Yuval Noah Harari on When Your Taxes Pay for War
Vložit
- čas přidán 14. 05. 2024
- At the start of this century, something amazing happened: governments worldwide started spending more on healthcare than on the military. This was unthinkable for most of history, but humans proved that it’s achievable. Unfortunately, the current resurgence of war has led global defense budgets to jump to a record high. Nevertheless, the unprecedented achievements of the recent past remind us that the decline of war is not some divine miracle: it’s a reality we can collectively choose.
From a recent conversation with @adammgrant on the ReThinking podcast by @TED. Listen at open.spotify.com/episode/15GS....
#war #peace #military #budget #defense #government #healthcare #taxes - Zábava
![How Did The Wealthy Gain Power In The Past? - Yuval Noah Harari [2015] | Intelligence Squared](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/TYAKHLrr51w/mqdefault.jpg)
![How Did The Wealthy Gain Power In The Past? - Yuval Noah Harari [2015] | Intelligence Squared](/img/tr.png)
even though i don't like paying taxes, i used to think it was the responsible thing to do if we want a better society. After learning more about my country's role in the middle east, i'm reconsidering this..
It goes to show how very stupid we still are.
Something happens to the mind of leaders that they just want to war
Great. Thanks.
This man speaks Truth!!! Thank you Sir!!!!
The fact that money is not nominally assigned to war machines in the official budget, does not mean you are not paying for a war. When you pay for intelligence agencies, police, instead of a proper education; when you pay for international policies that export inflation and conflict through debt and political unrest, rather than infrastructure and health; when most of your budget is to cover debt, instead of investments, you are also paying for war
Completely correct.
I have learned more from youtube comments than college textbooks. Thank you.
Absolutely agree. Political and economic sanctions can be nearly as destructive to a country's people as gunpowder armaments themselves.
You take freedom and peace and democracy for granted. Especially in America where people haven't experienced a war on their soil since 1865... For instance, people have zero understanding of Russia and they know nothing about Eastern Europe but feel entitled to have an "opinion" on Putin or Ukraine...
Figueiredo's comment contained more understanding and wisdom than the video
Cannot believe I used to repsect him
✨☮✨
📍1:50
How much of this was due to the US being a global superpower impossible to take down? The US military budget has consistently being much higher than average.
as unsavory as the Pax Americana is to much of the world, we don't know what happens when it ends.
surprised but very glad to hear that things actually can get better if nations make a concerted effort⚛😀
The 10% world expenditure on healthcare is misleading. The figure is hugely inflated by the US which leads the world in nominal healthcare expenditure.
In truth the money doesn't go towards improving people's health.
Healthcare in America is an enormous swindle that produces gigantic bureaucracies and enormous profits for shareholders while delivering among the worst health outcomes in developed countries.
A better label for so-called US healthcare is US sickness profiteering.
Excluding the United States the world figure for healthcare expenditure falls below the figure for war spending.
Those figures also do not include all of the off-balance-sheet expenditures on intelligence agencies, covert paramilitary support, black weapons programs and military-industrial research and development.
The picture painted here is misleading.
@@mmaximk you're absolutely right and spot-on about US "health care system" thank you⚛😀
We... the humans... ☮🌍✌🏻
Yuval, if you truly want to help - stop being a genocide apologist.
👏👏👏
👏👏
💯❤️
This is very true, people in Gaza paid taxes to Hamas via the charge for usage of tunnels to smuggle in food supplies and weapons.
Why, I, in this weak piping time of peace,,
Have no delight to pass away the time,
Unless to spy my shadow in the sun
And descant on mine own deformity:
And therefore, since I cannot prove a lover,
To entertain these fair well-spoken days,
I am determined to prove a villain
And hate the idle pleasures of these days.
As to current events, Professor Harari is welcome to leave his country and go live in one that neglects its own security even more than his present one does.
Exactly 💯 sir , sir please give overview of climate change topic from your book 21 century. Please give a comprehensive paragraph which we can used as reference in English essay for Compitative exams. Please sir
Thank you Yuval Harari for the reminder on History.
The 10% world expenditure on healthcare is misleading. The figure is hugely inflated by the US which leads the world in nominal healthcare expenditure.
In truth the money doesn't go towards improving people's health.
Healthcare in America is an enormous swindle that produces gigantic bureaucracies and enormous profits for shareholders while delivering among the worst health outcomes in developed countries.
A better label for so-called US healthcare is US sickness profiteering.
Excluding the United States the world figure for healthcare expenditure falls below the figure for war spending.
What pays the war expenses is infinite supply of Fiat money
I WONDER WHY YOU DO NOT GO A STEP FORWARD
he forgot about MMT. you can just print the money now, especially if you are in the USA.
Selective Memory….
Thats why he is talking in percentages not in nominal values.
@@ognjenjosifov126 what a dumb thing to reply.
And why is this a problem?
Honey, I am an economist. Just because you don't understand it doesn't mean it is dumb.
It is very telling of humans that this person is silent on the genocide next door
his hypocrisy stinks like a gutter.
That's nice. Tell Putin.
And you tell Biden, Obama, Bush, Clinton, etc first
Stop war
You can have violence without warfare... Such as by way of applying power and hatred to gain advantage or oppress those who you perceive as needing to be more subservient. It is not really that much better to be passively violent than actively violent. I would assert that while active violence is shocking subversive violence is more psychological twisting, that the pressing of the appearance of virtue across the true hostility like so much cheese, has the effect of actually grating the peace and melting faith. Mixing love and blood and joy and hate.
I feel like if I keep going with the metaphor it'll be a strange spaggetti thing that seems very silly but you get what I'm saying!
