Making radioactive balloons using Radon gas
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 09. 2023
- I bought a geiger counter, but there was nothing radioactive around the house, until I discovered you can gather radon decay products using electrostatically charged baloons!
The article I referenced:
sciencedemonstrations.fas.har...
Please keep going down this rabbit hole. Very interesting
@matthiasrandomstuff2221 yes, isn't it what "random stuff" was created for?
Indeed. Have faith in your audience of similarly minded excentrics to find the bottom of this rabbit hole a wonderland they are grateful they didn't have to explore personally! So much to do, so little time...
I agree!
i think we have just spotted the rabbit hole
This has classic Cody's lab feel to it. Love it!
I thought the same thing even before i seen your comment.
Cody went full retard though.
Only if the FBI hassles him afterward. 🙂 (Or the RCMP rather. It would be quite the event if the FBI showed up at his house.)
@@jasonpatterson8091 FBI and RCMP have a wonderful working relationship and it's not out of place to have an FBI agent doing an interview/investigation in CA (with RCMP support obviously).
IIf this were a Cody's Lab video, Matthias would have to inhale Radeon from the balloon and speak in a radioactive voice, whatever this is... ^^
Perhaps the cause of the strange 36 minute half-life is because the half-life isn't really 36 minutes. As you've noticed, the radioactivity first increases and then decreases - the model is thus comprised of more than one relevant half-life. For example if you conjecture the decay has two dominating steps you should fit your model to en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioactive_decay#Chain_of_two_decays rather than estimating a single half-life.
Good thought. The physisists behind the linked article probably wouldn't think of something like that. After all it not like they write things like "Since we do not know in what proportion the daughter nuclides of radon have been collected on the balloon, it is not at all clear what half-life has been measured." and later on discuss their use of measuring equipment to figure out the specific gamma frequencies to determine this proportion.
yes, I tried to model that, but couldn't get anything close to the nice exponential decay with 37 minute half life.
Maybe this set of lists look down for the 10s of minutes list (for bismuth lead chlorine maybe chlorine from tap water??):
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_radioactive_nuclides_by_half-life
here en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_radioactive_nuclides_by_half-life#103_seconds_(kiloseconds)
maybe it's a mix of multiple elements decaying
@@matthiasrandomstuff2221 I started with the (somewhat dubious) assumption that there was only Po218 on the balloon to begin with, and solved the differential equations to obtain the amount of Pb214 and Bi214 as functions of time. I then modelled the number of Geiger-Mueller clicks as the decay rate (lambda) for Pb214 times its quantity plus similarly for Bi214, assuming that no alphas are making it into your detector through the solid plastic.
The resulting curve looks quite a lot like the one you see, and if I estimate a "half-life" in the same way by drawing a straight line on the log plot between the rate at 90 minutes and the rate at 250 minutes, I get an apparent half-life of 38.5 minutes. I think the confusion might be caused by the fact that there is a chain of processes taking place -- it takes 9.5 minutes to reach peak rate of lead decay and 28 minutes to reach the peak rate of bismuth decays, and a substantial amount of new bismuth is still being added through lead decays at that time (though the polonium is basically gone).
If instead, I measure the apparent half-life between times farther along, say 500 and 1000 minutes, it converges on 26.8 minutes, the half-life of lead, which makes sense because the decay rate of bismuth is higher, so eventually lead is the bottleneck for all events.
I have a degree in Physics and I don’t have any answers for you. But I do have a funny Geiger counter story. For a Modern Physics Lab we were tasked with taking a Geiger counter around campus and logging radioactive sources. I went into a local WalMart to test the bananas and got kicked out by an irate Karen who thought I was making the food radioactive 😂
Throwing in my vote for a followup, deeper dive down the rabbit hole. This is fun stuff!
Brings back memories of when I used to ride my bike to work at the nuclear power plant. I could not get my wet cycling clothes and shoes past the radiation. monitors to get into the office. Others had difficulty getting in with wet coats from rain. Those Radon daughters really stick.
Must have had more sensitive adiation detectors than I do. I wish the geiger tube was bigger.
Oh yes, used photoluminescent detectors. IIRC. @@matthiasrandomstuff2221
It depends on your detector, but i doubt any of them are alpha detectors, so most likely you would only pick up beta and gamma decays. Looking at the decay series for Rn222, I think what's being picked up is the decay of Pb214 (hl=27 m) and the decay of Bi214 (hl=20 m). These two happening back to back are giving you the 38 minute half life.
The decays of Po218 and Po214 don't get picked up because they're alphas and for the time scale of your experiment, Pb210 is effectively stable.
