Amadeus -- What Makes This Movie Great? (Episode 99)
Vložit
- čas přidán 4. 06. 2024
- Sign up for my newsletter. CZcams channel updates, written reviews, and exclusive content -- free! -- eepurl.com/hbfI6v
Watch movies freely and securely with Atlas VPN. Sign up now for just $1.39/month!
atlasvpn.go2cloud.org/aff_c?of...
Amadeus is perhaps the greatest musical feast ever, a massive production with many staged operas in the late 18th century style. Written by Peter Singer and directed by Milos Foreman, starring Tom Hulce and F. Murray Abraham, the movie is about Mozart, the gifted composer who had a hard time earning money, spending it wisely, producing music for those who cared, and acting civilly towards others.
The movie, however, is a frame narrative about his old rival Salieri, an envious composer whose star has faded and who knows that Mozart was the greatest composer he'd ever see. The movie highlight Salieri's apparent relationship with God, whom he blames for giving the great gift of ethereal music to a vulgar man instead of to a pious and titled person such as himself.
This video reviews and analyzes Amadeus for what the movie is about, helping you to think about some of its major ideas, and how it creates meaning through its cinematic choices.
Twitter: / drjoshmatthews
Letterboxd: letterboxd.com/joshmatthews/
Understanding Movies 101 Course: joshmatthews.org/learn-more-a...
The Great Movies Series: joshmatthews.org/what-makes-t...
Comprehensive List of the Great Movies Series: joshmatthews.org/what-makes-t...
Movie Cliches Series -- Video Playlist: • Why Pianos Transform C...
The Great Directors Series -- Playlist: • Werner Herzog's 10 Gre...
Shot for Shot Analyses: • Understanding Movies 1...
Great Science-Fiction Movie List: joshmatthews.org/great-scienc...
Other Movie Lists: joshmatthews.org/topics/movie...
Disclaimer: All reasonable comments are welcome, including reasoned disagreements. You will be banned for foolish talk, harassment, and hate speech on sight; it's a tremendous waste of life. I believe in freedom of association and, by extension, freedom of dissociation from you. - Krátké a kreslené filmy
Tom Hulce deserves just as much praise as F. Murray Abraham. He's outstanding.
He comes across as an American brat, which is a choice that will alienate a lot of people. I appreciate it because it's of my social class and time. He played that particularly role very well, and it's partly why the movie is so memorable.
I agree. I thought Hulce, although a very good actor, came across as very American and therefore anachronistic. He gave a very good performance but I found Hulce didn’t get under the skin of the character in the way that a more intense actor probably would have. For example, the death bed scene could have been so much more powerful if it was played with the intensity it required. I would go as far as to say the part was miscast. Personally I would have liked to have seen an English-speaking German actor play Mozart. Conversely, F. Murray Abraham was absolutely superb in the role of Antonio Salieri
@@starryian007 made me think, you're right!
@@starryian007 The intent was to illustrate the disjoint between Mozart's personality and that of the "elite". Again, no opinion regarding historical accuracy. My take is that this goal was well met, and I enjoyed his performance, even though I find his performance a bit jarring at times. I would be more than interested to see how another might have played it.
Hulse’s choice to do that nails on chalkboard cackle laugh ruins every scene. Just utterly stupid of the director to allow it.
What I really love about this movie is that in the end, Salieri receives exactly what he wished for. In the beginning, he asks to be gods vessel, so that god through him can bring music to the world. And in the end, when Mozart is dying and instructing Salieri, Salieri indeed becomes this vessel. From god, through Mozart, to Salieri, who writes down gods music.
This is even hinted at (slightly) in the middle of the movie: "That was god laughing at me through that obscene giggle". Just like it was god instructing him in the end.
yes, and he is also acting as the death of his own wish to be God's vessel,, ie by killing Mozart.
His life ends in the " crazy house " as they called the Mental hospitals in those days - so he gets his punishment at the end. Also history had forgot his music - but Mozart 's music will live for ever. That is enough punishment for him.