Years of passive violence will end in active war and always victims will be blamed for war
can't believe you said recently that history has shown we should trust governments and systems of money. Oh man, that's funny. Bitcoin is trustless - that is a GREAT thing. It can't be corrupted by man
He's silent on his government's war on Gaza. Why's that? Is he afraid of losing his job and cosy life?
Why are you silent about Hamas starting this war and using people as living shields?
@@XOPOIIIO Because both are AIPAC lies
Far from it he’s spoken about many times on many podcast, Sam Harris’s for one, do your homework.
@@ericgilliomvideos Do yours. I'm not talking about other podcasts, silly
Yuval Harari promoted Russian Ukraine war. Thus this is partly his responsibility as well
Time to get into liberalist party.
Accepting International Law is the best solution. Ask your government to whom you pay taxes to accept UN two state solution of Palestine and Israel. Live like normal neighbors and forget the made up religious narratives to commit genocide and establish apartheid system 🙏
But taxes don't pay for things, big misconception there
There's so much judgy off-hand rivalry amongst you academics... Maybe I've even inherited this psychology... Or maybe had it the whole time?
If peace is an intention, then maybe it should reveal itself both in less overt aggression AND less passive aggression.
This man is pure evil.
Sorry but I have sent this comment elsewhere and thought here was also a good place to post it. I will try not do it again. Honest.
Please get on the good side of palestinians. When finally oil will be no more in the region in ten years (geologists say so) it will stop being profitable for the U.S.A. to invest in your protection and therefore they will stop protecting you (this already happened in Afganistan. foreign armies fled when oil reservoirs depletted). If you don't improve your relationships somehow with the muslim community on the region, without U.S.A.'s protection all your surounding neighbours will go against you and you won't last much (no one could). I'm European. I want to show the rest of the world (or try at least) that the path to justice, fairness, progress and happiness is the path of western democracies (if possible, laic republics with freedom of faith for its citizens). To accomplish that is very important Israel stands its ground in the middle east but as I said, in ten years it won't if things don't improve. Please, reflect and change your ways. Asap. As you say all those muslim countries are rather violent. As you say the problem will only stop when they will become more peaceful. How can that be done ? Bombarding palestinians ? This only makes them even more violent. Give them palestinians good things (a free state for themselves, hospitals, schools or whatever or at least stop bombarding them).
Show those muslim countries that unlike them who use violence even within their own borders with their own people, you use peace instead even with those who are not of your own. Lead by example. Someone has to break this endless cursed cycle of pain and suffering. Only the best can. Show them the best are you. A western republic democracy. We common people are extremely simple and pragmatic (due to thousands years of evolution forcing us to be so). They will follow your example if they percieve they obtain good things. If they don't bc of their fanatism at least they will not hate your people so much and will allow you to stay in your homeland. I they don't bc of, once again, their fanatism, like you say, I don't like either what I will say now but your people, sadly, once again, will have to leave elsewhere.....or well, I won't even say the other option. But it is an option. The last one. If you think otherwise please do tell how you think the problem can be solved. Like you I also like to listen to smart comments, ideas or solutions. Sadly on this video you haven't offered none. Maybe mine are silly, naive, unrealistic or whatever but I have tried at least. Like you said the essence, the soul of the issue here is the violence and the narrow mindedness of a very, very, very large community. How to make them more peaceful and open minded ? With care and knowledge ? Don't know for sure but someone has to.
haha he sounds like mis unverse, nothing practical out of this video :(
While with just this clip I'm likely missing some context, judging this clip alone the idea presented is not intelligent at all. It's pretending a consequence (the amount of violence necessary) is somehow a primary reality rather than derivative fact of the types of governments the populations of the world are willing to tolerate. The more people are OK with governments that don't uphold individual rights, the more violence will be necessary to essentially liberate ourselves as individual. DEMOCRACY won't help and should not be promoted, just look what evil will be voted in under democracy when the population accepts certain evil ideologies like far-left American politics or Islam.
You are just a warmonger
Awesome ....now let's talk about how Israel went from the bottom to the top of US military aid .
Why your country Isreal still living in ancient ,medieval period of war? Isreal must play positive role in bringing peace in the middle east.
As a historian and public intellectual, Yuval does not represent Israel or Israel's government so I am not sure why you are posing your question in such a way but he probably would have an intelligent answer to give in response. I would think Yuval is almost certainly opposed to Netanyahu's government, its actions and the actions taken by the IDF in Gaza. Israel's militarism is largely a result of ultra nationalism and religious fundamentalism which has created a militant Judaism, that combined with the collective psychology of 70+ years of being faced with existential annihilation by its surrounding neighbors while also grappling with the psychological impact of its Ashkenazi diaspora community experiencing the worst genocide in history at the hands of Europeans. As one of the only free and democratic nations in the region, Israel absolutely has a mantle of responsibility to bring peace to the middle east and so far it's extreme sectarianism, sense of exceptionalism and rise in its own religious extremism in parallel to Islamist extremism exhibited by groups like Hamas is helping to create a disaster.
No, We Israelis live in in 22nd century, but we must to protect ourself from medieval islamists and the leftists who help them.
I couldn't agree more
Let me share the case of my country Pakistan with you, you will get amazed. . . . . . .In pakistan more then seventy percent budget goes to defense sector. . . . . . .but when i see the palestine our life are still better then palestine. . . . . . spending on security living in 21st century is more important then spending on education and health
John 14:6 Jesus said to him, "I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through Me.
1 Corinthians 15:3 that Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures, and that He was buried, and that He rose again the third day according to the Scriptures.
Romans 10:9 that if you confess with your mouth the Lord Jesus and believe in your heart that God has raised Him from the dead, you will be saved. 🌍