CAA comes not with a bang, but with a whimper. Without NRC, it will fade into academic debate
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 03. 2024
- It would be reasonable to conclude that for the BJP, CAA was a strategic move that did not quite work out because those its benefits could easily have been accommodated under the existing laws, and new entrants would remain excluded. Watch this week’s #NationalInterest with ThePrint Editor-In-Chief Shekhar Gupta
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our CZcams Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
CAA- all are equal
UCC-how can you treat all equal
Secularism zinabad
Great point!!! Muslim favouritism to any extent, appeasement appeasement till the end of world
Left Librandu logic 😂
Lol CAA is for people from outside India, UCC is for inside of india😂 according to you we should invite whole Pakistan Muslim to india then tell me why did Pakistan was divided from india? Then there should not be any Pakistan at all. Right cause basis for division was religion then why you r crying now.
CAA's wording should have been "law for those who faced religious oppression due to India's partition"
Bang on Arjun. We are all equally Citizens but we also want our own personal laws. How can there be any social harmony, trust and integration?? Currently, every community is living in a different India.
U don't understand, this is designed not for Pakistan refugees, but for hindu refugees who came to india from Bangladesh after 1971 . This will give them citizenship, without any papers on virtue of being hindu.
And we can deny citizenship whom we want to keep out.
Old man us confused.
Only the Hindu refugees who fled Sri Lankan persecution won't get any benefit.
The Bangladeshi Hindu refugees ( the Matuas) have aadhar, voter, passports...all documents... as West Bengal has always welcomed the Hindu refugees with open arm. Their leader is a BJP MP. What more is required to become a citizen? How can someone is elected to the parliament without being a citizen?
Govt can give anyone citizenship who stays for 11 yrs in India,and all immigrants before 2014 were already eligible ,so there was no need for it apart from political stunting
So inconsequential that 'The Print' has done multiple stories on it.
It is not just about impact of CAA, it is for reminding future generations that India was partioned based on religion by Muslims. And to currnet living minorities in pakistan/bangladesh that you don't have 57 muslims country for you, still you will get some prefernces by countrey named India, if you go there. Although current cut out date is 31 dec 2014, it can be incrased in future.
Date should be decreased
BUT TODAY'S GENERATION HAS FORGOTTEN THAT RSS ALWAYS SUPPORTED THE BRITISH & THE TWO NATION THEORY BASED ON RELIGION.
OUT OF THOSE 57 MUSLIM MAJORITY COUNTRIES, CLOSE TO 30 ARE SECULAR STATES.
SUPREME COURT ME ELECTORAL BOND JAISE DHAH JAYEGA.
THIS CAA EXCLUDES THE OPPRESSED MINORITIES OF TAMIL HINDUS OF SRI LANKA, THE HAJARAS & AHMEDIYAS OF PAKISTAN & AFGHANISTAN & THE ROHINGYAS OF MYANMAR, DISCRIMINATING ON THE BASIS OF RELIGION. OUR CONSTITUTION DOESN'T ALLOW SUCH DISCRIMINATIONS ON THE BASIS OF RELIGION. IT'LL BE STRUCK DOWN BY THE SUPREME COURT FOR SURE.
CAA is the beginning NRC and UCC will follow. Gupta ji can live in fool’s paradise. Remember how these pseudos use to mock about Ram Temple and 370.
U are the one living in a fool's paradise. Go out of the country and check how other countries react when their politicians sell them Jumlas
Modi himself said NRC is not discussed or being planned. He took a backfoot, himself. Not the case in other issues you mentioned.
@@ShubhendraSingh2808but his notifications to District Magistrates says otherwise.
@@ShubhendraSingh2808 Still believing modi's bluff. lol. those words are for liberals like you. we will make sure rohingyas are thrown in the bay of bengal. NRC will come and throw all illegal muslims from our country
Political CAA is Time Pass
Granting citizenship in exceptional cases vs en masse is different matter... Shekhar is trying to downplay this means he hasn't got much of material to attack government on electoral bonds 😅
I have heard Ravish Kumar is still finding Adani Ambani names in the list.