As silly as it may seems, I found a little difficulty in reading your comment, it's the capital letter for the word God. Once I manage, I enjoyed it and see it's a great insight that resumes the whole movie.
Ah, right! It was God having the last laugh at the end.
I mean who doesn't like Amadeus, come on? It's perfect!!
well, except the overly long director's cut. I would like to see the theatrical version once again.
I prefer Bach, to be honest... I respect Mozart's music a lot, but I don't listen to it constantly... unlike Bach
prvesh lava, "who doesn't like amadeus"? anotnio Saleiri that's who
@@LearningaboutMovies Ive seen it a few times, and honestly it flows by
@@Johnadams20760 he did like Mozart, actually. The portrayal of the rivalry is blown out of proporción in the film.
My thoughts: Mozart wasn't just Salieri's rival, he was his childhood and lifetime hero. Deep down, Salieri never stopped admiring Mozart. Everyone else saw him as a burnt-out child prodigy, but Salieri's gift to appreciate music perfectly equaled Mozart's gift to create it--Salieri was the only one in his time to realize the extent of Mozart's genius when everyone else saw him as a gimmick at best. I really felt for Mozart's financial and creative struggles, despite his obnoxious demeanor--credit to Tom Hulce's fantastically endearing and nuanced performance. And I'm frustrated that Salieri speaks in a way that makes me fall in love with music, but only uses his gift to fuel his own wrath. I love the scene near the end where he dictates Mozart's Requiem in D, the way they work together, the way Salieri gets a front seat to his hero's creative process and can't help but be captivated, the poignant moment where Mozart admits he thought Salieri didn't care for his work all those years.
I am in love with this movie and all the layers it offers to it's audience.
thank you.
Can we just give credit to the priest in the movie?!...his gestures, his emotions seen on his face is phenomenal!!
I'm 51 years old. I'm a career classical musician and an avid cinephile. Amadeus has been my number one for 40 years.
Just saw this film and was shocked and speechless at the end. It was a cinematic experience. It is a musical epic!
yes!
The film makers took a lot of liberty in their portrayal of salieri.. it has been established that salieri was not the man the movie portrayed.. and certainly did not poison mozart..
Ryan Muneer Tapodoc That’s perhaps the very reason that makes this film stand out. Historical Fiction at its finest
We watched this in 7th grade music class. Still one of my favorite movies. I wrote my high school research paper on Mozart.
I love that through the whole movie Mozart has the look of a child on his face .
Yes!
He lost his childhood, much like Michael Jackson, he was made to be what he became because of an over ambitious father and always wanted to be a kid, or so history has told.
Not through the whole movie
czcams.com/video/FiNP0_iegNE/video.html
One of the great acting performances of all time: F. Murray Abraham!
When I watched this movie for the first time, I got obsessed!!!!!! After that, I used to watch it everyday for two weeks straight. I still watch it here and then , I also got the vinyl soundtrack. It makes me cry every time.
So glad to see I am not the only one 😅
One of my favorite scenes and it has been one of my favorite scenes since my first viewing is when Mozart first meets the Emperor and the court and Salari composes a musical piece welcoming Mozart to Venice. How Mozart takes the piece and literally re-writes and improves on the spot is quite extraordinary. The humiliation that F Murray Abraham is able to convey through his facial expressions is a fine testament to his great acting ability. The side eyes from the emperorplaying Salari'si
@@DWHarper62 So what! I was entertained. Btw, since you weren’t there , you don’t know if it was fiction or not. Gtfoh.
Ive still yet to see a movie that captures the joy of music and the creative process as well as this. Sadly most movies about a musician or composer seem to be based on the one semester of Music Appreciation. Milos Forman goes soooooo much deeper on this and captures the spirit of Mozart. Masterpiece
If I'm a fervent Mozartmaniac today it was because of this movie. "Amadeus", single-handedly, turned a beloved composer into a pop culture icon and a mega-star.
