Video není dostupné.
Omlouváme se.
Are Shoshana Bean and Scott Hoying Broadway stars? | All To Me | Opera Singer Reaction
Vložit
- čas přidán 3. 01. 2022
- Broadway star Shoshana Bean has everything you'd expect from a star of her caliber: energy, charisma, attitude, and solid musical chops, according to a News Nirvana article: nuvo.newsnirva... What do you think? I would love your thoughts in the comments. 🤗
Juilliard trained opera singer and voice coach, Maggie Reneé, reacts LIVE to Shoshana Bean and Scott Hoying | All To Me!
Just for you FREE vocal course "Sing Better Instantly:" skl.sh/3aHdSuy. Join our B-E-A-U-TIFUL Family on Patreon to influence and support channel content, connect with great people, and get personal replies from me: / maggierenee
You may also enjoy my reaction videos to:
Shoshana Bean "She Used to Be Mine" • Shoshana Bean "She Use...
Lea Salonga - On My Own (Les Misérables) • Opera Singer Reacts to...
Fly Like A Bird - Mariah Carey (COVER ft. Kiko & Adonis), 𝙼𝚘𝚛𝚒𝚜𝚜𝚎𝚝𝚝𝚎 • Opera Singer Reacts to...
Thank you to Richard for sponsoring this video! 💖🙏
‼️ To Sponsor Your Own Reaction: www.maggierene...
👉🏻 ALL THINGS MAGGIE: www.maggierene...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
💃🏻Maggie’s To-Do List for you:
✔️👍🏼 LIKE!
✔️💬 COMMENT!
✔️📺 SUBSCRIBE! bit.ly/2TRyEid
✔️🔔 RING THE BELL TO TURN ON NOTIFICATIONS!
✔️💖 SHARE WITH FAMILY AND FRIENDS
✨ SUBSCRIBER COUNT: 185,750✨
✨ SUBSCRIBER GOAL: 250,000 ✨
💖 Become my Patron: / maggierenee
🙏🏻 PayPal: www.paypal.com...
🙌🏼 Venmo: venmo.com/magg...
🏁 Become my Channel Member: / @maggiereneemusic
🎭 My Merch (support a great cause): teespring.com/...
🎁 My Wish List: www.maggierene...
🎵 ‘Sing Better Instantly" FREE Trial Singing Course: skl.sh/3aHdSuy
💿 Album: www.amazon.com...
Connect with me! ❤️
📲 Instagram: / maggiereneemusic
☀️ Tik Tok: / maggiereneemusic
👀 Twitch: / maggiereneemusic
👤 Facebook: / maggiereneemusicpage
💻 Website: www.maggierene...
📺 CZcams: / maggiereneemusic
💬 Discord: / discord
📩 Business Inquiries ONLY: Maggie@MaggieRenee.com
If you'd like to send me something (I usually open your lovely gits LIVE on my streams):
c/o Maggie Reneé 60 Lincoln Center Plaza No. 576 New York, NY 10023
EQUIPMENT
(I often get asked what equipment I use. These are affiliate links to items I use, so if you buy from here you support me too!)
My condenser mic: amzn.to/3ifKsHT
My dynamic mic: amzn.to/3A4Kzfi
My earphones: amzn.to/3fHl10j
My Interface: amzn.to/3lnSbWp
My guitar: amzn.to/3xbdJrm
My webcam: amzn.to/2WCoFSd
THANK YOU SO MUCH to my Top Patrons ❤️🤍💛💖💚!
Jerry, Mike N., Charles C., Sami K., Denny, John T., Dorky, Luna, Kate, Bart D, Jess G, Charles T, Dagfinn, Brian P, Jakob Ã, Trixie, Thomas H, Anderas S, Rose W, Richard W, Samuel B, Paul F., Lee W., The Alanyst
〰️〰️〰️〰️🔥FAQ 🔥〰️〰️〰️〰️
Occupation: Singer-Songwriter, Actress, Performer
Birthday: July 12
Education: The Juilliard School
Editing Software: FCP
About: Maggie Reneé is a singer, songwriter, vocal coach, CZcams, Twitch and TikTok content creator and Honors Graduate in Classical Voice from the prestigious Juilliard School. She has an original music Album out on iTunes, has a black belt in karate, and performs throughout the US and Europe with a goal of bringing joy to audiences all over the world through music that touches people's hearts!