I think you observed the transient equilibrium of the radon decay product my friend. I could be wrong but there is more than 1 isotope with short half life, a gamma/alpha spectrum would help identifying the culprit but keep in mind that you also detected a combination of gamma and beta radiation (maybe some alpha depending on the tube used ) also, the braking radiation of the beta and alpha particles will mess with the result a bit.. great video sir!
After I built a geiger counter myself I discovered the same thing, but I used the dust that collects on the screen of an old CRT television after a while. Just let it run for 10-20 minutes, then wipe the screen with a damp paper towel.
Next codyslab video will be extracting gold from plywood with a bandsaw
I have a few friends who are certified Health Physicists, and I can't wait to show them this video to see what they think could be behind the odd half-life. These guys are super knowledgeable in their field.
And what did they say?
Leaving a comment so id be notified for updates
Well I learned two things today - first that you can collect radon daughter isotopes in the form of dust (more or less) and that radon that is generated from thorium is called thoron by the folks in the know. I was reading the article you stopped on regarding the decay products of radon and saw the mention of thoron and fell into an even deeper rabbit hole about it. Sincere thanks - I always enjoy learning something new and interesting, especially in an area where I'm reasonably knowledgeable already.
And I would love another video on how your dehumidifier/HVAC affects background radiation in the house.
Yes, please, measure the obvious appliances most people may have at home.
Could be the effect of Pb214 -> Bi214 causing the decay of Bi214 -> Po214 to look slower than it should. (both are 20-30 min)
Because it is not an nuclear decay but rather just electrons discharging from the baloon skin.
I am impressed that you were able to get so good data from that. As others have pointed out it seems likely that you see parallel and consecutive decays overlaying.
This is pretty cool! If you're in the market for radiation detectors, I gotta recommend the Radiacode. It's not a Geiger tube, but uses a scintillation crystal, and it detects the energy level of gamma radiation. The benefit is that it makes it really easy to determine which isotopes you're seeing. It also easily hooks up to a computer or smartphone for data analysis.
I thought the point of this channel was for random stuff with almost no views. It's also one of the channels I get excited for. Nerding out on data collection, even other people's data collection, is not the kinda of thing we get enough of on CZcams. I really wanna know how much change you see running filters and HVAC. Random stuff! It's interesting!
I definitely thought you somehow got a balloon full of radon, and we are all glad you did not
That rabbit hole isn't deep enough yet... keep digging!
Really awesome video!
For the half-life mystery, are you computing mean-life or half-life? The mean-life is what you get from just measuring the exponential slope. There's a factor of ln(2) difference to get the half-life.
So for 214Pb: mean-life = 38.9 min, half-life = 27 min
Now I know what I'm doing this evening :) Catching radon decay products :) Greetings from Ukraine. Awesome stuff as always.
Of all the hazards you are facing right now, Radon probably isn't one of them. With your deep rich soil, you probably aren't that close to igneous bedrock where the radon comes from
Many years ago, I installed radon evacuation systems. I honestly do not remember how we tested for levels, but I do remember it taking a solid week. It's crazy that it decays so quickly (hours to days), but it is "around" long enough to give people cancer, etc. Of course, that's in higher concentrations.
Thanks for the interesting video! As usual, it was not a disappointment.
it isn't around that long, just that the radon in your house keeps getting replenished from he ground. I don't know what to think bout radon. Has there ever been anybody who conclusively died from radon in their house? Surely, there should be some extreme cases, right?
@matthiasrandomstuff2221 I do agree with your statements, definitely. As far as indisputable evidence, I can't answer that. I only assume what I was taught is correct; that exposure to copious amounts of radon is believed to cause lung cancer. I can only assume since it collects and has time to mutate cells.
I agree there are probably minimal "accounts" directly related, but I also know there are some areas (at least in the U.S.) where there are exponentially higher amounts being released from the soil. I seem to remember that farm land or areas that were forested for long periods are worse than those that do not have as much organic material.
Thanks for questioning everything like you do! Sometimes, I just give in, and other times, I fight for what is potentially the truth. Of course, as you have shown many times, facts/data can be used to make statements that may not be correct, whether intentionally or not.
@matthiasrandomstuff2221 The answer lies in the statistics - not single cases.
Some people can smoke their whole life and die at age 95. Others haven't smoked and die of lung cancer at age 30.
Somebody got in way too much of a hurry when they were typing the title to this.
I did Not notice the typo until I read this comment… 😂
oops, fixed
I love your rabbit hole
You come up with the most interesting video and ideas
Personally I watch all your videos
Radon gas and testing was always of concern in our Minnesota basements.
Please make more videos about radon. I love this random stuff.