This movie made me a lifelong lover of classical music, since early teen years. It opened my eyes to a beauty I never knew existed, and I have held it in appropriately grateful reverence ever since. Love Hulce in this role.
What I realized after many viewings was that not only did Mozart have what Salieri coveted, Salieri actually had what Mozart coveted: the adulation of a grateful society which recognizes his (Mozart's) talent (the film makes clear that this is probably a substitute for the love he does not feel from his father). One of the most emotional moments in the film is actually the brief line "why didn't they come?" when talking about the audience for The Marriage of Figaro. He has spoken in an almost angry way about being spurned over what he is sure is the "best opera yet written," but the way Hulce delivers it is so open and child-like in its disappointment that it provides a penetrating view into Mozart's emotional life, as imagined in this story. Then there is a great shot later at the comic opera where Mozart, sitting in a box, pulls back the curtain and sees the energetic enjoyment of the audience and realizes that is the place for him.
excellent comment, great observations. thank you.
Yes, hence, all humans are equal in the eyes of god... As the priest said.
The movie holds up 35yrs later
yes! btw, long time no see!
Hey boo!! Love ur work
I saw this movie in high school for music appreciation and it had that stigma. Now, as someone who's into films, I have seen how much more it is. It is a work of art.
yes indeed. thank you.
Amadeus is my top 3 movie of all time behind The Godfather and Lawrence of Arabia. I adore this film and have introduced many friends and family members to it’s epic story, acting and music.
those are all excellent.
I AGREE THE BEST
I'm going to watch it off this recommendation
Ah, a fellow lover of _Lawrence of Arabia_
Hmm i like this one but not the other 2
This movie only gets better with age.
The movie’s main themes are appreciation and envy.
4:54 to be fair, lol, though I guess the video might not really be saying otherwise, to be fair, the whole "no ballet in opera"-thing, while truly a rule, is only used to hinder Mozart, lol...if they didn't hate him, they would let him do it...they were looking for a way to attack Mozart, lol, it's not really that they were concerned with whether he was following those rules or not...Salieri was looking for something to attack the opera with, lol...so, it's not Mozart being a challenge to the establishment with new music...even his choice of the play would not have been a problem, they brought it to the attention of the emperor to get him in trouble, to hinder him...I mean, lol...
It's not that they were opposing Mozart for being innovative, lol...they didn't like him...
That laugh is what hooked me and as it went on with the story the music and outfits i fell in love
I've had a crush on Tom Hulce ever since I saw Amadeus in 1985. :)
That scene where Solieri is taking dictation for Confutatis Maledictis, (sp I know) is one of my favorite scenes of any movie ever, and is one of the most accurate portrayals of what it feels like to compose something that truly excites you that I’ve ever seen on film.
I agree; one of the greatest of scenes.
Within a few years of Salieri's death in 1825, Alexander Pushkin wrote his "little tragedy" Mozart and Salieri (1831), as a dramatic study of the sin of envy.
In 1898, Russian composer Nikolai Rimsky-Korsakov adapted Pushkin's play, Mozart and Salieri (1831), as an opera of the same name.
A hugely popular yet heavily fictionalized perpetuation of the story came in Peter Shaffer's play Amadeus.
thanks for this.
