Top 10 Ocean Liners
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 06. 2024
- We all have personal connections to the ocean liners of yesteryear, even though many of us have never step foot on one. Each ocean liner is unique which means that we all have our favorites. This video is a ranked list of my favorite ocean liners along with my rationale for each. What are your favorite ocean liners? Let us know in the comments section!
Thanks for checking out the first video of my new vlog series! I will be uploading these more casual videos about transportation history periodically, but these will not impact the regular Great Big Move video main video series.
There are no sources for this video as it is primarily an opinion piece and the specific information discussed is generally surface-level and easy to find.
Support the show on Patreon and get exclusive benefits: / thegreatbigmove
The best way to support the channel is to share this video with your friends and family and on social media. Subscribe! New videos are posted every third Thursday. - Auta a dopravní prostředky
I just want to take a minute to say Good Job! Your narration style and voice really draws you in, I've been on a binge of your content recently and i've noticed with each video your confidence and narration style improve. It's detailed, straight to the point and entertaining! Honestly, I don't know why you don't have more subscribers.
Legit same, been binging these for a few days. It’s this guy who’s now making me consider an apprenticeship at Cunard, so thanks bro, helping my future 👊🏻
@@josephelliott7336 Good luck to you.
i don't know how i got to ocean liner youtube, but I'm so happy to be here
Me too
Oh wow i love your videos and had no idea you watched some real shipster channels
@@blu_e1910 it's my new obsession
@@Cuestar you’ll never be able to get rid of it, trust me.
I have had it for two years
I see ocean liner, I click.
Love to hear it, so do I.
No, *WE* Click.
RAKEAFRI mmmmmmm
Same here
Same
Maybe you could do a list of the top 10 underrated or largely forgotten ocean liners or 10 of the largest ship disasters
Great idea!
I would totally watch that.
Same
Yes, like S.S. America
OO also R.M.M.V OCEANIC 3 that would be cool
My personal list:
1. RMS Titanic
2. SS Normandie
4. RMS Queen Mary
4. RMS Lusitania
5. RMS Aquitania
6. RMS Queen Elizabeth 2
7. RMS Empress of Ireland
8. SS Andrea Doria
9. SS Vaterland/Leviathan
10. RMS Oceanic (1899)
1. Normandie
2. Vaterland/Leviathan
3. Olympic
4. Oceanic (1899)
5. Queen Mary
6. France (1912)
7. Homeric (1922)
8. Lusitania
9. Paris
10. Andrea Doria
ManiacJH Damn it..! My list omits Empress of Ireland..! I love Empress more than Carpathia
@@ScatteredCollector rip carpathia
I’m obsessed with the Lusitania! Very sad, yet interesting story
@@morgancashman4132 yes
In my opinion, the Olympic Class sisters and Normandie were the most beautiful, elegant, and luxurious ocean liners - it’s a shame that most of them met such tragic ends. The United States was technically the most impressive in terms of engineering and outright speed and it is still with us to this day, albeit in a very deteriorated condition. (I still have hope that it will be restored to its former glory someday!) I would also have to include the smaller, but heroic, Carpathia as my favorite one funnel ship.
Seldom do we see posts about one of the most elegant, unusual and beautiful liners, the ss Michelangelo.
I've unfortunately never had the chance to be on a real Ocean Liner, but I did get to watch the Queen Mary 2 when it passed by my city during its anniversary run.
absolutely beautiful, haunting to see such a vessel running among the more "modern" looking craft.
she did pass by again in April this year but we had just started lockdown and police were looking for any excuse to be brutal during that time, so couldn't risk it. it's shame because she apparently docked here unlike prior where she only passed.
I wonder if we will ever get ocean liners running normal in the future, I understand the cost etc but it would be a wonderful thing to have again.
I haven't been on an ocean liner either, unfortunately. I did get to see the United States in Philadelphia last summer, but I hope to see the handful of other preserved liners and to travel on QM2 at some point.
My only experience on an ocean liner was a visit to the Queen Mary in Long Beach, CA back in the 80s. I'd love to cross the Atlantic in a ship like that.
The Great Big Move united stated is bound not to sail again eventually it will sink into the harbour when a pipe bursts or the draft closes in on itself well collapses
Fun fact, my grandparents have 7 of the seats from the (I believe) first class dining room on the Mauritania
WHATT?!!
I totally agree with what you said about single funnel liners. They're amazing ships and quite frankly underrated.
My list is:
1: Olympic (1911)
2: Normandie
3: Mauretania
4: Majestic
5: Imperator
EDIT to include 6-10
6: Homeric, she's underrated
7: Carpathia, the little liner that could
8: Queen Mary, helped get the industry through dark times
9: Aquitania, the Ship Beautiful indeed
10: Britannic (Olympic-class), her potential as a liner was incredible
Britannic 3?
Damn that's many of your favorite ships
I never liked the extra deck on the stern of the Britannic and the huge lifeboat davits. Olympic and Titanic were much better looking.
Very fitting regarding the Carpathia.
the Olympic must be my favorite, not the Titanic. The Titanic had a very short lived carreer where the Olympic had a long and succesfull carreer, surviving a collision, surving WW1 and sinking a U-boat that planned on attacking her
I knew Titanic was going to be number one. It's the ship of dreams.
CZcams highlighted this comment, ruining the video conclusion 🤷🏼♂️
@@liquidiced yeah right, yeah right.
Sureely Titanic was the ship of nightmares?
