The Storming of Gate Pah - the defeat of the British by Maori warriors
Vložit
- čas přidán 20. 05. 2024
- Free one month trial on The Great Courses Plus: ow.ly/gAEv308jLrJ
The British love tales of their own military disasters. This was their greatest defeat in New Zealand. Artillery against clubs and spades.
Support me on Patreon: / lindybeige
Disclaimer: "The Great Courses Plus is currently available to watch through a web browser to almost anyone in the world and optimized for the US market. The Great Courses Plus is currently working to both optimize the product globally and accept credit card payments globally."
After uploading this, I found out that a fellow CZcamsr and watcher of my videos has also covered this topic, and his videos add some more details: • Pukehinahina / Gate Pa...
Buy the music - the music played at the end of my videos is now available here: lindybeige.bandcamp.com/track...
More weapons and armour videos here: • Weapons and armour
Lindybeige: a channel of archaeology, ancient and medieval warfare, rants, swing dance, travelogues, evolution, and whatever else occurs to me to make.
▼ Follow me...
Twitter: / lindybeige I may have some drivel to contribute to the Twittersphere, plus you get notice of uploads.
Facebook: / lindybeige (it's a 'page' and now seems to be working).
Google+: "google.com/+lindybeige"
website: www.LloydianAspects.co.uk
/ user "Lindybeige"
Somehow it's deadly funny to think of a Maori warrior taunting English soldiers in English with, "Go on then have another go."
chur
Many Maori at the time as well as being multilingual international traders and travellers were more literate than the average English soldier. Mimicry had a long history in hunting and warfare for them as did psychological warfare. Maori tohunga schools taught astronomy, medicine and more. Pre European agricultural included seasonal movement between food sources, management of wild stocks to prevent, exchange of resources, and cultivated and engineered fields. designed to grow warmer climate crops in cold regions.
Or they be shouting come on try it again while I sip my tea hahaha
+shotguns!
so in us,"Go on then Have another go", 2020, go on then have another go....
say whatever you want about lindy, the fact that he does 30 minute videos talking the whole time in one shot is damn impressive
30 minutes is a skirmish for him at the point. Now he's doing full on campaigns with his videos
Wait why doesn't he do multiple takes
@@scribeslendy595 because he doesn't need to
I sat through a 2 hour vid of him in one take and didn’t notice 2 hours had gone by
@@scribeslendy595 hes very good at collecting his thoughts. Hes also not ashamed when hes mispeaks and corrects himself unlike every other youtuber with constant jump cuts.
"How many Maori were there?"
"Enough."
@@gregorybathurst7171 your Mrs done u over quite well by the sounds of it lmao
@@justintyme1171 thats where savage come to mind and with all that out the door @ x wifey thinking shes up there and all good stuff she will do in the community . ora vha chow
@@justintyme1171 whos laughing now the xmrs that thinks she did ok and some moron lhfao what you laughing at ! it may be you need take a second job
They tried to wipe out all our Maori people and they almost succeeded
@@juanita7562 We are survivor s.
1700 men being on a trek in 1900s nz? It's a formidable force even now in nz... I cant even get 1 bro to come to the dairy with me
Haha lol
What the fucks a dairy?
@@SwadianKnight101 it's a small local shop like the corner store usually owned by a Indian or Chinese lol
Because you know what happens if you leave you scooter outside
@@snigie1 nek minute
It's true the Zulu's struggled to compete on the mustache front.
Alexander Kerensky
The Sergeant Major made up for the rest of the command.
Think you mean "Colour Sergeant Bourne" There was no Sgt Major at Rorke's Drift.
Francis Wright
Thanks for the correction.
trueseeing ya u know what they say if u don't have moustache u gave no hope (though there r exeptions) what they needed was gandalph the great but black and loads of lumberjack zulus and many Chinese sensie moustaches
Colour Sergeant was also the youngest Colour Sergeant in the army.
"but he got the town of hamilton named after him" trust me, that is no honour
lol chur
dont talk shit about the tron bro. one outs g square up
I_360_No_scoped_JFK what it’s known for
@@RATSALLCAPS bro ctch me at kura kfc 2nite, gt a 1/2 eaten snck box and free hidin 4 u tena kuay
@@cinderblock4438 why you being heavy on the bro eah, falas just defending his hood.
"The Zulus just didn't have the moustaches"....
*Britishness intensifies*
harumphing
Humperdinck
Balhoggen
Oh wait, y’alls are real words aren’t they?
😂
It’s fascinating to note that even after they successfully defeat the Maori later, Cameron found the war extremely distasteful, and wished for it to end. He apparently found the Maori more courageous and chivalrous than the colonists he was there to defend.
Cameron might have found war distasteful but the Maori found their defeated enemies very tastful. Pass the salt old boy.
@@eardwulf785 cannibalization had pretty much ended by then
@@mattyallen3396
Just a light hearted joke Matty. I have a lot of respect for the Maori culture.
I thought the british didn't defeat the maori
@@boiifyoudont2952 Not in this battle, but they won the war
I prefer "culture who didn't spec into the gunpowder tree"
If you play them correctly, the Traditionalist buff let's you build some really powerful melee build, especially if you combine it with some AI exploits.
they actually do. just look at the balkans
+RAVA Corey
I mean they had double barreled shotguns, so they were at least partway into the gunpowder tree.
