3 Myths About Trekking Pole Tents

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 4. 07. 2024
  • Trekking pole tents are on the rise in popularity for backpackers, but many are still hesitant to replace their free-standing tent with one. In this video, Tayson lists the biggest myths about trekking pole tents and addresses the fears of many backpackers regarding a trekking pole tent's ability to handle the weather, difficult pitches, condensation, and ease of setup.
    The Fortius Trekking Pole Tents: bit.ly/3Gcg0IY
    Table of Contents
    00:00 Intro
    00:38 Rise in Popularity
    01:01 Myth 1
    02:15 Myth 2
    03:50 Bonus Myth
    04:28 Myth 3
    05:32 Is a Trekking Pole Tent right for you?
    Subscribe for more helpful tips and videos:
    czcams.com/channels/A0h.html...
    Great Outdoor Vitals Gear:
    bit.ly/3GqwqwO
    Backpacks:
    KOTAUL TRAVEL AND ADVENTURE BACKPACK: bit.ly/Cp5FSB
    SHADOWLIGHT ULTRALIGHT BACKPACK: bit.ly/3CctII1
    Shelters:
    FORTIUS TREKKING POLE TENT:
    DOMINION 1P ULTRALIGHT BACKPACKING TENT: bit.ly/30dCJDJ
    ULTRALIGHT DOMINION 2P BACKPACKING TENT: bit.ly/3wCIyGI
    DELANO ULTRALIGHT BACKPACKING TARP: bit.ly/3c5OHSh
    Sleeping Bags:
    STORMLOFT™ DOWN MUMMYPOD™ SLEEPING BAG: bit.ly/3wBsftU
    SUMMIT DOWN SLEEPING BAGS: bit.ly/3c3Cv4B
    ATLAS LOFTTEK™ HYBRID SLEEPING BAGS: bit.ly/3c3CgXf
    LOFTTEK HYBRID MUMMYPOD™ HAMMOCK INSULATION: bit.ly/30eV9DO
    OUTDOOR VITALS SLEEPING BAG LINER: bit.ly/3C5I0dt
    TopQuilts:
    STORMLOFT™ DOWN TOPQUILT: bit.ly/3wEScJ1
    LOFTTEK™ HYBRID 0 - 15 °F TOPQUILTS: bit.ly/2YGN0rA
    Underquilts:
    LOFTTEK™ HYBRID 0 & 15°F UNDERQUILTS: bit.ly/2YBGqT1
    AERIE 0° TO 45°F UNDERQUILT: bit.ly/3C5UTEE
    STORMLOFT™ 0°-30°F DOWN UNDERQUILT: bit.ly/2YDtLPD
    Sleeping Pads:
    ULTRALIGHT SLEEPING PADS: bit.ly/3n6rE03
    1/8" FOAM PADS: bit.ly/3gdpcAt
    Hammocks:
    ULTRALIGHT COMPLETE HAMMOCK SYSTEM: bit.ly/3c1sBQW
    HAMMOCK SUSPENSION SYSTEM: bit.ly/3c3zEJ6
    HAMMOCK BUGNET: bit.ly/3wCMDL6
    Pillows/Balaclavas/Booties:
    ULTRALIGHT STRETCH PILLOW: bit.ly/3wQPSil
    LOFTTEK™ HYBRID BALACLAVA / HOOD: bit.ly/3n6FZcZ
    LOFTTEK™ HYBRID BOOTIES: bit.ly/3n5h6hz
    Jackets and Hoodies:
    NOVAPRO MEN'S JACKET: bit.ly/3EExE5R
    NOVAPRO WOMEN'S JACKET: bit.ly/3FCTHv2
    NOVAUL MEN'S JACKET: bit.ly/3FDV1O1
    NOVAUL WOMEN'S JACKET: bit.ly/3eyn59F
    VENTUS ACTIVE HOODIE: bit.ly/3C8FKCc
    ULTRALIGHT LOFTTEK™ ADVENTURE JACKET: bit.ly/3n7CvGZ
    ULTRALIGHT REGULATOR DOWN JACKET: bit.ly/3C5M911
    Pants/Shorts:
    SATU ADVENTURE PANTS (MEN SIZING): bit.ly/3C7C6IQ
    SATU ADVENTURE PANTS (MEN SIZING WAIST SIZES 40, 43, AND 46): bit.ly/3wFneAh
    SATU ADVENTURE PANTS (WOMEN SIZING): bit.ly/3C7J7JK
    SATU ADVENTURE SHORTS: bit.ly/3D9MDEW
    Dragonwool:
    DRAGONWOOL HOODIE: bit.ly/3C9VsNs
    OUTDOOR VITALS MERINO WOOL NECK GAITERS: bit.ly/3n7noxu
    DRAGONWOOL ZIPOFF THERMAL: bit.ly/3C9oVHB
    DRAGONWOOL BOXER: bit.ly/3DkqELi
    Merch:
    OUTDOOR VITALS LIVE ULTRALIGHT T-SHIRT: bit.ly/3DdqA00
    OUTDOOR VITALS NEW LOGO T-SHIRT: bit.ly/3C2sBed
    OV PROFLEX ADJUSTABLE SNAPBACK HAT: bit.ly/3CcAw8x
    #ultralightbackpacking #trekkingpoletent #tent #outdoorvitals #backpacking #backpackingtent

