‘A problem in Washington, not just in Tel Aviv’ : Marwan Bishara
Vložit
- čas přidán 29. 05. 2024
- Al Jazeera’s senior political analyst Marwan Bishara highlights the deception within the Israeli war cabinet, led by Benny Gantz, Netanyahu, and Gadi Eisenkot, regarding the true motive behind the Rafah assault.
Bishara criticizes Israel’s refusal of a prisoner exchange, despite Hamas’s acceptance facilitated by the US. He questions the swift return to diplomacy, pointing to underlying issues within both Tel Aviv and Washington, particularly the apparent betrayal of CIA Director William Burns by his own administration.
Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow us on Twitter / ajenglish
Find us on Facebook / aljazeera
Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
Check out our Instagram page: / aljazeeraenglish
Download AJE Mobile App: aje.io/AJEMobile
#Gaza #GazaUnderAttack #FreeGaza #PrayForGaza #GazaUnderFire #GazaWar #GazaUnderSiege #Israel #Palestine #StopTheWar
Thank you Mr. Marwan Bashira. You have become my favorite political analyst of the Middle East. Thank you Al Jazeera for all yor outstanding staff members.
Same opinion here!!!
And here!
Mr Bashira provides no real argument and at no point challenges why these terrorists hamas keep using women and children as human shields, lie about ceasefires and abuse hostages in medieval conditions in tunnels for 7 months. Keep going Israel the world is behind you
Yalla!..I agree..but then..I'm Irish...how could I not.
Yeah me too
Al Jazeera is my go to news source and in my opinion the best objective news to be found anywhere.
Agreed 💯👍
Stop this genocide!
There's no genocide 😂
It’s not even a war. Only one side has an army, it’s not a hostage rescue tactic either, it’s clearly a land grab and massacre
Tell that to Arabs
@@efi13efinot in Israel it's a hidden secret...ask Al Jazeera 😂
@@tedbartlettvideochannel5740 you mean the Hamas mouthpiece?😂
Marwan is so brilliant. He is my ideal. Marwan, If you read this, people like you are the inspiration behind young people like us who are setting up encampments.
Marwan is a total fool and ignores facts and history. Alas he is inspiring the next bunch of fools to run around chanting for death. what a Rodney
Only that can make elites in WH start listening
I think Mr. Marwan is correct. The problem is in washington.
Blinken needs to be investigated. Ties, investments, history, harddrive.
What a good idea 🤔
@@tedbartlettvideochannel5740The jew Blinken is an Israëlian citizen. And a Zionist. And zionists always lie.It’s in their genes.
Marwan is a real professional. Always great to listen to him.
Nathanyahu NEVER had good INTENTIONS for ANYONE STOP this NOW Thank you 🌹
Yahoo only wants his political security
If he accepts ceasefire, out he goes!!
He want to occupy more land full of blood 🩸
"The israelis just don't care" what happens to Palestinians.
If that is the israeli attitude towards a so-called neighbour, then how much less do they care for the rest of the world's people?
Are you listening all you American evangelicals?
@@hitreset0291 Don't they spit on them as they pass by!!
Anthony Blinken is a "dual citizen" of ISRAEL and the USA...Blinken represents ISRAEL not the United States, yet he is the Sec. State.
And you talk nonsense with no valid point. Every so called Palestinian is Egyptian, Syrian, Jordanian et al. Only about 1/7th of the now called Palestinian population actually comes from the lands of Israel.
Blinken really does represent the US! America multiracial make-up is the well-kept secret of our Greatness. 👀👀👀👀😁😁
I don't trust blinken
Absolutely right!!
@amurry5042, you missed the point...The emphasis is on DUAL CITIZENSHIP
Al Jazeera the best channel I have come across. You’re Journalists and Analysts are extraordinarily brilliant at their jobs. So refreshing to hear truth. Thanks for all your coverage .
Respects M Bishara for the real question.
Does he condemn Hamas?😗😗😗😗
@@paulgifis1908
Would you condemn an owner of a house who is defending his family against a murderous intruder?