Shoshana Bean and Scott Hoying - All To Me
Original video link: • Shoshana Bean and Scot...
#ShoshanaBean #ScottHoying #Reaction #MaggieReneé #AllToMe #Pentatonix
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS
![Opera Singer Reacts to Pentatonix - Bohemian Rhapsody [Queen]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/f3f94UXjS8g/mqdefault.jpg)
Who/what should I react to next? Just for you: a FREE vocal course "Sing Better Instantly:" skl.sh/3aHdSuy and there is still time to become my Patron for 2021 and beyond: www.patreon.com/MaggieRenee Thank you so much for your support! 🥳💖🙏
"Lose Us" by Rozzi ft. Scott Hoying 💥MIND BLOWING R&B Vibes💥
Also see Shoshana Bean on Superfruit's "Pop Goes Broadway" with Scott and Mitch. (Not to be confused with "Hip-Hop Goes Broadway")
Part of what I love about your reactions is your honesty. I know there are a few thousand Pentaholics who may disagree with your assessment of Scott’s vocal choices, but you are confident in giving your opinion- popular opinion be damned. Most “reactors” are not comfortable enough to criticize the choices/arrangements/vocals because they don’t want to alienate a particular fan base. Your critiques are smart and come from a place of trying to understand/figure out what you’re listening to and I love that! And yes…both of these two can flat out saaaaang!
I'm a long time Pentaholic and when I subscribed to PTX, they had around 25k subs. That being said, Maggie was spot on with this. I would much rather have a genuine critique then yet another fangirl appraisal of Scott. He has a great voice with many colors to it. He needs to read the song and dial his voice into what he's singing.
I appreciate you!! 🤗💖🎶
I love Scott's voice no matter how he sings. He is one of the best and does not need to change anything. I also like your voice.
Thank you for your lovely comment. Will you be there for my 195K Subscriber Celebration Live Stream tomorrow?
@@maggiereneemusic Yes Maggie I will be there. Congratulations!
😊
Maggie, This song with Shoshana Bean and Scott Hoying's is amazing. Shoshana and Scott's voices blended together is breathtaking to hear. They should do some more songs together because their voices are amazing together.
😍 I LOVE Scotts voice! I LOVE that he sings where he is most comfortable!!
I LOVE that all PENTATONIX members have a different tamber to their voice making the group FABULOUS!
He has such an extensive range his baritone is YUMMY!
His bass is AMAZING his falsetto is INSANE!
You do you Scotty😘
Thank you for your comment. Did you like the new Pentatonix video reaction I recently posted? Will you be there for my 195K Subscriber Celebration Live Stream tomorrow?
Great reaction! I haven't commented to your reactions before, but I would like to add some things. I completely agree with your take on Scott's sound. My interpretation is he may have been holding back at the beginning in order to really accentuate the dynamics of building to the crescendo. Is it possible that for him he sounds "more up front" when he is holding back because he has such a powerful voice? With that said, you must complete the trifecta of Scott's big three duets by reacting to "Lose Us" with Rozzi Crane. This is part of her Bad Together CD from about 3 years ago. You will love it! It shows a completely different side to Scott, and Rozzi's voice is so unique. You gotta check it out!! Again, love your reactions!!
I think he is trying to sound held back or emotionally restrained with that sound. When he works with Ben or the other members of PTX they just tell him what sounds better. He likes that sound more than other people like it.
Thank you for your lovely comment. 🤗💖 Would love to see you on Patreon www.patreon.com/MaggieRenee?
Maggie, I agree with the placement/ tone comments you made. I feel like I’ve heard him do that before when he was trying to sing quieter and maintain balance, though I can’t think what a good example would be offhand. IMO he seems to have better placement when singing louder.
As for what to watch , if you’re looking for more of these Shoshana and Scott- there’s a Superfruit episode that has Shoshana, Scott and Mitch, it’s in the same style as the Frozen video. Also, speaking of Mitch, have you watched him sing Defying Gravity? Scott sings Glinda’s part hilariously and Mitch is Mitch singing Elphaba. If you want more Scott watch “I should tell ya momma on you”. It’s older so he sounds young but it’s still good.
