acting very nervous in this police interrogation that could be a sign of deception"
It seems a lot of people are missing a key point that the clip emphasizes over and over. Your behavior is not an absolute, it’s relative. That is why they take your baseline - an assessment of how you act when not lying but while being questioned. So if you are fidgety and continue to be fidgety in the same way, that doesn’t raise alarms. If you can’t make eye contact even when answering your question, then they won’t hold that against you. It’s unnatural changes in your behavior they are looking for, and they compare you to you, not some imaginary “innocent” person.
EDIT: wow 3000 likes, 0 dislikes and 26 replies. Thanks everyone!
Thank u for explaining things so simply. I hope it helped these idgits out there.
That was a great way to put it
Thanks! I was thinking I'm done for if I ever get interviewed. I have bad anxiety...I pick at my fingers and I dont like eye contact for long periods of time
Thanks
@R Cruz 100% with you there.
Criminals: "Write that down! WRITE THAT DOWN!!1!!"
I am SO confused: Why do I have so many fans on CZcams even though I am the unprettiest CZcamsr WORLDWIDE? Thank you for caring, dear krabs
@@AxxLAfriku?
no no you write that down, i need to listen
Name checks out
!*
Body language, and deception detection is something that I’ve been drawn to my whole life. This stuff is so cool.
Just being in an interrogation, with “Interrogators”, is enough to make anyone nervous. After all, you can be falsely accused, or just hear them making leading suggestions and you wonder where the heck this is going. No fun.
I don't know about the stress one. If i got falsely accused of something, i'd be stressed...
if you're always stressed during the whole interrogation, even when asking your name, then they won't think it as suspicious
@@magk2524 Ehh that depends... Sadly there are many false-positive endings
THIS like when my mom accuses me of doing anything I literally get so angry I cant control it
@@magk2524 If they ask a question that the guilty would get nervous at, and you know it, you'll reason that they really think it was you (or else why would they ask the question?). You'll start wondering what incorrect evidence they have on you, and then you'll be nervous too, innocent or not, because you know your answer will make or break your defense.
Im always stressed near law enforcement cause they cannot be trusted
So as a socially awkward person I am constantly lying in the eyes of the FBI. That's nice.
Arai LMAO
literally everything this guy said in the video r normal behaviors that everyone does
You're just nervous
Arai Realshit though
He did mention that you have to figure out what someone's "normal" is before any of that is useful.
Not that I have any confidence police will remember that at the time of interviewing.
In the immortal words of George Constanza, "It's not a lie if you believe it."
i could hear this guy analyse stuff for dayssss, his voice is so soothing and he explains things so thoroughly
please have Jim backkk
15 seasons of criminal minds has brought me here.
Same HAHA
SAME lmao
15 seasons of NCIS did it for me 😂
Same i missed that showwwwwww Hotch and Prentiss my faves ever!
SAME
*Wired:* "How to detect lies and deception?"
*My mind:* "Imma watch this so I can lie perfectly if FBI caught me in future. Like if my life depends on it. "
Thought the same but then delved one level deep and realise that when we try to apply what we know we are focusing so much of our energy observing our own behaviour that we might not focus very well on the questions or even our responses to them. This will be revealed in a thorough video analysis or possibly by the interrogator as well. You actually need a lot of practice. I suggest recurring petty theft to get yourself trained.
Disclaimer: I'm just joking around. Added for legal purposes 🤣🤣🤣
@@TusharSrivastava-raziel121 you sure have free time to type. Or just copy pasta.
@gir489 I know ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
@@justamanofculture12 it's night time here in India. And yeah, I kinda allocate it to my CZcams time. Lol 🙂✌️
Yet every single one of these criminals had the right TO REMAIN SILENT, they all thought they could out smart the law...lol.
Once you're suspected, you can't be innocent in someone's eyes, regardless of your body language, your honesty, you won't be seen as innocent.
All of your actions would be deemed as deception.
I love watching these so I can learn how to act properly when I'm lying and deceiving
Who does a handstand in such a situation ?!😂
she really brought it upon herself lmaooo
Lmao exactly i laughed so hard watching that and how did she not know that room would be wired with camera
Jodi. That’s who lol
A sociopath 😂😂
Jessica Day a person who is crazy enough to commit the crime in the first place
Me seeing a child doing a handstand: That child is lying
My friend: About what?