@@paulgifis1908
@@Amen.ahmed1 No.. But when his land, government, and people get conquered by another power, then it is time to surrender. Cultures come and go! Land ownership comes and goes
@@paulgifis1908do you have any idea in what time we are living. Yes we are living in 2024. If you think racism against another religion is a good thing then you should go many centuries back in time.
The root cause of all this is the occupation
The root cause of all this was the Arab world refusing to accept the two state solution where Arabs were given more land than the Jews at the end of WW2 two years after 6 million jews were genocided. The Arabs went to war and lost. Then after 1948 they invented a Palestinian people that never existed in any history before.
Right,so all palestinians must get out of Jewish land!
We're not here to solve the actual problem, but to point fingers.
No its not. The problem is HAMAS. These pro-Hamas media have been LYING to us. They have NOT been telling us the REAL facts.
For example :
1) No one here knows that Hamas leaders have RECORDED THEMSELVES publically calling for the death of ALL Jews around the world for YEARS (Do not take my word for it. Go watch the videos yourself).
2) The reason why ALL Arab countries REFUSE to accept Palestinian refugees is because Palestinian terrorist groups tried to over throw the governments in Jordan (the Black September War of 1970 which saw 26,000 people killed), the Second Lebanon Civil War (which the Palestinian Liberation Army started, and THAT is why they were forced out of Lebanon), and Hamas working with the Muslom Brotherhood to overthrow the Egyptian government. Even Egypt who shares a border with Gaza won't even allow in injured women and children into Egypt. Again STOP believing these LIES from the pro-Hamas media. 3) Hamas killed HUNDREDS of Palestinians when it took over the Gaza Strip in 2005. 4) They are NOT telling us that Hamas has a policy of kidnapping and torturing gays in Gaza. 5) They are NOT telling us that its HAMAS who has been DEMANDING a war with Israel for YEARS and has been firing rockets at Israeli women and children for DECADES now. (Go look it up yourself . There is a reason why Israel has the most advanced anti-rocket system in the world. Did you ever stop to ask yourself WHY?!) 6)And they are NOT showing us the HAMAS videos showing Hamas firing rockets from next to schools and residential areas, even though they KNEW that Palestinian children would die when Israel struck back. Hamas is PURE EVIL. Hamas has finally got the war they have been BEGGING for for YEARS AND YEARS AND YEARS. And its the Palestinians who are suffering for it.
Yes occupation of the Jewish land
Marwan always on point. Very educational to hear your analysis.
No he's a terrorist sympathizer 🤔
Natanyahu is the problem and not the solution.
Not only zionism is the problem
Palerstinians are the problem not the solution.
to your dreams?
As soon as Netafkface is out, another one just as bad will take his place.
Hamass want israel to accept a total surrender der leaving hamass in place ,releasing thousands of terrorists etc so naturally israel refused ,hamass behaves like they landed in Normandy..
America need freedom from AIPAC. Solidarity with Palestine today and forever.
😂 absolutely.
But unfortunately, it's only wishful thinking
I love this guy he is the greatest political analyst
He is absolutely the worst!! Thats why he is on Al Jazeera
@@amurry5042 You win the contest for the most HATEFUL
@@amurry5042 Al Jazeera report the truth and no propaganda
stop this genocide
Apparently H tried to organise a hostage exchange deal a few days after October 7th, however, Netanyahu rejected the offer and hid it from the public.
@@amurry5042Of course he did. He's the devil incarnate. Israel is quickly becoming the pariah of the world.
Egypt have said H have offered 3 times since the beginning to return them in exchange for a cease fire and I refused.
@@shikarahaar netanyahu and most israelis wanted war absolutely - They want Gaza to disappear, they want the land
You know it can't work like that, right?
@@shikarahaar Israel is not interested in the hostages, it never has been. it just wants to flatten Gazza.
Marwan Bishara is brillant
He is not.
Started wth Iraq war . He helped us knew much deeper the manoeuvres
Marian must receive an award for stellar journalism. He is a man of great intelligence, integrity , and I admire his analyses of the PM as a pathological liar- and why does the U S let Israel get away with it????
