Epilogue - Isabella of Castile: Reconquista - Part 7

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 9. 05. 2023
  • In the aftermath of the Reconquista, we look back at Isabella's legacy. Was she a saint to be venerated and enshrined? Or was she a demon to be hated and loathed?
    ===================
    CONTRIBUTE ON PATREON:
    / fphx
    =============================
    DOWNLOAD FLASH POINT HISTORY PODCAST EPISODES:
    itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/f...
    FOR ANDEROID USERS:
    fphistory.libsyn.com
    FOLLOW ON FACEBOOK:
    / flashpointhx
    VISIT ON TWITTER:
    / flashpointhx
    =================
    Amazing Artwork by the impressive Diogo Da Cunha
    Check out his website:
    readymag.com/u670849509/3650203/
    Big Thanks to Embrace History for the Total War Anima
    Please check out his channel:
    czcams.com/channels/Lzb.html...
    A huge shout out to Know History as well
    Beautiful landscape renders
    Check out his channel:
    czcams.com/channels/cwE.html...
    Also a big thank you to Fray Faraji and Claude Mackula for
    Their amazing music!
    ==================
    Bibliography
    'The Queens Vow' C.W. Gortner
    'Isabel of Castile' - Nichole Christakes Dapple
    'Isabella The Warrior Queen' - Kirsten Downey
    'Isabella and Ferdinand, King of Castile' - Ruby Mitchell
    'Kingdoms of Faith' - Brian Catlos
    'Muslim Spain and Portugal' - Hugh Kennedy
    'An Homage to Al-Andalus' - Micheal Barry
    =================================
    #Reconquista #Isabella #queen

Komentáře • 178

  • @FlashPointHx
    @FlashPointHx  Před rokem +51

    So I might have mentioned this would be released tomorrow - but realized I might not have time to launch it then. Decided to give you lovely peeps this video a day early. AND JUST LIKE THAT - My days of talking about the reconquista were over.

    • @beepboop204
      @beepboop204 Před rokem +2

    • @danielsantiagourtado3430
      @danielsantiagourtado3430 Před rokem +1

      Thanks! You guys rule!

    • @tituslabienus01
      @tituslabienus01 Před rokem +1

      🥺🥺🥺🥺💜💜💜💜

    • @nr3059
      @nr3059 Před rokem +3

      Thank you! Doing excellent work as usual! Keep the good spirit!

    • @doylekitchen9795
      @doylekitchen9795 Před rokem +6

      Yes, it's over. But, the body of work stands as one of the greatest stories ever told. Your ability in delivery, humor, and story selection (over 700 years of history things had to be chosen for summary or for details) provides one heck of a story. The music and pictures were pretty good also.
      You're a great storyteller, Nitin, looking forward to the Age of Discovery.

  • @ArchonShon
    @ArchonShon Před rokem +23

    The amount of work done on this series is in itself a Reconquista. Excellent job!

  • @theuniverse5173
    @theuniverse5173 Před rokem +29

    5 years later and the series is finally complete

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem +15

      Time for the next chapter . . .

    • @theuniverse5173
      @theuniverse5173 Před rokem +4

      @@FlashPointHx looking foward to it

    • @timmcclymont3527
      @timmcclymont3527 Před rokem +2

      @@FlashPointHx yes please

    • @nr3059
      @nr3059 Před rokem +1

      ​@@FlashPointHx She died, spoiler alert. There is another chapter? Looking forward for more. Thanks

    • @Darth_Enigma
      @Darth_Enigma Před rokem +2

      Wow, 5 years? It's hard to believe

  • @bear499
    @bear499 Před rokem +14

    This was a wonderful send-off to this chapter in Spanish history. I don't think I've ever followed a series as "religiously" for a lack of a better word than this one. This was hands down the sigle best historical series I've ever seen, not just on CZcams but anywhere. I'm very excited to cover the age of discovery. It has fascinated me ever since I first learned about the 16th century explorers and conquistadors during my 5th grade history class. I know you'll do it justice in your typical balanced, factual, and entertaining Flashpoint fashion. Thank you, and we await eagerly

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem

      Bear appreciate you being there for this entire journey - I still haven't decided how I'm going to present the Age of Discovery, but I was thinking going from one explorer to the next and covering their exploits rather than a chronological order. What do you think?