Komentáře • 122

  • @HamiltonvilleFarm
    @HamiltonvilleFarm Před 2 lety +5

    Just took my first hike with a trekking pole tent. I liked it a lot. Easy enough to set up. Definitely lighter and smaller to pack. It rained heavy on me one night and I was dry. Condensation wasn’t an issue other nights. I’m glad I switched.

  • @keithlawrence1472
    @keithlawrence1472 Před 2 lety +9

    I’ve dealt with trying to set up a trekking pole tent where all you have is a granite slap to pitch on. 10 stakes 2 trekking poles. Never again. Same lake with a free standing tent was cake. Run corner lines out and put rockets on them. Done easy no BS

    • @tadghsmith1457
      @tadghsmith1457 Před 4 měsíci +1

      100%. Free-standing tents are A LOT more forgiving of sub-optimal pitching conditions.

  • @driewiel
    @driewiel Před 2 lety +5

    Free standing tents are a myth. I still had to pay at the camp site!

  • @lakorai2
    @lakorai2 Před 2 lety +14

    Durston X-Mid is the way

    • @natehoover5266
      @natehoover5266 Před 2 lety +1

      Just got it. Glad to join the sage cult...uh I mean group.

    • @austinseph1
      @austinseph1 Před 2 lety +1

      All for the small price of $700 after tax

    • @natehoover5266
      @natehoover5266 Před 2 lety

      @@austinseph1 what is? The xmid is $300. The Xmid pro that's made of dyneema might be that price but that doesn't compare to this tent.

    • @CaMuzzy77
      @CaMuzzy77 Před 2 lety

      AGREED!!!!!!!!!!!

    • @thewanderingsoul71
      @thewanderingsoul71 Před 11 měsíci +1

      @@austinseph1wtf you talking about? The 1P is 240. The 700 ones are dyneema and that price is standard for that material.

  • @fuffydingo
    @fuffydingo Před 2 lety +10

    The more things a piece of gear can do is the quickest way to lighten your load. This is why for me it's a no brainer to carry a trekking pole tent..... I'm already out there with half the weight of my shelter in my hands.

    • @TaysonWhittaker
      @TaysonWhittaker  Před 2 lety +1

      Very true! Great point.

    • @DonTestosterone
      @DonTestosterone Před 2 lety

      The art is also to realize if the two things that can be done are REALLY necessary

  • @tylerwhittaker3027
    @tylerwhittaker3027 Před 2 lety +1

    I am getting one, I was able to sleep in a prototype in extreme wind and was amazed at how well it did. It is so small it will even go in my day hiking pack.

  • @johnnybell685
    @johnnybell685 Před 2 lety +2

    Ohhhhh I can’t wait to get my hands on this baby!!

  • @armyretired28
    @armyretired28 Před 11 měsíci +3

    Unless it's a really rough trail I rarely use trekking poles ,my one man tent weighs about the same or less than a trekking pole tent when you include the trekking poles. I have used both and found that in my states I backpack the weather is very humid and may be hot in the evening but cold in the mornings, the trekking pole tents tendency to have lots more condensation build up overnight than my freestanding ones. I'll stick to my free standing tents.

