जब वकील और जज में हुई तीखी बहस, लगा 5000 का जुर्माना Patna High Court
Vložit
- čas přidán 23. 09. 2022
- जब वकील और जज में हुई तीखी बहस, लगा 5000 का जुर्माना Patna High Court #law #legal #Advocate.
In this video the honble Judge at Patna high Court justice PB Bajanthri gets irked by both the lawyers anf fines the one. Patna High Court Karnataka High Court Live Stream.
#Patnahighcourt #supremecourt
Law books that are useful to read can be bought from here,
amzn.to/3C28lN4
#Mussorrie #advocate #lawyer #legal #livehighcourt #indianlaw #law #live #court #argument #criminaljustice #guiltyminds #learnadvocacy #courtlive #justicelive #lawmotivation #beajudge #ias #judge #law #legal #patnahighcourt #justiceashutoshkumar #judiciary #motivation #learnlaw #IAS #supremecourtofindia #IPS #2022 #Patnahighcourtstream #orissahighcourt #SupremeCourt #Orissahighcourt#GujaratHighCourt
#Law #Chakra#JusticeAshutoshkumar
*This Video is strictly for Legal Awareness & Education Purpose only.📚
🙏 Follow us on twitter, Instagram and facebook.
@Lawchakra
👉Twitter
/ lawchakra
👉 Instagram.
/ lawchakra
📑*Fair Use Policy -*
Copyright Disclaimer under Section 107 of the copyright act 1976, allowance is made for fair use for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favour of fair use.
Such things happen regularly in courts. At times it becomes difficult to explain very simple things. Tempers run high. The government advocate was not wrong... But he is no doubt bit short tempered or irritable. If a lawyer is constantly interfered or interrupted he will lost his cool or balance. Centuries back it was said that a judge must hear patiently.
Thanks sir for putting such valuable perspective. Aware subscriber like you add value to the channel.
True. However, my observations with respect to this judge is, he asks very pointed questions to the advicates/solicitors. When they do not respond or start brow beating he can get impatient, and rightly so.
Patience also will have some limitations
When a very ordinary man gets post and power, he starts thinking himself as a God...
The hon'ble judge is bit harsh in imposing cost, as the learned advocate is only putting some facts before the court. The court has already rejected the contentions in his order. Then why cost is imposed.
The judge is a very intelligent judge so far as Patna high court is concerned
Both are looking like brothers...
Lawyer and judge looks so similar 😊
All cases in the courts should be settled within one year.
Cost be collected from the parties.
100% cost be collected from the parties
it is more interesting than 99% bollywood movies....very entertaining😅
इन जज साहब को तनख्वाह दिया करो नहीं तो ऐसे ही यू ट्यूब से खर्चा चलाना पड़ेगा इनको।
I really like this judge, the way he speaks firmly, it's amazing. in Kolkata courts require these kind of judges, matter won't last long and people get justice fast.
Hon'ble Judge is apt in his judgement.I know him personally and he has dealt with service matters in Karnataka High Court before elevation.Language is a barrier for his highness.
Louda judge
What is he doing in Bihar high court if he doesn't even know Hindi? Language barrier seems to be a huge issue when 90% of documents are Hindi and need to be translated, where there can be a many a clerical errors in translation.
The other bank of river always looks greener ! 😀
Lawyers are expected to be articulate in the language in which they argue their causes.
Most of them can barely speak English, the required language of the high and Supreme Court.
Wow Idiot!!!
Instead of promoting our own Indic languages u are advocating for English!!!
Courts are for common people....This judge is from south in patna high court...he should keep a translator instead of expecting every lawyer to learn English
बहुत अच्छी भैंस कर रहे जज साहब की समझ से बाहर हो रही है
which article or code of conduct is English mentioned the required language for SC and HC kindly mention
@@mayanktyagi2287 Article 348(1)
Best possible interpretation and remedy given by the court.
Unfortunately, many Advocates are not sincere towards their clients. Sometimes, even if the truth is with you, only because of the carelessness of the
Advocate the case goes against you. I had an experience and I took permission from the Judge and I argued my case myself and got a favourable order. If I was not alert or illiterate, I would have lost the case ever after I was on the right side of Law. After 1.5 years of the case, I was byheart with the facts and dates which saved me. This is the irony.
@I am Sorry It was a civil case. I took permission from the judge in presence of my Advocate. The judge allowed me to have my say and it was very important point my Adv missed.
@I am Sorry What procedures? Milford Milford saying in between?. It is upto the judge to permit the Plaintiff to say few points infront of his Adv. Yes as I said earlier, at some point of time I started to feel that who is the Adv? Bcz I used to teach the Adv on the date of hearing. I am not saying they do it deliberately. But they take up all cases and they hv no time to study the case perfectly.