    • @bear499
      @bear499 Před rokem

      ​@Flash Point History that sounds perfect. A lot of these journeys overlaped. It would be better to focus on one main journey or individual in one video instead of covering multiple. It allows for greater depth and detail.

  • @ITPE94
    @ITPE94 Před rokem +3

    So good - The Reconquista Series.
    I spent a lot of time with my Grandfather in Sicily. He loved History. He told us stories about Rome, Byzantium, and the Reconquista. He would have approved of your storytelling. You were very objective.
    Well done.

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem

      Appreciate that - being objective in this particular history was no easy task. Even books that come out now are biased (IMHO)

  • @magvs_maestro216
    @magvs_maestro216 Před rokem +6

    Isabella, is such a pretty name

    • @TempleofBrendaSong
      @TempleofBrendaSong Před rokem +2

      Isabel La Castilla

    • @nr3059
      @nr3059 Před rokem +2

      ​@@TempleofBrendaSong it's just a reference to her origin. Isabel is her formal name, possibly nicked named as Isabella by her companions from French origin as their influence over Spaniards everyday

  • @danielsantiagourtado3430

    YEEEEEES! The finale to this incredible tale! Love you guys!❤❤😊😊

  • @ruzzsverion2728
    @ruzzsverion2728 Před rokem +3

    One of Europes greatest monarchs, showed no mercy to her Arab colonizers and made Spain a Superpower.

  • @Uncle_Fred
    @Uncle_Fred Před rokem +12

    If I recall, you started your channel with this series. Back then, it was just a few of us watching. Now look where you've taken things. Congratulations.

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem +4

      What a cray journey - can't believe I'm contemplating 200k subscribers at this point. Owe it to you guys

    • @nr3059
      @nr3059 Před rokem

      ​@@FlashPointHx it's your work, not us. Either we read or watch, it seems majority chooses the later

  • @KHK001
    @KHK001 Před rokem +8

    Was a great ride! thanks FPH for this great series, cant wait for the next one!

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem +2

      Thank you so much K for joining me on this. I can't remember a video where you haven't been along for the journey

  • @Glazox_
    @Glazox_ Před 11 měsíci +2

    I'm just sad it's last episode. It was fantastic journey through centuries of Reconquista. Thank you for your work and passion.

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před 11 měsíci

      Thank you very much! Saw your other comments. Seems like you binged through the whole series

  • @Darth_Enigma
    @Darth_Enigma Před rokem +4

    What an epic journey this has been, and I'm glad I've been able to experience it since the beginning. A new chapter is about to begin, and I am absolutely excited for our adventure to the New World, especially with a phenomenal narrator to guide us through.
    Thinking back to your first episode in the War of the Worlds series, I recall you originally intended to talk about Cortes in the Americas initially, but in order to get the full scope and context of his mindset and the time period, you ended up starting from the Early Islamic conquests instead. This unexpected detour would put the Fourth Crusade to shame, though unlike them we actually reached our destination lol.

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem +1

      I actually really excited about this next chapter as well. Time to start investing in a whole new series of books and give my old ones away

  • @DaHuuudge
    @DaHuuudge Před rokem +2

    This has been a brilliant series, excellently illustrated and narrated. It really captures the multi-layered complexity of historical figures and events. I can both admire Isabella as a remarkably strong, brilliant, and capable leader at a time when women achieving such power was unheard of, and revile the legacy of war, imperialism, colonialism, and brutal religious intolerance she unleashed.

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem

      If that is what you carried away from my series, then I'd say this endeavor was a success =)

  • @dylanrodrigues
    @dylanrodrigues Před rokem +9

    I’m not Spanish and I’m aware of the horrors that followed, but I’m still kinda proud of the Reconquista, idek why. Maybe it’s because of sheer chaos and privations the Christians went through for centuries until their ultimate victory .

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem +3

      At the end - they really had to earn it

    • @iamperplexed4695
      @iamperplexed4695 Před rokem

      You make it sound as if the 800 years was sheer hell for all Christians. That's not anywhere near the case at all.

    • @kevinumber7
      @kevinumber7 Před rokem

      I guess it's a point of view on conquest, especially when it halted the Islamic expansion. But these Christians went on to commit the worse genocide by killing native American cultures. That's nothing to be proud of. But a part of, the next part this history. If your religious it can be hard to compensate, and easier to ignore what happens by the Conquistadors.