  • @kkheinrich9224
    @kkheinrich9224 Před 2 lety

    Oh baby! Watched all 3 vids now, after getting the"Presale txt alert".
    Never thought about a"Trekking Poll tent" before...
    But protesting for our first HikeThru on the O.C.T....
    Weight is a factor. Our second half in Sept. 22ad will be lighter because
    *** I preordered!!!
    Thank you for all you do for our Hiking Adventures!!!

  • @morevananything7183
    @morevananything7183 Před 2 lety +3

    I really love your company for producing this tent! I personally feel like the next iteration should be a 50 inch wide bathtub for the 2P version. I understand, based on a comment you made, that this tent will technically stretch to fit the wide pads. But it'd be nice to just already be able to comfortably fit 2 wide pads in here. When life gets tough, I ask myself, "What would Dan Becker do?" And then I try to follow that. Sometimes at least. Because I imagine most people buying this type of tent is willing to take the small weight pentalty for the extra 2 inches for the wide pads. And while everyone loves the X-Mid tents, Outdoor Vitals is an established full-time company working hard to keep their products in stock. So I'd prefer an in-stock tent than waiting years for another drop. The only thing I didn't see listed on the pre-purchase sign up page is whether or not this is a single-wall or double-wall shelter? I'm going to assume it's single-wall based on your condensation comment. While I agree a single-wall/double-wall doesn't have a lot of different for condensation, I also appreciate the double-wall shelters so I can quickly set up just the fly in the afternoon to wait out a rainstorm or to share the weight with my wife. So just my personal opinion as someone who doesn't actually make outdoor gear--I'm sure your team has a reason for everything :P Thanks for sharing!

  • @boopernator
    @boopernator Před 2 lety

    Been waiting for this tent for quite awhile, bought a super cheap trekking pole tent out of necessity for a hike in June. But gotta have the Outdoor Vitals trekking pole tent.

  • @laurabolt5412
    @laurabolt5412 Před 2 lety +2

    One more addition to the benefits of a single wall tent: when setting up camp in precipitation, the inside of your tent stays dry because its never exposed without the rain fly!
    Side note: I preordered the Fortius and CAN'T WAIT for it to arrive!! Thanks for what you guys do!

    • @montuckyman4982
      @montuckyman4982 Před 2 lety

      Thats true but there are some great double walls that you set up the fly first. And then not be dealing with condensation. But yeah, it's all about what tradeoffs are worth it for you.

  • @WasatchWill
    @WasatchWill Před 2 lety +1

    Congrats on the new release. I will say however my favorite part about a freestanding or semi-freestanding tent in the desert is the ability to hold it up and shake out all the sand before packing it up. Beyond that, I agree that a trekking pole tent can be set up just about as securely, you just have to get more creative with how you anchor your guy-lines and other anchor points when in the sand or on slickrock. But you gotta do that too with freestanding tents when faced with high winds. As for condensation, I like the partial solid interiors you can get with some Tarptents like the Notch I have. The roof is solid and so that adds an extra layer to catch and block out any condensation that wants to drip off the main fly above. It can then run down the side of the tent and leave my face alone.

    • @ScottBussing
      @ScottBussing Před 2 lety

      Great point. I had my freestanding inverted over my head before breaking it down, exactly what you are saying, just last week. Getting all the little sand etc out like that is great

  • @jw62nl
    @jw62nl Před 11 měsíci +1

    Nice video. It seems that in the part about condensation there are two different categorizations mixed up though; freestanding/non-freestanding, and single/double wall. I have a double wall trekkingpole tent, and the mesh inner has the same effect as a mesh inner of a freestanding model. (And because I can keep the mesh inner attached to the fly so they're raised together at the same moment, there's never the question of setting up fly first or inner first).

  • @WALKITOFFDavidSmith
    @WALKITOFFDavidSmith Před 2 lety

    Good stuff. Great meeting you at Trail Days

  • @scottburkhart6953
    @scottburkhart6953 Před rokem +1

    I am going to add a Fortius 1 to my gear. I typically hammock camp but there are times when there are no trees, especially above the tree line. With a weight that is minimal, having one in my backpack assures that I will have shelter regardless.

