"I don't have to chew vegetables - score!!" This is where you're wrong. Greens powders are supplements, not substitutes! You still have to eat a well balanced diet! It's not supposed to be a one-drink-fix-all solution!
Well chewing vegetables everyday don’t even work either because it starts from the soil on the ground and from when your food come from the farms, it’s tampered with. Honestly good don’t even look like food these days, everything is Just fake that is why we deficient on many things smh.
The reason why I think people feel it works is just to show how unbalanced our diets are. I'm sure a lot of us is short in eating enough varieties of fruit and veggies.
Regardless of how “unbalanced” your diet is or how “organic” you eat.. our soil is shit compared to what it was in the 50’s. If you just look at the studies of soil samples and the produce grown in the soils 80 years ago vs today (as an example)… you would have to eat 53 bowls of TODAYS spinach to equal the same iron content as a bowl of spinach from 80 years ago. Balance your diet all you want. You are never going to get enough nutrients in the modern landscape. We have been robbed of that option. You are fooling yourself into “i just get all my nutrients from my food” no.. you don’t lol
I live in Germany and I was shown AG1 ads for the first time a few months ago. I did some research and the German consumer protection warns against these products. Once for your reasons mentioned and because often greens purchased on the Internet are poorly controlled. Thx for your video, Justina!
I'm German as well and AG1 is ALL OVER social media, it's soo annoying. Every podcaster/Instamodel/CZcamsr and their mother is advertising AG1 and gushing over how it changed their lives. They seem to forget how freaking expensive it is, like who wants to spend EUR 100per month on it?? Ridiculous, really.
Also in Germany here... So I agree with the video and the comments, AG1is just ridiculously overpriced, and constantly being shoved into my eye holes on social media... Question for others here in Germany: Is there a green powder here that is approved and meets regulatory standards of the "German consumer protection laws"? If I find some that are approved but The German Food Supplements Regulation (NemV), I will share them here thanks for the honest video
Thanks for saving me a LOT of money. Greens powders are hard for me to drink (because they are GROSS LOL and often taste like fake sweetener too) but I felt like I was missing out on something I really "should" be adding to my diet. I have apples, brocolli, cabbage, cauliflower, green beans and blueberries in my fridge so I guess I'm good!
All that excellent fiber from the REAL fruits and vegetables you mention, will go a long way towards feeding your healthy gut bacteria. And the latest research shows that the healthiest people are actually proving to be those who have the widest variety of healthy gut bacteria.👍
As someone who uses a green powder, I loved this video. Not because it taught me anything I wasn't already aware of, but because it was honest, educated and factual while not tearing any one side down or criticizing. Thank you. It's irritating seeing all the fitness and nutrition videos out there that are just full of false information and or no information at all sometimes, just people pushing a product.
Hi Chris. Could you share which one you use and maybe any feedback on it? I’d love to find one for my daughter who can’t eat raw fruits and veggies because of allergies
Thanks again for your informed and common sense approach to fitness and nutrition. I had been a fitness instructor/personal trainer for 28 years and was also a registered dietitian, and find your content on point. Proprietary blend is the biggest scam on the market!!
My husband and I were supposed to host Christmas this year, and we got the flu on Christmas Eve. Everyone was already in town and my brother-in-law swore that if we used a green powder, we'd get better. I was miserable and the green powder tasted like trash. Keep in mind, hubby and I are both fit, we eat a balanced diet, and we don't rely on supplements often (apart from Omegas and protein powder). Spoiler alert: the green powder didn't fast-track our recovery time. It only served to make me more unhappy. 😅 And that's okay. I wasn't expecting anything else. Maybe it gave me a little something, maybe not. I just continued to listen to my body and eat what it wanted to heal. I still have some green powder and on those days where I'm not able to get in as many fresh fruits and veggies as I'd like, I don't mind choking some down (Okay, I'm being dramatic, but it's not great.) But full reliance is dangerous for the reasons you mentioned. This is such a perfect product to market towards Americans and I'm not surprised they're so successful. We're lazy and if we could find a "take this one pill and live forever because it's all you" supplement, we'd take it. Personally, I really love vegetables and fruits, so they're not a struggle for me to get in normally and the green powders are not nearly as kind on my gut. I'm tempted to send this to my brother-in-law. His wife is part of several MLMs. They pretty much live off of various powders and red meat. It's wild.
Thank you for doing this! I see so, so many people (very random inluencers mostly) rave about this and I've always wondered it if was really worth it or not.
I LOVED that you said, not financially accessible!!! Thanks for acknowledging the people struggling to afford adequate nutrition! It's also important for more people to hear the if it's working for you, GOOD for You! As someone with chronic illness living in an ableist world, you hear about so many "cures" and we are sought out by companies, influencers, and representatives to buy the products. Much of it starts with shaming of the people who can't afford the products or food, and for those who have assumably already tried doing everything short of eating worms (I know of people who have actually consumed worms looking for a cure) and nothing worked for us, we're told we must have done it wrong, not taken it long enough, not eaten enough, etc. I've known of one good green powder that my sister-in-law used to sell and never shame anyone over it, that I thought was pretty good. I can't afford it, but it was decently trustworthy. I felt some benefits, but did it cure me? No. I do have to use electrolytes and probiotics. So here's the interesting thing to know about the marketing with that- Me, as someone with chronic illness who belongs to a large community of others who also require electrolyte supplements like people with POTS or absorption problems, etc, I have multiple social media accounts and though I'm not a big deal, I do know a couple medium deals and I'm a daily social media user. People like me, reach out to a company, to see if we can get a code and promote it for a small discount or to earn product, they respond with We'd LOVE for you to be a brand ambassador! You have to have over a million followers and then we'll sign you up. Guess what? Most people with chronic illness don't have a million followers! There's a good reason for that! But, if you ask millions of people in groups or chronic illness communities how many of them use the product, at least 80% will say they do. Many of them have subscriptions. Many of them learned about the product they use because they heard it discussed as a favorite or because it won in a lot of social media polls. But because we're not the pretty, perky, popular person, we're not enough for them. Again, ableist world, so that's something else for people to consider when hearing these stories from so-called changed/cured influencers. Great video!
Před 3 měsíci
"if it's working for you, GOOD for You" Or maybe they should learn to tell feelings from reality. Because you can say that about pretty much all quackery (homeopathy for example). It's still quackery and it's still (potentially) bad for you.
You can afford to have adequate nutrition if you just buy whole foods instead of these supplements. Veggies are super cheap, and much more affordable than any prepackaged food you can buy.
It's mind-boggling to me that people in the US can't find out what's specifically in their food/supplements. I just learned last year that packages in the US don't use grams or anything to compare but "portion sizes".
Wow that is pricey! I hate these predatory companies. I’ve been taking fruit and veggie snacks to work and eating during the day. It keeps my energy level up!
One of the things that waves massive red flags to me about greens powders (and reds, and those musrhoom supplements that were popular a few years ago, and pretty much any "holistic health and wellness" supplement) that I don't think people in general twig as being a red flag is when the product claims both anti-inflammatory properties and 'immune support'/'immune boosting'/whatever - it can't be both, inflammation is a function of the immune system, if it's suppressing inflammation it's immune suppressing. (immune 'boosting' also gets me, that's autoimmunity babes, but I assume that's fluffier language for 'supporting t-cell production' or something like that). Either of the effects are fine, there are reasons one would want that, but it can't be BOTH. They are opposing mechanisms! And that tells me the company is full of shit about their products.
You are wrong, sorry, food and vitamins can be anti-oxidants, hence decreasing inflammation, without reducing the ability of the immune system to protect the body. They don't act like ibuprofen and other medicines. Also, you can definitely boost the immune system without causing auto-immune reactions. Auto-immunity is a dysfunctional reaction of the immune system.
