Off Road 4x4 Recovery Board Comparison | Aren't They All Just Cheap Plastic?

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 27. 08. 2024

Komentáře • 73

  • @Iamtheoverlander
    @Iamtheoverlander Před 2 lety +31

    So I own the maxtrax extremes with the aluminum teeth and this past winter in the cold during a snow recovery, one of those boards shattered into multiple pieces.
    At $250 a board I was a bit tender about it. So I took the board back to maxtrax USA in Prescott Arizona and with no questions asked they gave me a new board.
    I don’t think anybody knows the maxtrax come with a lifetime warranty.

    • @IndependenceOverland
      @IndependenceOverland  Před 2 lety +5

      Yup, the warranty is a big deal and makes the extra cost even more worth it. Not sure they would warranty mine since I'm abusing them intentionally, but who knows. I'm undecided on the Extremes for the next truck build. I want to get 2 sets, and 2 sets of the Extreme are near the cost of a winch.

  • @remoterivermanaustralia
    @remoterivermanaustralia Před 6 měsíci +4

    Here in Australia, everyone who can afford it (and understands value for money) buys MaxTrax. Ronny Dahl has done a comprehensive comparison video between MaxTrax and the usual competitors, and the results are conclusive - buy the best, forget the rest. Cheap recovery boards are a false economy.

    • @IndependenceOverland
      @IndependenceOverland  Před 6 měsíci

      I am with you 100% on that. Cheap stuff fails at the time you need it most. I think the only exception is a winch, since basically all of them are Chinese at this point.

  • @usmc6157
    @usmc6157 Před 11 měsíci +1

    Stumbled across your vid here looking for alternative traction boards to MaxTrax. Damn good vid and informative, no sugarcoating, no bullshit and no crazy ass, punishing music to have to put up with. Subbed and keep up the good work. 10/10

  • @offroadaddiction2073
    @offroadaddiction2073 Před 2 lety +4

    If you are on a budget and don’t go off road to extreme places cheap ones we’ll do the job for the just in case scenario. But if you like the extreme off roading Maxtrax is the way to go for any situation and durability. Great review.

    • @IndependenceOverland
      @IndependenceOverland  Před 2 lety +1

      Thanks man! Yeah assuming they survive my winter testing, we will use them a bit in Baja here in a few months. Traveling solo a lot, I prefer having the highest quality, but having a group of people like we will in Baja it will be nice to have boards to hand off to each truck so everyone has some form of self recovery.

    • @offroadaddiction2073
      @offroadaddiction2073 Před 2 lety +1

      @@IndependenceOverland My wife and I do a lot off road on either our SxS Can am X3, ATV’s or an 07 FJ Cruiser we use to explore and overland, currently doing upgrades to it little by little, a lot ideas for our FJ Cruiser I am getting ‘em from your channel.
      Hopefully in the future we have the pleasure to meet you in person and may be join your group on an adventure.
      Have fun in Baja and looking forward for those videos.

    • @IndependenceOverland
      @IndependenceOverland  Před 2 lety

      @@offroadaddiction2073 likewise man! You never know who you might run into on the trail or at one of the Expos. I appreciate the support! I look forward to going on an adventure at some point!

  • @Bblindsey3572
    @Bblindsey3572 Před 4 měsíci

    I recently came across your channel. Thanks for putting in the time to make this video!

  • @madcratebuilder
    @madcratebuilder Před 2 lety +4

    Great review. I picked up 2 sets of X-Bull tracks on sale for $60 ea. I've used them in sand and snow, no plans on using as a bridge. Not spinning the tires on the board is key. If these wear out I'll replace with Max Tracs.

    • @IndependenceOverland
      @IndependenceOverland  Před 2 lety

      Yeah, spinning is a huge no-no with all the brands. Thanks for watching, Steven.

    • @tykenneth1
      @tykenneth1 Před 2 lety +1

      I stacked the x-Bull boards on top of each other to get back over a downed tree. Worked great.

    • @IndependenceOverland
      @IndependenceOverland  Před 2 lety

      @@tykenneth1 Glad to hear it. When you need them to work, they better do their job.

    • @skiboot1
      @skiboot1 Před 8 měsíci

      Have they worn out yet?

    • @madcratebuilder
      @madcratebuilder Před 8 měsíci

      @@skiboot1 Not yet, I have broken a few studs off. May try the bolt head mod.

  • @crashjump1849
    @crashjump1849 Před rokem +1

    Wow that was a real cliffhanger watching you take the different traction board through the pace. I can see why people pay so much more for the max tracks. Good video 👍

    • @IndependenceOverland
      @IndependenceOverland  Před rokem

      Thank you! Yeah, Maxtrax hard much more expensive but will worth the cost! Thanks for watching!

  • @jabeuerlein86
    @jabeuerlein86 Před 2 lety +1

    Thought I was watching Holes there for a min. Great vidya ol chap!

    • @IndependenceOverland
      @IndependenceOverland  Před 2 lety +1

      Haha thanks for checking it out bud! Looking forward to getting stuck in some beach sand before too long!