Me: I don’t know.
*Kicks the child in the gut while he's still upside down*
FBI: LIAR!
9
ABOUT EVERYTHING!
Lying about sumpthin', I'm sure of it!
@@User2jn I just visualised it and it was gold .
The fact that we are watching this to become more conscious about our and other body language gives me a shiver!
Jodi: you got this Jodi just act normal…
*Proceeds to do a wall assisted handstand*
Jodi: yep, cool as a cucumber..
"His palm is sweaty
Knees weak, arms are heavy"
Former FBI agent: *HE'S LYING*
@Freddy Brainy nooooooooo
Goddamit
--nervous, but on the surface he looks calm and ready
@@checkle1
Yessss
😂😂😂
So basically anyway you act or talk when you are under stress is a sign that you are lying. Anyone questioned by the police will be under stress. They could also make mistakes the police will decide as lying. All this video tells me is keep your mouth shut and do not talk to the police without a lawyer present. Which of course would also tell the police you are guilty. However, at least you have a lawyer to help you.
Police can think whatever they want but at the end of the day the lawyer is there to keep the police in check and make sure they can’t intimidate you or try to get a false confession
Not talking without a lawyer isn’t an admission of guilt, it’s a person using their right to remain silent
@@Kilborns How about pleading the fifth in a court?
All these deception indicators are to focus on specific details and find out the logical errors in someones story. Ofcourse everyone will be stressed but innocent people wont have holes in their story when asked about more details.
@@FleetTech97
U are completely correct
“Often times when a person is engaging in deception, they may make eye contact, cough, shift their weight, or even or in some scenarios, breathe.”
This video is amazing and you do a phenomenal job explaining these things. Thank you for doing this.🙂
Remember the immortal words of George Costanza: "It's not a lie if you believe it."
Living a clean life and staying out of trouble is highly underrated
Lol @@lesterdiamond6190
I think that is why the lie detector test is invalid.
I guess this means I'm not TRULY a man, yet? Watch Melissa explain this weird rite of passage >>> czcams.com/video/lRAfoxMuVn8/video.html
in a way yeah
"Stress can indicate deception" I'd never lie to the police but if I was stuck in one of those rooms I'd be STRESSED TF OUT regardless lol
In case it ever comes up (and this includes questioning, not only arrest), exercise your right to silence. Say that you will not speak to them without an attorney. It can only help you, and it might save you!
Scott Charney lmao i’ve seen ur comments so much are u a lawyer or something
@@HT-pl8du No; while I am trained as a paralegal, that's beside the point. I'm just somebody who knows how important it is not to talk to the police! It's helped me and countless people I know, and here's a law professor explaining it to you in a lecture that went viral: czcams.com/video/d-7o9xYp7eE/video.html
Lots of sociopaths or entitled types would behave casually though guilty. Sometimes they arrest innocent people who I am sure are terrified. Some people are accused of crimes when reporting a crime how scary is that?
@@AnnaLVajda All of that can be avoided by not talking to the police without an attorney present.
He's so good. I need more videos with him
Detecting a lie seems so difficult bc a lot of the behaviors he points out could be interpreted as having other reasons, like nervousness, conveying firmness, etc.
I need a whole netfiix series about this
Mindhunter has some elements about deception
Ther already was a show about this; that well has been tapped.
@Lorena Zampini only like 2 seasons
he’s the creator of criminal minds :)
Christine Marie Netflix doesn’t have that show in my country 😫
Never trust someone who can float
Also, if they can't look you in the eye when you are conversing with them.
Always trust int
Yeah, that's why I only trust noble gases.
Or someone that cranks out a spontaneous headstand
@@justamanofculture12 Depends, int cant do negative numbers, so long is the way to go
I love his voice, I can just listen to him all day talking about anything.
I’m glad he mentioned the difference between hearing and listening. I remember learning this early on when I was in college. Also, the analysis of Nixon’s and Clinton’s statements was very interesting.
This FBI guy is so chill, and the way he talks, he seems to be a good teacher/mentor
He gives off Veteran vibes.
