As Modi govt notifies CAA rules, abridged episode 1074 on the much-debated Act & concerns around it
Vložit
- čas přidán 30. 05. 2024
- Modi government on Monday notified CAA rules, before Lok Sabha polls announcement. In episode 1074 of #CutTheClutter, originally published on 14 September 2022, Shekhar Gupta explains the arguments by the govt for its implementation and those by the critics opposing it. He also explains the fears, myths & reality of the much-debated act and the concerns regarding the CAA-NRC combination.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our CZcams Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Great step, Muslims have more rights in islamic countries Pakistan, bangladesh & Afghanistan. They discriminate with non Muslims constitutionally.
Everyone has more rights in India then dictatorships like pakistan and afghanistan. It is only natural. It is absurd and anti=-india to kick people out on the basis of their religion
this bill is for INDIANS not for any particular community. But yes surely against a particular community😂
@@jim7863 In favour of communities who were discriminate becoz of their religion.
@@Rohit-cq7vm yes
@@jim7863that's good
CAA is simple and clear., Yet Shekhar tries to confuse by attaching it to NRC, Assam etc... This is how you bias and twist matter... Shame....
Yea you are right. He need to stick to the topic of CAA.
So true
Well said. These are the demons and antiIndians need to be sent to Pakistan or Bangladesh.
CAA is always attached with NRC.
Then made it clear by seperating CAA and NCR
10:25
Muslims who migrated from India to Pakistan , their assets were taken by WAQF muslim board not indian government during partition whereas Hindu migrants assets were taken by Indian Government.
Nice try to manipulate again SG.
Claim: Properties of Muslims who migrated to Pakistan from India after 1947 are vested with the Waqf board.
Fact: It is the government that took control of those properties of those who migrated to Pakistan following the initial years of partition. Government compensated people who came back from Pakistan to India with these properties. Legislations like The Administration of Evacuee Property Act, 1950 & 1952, The Evacuee Interest (Separation) Act, 1951 and The Displaced Persons (Compensation and Rehabilitation) Act, 1954 facilitated for the compensation. Later on, the government renamed these properties as enemy properties following the Indo-Pak wars. Subsequent legislations like the Defence of India Act, 1962, The Enemy Property Act, 1968 continued with control of government over these properties. The 2017 amendment to the 1968 act has provided the government to seize these properties. In fact, in 2019, the government has sold few of these properties. Hence the claim made in the post is FALSE.
Gupta MC
@@harshkumarmathur8255 hey, pls may you give me a source about this ?? Thanks. जय श्री राम 🙏
How did WAQF board become India's second biggest landholder after Central government?
@@AnunayGupta-bs7lf jai shri ram bhai
i am a Bangladeshi hindu from Chittagong, Bangladesh, you guys will never able to understand what we have been going through for the last 80 years. What happened to jews in ww2 is not even 5 % to what happened to hindus in Bangladesh from 1940. Only in 1971 3 million people killed and 5 lac women was raped for months( biggest rape case in 20th century). From 2013 to 2020 more than 3700 attack on hindus. More than 600 hindu leave Bangladesh everyday by statistics. We always live in fear, in daily basis force conversation,murder, women and girl kidnapped and converted and rape, house vandalised, mandir vandalism, land taken forcefully, etc.
In 1901 there was 33% hindus. And it is only 7% left. And predicted that with 2060 there will be no hindu left in Bangladesh.
come here brother
@@stormstriker2000No matter what it is very difficult to leave your ancestral land.
Leave the shithole
U r getting what u deserved. The result of COWARDICE
Dear sickulars will never understand but you have a caring nationalist party at center which is fighting for you guys with this islamists
No one has the balls to protest against CAA😊
No BJP/RSS/Andhbhakt have the balls to confront Chinese incursion..
😂😂😂@@SPrabhakar
No one in BJP have the balls to say SBI needs to reveal the Electoral Bond List..
@@SPrabhakarrota reh kallu
@@mg.f.9023so jihadi like u have balls then go to chini border with ur balls
Hindu population has fallen drastically in both Bangladesh and Pakistan due to persecution and is projected to keep decreasing in the future while the Muslim population in India has increased and is projected to keep on increasing.
Pakistan less than 1%, Bangladesh 7.5%, Kashmir almost 0%. In last few decades, Hindu footprint has been wiped out from one third of Indian Subcontinent.
