Case 167: Jai, Tyler & Bailey Farquharson
Vložit
- čas přidán 5. 03. 2021
- In Australia, Father’s Day falls on the first Sunday of September and is typically a time for families to gather together and celebrate. But on Father’s Day in 2005, the small Victorian town of Winchelsea was rocked by the news that a local man named Robert Farquharson had driven his three young sons - Jai, Tyler and Bailey - into a dam...
---
Narration - Anonymous Host
Research and writing - Erin Munro and Milly Raso
Creative direction - Milly Raso
Production and music - Mike Migas
Music - Andrew D.B. Joslyn
For all credits and sources please visit casefilepodcast.com/case-167-jai-tyler-bailey-farquharson - Zábava
Am I the only one who has literally watched all episodes of Casefile 😂☺️
Makes my night shifts better 🙏🏽
I’ve listened to every episode and anxiously wait for new ones to drop. I also listen to the other podcasts produced by the Casefile crew. They’re all so well done.
Same here, as per both of you 👍😎
I'm the 4th one whose listened to them all I guess! 😁Makes my 12hr shifts go by so much quicker!
Depending on the clip, I catch myself gasping or just making disgust sounds an have to take a quick look around to make sure no ones heard me. (Not supposed to wear earbuds at work lol)
Nearly
@@learobinson4450 what other ones do they do?
If I might suggest a case to cover, On Sept. 24, 1973, 11-year-old Amy Burridge and her 18-year- old sister, Becky Thomson, were thrown from the Fremont Canyon Bridge near Casper. Becky was raped before being thrown from the bridge. Amy died; Becky survived. Two local men, Ron Kennedy and Jerry Jenkins, were swiftly arrested. With your care and consideration I know you would do justice to this case. Thanks for all your work.
🥺
Disturbing that there are other cases so similar to this one here!
Is there a bad k written about this? It seems I read a book with these people exact circumstances.
@@shirleythompson2068 y😢😢
I saw Robert Farquharson when I was in jail back in 2009. I was on my way to see the prison doctor and a screw opened the electronic door for me but some other screws came through a side door and slammed the door in my face because they were escorting him to medical. He was under protection and was escorted around the jail by 3 screws. I could clearly see him through the glass but I wasn't allowed near him as I was a mainstream prisoner and he was in the protection unit. He would not have lasted long if they put him in mainstream. Someone would have put a few holes in him on his first day.
And he would clearly deserve it!
@@ANDREA-kk2gx I saw some guys bashed for similar crimes. One paedophile had his jaw and arm broken. Then they put out cigarettes on his face
Wth are screws?? Guards, bloaks, what? Lol
@@bekahward8710 My apologies. The word 'Screw' is the jail slang word for guard. I should have realized that not everyone would know that. Yes he was being escorted by 3 male guards and one of them quite forcefully pushed me through a door and slammed it on me as Robert Farquharson wasn't allowed near other prisoners.
@@SammiCurr I love you Aussies! 🦘
Unfortunately, Cindy died today at age 50. (May 13,2022) She is with her boys. 💔 I came here to hear her story.
Yes how sad she never got over losing those boys i lite a candle for her that day and for her 3 little boys . rest in peace Cindy you are now with your babies 😇😇😇😇
That news was so heartbreaking I guess the only comforting thing regaring this case is that now Cindy is with her 3 boys.
Oh no! Her poor children and husband! Tragedy on top of tragedy. It's all heartbreaking.
and also her two other children she had with her now widowed husband. So very young for Cindy to lose her life, may she rest in peace.@@malovela
When she passed she had two young sons. She died suddenly in her home. She had found religion and became a Jehovah's Witness. Mercifully that got her through the days until she passed. May she rest in peace with her three sons.
A chilling tale told with Casefile's trademark panache. God rest Jai, Tyler and Bailey. I hope Cindy rebuilds her life with her new family and that some day in the future the memories of her dearly beloved dead children brings her only joy without the pain.