On the Fnirsi GC-01 you can add the audible 'click' sound of the particle counter with a resistor. Foton Gamma has a demo of this process on his channel. Appears to be a very simple process.
The radon decay chain is primarily a series of alpha decays, where an alpha particle, which is a helium nucleus containing two protons and two neutrons, is ejected from the nucleus of the parent atom with the alpha particle typically having a few million electron volts of kinetic energy depending on which step in the decay chain we are talking about. Such an alpha particle slows to a stop in a few microns of travel in a solid by losing energy to electrons which it kicks out of atoms as it zips past. These ejected electrons produce x-rays as they collide with other electrons and the holes in the atomic shells left by the ejected electrons also produce x-rays as electrons further from the nucleus jump into the hole closer to the nucleus. I think that it is these x-rays that your Geiger counter is detecting, since alpha particles only travel a few microns in a solid they would not make it through the glass wall of the Geiger tube. By the way, a common detector for alpha particles uses an aluminized Mylar window, which is thin enough that some of the alpha particles can penetrate. Most fast electrons, that is beta particles, are stopped by a single sheet of paper, and would not make it through the glass wall of the Geiger tube.
Love your curiosity and scientific method.
Having just installed a radon abatement system in my home, I found this video very interesting, and would love any further trips down this "rabbit hole."
I'm one of the people who would appreciate a follow up. Maybe in the future you can just mention in another video that you've added notes about the radon decay to this one.
A good detector is the Better Geiger project.
It's actually a scintillation detector with pretty basic functionality, but it has a whole range of modding options as most the hardware is open source.
Another scintillation detector is the Radiacode 102, and the nice thing about scintillation detectors is you can actually determine isotopes, as they can measure the energy of the particles.
It costs almost 5x as much and looks like it was 3D printed. Surely, a sensible company would charge an extra $30 for something that doesn’t look like absolute trash.
Please continue this series
Definitely "random stuff". Love it!
It wasn’t beyond our interest :) it was awesome
This is facinating stuff! Short of having the measurement tool, it'd be a great experiment for older kids.
If you do more videos on it, you'd get my view for sure!
It might be a good opportunity for a collab. Not with me, because I'd be useless, but some youtubers in the radiation field would sure jump on that. Busting a few myths and what not.
Good plan. This is garage style can do, educational, hands on learning.
This is awesome! I love how you mix electronics, woodworking, science, math, etc. to scratch that curiosity itch! It's always practical, insightful, and to the point. If I ever got the guts to start recording myself, I'd model it after this.
I love this stuff! Have lots of parts to make Geiger counters and you are making me want to get going on those projects. Thanks!
Love your videos Matthias. I'm drawn to your channel for your frugal, MVP, and behind the science approach to science, making, and hacking. Keep posting and I'll keep watching :) John from Norway.
I appreciate that clamps were still included
Oh that is bizarre. Today I learned. Sounds to me like it's time for you to build a competent geiger counter using an arduino/pi and the basic board you've got, since it just needs a GUI.
Side note, I love how many random wooden gadgets you make on the channel that fufill such a specific purpose.
"This one here is designed to hold a balloon against a geiger counter"
"This one throws applesauce packet lids"
This stuff is practical and interesting! More radon decay products videos!
Very cool! Haven't seen many Radon experiments before.
I love your comment on going down the rabbit hole. Could have been me. 🙂
I am sure you know by now what gets views and what doesn't. I will only say that I love this type of video and will appreciate however many of them you feel like doing.
I have an air exchanger, which is necessary to be run 24/7 because radon does increase to unhealthy level. I use an Airthings meter to keep track of it.
Oh great, now balloons are going to kill us. Next you'll probably tell us bananas are radioactive.
Great rabbit hole, more please
Rachel: Whatcha doing today?
Matthias: Counting Geigs.
those clics give it the Chernobyl's death vives!! love it
With respect to residential Radon remediation (at least for the moment), there's very little variation in the consumer products that are available to homeowners. Using static-electricity as a gathering tool could have some serious potential in terms of its practical application.
So far, the typical method involves collecting radioactive particles _before_ they go into the house, but plenty of houses out there can't easily be buffered by a low-pressure cushion in this way. For such houses that test high, I can imagine a sort of baseboard-level electrostatic device that solves the problem before it reaches breathing level.
As usual, your simple, downright empirical approach delivers. Even if this idea is a total dead-end, this video has really challenged my thinking.
I have electrostatic filters in my HVAC system. I suspect that has an effect.
@@paulkolodner2445 It probably does, for better or worse. After making that comment, the problem I started to think about was how one might _clean_ a large electrostatic filter. Note that Radon isn't really dangerous, but its breakdown products can be, and they have a much, much longer half-life.