And they r all Muslim neighbours.
So the law has been implemented keeping this in mind.
@@thezoldics7648 it only applies to those who came before 2014. They need to change so all the Hindus, buddhists, jains, Sikhs can come to India
Shekar, can you stop saying “crackdown” and instead say “hindu genocide” in 1971? Also, you mention “refugees” came to Assam, but you fail to say “most of them were Hindus fleeing genocide.” By choosing to use “secular” vocabulary where you shouldn’t, you are just serving your own narrative and asking “why should CAA not be secular?”
By denying Hindus an acknowledgement of the atrocities that they go through in Af-Pak-Ban, you are doing a gross injustice.
That is why we need BJP until 2065.
Always playing victim card Hindu khatre mein hai bol bol kar bjp ko hi vote dalde
Really wish we Hindus played the victim card even 1% of what we should have @@gadgettv4472
Thank you BJP 🚩🚩🚩
"एक बार ये जो चोर-लुटेरों के पैसे विदेशी बैंकों में जमा हैं ना, उतने भी हम रुपये ले आए ना, तो भी हिंदुस्तान के एक-एक ग़रीब आदमी को मुफ़्त में 15-20 लाख रुपये यूँ ही मिल जाएँगे."
@@mg.f.9023pappu bhakt😂
@@mg.f.9023woh black money khangress rakti hain😂
Hope, the Print has no problem in implementing CAA.
CAA gives citizenship the problem is NRC which ask indians their citizen ship but this government is scared that's why this demonitization step.
Chl be Bhimte tujhe kuch pta bhi h @@vishalpatkar6819
@@vishalpatkar6819what's the problem in deporting illegal migrants. The whole argument that prople's indian citizenship will be taken away is so baseless bcz rules haven't even be defined regarding the process. Let rules come out first before making this false claim
@@jojosoni you don't know RSS I guess and their ideology they want a genocide NRC will do that.
@@jojosoni thats the fascists base ideology all around idiots RSS is no special they wanna colonize India and like the bootlickers you ancestors were of invaders you are doing the same like licking the boot is in your blood or something.
Print doing best what its best at - Confuse the good amplify the Bad .... topic is CAA the guy is going on discussing NRC 😂
Finally they did what PM Nehru and Pak first PM Liaquat Ali Khan planned in 1950 or so.
Then why Muslims are not leaving India to Pakistan or Bangladesh?
@@Sudhakarbathinihe will not reply to this 😂
Wait that too will happen because pakistan was created for muslims and 97 percent voted for creation of pakistan but after creation didnt go to Pakistan total partition must happened or as hindus population diminshed in pakistan same must happen here too,CAA must be created in pakistan too so muslims can move to pakistan for total partition.@@GraminIndia
947:
......... : we will make 2 countries one for hindu and one for muslim
: ok
2024:
hindus are tortured in muslim country, we will welcome them in our secular country
......... : How can you give citizenship to hindus in your secular country.
: But they are hindu, they are tortured, they have no country to go, also we were divided on religion.
........... No, India is secular. you can't welcome only hindus, welcome muslims also.
: Then why you divided our country?
...........: Because muslims are tortured in hindu majority.
: then why welcome them in hindu majority country?
...........: because....because...........
947:
......... : we will make 2 countries one for hindu and one for muslim
: ok
2024:
hindus are tortured in m@l!m country, we will welcome them in our secular country
......... : How can you give citizenship to hindus in your secular country.
: But they are hindu, they are tortured, they have no country to go, also we were divided on religion.
........... No, India is secular. you can't welcome only hindus, welcome m@sl!ms also.
: Then why you divided our country?
...........: Because m@sl!ms are tortured in hindu majority.
: then why welcome them in hindu majority country?
...........: because....because...........
CAA is the most humane and practical law formulated in recent yesrs.
When this new citizens will start taking your or urs families govt or private jobs n resources then u will realise
As general it is good humanitarian law yet all the problem is going to be faced by locals who have to give up their shares of everything
And lakhs no of more people might come to india
After it
BJP doing it for vote bank just like congress did bring bangladeshi immigrants
Only we common people will suffer
@@DM12768 when u can allow 20 crore ggazwa e hhind supporter inside iindia u have no right to talk about a prosecuted hhindus and sikh coming from paapistan.