😂😂@@theniravpanchal
These woke, liberandu pseudo-secular anti-Hindu anti-nationals will go on harping on non-issues like the electoral bonds even though they can't find anything in such issues to attack the BJP!!😂😂 Why do people subscribe and pay such idiots!!??😂😂
Whimper only in your mind !
Do not Worry Shekhar NDTV Babu😮After CAA, NRC will come,All Anti Modi,Anti National People will Go to Sleep
So be it🙌🙌
We will implement NRC after general election.. No one can stop BJP from kicking out Pakistani and Bangladesdshi muslims from India.. They divided India, and now trying to settle in India illegal??
Apidiya thambi , seri pannumgu
@@omerfarook2440 ni Yaru da Bangladeshiya illa pakistani ya?
Lol !! I don't know pakistani muslims but laughable to argue bangladeshi muslims . Bangladesh GDP is 3 times that of Assam and 1.5 times of west bengal ...Just FYI
@@motei1853toh bsdwale yaha aate hi kyu hai? Demography change karne? Population explosion karne? To become parasites on Hindus? To expand their religion?
@@motei1853..really!!,, we have enough comedy shows in India so don’t try to create more . Do you know the percentage of Bangladeshi Population of Assam …Hindus are already minority in Assam ..even Assamese Muslims ( thalua Muslim) do not want illegal Muslim immigrants from BANGLADESH. NOT ONLY IN ASSAM ALL THE NORTHEASTERN HAVE BURDEN OF ILLEGAL BANGLADESHI MYAN .
Yes, it will fade, will not affect social structure much. But, this was another bouncer to Oppositions. This announcement exposed many Opposition leaders appeasement and anti-H!ndu mindset more clearly, like Kejribawal.
It will fade just like Portion of India,370 and Triple Talak😂
Utter rubbish comment.
@@ChandranPrema123 At lest Effect of 370 has not faded and will not fade soon. Because many Political party want to bring it back, so sometimes they will help you remember 370 by their anti-India speeches.
For the last time -
1. CAA is a partition linked law
2. Hindus, Christians, Sikhs and all other non Muslim communities were rendered second grade citizens when Pakistan, Bangladesh made Islam as their official religion
3. Clearly being rendered second grade in a land where they were living forever is a gross injustice and they deserve to be in a country where they are equal
4. CAA is nothing but a law which restores justice for these non Muslim communities by giving equal citizenship
5. That's why minorities from other neighbouring countries are not included in this law as other neighbouring countries do not have a state religion, let alone the fact that these countries were not formed out of partition
6. What amazes me the most is that people who so vehemently criticize CAA are the same people who oppose Hindu Rashtra, as CAA is nothing but an act to protect people from similar Muslim Rashtras fanatically created in our neighborhood
Hope this clarifies!
Exactly,sir.
Good explanation
Yes. Nehru Liaquat agreement signed on the suggestion of Gandhi is the basis of it. So its related Muslims and non Muslims of undivided India /Indian subcontinent only.
Hypocrisy and double standard of Bjp's opposition parties :
1. They are opposing caa because they want citizenship for paķ and Bangladeshi Muslims.
2. In India every day and night they are champion of minority rights but they never speak a single word on atrocities on minority in pak, bdesh and afgan.
3. Every day they shout for democracy in India but they never want democracy in most of the Muslim countries and China. Anti Indians are mostly supporting these countries.
4. Sickular parties of India wants sickularism in India but not in China or muslim countries.
5. Sickulars wants equality in caa but not in ucc.funny selective.
There are 100 of such points.
@@rajeshnath5069 All because they want to get Muslims, Christians and SCs (who are unitedly surprisingly with Muslims) who are voting unitedly while we Hindus divided to khanchrist party, Lalus, Stalins and Pennerayi Vijayan etc foolishly. These parties released PFI to even IS people for their votes. When will Hindus learn? Even upto 80% not know what is happening to their own in India while muslims crying for Palestine people. We never cared Kashmir Hindus, not cared what's happening to Hindus in WB, Kerala or elsewhere m
When Shekhar Gupta criticizes something, that means it is automatically good for India. Keep doing good work so we can know whats good for India.