    • @StLouis-yg8jp
      @StLouis-yg8jp Před rokem

      @@iamperplexed4695 Don't forget how the Reconquista started

  • @andreascovano7742
    @andreascovano7742 Před rokem +3

    I've been aboard this ride since the very begging. And now it is over. It feels almost nostalgic. Will you host an AMA? What did you think of this series? Are there some stuff you'd rather have changed? What was your favourite part?

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem +3

      What's an AMA? I loved making this series - but the numbers don't lie - people don't seem to have much of an interest. Hoping with the compilation video it will reach a wider audience. If I could have changed this, I have side videos that cover just the battles. Favorite part was watching what an indomitable personality like Isabella was go from nothing to a supreme force in history

  • @loslobos786
    @loslobos786 Před rokem +6

    I don't see Isabella or Ferdinand as a villain or Monsters, I see them as two people who had to make the HARD choices most of us don't even understand. The Iberian Peninsula had been wracked by near constant religious war for almost 8 hundred years. Their expulsion and forced conversions were sadly necessary to end the bloodshed. Like dropping the bomb on Hiroshima by killing a few thousand we saved Millions so to by expelling the Jews and Muslims who didn't convert they stopped future rebellions and pogroms leading to a Golden age for Spain. Was it perfect???? Of course not it was a horrible thing to do but unfortunately it had to be done and it was necessary. Such a sad world we live in that such Hard decisions must be made but this isn't the kingdom of Heaven we have troubles here and they must be solved one way or another 😢

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem +1

      My friend, I would describe you as a realist - and TBH I agree with your assessment

    • @gorkaalbizu9226
      @gorkaalbizu9226 Před 10 měsíci +1

      dont forget the context of the rise of the Otoman empire. Religious uniformity and identity was the trademark of the empire about to come.

    • @loslobos786
      @loslobos786 Před 10 měsíci

      @@gorkaalbizu9226 the Ottomans in the first centuries of their rule were not religious fanatics neither were Isabella and Ferdinand they used Religion as a unifying force in Spain. The Ottomans were even called Friends for much of their early history by the Eastern Romans ...that turned out badly. It wasn't till after Suleiman the Magnificent that the Ottomans really sunk into Religious fanaticism which lead to their turning away from new technologies that cost them their edge against their fight against the Christian West. Which had become less religiously fanatical and more willing to embrace technology which lead to the west reclaiming the Balkans and the Ottomans slow but steady decline.

    • @gorkaalbizu9226
      @gorkaalbizu9226 Před 10 měsíci

      @@loslobos786 Nevertheless, the berbery pirats kindnapped and enslaved estimated 2 million people from the shores of western medirerranean. In that context muslims in Iberia were considered a potential threat, that proved true, some decades later in the Alpujarras rebellion, where Otomas were called for their rescue.

  • @NoOriginalContentOfficial

    How based can Isabella get?! She is definitely wife material

  • @ericgrace9995
    @ericgrace9995 Před rokem +1

    Thankyou. It has been a pleasure. Its been quite a journey.

  • @flaviopitanga65
    @flaviopitanga65 Před 8 měsíci +2

    Isabella did what she had to do. Long live Isabella

  • @allones3078
    @allones3078 Před rokem +3

    Been a long road getting here and learned so much. Thank you for doing this series. Has been one of my favorites

  • @ziedyacoub8488
    @ziedyacoub8488 Před rokem +10

    Although i am an amazigh from north africa , yet i am really happy that the reconquista was extremely successful and that the christian spaniards have restored all their land ... Viva Espania

    • @Mr9taileddemonhunk2
      @Mr9taileddemonhunk2 Před rokem +1

      Are you also happy about the nasty treatment of anyone who wasn't Catholic? The inquisition? The downfall from the peak Cordoba caliphate?

    • @adriancrespo1575
      @adriancrespo1575 Před rokem +3

      The amazigh need to regain their culture and autonomy

    • @leaveme3559
      @leaveme3559 Před rokem +1

      I don't think it was good for the north Africans considering they became weaker all the castlian attention was now on north africa

    • @MrFeynmanDiagram
      @MrFeynmanDiagram Před rokem +1

      ​@@Mr9taileddemonhunk2 There was conclusive evidence that Jewish gold was used to finance Barbary pirate attacks on the coasts of the peninsula, leaving aside the danger of an alliance with the Ottomans...