@@urrasscal8380 its not abt religion brother
@@DM12768dude it is about religion. Don't u see what is happening in West Bengal? Some religions are less peaceful than others. U don't need to be non-secular to understand this, its pretty self evident.
@@pmt7483 my point against is out of religion so if u want to counter it don’t go to religion
Im talking about employment resources which will be shared
And presently there is already huge unemployment n lack of resources in country
If u have so much empathy towards them will u give ur piece of land to them
Will u share ur resources with them
If u r ready to give all this to them then
Im sorry u r right
Maybe u r directly not affected by this act but indirectly every citizen will be exposed
And kindly don’t take this issue to religious way
Im neither support any immigrant getting citizenship of any religion
Bcoz Indian citizens itself is suffering from huge crisis and trying to pull more people make it more difficult for common people like us
The country was partitioned based on religion Hindu Muslim.
And hence now CAA .
bro are you mad ??? or you dont know how to read and understand??? if you have guts reply me
we have to see this from humanity perspective. In afghanistan minority population became zero , In pakistan from 23 to 1% and in bangladesh 25% to 8 %. If they really treat minorities well why will the population of minorities decreases in those countries? why they will flee to border countries? We christians welcome this move. I support CAA.Just a basic common sense.. its nothing against indian muslims.
@@DilipKumar-tl9utdude make a point otherwise what will he reply too? 😂 are u dumb?
It is an appeal to Pakistan to pass an act similar to our CAA.So that minorities that feel prosecuted in Bharat can be granted citizenship in Pakistan.
Planning for genocide soo early ?
Dayumm...bro wants to send mullas to Pak...w
Super 😂
All of them are Muslim nations. Departing their homeland implies they are either traitors or the nation is experiencing political turmoil.
😂😂😂😂😂
Mr Gupta, be sensitive towards millions of Hindu refugees coming to India because of Arabian cult's leave, convert or get killed options given to them. Please donot water it down saying in Assam, these refugees primarily stayed back mostly because of economic prospect. Will you leave home, land, everything to settle in a foreign land as refugee on the mercy of others?
You do not have to monkey balance every time to show 1 is equal to 1 lakh applying the logic that both not equal to 0 hence equal.
You are fucking idiot and really blind and unread fascists CAA is no issue NRC is which ask your citizenship and if this fascists came again then they will show what's holocaust looks like for non Brahmin.
CAA should have been implemented long back... Atleast now they did
Modi 2024 ✌️
2029 mein 500 Paar ❤
@@ps93747 ye thoda jyada hojaaega. Total seats are 543. Usmese 500 matlab fir election band karne padenge.
@@mihirpingle5067 2029 mein remember 850 jaisi seats ho jayegi delimitations k bad toh 600 bhi munkin hai
If we had to give citizenship to Muslims why did we have the partition. It was they who said that they can't live with Hindus and demanded a seperate country. They choose not to go is their problem. The country is paying the price of not listening to Baba Saheb, who wanted to send all of them ti Pakistan. A cancer surgeon knows that the entire maglinant peace should be removed otherwise the cancer grows back soon. That is what has happened, more so because it found very supporting environment during Khangress regime.
❤❤❤❤
Well said, Muslim favouritism to the core
I second that🙌
@@37sairamsmjane se faida nahi hai bhai dande se manne wle log hai dimag kharab h un log ka
NRC should be implemented in our country atleast in those areas or states where demographics are changing faster than normal bcz of bangladeshi and rohangiya immigrants. There are many such regions like Assam, Tripura, Seemanchal region of Bihar, Kerala etc. And many other regions.
And how will you distinguish who is an illegal and who is not? The exercise was done in Assam and 2/3 people who couldn't prove citizenship turned out to be Hindus. It's even mentioned in this video.
@@mathurp6889those all will get citizenship by caa.
State like uttarpradesh, Madhya Pradesh and Gujarat can give place in their state,, here in North East we are packed
@@hj2711 Muslims aren't included in CAA. Just like millions of genuine Indian Hindus got excluded in NRC, millions of genuine Indian Muslims will also get excluded. But they won't be able to get citizenship through CAA.
So, wouldn't that be a problem?