It seems a lot like music to me. Noticing nuances, tempo increases, and more.
he actually has a podcast with laura richards and lisa z. it’s really good!
Guy: fidgeting in your chair is a sign of deception
Me: *laughs in ADHD*
Kisa Yep, with my ADHD, I would definitely be considered guilty for everything
But if you had adhd you’d be fidgeting all the time, even when they’re just asking you your name, if fidgety is your norm surely they would take that into account
angeline808 ik!!
ZaraBee28 no. I don’t forget every second, but at random unexpected times, especially if the questions require me to think. The adrenaline just takes over lol. And I look around a lot because I’m always thinking of things😂
Lyrically Lyrical but you wouldn’t have specific deception leakage if you aren’t outright lying if they start asking you, idk, “have you ever been to bobs house?” & you’ve never been there, you might be thinking, “do they think I were there?” & look shifty but your answer would be honest so I’d like to think they’d pick up on that, plus would also have pre knowledge of the suspect having ADHD
Sum:
Understand baseline Behavior > Notice when things get Different.
overall:
+ Digging Deeper into details/timelines
+ full detailed awareness of them (as third person)
So basically if your body has any natural movement like a normal human being, you’re being deceptive
its the other way
Body language is BS. There's so many different reasons a person could do anything that it's stupid to think it means something. Since lock downs became a thing and zoom calls are a daily occourance I've discovered how much of a twitchy hand talker I am. I mean it's constant, I can't stop doing it. I do it when I'm lying, I do it while I'm telling the truth. But if I got in trouble and some cop or FBI agent that thinks I'm guilty of something watched me they would say all my moving around and scratching my head and twitchy movements were because I'm lying. When in fact I'm just a twitchy dude.
I guess you didn’t pay attention to the video
FBI agent : *moving his hands while talking, looks into the different side of the camera and rises his voice in some part of the sentence*
Me : hold up hold up 🤚🏼🧐
Lmao😂😂
Video: *explains usefull stuff*
Comments: He IS NoT SiTTiNg oN a cHAiR!
🤣🤣🤣
What if I told you........ there is no chair!
Simple brained humans ...
the chair and pants aren’t well lit, and dark in color. 😶
There is a Chair it's Just Black sk it Matches His Clothes so it looks Like he isn't Sitting on Anything
My question is, what if a suspect has an anxiety disorder or feel anxious even if you are telling the truth bc you have 2 cops cornering you in a room who are telling you that you did something unlawful, when you could be honest the whole time, but being trapped in a small room with cops, no matter how innocent you are, would still invoke anxiety and shaking
FBI: takes in a bodybuilder
(Dose hand stand )
FBI: We got Him
As someone who is already a little “fidgety” when sitting for more than a few minutes and watches way too many true crime docs about people who were wrongfully convicted, this video makes me nervous 😬 I know I would be extremely on edge being questioned by authorities even if I was 100% innocent.
(edit: grammar)
Same! Like I already have terrible anxiety and trouble w eye contact normally, I would be terrified if I’d was interrogated
Always get a lawyer
they ask background questions to get some idea of your "normal" behavior. that's what he meant when he said "After we've normed an individual". They know people will be nervous, and they have strategies to account for that.
But I doubt you would not be able to answer Dem questions.
I would think groups that are often targeted by police or wrongfully convicted would be especially nervous, so yeah, how are they accounting for that, if at all.
I wonder how these methods would hold up against a pathological liar , a manic , a genius or all three
Unless you admit you did it, interrogation is the "we'll keep him/her as a suspect o nothing to worry about" start point. Looking guilty is not enough to lock you but it's enough to keep you in their list.
so like Dr Hannibal Lecter then?
yea a smart and confident person that knows laws and his rights kinda hard to fall for this no?
what’s a manic to you?
I'm a diagnosed bipolar and the thing about when we're manic is that we pretty much have no filter. It's like being drunk or high for four months straight. Like drunk people, we're more honest when we're manic because being manic is like being drunk. My point is, bipolar people are unlikely to lie when they're manic. I don't remember lying much at all when I've been manic. Being manic is like being injected with truth serum. I have admitted many truths that I held inside for years whenever I've been manic.