I could never put my finger on it but I think you nailed what I like so much about the old ocean liners. The knife edge bow as you eloquently put it. I love how the sharp bows literally slice through the water. Great video.
I'm glad someone agrees!
Over the last two years, I have taken a real interest in ocean liners. I'm really fascinated by them 🚢
Well, mine would be:
1. SS Normandie - she is just too breathtakingly beautiful. For me, a machine of divine properties.
2. RMS Queen Elizabeth - The QE looked strong and yet, had a kind of welcoming aura. When comparing RMS Queen Mary to her and Normandie, feels like QM was born outdated....
3. RMS Mauretania - A great combination of sleek early liners design and 4 funnels (with those slighty allocated to the front half) that really catches my eye.
4. RMS Queen Mary 2 - I just love the "modern ocean liner" rendition that Queen Mary 2 is and, being born long after the end of the great liners, it is the last string holding this legacy alive to our generation, so it kinda holds a natural beautiful aura.
5. RMS Titanic - I belive that the Olympic Class had the best design of the early superliners, and in regard to that, Titanic peaked among the other two. The gentle curve of the bridge is so strong and asthetic that I have a hard time trying to find Aquitania and Imperator's Class beautiful with their "flat faces"...
Definitely agree about the flat bridge of Aquitania.
Aquitania had a curved bridge screen, but it was hard to see that curvature, unless she was seen from a broadside view.
@@cunard61 , and it's recently been discovered Titanic's navigation bridge also had a very slight curvature at the outermost windows.
Don't make fun of my favorite ship
I respect that you weren't afraid to list the popular choice as #1 -- she's definitely my top choice too. For me personally, Titanic's story is part of the reason she's number 1. If it weren't Titanic, I never would've wanted to learn of other ocean liners. I'm sure she alone generated a ton of renewed interest in other ships.
You're absolutely right. The only reason we're talking about this right now is, most likely, because of Titanic's allure.
My top 10 ships:
1: SS Normandie
2: RMS Queen Mary
3: RMS Titanic
4: SS Bismarck/SS Majestic
5: RMS Mauretania
6: SS France/SS Norway
7: SS Europa/SS Liberte
8: SS Kaiser Wilhelm II
9: SS L'Atlantique
10: SS United States
Quarteon why? Why are they your favourites? Have you travelled on any of them? Visited them? Know stories of their history!
Genuine question, as my favourites are the ships I personally know.
julie Wallis They are my favourite liners because I do happen to know what they look like, their down to their interiors and layout, and also their history. Now of course I haven't been to any of them because none of them longer exist (except for the RMS Queen Mary) but there are many videos, photographs, deck plans, even full websites dedicated to preserving the stories these liners.
Titanic
gydg nghy Well, not really. I chose Normandie as the first because I really like how they designed her 1st class interior spaces, and especially her avant-garde decor. She was even more innovative than the QM almost in every way.
HEY YOU ALL FORGOT THE RMMV OCEANIC THE FORGOTTEN UNFINISHED OCEAN LINER
I think I can only come up with a top 5.
1) SS United States
2) Normandie
3) SS France
4) Queen Elizabeth
5) Queen Mary
I guess I like 'em big and fast :)
Fair enough! Thanks for sharing
I'm with you. I might change the order a little, but those 5 are at the very peak of liner evolution. Though each is unique, they share in common great beauty, immense size and dizzying speed. It would be an honor and a privilege to make a Crossing on any of them.
United States, the big-block muscle car of ocean liners, is decidedly the fastest, but France is the second fastest, having achieved over 35 knots on her trials.
My favorite is the SS America 🇺🇸
@@Waiting_to_Exhale_era But she was a small twin screw ship, and slow. The SS United States was design by the same man and learning from SS America's flaws, created an engineering masterpiece .
I like your choices
Olympic is my favorite by far. Her story is fascinating (and absolutely wild) plus she and her sisters were, in my opinion, quite possibly the most beautiful ships ever built.
SS Normandie: if not for her stunning beauty, then for her ignoble death.
You can thank the New York Firefakers for that!
@@daveboydell2896 firefakers?
@@I_am_a_cat_My term for Firefighters because of it being the most overrated glorified job in the world. What the public are lead to believe they do and what they actually do are worlds apart. As a former Firefighter I can say first hand it's not a brain job hence the sinking of the Normandie by being sank by Fire Hoses!
@@daveboydell2896 I mean obviously pointing a hose and spraying water isn't rocket science... but they still help people in need. A lot of them are volunteers... my brother was a volunteer firefighter because he wanted to HELP people.
Just because some people accidentally sunk a ship long ago, that doesn't mean they're all "fakers" lmao. You sound like you have a grudge and bias.
As someone who has had firefighters stop a house fire that would have been catastrophic to my life, I hope if your house ever catches on fire, you don't call the "firefakers" and just watch all the things you worked for burn away.
2hat happ3nded. To her
1.SS Normandie
2.Olympic class ocean liners
3.SS United States
4.SS France/Norway
5.RMS Queen Mary/ Queen Elizabeth
6.QE2
7.SS Bremen/Europa
8.Rms Lusitania/Mauritania
9. Ss Rex/Corte di Savoia
10.SS Raffaello/Michaelangelo
Conte di Savoia
My favorite liners are:
5. Europa
4. Queen Mary
3. Normandie
2. Rex
1. Lusitania
Yee Lusitania is best gurl tho (◍•ᴗ•◍)
Queen Mary 2 ( yes it is the last and it is an ocean liner)
@new republic of dave me too!