I enjoy your reactions, keep it up! I’d join Patreon, but I just started grad school.
Thank you for your lovely comment. Will you be there for my 195K Subscriber Celebration Live Stream tomorrow?
I agree. I think it's either something he was taught when doing choir to bring his voice in so it doesn't outshine everyone or something he picked up from someone around them. He can sing gently in a different key without doing that same thing. When he's singing with others he often seems to fit himself where needed; I think of him as something of a chameleon because he can blend in where needed and change his tone to fit. But either it's something he thought he had to do or someone told him to do in order to hold back from the power he naturally seems to have/needs to use at that area in his range. It's like he's tensing the wrong thing up when trying to sing quieter and it pushes it to a different position. Could also be where his voice had been maturing before he'd figured out how to handle it. I'm going to be listening out for it now lol.
I will say his voice has definitely matured in the last 2-3 years, so idk if he got a new vocal coach. But there was an episode of his & Rozzi's podcast (it may actually have been he one with Shoshana on, I'm not sure, but the whole series is worth listening too, honestly) where he talks about learning to use his voice more efficiently because he always used to give 110% and it was fatiguing his nvocal cords with the amount of touring, I suspect it was a bad habit he developed for the Sing-off when he put so much pressure on himself for them to stand out. So he was talking about learning to reduce the intensity but improving the technique. It's called _Ugh! You're So Good! _ and I can't recommend it enough they have some incredibly interesting people on it along with the two of them just being hilarious and interesting together.
I often think when Scott does a duet, that he has a tendency to hold back so his partner shines brighter. I just don't think he sings with his ego.
totally agree - and he's never identified himself as a show-tunes vocalist - I think it's wonderful that he collabs with artists outside his "pocket", encouraging mutually beneficial cross over
That is possible, but of all duet partners, he most certainly does not need to hold back for Shoshana Bean (who in my opinion is one of the best female vocalists out there right now)-- they both have outrageous voices, but I would put my money on Shoshana in terms of sheer power. Personally, I think most of Scott's tendencies are learned stylistic behaviors -- he has a tendency to raise his larynx, singing on thinner vocal folds with a narrowed twangy sound. My guess is he started off singing musical theater and adapted his voice towards a more Justin Timberlakey sound when he realized he enjoyed singing R&B and pop runs, giving him the stylistic choices he makes today. That type of style wouldn't suit "The Prayer" so he adapted his sound to fit that song.
I love this song. And these two together are stunning together. We need a cover of you singing this, and add it to your song list :D Great job Maggie!
LOL! Thank you! 🤗💖
Very insightful commentary as always. Great job.
Shoshana, Shoshana, Shoshana, cannot get enough of her, she is so brilliant and makes you FEEL everything she sings. And Scott is always a favourite.
Can we pleeeeeease get more shoshanaaaaa!!
I am not a musician, but I hear Shoshanna doing the same thing Scott does with his...bring the vocal forward into a nasally place in parts. I know exactly what you mean about Scott's voice. Scott has been singing his whole life and I have a strong suspicion that he does this not because someone taught him, but because that is a stylistic choice that he's made in the process of discovering "his voice" throughout the years. I feel like what you mentioned is an opinion, a very valid one. I can see how someone could be turned off by that. But, the way you said it made it sound a bit condescending towards Scott. Like, he doesn't know better and he's actually doing something wrong. Like it was a mistake instead of a choice. That's how it felt to me. Still love your reactions!
Thank you for your comment. Will you be there for my 195K Subscriber Celebration Live Stream tomorrow?
I agree with you on Scott’s vocals here. 💯
Beautiful song! 🎵 🎶🥰 Amazing reaction Maggie!