Actually, it is rarely the case, just what happens is you have many scuffles over each more recent events that stretch thousands of years.
The Stoned Videogame Nerd lol. What happened? Did one of the brothers steal your mrs? Wait you are probably 11, in fact the Maori come from a people who were in Iron Age but reverted back to the Stone Age as there was a combination of lack of resources or lack of reason to need iron tools. To say that a people who could navigate between islands from America to Madagascar when Europeans were struggling to travel from France to England is hypocrisy. And knowing that the Polynesian people could sale to the America’s back to New Zealand via Hawaii is testimony to how brilliant us Maori are. We have Maori people throughout all forms of tertiary education and in all avenues of the workforce
I served in the NZ Infantry in the 70s and admired and respected my Maori comrades whose training cadre were incredibly tough, learned, intelligent and resilient. Kia kaha tatou. My father served five years in the 20th Armoured & Infantry Reg' in Italy and Egypt in WW2 and was a stretcher-bearer in the 28th Maori Battalion. He said that Maori bayonet charges were feared by the Italian and German enemy as Maori particularly relished it.
The lesser partner in ANZAC. Seems the Aussies have taken a lot of the glory. I guess you Kiwis are more modest, but more disciplined, as far as I've heared.....
I’d shit my soul out
@@thedumbdog1964 Imagine you were conscripted into the Wehrmacht 2 days ago and then suddenly you hear the LOUDEST haka ever and all the sudden the enemy start a massive charge
Kena koe e hoa
A very lovely story🙏
@@juwebles4352 I mean you'd just open fire with the MG-42.
"go on then have on have another go!" as a blindside flanker that played against some predominately Maori teams this gives me severe ptsd
Should verse us in a eating competitions 😂💀
@@davidsavelio6492 first armed combat trainer in the aus army was Maori
Where do you think the All Blacks got it from?
Thanks for this Lindy. I wanted to add something about this battle regarding the Maori.
There was a woman who extended her hand in aid to some of the fallen soldiers. This woman was the daughter of Paraone Koikoi and Matatu. Her name was Harata Te Auetu. During the night, she fretted for her uncles and her father who were engaged in the battle. She mounted her horse at Judea, and travelled alongside the kopurererua stream. She climbed up the stream and climbed up to Pukehinahina. But when she reached the other side of the river, she saw that the maori warriors had already escaped. When she arrived, she came across soldiers by the river who were injured from the battle. She took it upon herself to take them to the hospital. At the time the hospital was based at the home of Archdeacon Reverend Brown. Although she didn't even know their names, she managed to get one soldier upon her horse. By then it was daylight. She believed that if she were spotted with a soldier on her horse, they would be shot. So she took him home. She and her family nursed this soldier back to health. His name was David Hall. A few days after the battle, the British soldier returned to his infantry. But he eventually returned to the marae to ask for the hand of Harata in marriage. They then married.
Such a beautiful story. An honorable act of compassion.
That would be a fantastic premise for a movie
@@M4dM4n96 It definitely would. I can imagine it being an epic scene of battle mixed with bravery. Woman aren't nearly enough shown for the bravery they show. Yet, it most always comes down to bravado testosterone of the males.
@@ewartward damn right!
Courage and compassion are sorely lacking nowadays, both in media and irl.
This is a story if war. No time to read about whatever women where doing. Twidling their thumbs
Lloyd's casual animosity to the French always amuses me.
It's like Romanians and Hungarians just without the murders.
It's like if the Hundred Years' War was a tennis match.
It’s the stress of facing the French coast day by day
Its traditional.
Badger0fDeath
10:50, he said that he'd been taught that modern history started after the Congress of Vienna, after the French had just been stuffed.
It's a little, throw-away line, but I find it hilarious.
The moustache is a grossly underestimated tool in war. About time it was recognised
Imagine if the Maori had moustaches and fancy uniforms! They'd have been unstoppable.
And Flags!
Sheldon Cooper would definitely agree with you. These guys had some good ol' Fun With Flags.
tigermunky
And crenellated contextual pommels.
😉
Agnarr Salventius I cant believe no one commented about how orgasmic this statement is.
The Maori had some brilliant commanders. That trap is a nightmare scenario, and it's a wonder any British troops survived at all.
So that's why Zulus lost in the end
**Shakes Head**
*They just didn't have the moustaches*
They uhm.. Didn't lose.
Oh yeah, after they won, the Zulus were saying to themselves, we're sick of this land, let's give it to the guys we just beat in battle!
Britain took Zulu territory, while the Zulus had early success, they lost in the end.
Look it up
@@gfoog3911 You can take their land, but you can never take their freedom!
Ok then? I'm American, not British anyhow, so my country didn't colonize 'em.
@@gfoog3911 Haha I'm just bein' a cunny funt, dw mate, you are indeed correct.
This would make a pretty good war movie.
Jeffery Liggett there is a movie that takes place during the New Zealand Wars and it is called The River Queen.
There is a film called Utu which covers a period of the New Zealand Wars - www.imdb.com/title/tt0086497/
A good project for Peter Jackson and co maybe.