  • @livingworkingoutsidebox
    @livingworkingoutsidebox Před 2 lety +3

    Great job with your review and going that extra mile in creating real world scenarios. Questions; would a recovery line buried in the sand be a better option? A/b winch or tire wrap line? Great comment about plastic and flexing. You sir are a bridging mad man 🤯💥💯👍💪🤙

    • @IndependenceOverland
      @IndependenceOverland  Před 2 lety +1

      Be a better option for recovery vs the traction boards? If that's what you mean, then no. Traction boards are so easy to throw down and use that its much better than dealing with a winch by far. I would say 95% of the time traction boards will do the trick. If I misunderstand your question, please clarify. I appreciate you watching!

    • @livingworkingoutsidebox
      @livingworkingoutsidebox Před 2 lety

      @@IndependenceOverland I have seen traction boards do the trick quickly and easily. Winches are what they are . My main question was around those new types of recovery Ropes and netting. There is one that looks like a slingshot band which is buried in the sand then used to pull the rig out. At the level of needing to burry a tire in the sand. I've seen another that wraps around the tire like a snow chain but is a poloy nylon rope material that once wraps around the dire the winding by tire spin pulls it right out.
      Sorry for my layman's explanation. Our Expedition camper is in design phase and we are around 15k lbs Dry weight so looking at options that would compliment or surpass recovery boards.

  • @skindude9251
    @skindude9251 Před 7 měsíci

    Great video and comparison. I’m looking for boards for my two wheel drive Campervan as we are off to Morocco. I reckon the cheaper versions will be ok for sand but maybe I will drill holes in the boards and add metal bolts/nuts/lugs in a few strategic positions to add traction and avoid melting. Saw this done by another channel and it seemed to work well.

  • @michaelmatchee
    @michaelmatchee Před 2 lety +4

    Drill a bunch of holes thro plastics. No more suction well less for sure. Straps also help, old ratchet straps cut to length work good n cheap. Nice vids

    • @IndependenceOverland
      @IndependenceOverland  Před 2 lety

      Thanks Michael. Yeah straps can get you out in a pinch. I would assume drilling holes would effect the integrity of the plastics on the boards, assuming they were designed in a proper way that it was all designed for strength. I will be posting a video soon of these same boards being used in the snow, and some cracked immediately.

    • @michaelmatchee
      @michaelmatchee Před 2 lety

      @@IndependenceOverland drill holes on the earth flat side even a dozen should unstuck them n should not affect strength. Lots of items made have holes or cut outs n they remain their strength. But it's only my 2 cents haha n not my boards. There is another channel that tested a few diff boards . Good to see more reviews n tests. Happy trails and safe travels everyone.

  • @gwilli1754
    @gwilli1754 Před 6 měsíci

    Anyone thought about old tires? Taking the round side walls off and then cutting the metal circle into a straight line. Then put the circle below the line and see if can get out. It may work, or not, but they would not shatter

    • @IndependenceOverland
      @IndependenceOverland  Před 6 měsíci

      I suppose that would work fairly well, but if a tire already isnt hooking, I think having a rigid board helps a lot.

  • @vincenzodemarco7983
    @vincenzodemarco7983 Před 2 lety +1

    Great Review. Good Show. I'm now just a bit confused as Nothing Seems to work 100% as we would wish. Well actually I have a slight issue with the price of the MaxTrac but maybe should Shut Up as they have such a solid warranty. THX👍

  • @VeryCoolJeep
    @VeryCoolJeep Před 2 lety +1

    I got an FJ for my wife and going to get her Alu Cab tent next week :) cant wait

    • @IndependenceOverland
      @IndependenceOverland  Před 2 lety

      You are going to LOVE the Alucab. I seriously like it more than my camper. The ease of use makes it the #1 tent in my opinion.

    • @VeryCoolJeep
      @VeryCoolJeep Před 2 lety +2

      @@IndependenceOverland I have Bush Company tent on my Jeep and i Love it.

    • @IndependenceOverland
      @IndependenceOverland  Před 2 lety

      @@VeryCoolJeep those look pretty sweet as well. I’ve only seen one up close and person once. They look pretty well built!

  • @jamesmcgraw4584
    @jamesmcgraw4584 Před rokem

    I just got some good value from this. Thanks!

  • @cic-400
    @cic-400 Před 10 měsíci

    Thank you for this video... this is awesome!

  • @GrandPapi95
    @GrandPapi95 Před 2 lety +2

    Thanks for sharing

  • @johnarcher9480
    @johnarcher9480 Před rokem

    The “stress fractures”, where they discolor, can be quickly repaired in a few seconds with a heat gun.
    Once torn, then no, but discoloring is not a big deal.

    • @IndependenceOverland
      @IndependenceOverland  Před rokem +2

      Perhaps visually but I’m not sure if a heat gun would melt the plastic back together totally. Might be worth an experiment on my part.

  • @marcusj4467
    @marcusj4467 Před 2 lety +1

    Great review, be great to see you test Exitrax Ultimates or there other two models. And I assume you like Maxtrax over Actiontrax?