My fav:
1. SS Normandie.
2. RMS Titanic.
3. SS Ile de France.
4. SS France/Norway
5. RMS Lusitania.
6. SS Imperator.
7. RMS Queen Elizabeth II
8. SS Atlantic.
9. SS Rex.
10. SS Bremen.
Excellent...
What places are the SS America, SS united states and RMS Queen Mary
@@penkagenova7073 11. Queen Mary, 14. SS America, 16. SS United States
Love the Rex and Conte di Savoia. Too bad they were destroyed in WWII.
It is too bad that there are so few photos of ille de France in her original three funnel configuration.
Mine top ten Are:
1- Aquitania
2- Queen Elizabeth 2
3- Olympic
4- Oceanic 2
5- Lusitania
6- Normandie
7- SS US
8- Majestic
9- Queen Mary 2
10- Because of Her story the SS Principessa Mafalda
Ps: The Titanic is where my passion Begin so her do not fit in any list because Titanic is her own thing
Nice list, and I agree, Titanic is her own thing.
I like your list except for the ones that end with 2. The originals were beautiful and didn't have that cruise ship look .
@@majorneptunejr i Understand and respect your comment! But.. to be honest, Mary 2 is the only ocean liner that we can travel these days and i liked the experience dsspite of her.... bulkyness
SS United States. My favorite part of any ship is it’s engineering spaces along with it’s outward appearance.
Not actually she's kinda lame in terms of career
@@thegunner7942 That's not true. During her career she was very competitive and lasted to the end of the liner era .
@@thegunner7942 Made it through WW2, last to win the Blue Ribband, and she's "lame"?
@@the4tierbridge not a war hero like mary, and not even as famous as the mary and not even that famous outside us, even though ss united states was faster many travelers preffered to ride on the mary and mary carried even more passengers compared to her
@@thegunner7942 Yes, United States was a troop ship during WW2.
I agree with the choice of Titanic. I know all those liners and the Olympic class just so happens to be the most beautiful, regardless of Titanic's story.
It's a little coincidental, but you're right that the Olympic class just happens to be exceptional. They were, in a way, the pinnacle of their own style of ocean liner.
Absolutely! The enclosed A-deck promenade so massively improved her looks over the Olympic, plus all the other improvements the Titanic got. The gantry davits ruin the look of the Britannic for me and the curved railings and loss of space for the organ ruin the forward grand staircase.
@@TheGreatBigMove
I don’t have a Top 10, but my favorite is Britannic as an ocean liner.
However, there is still something I don’t like about the Britannic as an ocean liner, the added railings above the bridge makes her look like she has a “big forehead”.
Nice choices indeed
My favourites -
1. RMS Titanic
2. SS Normandie
3. MV Britannic
4. RMS Queen Mary
5. RMS Aquitania
6. RMS Mauretania
7. SS Ill de France
8. SS United States
9. SS Bismarck
10. SS Bremen
Here is my top ten, I hope you enjoy :)
10. Oceanic II - I really love her design and she was a bridge between the late 1800s ship designs and the early 1900s ship designs. I really like the fact that she didn't have a sister ship because it makes her unique
9. Mauretania II - I have a soft spot for intermediate liners, not as big as a superliner but still elegant. I like her funnels and she has more of a cozy vibe to her
8. Queen Elizabeth - She has such a powerful presence and had a really clean look to her, she imo was the ultimate superliner
7. Britannic (1874) - The first Britannic took the proven design of the Oceanic Class and improved it, her and her sister were wonderful ships astheticly and I love her funnels
6. Britannic (1929) - The third and final Britannic was a really good looking ship, she looked very tough and utilitarian but still had a charm
5. Oceanic III - Although she was never finished, from looking at her concept pictures I believe she would be the best ship of that time and its a real shame she was never built
4. Titanic - BALANCE, that's what I see in Titanic. She was sleeker and more modern looking than the Olympic but not as modern as the Britannic, and was the perfect balance between the two designs
3. Baltic (1903) - I had a tough time choosing between her and the Adriatic but Baltic's story wins out. I love Baltic's design but also her personality, always there to give a helping hand
2. United States - United States was (and still is) a symbol for the USA, she was built in one of the USA's most impressive times inovation wise. She had a very sleek design and it would be a treat to travel on her
1. Caronia (1947) - The Caronia is my favorite liner of all time her color and design are perfect in my eyes and her sleek look was beautiful. I feel like she could go anywhere and do anything
Completely agree with your rationale for your #4 and I wanted to get Caronia onto my list but I couldn't make it work personally. Thanks for sharing!
I almost put the Baltic over the Oceanic, the Big Four were so instrumental in WSL's bottom line and so very successful for the time. The Adriatic was the largest and most luxurious but by it's launch it was just too overshadowed by the Lusitania. In the end though, I had to step it back to the Oceanic, I know not a Big Four, but was just such a huge step forward for the time and seems to have a lot in common with the Big Four.
The Great Big Move My problem with Olympic is the A deck promenade being open and the B deck one being enclosed, like if you are gonna do one, do the other
Hypergon Vids the Titanic didn’t have any enclosed first class promenade besides what was on A deck whereas the Olympic had like 2/3s of B deck enclosed for first class promenade space so it didn’t really need it. Though it does look much better with that enclosure on A deck.
The trouble with Titanic being balanced is that she ended up as a bloody seesaw.