  • @Greg.K.C.
    @Greg.K.C. Před rokem +1

    I’ve never owned a trekking pole tent, with very little available to physically look at in Australia, even on trail, so definitely going to be an online order based on reviews. The pitching in difficult rocky terrain is a concern for me as some of these appear to need 10-12 pegs to get the necessary tension, especially where storm flaps are also required to pull the inner out, versus 6 pegs usually being sufficient on my existing freestanding options. Its hard enough finding 4 good tent peg spots sometimes, with the extra 2 sometimes having to span out a few extra feet. Some of the trekking pole tent pictures I’ve seen seem to have guylines going out 6ft in every direction?

  • @juanbackpacks
    @juanbackpacks Před 2 lety +1

    Agreed…. You can pitch a trekking pole tent anywhere. I’ve used a tracking pole tent across all kinds o terrain from the Sierra to the Smokies. I’ve also used them in rain storms, snow and arid climates. It is hard to beat a trekking pole tent in terms of versatility.

  • @TomyHovingtonHiking
    @TomyHovingtonHiking Před 2 lety

    Great video 👍
    I have a trek/pole tent and wouldn’t go any other way…🙌

  • @jdkarns
    @jdkarns Před 2 lety +2

    During covid I started buying hiking equipment thinking it would be fun to go backpacking. I watched a ton of CZcams videos and found it interesting. Funny thing though, I thought it was like striking out into the wilderness and in a way it is. But it turns out the Appalachian trail is not just walking off into the mountains, you are actually in a park with rules and pathways more like The road Less traveled than trekking off into the unknown wilderness. It's a lot like the highway system except for the fact you're on foot. I know this comment is off topic of the video but I just find it interesting. LOL

  • @Jo-oc8sc
    @Jo-oc8sc Před 5 měsíci

    Love my trekking pole tent, but it does require more work in finding good tent sites. Spent several months in the Sierras in 2023.

  • @Silkstep
    @Silkstep Před 2 lety +1

    I have a one man trekking pole tent, and like it fine except for the fact there is no extra room and just the one door. I think I'll give your 2-man Fortius a go so I can spread out a little.

  • @gondwanalon
    @gondwanalon Před rokem

    Magnificent beard!

  • @RiverRockXIII
    @RiverRockXIII Před 10 dny

    Thank Freya someone with a brain made a review/myth bust on this.. thanks for existing.

  • @SOTTO-ur2kz
    @SOTTO-ur2kz Před 2 lety

    I agree any tent sets up quickly once you have done it a few times!

  • @gregpower308
    @gregpower308 Před 2 lety

    Great content fellas. Please keep it up. Honest pragmatism is a great find on any media platform.
    The big question is; “Will you ship to the UK?” I really like the bomb proof look of The Fortius.

    • @TaysonWhittaker
      @TaysonWhittaker  Před 2 lety

      Yes! We ship worldwide. However customs fees are up to your local government and are not something we cover.

  • @briansimko1049
    @briansimko1049 Před 2 lety

    Looks good 👍.
    Are you still expecting the Kota UL to be delivered in June?

  • @rumblechick73
    @rumblechick73 Před 2 lety +1

    Groundsheet included?

  • @cmason87
    @cmason87 Před 3 měsíci

    what kind of stakes do you recommend for those do all conditions? from rock to sand.

  • @laurabolt5412
    @laurabolt5412 Před 2 lety

    Sorry if you already answered this, but does the 1p Fortius have two doors or only one? Also, do you provide a guide to how long the poles should be, or should we just experiment? It seems like the OV Fortius is a superior competitor to the REI Flash Air, which makes it super enticing! Every time I think I'm done buying gear, you guys release something awesome. Renewed membership here I come!

  • @tullochgorum6323
    @tullochgorum6323 Před rokem +1

    Myth #2 - Weather Conditions. The main failure point for freestanding tents is the poles - they can bend or break under load from wind and snow. Trekking poles are FAR stronger, so virtually eliminate this risk - especially if you use alloy poles.
    In exposed areas I use my MLD Trailstar tarp, which has legendary wind-shedding ability. There are many tales of Trailstars surviving unscathed when far heavier 4-season mountain tents were shredded. This isn't true of all trekking pole designs though - so be careful to match your choice with the worst conditions you might be facing. In general you have to trade off liveability and/or weight for storm resistance, so it can be a tricky decision.

  • @blakeberlin6295
    @blakeberlin6295 Před 2 lety +1

    I didn't understand the answer to Myth 1. You said you can get stakes in the ground even in rocky terrain, but didn't say how. So, how?