So refreshing to listen to accurate, intelligent reporting on this atrocious genocide
Netanyahu goes to the ICC. Send him there.
Stop Genocide
That's b'cos Blinkey is an Israeli...not an American.
Surely, this is one of these best channels around.
Can not support genocide.
Thank you marwan.
These pro-Hamas media are NOT telling us the whole truth.
Don't believe me? Well, did you know that Hamas has a policy of imprisioning and torturing gays and lesbians? (No, you did not know that. Go watch the testimonial videos from the survivors)
Did you know that Hamas has been firing rockets at Israeli women and children for DECADES now? (did you ever stop and ask yourself WHY Israel has the most advanced anti-rocket system in the world? THAT's why)
Did you now that Hamas has RECORDED THEMSELVES demanding a war with Israel?
Go watch the videos. Go read Hamas' mission statement. Their sole purpose is to destroy the state of Israel.
Did you know that 20% of Israel's population are PALESTINIANS who own land and businesses and can travel within Israel? (how many Jews are in the Gaza Strip? NONE.)
Did you know that the Jews who lived in the Gaza Strip for thousands of years were forced out after the Palestinians there MASSACRED hundreds of Jews in 1929? NO, you did NOT know about any of this because the pro-Hamas media has been controlling what we see and hear.
One last thing : There were 80,000 Jews living in Bagdad in 1900. There were hundreds of thousands of Jews living in Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Syria, Jordan, Lebanon, Lybia, Omar, Iran, Turkey, and other countries in the Middle East in 1900.
Now there are none. WHAT HAPPENED TO THOSE JEWS? Can ANYONE here tell me what happened to those ARAB Jews who lived in those countries for THOUSANDS of years?
They were KILLLED or forced out of their homes. Where did they move to ? The Holy Lands
Excellent discussion. I've been very impressed with al Jazeera coverage and analysis
It was never about Hamas or the hostages
🇵🇸 I am the Palestinian flag. My colors represent my people. My people represent me my colors. Also have a meaning the black is for the darkest day of our history. The white is the resilience, the purity in our hearts to seek justice and freedom the red is the sacrifice we pay in blood the green is for my land, for I am the Palestinian flag a flag, which ruffles throughout the world to signify justice in freedom🇵🇸🕊️🕊️🕊️🕊️🕊️🕊️🕊️🕊️✌🏼✌🏼✌🏼✌🏼
The Palestinian flag represents terrorism. It symbolises hatred and murder nothing more and nothing less.
I love palestinian flag with my heart
Beautiful ❤️❤️❤️
Prospective is everything, any human suffering on any side is not bearable in any humane and non barbaric society. Let's not forget that there are thousands of hostages, Palestinians held in Israeli prisons in a so called democratic society without due process and without charge. They have been held for years and no one in the world has raised and eyebrow. Amongst whom we have children and women !!!!
There you go talking rubbish. But you want facts.... Palestinians as a people were invented by Arabs after the loss of the 1948 war. And thats according to the leaders of the Palestinians. Even Arrafat was Egyptian. Palestinians started a war in Israel on the ~OCT 7th and committed the most heinous crimes and genocide and now complain they are loosing the war they wanted.
@amurry5042 Hamas' crimes look like childs play in comparison to these Zionists. That's why Israel doesn't want any media coverage of whats happening. Here I thought Jewish ppl were smart & empathic. Guess the world will really see the truth now.
@@amurry5042 Palestine belongs to Palestinians
@@amurry5042You are a perfect combination of ignorant and evil 🙈
@@amurry5042 you are a complete combination of ignorance and evilness. 🙈👹😈
The most important video I’ve watched today. Thank you
" Gentleman's Word " doesn't exist anymore!!
❤️ Marwan Bishara ❤️❤️❤️🙌
Thank you so much Mr. Marwan Bishara and Ms. Elizabeth for great analysis as always. My respect and honour to you both. ❤❤❤❤❤
This ENDS NOW Thank you 🌹
Thank you Mr. Marwan Bashira
For the ones who arent subscription to Aljazeera. Please do it.. to show israel they made a mistake.