Wise amend despite all kind of posture. This should have been done from the immediate aftermath of 15 Aug1947 and continued till all victims were saved.
not to wise to fund left wing propaganda why ur wasting ur money wipro already funding left wing media in india ???????
read little history. Several times refugees were given citizenship. Like SG said you don't need CAA for that. Government has mechanisms to provide citizenships to refugees as it see fit !! sorry to burst your bubble.
@@motei1853 CAA is the targetted mechanism of GoI, to facilitate refuge to non Islamic people who are suffering persecution in the three Islamic countries because of their refusal to proselytise. The basis of the law is the religious partition of India. Those from Afghanistan are the non muslims who has to flee from Pakistan through the porous border. Vast majority of them are from the lower castes, who have constitutional protections in India. Though the current law is for those came to India prior to 2014, it is up to Parliament of India to enact laws and provide succour to those who are still trapped in those countries suffering religious persecution. The basis of partition provide them rights to seek refuge. What has been bursted is the carefully curated notion that the term 'secularism' means India is a coalition of abrahamic - theocracies while others especially Hindus have no rights in any parts of india, whether majority or minority. This practice has made Hindus refugees in many parts of their sacred birthland and only abode on the planet!
@@motei1853 The only bubble that was bursted is the carefully curated notion that 'secularism' means Hindus have no religious rights in any parts of india whether majority or minority while others could practice their faiths as if in their religious theocracies. It is a fact that this has made the Hindus refugees in many parts of india, the sacred birthland of their faith and the only abode on the planet.
Till date I have Never heard a cohesive argument agaist caa and nrc, only rhetoric about democracy secularism but always shifting the goalposts.
If it was non significant, why so much resistance? It only means opposition indulged in fearmongering over an issue which will soon become an academic debate only.
Without NRC it is non-significant. NRC became non significant because of protests. Modi took a backfoot on NRC.
What resistance?
@@ShubhendraSingh2808 NRC can weed out illegal refugees who may have gotten voting right, land rights etc. without getting citizenship. Which is feared by many left-liberal parties. W.Bengal is such example. But only CAA has been implemented because govt. only wants to help those refugees who need/want citizenship.
@@eldamarmaiar2457 NRC can be done in individual states on urgency basis and no CAA is required in that case. For example, in Assam present CAA is not even applicable and still NRC was done.
AAP insulted Bengalis. No AAP in Bengal. We hate AAP!
ofcourse, rn they are limited in Delhi and Punjab, and will continue to do so, because there is only so many Freebie scheme one can afford
Aap has complete understanding wd tmc ...aap will never be so much active aginst Tmc in wb.
TMC or No TMC, we will not welcome any party without link to Bengal or Bengalis 🙏
no bangallies in assam, hence no CAA in north east, and native tripura are given rights
@@sombasu86can you tell me what conection between Bengali culture and CPM? দাদা এতো সহজ নয় বিজেপি কে বহিরাগত প্রমাণ করা।
Shekhar is hugely disappointed- Adani Ambani ka to naam hi nahin aya bond mein ab Modi ko kaise harayen! 😀
Ambani ka naam to aa gaya
Sir you said that the government took 10 years to give citizenship under CAA. But they brought a bill in 2019 itself, it means they wanted to give citizenship under CAA within 6 years itself.
1:30 encouraged by BJP? Why haven't you ever said farmer's protest encouraged by AAP?
B'cos his political masters will cut his funding 😂😂😂
Also why doesn't he say that illegal Muslim "ghoospetis" are encourages by kejruddin and mumtaz bano?? What a hypocrite and what humongous double standards by this man who calls himself a "journalist"!!!!😂😂
@@bharatmatakijai9601 nah . He calls himself an unbiased journalist.. shekhar ji.. you could have done a lot better
@@pravinmeher2036 but that goes without saying!! Every journalist should be unbiased!!😂😂
He thinks he's some special brand of journalist!!😂😂
@@bharatmatakijai9601 hippocracy ki bhi seema hoti hai..