  • @ericbrabham3640
    @ericbrabham3640 Před 2 lety

    love my MLD duomid. Even works if you forget the trekking pole. Just use a stick.

  • @Wsmith247
    @Wsmith247 Před rokem +1

    Just ordered one of your insulated sleeping pads.

  • @vvs3796
    @vvs3796 Před 9 měsíci

    come with this tent to scotland !

  • @tom_olofsson
    @tom_olofsson Před 2 lety +1

    Excellent points. I wonder who makes a good trekking pole tent. 🤔

    • @InOurElement
      @InOurElement Před 2 lety +6

      Durston hands down

    • @tom_olofsson
      @tom_olofsson Před 2 lety

      @@InOurElement I was thinking OutdoorVitals but Durston sounds ok.

  • @simonjohnson7025
    @simonjohnson7025 Před 2 lety

    I wish they made a semi free standing trekking pole tent. Like the rei one but with more space

  • @volodymyr8649
    @volodymyr8649 Před rokem

    Hi! How to setup trekking pole tent in cold weather, when the ground is frozen but there is no snow?

    • @TaysonWhittaker
      @TaysonWhittaker  Před rokem

      If you are asking about the stakes not going into the ground because it's too hard I would recommend using rocks to hold the lines in place. You can also upgrade your stakes. outdoorvitals.com/products/easton-tent-stakes?_pos=1&_sid=8b4ebf619&_ss=r

  • @brettnelson5908
    @brettnelson5908 Před rokem

    Do you guys make a tent adaptable for a wood stove?

  • @derekhand7904
    @derekhand7904 Před 2 lety +1

    Can you fit 2 regular nemo tensor pads in the 2p ?

    • @TaysonWhittaker
      @TaysonWhittaker  Před 2 lety +1

      Absolutely! A regular Nemo Tensor pad is about 20 inches wide. The Fortius 2p Trekking Pole Tent is 48 inches wide plus there are two large vestibules that can easily fit any gear.

    • @lakorai2
      @lakorai2 Před 2 lety

      Regular width yes; if you want long wide pads that are 25" wide then you need an Durston X-Mid 2p

    • @thetaysonwhittaker
      @thetaysonwhittaker Před 2 lety +1

      @@lakorai2 While our footprint says 48, in the field we've been able to do two 25" pads for sure! 48 inches to the bottom corners, but you've got forgiveness and the 50 inche widest part are about an inch off the ground.

    • @derekhand7904
      @derekhand7904 Před 2 lety

      @@TaysonWhittaker sick I’ve been looking for a good 2p trekking pole tent so I can get my GF out, but I hear the gossamer gear tent leaks and I don’t want spend $600 + on the z-pack tent

  • @johngould7548
    @johngould7548 Před 2 lety +1

    How much does the Silnylon tent fabric sag when it gets wet?

    • @lakorai2
      @lakorai2 Před 2 lety +4

      Allot more than the SilPoly on the X-Mid

    • @TaysonWhittaker
      @TaysonWhittaker  Před 2 lety +1

      Silnylon can sag, but typically, if you pitch it, have dinner and hang out for a bit, then tension again before bed you are going to be in a great position. Silnylon is simply stronger so it helps us keep the tent light while meeting our performance and durability standards!

    • @bcloetta
      @bcloetta Před 2 lety +1

      Understand that sil-nylon might be stronger, but what about the weight penalty when it is soaked? I only have experience with the Durston, and it dries super quick.

    • @johngould7548
      @johngould7548 Před 2 lety

      @@bcloetta Well there is apparently Sil-nylon and Sil-poly. Don’t know much about either. I think it is good that they are providing a relatively inexpensive trekking pole tent for people who might be interested in trying lightweight single wall tents. I don’t plan on giving up my dyneema Duplex though.

  • @denisestarr2314
    @denisestarr2314 Před rokem

    I love my trecking pole tent .
    Except when I want to leave camp ,
    Lol .