@@prdblessed4016 EXACTLy !! Honestly speaking out of every 5 indigenous people of assam you will find 1 Bangladeshi. And I won't even comment about Tripura. The state has unfortunately lost all its pure culture and has been turned into Mini west bengal
Congress divided the nation on the basis of religion. Because of which Hindus became minorities in Pakistan,Bangladesh..These Hindus have fought against the British. They deserve citizenship of India. Above all they are human beings being treated like Animals in these Islamic Countries. We Indians should help these Hindus along with the Other minorities..They had their origin from Bharat
You get this history from WhatsApp clearly
@@mehmano9045Blood thirsty Jihadi spotted
@@mehmano9045u get ur info from ur neighborhood aunty😂😂
ur name is arabic, first keep a indian name before u dare speak, u backstabber@@mehmano9045
You do realize most of pakistan and Bangladeshi population used to be hindu's?!, there ancestors were hindu's!, i was born in a Muslim family but my ancestral history was off Royal brahmin's of gujrat , my sect in particular had to convert to survive after loosing the war!,also my family in particular doesn't like to be called muslim and hence my name shalin's a sanskrit word but we gotta act otherwise due to societal reasons
Now what you guys who really hate muslims suck at is ,you believe muslims are the problem in genreal but forget about countries like turkey for example or Azerbaijan's baku ,the problem isn't the realigion but the religious preachers who preach on the streets of our country ,they should be forced to not do these preachings , they teach nothing but either hate or brainwash unemployed, uneducated ,disloyal people ,they teach old teachings which are inhumane to other religions to say the least !, the problem with islam in general is their resistance to adapt to mordern times all due to them forgetting the main teaching of their prophet which was to say there is only one god but nowadays they treat everyone who preach as if he's near god ,like dude WTF !, it litreally goes against the core belief of islam itself all cause of these preachers
Media like print should accept show acknowledge that secularism is possible when Hindu are in more then 80 % population the movement it fall below 60 that state and country will be a converted into religious law abide country. Everyone know every Bangali was Hindu they are no where near to ethnic Muslims.
Problem is you hindus want to decrease the muslim population but not increase your own hindu population
Our Hindu brothers and sisters might have went through lot of hell. I hope this CAA help my siblings from other parents.
Shekhar: Pakistan does not want Bihari Muslims from Bangladesh, and recently expelled millions of Afghans.
Howls of Protest in Middle East countries where by law non Muslims can't get citizenship.
False. Non Arabs can't get citizenship
This act is 5 years too late. NRC is also a must at this time. Illegals need to kicked out.
Minorities might have faced ....
are you serious.
See the minorities data from these countries Afghanistan Pakistan Bangladesh
Discussion about Article 14 in case of CAA is a moot point as Article 14 only talks about people who are citizens of India whereas CAA only talks about the people who are NOT a citizen of India. Mutually exclusive.
Utter rubbish
Legit quoting article 14, " The State shall not deny to any person equality before the law or the equal protection of the laws within the territory of India, on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth."
Where is citizen word here?
Actually sad truth is,lies are sold so easily
@@maitreyeemishra2498 Art. 14 applies to Indian Citizens only. In 1947, India was divided on religious lines. The transfer of population should have been done. CAA is a milder version of LAUTENBERG AMENDMENT in the United States which enables citizenship to identified persecuted religious minorities in Soviet Union, Iran etc. Under this law - ‘persecuted religious’ minorities like Jews, Christians, Baha’ is fleeing Iran to jump the queue to gain citizenship in USA. The LAUTENBERG-SPECTER AMENDMENTS positively discriminates among minorities by creating a ‘reasonable classification’ to EXCLUDE the Muslim majority.
Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) 2019 provides the Hindu, Sikh, Buddhist, Jain, Christian and Parsi communities from Pakistan, Afghanistan and Bangladesh staying in India without required documents, a chance to become naturalized citizens on favorable terms. Pakistan, Afghanistan and Bangladesh have declared themselves to be Islamic nations constitutionally, therefore Muslims in majority there excluded.
@@VK-md7jm all this knowledge cannot negate my argument of applicability of article 14 also what the US does is none of india's concerns the whites act as hypocrites by allowing free borders and assimilating persecuted populations, they were the only ones to wipe of generations of natives Americans, Latinos, aborigines, hispanics and construct uncle Sam.
I am not against caa, but I felt the urge to correct your facts
Gupta ji, please don't cry.
We all pray and hope that once congress comes back, they will bring MAA( Muslim Appeasement Act).