    • @MrFeynmanDiagram
      @MrFeynmanDiagram Před rokem

      In any case, later on, both France and England established alliances with the Ottomans in the first case and in the second case with the Barbary piracy, an unequivocal sign of the sincerity with which these kingdoms received the news of the conquest of Granada...🤣🤣

  • @ricardoguilherme5170
    @ricardoguilherme5170 Před rokem +1

    And just like thar, it's all over. Thanks man, this series is the best Reconquista material you can find on CZcams.

  • @Landiosmedjos
    @Landiosmedjos Před rokem +1

    Excellent video as always!

  • @dlynskey4310
    @dlynskey4310 Před rokem +1

    At last u have completed your reconquista journey your Historical symphony and it all boils down do one epic cadenza cheers to the next chapter

  • @percyprickwillow9754
    @percyprickwillow9754 Před 8 měsíci +1

    My queen Isabella was bigger than life and did nothing wrong except, perhaps, to be too mercyful.

  • @egillskallagrimson5879
    @egillskallagrimson5879 Před rokem +3

    I hope you mention again the testament of Isabel next time when you explain the history of the Americas, as the testament it's a document of paramount importance. And I recommend you to contrast all information on the Inquisition as there is to much legend about it compare to the reality that it was.

  • @MaeviousPachatourides
    @MaeviousPachatourides Před rokem +1

    great vid once again!

  • @saquashkingbananas6399
    @saquashkingbananas6399 Před rokem +2

    Loved the whole story telling and images for this series!

  • @aleksandarandric4631
    @aleksandarandric4631 Před 11 měsíci +1

    I enjoyed the journey so much! Thank you for the tremendous work.

  • @SilverWave64
    @SilverWave64 Před rokem +1

    Amazing series! Thank you a lot!

  • @vinodpaul9596
    @vinodpaul9596 Před rokem +1

    Well done sir. Excellent series 👏

  • @dr.zoidberg197
    @dr.zoidberg197 Před rokem +2

    I would love to see a continuation of this serie by following Columbus.

  • @hochmeisterjer
    @hochmeisterjer Před rokem +1

    Awesome series, thank you so much!

  • @turloughkennedy6579
    @turloughkennedy6579 Před rokem +1

    Sitting out in the sun surrounded by quiet field's, coffee, cigar and Flashpoint History. Bliss 😌

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem

      Whoa - that sounds like an awesome experience - glad I could be a part of that

  • @Astillion
    @Astillion Před rokem +1

    This has been an excellent series!

  • @austinhornbeck5060
    @austinhornbeck5060 Před rokem +2

    Fantastic coda to this amazing masterpiece.

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem +1

      I think this is going to do really well as a compilation

  • @MariaCKouto
    @MariaCKouto Před rokem +1

    I follow the saga since th first video. Congrats 👏

  • @ithius99
    @ithius99 Před rokem +1

    Such sweet sorrow....

  • @Johnnycdrums
    @Johnnycdrums Před rokem +5

    The Inquisitions were noble and Holy endeavors.

  • @lonelytraveller5062
    @lonelytraveller5062 Před rokem +2

    For me, nobody can replace Isabella. She might not be a saint, but I pray her for her eternal reward in heaven.

  • @misterangel8486
    @misterangel8486 Před rokem +1

    I will miss waiting for episodes of the Reconquista immensely.
    But boy what a ride, what a ride indeed👏👏👏👏
    🏆🎖️🍻

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem

      looking forward to posting this as a combination movie !

  • @ciuyr2510
    @ciuyr2510 Před rokem +1

    can`t wait for the Next Chapter in history

  • @savagedarksider2147
    @savagedarksider2147 Před rokem +3

    Isabella of Castile and Elizabeth I would been great rivals.

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem +2

      They were separated by only one generation

    • @savagedarksider2147
      @savagedarksider2147 Před rokem +3

      @@FlashPointHx True but if they had live in the same generation they would have been formidable rivals.

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem +4

      @@savagedarksider2147 Oh hell ya - and due to the issues of Protestantism - they would have been enemies.

  • @laenorvelaryon5835
    @laenorvelaryon5835 Před rokem +1

    The inquisition is a dark legacy of Isabella, going sadly hand in hand with the birth of modern Spain. Some historians say it's not really religious fanaticism but a response to Ottoman expansion in the west mediterranian so the suspicious elements of society had to be purged. Either way it was marketed as the work of God, I think we'll see that again in the new world when you get there.
    A fitting epilogue. Cant believe its been 5 years already. Thank you.