I also faced same problemm and lost a case.....
@I am Sorry I think he means he was allowed to speak few points that were very important in the case while the hearing was going on. Entirely different from what most of us thought.
Very good
Lawyers should come prepared and focus on the limited point of the case to bring clarity and solution. But what a colossal waste of Court's time on such cases, caused by poor governance at the District level.
Won't be an issue if the judges does his work, I.e., to listen. This judge has seriously taken the words "My lord" and behaving like a lord. Funny judge he is.... 🤣
Why judge so much rush, lawyers always come prepared. Issue is with judges, they start making preliminary assumptions.and try to drive and control the proceedings and try to guess the submissions even befor advocates speak.
Judge must limit his prejudiced/judgemental behaviour he must listen patiently and allow lawyers to drive and submit their arguments and not to guess their arguments before submissions.
#Justice_Rohit_Arya n
#Justice_Ashutoshkumar are very sincere 👍
The behavior with old adv was unexpected
At 8:01 aap chup rahiye humein bolne dijiye nhi humara case hai hum to bolenge toh aap hi bol lijiye 😂😂
Language is being a big barrier to make judge understand by both sides
As per indian constitution english is the language to be used in high courts.
However the laywers are not fluent n comfortable using English.
I wonder how they passed the bar exam ?
The judges lack of patience is understandable.
@@nainitalism indeed, how critical this profession is and these scenarios show the lack of implementation of the basic requirements even to communicate in the court, just incredibly tough to understand.
@@nainitalism they passed the exam long years back when english was not used much in speaking only in written.. and then this guy comes from south.. people from south always hates hindi and thats why he is speaking english and advocated of old age have lost their english skills.. thats why its difficult..whereas after 25 years todays generation advocate will be senior and these issues will be solved..
Legal Profession is the only profession where the regulation has diluted a lot. The quanitity of lawyers being churned out from every nook of the country has led to the dilution of the quality. We need to have strict compliance as well as standard exam for qualifying the same.
@@nainitalism there is difference between academic english and competitive english
इसे कहते हैं बिला वजह बाल की खाल निकलना. साफ़ साफ़ लिखा है कि अमुक व्यक्ति को accountant post पर वापस बहाल किया गया है....इतनी सी बात को chewing gum की तरह क्यों खींचा जा रहा है
Pagla hai judge
8:03 8:07 8:09😂😂 9:06
Mr Bajanthri is always annoyed because he is made to serve not in his home state but in North India (Bihar). May be the reason.
It’s Justice Bajanthri to you.
Fully agree with you
@imCursed Respect the judge. Even if you don’t like his way of working.
@imCursed don't worry he is much more powerful and also making a difference, not passing comments on CZcams.
@imCursed what slave mentality lmaoo 😂😂 read my comment thoroughly.
जिंदगी भर मातृभाषा में पढ़ाई कर यहां अंग्रेजी में बहसबाजी हो रही है
Toh tera kya jaata hain... tu saste reh hindi main hi... Dakhiyanusi!!!
08:08 😂😂😂😂 what a gesture 🎉
Whatever the advocate is saying is right, post of account mentioned their and judge should understand that.
Looking at the quantum of the discussion for this small case, I just wonder how much discussion must have happened for the 1993 mumbai bombings or Ayodhya case Respect for judges🙏
these are collgium judges without any merit 😂😂😂
The judge is having a tough time in Patna High Court since most lawyers do not know English and he does not know Hindi 😂.
It's a shame, we are in 2022 and still facing conversation issues.
in delhi there is no such problem. lawyers and judge usually communicate in hindi
If anybody doesn’t know Hindi , it’s a shame
@@gaurabsarkar2367 why it's a Shame? Do Tamil Telugu or malyalam people Leave their language?
@@vipint3694 for your kind information, We live in India 🇮🇳. Hindi is our national language. Hindi is required if you’re working in govt sector. Who is pointing on Tamil Telugu ? Be mature, don’t be so quick to judge any comment. Mind it
This is Lal phita sahi of judge and government
Laws are very simple to interpret but judges make it complicated.And now a days every thing goes wonderful and scrutiny or interpretation of evidence on record does not run with the Law but it walks with set of mind of a judge and therefore we can not get justice but receive decision.
Both r looking same🤣
😂😂
Judge behaviour is very rude having no sense of insulating anybody as there is no personal matter here and be remain independent in Judgement process. If any misbehave noticed then proper action must be taken by another judges bench on this type of roughness and not be tolerate because this is the matter of Justice on the basis of pure humanity. Very shameful.
He dont want to waste time hearing the whole story, thus to save time inorder to take a faster decission, it is quiet natural that brilliant justice asks random questions like this.
Th ability of a learned and good advocate is that he should be deeply thorough with the facts of the case, so that he can utilise the opportuniy, when gets a turn!