If your immune system is functioning properly and efficiently inflammation should be low (ie can mount a defense and clear the pathogen without getting a lot of players involved - such as an antibody binding a virus and preventing from invading a cell which would then require a larger inflammatory response to eliminate)
good video. I am an ER doc and have been taking AG for about 7 months. It seems to have improved my digestion at least, although I havent noticed any of the other claimed benefits(increased focus, energy, less sleep needed). I am curious, because I do eat fruits and veggies, like raspberries, blueberries, spinach, asparagus, broccoli cauliflower and carrots mainly. I used to have gi upset like IBS symptoms, and that is what improved on AG1....do u think its possible they some people need additional digestive support...such as is offered in some of these powders? I am guessing u would say yes. Thanks this was one of the more informative vids on the subject. Popular "influencers" are paid substantially, I believe commission based on purchases that use their code. So obviously a ton of that monthly cost is to pay those people and otherwise market...which means the product costs a fraction of the charge.
Thank you for this. It really bums me out when I see people who normally do good things make their sad drinks with green sawdust and a mini whisk, and then tell me how great it tastes. We all know it does not taste great.
It's mind-blowing to me how far of a reach Athletic Greens has. I consume content from different types of creators -- not just in the health and wellness space but creators in the DYI industry, Finance, and Music and they're all promoting it! It's really insane.
Something I think is extremely insidious about greens is that along with advertising "wellness" benefits, they prey on the very normal phenomena of being ~bloated~. Absolutely wild that so many influencers advertise a product that essentially makes something that's not usually a problem and makes it a problem 🥴
I wished you had listed some example of high quality powders vs low quality. I saw AG1 in the picture but that wasn't mentioned in the video so now I'm wondering which category it falls into. Thank you for this video just the same! ❤❤❤❤
The ones that are considered meal replacements and not “supplements”are the good ones. Most are super expensive though. Anywhere from $85-120 for 15-30 servings.
Don't waste your money on processed powders, eat more whole, fresh food whenever possible. The less that has been 'done' to it the better. Greens, fruit, root veg, legumes... Frozen unprocessed products like berries can be useful.
I had to rewatch this video since I caught myself thinking I needed to buy greens after seeing them popping up on my youtube non stop. Thanks for the video! Will probably have to rewatch when I think I need them again in a couple months lol
@@JustinaErcole I disagree, you're doing the video about green powders because of it's current popularity among creators. You said so in the beginning of your video. You called it an anecdotal evidence from 1 person's experience but couldn't the same be argued to the product you're promoting? Don't get me wrong, the reason why I landed on your video is because I cancelled my subscription to AG1 Greens, se we agree on it's lack of results, but I find it ironic that you come out to discredit other creator's product placement by calling it a scam, which is a strong claim, and u place a product for profit in that very same video.
@@JustinaErcole Your product doesn't have ingredients... and as for the results that's for each person to decide, hence the trial on ur product and the 90 days money guarantee on powder greens. 1- Not at any point on your video do you mention an ingredient that they have been proved to lie about. They do not disclose the composition of the blends, but that is in fact on the product nutrition list. 2- You say Green Powders are a scam. That includes all green powders, but not all green powders claim the same thing, or have the same nutrition facts. In fact most green powders offer you a 100% refund If you are unhappy with the results, which I can confirm with AG1 Greens. If the effects they claim are not visible here's your money back. How is this a scam? 3- You literally say "It never ceases to amaze me what people will say to convince you to buy things you probably don't need", alleging without proof that they are lying when they say claim they've felt the benefits of what e.g. AG1 offers. Looking at your product placement, isn't there as much proof that these people don't actually feel the benefits from powder greens as there is that you revisit Sonja Rasula's course? Doesn't your product offer a trial in case you feel that their product is to your liking you can cancel your subscription to ensure costumer satisfaction? I don't see any differences between what you are selling and AG1.
I have a 15 year old son who refuses to eat vegetables. I realize that greens powders are not ideal, but his doctor recommended it along with a good multivitamin. I also have a son leaving for college in 5 days. I just bought him some because he isn’t likely to eat anything more than donuts and chips for the next 4 years. How can I make sure that I am getting them a higher quality product? (I have to note here, my kids grew up vegetarians and they both loved vegetables until recently.)
Definitely don’t tell people they could get freeze dried veggies/fruits and blend it into a powder or dehydrate their own to make a cheaper green powder. One that you may actually be able to trust
There are a few dehydrator/ food preserving/homesteading channels that have great green powder recipes that cost significantly less then buying it from a large company if you invest a little time and a trip to a local thrift shop for a cheap dehydrator or use your oven if it gets low enough
I agree with most of this! However, I do not think Athletic Greens is a scam but I DO think it is way overly marketed and the majority of people do not need it for the price. Athletic greens is for athletes, and part of the reason why it is so expensive is that it is certified Safe for Sport, i.e. the ingredients are independently tested to make sure it contains what it says it does, and not any banned substances. As someone who could be drug tested in endurance sports, that is really important for me! Anecdotally I've seen improvements in my blood work after taking AG1, and optimal levels of these vitamins and minerals can differ for athletes vs the general population. But yeah, all of the influencer marketing doesn't sit well...
4:38 well yes and no... because if they just told everyone how much of all the ingredients they put in there would be nothing stopping another company just copying the formula.... but im also not niave enough to believe that the other reason is because they don't really have optimal dosages of the specific ingredients in them to make a scientific provable difference.... 🤔
I did bloom greens for quite a few months. I started having nothing but diarrhea for 3 straight months. Stopped the greens and then got a regular poop back
@@JustinaErcole literally. Went to my gastro and then quit the greens and then didn't end up needing anything because we found what was probably causing it.
I know they're popular with neurodivergent people who have sensory issues with actual fruits & vegetables. I have the same issues but take capsule supplements to help. Are there any reputable green powder brands you recommend?
Thank you for bringing ALL this out. So, is there a greens powder that actually delivers all the nutrients that they claim and has been scientifically proven to be beneficial? Please anyone, especially Influencers that doesn’t have sincere scientific evidence with old from replying.
Bloom is owned by a pretty scammy/untrustworthy influencer in my opinion. I used to follow her a long time ago, but her business decisions, how she marketed her fitness, and consistently bad form turned me off over time.
I didn't read the comments so this may already be there but one of the reasons these companies do not list any vitamin and/or mineral amounts is because labeling law for these is pretty strict (at least in Europe) and usually that also means regular testing of the amounts of vitamins which are some of the most expensive tests you can do on food products (I know I work in food manufacturing). Vitamin and mineral labelling is complicated but the companies listing blends instead of vitamin/mineral amounts are trying to save money on lab tests and possible corrective actions due to too low/high amounts as well as inconsistent amounts in the final product. Should you believe everything a label says, NO but if vitamins and minerals are listed on a label, it means it is tested regularly (again at least in Europe) and that's a bigger effort to give accurate information to consumers than just listing blends.
Very rare. A CZcams post that's clear, honest, up front, simply explained and easy to listen to. Funny thing is that an AG1 advert came on right after my view.. How ironic is that...
Every single thing you said was accurate and rational. Especially the point to which why wouldn't the company tell us the amounts if they truly want it to help us. I can only imagine what those $9.99 tubs of greens at Marshalls or TJ Max have in it.
Does anyone have a recommendation on finding high quality greens powders? Are there any products that are transparent about the ingredients and production process? TBH, I use greens powders because I just hate the taste and texture of most vegetables. I've found that putting a scope of powder into my daily fruit smoothie is the most realistic way to regularly get it into my body. I realize that "eat vegetables" is an easy answer a lot of people are giving, but that's kinda like saying "abstinence is the safest form of sex".
I tried AG1 for 2 months, then came to my senses and cancelled. I think the product does have some good things in it, but the company promises so many benefits from the product that it is quite unrealistic. The other thing is that the powder does not completely dissolve after being shaken in water, so there is always powder sediment left at the bottom of your glass. And it is outrageously expensive. As Justine mentioned, all supplements are unregulated so you really don’t know what you are actually getting.