    • @TaysonWhittaker
      @TaysonWhittaker  Před rokem

      outdoorvitals.com/products/fortius-carbon-fiber-tent-poles?_pos=1&_sid=14ee15e7d&_ss=r

  • @raybenash8347
    @raybenash8347 Před rokem

    Do we all agree that a footprint now is not required for either style tent? With a free-standing style I have the luxury of a grommeted footprint that works great with the aluminum supports. Adding a footprint to a trekking pole tent you are typically using a Tyvex as work around without grommets.
    The TP tent will slip and slide on that DIY footprint, it can be a PIA if you go that route - unless you are lucky to have a perfectly flat spot.
    When folks talk about weight they always leave out the 16 oz or so for the poles. If you have them stowed in your pack, they still count as pack weight IMHO. I always stake out with either style tent.
    On a recent trip I did trial a SP tent with a DIY Tyvek footprint. I liked the pack size. I didn't like sliding around on the DIY footprint. The tent was staked out by someone who was practiced. I like the concept of SP tent but not totally sold.
    That said - I'll have both available :-)

  • @harrisonshao4537
    @harrisonshao4537 Před rokem

    I think i tried almost every type of shelter and my favorite have been non freestanding shelters.

  • @beetooex
    @beetooex Před 10 měsíci

    It seems to me that most of the issues with trek pole tents is that they're often from no name, low quality brands. Any tent can have crap ventilation, waterproofing and durability. Any single skinned tent has the issues that single skinned tents have. Every tent needs staking and sufficient guy lines. I think of them like a complicated tarp- find some trees and hang them off a tensioned line by prusic loops. That'll keep them upright and taught.

  • @varde6965
    @varde6965 Před 2 lety

    Do you guys ship wordlwide btw?. Really innterested to buy quilt and down jacket from you guys,

  • @themightiness
    @themightiness Před 2 lety +1

    Good video because I do feel a lot of people are afraid of trekking pole tents for no real reason. I mean, you really can't do ALL terrain in a trekking pole tent but you can do like 99% of areas I guess. I've setup a freestanding tent on a giant rock before, not sure how that would work with a trekking pole tent. That being said I would never carry anything else backpacking a trekking pole tent but the terrain you do have to be mindful of.

  • @evanhammond7305
    @evanhammond7305 Před 2 lety

    Tell us more about that tent

    • @TaysonWhittaker
      @TaysonWhittaker  Před 2 lety

      There's a lot more info here: outdoorvitals.com/collections/fortius-trekking-pole-tents

  • @wandering_not_lost
    @wandering_not_lost Před 2 lety +1

    Interesting video but simply incorrect to suggest that an inner tent makes no difference to the condensation getting on to the user. The same amount of condensation will be produced but an inner tent will be at least partially effective at keeping it away from the occupants

    • @asmith7876
      @asmith7876 Před 2 lety

      I agree, he mentions mesh…well in tents that have solid walls as the inner layer and not simply mesh the condensation will never touch you. I say he’s wrong on that one, depends on the tent.

    • @thewanderingsoul71
      @thewanderingsoul71 Před 11 měsíci

      Correct. He is just wrong on that.

    • @ivanilarionov1893
      @ivanilarionov1893 Před 2 měsíci

      I have a double wall tent with mesh inner tent. When the tent is setup correctly, which is quite easy, the mesh is so tight, that even when the condensation drops over it, most of the time it beads and doesn't penetrate it. I've never had more than a few drops of water inside the tent, and only in the worst conditions.

  • @journeyman7189
    @journeyman7189 Před 2 lety +1

    Nice myth dispelling Tayson. I agree especially with the condensation one. Only thing that does better with condensation is a tarp.
    Nate

  • @paulbuckley1565
    @paulbuckley1565 Před 2 lety

    I have bought 2 trekking pole tents and hate them. After months of review and research I have found the perfect tent. It is a tent by Featherstone, UL Granite 2 person tent. It weights 5 pounds, can be configured in 3 ways and it comes with a footprint. I have set this tent up during a thunderstorm, heavy rain and high winds and it was rock solid in Texas. Last weekend me and my 2 kids ages 8 and 24 setup both tents, (I bought 2 of the Featherstone Granite tents) and camped out, the winds were so strong because a cold front was coming through and the tents were amazing. For $139.00 on Amazon they come with everything, tent body, rainfly, footprint, tent stakes and guide out lines. I bought 2 of the tents and cannot be more happier on my purchase!!!

    • @thewanderingsoul71
      @thewanderingsoul71 Před 11 měsíci

      Lol. A 5 lb tent? Why not just carry a bed? No one except you wants to carry a tent that heavy.