Khangress passed MAA in 1947 itself… it’s only that they did not declare it to general public.
Con-gress created 2 mu-slim countries in 1947, and an additional one in 1971.
Well said😅
@@chaitanyakada1341 Yep - u are right.
The goal was to make 2 is-lamic countries in 1947
Kudos to the Govt even if it is a BURNOL moment for .........an ever burning future for Gupta ji.
Salute our honourable prime minister Shri Modi and shree Annamalai for their good leadership and vision ❤
Live long safe, prosperous and incredible India ❤
Best wishes from Kerala state, India ❤
I hate abridged versios of ctc
+1
+1
+1
Let me clear why are Muslims not included in #CAA.
It's because this initiative is to help those minority Hindus, Parsis, Sikhs, Buddhists, Jains and Christians who are being oppressed in neighbouring IsIamic countries.
Muslims aren't being persecuted in Pakistan, Afghanistan & Bangladesh type countries so they don't need it.
But rohingyas are being persecuted in Myanmar, isn't that a border countrt of india?
@nerdcell4657 NE hindus are already a minority now
This is atleast a 70 yr old plan now being official applied.
CAA toh jhaki hai NRC, UCC abhi baki hai 😅
We know dude fascist have been shouting for a while.
In 1947, British-India was partitioned based on Religion. So, CAA should be extended to all Hindus, including Sikhs, Buddhists, and Jains as defined in the Constitution, and for any time in future.
I am wondering who are those critics???😂😂😂.....I am not intelligent, could anyone answer?
Those selling biriyanis of stray meat - Khangress' voters
Yeah, it's a bad idea. Ask away, I could help you with some answers.
@iac Shekar Gupta.
@ica Shekar Gupta.
Wrong messaging. Totally disagree with Print. Why shouldn't the minorities of the neighboring Islamic countries not get citizenship those who landed in India by the cut-off date seeking asylum. Why should Muslim citizens of those Islamic countries get citizenship in India. Don't give this high morality lecture to Indians. Go there and give it to your friends in Pakistan, especially those who are persecuting minorities in their countries. After all, they got 3 countries and 2 carved out of Bharat in the name of Islam. Stop spreading the wrong interpretation. Present the facts. This is not against the current Muslim citizens of India. 😮
How come these same gulf countries go silent in uighyur Muslim issue when it comes to China
The logic is simple, Muslims have many options if they are persecuted in western countries. They can go to Afghanistan, Syria , Lebanon or Bangladesh and Practice their religion without discrimination. Unfortunately Other religions don't have the luxury
Let's ask a simple question ourselves Muslims got Pakistan and Bangladesh in 1947 what did the Hindus get? And if Muslims from the Muslim countries are asking for Indian citizenship then why did the partition happened? The Rohingyas have permanent residence card of Jammu and Kashmir I mean how? Why the islamisation of India should be funded by Hindus themselves? Shekhaji please make video on illegal Rohingyas in Jammu and Kashmir, Maharashtra, Delhi and many parts of the country as well.
Why would this halfwit be interested in making videos about illegal Rohingyas in India?
Shekhar ji Why Pakistan Bangladesh because it's partition era issue...
CAA is to Carter to this..
Muslims Hindus from any other countries can also eligible but they have to come through the existing old laws..
Thank you so much to this government for CAA, now distress call can be addressed, there are so many distress call even on CZcams but nobody cares for persecuted Hindus and Sikhs. This will give them hope for better future. They should also be help economically as well.
Sir correct you’re facts,,
1) properties of Muslims or any other community who left india were taken by Waqf board not govt.
2) His points raise a similar question to the Muslims of india, which if you feel pressure,
if they’ve been persecuted or something for example then why our land was given to Muslims Pakistan & Bangladesh ???
So why you’re questioning now the same logic is being applied to Hindus in those Islamic countries ??
Great job by this govt.
Gandhi said this bt couldn't make it happen
Nehru said this bt couldn't make it happen
Lohia said this bt couldn't make it happen
Manmohan said this bt couldn't make it happen
All the political giants just said but didn't implemented it, all talk no work finally someone did it🙌🏽🙏🏽
Bharat is natural home of dharmic pariwar jain+sikh+hindu+buddhist= dharmic pariwar, bharat is our ancestral land. Rest are alien to this land hence this bill does justice with those who were persecuted just cz an alien community decided to break our land & inflict tyranny on the people who were the rightful heir of this land.