Question what is your opinion on: Option 1) if you make your own greens powder. You buy organic vegetables save the green from the actual vegetables. Then you wash, then blanc to get rid of the oxalic acid and kill off the bacteria, then dehydrate low temperature at 110 deg F and slowly until dry. Then you powdered, then condition it to make sure the powder is dry, and then vacuum seal in a glass jar for long term storage until ready to use. I would consider this high content green powder. Option 2) if you buy variety of organic green vegetables, algae, mushrooms either already dehydrate leaves or powder green for that one ingredient from organic suppliers by the pound (ex. Spirulina, blue green algae, moringa leaves things you cannot normally buy at the farmers market, but can buy online)and mi-x them powders together to make your own mixture? What would you think of those 2 options or combinations of them together. Their are a bunch of videos from homesteaders that make their own greens powder from their own home grown crops. Or people like myself who hate eating green vegetables but does have access local farmers market who sell organic vegetables when in season. And we can pre-make so we have greens in a powdered to use when we cannot get local fresh vegetables. It takes a bit of work but wouldn’t it be much healthier then nothing from the sounds these pre-mix manufacture green powdered and a lot cheaper too?
to be honest as a european is since covid I'm hearing about AG and thought it was crazy, but then seeing the price and media coverage by sponsorship even by professionals (like Huberman) I though I was the mad one. If you want to pay 100$ to not eat your broccoli not gonna complain
Despite the uncertainty surrounding the quality or quantity of ingredients, businesses successfully leverage the placebo effect to drive substantial revenue. Our inclination to believe in the effectiveness of such products leads to repeated purchases, as our perception is influenced by this psychological phenomenon. Nonetheless, it's reasonable to assume that consuming greens is preferable to not receiving essential nutrients at all, right? I totally see your point though Justina!!! Great video! I feel your frustration. 😎
I like your product criticism, however, because I work in the industry I can confidently say that *your take is one side of the story.* While there are companies that either use cheap ingredients or falsify data on the percentage of ingredients, some are genuine. For example, the company I work for had to obscure the percentage of some ingredients within a complex mix because other companies could "steal" our formula. We took that measure because of the expense of the patent. How many countries can we cover? Or how many products do we want to patent? All it would take to make a patent worthless is using an alternative ingredient in another mix, just one change can nullify your patent. So, instead, we went through the route of hiding our actual percentages. We are sure of our quality and quantity that if it is quality checked at any point in time it would be exactly what we say it is. Besides, we also stand on the premise that when a consumer uses our product and finds that it delivers as promised, then they will tell their friends and family about us, this differentiates us from the rest.
Hi! From a licensed therapist perspective. Qualitative data is just as important as quantitative data. Some might argue more important because it looks at the persons lived experience that is unique and tailored to them since each one of us have our own unique variables. Media has put more emphasis on numbers but it should be balanced. That being said, if it works for you, it works for you because you have your own unique needs, wants, beliefs, and values. Simply just giving someone “data” and “facts” leaves out the human experience because we do not live in a vacuum. Side note: there is nothing wrong with the placebo effect. It’s a powerful tool and a persons “buy in” is what matters. Again because we are human and each have our own beliefs that are extremely powerful. Do what makes you happy y’all. Everyone has an “opinion” (belief) and remember, believing is seeing. Not the other way around 😊
Like I said multiple times in the video, if people benefit from these products I think that’s great. I’m simply providing more information so people can be educated consumers.
Thinking of them as supplements is the problem. If you are growing your own greens for better health, and want to have them over the winter, they must be preserved. Dried greens (well, dried anything grown) are never "as good" as fresh. This is undeniable. But, the real question is how much nutrition is lost if you dry them with the best methods and procedures, and what are those best methods and procedures. And, even if they did tell you the items in the blends, what they don't tell you is that all the greens are industrially grown in greenhouses where the glass and plastic keep out UV rays that are necessary for proper photosynthesis. Tomatoes were tested as having appx 300 phytonutrients (grown outside) compared with only appx 50 phytonutrients (grown in a greenhouse). Conclusion? Grow your own greens, and preserve them naturally yourself. Also, I do not believe it is cynical to believe the worst about the products produced by corporations. Money is their objective. That is not cynicism; it is reality. People buy these products because they want benefits without any real personal cost. Eating your greens fresh is best. Grow your own, and preserve what you can for times when the weather and climate where you are keep you from growing them. Remember, many greens can grow outside year round. I had Kale and Swiss Chard growing all winter. It snowed on them three times, and we had frosts (a couple of them hard frosts) five or six times, last winter. (And I live in Tucson, AZ where that is not supposed to happen! Yes, please pity me. LOL) But seriously, folks. They just laughed at the cold and the snow. They are super proud greens to be sure. HA HA HA Then, they made it through our super hot and dry summer this year. Obviously, I am propagating new plants from them as I type. We need more soldiers like them in the Food Forest.
Makes sense the way she put it, especially in the end. She makes a valid argument. These supplements are likely healthy, and worth a look. If you like the product as she said, and you have the money, and you want to put something with health benefits into your body (although not fully knowing those benefits) then do it.
I loathe proprietary ingredients and don't trust a company if they are not transparent. I'm allergic to chemical fragrance and therefore flavor additives because artificial flavor always is perfume and natural flavor often is too--but is unregulated so it doesn't have to be listed--and hot oils like cinnamon and clove are chemically similar to fragrance and not ideal for me to ingest but are in all kinds of products marketed as healthy. I find it bizarre a company can't provide an ingredient list just in the service of reporting potential allergens. I've tried greens powders when my diet has been lacking at times due to poor appetite from endometriosis but some taste so bad I couldn't drink them in smoothies anyway! I also admittedly got a Nutribullet when their infomercial was in heavy rotation in 2013 and they were making outlandish claims about nutrient absorption from pulverized fruits and vegetables before the FTC made them put a visual disclaimer visible during the infomercial, but it broke pretty quickly so I didn't keep it and got a knockoff Blendtec instead for green smoothies.
I was super ticked to get some of those but after some research since the price of these products is not exactly in my price range, I am sticking to my time and energy demanding preparing these mixes myself. I do not like that proprietary blend where you have zero information of how much of what. RED FLAG
It's important I tell you now that smarter greens save my life.. I don't have access to fruits and vegetables and I don't have money for such a nutritious diet anymore I just started taking this a few months ago I didn't try to lose weight but I lost 20 lb I also stopped hurting I feel fabulous no inflammation I look amazingly different like just to look at me I look like death before so I just want everyone to know that if you don't have the money for fruits and vegetables you don't have to be in pain it's 14 or $19 at Walmart and it I don't care about the quality at this point all I know is the results I don't care what the video say all I know is the results and my depression Has Lifted so what's that about nothing else has changed in my life except this power so I call it the new miracle drug to me
I use a greens powder, it doesnt give me any feel good feeling or what ever, I add it to my protein shakes (whey issolate) and if I don't I sometimes struggle pooping.
I must be pretty cynical because you just said everything I think when I see influencers with their bloom product placements. “Oh, I guess this is the new product all the tiktokers are getting paid to promote these days, moving along.”
I take a cheaper version of AG1 one its called FS Greens. It's marketed here in UK. Since I been taking. I threw away my Anti Depressants and experienced less noticeable withdrawal effects coming off them, and my sleep has gotten better drastically. Coming off Venlafaxine is hell and let me tell you now it is no placebo for me.
The reason I was interested in the green powders was convenience. When I buy produce stuff goes bad quickly and it can be time consuming. I will try frozen then. Thanks for your input!
So anything that is marketed with a well known person is something to steer clear from. Not saying it’s necessarily a bad product but worth looking deeper into as a just in case.
Hi, thanks for educating us. Pls share your thoughts on this: Grown American Superfood - 31 Organic Whole Fruits and Vegetables Concentrated Green Powder Increase Energy and Performance - 100% Certified Organic and Vegan Non-GMO (14 Servings, 1 Bag)
Hi Justina! I'm a new viewer and not sure if you answer comments on old videos, but in case you do.... Do you have a recommendation for a high quality greens powder? I'm actually in the category of people who can't have raw fruits and veggies- I got my colon removed and live with a j pouch, so I have malabsorption and can usually only tolerate cooked spinach or juicing. Juicing takes SO LONG so I have been thinking about trying one the the green powders I see everywhere, but most of them make my scam radars go nuts which is how I found this video😆 anyways, any recs that you have would be greatly appreciated! thanks for the education😊
Hey! Due to your unique situation, I would check with your medical team. I don’t want to recommend something that your system can’t handle. Happy to have you here Ruthie!