Good god NO, he will make it a trilogy and introduce an Elf chick !
So humor was not part of your NZ military training ?
Tena koe Lindybeige. Nga mihi ki a koe mo to korero pangia tenei mahi rongonui o nga tupuna.
Thank you LB. Thank you for presenting this talk about these famous deeds of our ancestors.
I did enjoy hearing about Gate Pa again and in such a competent and balanced way. When your used to hearing your language and history get butchered by others, its was refreshing to hear your presentation.
You have earned my loyal subscription. Cheers.
Hey my pee pee hurts wlare you te roopo
Ae bro
only the best got sent into the 'final' war of empires, hence why we are still lacking to this day. Republic Aotearoa Zealand
Please be aware that when he says "british" what he means is supporters/active participants/employees of the UK REGIME. The british are the indigenous habitants of the british isles who were just as poorly treated by the violent gangs of the regime as the mauris...just many many years previous.
so butchered
The Maoris were one of the few native populations that invested heavily into guns for their forces.
Like the rest of us, we where all less boring in the past then we are now
A lot of tribes on the Great Plains in a North America also invested heavily in guns, they recovered something like 42 different types of bullets and casings from the battlefield at Little Bighorn, compare that against the 2 types of firearms carried by the US Cavalry troopers at the same battle.
Not true bro it was difficult and illegal for maori to buy firearms since gun laws started here in 1840, firearms were purchased from mostly foreign whaling ships. Maori crudely manufactured there own bullets and gunpowder
@@admiralgoodboy thank you brother.
Indeed. Not only smallarms, but artillery as well.
As someone of Maori descent, this is incredibly well done. My ancestors and family are warriors and I am proud to say we still practice many of our marshal traditions. It's incredible to see interest in Maori history, not many people know it, except for "British come in etc" when there is more to it than that, there is so much history there. The history of this country is just one tragedy and misunderstanding after another. Might I add your pronunciation of Maori words was pretty good, better than most non-Maori speaking CZcamsrs, a few mistakes but you did your best.
happy columbus day
Ka pai ehoa
So, when are you going to do the decent thing, and adopt the standard issue British army mustache? You're not on a U-boat, you know.
Squire hi squire
I say someone should start a crowd fund to have Lindybeige shave and grow a proper handlebar
Squire How come im not surprised to see you here
Now the Royal Navy isn't so found of the face caterpillar by itself, full beard or no hair at all.
Found someone more british than you Squire ?
The last time I was this early, the British still had an aircraft carrier with planes on it.
Bismarck - Military Aviation History you arent wrong but why remind us
*sips tea for comfort*
Last time I was this early German spent a decade trying to build an aircraft carrier only to give up and let the Soviets use it for target practice.
I AM ALIVE !!!!! You are an idiot. The UK when it was the head of empire was extremely multicultural.
Come on, be fair. It's still undergoing sea trials.
They performed the seismic haka, the shockwave then preceded to atomize every single British solider.
I'm in Hawaii and when you said it is actually called "Gate Pā", I was like Ohhhhhhh. Pā, of course, means "wall" throughout Polynesia.
While it's true that pa is a colloquialism for wall in Samoa it's much more commonly referred to as a puipui
Pa is pretty much just a plot of land that has been bordered off in Maori
For Māori it means fort
@Ujuani Abelsen That's very interesting.
Yes in Tongan we say 'A which means wall like 'a maka "rock wall"
As a new Zealand Maori I prefer Savage.
Having met Maori's I can confirm you lot are pretty fucking savage. Never heard banter like it.
It does sound pretty badass, befitting of Maori Badasses xD
@Caligvla Caesar Incorrect. Maori were not outright cannibals, they only ate their enemies not for food but for respect as Maori thought that it would be a waste for a warrior to be eaten by worms. Maori lived in hilltop fortresses with Greenstone weaponry. Their written language were their carvings. While no domesticated animals they were advanced aquaculturalists and aviculturalists and they did indeed have cities, two infact being Kaiapoi and another I've forgetting the name of. The wheel doesn't justify savagery, the Inca and Aztecs didn't have the wheel yet they did pretty well for themselves. As for philosophy, well I'm not going to argue that cause it's quite apparent that they did posses that.
So everything you said is just a misinformed, petty and ignorant comment. You need to research more.
LaughableSynonyms Precisely, for a relatively small set of islands in the corner of our conceptual globe, they did quite well for themselves. The main reason that continental cultures developed far faster was due to an abundance of varying people’s and cultures within trading/contact distance.
@@Condobius Not to mention...
...METAL.
so I'm a Maori boy living in New Zealand and this is really accurate and its good that someone actually uses accurate facts to show people that we arnt that boring hahahaha
People very well might think kiwis as a whole or boring, but I've never heard anything of the sort about the Maori lol
Yo I saw the all blacks do a haka in person. It gave me shivers and sweats. I wasn’t even playing them
As a rugby player (former, now i m too old) from Belgium I mvery familiar with the All Blacks and the Haka ... I also love the NZ band Alien alien weaponry (I recognized the language as soon as they they first appeared in my CZcams recommended playlist) ... I just know the Moari are not boring ...