India and Indian government can decide who should be given citizenship. We are a sovereign nation. But who were here generations can’t be thrown out
Looks like Shekhar Gupta is troubled with the notification of CAA😂😂
They Just waited the number in Lower House as its Almost both houses BJP had full strength, its time for CAA and UCC
Pakistan and Bangladeshi government must implement their CAA for Indian Muslims. We don't have any issue.
Best comment 😄👍
No
Absolutely welcome step. All countries will follow this for their own people. Probably the best way to control terrorism.
Gandhi opposed and Muslim’s property who left (30% only left)were not given to returning refugees from Pakistan!!
Your channel comes on automatically even when I don't press any button. Are you using some software to force people to watch your channel?
The name of his software is called : SECULARISM.
Pappu & Soros are promoting it to Hindus of Bharath.
Nrc should be brought now
It will be implemented along with NRC
Govt should maintain 1947 ratio of diversity to protect democracy.
If not what happened in Kashmir is what will happen.
What sort of an argument is this that India should take all minorities from the entire world?
This is the reason i have to vote BJP.
Modi 3.0 will be Fire. They already crying.
NRC should also be introduced soon. Better late (after 2024 elections) than never.
prosperous country?. that why they stayed back.? read selective genocide chapter in Arrthur Blood's book..
"Tripura Also"!!? . Sir you missed Tripura , the most effected state in India due to influx of illegal immigrants from Bangladesh between ( 1940s-2000s) more than 10 million people came in undocumented !! If you really want to understand CAA, understand what's happening in Tripura. You will get your answer. Your own answer is here by print media: -czcams.com/video/NxmVXe7zIHo/video.html
Agreed 100%!!
Yes
Agreed!
The most neglected state in India!
@@Modeuga11 , Tripura is a mini Bangladesh!
Sb Isi 5 saal me kr denge,, pta ni next term kon kon sa shock milega..
Flag march by police should be held on buldozer 😂
Next term me pok le lenge.....(asan nhi hai lekin)
Thank you Mr shekhar Gupta, for articulating your thoughts so effectively. Why do only Hindus or religion based on India receive these CAA benefits? Why not be others considered. However liberals like you seem unconcerned about the persecution and struggles faced by Hindus, Sikhs, and Budha. You liberals find anything that helps to bring equality among everyone is not good but appeasing only one religion and religious people is at most priority
Now I got it. Which party is implementing this law that is most scary to everyone.
Both preys and predators don’t equally qualify for being a refugee! We help the preys! Intentions Guptaji, as you put it, is to protect the interest of Indian citizens. I don’t know if you have a problem about that!?
Gupta Ji’s version of SICKULARISM says that the Peacefuls are always the victims and the Prey ..
Please understand this above concept !!!
Hindu Sindhis will be forever grateful to Modiji 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
I have a profound sense of empathy towards the youth of India, recognizing the multifaceted challenges they encounter in navigating societal narratives shaped by historical burdens. It is palpable that concerted efforts are underway to mould their perspectives, often laden with biases inherited from the past. This complex amalgamation of influences underscores a journey that, in my estimation, may span several hundred years before India realizes its fullest potential. This perspective isn't merely speculative; rather, it's grounded in a nuanced understanding of the intricate dynamics at play within Indian society.
India has to get noble peace prize for implementation of CAA because we know how minorities are treated in muslim countries especially hindus in sub continent
Comprehensive clear simplified explanation. A public service. 🚩🚩Jai Shri Ram🙏🙏🙏
Was waiting for this from the Print!
Complete exchange of population was to be done as per Dr Ambedkar
Aare bhai hum apane Hindu bhaiyon ke liye kyu nahi kanun bana sakte..Hindu Hindu ke kam nahi aayega to aur kon aayega..
This man can’t digest Modi’s popularity
The reason it's limited to those 3 countries is because they were historically part of India.
All the Muslim of India and Pakistan love “the print” for true spirit of journalism.
Counter to you argument
Pak Bangladesh and Afghanistan's persecuted minorities were part of British raaj
Where in case of other countries were not part of India
Are we forgetting that the laws are applicable to CITIZENS
It gives non citizen citizenship.
Cut off date should be removed.