If I were you, I'd be interested to hear what a radiation detector has to say about my electrostatic furnace filter ~ especially since some of them get marketed as "lifetime."
@@pocket83squared Excellent suggestion - a functioning filter should always be radioactive. That's a comforting thought. However, I am pretty sure mine work, because they are always covered with dust when I clean them every 3 months. Plus I replaced them a few years ago, just to be compulsive about home maintenance.
This video was so cool! I concur with other commenters, keep going down this rabbit hole!
I have a radon measuring device (airthings). The count was pretty high in the basement. I have to leave windows open to avoid high levels of radiation now. I have neighbours that used to sleep in the basement until I told them... Now they sleep upstairs.
Nice topic, of what most people have no idea.
There's evidence of a protective effect from low levels of radiation exposure. It's far from a linear dose/response curve.
@@davelowe1977I guess that is outdated. Back then, people used to visit caves with high radon concentration for health reasons. Nowadays, common understanding is, that each little tiny bit of radiation is dangerous.
Very interesting rabbit-hole. watch out for radioactive rabbits which glow in the dark.
Super interesting! I just tried it myself and also got an above background measurement!
i'd love to see a followup video about this mystery!!!
Static charging units - cats are ideal (dog fur is generally rougher) - if you lack for cat, borrow from a friendly neighbor or repurpose one of your traps or a cage trap and catch, rub and release stray cats (maybe captured squirrels can have their tails pulled gently from a cage trap and used to activate the static charging mechanism without activating biting or scratching modes of action - a standard candle so to speak).
I'd love to see the faces of the owners of the neighborhood kitties, if i'm chasing them with an inflated balloon, desperately trying to get them to sit still for a few seconds...
Something that seems to be missing from the discussion here: Radiation emitted outside the human body is much less damaging than radiation emitted from inside the human body. This is what makes radioactive dust so much more dangerous than high background level radiation. Radioactive dust can be inhaled directly, or settle on foods and be eaten; in this case, the radiation originates inside the body and is absorbed directly into organs that have a low cellular replacement rate. Radiation from external sources must pass through air, skin, and muscle before getting the chance to be absorbed into internal organs; skin and muscle have a relatively higher cellular replacement rate, so radiation damage to them is much less likely to result in cancer.
I hope you make more videos on this topic. I’ve found that when observing barometric pressure and radon levels in the house, their fluctuations are closely related and the radon lags behind the pressure, as you’d expect. It’s the biggest influence over radon levels that I’ve been able to determine. in my experience, anyway.
Always something new and interesting. For pulse accumulation, I'll use one of those little Arduinos and have it accumulate the pulses, taking into account for overflow of the 8 bit register and then talk to the Pi via its unused console serial port. Came in handy for a weather vane wind speed signal.
He does the most fascinating videos!
Please keep going down the rabbit hole Matthias, I'll watch and so will others.
Interesting, great show.
you should check out your ceramic products like your sinks and toilet as when i was hauling loads of these in trucking i showed excessive radiation in checkpoints.
Quite curious. Does anyone have a guess where this is coming from?
Everyone that buys a geiger counter immediately tests bananas
That's actually really cool, I learned something new from this video
Please make more radon videos!!! This is really exciting stuff to me.
Very informative, thanks. You can make your own GM tube that will pick up everything, even alpha. You just need a copper end cap (2") and a BNC connector. You put the connector in the center of the cap. Then solder a rod from the BNC center tap that goes most of the way down into the cap. Place the cap over the sample with a smidge of pure alcohol off to the side (it prevents multiple triggers from the same particle).
Thank you for testing this I bought a counter years ago but couldn’t find many things to actually detect I’ll give this a try!
Fun with a geiger counter!
Yes, other than that, its peace of mind having something in case disaster happens.
Hi Matthias, long time viewer first time commenter. This video is one of a trend where you become interested in a topic, then follow a path to learn more about the topic using your engineering and programming background. I hope you would consider a "guided" follow along for the more hands on viewer! I have children a few years younger than yours, this is the first video that seems simple enough where I would love to follow along and create a small electronics project with the kids. I can already see them running around the house testing things to see what clicks more. Thanks for the video!
a follow along for an electronic project is useless. Because something will go wrong for you that didn't go wrong for me, and now, without in-depth knowledge, you don't know what to do. So instead, get enough general knowledge of a topic to be able to execute your own projects without handholding, so you will be able to debug what will inevitably go wrong.
your dryer lint is gonna emit alpha particles (if anything), which a "gamma beta xray" (*not*, despite labeled as such, "nuclear radiation") detector won't pick up on. same for radon by the way, your detector would have to see secondary-decays to pick up anything.