You're the only Maori who's boring
I am a direct descendant of rehara wakatairoa who fought at gate pa and was seen yelling out British commands in a British accent it's said that he made 15 British soldiers come into a area were him and other Maori were waiting in ambush when they got close enough they got mowed down..his deeds are rembered in songs today
Ushh.
Can you make a video where you sing it, possibly with English subtitles?
proud heritage
That's not cricket old boy...
You're proud of that?
the double barrel shotgun finally gets its moment of glory
lets not forget its other moment of glory when newton knight started a militia regiment with a few double barrels against the confederacy.
As a New Zealander I thank you for covering a very much not covered much at all
Cody Dockerty what do you say Tauranga!?
Hello, fellow countryman
Good morning lads
Reporting in
I grew up near Gate Pa.
I hope he covers more of the land war stuff in future.
*I wonder if back in those days you could fuck with enemy artillerymen by building things to weird scales (e.g. 3-foot-high dummies) so they'd miscalculate distances.*
That sounds difficult to pull off but also hilarious.
Now I want to see a Lloyd video about that...
leadfoot9x Ye Olde Trolls
You are fantastic, a sort of historical Kenny Everett! I was born in Tauranga, live in Hamilton, and am moving to the UK next year. The first paper I took at university was the New Zealand Wars, and as part of our assessment, General Sir Duncan Cameron (portrayed by our lecturer, complete with Highland accent) was put on a mock trial for misconduct in the Battle of Gate Pa. The class was divided into two - prosecution and defense, with 'lawyers' elected from each group. This all took place at the Tauranga Courthouse! He was found Not Guilty, by the way :-). Happily subscribed!
God I remember Kenny everet 😂
Good video! My uncle is generally considered the main authority on Gate Pa, I work with him as a cultural consultant to Tauranga City council. I'll be sure to show him this video, if he hasn't already seen it, I'm sure he would be quite happy to see that this rather significant part of New Zealand history is being told around the world in such a concise manner. :)
Whose your uncle ehoa , you cultural consultants are a waste of money and hinder the progress of the rest of us . Ive 'worked' with ngati whatua up in auckland and appalled with the bs and corruption hat goes on up here under the fake authority of cultural mana whenua. aka cultural arrogance just creating a lucritive money train for tribal elites. pukana.
Lloyd! If you are being held hostage by French agents forcing you to cover British military failure all of a sudden, blink twice with your left eye in the next video to signal for help!!!!
Hogh hogh hoghh! beije du lindee iz not a hostaage! sacre bleu!
Carbon 12 😂😂😂😂
gotta throw a dog a bone once in a while, takes the sting out of getting conquered.
Lindy, as a Kiwi, thank you very much for covering this sadly little known kind of history! Not enough kiwis know about the New Zealand Land Wars but they should for the military strategy and technology shown is amazing. Point of note: The wars from 1807 to 1842 are the Musket Wars (inter tribal) and the later wars from 1845 to 1872 are the NZ Land Wars (british and tribal allies vs māori)
Pronunciation: Toe--wron-nga. The first two a's become long sounds closer to o.
I live in Waiuku and not that far from where I live is the site of a battle from the musket wars.
Fully agree - even in NZ this part of history tends to gets brushed over. I thought the same thing about Lindy's pronunciation of Tauranga, but having looked at the Wiki for this page, the old diagrams and notes about this battle refer to "TeRanga" not Tauranga. I think that was just what pakeha used to call Tauranga, so i guess Lindy has simply used an older book referring to this battle.
Also the g is silent
the battle of Gate Pa isnt that looked over, every year theres a sizable memorial in tga.
Technically it isn't. The G in "nga" helps shape the sound differently than if it were actually a silent letter.
I love the energy that you exude while delivering these little lectures. You have a knack for making these subjects extremely interesting
"Another way to balance a wargame involving british troops is to have the enemy attack at teatime on a bank holiday weekend."
O-HO
A CHEEKY STING
Clearly you have studied your history of the Roman invasion of Britian based on the writings of the contemporary gallic druid from a small village of indomitable gauls.
FISH AND CHIPS
Celtic Revival / Adfywiad Celtaidd
Yeah let’s not forget the Scots:welsh/Irish
That fought in the British army
While eating Victoria sponge. . . .
"Add the sound effect, thank you" he says to his editor, which is himself.
Jontman42 lol weirdo talking to himself
Jontman42 he had a shoving match with himself once.
"... they just didn't have the mustaches."
I'm laughing so hard I might die... XD
That's why i don't shave. People are so ignorant.
this is where the video got my thumbs up
The passion this man has for history makes it a lot more fun to watch. I really enjoy this channel, i thought I knew quite a bit about history. This teaches me about things I have never heard of. Keep up the fantastic work my friend.
I am so glad I came across your channel. I love history and you do a fantastic job of telling a story. From across the pond in New York I thank you.
"Socking great big bits of iron-mongery and explosiveness"
When even Lindybeige out Lindybeiges himself
"He wears an acceptable amount of beige." Lol
Lol... At least HE WEARS IT WELL!!! 😂😂😂
Kia Ora from Aotearoa, I am a Māori, just popping in to see an international interpretation of what happened here to our ancestors. Thank you! I easpecially appreciate the humor. Ngā mihi!