I looked into ag1 once and saw how high the % of vitamins were, including fat soluble vitamins… taking that every day gives you way to much very quickly. You would get negative effects rather quick if you take over 200% of vitamins every single day… I’ll stick to actual veggies thank you
I have a video about taking the NASM CPT and some super old vlogs that kind of discuss it, but not a dedicated “journey” video. Maybe when I hit a big milestone 😊
I disagree. Although, not all greens powders are created equal for sure. I have tried several, and I struggle with fatigue, and consistently feel more energetic after drinking a scoop of my greens powder with water. I recommend trying different ones to find the right one for you, and see how you feel after taking it by itself.
How do you eat fruits and vegetables once a person has had to have denture surgery? I have been trying for 8 months and ready to give up and just rely on fruit smoothies for nutrition
It's quite predatory to give so much power to something that not everybody can affort confortably. Maybe if this doesn't work for the influencer that promotes it, doesn't matter, but no everyone can affort to make a _greens powder price_ mistake.
I’m not surprised because they do the same with skin care. Brands do this all the time and though it’s wrong, they literally can’t get in trouble for it unless their sued
Hello Justina, beautiful as always. Before I played the video, I thought: isn't everything a scam in today's fitness? Sadly, yes. Anyway, as always I appreciate your honesty and I hope this will help people who tend to buy these products.
You make some good points. But let's flush this out a little more. First, if you're looking for and taking ANY advice from Tik-Tok, you're living your life wrong. With that out of the way, let's proceed. In your defense you're specifying "Green Powders". But there are products out there that are specifically spinach or kale powders. The question I have is, is there a difference in quality or effectiveness between heat processed powders and freeze-dried powders? I think there may be. Leaning toward the freeze-dried product(s) being better. Lastly, as to why. I practice clean Keto. It's recommended to consume 7 to 10 cups of leafy greens a day. I can easily do four. Plus, a unit of protein. And a healthy Keto smoothie. If I can get to 10 cups of leafy greens by adding a couple-3 scoops of powdered kale to my smoothie, I'm all in. But as you say, they provide next to zero macros information. So I'm left wondering, am I consuming worthless dust or am I helping myself? Thanks for the conversation.
I totally understand what you're saying but my reason for trying one is that I truly hate most vegetables! So I hoped the powder would help me in that respect. However I found the powder to taste terrible AND it's too expensive! Now what do I do?
Hey! I'd really focus on the veggies you DO like and find ways to diversify them. Also try adding sneaky veggies into sauces, smoothies, etc. And I'd recommend getting a blood panel done to figure out if you're deficient in any vitamins. Then your doctor can recommend a supplement from there.
I’d love to hear your thoughts on Teami Blends. I’ve been using some of their products for years now. One of them happens to be their Greens Powder. Lol I only use it when I don’t want to drink coffee and/or I haven’t eaten vegetables in a long time. But I love their protein powders and their clay masks are my favorite products. Maybe you can do an arbitrary ranking video for health & wellness brands like Teami Blends and Bloom? I’m interested to see where Teami would end up.
@@JustinaErcole yes, they do sell several bloating banish products and are most well known for the 30 day teatox program (I think). I didn’t think they had laxatives in the protein powders until I read your comment and looked at the ingredient list. I should read the ingredient lists better. 😂
Thoughts on a 19 year old college kid ,who doesn't do a good job with diet, uses one of these products. Vibrant Health Green Vibrance shows exactly how much of each ingredient is in there. Are you familiar with this product?
I rarely post anything, but I struggle with this. I'm a bariatric patient. Most of meals have to be protein heavy and I seriously can't fit in full servings of fruits and veggies. I eat a little bit at each meal and take multi vitamins every day. My doc does track my blood levels and everything appears fine, but I have been drinking greens to try to boost nutrients some. How do I know I'm getting a high quality one? The one I currently use does list the daily value of the vitamins in it.
Hi! You're definitely in a different situation than most, so my advice in this video isn't really for you unfortunately. Unfortunately it's difficult to figure out which brands are "high enough quality", but I'd start by avoiding any that use proprietary blends. I'd also recommend asking an RD since they have far more nutrition training than MDs.
I have dried them ground up greens (kale, spinach,etc) to add to my food. A little sprinkle in pasta sauce, in soups/stews, whatever. Not sure how many vitamins are retained, but it is a cheap way to make me feel like I am doing something healthy for me and my family. It would probably be disgusting to drink though.
I feel like greens powders are the ultimate placebo effect. It says green so it must be good for me! And I don’t have to chew vegetables- score!! LoL
YES
I was thinking this as well! What a great placebo. Besides, it tastes horrible, so it may be good for you lol
"I don't have to chew vegetables - score!!" This is where you're wrong. Greens powders are supplements, not substitutes! You still have to eat a well balanced diet! It's not supposed to be a one-drink-fix-all solution!
It’s like the new skinny tea.
Well chewing vegetables everyday don’t even work either because it starts from the soil on the ground and from when your food come from the farms, it’s tampered with. Honestly good don’t even look like food these days, everything is Just fake that is why we deficient on many things smh.
"I'm not trying to deter you from buying a green powder"
also, "Green powders are a scam."
The reason why I think people feel it works is just to show how unbalanced our diets are. I'm sure a lot of us is short in eating enough varieties of fruit and veggies.
Absolutely!!
Your diet
Regardless of how “unbalanced” your diet is or how “organic” you eat.. our soil is shit compared to what it was in the 50’s. If you just look at the studies of soil samples and the produce grown in the soils 80 years ago vs today (as an example)… you would have to eat 53 bowls of TODAYS spinach to equal the same iron content as a bowl of spinach from 80 years ago.
Balance your diet all you want. You are never going to get enough nutrients in the modern landscape. We have been robbed of that option.
You are fooling yourself into “i just get all my nutrients from my food” no.. you don’t lol
@@jasonborne5359if we follow your advise then we might as well become cannibals
"people feel" There is the problem. Anecdotal evidence isn't.
I live in Germany and I was shown AG1 ads for the first time a few months ago. I did some research and the German consumer protection warns against these products. Once for your reasons mentioned and because often greens purchased on the Internet are poorly controlled. Thx for your video, Justina!
You're so welcome!
I'm German as well and AG1 is ALL OVER social media, it's soo annoying. Every podcaster/Instamodel/CZcamsr and their mother is advertising AG1 and gushing over how it changed their lives. They seem to forget how freaking expensive it is, like who wants to spend EUR 100per month on it?? Ridiculous, really.
@@cl5420 SAME! Thank god it's so ridiculously overpriced :D
You won't afford organic greens in German supermarkets. 😅 How much does it cost a tiny amount of microgreens on German shelves? 😮😂
Also in Germany here... So I agree with the video and the comments, AG1is just ridiculously overpriced, and constantly being shoved into my eye holes on social media...
Question for others here in Germany: Is there a green powder here that is approved and meets regulatory standards of the "German consumer protection laws"?
If I find some that are approved but The German Food Supplements Regulation (NemV), I will share them here
thanks for the honest video
Something is better than nothing, simple as that.
I don't eat vegetables that often so it's mostly for convenience. That's why I take one.
Thanks for saving me a LOT of money. Greens powders are hard for me to drink (because they are GROSS LOL and often taste like fake sweetener too) but I felt like I was missing out on something I really "should" be adding to my diet. I have apples, brocolli, cabbage, cauliflower, green beans and blueberries in my fridge so I guess I'm good!
You’re so welcome!
All that excellent fiber from the REAL fruits and vegetables you mention, will go a long way towards feeding your healthy gut bacteria. And the latest research shows that the healthiest people are actually proving to be those who have the widest variety of healthy gut bacteria.👍
They're worse for me to EAT let alone drink. Like veggies literally make me gag (and I can't process them digestive system wise either...)