It's gonna be banana republic until June 1st. Liberals and opposition are looking at the electoral bonds issue like a gold mine. Because, even though the opposition is down and out, this can cause some damage to BJP. Probably not enough to inflict a loss upon BJP, but a chance to keep the far away from the 400 seats. Opposition has been reduced to the ability to say "nyaa nyaa, you didn't get 400" in the parliament. What a shame.
I doubt it. The opposition is harassing their own donors. Killing their own chances to organize. Congress is going after BRS’s donors (Megha) and SP is alleging Pakistani company bought out the BJP. These allegations are self inflicted wounds and doesn’t stick the landing. BJP stoic silence says everything (The Govt knows who donated money to who after all). My 2 cents is Electoral bonds was the cover for CAA.
Not a single video on electrol bonds shekar ji this is exactly what is hippocrocy 😂😂😂
Like even Congress will get exposed if he does that.
There's a reason why No Parties besides Idiot congress wants to talk😂
If print talks on Electoral bonds they will need to justify why Congress wants political funding in cash and without trace . To fill the coffers of few politicians . Thank me later for educy
Yes shekhar Guptas “unhyphanated” journalism
@@ChandranPrema123precisely and they are using it as an ammo against their own allaince partners. 🤣🤣
You missed the videos?
Guptaji,discuss:: why bdeshis coming to india after genocide of 1971 and now having ration card,aadhar,voter id,pan ,and having property in india,serving govt,their sons and daughters settled..will have to apply for citi and face interview twice..whereas by their votes mps,mlas have been elected, some of them ministers..biplob dev became cm of tripura,ghosh of bandhan bank,,is a founder of bank..clarify and help to understand..since mainstream media not discussing caa,rather becoming partisan...harharmahadev
Are the extra facilities given in the education sector to non-Hindus not based on religious basis ?
Fitst of all, India has to dump the word Secularism from Constitution..
West bengal be to benefit kargya bjp ko, acc to every survey bangladesh hindu really shifted toward bjp south east region, bjp already super strong in north, it might take them above TMC this time in lok sabha
I hope so
Many Hindus fear NRC and CAA. Mamata also plays with their fear. BJP was strong anyway this time. CAA might backfire.
You must change the name of the program from National Interest to ‘My Hobby’ and then we will clearly relate to how you like being negative about everything that’s done by BJP.
And then, in the ‘National Interest’ (In Bharat’s interest) open up your mind to acknowledge that we have had influx of too many from all round.
Bharat is natural home for all around us, because they were all Bharat at some point in time. Now that we have made divisions by religion and we can’t go back and change that, we can realign the population now to where they belong, which is Muslims to remain in their own country, that we gave it to them.
Even if now you understand this, then try an apply citizenship to neighbouring countries and see how that goes. Even better if you actually leave the country and cosy up to whatever aligns with your hobby.
The Print wants NRC😮😮😮 sahi me acche dim agaye bhai
NRC coming in 2029.. 2 Months before elections.. 🤣
Lol
Shekhar Gupta Ji , Is Pakistan also Going to Enact CAA for India Muslims who are So Called Everyday Prosecuted in Hindustan
Shekar Coupta in 2025 how CAA played a Vital role and why it's significant to India's future
Those who have adhar card and voters card do not need CAA unless they apply for the passport . Change the passport law and make it simple so that all refugees can get Passport.
Everything tried to stop CAA, but when it did not work, say it academic. Wow !
Nothing on electoral bonds. Too much balancing.
What exactly do you want to talk about ? Its not some sort of "Crime". Its a pre-decided Agreement that Companies could buy bonds and back Political Parties.
It was clearly introduced as "Experimental Move". India is not the first country to adopt such a thing, It exists in many Nations. In America something 100 times worse exists called ";Lobbying", Where Companies can directly influence discussions on "Topics that are debated" in the Parliament.