I actually like Lusitania's interior better than Mauritania's lol ಠ∀ಠ
I like both but for different reasons
@@TheGreatBigMove could you tell me the reasons? I somewhat do like some places on the Mauritania becuase there are so many places on the Lusitania where it's pretty white (especially on first class). But I really do love Lusitania's dining saloon than Mauritania's.
@@heatherchandler724 i like lusitania because the front of her superstructure looks way more clean imo
@@globial5329 I overall like Lusitania better, but some interiors of Mauritania I think are a bit better than Lusitania's.
@@heatherchandler724 ,c'mon, don't be ridiculous, Lucy doesn't hold a candle to the Maury.
My top 10 in no particular order:
1. RMS Titanic 1912
2. RMS Lusitania 1907
3. RMS Aquitania 1914
4. RMS Queen Mary 1936
5. RMS Atlantic 1871
6. RMS Carpathia 1903
7. RMS Oceanic 2 1899
8. RMS Olympic 1911
9. SS Normandie 1935
10. MV Georgic 1932
Honorable mentions:
HMHS/RMS Britannic 1915
Queen Mary 2 2004
SS United States 1952
RMS Mauritania 1906
RMS Majestic 1914
SS American star 1940
RMS Adriatic 2 1906
SS Andrea Doria 1953
Growing up in the 70's and 80's , I got ridiculed for loving ocean liners as opposed to sports. I still love them. It's so nice to see younger people still having an interest in them. I love the fact that we have an attractive young man carrying on their history. Great job!
Good Video! Enjoyed the VLOG series, hope you do more. Would also be down for a live chat some time.
By top 5:
#1 - Titanic - Same reasons as video. What got me interested in ships, best overall Olympic Class.
#2 - Normandie - So ahead of her time, so beautiful. Wish she got to live a longer, fulfilling life
#3 - Oceanic - Just a huge step forward at the time, like koolaid man busting through to the 20th century
#4 - Mauretania - Another huge step forward with her sister, there's just more info so I know more about the Maury
#5 - United States - Sleek, modern, Art Deco, hauls ass
Good picks! I'd be open to doing a livestream at some point if people are into it.
@@TheGreatBigMove Lol also curious, that seems to be a pretty heavy sweater for the middle of August.
@@mattbots1 I keep my A/C cranking in my office where I record. Had to turn it off to record this video, though, and I admittedly was pretty toasty by the end.
I like this video very much. Normandie ranks first on my list. SS France makes it as a close second. I also have a soft spot for the Queens and most German liners.
But boy must Normandie have been a gorgeous sight to behold inside and out. Her propulsion was cutting edge, and her hull was mind boggling. Could you do a video on the French Lines ? Love your work.
Normandie was undoubtedly an outstanding liner. I will definitely be doing videos on Normandie, Paris, France, etc.
@@TheGreatBigMove Thank you! Looking forward to it! Your channel is great 👍
You know the Videos Gonna Be Good When it’s Titled “Top 10 Ocean Liners” !
1. Externally I'd go for Britannic but Titanic wins because of the same point you gave
2. Majestic
3. France (The first one)
4. Rex
5. Normandie
6. Georgic (Underrated ship)
7. Queen Mary (She was the 2nd ship I knew about outside of the Olympic class ships and started my interest in ocean liners)
8. America
9. Lusitania
10. Asama Maru (I kinda like her industrial look)
Yay so happy to see you posted a new video :D
You forgot to tell us your favorite liner!
I love the Normandie! I am a sucker for art deco and she was just gorgeous 😍
@@TheGreatBigMove I almost forgot I love the Leviathan! Partly because of her name :P
@@VanessaScrillions Leviathan is a great name for an ocean liner 😉
My top 5:
Rms Olympic (1911)
SS United States
Rms queen Mary
Rms titanic
Ss Normandy
*Normandie
Great list! I am relieved you didn't chose Queen Mary as your favorite, sigh of relief that you didn't because she's still here, as is SSUS.
1. CGT Normandie
2. RMS Titanic
3. SS United States
4. RMS Teutonic
5. Homeric
6. Leviathan
7. RMS Empress Britain
8. Queen Elizabeth
9. SS Cristoforo Colombo
10 Queen Mary 2
I'll put ss united states as no 8, never really famous outside america
Funny I just noticed your likes and I cant believe we have the same three
What does CGT mean
@@Bluegoose-df7if CGT = Compagnie Générale Transatlantique = French Line = Best liners ever
This channel deserves so many views and subs. I wish more young people like myself were as interested in history as we are.
I agree with most on your list. Another good video
Normandie is that most sleek, majestic and enchanting ocean liner I have ever seen. Her fine, sleek lines and bow shape just casts a spell on u. Even thought her time came under unfortunate circumstance, she is the most beautiful ocean liner of all time.🚢👑😊😍
If somebody were trying to design the most iconic of ocean liners both inside and out they could do worse than come up with a ship like Normandie. She was an incredible piece of engineering and decorating, and it is heartbreaking to realize that she never even lived a full decade nor ever turned a profit for her owners.
1. SS Normandie
2. RMS Queen Elizabeth
3. RMS Queen Mary
4. RMS Queen Mary 2
5. SS United States
6. RMS Queen Elizabeth 2
7. RMS Aquitania
8. SS Bremen
9. RMS Titanic
10. SS Imperator
Big list!
Wow, I just got back in my childhood interest of the titanic/maritime ships in general, and this was the perfect channel I was looking for! Definitely gonna veer over to the starboard side and smash that red subscribe button!