As a retired high school music teacher, I can say that, for my purposes, this was one of the great tools I had. As a musician in general, it was one of my favorites! I love Mozart’s music. I taught a general music class, which was required for students to graduate. So, it was always populated by a captive audience of students who did not usually choose music, ie athletes, cheerleaders, goths, etc. in other words all students, minus band and choir students, lol. I wrote the curriculum for that class, with my goal to expose those students to the beauty, history and creativity of music. They learned to read and write the basic language of music, and a general overview of the history of the eras of music, from ancient to present day, tracing the roots of what they listen to today. That’s where Amadeus came in. Providing a disclaimer that much of the movie was typically Hollywood- overdone and twisted, I would show them the movie, Amadeus. It exposed them to Mozart, which they might never had chosen on their own. I had a study guide of questions to answer and things to notice, and all the while they were hearing the sweetness of Mozart, knowing this might be the only time for them to hear it. And wonder of wonders! All of my classes loved it!!! Many students began to listen to Mozart, and wanted to know more. Amadeus was a tremendous teaching tool for me! Great presentation! Keep up your good work! 🎉
I saw "Amadeus" seventeen times in the initial release. I LOVE IT. Just a note: The "harem" is the setting of "The Abduction from the Seraglio," "The Marriage of Figaro" takes place outside Seville.
Excellent, thank you.
17 times? mate it's not thar good
This is my all time favorite movie. Like you, I had loved it every time I watch it since I was a teenager. A true cinematic masterpiece.
BEST movie. Has constantly entertained me and made me laugh throughout the seasons of my life. Introducing this movie to someone who has never seen it is a gift in so many ways.
excellent, thank you.
This movie will forever stay in my mind! Such wonderful piece of art!
yes! thank you.
I watched this movie 3 years ago and all I can say is wow I was always at the edge of my seat to know what was gonna happen next , a must watch film
yes, for sure.
Even though I'm an actor & script writer honestly I can't describe my feelings about the movie!! (directing, acting etc.) I watched Amadeus 73 times I swear to God if I have time I will watch again & again, till now I feel I didn't have enough Thank you for everything God bless you all🙏🌹
The cast of Amadeus is consistently excellent. Tom Hulce, of course, was wonderfully convincing, but do not, for example overlook Elizabeth Berridge whose role took her through a whole range of emotions. She was marvelous. However, F.Murray Abraham was the actor's actor. His performance was so subtle, so realistic I needed to watch it the movie again to appreciate the incredible craft he brought to his really difficult role.
I would say that all Salieri can do at the end is laugh, because none of his plans worked out and he was unable to prevent what he was trying to prevent, even though he thought he had a foolproof plan. I love that moment near the end when, after we just witnessed Mozart's beggar's funeral (not the grand showcase Salieri imagined), and the film cuts back to the framing story, with the exhausted and incredulous priest overwhelmed and in tears... and then Salieri just laughs, even through his bitterness, because what else can we do when we see an inevitable outcome and the futility of trying to fight God?
By the way, the care they took on the framing story to show that Salieri's recounting lasted from one day, through the night, to the next day, with subtle shifts of lighting, lent an almost subliminal weight to the film's narrative arc.
excellent, thank you.
It shows the effects that bitterness and envy will lead to
This is one of the greatest movies of all time because we’re talking about one of the greatest composers of all time, but the movie itself how it transcends the historical figure of Mozart. I can watch this again and again.
Whether or not the movie portrayal of Mozart is accurate, you can hear a kind of playfulness in his music. In a way, it's like progressive rock. He's so damn good and he knows it, so he can't help indulging himself and showing off a little. And I think that mastery and playfulness exerted an enormous influence on the composers who came after him.
A beautifully crafted movie that at its essence is a super hero movie. We crave the alliance with excellence and this movie delivers it. The hero here succeeds, not with brawn, but with brains and this movie is adept at lifting us all up in Mozart's brilliance.
One of the best movies ever. On my top 5! Thanks for the review!
you're welcome.
I loved this movie, I play violin in a civic orchestra and this movie inspired me to do research on Mozart to see how his life was really like historically. It was fun to talk to my conductor about Mozart more and understand him more so I could interpret the music from my view and inspired me to play better in our civic group. I love your insight with this movie thank you 😊
Thank you.
Same, I ended up a different route, guitar rock player, but I learned scales and music theory because of Mozart.