I know even less about this, but more now having watched to the end.
What you choose to experiment on is always interesting.
Measuring one geiger Muller counter with another one, hv, measures more than there is. Higher aperture
No, please make more of this! Its awesome owo
Great to see your old geiger counter. The moving coil panel meter was made by my first ever employer Sifam (based in Torquay in England): a proper old school engineering firm where I learnt to be an software engineer as we replaced the analogue instruments with digital. I wonder which were the better?
I too was disappointed by the lack of clicking. Glad you found some that do
The interesting thing would be to try to backtrack to the radon levels
I am interested. Please keep going
time to take some Radaway.
the video we've all been waiting for
I'd watch it.
When Matthias started talking about the difficulty in consistently charging the balloon, I half expected him to say something like, "so I build a Wimshurst machine..." and go into a short build segment.
The half-life is not only due to radioactive decay, but also ‘evaporation’ - or various form of escape from the ballon surface.
This sounds like a job for Thunderf00t.
A piece of advice from my past life as a respectable physicist: fitting curves to multiple exponential decays is a risky business.
This was really cool! I've gone down the air quality rabbit hole, and bought a radon monitor. I had no idea you could capture radon decay products with filters or static charge! I'd be interested in learning more, could the half life be due to a combination of radon decay products? Or is it from some other radioactive substance in our air?
I think you should do a check on what's ticking in your HRV front-end filter.
Just discovered your channel - love it, I think your mind works much like mine.
With regards to the odd half life, and also the early increase, I think I can offer some insights. I recently did this same experiment with a home designed geiger counter that picks up alpha as well. My decay curve had some similarities and I was interested in how the different half lives and captured isotopes interacted.
I put together a spreadsheet where I could alter the relative isotope starting amounts, and it would calculate the activity level each second as the various isotopes decayed/formed.
You'll start with less Po-218 as it has a short half life, and by the time you start measuring a lot of it has already turned to Pb-214.
If you start with Pb214:Bi214 ratio at least 6:1, you get an initial increase in activity peaking at around 15-30 min (depending on ratio).
In my case, the only way to get the decay curve I observed was if I also captured a high proportion of Pb210.
Hmm, yes, I may have been capturing some of the later decay products as well, not just the initial radon decay product.
This is dope!!! So interesting!!!!!
Would love a way to test radon exposure at home with a home lab setup, very cool experiments!
I like videos like this a lot! The kinetics of series reaktions is not that difficult. It is not uncommon for the activity to rise in decay series. When you take pure Uranium and wait as the decay products "fill" the chain the activity gets higher... (you have to wait a bit longer ;-) )
Very interesting!
That was very interesting. I’m gonna get one of those yellow counters also.
Oh, and I think the rabbit hole must be explored!
Radicode 101 or 102 reasonably priced excellent tool.
I checked, 10x as expensive as the one I bought! And needs a smartphone. No thanks!
Really It cost $303 dollars, You paid only $30 for yours? You do need a smart phone.@@matthiasrandomstuff2221
if you live anywhere that has transient radon, a great place to find radon daughters is the dust that gathers on an old style CRT display. Thank you for this video. The next tier is buying a gamma spectrometert, like Spectro 1 Pro Mobile Spectrophotometer. Just FYI.
wish I still had a CRT. That would be much more consistent than charged up baloons
Amazing 👏
i live a few miles away from two massive uranium mines (one active and one inactive). every single house here has a radon pipe to make sure that radon in the soil has a path to flow through the house that doesn't mix with the air we breathe. from what i understand, its literally just a big pipe (i think its 4 inch PVC) that is set into the slab in the basement so its open to the soil, and it runs straight up to the roof. we can all get radon test kits from the state for free too which is nice. i've measured background radiation numerous times over the years, and its actually not much higher than other places without uranium ore. living my entire life here will net me about one extra chest x-ray worth of radiation.
i've never though to do the experiments you did here with the balloon or to test my dryer lint, and now i think i will have to test it to see how strong the radiation is haha
Interesting experiment. I've never convinced myself I have detected radon or daughter products before. After seeing your video I hoovered the house, (takes a while) and checked the contents for any change in background. Nothing detected🙂. I'll try the static test at some point but I guess it has a lot more to do with where you live and it looks like your experiment could be conducted in a basement, a favourite area to find radon.
Even metals evaporate, especially there they are really atom size particles, and with the help of a 4MeV of energy on each event, after what it was fast and full ionised.
I think you need aluminium hermetical tube around Geiger tube, to get graphics look like that they should to look.