Shekhar gupta retrying setting the country on fire
Shekhar ji, you have again precisely emphasised on the importance of the trust in the government and their policies. It needs proper communication and less politics. This problem of linguistic identity vs religious identity would not die out soon. Kudos that you decided again to put this video out, because there is so much misinformation out there that we don’t want people to lose their lives over this again. Hope the North East does not go up in flames again. Dear people, stay calm.
Any Hindu, per Indian constitution , for any reason and at any time should be allowed to come back to India.
India is in dire need of law for protection of foreign tourists
10 Indians have been offed in America in last 45 days … do u see them give a sh**….
Pakistan doesn't want CAA to be implemented in India
KHANgress doesn't want CAA to be implemented in India
Gupta doesn't want CAA to be implemented in India
yeh rishta kya kehlata hai?
Mr Shekhar Gupta, you said that BJP did not want to lose the Hindu or Buddhist votes of migrants. Did you ever say that Congress did not want to lose Muslim votes? You must have remained silent on this. This is called reporting loyal to the Congress. Talking half truth and not talking the truth that will affect Congress. Half truth is worse than a lie.
*इस्लामिक देश में मजहब आधारित अल्पसंख्यको के उत्पीडन,, प्रताड़ित व्यक्तियो को भारत में CAA कानून से न्याय और सहारा मिल पायेगा ,,,, मोदी जी को धन्यवाद एवम् साधुवाद ।*
The equal treatment before law is for all citizens. Here people have not even become citizens
It's their short-sightedness. One thing which keeps a person loyal to a country is citizenship irrespective of how poor he/she is, how neglected he/she is. And they are about to take that final straw away from millions of people. It will have devastating consequences for the nation!
Sekhar sir always doesn't care about anything if there is anything done by central
govt he will twist confuse fear mongering then with a philosophy to viewers i am a man of wisdom
Well done Modi Government❤
bike hua merE darbari gupta ji :), dukh dekha nhi ja raha inka 😂
Thank you modi
In 1947, British-India was partitioned based on Religion, so Hindus must be allowed to come to Bharat through CAA. Since partition, East Pakistan/Bangladesh has ethnically cleansed 15 million Hindus , from 20%, per 1951 census, to 5% today. During the same time, 20 million Muslims have come to Bharat through illegal infiltration, changing Muslim population from 20 % to about 40% today in WB.
Those who don't like CAA should take the next trawler out of India for good.
Great action.by.,b,j,p❤
😂😂😂 fucking joker they will change your country and its name too and kick you lower caste out too.
What is not there why oppose that?
He forgot(deliberately) the back ground/context : portion of the country on basis of religion and consequently persecution of minorities who could come or leave pak... They say Persecution of minorities happening in India then why muslima r not migrating to their safest of heaven : pak, B'deah Afghanistan. Or why not pak is making similar law after all pak is for all muslims especially subcontinent muslims.
atyicle 14 says all CITIZENS have equal rights, but it can't be applied to the context of CAA, cause they are not citizens yet, so it really doesn't apply to them, so this argument should not stand any ground in the court.
article 14 resevation pe lagu nhi hota ha kya?
😅
Sir Indian constitution is for giving protection to citizens of India. So Article 14 applies to citizens of India only. CAA is for non citizens of India who intend to take up Indian citizenship. So clearly Article 14 of Indian constitution does not apply. This is common sense and Govt is not fool to do such a silly mistake. Let the opposition does whatever they want. Now the real question is whether citizenship should be given to enemies just based on religion. That may be matter of may security concern. And secondly how we are verifying their actual religion. I believe India shouldn’t give citizenship just like that without any thorough scrutiny. And we are already 1.4 billion and this act may increase illegal migration to India in a hope that they may get citizenship in future. So this is dangerous for national security. Hence I believe CAA is not required.
Muslims divided the country in 1947on the basis of religion, why they shd be taken in bharat
Kya rss k kutte RSS was with leash in British helping British divide India,and now trying to colonize India with Brahminism even shamelessly calming to change country constitution and name to brahminrhastra.
Respect
Dear SG, the CAA us pretty simple and straightforward. You just tandem compound that with NRC and confuse it intentionally (?)
It's moye moye for the print 😅
the reason i watch shekar ji is because he reminds me of my grandfather he is not there anymore but i get to see in shekar ji 😊