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem +3

      Thats a really good way of looking at it. Just like in the 11th century when the Crusades took off - both religions became more polarized

  • @henkstersmacro-world
    @henkstersmacro-world Před rokem +1

    👍👍👍as always!!

  • @anacasanova7350
    @anacasanova7350 Před 8 měsíci +2

    La reina Isabel tuvo los mismos intereses que San Luis de Francia, pero más benevolente.
    La Inquisición española fue la menos cruel de todas las Inquisición europeas.
    Los que más reclamaban limpieza de Sangre fueron vascos y navarros para poder conseguir cargos preferentes en la corona de Castilla como no pagar impuestos , cargos militares y funcionarios.😊

  • @ianyork2655
    @ianyork2655 Před rokem +2

    My specialty was actually the reformation and while the inquisition wasn’t as bloody as people expect the issue Is all your wealth and assets are dissolved even if found innocent

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem +1

      It was a hustle to make money - even your own relatives were forbidden to buy the stuff the church had confiscated from you.

    • @ianyork2655
      @ianyork2655 Před rokem +1

      Well conformity mostly this was probably the best chance to create a Spanish identity

    • @ianyork2655
      @ianyork2655 Před rokem +1

      Also let me know if you like help with one of these. I would do it for free because I like your work :)

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem +1

      @@ianyork2655 email me what you have in mind - flashpointhistory@gmail.com

  • @TempleofBrendaSong
    @TempleofBrendaSong Před rokem +4

    Isabel La Católica

  • @jwink7795
    @jwink7795 Před rokem +2

    ohhh nooo too short.. . jk phenomenal work as always doc.

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem +1

      I'll compile all this together for a 2 and a Half hour movie for ya =)

    • @jwink7795
      @jwink7795 Před rokem +1

      @@FlashPointHx whooop whoooooop

  • @orlandosanchez1613
    @orlandosanchez1613 Před rokem +1

    There it is 🎉

  • @dennismarquez7354
    @dennismarquez7354 Před rokem +1

    well, i was not expecting the Spanish Inquisition to be in the last video

  • @kamilom.8711
    @kamilom.8711 Před rokem +1

    Wonderful series!!! I would like to know the soundtrack of the series, please !!

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem +1

      Give me a time stamp - there are at least 30 different songs for the entire series and 5 songs for this video alone

    • @kamilom.8711
      @kamilom.8711 Před rokem

      @@FlashPointHx Could you gimme a list with all of them?

  • @HistoryTVBangla
    @HistoryTVBangla Před rokem +1

    Which application you are using for make this map....

  • @AlejandroLopez-ed8kj
    @AlejandroLopez-ed8kj Před rokem +1

    At last!!!😊

  • @baggelis_aikaterinis
    @baggelis_aikaterinis Před rokem +1

    👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

  • @beepboop204
    @beepboop204 Před rokem +1

  • @mrsanchez256
    @mrsanchez256 Před 10 měsíci +1

    I wish my dad could have still been around to hear the end of it

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před 10 měsíci

      What do you mean ?

    • @mrsanchez256
      @mrsanchez256 Před 10 měsíci +1

      @@FlashPointHx every time I got together with my dad we would discuss these topics, and watching your videos was always part of our get together. He loved hearing about the reconquista, and other historical events. My dad passed away not to long ago. It’s been awhile since I’ve seen your videos and it just brought back memories.

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před 10 měsíci +1

      @@mrsanchez256 this is one of the greatest comments I’ve ever gotten. I’m honored that your father enjoyed my videos and that this was such a bonding experience for you. Sánchez - I personally invite you to join me tomorrow for the video premiere on Vasco - hope to see you there

    • @mrsanchez256
      @mrsanchez256 Před 10 měsíci +1

      @@FlashPointHx it sounds interesting I’ll check it out

  • @MCorpReview
    @MCorpReview Před rokem +1

    Your intro is very good. Just read a book 📕 called bloody queens 🤴 n surprised to c her selected 😅as one of them alongside Elizabeth bathory, the she vampire 🧛‍♀️, but she sounds more like a heroine 🦸‍♀️ without whom there wouldn’t b a Spain. Their main rationale is all d moors n Jews whacked during the inquisition 😢

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem

      This sounds like a really interesting book - your emoji crack me up

  • @pauloemanueldeoliveirafrei654
    @pauloemanueldeoliveirafrei654 Před 11 měsíci +1

    She ends the tax collectors máfias.....