Not me getting an ad for AG1 at the end of the video😂😂😂😂
NOOOOOOOO LOL
As someone who uses a green powder, I loved this video. Not because it taught me anything I wasn't already aware of, but because it was honest, educated and factual while not tearing any one side down or criticizing. Thank you. It's irritating seeing all the fitness and nutrition videos out there that are just full of false information and or no information at all sometimes, just people pushing a product.
Thank you so much for watching!
Hi Chris. Could you share which one you use and maybe any feedback on it? I’d love to find one for my daughter who can’t eat raw fruits and veggies because of allergies
Thanks again for your informed and common sense approach to fitness and nutrition. I had been a fitness instructor/personal trainer for 28 years and was also a registered dietitian, and find your content on point. Proprietary blend is the biggest scam on the market!!
Thank you for watching!
My husband and I were supposed to host Christmas this year, and we got the flu on Christmas Eve. Everyone was already in town and my brother-in-law swore that if we used a green powder, we'd get better. I was miserable and the green powder tasted like trash. Keep in mind, hubby and I are both fit, we eat a balanced diet, and we don't rely on supplements often (apart from Omegas and protein powder). Spoiler alert: the green powder didn't fast-track our recovery time. It only served to make me more unhappy. 😅 And that's okay. I wasn't expecting anything else. Maybe it gave me a little something, maybe not. I just continued to listen to my body and eat what it wanted to heal. I still have some green powder and on those days where I'm not able to get in as many fresh fruits and veggies as I'd like, I don't mind choking some down (Okay, I'm being dramatic, but it's not great.) But full reliance is dangerous for the reasons you mentioned. This is such a perfect product to market towards Americans and I'm not surprised they're so successful. We're lazy and if we could find a "take this one pill and live forever because it's all you" supplement, we'd take it. Personally, I really love vegetables and fruits, so they're not a struggle for me to get in normally and the green powders are not nearly as kind on my gut. I'm tempted to send this to my brother-in-law. His wife is part of several MLMs. They pretty much live off of various powders and red meat. It's wild.
thank you for sharing your experience!
Thank you for doing this! I see so, so many people (very random inluencers mostly) rave about this and I've always wondered it if was really worth it or not.
I can't speak for every single brand, but this is the industry standard for sure.
I LOVED that you said, not financially accessible!!! Thanks for acknowledging the people struggling to afford adequate nutrition! It's also important for more people to hear the if it's working for you, GOOD for You! As someone with chronic illness living in an ableist world, you hear about so many "cures" and we are sought out by companies, influencers, and representatives to buy the products. Much of it starts with shaming of the people who can't afford the products or food, and for those who have assumably already tried doing everything short of eating worms (I know of people who have actually consumed worms looking for a cure) and nothing worked for us, we're told we must have done it wrong, not taken it long enough, not eaten enough, etc. I've known of one good green powder that my sister-in-law used to sell and never shame anyone over it, that I thought was pretty good. I can't afford it, but it was decently trustworthy. I felt some benefits, but did it cure me? No. I do have to use electrolytes and probiotics. So here's the interesting thing to know about the marketing with that- Me, as someone with chronic illness who belongs to a large community of others who also require electrolyte supplements like people with POTS or absorption problems, etc, I have multiple social media accounts and though I'm not a big deal, I do know a couple medium deals and I'm a daily social media user. People like me, reach out to a company, to see if we can get a code and promote it for a small discount or to earn product, they respond with We'd LOVE for you to be a brand ambassador! You have to have over a million followers and then we'll sign you up. Guess what? Most people with chronic illness don't have a million followers! There's a good reason for that! But, if you ask millions of people in groups or chronic illness communities how many of them use the product, at least 80% will say they do. Many of them have subscriptions. Many of them learned about the product they use because they heard it discussed as a favorite or because it won in a lot of social media polls. But because we're not the pretty, perky, popular person, we're not enough for them. Again, ableist world, so that's something else for people to consider when hearing these stories from so-called changed/cured influencers. Great video!
"if it's working for you, GOOD for You" Or maybe they should learn to tell feelings from reality. Because you can say that about pretty much all quackery (homeopathy for example). It's still quackery and it's still (potentially) bad for you.
You can afford to have adequate nutrition if you just buy whole foods instead of these supplements. Veggies are super cheap, and much more affordable than any prepackaged food you can buy.
You don't need that garbage anyway. Meat and eggs are cheaper by the calorie and for the real nutrition they provide, no one needs vegetables.
It's mind-boggling to me that people in the US can't find out what's specifically in their food/supplements. I just learned last year that packages in the US don't use grams or anything to compare but "portion sizes".
Yeahhh it's a shame!
Not sure where you are getting your info from but all my food has grams on it
Wow that is pricey! I hate these predatory companies. I’ve been taking fruit and veggie snacks to work and eating during the day. It keeps my energy level up!
I love that tactic!
One of the things that waves massive red flags to me about greens powders (and reds, and those musrhoom supplements that were popular a few years ago, and pretty much any "holistic health and wellness" supplement) that I don't think people in general twig as being a red flag is when the product claims both anti-inflammatory properties and 'immune support'/'immune boosting'/whatever - it can't be both, inflammation is a function of the immune system, if it's suppressing inflammation it's immune suppressing. (immune 'boosting' also gets me, that's autoimmunity babes, but I assume that's fluffier language for 'supporting t-cell production' or something like that). Either of the effects are fine, there are reasons one would want that, but it can't be BOTH. They are opposing mechanisms! And that tells me the company is full of shit about their products.
Ooh good points!
thank you so much for sharing this! we need more people sharing what’s true.
You are wrong, sorry, food and vitamins can be anti-oxidants, hence decreasing inflammation, without reducing the ability of the immune system to protect the body. They don't act like ibuprofen and other medicines. Also, you can definitely boost the immune system without causing auto-immune reactions. Auto-immunity is a dysfunctional reaction of the immune system.
If your immune system is functioning properly and efficiently inflammation should be low (ie can mount a defense and clear the pathogen without getting a lot of players involved - such as an antibody binding a virus and preventing from invading a cell which would then require a larger inflammatory response to eliminate)
good video. I am an ER doc and have been taking AG for about 7 months. It seems to have improved my digestion at least, although I havent noticed any of the other claimed benefits(increased focus, energy, less sleep needed). I am curious, because I do eat fruits and veggies, like raspberries, blueberries, spinach, asparagus, broccoli cauliflower and carrots mainly. I used to have gi upset like IBS symptoms, and that is what improved on AG1....do u think its possible they some people need additional digestive support...such as is offered in some of these powders? I am guessing u would say yes. Thanks this was one of the more informative vids on the subject. Popular "influencers" are paid substantially, I believe commission based on purchases that use their code. So obviously a ton of that monthly cost is to pay those people and otherwise market...which means the product costs a fraction of the charge.
Thank you for this. It really bums me out when I see people who normally do good things make their sad drinks with green sawdust and a mini whisk, and then tell me how great it tastes. We all know it does not taste great.
hahahahaha
Have you tasted it?
Why do so many people think powdered greens should taste like ice cream??
It's mind-blowing to me how far of a reach Athletic Greens has. I consume content from different types of creators -- not just in the health and wellness space but creators in the DYI industry, Finance, and Music and they're all promoting it! It's really insane.
Oh totally
Something I think is extremely insidious about greens is that along with advertising "wellness" benefits, they prey on the very normal phenomena of being ~bloated~. Absolutely wild that so many influencers advertise a product that essentially makes something that's not usually a problem and makes it a problem 🥴
Ughhhhh they'll just slap on whatever wellness topic is trendy
I've also seen people say it helps with their menstrual cycle...not sure I buy that.
I never thought of being "bloated" was a problema until I saw it on social media lol
@@1katcab what if some people feel bloated all the time?
@@Asrg they should go to a medical doctor not to an influencer endorsed brand. As far as I know, you're not suppose to be umconfortable *all the time*
I wished you had listed some example of high quality powders vs low quality. I saw AG1 in the picture but that wasn't mentioned in the video so now I'm wondering which category it falls into. Thank you for this video just the same! ❤❤❤❤
The ones that are considered meal replacements and not “supplements”are the good ones. Most are super expensive though. Anywhere from $85-120 for 15-30 servings.