I wish my teachers had been like this in school. this man is very well spoken, and manages to keep everything exciting. even the most mundane details....
10 minutes in: how did the British mess this up?
Later: ... so, like that. I am impressed
More like 15 minutes in.
Obviously they didn't have enough mana.
They had every advantage and still lost.
They got distracted with the advertisement.
Sounds more like the Maori won through their valour and tactics. There is no obvious mistake made during the assault by the British.
You have been my favorite youtuber for as long as I can remember and videos like this is an exemplary example as to why, Fantastic job! I may add that I am British Maori, I was born and raised in Berkshire but my fathers side of the family comes from the Ngti Awa tribe in Whakatane which is beside Tauranga, along the coast. When ever we go back home there is always talk of this battle even today and you're video is fantastic at representing both British and Maori people in an honorable objective manor!
So glad to have pleased you! I have never been there, but one day...
...you've never been to Berkshire?....shame on you Mr Beige!
British Maori's rule lol. Love from NZ!
Please do - we have both Lindy hoppers AND reenactors!.... and all that other stuff too
Pa (no 'h' ) is the correct spelling for a fortified Maori village.
Great video. So much of our history here in NZ is being re-written in the all-to-familiar "goodies vs baddies" narrative that is, to put it as kindly as I can, utter horseshit. The various "Maori Wars" period is complex and fascinating and there were a lot more than two "sides" involved. Nor were they all "rebellions". Over 500 chiefs signed the Treaty of Waitangi (1840) that gave full British citizenship to all Maori, ostensibly making everyone "equal" at least in the eyes of the law. Much, or at least some, of the unrest was not aimed at overthrowing British rule as much as it was anger that the Treaty was not being honoured properly. Certainly some of it was the inevitable result of telling a tribal, warrior class, "You can't fight anymore but don't worry, you can go to the Police if something crops up" and thinking that would work.
Thanks for this. I hope our history is being accurately preserved somewhere, even if it isn't here, where it belongs.
PS: "Tauranga" is pronounced TOW (like 'how' or 'cow') RONG (like 'song') A.
Tow - rong - a
Cheers.
I don't know how I found this channel, but 2 videos in and I'm hooked. I could, and indeed have, listen for hours.
Thanks for doing this video Lindy! Hori Ngatai (who fought in this battle and is known for reciting this story) was my great great great grandfather direct line from eldest son to eldest son. His father was also one of the members who signed the Waitangi Treaty that finally unified New Zealand. I've always liked the story of Gate Pah, my ancestors were bad ass apparently! Don't stress about the PC police... some people have poles in their backsides.
at least spell Pa correctly...ffs
another bounty bar maori...brown on the outside , white on the inside :)
Books of the time wrote it as "Pah" and the Maori of the time didn't have a written language, not sure what your problem is
My problem it's spelt incorrectly and there's is no need to remain ignorant in 2018. the book he quoted was printed between 1900-1910. Maori have been exposed to the written word due to the introduction of the bible and the missionaries during the early 1800s. Note: Literacy, in particular, became extremely popular among Māori. By 1842 most Māori aged between 10 and 30 could read and write their own language, a higher literacy rate than in the non-Māori population. You drip of the same ignorance and disrespect that lost the british this battle :) teara.govt.nz/en/maori-pakeha-relations/page-2
mb1968nz so how do you think Pa was spelt, by Maori themselves, in 1842? Because I’ve also seen it written as “Pah”. I use the usual Pa spelling myself - but my point is both are “correct” if you’re trying to be picky. People at that time both British and Maori were just making up the spelling as they went, because Maori didn’t have their own writing previously. I don’t think use of the older spellings necessarily makes somebody ignorant
Well, the Brittish had red shirts, and we all know that red shirts die first
How many times has Scotty, Uhura, or Janice died for wearing a red shirt?
They're main characters. The red shirts thing is kinda like in medieval if you're wearing helmets and are not a main character, you're the first one to die.
Christopher Noel
That just means they're even more badass.
Actually, when they attacked, they had changed into their mostly blue kit.
You remind me of one of my old history teachers - so much enthusiasm in the material.. it really is a joy to watch..
Really love the channel, the content, delivery, all wonderful. Thanks so much.
The maori losing 50 to the british 100 is better put into perspective when we remember that the maori people never had a population over a million in all of world history.
At the time of the battle they probably had less people in their... nation? ethnicity? than was the population of some british towns.
giveussomevodka given their pop was around 80000 at max at that time and how 50 years before they were basically in the Stone Age they did very well.
Weren’t there Maoris that also fought for the brits...
Yep the Mairis hate each other's tribes with a passion, They even exterminated the Morioris.
The Boyd massacre is pretty messed up.
When the british first got to NZ there where around 90,000 spread across Aotearoa (New Zealand) in total
Next time on The Great Courses Plus: how industrial moustache technology lead to British Hegemony in the 19th century
eric3844 Absolutely. I think we should be told.