  • @OPKakashi928
    @OPKakashi928 Před rokem +2

    😂😂😂😂😂

  • @Lacteagalaxia
    @Lacteagalaxia Před rokem +1

    La historia de España generalmente es minimizada o desprestigiada cuando no tergiversada en el extranjero en youtube; por ineptitudes ; equivocos; desconocimiento real o filias hacia otros paises o fobias hacia España y es algo que no entiendo sobre todo en los videos en Ingles que son los pocos que veo principalmente en otros idiomas por la traduccion y solo valen la pena leer del extranjero a los hispanistas de otros paises cuando mas prestigiosos mejor eso es curioso y es asi no estan atados a nada anti-Español. y esos no son youtubers " cualquiera...

  • @3idraven714
    @3idraven714 Před rokem +2

    Well done! I like the tidbit (segway) at the end (like a Marvel Movie :)...I smell a Columbus story in the wind. I hope you get to Coronado (found a lot of hostiles, and beautiful land), Cortez (stole a King's Ransom), and Pizarro (found the "Pot of Gold at the end of the Rainbow"). The Spanish went for the Money (south), and let the British and French sneak in and get all the good land (north, lots of warm calm seaports, temperate climate, a efficient river communication network, vast fertile plains and forest, "and the Rockets red glare...") i.e. USA, Canada. But as I understand the Natives had no horses until the Spanish showed up?

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem +1

      Hoping to hit up all of the above

    • @3idraven714
      @3idraven714 Před rokem

      @@FlashPointHx You da man! If you follow the white rabbit (lust for gold, and your attention to detail, :), it leads to the Spanish Armada!

    • @3idraven714
      @3idraven714 Před rokem +1

      @@FlashPointHx You should sell this to HS kids, I'd guide my 15+ yr old to your content. This history (Huns, Romans, Byzantines, Muslims, Spanish, to be continued) tells us a lot of ourselves, without having to learn it the first time, like a hot stove.

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem +1

      @@3idraven714 I think if a young adult comes across this content, they'd be more inclined to be inspired to learn it on their own instead of having it crammed down their throats in a classroom environment.

    • @3idraven714
      @3idraven714 Před rokem +1

      @@FlashPointHx Kids should study more history, it's like opening a 401K when you are 16, as opposed to 30, when you finally wake up.

  • @faylure9985
    @faylure9985 Před 6 měsíci +1

    I don't really agree or like how the last part of the video portray Isabella or her religiousnes, specially regarding to America. While all the other Empires that set foot there (and we could include the US) willingly anhilated the population, the Spanish empire mixed with the natives and a big, big part of the deaths were caused by unfortunate diseases brought by the Spaniards to this new lands without antibodies to defend against them, not by sword.
    It should also be noted that Isabella, even to her final moments tried very fiercly to protect the new natives, give them Spanish citizienship, teach them Spanish without making them renounce to their original language (albeit it is true that some religious fanatism ended in the destroying of A LOT of native texts, a very shameful stain in Spanish history) and made the "Leyes de Burgos" to try to guarantee indigenous rights and freedom as well as to prohibit the enslavement of those people that were now citiziens of the growing Spanish empire as well (there are numerous cases of this laws not being respected, but still).
    Also it should be noted that the Jews were not expelled because of religiousnes alone, but because they were found guilty of ploting and murdering important members of the catholic faith that were growing suspicious of them. Colón (Columbus) was a Jew, and it took numerious negotiations and 2 years of preparation for his travel to set sail. When he retourned from what will be known as "La Española" ("La Hispaniola") the Queen was horrified of the sight of natives in shackles and with time (after Columbus second travel to America) he was striped of a lot of wealth and titles due to the atrocities he performed on the natives he found, and the "Haciendas" he made were dismantled.
    Lastly the Spanish Empire will build roads, schools, universities, hospitals and burocratic buildings all along "the Americas" (and the first expedition of "global Vaccination" was also launched by the Spanish Government, much time later on). The cities on the American continent in general didn't had stone walls because they didn't need them, the natives were instrumental on the flourishment of the hispano-american culture and society and they were allowed in schools, universities and hospitals. The huge number of languages spoken were outshadowed by Spanish, the common language and also used for burocracy but the decline and extintion of those languages came by most part after the independence wars lead by Bolívar (who ironically offered the idiot King at the time, Ferdinand the VII for "the Americas" to remain Spanish with some concesion, and that moron of a King declined.
    Same king who would delegate everything into a traitor that allowed Napoleon to easily set foot in Spain).
    I loved this series so far but I always see in any English speaking channel talking about the topic the common rule of demonizing, diminishing and vilifying the Spanish episode of "the Americas" when in reality it was the first, coming from a LONG struggle marked by religion and even then was the only Empire to set foot there that created instead of destroying (albeit some did indeed Destroy, Nino Bezerra or Pizarro are good examples of that). The period where Spain ruled over "the Americas" is commonly known as "Pax Hispana" and ironically while it was very much true and agression almost every time came from outside (mainly England, France and later Holland) the European part of the Spanish Empire spent all those almost 300 years of "Pax Hispana" engoulfed in consant fighting against (but not only) other European powers, mainly the English (many times not directly, since many times England suported enemies of Spain), the Otomas were a big problem as well for a long time.
    I don't think there is any ill bias (I hope at least), specially by this channel. But the sources used are sometimes lacking to some extent and in other times straight up trying to portray a very nasty image and uphold people from the 16 century to 19,20 and 21th centuries standards.