Karma caught up with "Sain" Cindy.
@@Billy-ng4ihWhat did Cindy do wrong?
I read this story, it was so sad for those little boys, the father was a selfish tosser. Great narration as usual, love your channel
The narrator has such a great voice and pitch, he is going to get a permanent job in commercials.
Great episode, thank you. My heart goes out to everyone touched by this senseless tragedy 💔
I have seen this story told 2 ways. Crimes that shook Australia and 60 minutes Australia. Your narration is complete and thorough. I listened to the case of that awful Von Einem and I mk also listened to John Newman. I love your reports. Excellent work. I am hooked.👏👏👏👏👏 Kudos.
I followed the case and later read Helen's book. A shocking crime of revenge. Those innocent children and the betrayal of their father. So sad to read here of Cindy's passing , her new children must be devastated.
As a Australian as well as a Victorian, I kinda remember this case. Great job mate. Keep up the good work
Those that do harm to kids need to be fayed alive. I love kids the simple fact that they show us how to be childish they remind me of what we once where with there innocents. If everyone remembered there childish instinct instead of stressing and over doing everything I think we could all live a little bit happier. R.i.p little kiddos 💕 hope you's are having fun
true, never MURDER anyone, ESPECIALY KIDS AND THE ELDER.
This story broke my heart.....rest in peace little angels.....
You should see their photos. They were adorable. That poor mother, Cindy. She ended up marrying Michael. Thank goodness he has children. Robert Farquharson is plain disturbed. Awful.
The question "why would a man committ such a cruel act?" has no answer.
Three things their genes, their upbringing, and their environment make us who we are.
Well he did it for love, as he said. The other guy said he did it for the money he was promised. Which could mean maybe she had learned of a life insurance policy on her parents, so with all of them dead she’d get the money. Which she’d share with her beloved and their friends.
OMG I am such an idiot. I didn’t realize the case had changed from the one I was listening to!!!!!🤦🏾♀️
@@KenyanBunnie :) no worries, this case is really perplexing in terms of understanding what was wrong with the perpetrator I think. Really good episode!
@@KenyanBunnie it takes more than money or an insurance policy back to what I said the a person's make up "their genes " makes your brain the way it is together with nurture from the parents and environmental factors.
Thank you. Love all your work ❤️❤️🇨🇦
Thanks for the upload.
I just love your channel! Best wishes!
Another fine episode keep up the great work xxx
Pleasantly surprised to see this at this time of night. Thanks 👌
How good ay
Thank you.
you really are a hero Steven Moules, and have been every day since. I admire the man you turned out to be Steve. (im yr ex sister in law)
Thanks, Mate 👍
You deserve way more subscribers 💕
I think most of the listeners are on the other platforms like Spotify or Apple
@@89RealThe Thanks for the info I never thought of that 👍
@@shirleythompson2068 I primarily listen to it thru Spotify but still will listen through CZcams now and then. A while ago, there was a podcast service app (I can't remember the name but it was a paid subscription one) that they would exclusively release episodes a week early, but I don't think they have that anymore.
@@89RealThe thanks again 😉👍
I think this is a highlight of the terrible child support and divorce problem in the world. In cases of divorce men basically lose every thing they ever built up in life, and the system unfairly favors women while telling men that they have to deal with it.
This worked back when women didn't work and men were able to support a family of 3 with a single job alone. But in a world where women and men both have to work just to keep themselves alive, trying to demand everything a man has and most of his paycheck is cruel.
Maybe if they were forced to share the house and all of their belongings after the divorce while allowing joint custody then this wouldn't be an issue
If you're unconscious, you can't steer around a tree.
If the car was underwater and the son opened a door, there would be no way to close it again against the water pressure.
Robert was a petty, vicious narcissist.