The more subscribers, the more the messages of Aljazeera will be seen
I've watched it and what a load of biased tripe!
I subcriped - thank you
Evil only Netanyahu should icc need action on Netanyahu
In a just world Herzog, Smodrich, Gvir and Galant would all be on trial this is societal its bigger than Netanyahu
The only evil comes from Palestinians following the hamas doctrine.
Attacking Rafah is politics, not strategic warfare.
It is deterrence and self- defense.
@@talmudovsky Not when you are an occupier.
@@TheStrategos392 BS. Israel holds ownership for all lands including Gaza and West Bank under bulletproof international law since 1948.
Of course, next thing from you would be - you are liar.
Go ahead, try me.
@@TheStrategos392 BS. Under bulletproof international law Israel holds ownership title for all territories of British Mandate for Palestine, including Gaza and West Bank, since 1948. Hence it is not an occupier and never been.
It is more genocide.
Marwan thank you sir
An intelligent man.
It would be an insult to Netanyahu to paint him as caring for the hostages.
Do YOU care for the hostages?
Netanyahu s'en fout des otages et des familles d'otages. S'ils meurent ce n'est pas son problème...
It would be an insult to Palestinian Hamas to paint them as caring for their own people let alone hostages.
@JackFieldBand
because I'm a human being I do care about ALL The hostages, including the 8+ thousand Palestinian jailed since October 7 without charges.
Do you care for the thousands of Palestinians who are dying?@@JackFieldBand
Stop sending any money to Israel
And weapons.
I love aljazeera and their unbiased no BS news!!
Palestinian civilians are not Hamas. Just because Hamas is a Palestinian group that does not mean all the Palestinians are Hamas. Just like how in Israel not all civilians there are the idf.
Yes but ...70% support Oct 7th even now the rest are plo supporters which is a little milder hamass version basically same s**t mierda .
@user-oi6zd3lq6e 50% of Palestinians in Gaza are less than 18 years. Average age of causality is 5 years old. Let that sink in. Since when did kids anywhere vote for anything?
@@user-oi6zd3lq6e The children?
@@user-oi6zd3lq6eAnd with your logice moat isralis support idf som..
This may be true but it astonishes me how many Israeli citizens seem totally ignorant about what is actually happening in Gaza and that's scary😮
ICC where are you?!?!??!? Take immediate action against netanyahu and his israeli ministers!!! Shame on you all for remaining silent!
We desperately need NEW world leaders. Leaders who believe in Justice. Freedom. Peace. Humanity.
The problem is everywhere
Wrong. The main problem is with Biden and Netanyahu.
No its not. It is in the Quran.
😊😊😊marwan I enjoy your predictions…….keep up the good work…….
Marwan try doing some research before you spout nonsense
@@amurry5042 yeah a research for a nonsense tomato like you😁😁😁
Great to see Mr Bishara smile at the end☺
Thank You Al Jazeera from Canada. I like your coverage of the Gaza issue.
Marwan is too intelligent: why did Biden send Burns to negotiate, get Ganas to agree, and then leave Burns out to dry when Israel rejected it?
Israel didn't reject anything. The Palestinains made up their own cease fire just after they fired rockets killing Israelis at the Aid crossing and just before Israel had plans to carry on the war, started by Palestinians, without Israel ever seeing this peace plan or agreeing to it. Rodney!
@@amurry5042 Wow. Where did you get that crazy scoop? Were you in the negotiations? Why do people repeat stupid stuff they know nothing about? Where did you hear this shyte? What makes you think it's a good idea to just repeat stuff for the sake of repeating it?
@@amurry5042😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Hamas called Netanyahu's bluff. However, this deal that they wouldn't agree to is already starting to make some pro Israel voices start to doubt many things now
Outstanding analysis ❤
I have total respect for this gentleman the second war finishes Netanyahu and his govt are finished in elections m.bishara is very well educated
No he is very biased and can only see things from one angle. Its called narrow minded
Marwen knows the right questions.