😂
I was born and raised in Tauranga. They hold a memorial service every year for the battle of gate pā. Would be interested in hearing about the battle/“massacre” that happened 7 weeks later near Pyes Pā
Kia ora, there is a 3 part video with more information on the battle and history of Tauranga. Tauranga Moana Elders tell the history of Mauao, part 1 by Kihi Ngatai and part 2 and 3 by my Koro Hauata Paama.
When's the next one?
"Socking great big bits of ironmongery and explosiveness." This is my first Lindybeige video. After I heard this, I was sold.
Also, Duncan Cameron bears a startling resemblance to Duane Allman.
Want to talk about asymmetrical, just cover the terrible defeat of the Australian Army in the great Emu War. Though those wounds are long past and the Emus now help fight the Drop Bear menace!
My grandfather was a veteran of that terrible war, he didn't like to talk about it much but anytime he had a bit much xmas egg nog he would open up just a little.He's ok now but when his feather doona rips it all comes flooding back and when one of soft grey bastards struts arrogantly across the road in front of the car his eyes glaze over and his foot presses a bit harder on the accelerator
Tbh it's genuinely awful and sad the fact they killed so many Emus and harmed them. They are living beings that feel and think like any other.
TheTaterTotP80 And they taste pretty good. What a waste of emu meat that was, I don’t think a single Australian soldier ate emu flesh during the entire war, even though they had like 900 emu corpses to work with. Albeit these corpses were full of bullets.
Wait, were the emus a code name for the army or were they actual animals? I'm very confused now
Trance Kowhai Nope, these are just emus in the outback.
Many thanks for not spoiling the scholar's cradle outcome. Takes the excitement right out of it for me when I know what happens.
Honestly, whatever the Great Courses Plus are paying you, it isn't enough.
BrendanBlake42
They are sponsoring his beige shirt addiction.
This guy is so interesting to listen to that I didn't even skipped the ad.
Incredible courage and staunch- heartedness is not just a British attribute and actions like Rorke's Drift were fought by many other soldiers/ warriors of other nations and people - as Lindy once again shows us in his brilliant style. Such lesser known actions deserve to be brought out of dusty, seldom read history books to show people that bravery is a human characteristic and not only bestowed upon a few specific nations. For example, I have just read that during the Peninsular War a company sized unit of French soldiers (about 150 men) held off an attack by a force Spanish Guerillas numbering thousands for a whole day and night, an event I for one had never heard of before.
Storming out to get myself a Lindybeige's knitted jumper.
Uncle Traveling Matt you may get one for Christmas 😂
Don't forget the beige, round collar shirt! He has a video on how to make that on his channel
He should have a merchandise store
Surprised Maori reacts only.
Just steal one out of Bill Cosby's closet like Lindy does :-D
Lloyd you're one of the few youtubers who can hold my attention for half an hour. Great video!
That. Is. Wonderful.
Full credit to the Maori. That is the kind of brilliant yet simple genius that one can only think of if you are trying to bridge such a tech gap. Well played
Lindy makes the best ads. Let it be known. This one had me laughing at multiple points. And I watched the whole thing which is much longer than it needs to be (I think most companies just require a minute) but Lindy's are so animated and personal. Always a treat
is it clear, that the pole with the flag was bad luck? The Maori clearly where quite familiar with how artillary works.
Perhaps, they put it there on purpuse.
They certainly did. What did the Maori need a flag pole for? And if they really wanted a flag, why was it far behind the actual fortification? That was no accident or luck. They gave the artillery something that looked so incredible useful that nobody gave its intent a second thought.
I have never come across any evidence that it was deliberate, but it isn't impossible. The commander of the British would still have been unlucky that the CO of his artillery used the flag as an aiming point.
The way you told the story, I assumed that to has been standard procedure. If so, that would make it an angle of manipulation. If it was on purpose, that would make the Maori plan even more badass.
When I was at uni it was suggested that as the defenders were familiar with the British practice of placing their flag pole toward the centre of their encampments and had on occasion adopted this custom themselves, for example at Ohaeawai Pa, that the positioning was most likely a deliberate attempt at misdirection.
coool
"... because the Zulu's, fabulous warriors that they were, just didn't have the mustaches." 4:00
Joshua Stoczko or the rifles
Joshua Stoczko your South African ?
racist
racist boo. they actually used alot of tactics to get to their enemies, they also adopted the rifles and they did actually dig trenches, and they established a way of communication between the chieftains and the soldiers. they also used the bull strategy with the head, the horns and the loin very well, also much better with the short knives or spears.
@@ori6990 ITS A JOKE GET OVER IT
Nicely made, sir. I had not heard of this particular action. I must say that the closing placard would likely be very true, but I'd not know.
Merry Christmas, Happy Boxer Day and Happy New Year to you and yours!
Great lecture! And on a topic I knew nothing about. I love the humor too, it does a lot to keep my mind from drifting.
We're lucky Hitler's mustache was so short.
And everybody is lucky Stalin didn't grow his out any further.
What a confusing profile image :L
I think everyone had the misfortune of him growing it out as far as he did.
As a Zulu would you rather have a mustache or a big dick?
Who wants a mustache ride?!
That was great. Thank you Lindybeige. I really enjoy your videos. Please keep making more!
Never stop giving the details, love it.