My point is this - All Indian Parties were involved in it, Why are some people only cornering BJP now ? Its stupid and ignorant. Either everyone is guilty or no one is.
If bjp has got 48 % of money opposition parties have got 52% of money are they all innocent?
@@hindurashtra63good you brought up lobbying in US because it’s transparent in US, and in India government sends Harish Salve to hide number any which way it can.
If he talk about electoral bonds given to khangress and Tmc then then Pappu's like you will blame him again thats why he is afraid to talk
@@chetanpatil1654 right because a party that is erased from India’s map has more to fear than one who is ruling the country from 10 years 😂 Joke acha kar lete ho tum. Charlie Chaplin ke assistant the kya?
The major substance of the entire episode is in the last 30 seconds. Thank you SG sir.
Gupta ji expected protests and riots. Then it would be bang for him.
Bjp will 100% conduct nrc be it within 2029 or within 2034...but it's sure they will do it.
As a paying subscriber, I find it profoundly disappointing that among the latest 50 videos released, not one has addressed the crucial topic of the editorial bond reveal. While I recognize the potential pressures and risks you may face for addressing sensitive issues directly, it's precisely these moments that underscore the importance of courageous journalism. I support your platform because I believe in the necessity for media to take a stand, especially when it seems most daunting. This oversight not only undermines the value I find in your work but also calls into question the commitment to the principles I expect you to uphold.
Indeed! Shekhar ji, as a paying subscriber, I also most humbly request you to look into this clutter and cut it.
Sathe problem with SG / CAA is that there are no riots / processions .
I don’t understand why the law doesn’t permit the affected minorities who are still being discriminated against in these countries. They may be about two crores and unlikely that everyone of them would like to migrate to India.
Assam cannot differentiate between those who call themselves Assamese Hindus and Bengalis irrespective of religion because Assam has migrants to Assam calling themselves Assamese without being historically from any of the ethnic tribes of the region.
Unsubscribed to the Print since there is no cut the clutter on Chandigarh Election riggings or Electoral bonds. I feel Mr Shekhar Gupta only makes videos in which the government can be defended, maybe out of fear of the government, I don't know.
He is sitting on the fences for a long time
Good decision. Stop paying for this so called unhyphanated and spineless journalism. This channel is infested with bigoted bjp supporters.
Then why you are still here 🤣🤣
Why this headline. Is he mocking or challenging govt. such a sick person.
Every country has national register of citizens and citizenship number - not counting legal temporary workers and illegal migrants - it is good to give work visas for definite period to illegal migrants
Man why no talk about electrol bonds.
So do you want khangressi and DMK and TMC to get exposed?
No episode on electoral bonds??
You always against Hindu.
Don't worry Shekhu daddu, the sting of CAA will be felt even more when NRC is implemented. Keep picking up holes...and one day you'll realise what ground breaking, game changing difference it will have brought for Bharat!! 😂
Bullshit
@@austinfernandes7865 Yaa..I mean, picking up holes in CAA is typical of a jealous spokesperson of an opposition party!😀. This is just the beginning...Let Mr Shekhu daddu wait for the NRC to be implemented. I am sure, he'll feel the need to upload a longer video for that as well 😂😂😂.
CAA was passed in 2019 . Because of politics it was difficult to apply CAA.
You need 14 years of continuous stay in India to apply for citizenship. CAA shortens it to 10 years for the persecuted. Adnan Sami spent more than 14 years and became a citizen. It is so simple
Rather than lecturing India US shud accept all Rohingyas that are illegally in India. Plus Bangladeshi Muslims in India. US must mind its own business.
Let modi get 2/3rd majority in the combined house (Lok sabha+rajya sabha) then you will have to do so many such episodes on so many things changing in the constitution Gupta ji😅
The opposition argument for giving shelter and citizenship to ahemadis shias of pakistan is so ridiculous and foolhardy the no one imagine. Are we here to remove shortcomings of islam?
why there is cut off date for CAA
Wasn't this paused earlier because of widespread protest from Congress. Hence the 10 year wait.