Americans are benefiting from this war and this conflict actually the Americans are behind all of this situation
A single Netajew who is being fed by superpowers has put the whole world upside down?
What a joke !!
Israel owns the US government, industries, and markets. Biden is a puppet enjoying the power of Aipac SSS. But he also knows that if he doesn't jump high enough the Zionist mafia will destroy him.
It is a zionist problem not a jewish problem.
You are sounding a bit racist there matey. Actually it's the invention of a Palestinian people and the Fanatics in Iran that have achieved that. Including Hezbollah, that have ruined Lebanon despite having no elected mandate. Palestinians supporting the hamas doctrine have completely ruined Gaza. Thery could have built an incredible Gaza but opted for genocide in Israel and then moan about loosing a other war.
Excuse you?
Satanyahu being a POS has nothing to do with his ethnicity or religion.
THE PALESTINE PEOPLE AND ISRAELI PEOPLE. MATTER. PEACE FOR BOTH PEOPLE AND THE WORLD PEACE.
Arrest Netanyahu.
Burns is not Jewish. The others are. Its time they were replaced.
Anti-Zionism is not anti-Semitism. Yeah, right.
@@JackFieldBandperpetual 'victimization' marketing narrative
@@JackFieldBandJews are not semites.. Arabs are semites and African jews are semites. Israëlis are AshkeNazis from Europe. 0% Semite blood. Thats why dna test are forbidden in Israël.
Time you were replaced. Maybe hope over to live in Iran.
@@JackFieldBandyou have to be a Semit first, which non of you aren't. Kick rock, or in your case, pound sand
Thank you very much for the update
Palestinians and Israelis are neighbours they should not be enemies. They should live in peace now. And don’t say Hamas started the war because they did not.
Where is humanity???
ICC n UN security please call together a world army to go protect Rafah and send the Isreali back. Failure to do this means years to come ICC will have no respect!
this dude is the type of dialogue we need
Marvan brother, you are great from pakistan .we need a lot of Marvin's God bless you
Wow. Keep bringing him on please. Passionate and grounded in factual analysis. Excellent coverage of America dragging its feet in making the right choices.
Thank you..🙏🙏🙏👨🌾🚜👨🌾
Brother marwan Wishart is a very highly educated man and he speaks facts with honesty god blesses him and his family and all the folks at aj keep up the good work fr us alll and God almighty is with us allllllll❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Aamerican snakey approach
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Marwan Bishara, being the usual genious he is.
Unbelievable
Marwan's analysis is just outstanding.
Peace to the world
Mr. Joe Biden Sir, please make Israel stop this mad crusade. Thank you Joe.
Wow you are too polite
Excellence Marwan
Excellant start
Thank you for calling out the lies.
20 gunmen and 3 tunnel lies is what that is mister Bibi
I understand your guest loud and clear. Don't you it could be pre-planned between Blinken and Netanyahu. We must focus hard how to bring them to justice to ICC for the genocide.
Great 👍!
Outstanding analysis..
Very astute reporting. Thank you.
May Allah bless you 🙏❤ the analysis but where is the solution😢 now only prayers and tears left but good days will come Inshallah 🙏🙏🙏🌹
marwan is amazing
Great analysis.
Fantastic analysis
he hit the nail on the head. it comes down to the lying, not who kills who. only evil will resort to lying. good appears to lose because evil has more options at their disposal. but good has the integrity to remain good, standing the test of time. dissemination of the truth is king.
Blinken is the U.S.’s Himmler.
Al Jazeera is the only mainstream media channel I trust and watch
The main problem is Washington
Blinken being a dirty psychopath holding such a serious post is insane.
H offered three times to release hostages within the month after invasion, but N refused. It just proves it was never about the hostages. It was about the opportunity to cease more lands for beach houses for his real estate company.
More MURDER, More MURDER, More MURDER...WHY ?
100%righr
free gaza for life
A charismatic leader does not demand the impossible, does not stumble all the time. Capable of compromise and empathy to move forward towards the best for all. Natenyahu is good at trapping himself and shooting himself in the legs all the time. It is clear that he is trying to save his skin at all costs.