Don't waste your money on processed powders, eat more whole, fresh food whenever possible. The less that has been 'done' to it the better. Greens, fruit, root veg, legumes... Frozen unprocessed products like berries can be useful.
I had to rewatch this video since I caught myself thinking I needed to buy greens after seeing them popping up on my youtube non stop. Thanks for the video! Will probably have to rewatch when I think I need them again in a couple months lol
Debunks creators promoting a product, starts video by promoting one...
Debunks PRODUCT :)
@@JustinaErcole I disagree, you're doing the video about green powders because of it's current popularity among creators. You said so in the beginning of your video. You called it an anecdotal evidence from 1 person's experience but couldn't the same be argued to the product you're promoting? Don't get me wrong, the reason why I landed on your video is because I cancelled my subscription to AG1 Greens, se we agree on it's lack of results, but I find it ironic that you come out to discredit other creator's product placement by calling it a scam, which is a strong claim, and u place a product for profit in that very same video.
Fair enough! But the product I’m promoting isn’t lying about the ingredients or results.
@@JustinaErcole Your product doesn't have ingredients... and as for the results that's for each person to decide, hence the trial on ur product and the 90 days money guarantee on powder greens.
1- Not at any point on your video do you mention an ingredient that they have been proved to lie about. They do not disclose the composition of the blends, but that is in fact on the product nutrition list.
2- You say Green Powders are a scam. That includes all green powders, but not all green powders claim the same thing, or have the same nutrition facts. In fact most green powders offer you a 100% refund If you are unhappy with the results, which I can confirm with AG1 Greens. If the effects they claim are not visible here's your money back. How is this a scam?
3- You literally say "It never ceases to amaze me what people will say to convince you to buy things you probably don't need", alleging without proof that they are lying when they say claim they've felt the benefits of what e.g. AG1 offers. Looking at your product placement, isn't there as much proof that these people don't actually feel the benefits from powder greens as there is that you revisit Sonja Rasula's course? Doesn't your product offer a trial in case you feel that their product is to your liking you can cancel your subscription to ensure costumer satisfaction? I don't see any differences between what you are selling and AG1.
I have a 15 year old son who refuses to eat vegetables. I realize that greens powders are not ideal, but his doctor recommended it along with a good multivitamin. I also have a son leaving for college in 5 days. I just bought him some because he isn’t likely to eat anything more than donuts and chips for the next 4 years. How can I make sure that I am getting them a higher quality product? (I have to note here, my kids grew up vegetarians and they both loved vegetables until recently.)
Find ones low in heavy metals and organic ones
Definitely don’t tell people they could get freeze dried veggies/fruits and blend it into a powder or dehydrate their own to make a cheaper green powder. One that you may actually be able to trust
….what?
There are a few dehydrator/ food preserving/homesteading channels that have great green powder recipes that cost significantly less then buying it from a large company if you invest a little time and a trip to a local thrift shop for a cheap dehydrator or use your oven if it gets low enough
What are your thoughts on Tonic Greens & it's claims of curing Herpes????
If you hate greens like I do, these green powders help.
I agree with most of this! However, I do not think Athletic Greens is a scam but I DO think it is way overly marketed and the majority of people do not need it for the price. Athletic greens is for athletes, and part of the reason why it is so expensive is that it is certified Safe for Sport, i.e. the ingredients are independently tested to make sure it contains what it says it does, and not any banned substances. As someone who could be drug tested in endurance sports, that is really important for me! Anecdotally I've seen improvements in my blood work after taking AG1, and optimal levels of these vitamins and minerals can differ for athletes vs the general population. But yeah, all of the influencer marketing doesn't sit well...
Well they certainly don’t market to athletes.
4:38 well yes and no... because if they just told everyone how much of all the ingredients they put in there would be nothing stopping another company just copying the formula.... but im also not niave enough to believe that the other reason is because they don't really have optimal dosages of the specific ingredients in them to make a scientific provable difference.... 🤔
I did bloom greens for quite a few months. I started having nothing but diarrhea for 3 straight months. Stopped the greens and then got a regular poop back
Don't know if there's a correlation but.. Haven't bought any since.
HOLY CRAP! (literally lol)
@@JustinaErcole literally. Went to my gastro and then quit the greens and then didn't end up needing anything because we found what was probably causing it.
Justina, I love your objective & scientific breakdown of product marketing. Keep it going.
Thank you!
I know they're popular with neurodivergent people who have sensory issues with actual fruits & vegetables. I have the same issues but take capsule supplements to help. Are there any reputable green powder brands you recommend?
Great point! I don’t know of any (simply haven’t don’t the research) but Abbey Sharp made a video about some she trusts!
Thank you for bringing ALL this out.
So, is there a greens powder that actually delivers all the nutrients that they claim and has been scientifically proven to be beneficial? Please anyone, especially Influencers that doesn’t have sincere scientific evidence with old from replying.
Bloom is owned by a pretty scammy/untrustworthy influencer in my opinion. I used to follow her a long time ago, but her business decisions, how she marketed her fitness, and consistently bad form turned me off over time.
Yeahhhh I’ve heard, but I didn’t even want to mention her haha
My first ad was for athletic greens😂
Bahahahahha
I didn't read the comments so this may already be there but one of the reasons these companies do not list any vitamin and/or mineral amounts is because labeling law for these is pretty strict (at least in Europe) and usually that also means regular testing of the amounts of vitamins which are some of the most expensive tests you can do on food products (I know I work in food manufacturing). Vitamin and mineral labelling is complicated but the companies listing blends instead of vitamin/mineral amounts are trying to save money on lab tests and possible corrective actions due to too low/high amounts as well as inconsistent amounts in the final product.
Should you believe everything a label says, NO but if vitamins and minerals are listed on a label, it means it is tested regularly (again at least in Europe) and that's a bigger effort to give accurate information to consumers than just listing blends.
Very rare. A CZcams post that's clear, honest, up front, simply explained and easy to listen to. Funny thing is that an AG1 advert came on right after my view.. How ironic is that...
Every single thing you said was accurate and rational. Especially the point to which why wouldn't the company tell us the amounts if they truly want it to help us. I can only imagine what those $9.99 tubs of greens at Marshalls or TJ Max have in it.
Does anyone have a recommendation on finding high quality greens powders? Are there any products that are transparent about the ingredients and production process? TBH, I use greens powders because I just hate the taste and texture of most vegetables. I've found that putting a scope of powder into my daily fruit smoothie is the most realistic way to regularly get it into my body. I realize that "eat vegetables" is an easy answer a lot of people are giving, but that's kinda like saying "abstinence is the safest form of sex".
There’s a lot of evidence for the health benfits of spirulina and Chlorella even for people who eat a balanced diet. but idk about these blend things.
Well I for one who doesn’t eat greens or veggies I can tell a huge difference in how I feel after a couple weeks I guess it’s all in my head
There are brands that are transparent on their ingredients. (supergreen tonik is an example… no affiliation)
ok
I tried AG1 for 2 months, then came to my senses and cancelled. I think the product does have some good things in it, but the company promises so many benefits from the product that it is quite unrealistic. The other thing is that the powder does not completely dissolve after being shaken in water, so there is always powder sediment left at the bottom of your glass. And it is outrageously expensive. As Justine mentioned, all supplements are unregulated so you really don’t know what you are actually getting.
Question what is your opinion on: Option 1) if you make your own greens powder. You buy organic vegetables save the green from the actual vegetables. Then you wash, then blanc to get rid of the oxalic acid and kill off the bacteria, then dehydrate low temperature at 110 deg F and slowly until dry. Then you powdered, then condition it to make sure the powder is dry, and then vacuum seal in a glass jar for long term storage until ready to use. I would consider this high content green powder. Option 2) if you buy variety of organic green vegetables, algae, mushrooms either already dehydrate leaves or powder green for that one ingredient from organic suppliers by the pound (ex. Spirulina, blue green algae, moringa leaves things you cannot normally buy at the farmers market, but can buy online)and mi-x them powders together to make your own mixture? What would you think of those 2 options or combinations of them together. Their are a bunch of videos from homesteaders that make their own greens powder from their own home grown crops. Or people like myself who hate eating green vegetables but does have access local farmers market who sell organic vegetables when in season. And we can pre-make so we have greens in a powdered to use when we cannot get local fresh vegetables. It takes a bit of work but wouldn’t it be much healthier then nothing from the sounds these pre-mix manufacture green powdered and a lot cheaper too?