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před 6 měsíci

      You make excellent points - there was some degree of balance and you're right Isabella did attempt to safe guard those that her country would go on to conquer. However any civilization that owes its strength to a conquered people can't be entirely justified in their actions. I don't intend on being biased in any way and if that comes across it is not my intention. I will say that in creating this series - that dates back to the beginning of the Reconquista - I have encountered so much bias in so many sources that I've learned to take a 'middle of the road' approach. Thank you again for such a strong comment. At the same time, also be careful when you look at the good a civilization does. Its as they say of the Pax Romana - Rome created a wasteland and called it Peace

  • @doylekitchen9795
    @doylekitchen9795 Před rokem +2

    Exile isn't that bad. The Almohads and Almoravids just killed or enslaved the Christians and Jews.
    I bet some Portuguese sailors are in the next video (Leif Erikson doesn't count as Age of Discovery). 😊

    • @shamsishraq6831
      @shamsishraq6831 Před rokem +1

      Well that's just a lie.
      Christians were persecuted - in the early years of Almoravid rule. Churches were destroyed, riots occured- genuinely nasty stuff. And yes, many Christians and Jews fled North to protect themselves. But in any case this is a very short period in the context of Al Andalus.
      Isabella and her successors on the other hand, were vicious. First of all, not everyone had the money to emigrate (it's not like Castillians were offering it for free), so for the rest it really was "convert or die". Many people WERE enslaved, despite this edict saying nothing about it. That's without even pointing out how even being a Christian didn't save you as Moriscos and Conversos found out.
      It was an exceptionally intolerant and fanatic state, even by Iberian standards.

    • @doylekitchen9795
      @doylekitchen9795 Před rokem

      @@shamsishraq6831 BS. The Christians and Jews did go North and the Muslims did NOT give them money to emigrate. Those that could. Most stayed as dhimmis. They had to pay extra taxes, could not wear symbols of their faith, could not build churches or synagogues, and could be enslaved for not paying their tax.
      The Muslims murdered and enslaved Christians since their arrival.
      Purges during the fanatical Almoravids and the even worst Almohad arrivals were massive (as per the historians). Thousands more died or were enslaved. Muslims liked slaves and the economy of the caliphate depended upon it. Converts to Islam were treated as second-class citizens. The Berbers led revolts against this.

  • @SamDiMento
    @SamDiMento Před 11 měsíci +2

    All of your aired criticisms of Isabella starting at 10:00 could apply equally and with more force to, say, Mohammad, the founder of Islam. We will have to hold your feet to the proverbial fire to remind viewers that some thought him a demon, as they no doubt did, if you ever do a doc on his conquests.

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před 11 měsíci +1

      I have a series called war of the world that starts with the Islamic conquest

  • @iamperplexed4695
    @iamperplexed4695 Před rokem +2

    It seems like there is A LOT of moral equivocation surroumding this woman. She did great good and she did great evil. Its a conundrum which behavior do we celebrate and which do we vilify? I think this woman deserves much more vilification than she has received. You breezed past one point in a past video where deserters of the catholic army were hunted down and burned at the stake. Just christians whose only crime was no longer wanting to kill, burned alive. She didnt need an Inquisition to be evil, she was born that way.