When the judge is trying hard to do the homework, the Advocates should do their part well too, by staying away from procastination! 😂
Patna high court ke vakil ki english really top grade hai
This is happens when judge acts like a God in their court
Its all about being me, my court, my way, my choice, and my conclusion theory. Where judge assume more and listen less to the councils.
मुझे लगता था कम से कम High court ke जज तो file वग़ैरह पड़ ke kaam करते होंगे par यहाँ तो bhaji mandi की तरह बहस चल रही हैएफ़
Jb 25 saal practice kr lete hai. To anubhav ho jata hai. Jaise doctor report dekhty hi turant bta skta hai bimari k bare me.
As judges get transferred any where in India they are not expected to know all languages of India the most common is English next comes Hindi. The local courts should adjust to honorable judges
.and Don t expect judges adopt
I completely agree with you Narayan. I don't understand that why these so called lawyer can't learn English which is official language in judiciary.
@@abhishekawasthi3827 if u think language of judiciary is english then u cant be more wrong.
Below HC in every state there r many courts which work in local languages only. In Gujrat lower courts do everything in gujrati so is the case in keral so in TN. So technically english is a thing qhich is imposed by HC only. All papers r in local language HCs get it translated and then proceed .
High courtsand Supreme Court judges may get transferred any where in India unlike judges of below high court level
@@narayanrao8339 then they can be trained to learn regional language. What's wrong? If judges can't be trained then hire competent ones
Nothing wrong sir for that matter how many languages we have learned?
A new development in the case was that the Judge and advocate were twins.
100% twins
Our judiciary is most inefficient
Here should be lot of changes
Sometimes i feel Judge just fucks up with the minds of the lawyers...
Most lawyers speak to influence, a Judge sees through all the bullshit and tries to stick to the facts of the case. If facts are not presented in a direct manner when questioned - Judge may tend to talk in an aggressive way😀
Judges are like machines now a days
Gvt job seeker jiska khata usko h daga deta h writing mistek me v is k job se h nikal dena chaie
🙏🙏🚩🌹जय श्री राधे कृष्णा 🌹🚩🙏🙏
पटना में कोर्ट भी दोयम दर्जे की हैं!
माननीय कोर्ट पर जनता का विश्वास मजबूत हो रहा है
Mr. PB Bajanthri is always annoyed
Justice*
@@Shivammadhur18 nah
Hats off to the honarable judge 🫡
Why Law chakra has a misleading title. The lawer has been punished for filing the case under contempt of court not harsh argument.
both things happened. Thanks for watching.
It is ironically said that if a person fails in seeking jobs in all other sectors he does LLB n joins as an Advocate
Well it's not easy to be a good advocate it requires a lot of hard work
@@riteshchaudhary2836 good advocate and quantity of advocates are two different things
@@kddesigner149 it's easy to pass remarks on others than face the challenge themselves ...sounds like when the cricketers are on pitch how half million public gives free commentary and advice😂...
@@shilpa110 why r u so bothered..lagta hai advocate ho jo feel kar gyi .. doosri baat opinion word ke bare main suna hai kabhi uske liye voh profession choose nahi karna hota 🤣🤣
This judge is very rude. He has no right to treat any human being as someone lower! This judge should be fired!
Nowadays atrocities of lawyers and judges increased enormously to protect the honesty and dignity of our systems we need unbiased judicial systems Justice for men's also Good India future India is the best place to
Condition of courts and it's preceding is pathetic in India
"don't annoy with me" .
Entire lawyer fraternity needs to go back to primary school and relearn whatever their language of presenting in court is
😂
It made me remember the famous dialogue "don't angry me" 😂😂
@@lawyersoniasaini more like, we need better judges who do their work, I.e, listen, and not speak needlessly.
जरूरे सुने
The honourable judge is a brilliant one with Police mind and knowing all practical cum Law procedures. Thus, he cannot be tricked by anyway!
For the reason above, he dont believe things so easily & he randomly asks random questions, which make the unprepared Advocates to wet with sweat, some lose coolness like this!
However, Patna Court has a good asset with them!
Sach mein tabhi courts ka yeh haal hai yha sab apne aapko tees Markha samajh rhe hai jabki hai koi nhi 😒😒itne gande tarike se kon baat krta hai yaar yeh judge bhi aur lawyer bhi...bichara jo victim hai uska tou koi wajud hi nhi hai..nonsense hearing.. 🙏🙏
I have been to taluka court for justice, The judge advise me to become a person to whom i had accused , what a shame, these corrupted juge just give date after date, and the next judge told me, if i have paper of my land and i pay the land tax, it does not mean the land belong to me, which means if a bad person put a gun on your head and tell you to go out and you leave your home and he occupies it then you go to court and such shameless judges give you sermons to become a person like that bad person, how do you feel ? I do not believe in this judiciary system of india, these corrupted police and judges are real terrorist of india . I hate this entire judiciary system of India which just entertain the bad people and bad mafia. Only the God is judge in india, the police station where i had filled the complaint , he did not took me to court and the court closed, because i had not given him rupees. I think money is the judge of india, the more you spend the quickly you get results. Billions of cases are pending which is crime in itself.