1:17 That writing is a crime against humanity!
to be honest as a european is since covid I'm hearing about AG and thought it was crazy, but then seeing the price and media coverage by sponsorship even by professionals (like Huberman) I though I was the mad one. If you want to pay 100$ to not eat your broccoli not gonna complain
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Despite the uncertainty surrounding the quality or quantity of ingredients, businesses successfully leverage the placebo effect to drive substantial revenue. Our inclination to believe in the effectiveness of such products leads to repeated purchases, as our perception is influenced by this psychological phenomenon. Nonetheless, it's reasonable to assume that consuming greens is preferable to not receiving essential nutrients at all, right? I totally see your point though Justina!!! Great video! I feel your frustration. 😎
I like your product criticism, however, because I work in the industry I can confidently say that *your take is one side of the story.* While there are companies that either use cheap ingredients or falsify data on the percentage of ingredients, some are genuine. For example, the company I work for had to obscure the percentage of some ingredients within a complex mix because other companies could "steal" our formula. We took that measure because of the expense of the patent. How many countries can we cover? Or how many products do we want to patent? All it would take to make a patent worthless is using an alternative ingredient in another mix, just one change can nullify your patent. So, instead, we went through the route of hiding our actual percentages. We are sure of our quality and quantity that if it is quality checked at any point in time it would be exactly what we say it is. Besides, we also stand on the premise that when a consumer uses our product and finds that it delivers as promised, then they will tell their friends and family about us, this differentiates us from the rest.
I shit you not, before this video played, I got an ad for AG1. 😂
Hahahahahah noooooo
Hi! From a licensed therapist perspective. Qualitative data is just as important as quantitative data. Some might argue more important because it looks at the persons lived experience that is unique and tailored to them since each one of us have our own unique variables. Media has put more emphasis on numbers but it should be balanced. That being said, if it works for you, it works for you because you have your own unique needs, wants, beliefs, and values. Simply just giving someone “data” and “facts” leaves out the human experience because we do not live in a vacuum. Side note: there is nothing wrong with the placebo effect. It’s a powerful tool and a persons “buy in” is what matters. Again because we are human and each have our own beliefs that are extremely powerful. Do what makes you happy y’all. Everyone has an “opinion” (belief) and remember, believing is seeing. Not the other way around 😊
Like I said multiple times in the video, if people benefit from these products I think that’s great. I’m simply providing more information so people can be educated consumers.
Thank you for covering this. I’m so sick of influencers. Mari has no accreditation but for some reason people just trust her.
She just launched the protein bar and since you have to disclose ingredients, people are APPALLED at them lol
Thinking of them as supplements is the problem. If you are growing your own greens for better health, and want to have them over the winter, they must be preserved. Dried greens (well, dried anything grown) are never "as good" as fresh. This is undeniable. But, the real question is how much nutrition is lost if you dry them with the best methods and procedures, and what are those best methods and procedures.
And, even if they did tell you the items in the blends, what they don't tell you is that all the greens are industrially grown in greenhouses where the glass and plastic keep out UV rays that are necessary for proper photosynthesis. Tomatoes were tested as having appx 300 phytonutrients (grown outside) compared with only appx 50 phytonutrients (grown in a greenhouse).
Conclusion? Grow your own greens, and preserve them naturally yourself.
Also, I do not believe it is cynical to believe the worst about the products produced by corporations. Money is their objective. That is not cynicism; it is reality. People buy these products because they want benefits without any real personal cost. Eating your greens fresh is best. Grow your own, and preserve what you can for times when the weather and climate where you are keep you from growing them.
Remember, many greens can grow outside year round. I had Kale and Swiss Chard growing all winter. It snowed on them three times, and we had frosts (a couple of them hard frosts) five or six times, last winter. (And I live in Tucson, AZ where that is not supposed to happen! Yes, please pity me. LOL) But seriously, folks. They just laughed at the cold and the snow. They are super proud greens to be sure. HA HA HA
Then, they made it through our super hot and dry summer this year. Obviously, I am propagating new plants from them as I type. We need more soldiers like them in the Food Forest.
So make our own and get the same or better effect. Heard!
This is why I get all of my supplements from Alex Jones.
Makes sense the way she put it, especially in the end. She makes a valid argument. These supplements are likely healthy, and worth a look. If you like the product as she said, and you have the money, and you want to put something with health benefits into your body (although not fully knowing those benefits) then do it.
I loathe proprietary ingredients and don't trust a company if they are not transparent. I'm allergic to chemical fragrance and therefore flavor additives because artificial flavor always is perfume and natural flavor often is too--but is unregulated so it doesn't have to be listed--and hot oils like cinnamon and clove are chemically similar to fragrance and not ideal for me to ingest but are in all kinds of products marketed as healthy. I find it bizarre a company can't provide an ingredient list just in the service of reporting potential allergens. I've tried greens powders when my diet has been lacking at times due to poor appetite from endometriosis but some taste so bad I couldn't drink them in smoothies anyway! I also admittedly got a Nutribullet when their infomercial was in heavy rotation in 2013 and they were making outlandish claims about nutrient absorption from pulverized fruits and vegetables before the FTC made them put a visual disclaimer visible during the infomercial, but it broke pretty quickly so I didn't keep it and got a knockoff Blendtec instead for green smoothies.
I was super ticked to get some of those but after some research since the price of these products is not exactly in my price range, I am sticking to my time and energy demanding preparing these mixes myself. I do not like that proprietary blend where you have zero information of how much of what. RED FLAG
Thanks because you saved me money on getting these. We love truth that protects us from scammer-corporations.
Tried one 10+ years ago. Was supposed to help with weight loss. The only thing it did was make me hate mornings, it was so foul.
Ooooof no!
It's important I tell you now that smarter greens save my life.. I don't have access to fruits and vegetables and I don't have money for such a nutritious diet anymore I just started taking this a few months ago I didn't try to lose weight but I lost 20 lb I also stopped hurting I feel fabulous no inflammation I look amazingly different like just to look at me I look like death before so I just want everyone to know that if you don't have the money for fruits and vegetables you don't have to be in pain it's 14 or $19 at Walmart and it I don't care about the quality at this point all I know is the results I don't care what the video say all I know is the results and my depression Has Lifted so what's that about nothing else has changed in my life except this power so I call it the new miracle drug to me
I use a greens powder, it doesnt give me any feel good feeling or what ever, I add it to my protein shakes (whey issolate) and if I don't I sometimes struggle pooping.
I must be pretty cynical because you just said everything I think when I see influencers with their bloom product placements. “Oh, I guess this is the new product all the tiktokers are getting paid to promote these days, moving along.”
I scroll past immediately when I see Bloom 😂
I literally got an AG1 ad on this video 😭😂
LOL. NOOOOO
I take a cheaper version of AG1 one its called FS Greens. It's marketed here in UK. Since I been taking. I threw away my Anti Depressants and experienced less noticeable withdrawal effects coming off them, and my sleep has gotten better drastically. Coming off Venlafaxine is hell and let me tell you now it is no placebo for me.
What if I absolutely hate the taste of vegetables because I am a meat eater....would I benefit from green powder?
The reason I was interested in the green powders was convenience. When I buy produce stuff goes bad quickly and it can be time consuming. I will try frozen then. Thanks for your input!
So anything that is marketed with a well known person is something to steer clear from. Not saying it’s necessarily a bad product but worth looking deeper into as a just in case.