Just found this channel ! Good place 👍
Hey, Ho casefile great podcasts No 1in my book thank you.PS any chance of doing one about Ned Kelly.
well told
I find it a little strange that Greg’s wife has no recollection of Greg telling her what Robert had just told him that same night. Surely his wife would have remembered hearing something like that 🤔 Did guilt help her to forget? Or did Greg not tell her?
Also, Greg’s recollection a month after first going to the police about Robert is very alarming. He recalled Robert telling him he was going to kill his kids, he hated them (not sure if he meant his kids or his wife and New man Steven) and was going to drive his car into the water and drown them. Why didn’t Greg tell the police the same night Robert had told him what he was going to do to them? If find that very strange to understand.
However, it Was proven a conversation happened between Greg and Robert that night, but, I’m wondering if Greg was actually recalling what Robert had said or had he in fact just heard what had happened to them and then literally began to believe he’d heard it from Robert himself. After all, it stated that Greg was in a very bad way after the children were killed so perhaps he was so affected by it that he believed he’d been told this by Robert himself.
I thiught so, too, especially when his story got more and more detailed. Memory is a very unreliable witness at best… also, Robert seems to cunning to tell someone. Quite the opposite, I suspect he was faking the coughing fits weeks before the deed as a means of an alibi.
I agree with you. I don’t believe Greg.
you re a moron then@@jennifer60515
I do believe Greg, I think he thought that Robert was mouthing off with no intention to actually do the deed. He had no reason to fabricate his story and quite a bit to lose in the way of emotional turmoil.
He actually received a lesser sentence for his testimony against Robert. @@wendymckay5216
They seriously think his name should be there? No fucking way.
We need the death penalty brought back in Australia.
Never will I understand this. Who is it that thinks the person that dumped them is the only fish in the sea first of all that you would get that obsessed with wanting to get back at them. I would have zero interest in somebody who no longer wanted me for whatever the reason. Not saying I wouldn't have a grief period or whatever but what connection could he have ever actually had to his Three sons if he would be willing to hand them over so easily to death, somehow already knowing that it wouldn't bother him at all that it would only hurt her with a pain beyond all pain. It's like Chris Watts except this fine specimen of a man Robert here wanted to punish and watts didn't necessarily want to punish shannan he just wanted all of them gone.
My point is I do not understand how you can go through the motions of loving your children, all those millions of minutes you spend with them pretending to love them? I don't get it I don't believe either Watts or this guy or any other family annihilator ever spent one second feeling any grief over the children they killed. There was no loss at all for them it was just, so yeah the kids are gone so what, what the hell do I care? What is so broken inside these people, that they can spend years acting like and seeming like they love their children~then dispose of them so cruelly knowing the suffering and wants his case, watching the suffering and still continuing on with it..... Was never a moment of suffering the loss.
I guess some people's hearts are incapable of breaking, it's just the ego, the insult to the ego, the rejection. All they care about is themselves. They don't even seem to care that they are not going to get away with it
Yeah agreed it’s madness isn’t it like they must think what happens if I get caught il be in prison forever and hated by everyone and my life will be over ? I honestly think watts thought he would get away with it
Needs more commercials
what a piece of garbage..the oldest kid was just 1 year older than me...absolute heartbreaker this one
Little Bailey wanted to stay with his Mom on that day… details like that never leave my mind. How it must have tormented Cindy in all the years since that she didn't give in to him…
Anyway, now imagine that asshole being an American. Once freed he could not have been prosecuted for that same crime again, right? Such nonsense!!!
yes, I thought of that little boy of 2, wanting to remain with his Mum, it just leapt out at me, this whole case is beyond heart breaking.
Wrong!!! He won his appeal with a right to a new trial. If that happened in the U.S., there would be a new trial.
Way too many damn commercials now
I don’t believe the conversation with Greg occurred as he said. Perhaps the first part that he reported to the cops, but not all the embellishments he typed and added. I don’t buy that.
Edit: I just got to the part about Greg’s drunken brawl, and I am even more convinced that he made that stuff up to have his own criminal charges reduced. I’m just not positive that Robert killed his kids.