So glad you enjoyed! 🤗💖
I subscribed bc I instantly trust the taste/wisdom of anyone who TRULY appreciates the wonder of Shoshana Bean! :) I absolutely love Scott (& Pentatonix) as well - tho I totally agree w your assessment re: the pop sound! - and this video is a beauty, but no one's vocals move me like Sho's. This song of hers is so good. You should totally check out the VERY flirty and improv-y performance of it that she does w Avery Wilson...let's just say it's a ride! ;)
Welcome to my channel and thank you for your lovely comment. 🤗💖 Would love to see you on Patreon www.patreon.com/MaggieRenee?
Love your reactions. Never be afraid to express your opinion. While everyone has their own, you are much more qualified to critique a musical composition than most of us.
It's so beautfull I love🤩
I would take timing into consideration with your perspective. I think this video was made several years ago. The prayer was very recent. So it does seem like he’s been growing and applying new technique over time. It’s interesting to see the evolution.
Please react to her performance of “make it rain” at the Ace theater
Love this one.
YAY!! 🤗💖
1. How have I not heard this?
I.tj8nk Shoshanna would be epic in Rythym and Blues but her voice is incredible
Happy New Year to you!
Great reaction and analysis as always.
Thank you for your lovely comment. Will you be there for my 195K Subscriber Celebration Live Stream tomorrow?
Will try to be, if for a little while. It's final exam time and I have so much to grade!
😊
Thanks for this great reaction. I had not heard of this.
Thank you for your lovely comment. Will you be there for my 195K Subscriber Celebration Live Stream tomorrow?
@@maggiereneemusic yassss I will be there.
He just lifted his larynx added a bit of twang to lighten the sound as to not come in way too strong on his verse and give the song somewhere to go dynamically. Had he done it softly but with his full on tone it wouldn’t have suited that section as nicely it would’ve sounded heavier. Scott is a soul singer. Regardless of genre lines. That boy has soul! It’s all about playing with tones and sounds. Not everything needs to be in the same tone or in heavy full on tones all the time. Granted I’m not a huge pentatonix fan. I like them but I don’t and won’t go out of my way to listen to them like at all. But he clearly has amazing technique. And everyone of course can grow technically speaking. But let’s let people express the music as well without everything needing to be technical. Also shoshana sings in the same forward and nasal placement sometimes so I think it’s more of you don’t like his tone when he does it vs her. No hate here at all by the way. I love you and your content. Just wanted to give my opinion.
Thank you for your comment. Did you like the new Pentatonix video reaction I recently posted? Will you be there for my 195K Subscriber Celebration Live Stream tomorrow?
Angel Johnson. You are absolutely right.
Maggie you should listen to one of Diana Ankudinova's new songs
I can recommend "Can't help falling in love from Elvis" or a song called "Crow"
I think you would love them
Thank you for your comment. 🥰 Did you like my new reaction video to Diana Ankudinova I just posted?
If you like this listen to Rozzi featuring Scott hoying lose us
this song reminds me a lot of "Somewhere Only We Know" - Keane (ft. Max Schneider & Elizabeth Gillies)" just in the harmony's between the 2 main singers.
You put into words why I only like this song instead of love it. Thank you Maggie
Thank you for your lovely comment. 🤗💖 Would love to see you on Patreon www.patreon.com/MaggieRenee?
1 Shoshana, natural unabashed alto, with nice upper range without the modern whininess........ 1 Mags....nat Soprano.... and of course the brows
Wait. Shoshana is literally a Broadway star. Is that the joke here (in that Headline)?
Makes it sound like a winny box when he does the technique you don't like
When will you react to Brazilian singer Gabriel Henrique? and Chakra Khan singing Tenesse Whisky?
Thanks for that breakdown. I've had the same thoughts about Scott's voice but didn't have the musical language to articulate it, even to myself. On the whole I think his voice has developed well over time but he has one other habit which I find grates a little, not just with him but with others whom I've heard it in over my whole life and it has always caused an inner cringe every time I hear it. Again language becomes a barrier in explaining it but I would describe it as inserting an 'h' before his vowels. It feels like an affectation. It's a minor thing and probably peculiar to myself because I like his voice in enough other respects that it doesn't stop me enjoying him. Mitch also does it sometimes but it feels to me that it's more intentional when he does it - a choice for colouration rather than a characteristic and it doesn't break the flow for me in the same way. Then again, maybe I'm just weird. Well there's no maybe about it but I mean in this particular case.