Pakistan should now introduce CAA of its own, calling all the Muslims who live in fear in Bharat to Pakisthan.
And Pakistan shud take away everyone living in UP & Bihar. You guys are costing us too much of taxes and we get nothing in return except cheap labor.
🥱🥱 so when r u going to Pakistan?
You also know NRC will come😅
Late 2000s, Assam's ruling elites confronted a daunting prospect: the Muslim population was rapidly growing and was projected to equal if not exceed the Hindu population in a matter of decades.
Since independence, these Muslims and their progeny embraced Assamese as their language, and mother tongue, solidifying their place within the Assamese cultural framework, which helped maintain Assamese hegemony. Consequently, Assamese Muslims faced minimal scrutiny and were often overlooked compared to Bengali Hindus. While Assamese Hindus harboured animosity towards Hindu Bengalis, Biharis, and Madwadis, they were more or less accepting of Assamese Muslims, who ironically were descendants of migrants from undivided Bengal as well. They voted for Congress as a bloc and ergo, politically too they were not undesirable. Hence, the influx of Muslims from Bangladesh continued, and their numbers was further compounded by the high TFR due to their impoverished conditions, where, as is often said, sex served as the primary form of entertainment for the poor. Many aren’t aware but outside of J&K, Assam houses the highest number of Muslims in the country, not UP, not Bengal, but the North Eastern state of Assam.
This status quo however altered with the emergence of AIUDF, NE’s AIMIM, when Muslims started shifting to perfume baron’s party. This created a potential for Assamese Muslims to gain political dominance over Assamese Hindus ie posed a genuine possibility for Assam to be ruled by Muslims albeit in the future. But in politics, foresight is paramount.
You know how its said that Kurdish focused parties spelt doom for Kurds in Turkey as they were no longer an asset to Erdogan? Likewise, you could say Muslim focused AIUDF would lay the seeds for the eventual bawasir in Assam.
To address this looming demographic challenge and existential threat, the National Register of Citizens (NRC) was formulated. Heralded by the then Congress government and backed by the verdict from an Assamese Chief Justice of India at the Supreme Court, the objective was to pinpoint aliens (expectedly Muslims), strip them of citizenship, and relocate them to detention centers or deport them, essentially nullifying their voting privileges. Thus, a massive operation ensued, costing a staggering 1300 crores, garnering extensive attention for several years until the results were unveiled.
90 lakh aliens, 85 lakh muslims. Great success.
Lol. Jk. This was the expectation.
But the eventual outcome of the NRC exercise was far from what was anticipated: out of the mere 20 lakh individuals identified as aliens, 15 lakh were Hindus and 5 lakh were Muslims, indicating that three out of every four identified aliens were Hindus. This revelation sparked a cataclysm of repercussions.
The dilemma arose: how to disenfranchise Hindus without triggering significant backlash from mainland? Could it be justified to destabilise their fate? Where would they go if stripped of citizenship? And would it not be counter productive? Conversely, how could Muslims be spared disenfranchisement without undermining the original objectives and plans laid out? These questions presented complex challenges.
To assuage that, Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) was devised. Disenfranchise all 20 lakh aliens, and more to be detected later (there were concrete plans to conduct NRC again) and then give citizenship back only to the Hindus.
Ever wondered why the CAA has a cut off date of 2014? Think about it, why 2014 of all dates? Now I understand law has bright line rules, can’t get married or drive before you’re 18, can’t drink before 21, but providing a cut-off date here sounds antithetical and undermines the ostensibly humanitarian objectives of the law, doesn’t it? I’ll cut to the chase, the cut-off date in CAA is 2014 because the cut off date of Assam’s NRC is 2014 as well.
Thanks for sharing that information on 2014 cut-off date. Are you an Assamese? But on internet it shows march 25, 1971?
@@AmalTan I'm from Meghalaya. Not NRC cut-off, sorry, it was when NRC began.