He killed his children over a fucking car?? Jesus Christ
I wonder if there's a psychological profile that was done on Robert.
🌹❤️🌹❤️🌹
Can anyone tell me where casefile 55 is?
They took it down because, as they said, it was somehow considered offensive to the dreaded LBGT (or was it LGBT?) community. I think they were going to overhaul it and put it back online. Anyway, even though my last sentence seems rather unfriendly, I am very sensitive to picking up these things, and I do not remember finding anything ever offensive in any of the cases of this excellent channel… hence my ire at those LB-whatevers for keeping me from re-listening that episode.
@@ulalaFrugilega I'll have it in my archive if you want it - I download but don't delete.
Good lord these ads. I love listening to your videos. You put in a lot of research and hard work and develop such an amazing piece of work. Then, in the middle of the plot: Here’s a useless piece of crap product you don’t need but I have to mention because they’re sponsoring this channel. 🤦🏻♂️ Can you get them all out of the way up front or put them all at the end so that we can enjoy your videos without having to be interrupted by these ridiculously stupid ads? Thanks for your consideration. Your videos rock!
Hi, greets from Poland. Lovin’ Casefile podcast mainly due to great narration and solid content. I do have strong doubts in Robert’s guilt because evidence presented by prosecution are shaky. Greg’s testimony (in exchange for court favors) that his wife couldnt recall and Bob’s belief of missinterpretation. 200 something degree steringwheel turn. That lady’s testimony proving not sure what. Court handling of this case for example defence doctor’s statement of having 15 cases in last decade of severe cough leading to passing out overturn by presecution doctor’s statement that he never heared of such thing or another example of asking Bob if he was the only one in that car able to turn ignition key and subsequently staging his arogance by planting in his lips statment he didnt produce. Above all in regards of ignition key: i remember in my first car i was able to turn this key with my knee when lifting up my feet. Not sure about parking brake placement but if in centre it could have been easly engaged by passenger. What do you think people?
I think you're right. But I mostly feel suspicious about Robert conveniently telling Greg exactly what he was going to do. Not just to Cindys children, but also his own
You just keep resisting Cindy.
He will be released when hes 60 and will he have his famiky house to return to. He had paid the morgage.not sure if property entitlement is forfeighted when people are imprisoned. His name would be on the property tittle
Jai is pronounced 'Jye'...it was a popular name in the post-WWII era.
I have no problem with suicide and I try not to judge but the person has no right to take another’s life just because they want to die. It is not their responsibility to make that choice for the others. To be blunt, one should die alone.
I din't know what that got to do with anything here, but imo, one should really BE alone before committing suicide, else it's a bastard move against those who remain.
He had no intention of committing suicide. It was murder all the way.
This one makes me feel a little uneasy. While there’s clearly a chance that he did it, there’s also no concrete evidence that he’s guilty. Idk dude
Agreed. It seems like he could’ve easily blacked out and been in shock.
Guilty ass of a dad
When will people stop having children with people whom, deep down, they're not sure they should be with?
If you don't feel with every fibre of your being that you want to be with a person for the rest of your life, that your relationship with them has every chance of being good for both of you, and that they'll be the kind of parent you want for your children... then don't have children with them. PLEASE.
It really seems like the cops didnt think they had enough to successfully prosecute, and therefore fabricated some 'evidence'.
However, he belongs in jail. Even if he was telling the truth, it was very negligent homicide to continue driving after recently experiencing cough syncope, and if you are coughing hard enough to induce that you SHOULD pull over immediately, not doing so IS endangering lives. Whether it was murder or negligent homicide he does deserve punishment for killing those darling boys.