Enjoyed this vid. And because i did, you have yourself another subscriber. Thanks man.
I don’t comment first, I don’t watch last. When the Great Big Move uploads something I click real fast.
1: SS NORMANDIE
2 : SS FRANCE
3 : SS ANDREA DORIA
4 : RMS LUCITANIA
5 : RMS OCEANIC
6 : SS UNITED STATES
7 : RMS CARPATHIA
8 : RMS MAURITANIA
9 : RMS QUEEN ELIZABETH (1930’s)
10 : SS AMERICA
Wich oceanic? The first or the second? They were both rms lol
The first is from 1870 and the second is from 1899
@@Kapitan_Creeper most likely 1899.
Now this is my kind of top-tens video.
The list was terrific including many of the smaller liners I lacked knowledge about. Normandy is the one I would love to have traveled on. The elaborate grand couture of a marvel of engineering and art. But I wish we could have seen the grand plan of the three gorgeous Olympic class ships come to fruition.
Love your videos about liners man! So much good info!
my list is
1. RMS Brittanic as she would have been.
2. SS Leviathan
3. RMS Titanic
4. SS America
5. RMS Lusitania
6. RMS Queen Mary.
7. SS Britannic (1874)
8. RMS Mauretania 2.
9. RMS Mauretania.
10.RMS Queen Elizabeth.
Leviathan is great Eastern Isnt it
@@rmslusintania7720 no the SS Leviathan of the Imperator class.
Agreed, the Britannic in her revenue configuration would have been one of the grandest liners of all time.
You know for a White Star Line Fanboy you got some cunard lines on there
@@renttojo I can never tell a lie
Great choices and you provide wonderful rationale for your picks! I'm glad you have some intermediates and older liners - I personally am a huge fan of the non-express steamers. The post-war Saxonia class are a favorite, along with the Britannic and Georgic, "The Pretty Sisters," and Cunard's "A" class. I am a Titanic buff too, she is what started my whole ocean liner interest in 1983! And the Normandie - what a liner. Thanks for sharing your choices!
I’m trying to figure out how I ended up watching your videos. But I’m loving them. I’ve learned more about ocean liners and cruise ships watching your videos than I ever did in school. I don’t know why, I find myself obsessed with White Star Line and Cunards liners. The style of the ships in the early 1900s into the 40s are my absolute favorite. I think modern day cruise ships are complete eye sores. These old liners, are just so beautiful. What ships should look like to me at least. I very much appreciate your videos. Not to mention for the first time in my life, I’ve looked up prices for tickets on Queen Mary 2 from New York to London. Surprisingly enough, I may actually do it some day. 😂
Great video and list. I learned something new: Atlantic! Oceanic! Your list also brought to mind some of my (more modern) favorites: Conte di Sovoia, Leonardo da Vinci, France, and the ultimate for me: Normandie.
Here are some things you mentioned I want to address and a following list of the ocean liners I consider the greatest.
3:36 QE2’s interior was made for the late 60s and 1970s modernistic style. Even though it broke from tradition in many ways, the design worked at first. Over the years they tried to update it with new more classical-looking furniture and fittings. But the thing is, the futuristic 60s design was infused into the very design/layout of the ships interior, and it did not blend well at all with the updated furniture and fittings they put in it.
4:22 Aquitanias exterior _was_ beautiful. I don’t understand why people think otherwise. Is it the boxy forward superstructure? If so, why? That was the trend at the time. It had been the trend for a number of years and it can be seen in the beloved Olympic class, the Imperator class and more. The only ships at the time that really broke from this trend were the Lusitania/Mauretania.
5:00 I mean no offense, but why is it always an offense in need of apology for one to say they think a certain ocean liners interior and exterior to be better than the Olympic class? The Olympic class was no where near the be-all-end-all of shipbuilding and was not an all too extraordinary milestone in ocean liner history, besides the Titanic disaster. It is as if people are so hung up on the romanticism surrounding the Titanic (and in turn its sister ships) that they fail to see the beauty and technological achievements of other ocean liners in an objective light.
I agree that Lusitania _and_ it’s sister Mauretania to be the first true superliners. They were the most impressive liners of the Edwardian era, a huge leap in liner history and an achievement for Britain and Cunard.
5:57 I don’t understand how Lusitania’s interiors were more unique than the Mauretania’s? They were unique amongst themselves. Both offered distinct styles that made them benefit one another. I personally prefer Mauretania because I feel that many of her rooms had more detail and richness than did her sister. I also prefer her exterior over Lusitania. I think that her forward superstructure had a more appealing shape, I like her white skylights and vents over the brown ones of Lusitania, the overhang of her A deck promenade and boat deck, and more.
Now here is my list of what I believe to be the greatest ocean liners of all time, in order:
1. *SS United States*
2. *Normandie*
3. *SS Great Britain*
4. *SS Great Eastern*
5. *Lusitania/Mauretania*
6. *Oceanic class 1870*
7. *Queen Mary*
8. *Queen Elizabeth*
9. *Kaiser class*
10. *Bremen/Europa*
My personal favorite liners, not necessarily the best:
- SS United States
- Lusitania/Mauretania
- Aquitania
- SS Great Eastern
- Queen Elizabeth
- Queen Mary
- And not necessarily the ship, but the _story_ of Titanic.
Thanks for the detailed, thoughtful response. I'll respond to a couple of these:
- I do like Aquitania's exterior, but I wouldn't describe it as beautiful. It may have been the trend at the time (although I would argue that forward superstructure was never intended to look the way it ended up), but that doesn't really make it any more or less beautiful.