Lindy has the best military history channel on CZcams in my opinion. Although I would watch a 45 minute long video of nothing but lindy's 3 minute ads patched together as a single video hes such a good storyteller
"They just didn't have the moustaches" Lindybeige Nov 2017
Also google spellchecker, how dare you try to correct with American English on this channel :P
NorfolkTears What did Google do?
As far as I know it's the browser doing the spellchecking, not CZcams. But perhaps your browser is from Google as well? Don't you have an option to add another language? I just (finally!) managed to add "English (British)" to Firefox. The option they used to have just never worked.
Gillsing It was probably their phone keyboard
If I had to choose between fighting a Maori or a Gurkha, with my 14 years martial arts experience, at least a passing familiarity with most weapons, both modern and antiquated, and a fair understanding and respect of their cultures; I think I'd choose to wander off into the woods until I found a bear with cubs and fight her instead. Much better odds.
LOL! ... yep
Playing with toy lightsabers doesn't count though.
Definitely. Throw in a kampilan or barong-wielding Moro warrior in there as well.
WW2 German #1: Well, der Tommies are here
WW2 German #2: Eh, we can handle them
WW2 German #1: They have Scots, Maori, and Gurkhas.
WW2 German #2: (cries)
hahahaha best comment
Kia ora bro,this description of the Maori warriors is Tu meke, they were and still are fierce warriors, keep up the good work bro!!!
That was the greatest plug for The Great Courses Plus.
How is it that I have despised school (especially subjects like history that seemed to be extraordinarily boring) for my entire life yet I’m willing to sit here and learn about something basically useless from some random dude on the internet for 30 minutes?
Public education is more about teaching the masses than learning specifics. History classes here were all about the Australian gold rush, the explorers, etc., nothing about the Hundred Years war, or how the Mongols learned the hard way that they were fucked the minute they stepped into the kingdoms of Java.
Because it is interesting knowledge, presented in an engaging style?
and documentaries, I never wanted to watch them when I was younger, but they are just about my favorite thing to watch now.
Uriah Siner young people tend to want to make their own mistakes. And that's how it should be.
+Uriah Siner Easy, Lloyd is an excellent educator.
A diagram would have been good, but thumbs up for the narration.
I love me some maps.
you can go on google ive seen some good ones
czcams.com/video/zyeCbn8u0og/video.html Here is a video showing the battle with maps.
That's better, thanks.
the wikipedia map en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tauranga_Campaign#/media/File:Plan_of_the_attack_on_gate_pa.jpg
As much as I like your new content I've always loved your videos like this, would be nice to see more in the future!
LB is so easy to follow, he has a really smooth way about him. Very cool synopsis and well condensed conclusions about the battle, its disparities, and similarities of forces. So many people following, and of course the particular topics LB chooses, make me feel so much less alienated and odd. I am in to what he posts about, always informative. LB rocks, and this vid about maori was particularly cool.
My ancestors were involved in this battle against the British.They were also involved in another battle where the British were withdrawing for lack of ammunition.The chief sent a warrior over to see if they wanted to borrow some ammo as the fight was just getting good !
Are the Maori real life Orcs? Because both have so many similarities in culture and view of the world that I would not be surprised the Maori inspired the creation of the Orcs.
@@Jamhael1 Orcs are from Angle and Saxon pre-Christian mythology, so perhaps not. Although, every fantasy franchise has a slightly different spin on Orcs, so maybe you can find one in particular that's as close to your idea as you like.
@@Jamhael1Maoris are all mixed now, it's Pacific Islanders taking the role of Orc nowxD and West Africans
Within one generation New Zealand formed a special force of their own and have been trouncing the British (73% of the time), and the rest of the world, ever since. The All Blacks.
Then they met the French---
might want to watch the last two world cups if you think the French are any difficulty
ginganutjob : I didn't say anything about the French winning - they are the greatest whiners tho-
pretty good actually. more people play rugby in britain too, and aus and france and the us and japan and south africa. hows briain doing at soccer lately?
so u r saying nz does really well in a sport that some people in nz care about (rugby). our olympic and commonwealth record in cycling and rowing is very good. our mens basket ball came 4th in the olympics not too long ago and our team has beaten the aussies in their competition more than once.
cricket, well weve given the worlds best a surprise more than a few times. so nz does well in its 'mainstream' sport and pretty good at other sports (relative to our population) that no one in nz really cares about.
we may have failed to qualify in soccer world cups but look at the record of defeats at our last showing. no one plays it, no one cares, its like watching paint dry. a sport for people who cant think up a decent game.
i'll think youll find england, sa, france, usa, japan all have more registered first grade players than nz in rugby.
u also failed to mention sailing, wind surfing, womens shot put, womens soccer, kayak. and on the motorsport front watch this space. i can think of many more successes but if u look at the olympic medal count for nz relative to its population it will speak for itself, especially when u realise most of our sports people arnt even fully professional.
Hey I enjoy your “modern” history stuff too! You just do a really good job narrating and hitting all the important points
I love your sense of humor. really enjoying your videos sir! thank you!
Magnificent mustaches, nice red uniforms and an almost fanatical devotion to Queen and Country.
SlideRulePirate no where near as good as blind fanatical American patriotism
The joke.
Tiger Claw252's head.