Hi, thanks for educating us. Pls share your thoughts on this:
Grown American Superfood - 31 Organic Whole Fruits and Vegetables Concentrated Green Powder Increase Energy and Performance - 100% Certified Organic and Vegan Non-GMO (14 Servings, 1 Bag)
Here's what's in Field of Greens by brick house
👇 And here's the ingredients on the back of the jar
👇
NUTRITION FACTS
Ingredients: Organic Greens Blend
(Organic Spinach Powder, Organic Parsley
Powder, Organic Kale Powder, Organic
Servings Per Container: 30
Barley Grass Powder, Organic Wheat Grass
Serving Size
1 Scoop (10g) Powder, Organic Spirulina Powder, Organic
Chlorella Powder, Organic Green Pepper
Amount Per Serving
Powder, Organic Green Apple Powder,
10
Organic Green Banana Powder, Organic
Calories
Sweet Potato Powder, Organic Broccoli
Powder), Organic Prebiotic Fiber (Inulin),
% Daily Value * Organic Antioxidant Reds Blend
(Organic Beet Root Powder, Organic
Total FatOg Og 0%
Strawberry Powder, Organic Raspberry
Powder, Organic Blueberry Powder
Saturated Fat 0g
Organic Tart Cherry Powder, Organic
0%
Pomegranate Powder, Organic Cranberry
Trans Fat Og Powder), Organic Metabolic Blend
(Organic Ginger Powder, Organic Licorice
0%
Cholesterol Omg
Powder, Organic Turmeric Powder, Organic
Green Tea Powder)
Sodium 10mg
Hi Justina! I'm a new viewer and not sure if you answer comments on old videos, but in case you do....
Do you have a recommendation for a high quality greens powder?
I'm actually in the category of people who can't have raw fruits and veggies- I got my colon removed and live with a j pouch, so I have malabsorption and can usually only tolerate cooked spinach or juicing. Juicing takes SO LONG so I have been thinking about trying one the the green powders I see everywhere, but most of them make my scam radars go nuts which is how I found this video😆 anyways, any recs that you have would be greatly appreciated! thanks for the education😊
Hey! Due to your unique situation, I would check with your medical team. I don’t want to recommend something that your system can’t handle. Happy to have you here Ruthie!
Green powders work my dad had severe acidic issues in his body , the greens helped his body feel better .
Thank you for this, you just saved me $50 a month😊
Glad I could help!
I looked into ag1 once and saw how high the % of vitamins were, including fat soluble vitamins… taking that every day gives you way to much very quickly. You would get negative effects rather quick if you take over 200% of vitamins every single day… I’ll stick to actual veggies thank you
Justina, do you have a video in how you became a personal trainer? As an aspiring one or would be helpful!
I have a video about taking the NASM CPT and some super old vlogs that kind of discuss it, but not a dedicated “journey” video. Maybe when I hit a big milestone 😊
Had a huel greens advert before opening this video 😂
I disagree. Although, not all greens powders are created equal for sure. I have tried several, and I struggle with fatigue, and consistently feel more energetic after drinking a scoop of my greens powder with water. I recommend trying different ones to find the right one for you, and see how you feel after taking it by itself.
That’s great! But remember that anecdotal evidence isn’t the same as controlled studies.
This is bullcrap. Ag1 changed my health completely for the better.
How do you eat fruits and vegetables once a person has had to have denture surgery? I have been trying for 8 months and ready to give up and just rely on fruit smoothies for nutrition
Man as someone who works in the pharmaceutical industry, i cannot believe the claims that the supplement industry can get away with...
It’s wildddd
@@pmason6076my thoughts exactly. 😂
It's quite predatory to give so much power to something that not everybody can affort confortably. Maybe if this doesn't work for the influencer that promotes it, doesn't matter, but no everyone can affort to make a _greens powder price_ mistake.
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
I always assumed most people drinking greens are like me and don’t eat much greens. So what about people who actually need it. What is the research.
LOL at the greens powder ad that played before this video
Hahaha nooooo
Not gonna lie, I was hoping this video would be sponsored by AG1 for the giggles.
I’m not surprised because they do the same with skin care. Brands do this all the time and though it’s wrong, they literally can’t get in trouble for it unless their sued
Hello Justina, beautiful as always. Before I played the video, I thought: isn't everything a scam in today's fitness? Sadly, yes. Anyway, as always I appreciate your honesty and I hope this will help people who tend to buy these products.
Not everything, but unfortunately many things :)
You make some good points. But let's flush this out a little more. First, if you're looking for and taking ANY advice from Tik-Tok, you're living your life wrong. With that out of the way, let's proceed. In your defense you're specifying "Green Powders". But there are products out there that are specifically spinach or kale powders. The question I have is, is there a difference in quality or effectiveness between heat processed powders and freeze-dried powders? I think there may be. Leaning toward the freeze-dried product(s) being better. Lastly, as to why. I practice clean Keto. It's recommended to consume 7 to 10 cups of leafy greens a day. I can easily do four. Plus, a unit of protein. And a healthy Keto smoothie. If I can get to 10 cups of leafy greens by adding a couple-3 scoops of powdered kale to my smoothie, I'm all in. But as you say, they provide next to zero macros information. So I'm left wondering, am I consuming worthless dust or am I helping myself? Thanks for the conversation.
One thing is for sure everyone has got to eat something.
AG1 commercial before during and after the video, I can't!! Lol
LOL
I totally understand what you're saying but my reason for trying one is that I truly hate most vegetables! So I hoped the powder would help me in that respect. However I found the powder to taste terrible AND it's too expensive! Now what do I do?
Hey! I'd really focus on the veggies you DO like and find ways to diversify them. Also try adding sneaky veggies into sauces, smoothies, etc. And I'd recommend getting a blood panel done to figure out if you're deficient in any vitamins. Then your doctor can recommend a supplement from there.
Yes I have been asking fS greens for a while and they still have not got back to me about how much of everything there is in their package
I’d love to hear your thoughts on Teami Blends. I’ve been using some of their products for years now. One of them happens to be their Greens Powder. Lol I only use it when I don’t want to drink coffee and/or I haven’t eaten vegetables in a long time. But I love their protein powders and their clay masks are my favorite products. Maybe you can do an arbitrary ranking video for health & wellness brands like Teami Blends and Bloom? I’m interested to see where Teami would end up.
Isn't that the diet tea company? I know they put a lot of laxatives in their products.
@@JustinaErcole yes, they do sell several bloating banish products and are most well known for the 30 day teatox program (I think). I didn’t think they had laxatives in the protein powders until I read your comment and looked at the ingredient list. I should read the ingredient lists better. 😂
Thoughts on a 19 year old college kid ,who doesn't do a good job with diet, uses one of these products. Vibrant Health Green Vibrance shows exactly how much of each ingredient is in there. Are you familiar with this product?
Adding to the scam that you actually need fruits and vegetables. Honestly, you're better off just eating real whole food.
What?
Is Huel a good brand?
Never knew these existed. Another one added to the useless supplements list.
Yup lol
I rarely post anything, but I struggle with this. I'm a bariatric patient. Most of meals have to be protein heavy and I seriously can't fit in full servings of fruits and veggies. I eat a little bit at each meal and take multi vitamins every day. My doc does track my blood levels and everything appears fine, but I have been drinking greens to try to boost nutrients some. How do I know I'm getting a high quality one? The one I currently use does list the daily value of the vitamins in it.
Hi! You're definitely in a different situation than most, so my advice in this video isn't really for you unfortunately. Unfortunately it's difficult to figure out which brands are "high enough quality", but I'd start by avoiding any that use proprietary blends. I'd also recommend asking an RD since they have far more nutrition training than MDs.
I have dried them ground up greens (kale, spinach,etc) to add to my food. A little sprinkle in pasta sauce, in soups/stews, whatever. Not sure how many vitamins are retained, but it is a cheap way to make me feel like I am doing something healthy for me and my family. It would probably be disgusting to drink though.
Hahaha you’d need a lot of sweetener
Haha i got an ag1 ad before this video
I don't think you can scroll on CZcams any more without seeing some strategically placed ad reads for Skillshare at the front of the video...
Hahahahha touché
I have a issue with how little it shows whats in it,if they were honest id buy it more often.