IMHO, this is one of the best movies of all time. I agree that it can easily be classified as a musical. The casting, the music, the costumes, the script and the themes are all outstanding. I agree that we all have at least one person in life that we are envious of. Be it their position, their abilities, their wealth, health, etc. F. Murray Abraham was outstanding, and Tom Hulce really brought the character of Mozart to life like no one before him. I like the policy that Peter Schaffer had in making the music for this movie. He told everyone involved that he would refuse to make this movie if even one note of Mozart's music would be altered. That made a statement right from the start ... ! Milos Forman is one of the most brilliant directors of all time and Saul Zanitz is right up there with him on the production side. I love the opening scene with the candelabra, the horses, the music, the dancing and the snow. I will never tire of watching this movie.
My wife had never seen this, her being an American, which astounded me a bit.
Saw it available on Netflix and I exclaimed "oh you're gonna love this!"
Once the movie finished she mentioned wanting to see it again someday. Pretty dope movie indeed.
Never heard this movie described so perfectly
This movie also came at a great year for movies (1984): Once Upon a Time in America, Paris Texas, 1984, Purple Rain etc.
yes, a quick glance at 1984's movies indicates that was a good year: Spinal Tap, Repo Man, Fanny and Alexander ...
@@LearningaboutMovies don't forget The Terminator and The Killing Fields
@@LearningaboutMovies I have to put my two cents in. One of my favorites from 1984 The Adventures of Buckaroo Banzai Across the 8th Dimension.
@@LearningaboutMovies Repo Man is a fantastic cult movie. Brazil and Blue Velvet came out around that time as well.
One of the most lasting effects of the film for me was it changed the way I listened to music. That brilliant sequence at the end where the film deconstructs the Confutatis from Mozart's Requiem, allowing the audience to hear the individual elements, led me to listen to other music with that same idea, of looking at how parts of composition combine into a whole. This is like bringing Salieri to the doorstep of Mozart's talent, but Salieri still cannot see how everything goes together, and it becomes clear there is a gulf there he cannot cross.
An excellent visual score accompaniment for that scene is given here:
czcams.com/video/UMwaiA581AQ/video.html
thanks for this.
Absolutely.
Powerful and very beautiful.
He has transcended time❤️
yes, he's popular all over the world, with most/all cultures.
This film is my all-time-favorite-film. I dragged everybody I know into the cinema. I don't care that some of the scenes had nothing to do with reality. I saw it like an opera by Mozart and it is just as impressive. And it has brought many people to Mozart who did not know his music (and to the music of Salieri that I never heard of before - his music, by the way, is not nearly as bad as it was shown here. His music is not Mozart, but it is good.) The only thing I did not like about this film was that they did not mention my personal favorite opera: Cosi fan tutte. And: Mozart is not one of the greatest but THE greatest composer of all times.
great comment, thank you.
I did the exact same thing and ran around talking about it all the time
I was introduced to this movie in 1993, at age 12. Immediately, it captivated me. I purchased the VHS version at a flea market for a couple bucks and watched the tapes (two-part) regularly.
In '08, Warner Bros released the DVD, which I purchased, no doubt. This DVD (currently on my 3rd day of having it running around the clock in my bedroom "for the dogs") is one of my prized possessions. Haha. Absolutely NO ONE cares about it, but much like Salieri, I love it so much, I'm disillusioned (though aware, thank God!).
Thank you for your thoughts on this movie. It moves me in regards to so many topics (jealousy, exploitation, religion, greed, tragedy, etc.). Out of curiosity, I decided to take to CZcams and see if there were others who appreciate the film as much as I.
Have a lovely day :)
thank you. That DVD probably has the original release, which most here have said they preferred better. The scene where Salieri exploits Constanze isn't necessary, I think, and the Director's Cut is a bit too long. (Too many notes!)
We are about the same age... I saw this when I was 5 and my parents say I was obsessed and wanted to watch it every day. None of the adults could understand why I was picking this over Disney movies 😆
@@travelchic908 You've got great taste! Haha
My all time favourite film of all time, just watched it again yesterday in a cinema that shows classic films. The acting , the music , the opera scenes and the script makes an amazing film. The thing with Milos Foreman's films, even the minor roles stand out.