@@Arban19 I understand that BJP has tried to change Assam politics from Assamese vs Outsider to Hindu vs Muslim.
But why then still there are protests against CAA in Assam? What about leaders like Akhil Gogoi?
How US know anything about this?
Godi Media Guruji Shekhar Gupta , kabhi SC order on electoral bonds ka bhi kabhi elaborate program nahin to zikr kar lijiye !😅
Usne sandeshkhali ka bhi kuch nahi bola 😂
CAA was misnamed. Should have been named ‘Keeping promises made during Partition Bill’.
Muslims in West Bengal Wellcome CAA, as Muslims live in close congested area, new one add pressure on them, in jobs also. I live in Bengal and do business in yeat, bread and fresh food where 90 % of them are working, and everybody hates infiltrated ones and CPIM who started it and TMC more as they encourage it. This truth is going to change Bengal politics.
Implementation of NRC with 1987 Law is foolishness in present years
DM have power to give citizenship. Many of hindus got citizenship already.
All in the list must be given Citizens ship immediately.
A gang already on prowl to
Sabatoge persecuted Hindus
How much have you been paid to not talk about the electoral bonds scam! It’s really shameful, hadn’t expected this out of you Shekhar ji.
I don’t expect to be like The wire but neutral
In fact the original thing to be implemented was NRC. But looks like a lot of people in assam would be trapped in NRC.
To take them out of this net, first CAA had to become a law and these people should be given citizenship.
So after CAA is implemented and then comes NRC. Moslty this will be done in the border states of Assam, bengal and bihar.
When will uncle talk about electoral bonds
Thank you sir
Nrc will come with major upheaval, hence saved for after elections.
Why are you guys not covering the electoral bind issue, nr Shekhar Gupta the journalist in you should ideally be jumping on to a story likenhis!
Shekhar Gupta asking for NRC wow
Unhyphenated true, but avoiding EC Bond issue shows conservatism or at worst cowardice
Give it a rest Gupta ji!
Very interesting POV Shekhar. I have listened to multiple analyses of the CAA recently and yours definitely stands out as more grounded in reality and real politick. I wouldn’t put it past the BJP to raise the NRC bogey sometime in the future, particularly when new temples no longer distract the public from their many failures and they need a new (old) shiney toy to win yet another election.
Hey , kindly tell me about the failures , got to know them in details if you will
@@biswajitsamal8336 if you have to ask, you aren’t paying attention.
Nice chair boss! Where did you get it 😅
Shekhar you sold your soul for meager salary of print!!
Shekhar, Electoral Bonds story died because ita opponents have only an agenda nothing more. CAA has died because it's opponents have no substance. NRC must follow after elections.
This is a good opportunity for Pakistan to introduce a CAA-like law they can help minorities in India like Muslims 🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰
Why 2014?
Why this video of caa effect not come on that particular day but come after four hour after 2024 election schedule declaration ?
This is the correct analysis of what CAA is. Without NRC, it is just an ideological point. It is inconsequential on ground. Government can give citizenship within the laws present before. I consider it as a win for Indian democracy. Protests all over India, specially colleges forced Modi to come out himself and take a backfoot on NRC. He went from saying “kapde se pehechano” to saying “NRC kabhi discuss hua hi nahi hai”. Amit Shah’s chronology is cancelled. Ultimately, win for Indian democracy should be considered win for BJP.
another colonised puppet still believing a fool's paradise called Democracy where capitalists can fund and shape narratives
What 😂😂? Win for Indian democracy? It is win for appeasement politics. Problem with Indian people is that they dont understand the difference between slavery/appeasement and democracy. CAA NRC and UCC should have been implemented much earlier. Muslim appeasement should have been cured much earlier. Taking back NRC was the defeat to democracy by appeasement politics and it shows the idiotary and dumb mindset of Indians who appeasement means democracy and secularism.
Lautenberg law of us
NRC will follow. Just wait.
UCC next.
Where is your Omega, Shekhar sir?
Please do CTC on Karnataka droughts.