    • @IndependenceOverland
      @IndependenceOverland  Před 2 lety

      If I get the chance I’ll test them all out.
      I’ve never used Actiontrax yet. Maybe one of these days I can get my hands on some and I will post up my results.

  • @DJTheGX
    @DJTheGX Před 2 lety +2

    Thank you 😊

  • @Espinal_424
    @Espinal_424 Před rokem

    I got the cheap amazon orange one with the hi jack center and i've gotten a lot of u-haul box trucks including 26' ones out of mud here in FL

  • @trevorschroeder6745
    @trevorschroeder6745 Před 2 lety

    Can’t wait for other vid I have cheap xbull and was like pink instead of orange so got arb treads and love thos

    • @IndependenceOverland
      @IndependenceOverland  Před 2 lety

      Yeah my color grading on this video makes them look orange, but they are pinkish looking in person.

  • @jamestaylor9258
    @jamestaylor9258 Před rokem +1

    Time on each board?

    • @IndependenceOverland
      @IndependenceOverland  Před rokem

      You mean how fast I got unstuck? I didn’t go that far but a good idea for next time.

  • @ongoingcoyote5601
    @ongoingcoyote5601 Před 11 měsíci

    When I bought my gladiator about a month ago I ask if they could give me a discount for shit in the dealer part store and I got them to give me maxtrax and a hilift for 250

  • @proyoutuber3406
    @proyoutuber3406 Před rokem

    Same model of FIERYRED costs 20$ in my country. So I will just buy 4 of them?😂 still does the job and cheap.

  • @robeveridge8329
    @robeveridge8329 Před rokem

    I feel like you coulda just drove out of all of those after you dug it out.

  • @patrickdoyle6519
    @patrickdoyle6519 Před 7 měsíci

    My tale away is, buy the cheaper boards no matter what.
    Look if i can get 2 pairs for the price of one pair... Then im way ahead. Watching those cheaper boards get you out of sand and then you are pubishing them in a climb making them flex loke that? Come on dude, at least 70% of us are never going to use then in that fashion and i just think that the few times we need to use them to get out of some sand or snow are well within the cheap boards likits of usability even multiple times. And in the rare event that we need them to clear a gap or whatever... I have 2 pairs! Abuse the shit out on one pair and use the other pair for general use.
    I have lived by "you get what you pay for" but sometimes common sense needs to prevail, especially when a market is flooded with a bunch of newbie consumers eager to spend cash on the top gear. Anyone following the mountain biking scene since 2020 and covid-19 should know and understand this.

    • @IndependenceOverland
      @IndependenceOverland  Před 7 měsíci

      Common sense isn’t part of it, that’s kind of asshole way to word that. In the second video I did on these in the snow, the black ones shattered pretty much right away. The pink ones got so stiff that they basically no longer functioned because the knobs aren’t good enough to really hook a tire when they are cold.
      If I take a cheap set down to Mexico/Arkansas/ PNW on a 2 week trip and they break, I am instantly at a disadvantage if I planned to get remote. One of my tools is now gone.
      Actually using them to bridge a gap isn’t common, but if your in a mud pit and stuck them under a front tire trying to to climb out of something, you have a rounded hole with a flat board. Your putting forward force on the center of the board, similar to bridging it. If they can’t hold up to bending then it’s a problem for more than just a bridge.
      If your someone who bolts them to the roof rack so the neighbors think your cool and you camp 3x a year, the cheap ones might be perfect for you. For those that actually find themselves in squirrelly circumstances fairly often, I recommend the Maxtrax.

    • @patrickdoyle6519
      @patrickdoyle6519 Před 7 měsíci

      @@IndependenceOverland hey sorry if you felt like I was taking a shot at you personally.
      I don't have the experience required to go toe to toe with you on this. I will say this though, at $60 for a pair (I think that's what you said, I'm not going to go back to get the exact quote) but maybe you can spend double that, get much better quality and still buy a second pair for the same or close to the same as the max trax... I rarely, if ever buy the cheapest. Most of the time I buy the best that I can afford. And seeing as how these are plastic and they're just never going to be a 1 time buy, especially if, like you just said, not just a weekend camper 3x a year..
      Also, if you're not the weekend camper you are almost certainly going to have additional means of recovery. I don't know man, feels like common sense to me. 1 is none, 2 is one.

  • @turbosupra2jzdragracingtob249

    Squeaky info….lol

  • @georgecook1374
    @georgecook1374 Před měsícem

    You lied you didn't burry the vehicle to the frame rails. thus nothing else you say is believable as you proved you are a lair right off the bat. Good on ya mate

    • @IndependenceOverland
      @IndependenceOverland  Před měsícem

      Pretty sure I even said in the video that the sand was so wet I couldn’t get it buried more 😂. Go cry to someone else

  • @seanc5827
    @seanc5827 Před 8 měsíci

    very squeaky suspension

  • @mdbnc2704
    @mdbnc2704 Před rokem

    MAXTRAX is the best

  • @rone4220
    @rone4220 Před rokem

    Save your money. When you bury that POS and you’re stuck just call your buddy to bring his early Bronco (66-77 for you millennials) to rescue you….