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem +1

      I think every super successful ruler in history has that aspect where they are willing to look beyond human suffering for their gain or the gain of their country. To me its a ubiquitous characteristic - people of that caliber achieve high power and are ruthless in their control. Rarely do you have a philosopher king (or queen)

    • @iamperplexed4695
      @iamperplexed4695 Před rokem +1

      @@FlashPointHx When you are born into war, everyone looks like an enemy.

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem

      @@iamperplexed4695 when you’ve become a hammer everything looks like a nail

    • @StLouis-yg8jp
      @StLouis-yg8jp Před rokem +1

      Deserters have always faced death as a punishment throughout history. Only in modern times has this changed and even then not for every country

  • @kevinumber7
    @kevinumber7 Před rokem +1

    Not even complete. Juan Elcano was first to circumnavigate, not Magellan. That's a whole history. Columbus of course. Then the race to the spice Islands. Next defines globalism is a new way.

  • @tituslabienus01
    @tituslabienus01 Před rokem +2

    1st Comment

  • @victor382
    @victor382 Před rokem +2

    Ok, now I’m really annoyed at this video, which I see as totally unnecessary.
    For one, it is full of “presentism” aka moral judgment for events over 500 years old. I don’t see the need of this caveat. Also, some of it is just plain misinformation. It shows as if the inquisition was bigger and more present in people’s lives that it actually was. The inquisition was just a phenomenon of what was common and rampant in the world at the time, religious intolerance.
    The idea that someone could be Christian as they saw fit was not tolerated for real until the 19 century. All countries at the time had institutions that looked for keeping religious dissension in check.
    Also, there is proof of how many people were condemned to death because of religious crimes. In the life of the institution that lasted for 350 years, from the time of 1540-1700 which was when it was more active, it condemned to death 1346 people.
    Obviously is a very large number, but if we take it out of context, and put it as something exceptional… is just not right. Let’s compare it to other events of a similar nature, religious intolerance. In England alone during the reign of the king Henry VIII it’s estimated that up to 70,000 people were put to death just for not accepting him as head of the church, and same with his children. In France the St Bartholomew massacre killed 3,000 Protestants in Paris alone, over twice as many condemned by the inquisition, and it was done in one day!
    Religious intolerance was something common and accepted and approved of in every corner of Christian Europe. Putting the emphasis on the Spanish Inquisition is nothing but dishonest and plays into the Spanish black legend, which considers the Spanish culture and history as nothing but subpar and inferior in the qualities that we see as superior today like tolerance, democracy, economy, etc…
    About the Jewish population… everyone, absolutely everyone in Western Europe like England, France, HRE, etc had expelled them from their countries, even centuries beforehand, so the idea of tolerating Jews was not looked kindly upon either. Again, present day people tend to put an emphasis on this expulsion for some reason, when it was not a unique thing related to Spain.
    Anyway, I feel this series was mostly well done, but this last epilogue soured the experience for me…

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem +1

      You made some good points here - Sorry the ending wasn't to your liking. I'm hoping at some point to get back to the Inquisition

  • @brokenbridge6316
    @brokenbridge6316 Před rokem +1

    I respect Queen Isabella. But I don't like the fact that she establish the Inquisition. I think it would've been better for her to accept the other diverse people's of her kingdom as they were. But I'm likely speaking from hindsight. Awesome video. And nice end to a nice series too.

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem +3

      You have a very good point - some of this stems from her desire to consolidate hold on the peninsula with various religions under her rule. Some of this came from her childhood, where she became indoctrinated into Catholicism and it was her only source of solace in an otherwise turbulent world

    • @brokenbridge6316
      @brokenbridge6316 Před rokem +1

      @@FlashPointHx---Yeah I get what you mean

    • @brokenbridge6316
      @brokenbridge6316 Před rokem +1

      @@FlashPointHx---Hey got any idea on what you'll be doing next?

    • @FlashPointHx
      @FlashPointHx  Před rokem +1

      @@brokenbridge6316 age of discovery - likely Prince Henry the navigator

    • @brokenbridge6316
      @brokenbridge6316 Před rokem +1

      @@FlashPointHx---Sounds like it will be a delight. Can't wait to see it.