Why sheker guptha has not done any episode on electoral bonds, we are expecting your view on it.
Before ThePrint discuss on the CAA , give clear explanation and its main practical points which affects to the common Indian legal citizens. The Israel have the similar rules for the Jews from other countries which is not extended to the Palestinians. The USA and world liberal and conservative politicians can not dare to question on that rule!!!!
SG's argument that it's 10 years since 2014, so they would've got citizenship anyway without CAA is flawed.
The usual manner of getting citizenship by naturalisation (staying for 11 years in India) is avaible only to those who have come by legal visa. Illegal intruders can't get citizenship in any manner without a special law like CAA.
I only want to ask the Leftist Media - Did we even have such a Detailed Discussion when Rohingaya and Bangladeshi came to India ? No. So why talk about this now ?
It is becoming difficult by the day to endure Shekhar Gupta cutting the clutter when it comes to Indian politics or policies of Modi. He has such a biased opinion!!
Shekhar ji, ED Bonds ka Clutter kab cut karoge?
Apply caa and nrc in Gujrat and rajasthan. Reject their documents and send them to detention camp.
Sekhar sir dont worry u still mock anyone u want to be in favourites of pseudo
start a taro card reading service along with kundali vidya... else print shall fade into oblivion
One thing for sure .. what ever BJP does, Mr SG projects it as something political implied in it. But whenever he talks about something done by congress and its allies (even the worst) , he don’t even see an iota of political thing in it but projects it as taking country forward thing
Tribal communities in India have faced historical marginalization and lack of recognition. Factors include limited access to education, healthcare, and employment opportunities, leading to socio-economic disparities. Additionally, issues like displacement due to development projects and inadequate representation in decision-making processes contribute to their marginalized status.
That’s why Hindutva is the answer for their problems. 😌
@@libshastra
Yes, Sanskari serial sex offender MP Brij Bushan agrees with you
@@libshastra
Serial sex offender MP Brij Bushan, Asaram Bapu agrees with you. 😂
@@libshastra u saw sham sharma show interview podcast
India is far better country for tribals compared to many other countries
Not in the context of the video but the problem with the Print is that it has a socially liberal perspective, yet the audience it has is bigoted Sanghis. So ideally Gupta ji should be screaming democracy in danger, but he pulls his punch a lot. Like in case of SBI incident, he should have been crying how SBI is being forced by the BJP is a very dangerous or with the whole election commissioner fiasco or of the bias of the election commission. But he knows his audience and this he pulls back his punches.
Edit - And I am saying this as a very old observer of The Print and with being a member for more than a year. However I am questioning whether to continue or not. Honestly DK and Vir keep me in.
He’s here to make money serving what bhakts want. Dk is same. Stop paying these spineless so called journalists. This channel is infested with bigoted saghis.
Only Muslims including jihadis(Zubairs, Sayemas Arfas, Rana Ayyubs) Christians along with conversion mafia(beef brigades ) and LeLis could be members of the print, the wire, the Hindu (the Muslim cum Christian practically) could be subscribers. Oh! Forgot Shehar Gupta, Sumanti Raman and Sanjay Jha like Jaychands in Hindus.
Sir, each story is different electoral bonds, CAA
Shekhar sir, do you think that modi wont be able to bring NRC? Are you again underestimating him?
THIS CAA EXCLUDES THE OPPRESSED MINORITIES OF TAMIL HINDUS OF SRI LANKA, THE HAJARAS & AHMEDIYAS OF PAKISTAN & AFGHANISTAN & THE ROHINGYAS OF MYANMAR, DISCRIMINATING ON THE BASIS OF RELIGION. OUR CONSTITUTION DOESN'T ALLOW SUCH DISCRIMINATIONS ON THE BASIS OF RELIGION. IT'LL BE STRUCK DOWN BY THE SUPREME COURT FOR SURE.
Listen to post by J. Sai Deepak, Supreme court lawyer, and inform yourself better. The refugee issue concern with Art 5 and not Art 14.
Tamil hindus did get entry during peak of LTTE activity.