Hi Maggie 😊 please react to "ONE SWEET DAY" of BUDAKHEL Ft. Katrina Velarde 🥰 thank youuu!
OH MY GOD, THANK YOU. I love Scott. LOVE. His tone can be so bloody gorgeous but there's this spot in his upper range that when he needs to be quiet he goes into that nasally tone you noted. It's gotten better in recent years, but I also think that he's being set differently in Pentatonix's arrangements to take advantage of his belt and the tone in his lower register. I also think in this particular performance he overdid the runs in that first verse. Shoshana was quite restrained with her adlibs and it just felt a bit off. My two cents!
Thank you for your comment. Did you like the new Pentatonix video reaction I recently posted? Will you be there for my 195K Subscriber Celebration Live Stream tomorrow?
Is Scott trying to match Shoshana's style or something like that? It would sound better if he did not try to be 'poppy' as you called it. Duets are best when they complement rather than match. Nit stll a good video. And a good reaction and analysis. Good editing job as well.
Thank you! 🤗💖🎶
Love this song, but could I recommend the same song with Avery Wilson
I agree that lower female voices are more beautiful, rich and can do more things, unfortunately i am a soprano, tho. The natural placement of my voice is something that can sing Ariana Grande easily, shame i don't like it.
I get what you say from that nasal pop sound, i also don't like it, idk why it became so popular. I don't sing with this, and just now I'm realizing that this is what I find weird hearing myself, lol.
Thanks, came for the reaction, got an insight about my singing technique.
He definitely chooses that lighter sound. I think maybe even sometimes himself likes to sound lighter. I can always tell when he does it but he sounds SO good in his natural baritone ranges. Whether just low notes or his belting. His tone there is perfect. Same reason why I think he avoids singing in a mix belt. Generally he sings chesty or head. Very rarely does he mix much in his belts. Only the Waving Through The Window have I heard him mix. The quality is lighter and not his style as much
MAGGIE!MAGGIE!MAGGIE!MAGGIE!MAGGIE!MAGGIE!MAGGIE! Go listen to some Eskimo Callboy (any of their 3 latest sons - Hypa Hypa, We got the moves & Pump It) YOU WILL LOVE IT!
Thank you for your suggestion! 😊
1
My son likes Shiba twain she does that a lot in her music. She has some great sings and voice but I don't like the winning.
Should be Shania
I agree with you about the way it was recorded. It's too bad because it detracts from the song.
Im a massive PTX fan and never take well to anyone critisising them but you were so constructive and your demonstration and explanation had me agreeing with you. Love your reactions but more "cheese muffins" please.
The thing Scott did here that drives me nuts is the hand-gesturing. I know a capella singers tend to do a lot of needless hand gestures because they don't have instruments, maybe, and it looks kind of lame to just stand there and sing? But look at Shoshana and her meaningful gestures, over her heart, reaching out, etc....more like someone who's done Broadway and has to act with her whole body instead of sing a capella. Maybe? I dunno. But it really stood out in this song to see him be the ONLY one doing it instead of all five Pentatonix doing it. :)
Thank you for your comment. Did you like the new Pentatonix video reaction I recently posted? Will you be there for my 195K Subscriber Celebration Live Stream tomorrow?
Scott is literally known for his hand gestures when he sings, he can't help himself. It must have killed him to keep his hands still in the Say Something video (he was holding onto that chair for dear life as he is so used to singing with his hands).
Maggie… I wonder why Shoshana chose to sing with Scott instead of sooo many other amazing singers. Surely she knows his styles and flaws but loves his passion and that he is different from a classical singer. Perfectly performed songs often lack interest and can be boring to the listener. Can explain why many classical singers can’t sell their music and come and go. Scott has been around 11 years and continues to get better and better. He touches my soul. So does Shoshana.
Sorry, but to my ears, Ms. Bean is out of tune most of the time. Good female singers to me ... Eva Cassidy (RIP), Rebecca Lovell , Natalia Tsarikova and/or Stefani J.A. Germanotta, among others.
Thanks for your comment. Did you like the new reaction video I just posted to Powerwolf?
@@maggiereneemusic You are the best Maggie.
😚💖