Timeless masterpiece. No matter how many times I watch, I’m still captivated. If you get a chance, buy the two disk special edition Director’s Cut. It has a disk devoted to how the film was made. Fascinating story. I personally met the director, Milos Forman, back in 1975, when I was dating his attorney, and we all had lunch together. At the time, I had never heard of Milos Forman. Then I went to see One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest, which he had just finished directing. I was completely blown away. Amadeus had the same impact on me. I just sat there stunned, when it ended. There aren’t many films that can move you in that way. Bravo, Milos Forman, bravo!
Great analysis and comment. Music is so, so important in movies. Barry Lyndon for example - same period and same delicious use of contemporary music.
thank you!
BARRY LYNDON was NOT as GREAT
It’s my favorite movie of all time, i watch it at like 8 when it came out, and looooved it ever since, tried many times with my kids but they never really fell for it!! What was it that my 8 years old self loved so much that it stuck for my entire life, i don’t quite know, but just the images has been a remedy during trouble times!! 💜💜💜💜
Amadeus was the supporting actor in the movie. It was more about how someone with natural talent affects the person that worked his whole life for what he has gotten. I quite enjoyed it when I watched it back in the 80's.
Just rewatched it after a long time. It is a masterpiece. So many layers of meeting, so much good humor, love and drama.
I love at the end how Mozart thinks that Salieri is his only friend XD. Also as many true genius artists, doesn't give an f about the divine subjects, high art, but rather would create operas about silly comic subjects.
A few months ago, we had our teen kids watch this movie. They loved it (my boy wrote a symphony piece since he was so inspired). It is one of the movies that are now heavy in rotation for our movie watching.
We'll probably never see a period piece with such production again.
Beautiful🌹The opera scenes are breathtaking🌺
yes!
The main character is the music. I love this film. Saw it as a teen with little to no knowledge of Mozart and loved it for what it was. Now as a middle-aged adult I love it more for how it honors his musical legacy and for its brilliant craft. Great video review btw
First time I watched it with my dad. God Bless his previous soul. He loved to listen to Mozart and Beethoven etc.
thank you.
Wonderful review. Love every minute of this movie.
thank you.
i enjoyed your commentary on this and you hit the nail on the head. one main thing I have often told people is that the facts "about" mozart's abilities and things he wrote etc.. are factual. he did in fact meet salieri, but this movie is litereally an 80 ish year old senile old man telling the whole story from his old and senile and jealous point of view.
and i have also said the music in this movie is essentially a main character. but one thing for sure, the people who wrote the lines and murray abrahams's delivery of those lines, described music more beatufiully than any way i have ever heard in my life.
thank you.
@@LearningaboutMovies you are very welcome :)
A commenter below said that Mozart was like a rock star and I totally agree. His compositions truly were "new". However, we had a Mozart/Salieri concert actually narrated by F. Murray Abraham. They played a piece by Salieri paired up with a lesser known work by Mozart. I'm pretty familiar with Mozart's sound, but I wasn't able to identify which was the Mozart piece. Apparently not every Mozart composition has the signs of his obvious genius.
thank you.
I cried during this movie, a cry of desperation.
I have watched this movie many times. It’s one of the best.
Tom Hulce was absolutely brilliant
Not to mention the cinematography! Very underrated but so effective
Tom deserved the Oscar for his comedic and dramatic representation. Abraham just huffed and puffed through the whole movie.
I have loved the composer, the play and the movie for as long as I can remember. Thank you for this review.
Hello, I am like you with this movie. I loved it from the first viewing until the present day. I have owned the soundtrack in the album, cassette, and CD. I also own the movie in Blu-ray and just recently watched the Director's Cut. After every viewing, I see something I did not notice in prior viewings. A great timeless flick that I will come back again and again for additional viewings. Thanks for this video.