- The reason I 'apologized' for liking Aquitania's interior is because Aquitania was the primary contemporary and rival of Olympic, so it makes sense to compare the two.
- When I said Lusitania's interiors were more unique, I meant that I think they were more unique among Cunard ships at the time. But this stance isn't a hill I'm going to die on.
The Great Big Move
I thought you apologized about the Aquitania/Olympic comment because you’d think you would have a mob of 12 year old Titanic fanatics roasting you in the comments lol. But I bet you would have if you hadn’t apologized lol.
Olympic - its story is pretty amazing. I liked this format and makes me think I should do one for my channel. I am approaching 500 videos and this might be a nice way to look back. Thanks for the idea.
i agree Olympic as well the story is so good considering what happened to its sisters
love your series very well done 10/10
Loved the new style!
Oh no not another one of those Watch Mojo Vids. Oh, wait a minute this is by the Great Big Move, his vids are always better than those money machine channels. Amazing work Charlie. :)
1. SS United States 2. SS Normandie 3. RMS Olympic 4. RMS Oceanic 5. Queen Mary 2
I love these vlog type videos! Keep up the good work!
If other people like them too then I'll start making them more often
Great list! You should do a video about the sinking of the Estonian cruiseferry m/s Estonia!
I might do that, but I noticed that there was recently a very popular video on the subject. I have to watch it, but I have a feeling I won't be able to out-do them on that particular topic.
@@TheGreatBigMove Would be interesting to see your take. Especially since this disaster isn't as well known in the US or Canada like other big ship disasters.
I'd have to say that my favorites are Lusitania and Titanic, but the video was really good, I have recently learned of the Atlantic and the story behind her.
If we’re talking purely about exterior aesthetics, then my favorite is probably the Olympic. Particularly in her 1911 layout. I just find that her fully open A deck, and her longer B deck promenade, give her a more symmetrical and more open feel if that makes sense. And I also just find her career so fascinating. She was the true bad ass of World War I.
I stayed on the Queen Mary in Long Beach when Disney was running it. You kind of got the feeling you were boarding the day before a trip. Walk around checking everything out, enjoy dinner. It was sweet. The cabin was classic. The cabin door still had a threshold to step over upon entry/exit. Love the old ocean liners 😎. Great video.
Comfy jumpers and ocean liners,
Subbed!
If we’re basing our choices on design purely my #1 choice would be the Oceanic II of 1899. Basing it off of design, story and everything else is Titanic. It’s such an iconic story that will probably never be forgotten to history. I also have a soft spot for Normandie, I love the Art Deco interiors, I don’t find them over the top or ugly. I also like Queen Mary and Great Eastern as well as Teutonic of 1889.
It's true that the Titanic is seen as "too popular" because of her story, but she also deserves credit for having been a gorgeous ship. That's why she's also my favorite along with Britannic.
The more I think about it, the more I realize that it is just a coincidence that Titanic is among the most beautiful ocean liners ever built and also happens to be the most famous for a totally different reason.
Harland and Wolf long considered the Olympic class liners as among their finest work. She and her sisters were indeed beautiful ships. As John Maxtone Graham said (when referring to Olympic), "she was in one breathtaking ship the last of the lean yacht like racers and the first of the floating palaces." They neatly avoided the grotesque Brunhilda like ponderousness of the Imperator and her sisters and managed to avoid some of the cluttered upper deck issues of Mauretania and Aquitania.
Just discovered you. Totally enjoying your videos . Looking forward to watching them all and for what is yet to come. 😊
Glad you like them!
Great vlog! I truly enjoyed this. New subscriber
Got to be SS Normandie- Nantais till I die
I too prefer the old ocean liners, beautiful ships, each with its own personality. Today's ships (apart from the queen mary 2) are simple square boxes, to hold as many people as possible. However, the Italian "michelangelo" and "Raffaello" were also beautiful ships.
Great video with interesting and uncommon information. I enjoyed hearing about some of the less publicized liners featured in your top 10 and the reasons for choosing as you did. While it was disappointing not to find the original Queen Mary in first place, I can well understand your choosing Normandie and Titanic. While the Normandie was visually stunning, the feeling aboard the Queen Mary is one of unrivalled contentment.
I’m not a major fan of ships, but this channel is starting to make me fascinated with ships.
I’m more of a trains and railroading guy, but this channel is slowly making me into ships.
I'm glad you're getting more into ships. I have the reverse problem and want to get more into railroads and I do intend to do that with this channel.
The Great Big Move Amazing! To start, I’d recommend checking out Canadian and US Railroads first. The most powerful and best locomotives came from the USA and Canada.
The Great Big Move Also, I got a recommendation for a video. A History on the Doña Paz?
I’m sorry but I have to make this reference, Thomas the Tank Engine Rolling Along
@@Train_Tok_Man It's requested a lot, so I probably will do a video on her.
My favorite Liner...."Minnow"
Gillhons island theme llayes in the backyard
Yo could do also a video about tour favourite warships or war-related ships, it can be interesting
That's a good idea!
@@TheGreatBigMove thanks for answering!
Great Job for this presentation ! One of my cousins worked as a Long Shore man in the 1940's , 1950's and 1960's in New York City . He said that of all the the Ocean liners he had been on, that Normandie was Number 1 and France (1962 version) Number 2. Queen Mary 1, and Queen Elizabeth 1. were next. Everything about these ships had Style and Class, down to the Bell Hops. Thank You for this Presentation. I have been looking for a list like this for along time !