Pura order likhane k baad wakeel sahab ko kya chull machi thi
Aa bhel mujhe mar.
Justice P B bhajantri
My Lord 😆
Lot of "mi lord"
Dear advocate :1st remove the me lord word, 100 times in a line
Kindly humbly😂
सीधी बात नो बकवास: वकील हिंदी में ही बोलना चाहते हैं और मीलोर्ड इंग्लिश में। एक mismatch है। समस्या गई तेल लेने, हमारे देश में पद आपस में ही लड़ते हैं। दूसरी बात आप कोर्ट से लेकर संसद तक देख लें, बात को साफ तरीके से बोलने ही नहीं आता। More noise less substance.
Hindi me bat sunne me kya problem hai
Kamal Rachna
Cases should be heard in regional languages as it is seen in this case its inherently difficult for the lawyers to communicate in English. Language is a means of communication and if proper communication does not take place using the language which is not the mother tongue of the communicator the whole objective of communication becomes futile. This can be detrimental in a profession like law where proper communication of one's stance is so important.
Judges get transferred all over india, they may not understand regional language of the place they are transferred to. Forcing hearings to take place in regional languages of the court will increase the problem of the language barrier even more.
ghatiya system
If you can pass the law exam, you can definitely learn basic English
The language of all High Courts is English, by law and constitution.
@@2099santosh dont make such comments on Judiciary. You might be held for contempt
Haah !
Yh tareeka hai yha insaaf lene ka......
Very painful process
15 तारीकय तोय लालकिले पार शादी होता ऐसा कुन्नूयहाय
Lawyers should either speak in regional language with permission or master english
Judge don't know Regional language 🤣🤣..
Ager judge k pass aye hai toh pehle unki baat soon ni chahiye.kyuki woh judge hai
Judge unable to under stand that raju has been taken back as accountant in patna trusury office.
senior lawyer was irritating, unclear and reluctant. He blamed judge for his own unpreparredness. Senior lawyer should not be like this. He should have been fined for sure.
Attitude of judges are inherent from British era, the way they is to sentence our Indian’s. Still advocates need to address them as My Lord.
They need to speak in regional or Hindi language.
Judge saheb bahut batamiz hai😢
तो आप ही बोल लीजिए पहले
My Lord Puneet 😂😂😂
👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿
It is too much , letter if sprit of contempt does not warrant imposing costs, in fact prima facie petitioner was subjected great hardship . Secondly why court to rescue for correction n issue corrigendum...
Mee Lord
I think both are brothers there faces are similar so all revenge taken in court 😂😂
Isliye desh aage nahi badh raha hindi bhasi sunwayi jo nahi hoti
Please upload some videos of #Uttarakhand , #Nainital too.
If better argument are there accept, rules should change with the change of time
Why it is my lord...??
This judge always seems irritated.. needs training I suppose..
😂😂😂
There are no Lords in India now. Why not call the judge simply Sir or Mr.
Dono bhai lgre hai
The judge sahab had been in a circumstance earlier also due to language barrier
First give exact answers to judges question even if it's against you...then agrue further as u wish
Doosron ko sunna ek bahut bada attribute hai, kisi bhi kursi par baith kar khud ko Bhagwan nahi samajhna chahiye
Ego issues between these two
Everytime in high tone.
Short tempered judge
Clerk is written in govt order upon the client doing accountant job in patna treasury which remains true for always if the accountant doing accountant job unconsiders the word "clerk" which has been cleverly told as gramatical mistake.
This judge is larger than life
ENGLISH should be used as Language of the HIGH COURT.
Judge don't know hindi
@@hyperx5264he dont even know marathi😢
@@arg3882 c'mon brother he doesn't even speak english fluently. if you call that a good english then rather they should do the precedding n all in local languages only!!
why he took office at patna high court, where most of even college grad can not speak fluent english. He should request for transfer and hold office in south states or in metro citites where most lawyer can speak english.
The judge is very particular...how ever he only wants..he is very arrogant it seems
The judge is simply impatient.
Is judge really addressing him *sir*
10000 fine krna chahiye tha on that advocate for unnecessary arguments
Sir please look into the undue delays. I have a case for recovery against Arbitration award of 2006 still awaiting orders
Kamal Gajal Call Recoding
..भारत से अंग्रेज चले गए??