Just wow. Lots of information here and very helpful.
This man is point out every possible moment we do when we lieing not even staying still is an exception
I'm a person with anxiety and I fidget a lot when I'm being questioned by any kind of authority even when I know I am telling the truth. I just get really anxious so.....
Then they wouldn’t have a reason to believe you are lying if that’s your normal...
Same...
But if they dont know its ur normal they see it as deception and dont believe its ur norm .. u kno ppl ur tryin to get to kno or them trtin tolearn u and they judge u b4 they kno u and stop talkin or dont chose not to believe u even tho ur tellin the truth.
@@amberturnage6184 they’re trained to be able to discern the difference. Like Mel commented above, they’re not going to suspect if you’re anxious or nervous or wtv the case all throughout the interview. They’re more looking for a change in behavior: if they notice you’re fidgeting the whole time rather than only fidgeting when being asked something regarding the crime, they might not raise an eyebrow.
@@amberturnage6184 I don’t they think gonna drag u in the room and interrogate you out of the blue. Lol. I mean if u have a history of struggling with social anxiety, they are gonna take that into account prior to investigating you. Plus they do have medical examination
"When lying their voice goes up a couple of octaves??" Either they question Mariah Carey 3 days a week or the term octave is being used a bit loosely.
probably Mariah are being questioned on a daily basis hahaha
This can be used on wild n out. Reworded to say nick cheated
My thoughts exactly lmao
Paul Camus 😂 Right?! 🍑💨
Hahahahahahahahahaahahahahahahahaha
When anyone starts out answering you with, "Honestly" or "To be honest..." or "To tell you the truth..." it's a lie! 💯
I love this area of study I'm pairing it with my psychology degree. So thankful for these videos 👊🔥📚🧠
FBI: We’ll be back
The girl: Understandable, meanwhile I’ll do a handstand...
Fun fact: he was a writer on criminal minds and even acted in a couple episodes!
Do you know which episodes?
it was a few! he made cameos in ones that he wrote/ helped write. Season 5 in “Risky Business” he was an ER receptionist. In season 11 episode “Badge and a gun” he was a former FBI Agent named Ed. there were other epsiodes but these ones i remember.
@@eramsyed3135 man..I’m barely in the beginning of season 2 lol. I must be patient. Lol
you guys are nerds!
@@rahmatismail9818 No u
This guy is good. He said pretty much exactly what he said a year and a half ago the first time I watched this.
He's consistent.
Well alot of these nervous symptons i can imagine also show up if youre not lying, because you are afraid they still think youre guilty or for some reason convict you even though youre innocent. i guess that causes stress, nervousness and adrenaline also.
Which is why you baseline first, ask questions they have no reason to lie about or to be stressed about, then you look for changes. Why did their body language change? Why did they add qualifiers to this answer but not the others? Why did they use a non-contracted denial for this answer but not the others? Etc..
100% someone's girl is watching this about to interrogate tf out her boyfriend
Don’t expose me like that bruh 😔
LMAOO that's what I'm preparing for..
Yupppp🤷🏾♀️PERIODDDDD
Funny af
More like crush haha
I’m so bad at detecting deception. This is very helpful. I know that the next time someone does a handstand in my office, I can be sure to discount the next sentence coming out of their mouth.
this field was debunked and isnt used anymore . i wouldnt use any of those to see if people around you are lying .
This makes me wonder how he would approach sociopathic and psychopathic criminals. Since they have no emotion, they wouldn't feel fear and have any of these responses. My two fav shows are CSI (the original) and Criminal Minds so I've seen a lot of episodes with those types of people, but I would love to hear about his professional opinion and experiences with those types of people. Also, how he dealt with psychopathic/sociopathic children
If you're ever arrested, say absolutely nothing and demand a lawyer. And as you wait for that lawyer, say absolutely nothing. Innocent or guilty - do not say a word, do not answer any questions. Even if they say "your silence tells me you might be guilty" or something like that, still say NOTHING. They have ways to move you down the conversation, slowly picking apart anything you say until you've implicated yourself (again guilty or innocent). Just say nothing.