I love your videos!
Have you ever considered making a video about the great passenger steamers of the great lakes? There were some spectacular ships back on the day!
honestly my favorite is the oceanic, I just love it.
Oceanic is very unique which only adds to how great she is.
Which one?
1, 2, or 3?
Great video love the channel
Great video. I took your advice and made my own top 5 ocean liners. Also, like you, some are because I really like the looks and lay out and some are partly because of their story. These are in no particular order, I'd be fine with any being my number 1. 1- SS United States, 2- RMS Titanic, 3- RMS Queen Mary, 4- RMS Windsor Castle (1959), 5- RMS Lusitania. On the good days I would have liked to have been on any of those. Thank you for your amazing videos and keep them coming!!
I knew the titanic was going to be you’re number one pick
Person "titanic was the best cruise ship ever 😍🥰"
Me in pure anger: ITS A OCEAN LINERRRRR
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Your channel is awesome
It was really cool to see the amazing SS Atlantic on your list! As with many others, I agree that Titanic earns a high spot on any list for many reasons, and it's understandable why some might disagree but we probably wouldn't be here talking about boats without her legacy.
I'm new to Ocean Liners, other than the childhood fascination with Titanic of course. So my few favorites for now are: Atlantic, the entire Olympic class, Nomadic, Baltic II, all 3 of the Lusitania class, Carpathia. Pretty much all the newbie faves, im sure my list will become more sophisticated with time. Love your channel.
Btw, please do a Video on Pricipessa Jolanda and Principessa Mafalda
You should do casualties of the queen mary
I have the same feelings with your choice of Titanic. Most people would think that choice is unoriginal but for me it really think it is the coolest ocean liner because of the classy and timeless interior it has (along with the Olympic class ships in general). I loved how each room in first class had a theme to it like it didn’t just reflect the British but other countries as well (Turkish baths, palace of Versailles theme in first class lounge etc). I think the only thing I would have changed on the titanic was the pool. If they had done a Roman pool house aesthetic similar to the Normandie that would have been awesome. Awesome video. I enjoying watching your content.
Excellent list, keep up the vlog videos, and the great historical content. If you are looking for videos, maybe a list of the top 10 ocean liners by history/and or technical specifications, possibly (because my favorite part of maritime history in this era are these ships more shall we say Marshall counterparts, andequally deserving of the title queens of the sea, that being the dreadnought battleships) maybe even a list of top 10 battleships or a video comparing say HMS Dreadnought technical achievements with that of Lusitania or Britannic or one of their contemporaries. This may be outside your scope and more inline with Drachinifel’s channel, but perhaps some videos on Kaiser Wilhelm de Grosser or the Carmania vs Cap Trafalgar
My list:
1-Queen Mary because of its service history (the Germans put out a bounty on her head of several thousand reichsmarks and the iron cross to any u boat captain who could sink her, none ever claimed it) and because I think she is a beautiful ship
2-Titanic-partly because of her history (it being a great social commentary on humanity’s arrogance in the face of nature and indeed god if you ascribe to that particular religion, being named titanic in a reference to the ancient enemies of the Greek a Gods, which I believe you pointed out in a video at some point and it was a stroke of genius I never considered) but also because she is the quintessential ocean liner, fast, but not so fast as to be uncomfortable, but not so garishly decorated either as to be ridiculous
3-Lusitania-again partly for her history, but also because she is kind of the HMS Dreadnought of the ocean liners, essentially making everything else obsolete on launch (though not as drastically)
4-SS United States/SS America (yes I know they aren’t sisters, I don’t care)-Great looking, fast, great and unique histories, and I’m American so a little dash of American pride
5-Aquatania-Pretty to look at great history, but a pretty bog standard career no spectacular war stories or (fortunately) sin kings
6-Britannic-again, history, but she looks good as a hospital ship and anything regarding Gallipoli is interesting
7-Normandie-very beautiful, very fast, but two marks against her, one is a not particularly note worthy career except for the blue riband (though there are designs from the US navy to convert her into an aircraft carrier during wwii which would have been hilarious) and the way she was lost
8-Andrea Doria-The story of her sinking and the subsequent rescue is very inspiring, and I think the ship is very pretty
9-Queen Mary 2-I think she looks better than Queen Elizabeth 2, something about QE2s funnel I don’t like, and I think that Queen Mary II is evidence that a cruise ship aesthetic can look good if effort is put in, also that whole last of her kind thing (the one problem with being the last of your kind, by and by there’ll be none left at all)
10-Imperator-Interesting story, also I love how German shipbuilding is pretty consistent from military to civilian, Imperator had stability issues and needed anti-role tanks, battlecruiser SMS Derfflinger had stability issues and needed anti role tanks, also I like her bridge better than avatar land or Bismarck (why was it recessed so much on vaterland and Bismarck, weight or other stability reason, styling, some other reason) and I actually like the figurehead, both stylistically, gives it a steampunk kinda look, and for the hilarious “we need to one up the British, so let’s put this ugly ridiculous thing on there because they never would and then to one up us they have to build a better ship” also they all have fascinating histories and are a good microcosm for how Germany was screwed at the end of wwi and how it eventually led to wwii
HRs
-Wilhelm Gustloff-not sure if this is technically a liner or a cruise ship, but it has a very interesting history and is a good example of the winners writing the history books, Lusitania sinking is illegal, Wilhelm gustloff, yeah no problem there, and while we are at it let’s just add in that the sinking of the General Belgrano was legal and inevitable. Also let’s all remember the deaths from this sinking and the lesser known concentration camp victims on board the cap arcona which was sunk by allied aircraft because they didn’t know who was on it. I also happen to think that apart from the massive swastika, the gustloff was a good looking ship (sorry if any of this is insensitive to say, but I am a history buff and I think that stories like Wilhelm a Gustloff and Cap Arcona should be remembered).