  • @palbal
    @palbal Před rokem +1

    This is how it sounds when the guy selling or working for the product "debug myths". First, just mentioning snow/winter alongside this tent is dangerous and irresponsible! Its simple, this is not a 4th season tent. Period! But, a two season, yes. But, a little wind, and it gets "breezy" inside. Second, condensation. On a two wall tent the condensation build up on the inside of the outer wall. However, on single wall tents, the condensation occur on the "inside" of the tent. A little wind, and you and your gear get sprayed, and possible wet floor. Third, a no brainer, this type of tents apply to trekking pole users only. No, not everybody should use trekking poles. You sell trekking pole tents, that's why the statement. Go figure. There are many types of hikes, like various terrain, that trekking poles are non practical. Lastly, you can find several double wall tents matching the weight of trekking pole tent and the poles together.

  • @ericschwartz9982
    @ericschwartz9982 Před 10 měsíci

    The condensation in a double wall tent does NOT fall through the mesh, nor does it land on the interior. It's never happened to me. I own a free standing tent and two trekking pole tents. There is more room in the freestanding tent, and the trekking pole tents are definitely less bulky in the pack. Will I spend $700+ for a super-light, DCF, single wall tent? No. But again, it is all a matter of personal choice. Free standing tents, IMO, are easier/quicker to set up. The weight differential is modest within a comparable price point. The video is more like an ad for Fortius than anything else, and should be labeled as such.

  • @bihlygoat
    @bihlygoat Před 2 lety

    Regarding “trekking pole tents used in any terrain” and staking out a trekking-pole versus “free-standing” tent (which is a misnomer): I have owned and used, and still do, several different styles of trekking-pole tents, and structural pole “free-standing” tents. Yes it is true that you must stake out a free-standing tent, unless you are certain there will not be any wind (and don’t want to use vestibules). But most of the stakes on a free-standing tent carry much less load than those in a trekking pole tent. The pole structure does carry part of the wind load. The only stakes fully loaded by wind are the windward (upwind) ones holding the vestibule points out, and any guy line stakes on a wind-loaded panel. Compare that to a trekking pole tent where ALL the windward stakes are fully loaded by wind. And, if a stake pulls out in a storm in a free-standing tent, the tent is not in immediate danger of collapsing (assuming you can keep the poles from breaking due to the increased load, until you can get it re-staked). Compare that to a trekking pole tent where if any one corner stake pulls out, likely the entire tent will collapse onto you until you can find the door and go reinforce that stake point. And remember, they’re more likely to pull out (given the same stake pull-out strength) than the stakes on a free-standing tent because they carry more load.
    I still love and use both styles, but definitely choose which to take depending on weather and soil type I expect.

  • @EverythingIsPhotogenic
    @EverythingIsPhotogenic Před 2 lety +6

    Unpopular opinion: DCF is overrated. I'll take this tent for the 1 lb penalty over the X-mid pro all day. The added durability, additional space, and ease of properly staking out a nylon shelter makes for a much better backpacking experience, in my opinion. The better price tag is appealing as well, but even with cost being no object, I would rather sacrifice the grams somewhere else in my pack. I feel like Dyneema products tend to skirt that line between effective use of the material to save weight and status signaling with the mainstays coming from companies like Zpacks. Ultralight is a philosophy not an indiscriminate approach to every single item in your pack. To each their own, but nearly every time I see a DCF tent it looks like a brittle old tarp that's been crumpled up in a garage far too long 😉 Can't wait to try this out!

    • @morevananything7183
      @morevananything7183 Před 2 lety +2

      Totally agree! Just to clarify though, the X-Mid Pro is the DCF version. They also produce a regular version of the X-mid in the sil fabric that is at the $300 and under price range.

    • @justfleeceitout
      @justfleeceitout Před 2 lety +2

      I have to say that having a material that does not soak up water like nylon is super nice. They each have their benefits. Each have their own place.

    • @jurgschupbach3059
      @jurgschupbach3059 Před 2 lety +1

      a completely wet silly poly or nylon tent weighs about 1 kilogram more than a dry one so i love my DCF tent

    • @EverythingIsPhotogenic
      @EverythingIsPhotogenic Před 2 lety

      @@jurgschupbach3059 good for you... Again, weight is not the sole consideration when choosing a tent.
      Additionally, your 1 kg estimate is wholly inaccurate. You're either being deliberately hyperbolic or disingenuous. Unless you don't make any effort whatsoever to shake out the loose water from the tent before packing it up, you can expect to carry an extra ~20-25% weight penalty on most sil-poly or sil-nylon shelters. We are talking up to 500 g not a kg... Unless you're carrying a 4 kg tent!