I'm going to say this. Its "convenient" that a lady remembered the car 'after' the case was overturned. Seemed like the prosecutors set that up, just like they setup Greg. Greg just filled in details after more than 1 month and more months. Its bullshit. He just happened to start writing and then remembers specific sentences that he left out. I call bullshit on alot of it. He is and may be guilty but the way they tried to get him convicted was just to add any damn thing to it. Dawn full of shit and the prosecutors told her to say that so they had another witness. They figured the first trial had a witness that got him convicted and then they couldn't use that witness so they needed a nee one. Robert getting on the stand the second time was fucking nuts. He should have shut the hell up.
Killing the kids would have made things worse for him.
What a tragic story! I do question why Cindy had 3 children with such a man if she never loved him, and if indeed he wasn't the supportive father he should have been. After the first baby, it should have been a sign what sort of dad he was. Those poor little lads..... They didn't have a chance.
I should have skipped the description of the boys in the car ! I feel horrible now 😞
I'm glad I read the comments first. I'm still disturbed from hearing about the most horrific prolonged (ie 6 years) torture of a child that I've ever heard of and am not ready for any more yet. I'll skip this episode. I hope you feel better soon :c
@@Vexarax woa, where did you here that? Pray tell, so I can avoid it!
I guess it took her 10 yrs and 3 kids to realize the guy wasnt for her.thats typical, there's always 2 sides to every story and the mother gets to throw all the rocks.Be careful who you breed with you will be stuck with the consequences.
Riveting and worse than any fiction.
Those towns in Aussie-land have names that sound like god damn India or Pakistan! 😂😂😂
(My thoughts continued) Why would he killed the kids? It's a stupid motive to kills his kids to have her suffer. She still will live in the house and still be married to the other man. That doesn't help make him feel better.
He would have been looked at for the kids death and that's not going to hurt her but make him feel worse and possibly lose his freedom while she out being semi happy. That's just stupid. It doesnt make sense.
If his motive was to hurt her he had a better chance to just kill her and get custody of the kids.
Ever heard of Medea? Killing the kids to get at the Ex is a very old form of revenge.
@@ulalaFrugilega I know that but man that's some sick stuff. No same person could look at a child and do that to spite a parent. That's crazy
@@ulalaFrugilega but it does happen.
@@crowncreative9139 Medea was rather crazy. If you read her story, you know why, too.
Love this channel hate the adds
Call me crazy but I'm not convinced the verdict is right.
Which one?
Pp
It seems like a father in shock, nothing more
In shock after murdering his babies
Woohoo! Am I first?
With the case being innocent children you wanna brag about being first? At least pay some respect.
Those boys deserve to be respectfully acknowledged every time this story is seen.
Grow up.
4th, 😂
Grow up....kids died and you care about your placement.
Shit fuck.
Who fuckin cares if you didn’t get first you really wanna carry on while these kids lost their lives?.....shame on you.
I’ve had coughs in my life where I thought I was going to black out. Horrible in shock father who is not guilty .
Love these podcasts. However, do yourself a favour and avoid the poor grammar and incorrect vocabulary that is so common in the USA. The part tense of "dive" is "dived" and not "dove"
The schools in America teach Common Core curiosity of Bill Gates. Enough said.
I dont know the CZcams had a new function. Some randoom person, corecting the vocabulary of the narrator and the grammers of da subscribers in the coment sextion. Brilliant idea. If only it was a paid job. You would have just made a million dollars reading my comment and fixing my errors. 😆
What is "part tense"?
Oops! Typo. Meant to be past tense.
I mainly listen to casefile because of how the anonymous host talks.
She was never in love with the guy yet she had 3 kids with him, she is responsible for his actions
😂😂😂 WTF
Hey come on now mate....that’s a bit rude.....unless your an expert you really shouldn’t judge the story that way.
Please check yourself...
No numb nuts, it's ALL on him.
@@dragonladygray1335 exactly....
@@nickyv2276 yep!
My heart broke for Cindy. Now I hear that she as passed away. As sad as it is, that Cindy passed so young, at least she is now reunited with her babies. 💙💙💙🩷