-Mauritania-pretty, interesting history, not pretty enough or interesting enough to make my top 10
-USS Wolverine and USS Sable-two paddle wheel lake cruise ships (yes not liners I know but you will love this) that were converted into training aircraft carriers during wwii to train pilots on carrier take off and landing and to this day are the only paddle wheel aircraft carriers
-SS Great Eastern for the sheer obserdness of it
-Oceanic purely because of your video, because if you didn’t make a video, I wouldn’t know anything about it
And of course a quick shoutout to carpathia, cap trafalgar, carmania and Kaiser wilhelm de grosse because hey neat history and good looks, but
Hope you like the list, sorry it’s so long winded but I am a passionate guy when it comes to history, especially maritime history and especially in this era. And I find your videos so fascinating. You are kind of like the Drachinifel or civilian ships of the period. Hats off to you, hopefully one day my channel can be as good as yours is, keep up the good work my friend. Stay safe and well, and I look forward to your next video.
No worries, I appreciate the enthusiasm and the detail. Thanks for sharing!
No problem
Interesting, I wear a hat near identical to that. Anyways great video!
Check out the s.s Monterey.
One of the most forgotten ocean liner of all time.
As I could rarely find info on it.
I know it existed because my grandfather was on it. Sadly he didn't get a souvenir from it.(money problems)
Also helping was wikipedia being the only website that has info of it. (Sadly very few pictures of it could be found)
So explore it when possible.
One of my favorite ships doesn't even have a Wikipedia on it and her sister ships so I feel your pain on little info
Pauline? Trivago. Damn
Do you at least remember the name
@@coolman6139 ya, its the RMS Connaught 1 (you can find her and her sisters mentioned under the Dublin city packet steamer company wiki). I found some old and obscure websites tho but still so little is known. Her sisters are Ulster, Munster, and Leinster all built in 1860, and apparently Connaught was the first ship to reach 18 knots and held it for some decades, all between 315-350 ft long, all were 4 funnel paddle steamers and got reduced to 2 in the 1880s and scrapped in the mid to late 1890s. So I guess there's some info but I'm not sure how much of it is true because these websites are like, from the 90s. I saw some mention of them in the Dublin library but I live in California
@@coolman6139 it also doesn't help when there was another paddle steamer built in 1860 named Connaught that sunk
Pauline? Trivago. The one i found( the one that didn’t sink)
The only info i could see was that it sailed in 1860,scrapped in 1890 and one held blue ribbon.
Everything else is a mystery.
Btw the post of it was from 2009
Link:www.papermodelers.com/forum/design-threads/2829-here-comes-irish-mail-rms-connaught-1860-a.html
New video! :D
Queen mary is my favourite!
Your a great moderator, just found your channel and are hooked. Maybe some videos of lighter than Air ( blimps) would be cool too.✌️
My favourite is really between Titanic and Olympic. But given their very different careers, I gave them their own titles which reflects how I feel about them. I also like the Queen Mary and the majority of what they planned for Britannic if she had entered service as an ocean liner. The Aquitania and Mauretania are on there because they were great ships too. So my list is as follows:
1. RMS Titanic (my special ship)
2. RMS Olympic (my favourite ship)
3. RMS Queen Mary/RMS Britannic
4. RMS Aquitania
5. RMS Mauretania
I couldn't decide which out of the Queen Mary and Britannic should occupy third place, so I decided to put them as joint third. And as you can see, given the Titanic is so well known for his tragic maiden voyage, it has the slightly superior position of special ship, over the Olympic. But the Olympic is still very much my favourite.
My top 10 favorite ocean liners are:
1. RMS Titanic [1912]
2. SS United States [1952]
3. SS Normandie [1935]
4. RMS Carpathia [1904]
5. RMS Lusitania [1907]
6. RMS Queen Mary [1936]
7. RMS Majestic [1921]
8. SS Imperator [1913]
9. RMS/HMHS Britannic [1916]
10. RMS Oceanic [1899]
@Prathyush Ivan I too like your top 10 ocean liners.
@@geethaa2672 Thanks
My favorite is Olympic, mostly because she rammed a u-boat to death in WW1 while also being a very elegant liner before and after, and having a wonderfully long and storied career. Since you seem rather taken with the Normandie in this video, maybe you should do a special episode for her! I'd love to learn more about the French Line and their ships. Well done!
Think I found my new favourite channel
Oh my- I thought this was years old yet its minutes old.
Being 107 sucks doesn't it hm
My list would be
1. United States
2. Titanic
3 Queen Mary
4 normandie
5 Lusitania
6 qe2
7 imperator
8 Queen Elizabeth
9 qm2
10 Mauretania
My most favorite ocean liner, no other than "RMS TITANIC"
On pure aesthetics, I'm going to put in a word for the original CP Empress class with the yacht like lines. As a second pick that someone will argue about, being a cargo liner, I actually have a soft spot for the double superstructure on RMS Magdalena.
I really like seeing liners that put conventional aesthetics aside and do something unique (Magdalena included).