Me: *Figuring out how to lie to detectives*
Also me: *Remembers not to be a criminal*
In case it ever comes up (and this includes questioning, not only arrest), exercise your right to silence. Say that you will not speak to them without an attorney. It can only help you, and it might save you!
100%, it's terrifying that they can pick this stuff up.
@@pelago_ They can't. Its pseudo science.
@@MrDavidRamm whether it's scientific or pseudo-scientific, you can't argue with how effective it can be.
@@pelago_ I guess my concern is that innocent people are locked up because of this nonsense. I'm sure some law enforcement types are good at reading people. But I'm also sure lots are just confident that they are good at it.
"There is no universal indicator of deception." Remember that.
Right right
actually... its the other way.
@@fabiotellez6192 only explain if you want to go to school while school is out.
“It appears to be a denial, when it’s not really a denial at all.” So good.
Basically, if you're guilty and being interrogated: be consistent
It seems more like an art than a science to me.
It's more like an art because there's really no real structure or process to it.
It's way to subjective to be science. I definitely wouldn't call something like this art though. Art is reserved for beautiful, creative things, not perceptiveness.
holycrow! I believe calling it a skill would be accurate.
I think he's probably good at his job, but he also might be overly convinced of his own accuracy. I think there are definitely cases where people are easy to read but at the same time, I would be cautious not to over simplify body language and assume you can read people's thoughts.
Charlie EN yea it’s all relative not official
Biggest lie ever:
*I have read and accept the terms and conditions*
OMG that's like every one lies about that
I feel like this comment has been copied.
@@kheibelsson Meh doesn't really matter
Lmaooo the amount of things I have agreed to💀
Who wouldnt want to lie about that LOL
Everyone in the comments is pointing at how one indicator is wrong and how just cause they do blank doesn't mean someone is lying. That's clearly not the point. No investigator sees one sign of description and assumes someone is lying.
Wow, am I the only one who's in love with this guy's voice? Had to rewatch this video for the second time because I wasn't listening to what he's saying. His voice is so serene.
Suspect: _breathes_
FBI: “Got ‘em.”
🤣🤣🤣
FBI: *gets him food*
Suspect: *eats it*
FBI: "ladies and gentlemen.... We got him"
So basically anything you do or don’t do is suspicious. Makes sense
"you have the right to remain silent, everything you say may and will be used against you"
It's more about the perception you have to watch for a change in behaviour on a particular topic
Billy Hicks perception is reality
Patterns are important. Poker players call them “tells.”
No. Anything you do or don't do CAN be suspicious based on the context and your prior behavior patterns. Yes, it does make sense, if you pay attention and watch the whole video.
I feel like alot of these are also just how anxiety and stress comes off in innocent people as well. I could see myself having these behaviors and changes if I'm anxious about being accused of something i haven't done.
I love this guy because he's doing what's right because if his childhood and for justice. Plus, he studied philosophy which is cool.
Oh man, i'd be so screwed even if I wasn't lying. I do almost all of these things no matter where I am.
Same here...
Sameee
But I think he said they observe the change in your behavior. 😂 so if you’re fidgety that’s fine but if there was a sudden change all throughout the conversation, that’s a deception. So their initial warmup convo i guess is how they study the person being investigated. I mean, that’s how I understood it. Lol
that has not a single thing to do with what this guy said. you missed the entire point.
they observe CHANGES in your behavior. they don't look for all these specific things. they look for how your behavior changes before you start speaking versus after.
You would...do a handstand in an interrogation room...?
The only word you should ever say in an interview is "Lawyer" Guilty, innocent, or anything in between: Do not talk to law enforcement.
Though only asking for a lawyer and not talking is sometimes taken as evidence of someone's guilt
In case it ever comes up (and this includes questioning, not only arrest), exercise your right to silence. Say that you will not speak to them without an attorney. It can only help you, and it might save you!
@@enotsnavdier6867 doesn't matter what the cops think. That's not evidence in court.
@@enotsnavdier6867 Except that's not true.
@@enotsnavdier6867 that's not actual evidence. presenting the judge with baseless, circumstantial evidence saying "they wanted to use their consitutional right to talk to their lawyer, instead of talking to us!!! they're guilty!!!!" will just make the presenter look stupid.
You can never tell really with someone who’s good at lying
Thanks for the help