And ruthless efficiency! Our four great attributes are... among our attributes are such diverse elements as surprise, fear, nice red uniforms...
YOU DIMWIT
YOU FORGOT THE MUSTACHES, THE BLOODY MUSTACHES!
Tiger Claw252 If it wasn't for the French (and the two other countries that Britain was fighting at the time in addition to trying to suppress the rebellion). The revolutionaries could not and would not have succeeded, the British after all won nearly every battle in that theater. That was until requirements for reinforcing other theaters of war lend to the situation becoming untenable in the Americas. Learn some history before you go around making a fool out of yourself. 'American patriotism' ha more like the opportunism of other countries.
Maor videos like these please.
I'll show myself out.
good
I Zea what you did there.
Tom Stafford we could diffntly do wth more NZ war videos but done in a more u tube graphic way
GRIFFIN PAYNE twas a joke mate
Tom Stafford yea I did realise that ☺ all good ,some people take u tube videos far to seriously .have u read some of the comments below. In a different some of these guys would be slapping each wth gloves before pulling pistols on each other 😈
absolutely legendary story.
go on then, have another go
Really interesting stuff! Also your “mad professor” haircut somehow works with these presentations 😂
listening to you say tauraunga, i could feel the mustache. highly amused.
your articulation is amazing.... glad I found your site
Bear Nicholas someone not giving him flak for once 😂
Having the city of Hamilton named after you is not really a compliment.
ikr
It could be worse we named a fort after General Custer here in the US. Custer lost the battle of Little Big Horn against the Native Americans. He ignored his scout reports and ran into a force double his size and still tried to fight them. It did not end well for him or his men.
@@johnsturm9344 He means Hamiltons a shit hole here in New Zealand. Has the highest STI rate of any town to give you an idea.
@@mrgray3474 i aint been to hamilton but i always thought porirua was bad
Man thats hilarious I live in scotland and the hamilton here is a shitehole as well
And thus was the template set for modern rugby.
Loved this video. Superb stuff.
Yes, the British brought the organisation and the Maori brought the flair. Good analogy bro.
The signoff joke made me smile because there's a comic book titled Asterix in Britain in which Julius Cesar does just that, attacking the Brits at tea time and during the weekends.
Francois, I suspect Lindybeige is a big Asterix fan 🤔 and Terry Pratchett and Monty Python🤔 Terry Thomas… a whole bunch of others lol 😂
I wasn't going to do that Great Courses trial, but once you mentioned that the professor did INDEED wear an acceptable amount of beige, I jumped on that opportunity!
I love your channel and the way you speak. Just dropping this in here. :)
The zig zagging is called the sap ... that’s why the Royal Engineers are called Sappers
Nice little fact, cheers.
And the Maoris and Polynesians were used to dig them during WW1,some of my people never returned from that war,whole family lines were wiped out.
@@Andy_M986 Yeah. We lost entire families as well. Millions eventually.
Chance for a Battle of Ohaewai video? Similar concept as Gate Pa but the walls repelled artillery fire, and the it was the first battle between Native and Colonial forces and the first defeat the British suffered in NEw Zealand.
Future battles of the Flashstaff War were also very unique playing to the Asymmetrical style battle you mentioned, where an attacking British force with a Native contingent set up camp to attack a Nga Puhi leader Hone Heke, who set up base camp purposely within range for an attack by cannon fire, but nearby was his uncle, Kawiti who led troops towards the rear of the British camp.
When Kawiti attacked Heke fled, the assumption being that Heke was leaving the battlefield so the Brtitish troops turned their full attention to Kawiti. The native contingent, who were also a Nga Puhi clan, suggested against that but were not given attention to their warnings, so they walked away. Kawiti's forces took fire and then fled while Heke returned to his fortifications and started shooting again while the British were turned around.
Heke and KAwiti kept this up the entire day, rotating around the British camp, surrounding them. The British couldn't split their forces to attack both, despite being a much larger force they couldn't risk going into trees, up hill or down hill into enemy trenches that were filled with melee warriors waiting. Splitting up would mean being lured into a trap.
The only thing they could do was retreat. They didn't ahve enough guns, munitions, or cannons to fight and move around every half hour.
Pā - Spelt this way because, all Māori words end with a vowel.
Yes. 'Pah' is just a European-y way of spelling a Māori word. Pā is proper
Amazing that both languages have exactly the same alphabet!
@@jaceacekalgoorlie I can't say for sure, since Samoa and Aotearoa have their differences, but in the precolonial Samoa (and as I suspect, Aotearoa/New Zealand) language was largely oral with no phonetic written form. Histories were non-orally kept through logologo and tatau but post colonization they developed a Latin written form. That's why we use Latin script, because our traditional forms of writing were deemed as backwards and unlearned, and reduced to niche artwork instead of the language of a people.
@@jaceacekalgoorlie they dont
@@vegasspaceprogram6623 They were clearly joking.
Fascinating. Great video.
I really enjoy listening to this guy. Regardless of the topic. I've learnt a lot listening to his stories in the last day or two. More please! Don't care what it's about as long as this chap is the one narrating.
For the first time, skint as i may be I am actually considering this patreon thingimy... More of this dude and this sort of thing!