  • @Kevinschart
    @Kevinschart Před rokem

    the condensation myth is the most annoying. thanks for debunking it. double wall tents have just as much condensation.

    • @ivanilarionov1893
      @ivanilarionov1893 Před 2 měsíci

      the condensation in the double wall tent won't go inside the tent, as the inner tent stops almost all of it.

  • @vintagebentley7
    @vintagebentley7 Před 7 měsíci

    This isn't true if you need two trekking poles for one tent. 0:41

  • @NatureBoy711
    @NatureBoy711 Před 2 lety

    any weight under 1 lb. won't make any difference, whether tent, sleeping bag/ pads, etc....
    too many folks don't have common senses .... LOL !!!

  • @stuartsteele9984
    @stuartsteele9984 Před rokem

    WHAT YOU ARE MISSING: 1. Not all hikers, mountaineers and bushcrafters use trekking poles. 2. You fail to make the option of hanging a tent from above by about 8 or so different methods. 3. You expend energy raising the weight of trekking poles which generates fatigue. 4. It is simple and practical to pick up a downed section of tree limb for crossing a stream and descending a severe slope otherwise you don't need the support. Some users of trekking poles use them for ascending assist. I consider trekking poles as another item to store/carry, occasionally use and waste energy.

  • @thomashughes_teh
    @thomashughes_teh Před 2 lety +1

    free standing tent in the desert = nylon tumbleweed riding the wind toward the horizon.

    • @armyretired28
      @armyretired28 Před 2 lety +1

      That will include that light weight trekking poll tent also, like a trash bag flying in the sky. Both rely on stakes to secure them to the ground...lol

  • @NoOne-yt6yf
    @NoOne-yt6yf Před rokem +1

    How many grams does your beard weigh?

  • @williampennjr.4448
    @williampennjr.4448 Před rokem +1

    why use a tent at all? Nothing beats sleeping under the stars.

  • @jenyates3033
    @jenyates3033 Před 2 lety +4

    No way can any treking pole tent be as strong and weather resiliant as a strong freestanding tent. I have a four pole NorthFace geodisk and a three pole Hilleberg - they will out survive the strongest of treking pole tents.
    Some treking pole tents can be as weather resiliant as some freestanding, but it's blatently a false claim to talk about treking poles tents being okay in 'extreme wind' and just as good as freestanding designs.

    • @lakorai2
      @lakorai2 Před 2 lety +4

      The X-Mid is very storm worthy. Not 80 mph mountaineering resilient but 40 mph is no problem.

    • @thetaysonwhittaker
      @thetaysonwhittaker Před 2 lety +3

      That looks like it might be a 4 season tent...we are definitly not trying to compare our 3 season tent to something like that!

    • @derekhand7904
      @derekhand7904 Před 2 lety

      That tent probably weighs at lest 5 lbs, looking at the shape of this tent I’d trust it in mild-medium size snowstorms

    • @armyretired28
      @armyretired28 Před 2 lety

      @@derekhand7904 Snowstorms with a single wall tent...Most trekking pole tents weighs around 1 1/2 to 2 pounds that's not to include those poles, that's for only a one person which has little to no extra space for anything but you, I had to buy a two man trekking pole tent (Zpacks Duplex) to have any space witch adds more weight.

    • @LMay64
      @LMay64 Před 2 lety

      @@armyretired28 My 9x7 flat dcf tarp held up by trekking poles just survived a spring snowstorm event that dumped 12-18 inches of wet snow on us. Others in our group used their tent fly held up by trekking poles as well as a couple of single walled tents, all held up fine if they were pitched properly. I'd estimate winds approached 60 mph and the wet snow weight was incredible. None of the shelters in our group were 5lb four season tents, but up between 10,000 to 11,000 feet elevation, we all did fine with proper guy line reinforcements (rocks and trees). A four season tent is always ideal when weather is expected and planned for, but in a situation like ours, we put the gear to a test and trekking pole tents, tent flies and flat tarps all held up to extreme weather conditions.

  • @infobaseworks2401
    @infobaseworks2401 Před 8 měsíci

    Settle down on that beard bro