Nice discussion. You pretty well vocalized my feelings regarding the film. I honestly feel sorry for people that might not love the music presented.
thank you.
One of the best movies of all time !! FOR ME THE BEST !
It's a classic about human nature, family relationships, and personal finance, as well as the conundrum of genius, eccentricity, passion, and creativity. well-deserved BEST PICTURE...Also, so WITTY!
yes, I agree.
One of my top ten favourite films of all time.
I think the screenplay was written by British playwright Peter Shaffer, and not Peter Singer, based on one of his own plays
yes, that's right. If I said Singer, that's a mistake, and thank you for the correction. Peter Singer is the philosopher who wrote a great introductory book on Hegel, among other things of course.
I love the movie, and i love W.A. Mozart's musik! I have a nice CD collection of his musik, including his operas.I thank God for the musical gift He gave Mozart.
My all-time favorite movie! ❤️
excellent!
Same!
It’s a movie about the sin of PRIDE. Though Salieri was jealous of Mozart, he was simultaneously the only one with the full capacity to appreciate Mozart’s true genius. We are all mediocre is a subtitle - get used to that reality is the message. Your commentary video is excellent
thank you
Thanks for the analysis 🌻
I have watched this film over 10 times. Still as new as the first time 🌻 one of my most favorite films of all time. 🌻🌺🌻
Thank you Mozart for the music 🌻🌺🌻
you're welcome.
Music transcended down from 1791 was no accident ... completely flawless and timeless in quality .. no decendents , just left with sublime music 👌
yes, and most moderns worldwide agree.
Excellent insights! I've seen the movie many times, including the first release. As a lover of classical music I was already very familiar with the music of Mozart, but this movie was a revelation to me of the true genius and emotional power of it. I'm not alone! It is said in the classical world that the movie had the effect of replacing Beethoven with Mozart as the GOAT of classical music.
But, you do much bring out much more than the music, and I found that especially worthwhile. I agree with your comment near the end that Salieri is struggling with his own purpose in life. Why did God put him here, only to make mediocre music - despite his efforts, sacrifices and apparent success? It drives him crazy, but only after he has met Mozart. Great insight!
I would LOVE to see this as a play
would be great. see how much buying the rights is and put it on in your local area!
For sure Mozart is the greatest composer ever. No debate on that.
Thank you for your very insightful look at this amazing, life-affirming film... your study of this cinematic Masterpiece is indeed a lovely insight, a cue for us to watch and be entranced by, the wonder that is Mozart and his music legacy. Off we go, brethren, to be charmed again by the master... enjoy...!
you're welcome. thank you for watching.
As a musician let me provide some more context. I believe the reason why this movie is great only scratched the surface level. I will list out points and then conclude to tie it all in neatly.
- Musicianship.
There is a scene where the wife of Mozart brings the music sheet to Salieri. She says to him that doesn't make copies. Need I remind you that genius level of musicianship? No copies. No edits. No changes. No alterations. The music simply flows from his head and is written down on paper. All perfect. All nothing short of Mastery. All which would take years of studying music to appreciate what came out from his head in mere seconds. I won't go deep into his genius but this small aspect is what musicians spend their entire lives changing. Heck, even Hendrix. Picks his guitar music flows. "Hey Joe", "Purple Haze", "Little Wing", "Wind cries Mary". Music that simply came easily to them.
Like Salieri, I hide myself in Music Theory. Ashamed and Insecure. Sometimes it slips even though I contain myself to all my humane effort to criticize genius's music. "Oh that is off tone", "That riff you played has a diminished note", "That doesn't sit well with the theme of the song", "Lyrically you need to add structure". Just cold hearted criticism when we all know music is beyond such structure of forms, this realization only comes to Geniuses. They are above reason, statistics, numbers, scales, harmonies, structures, tonal structure, motifs.
Even now, you listen to Mozart its so "Heavenly". There is even a saying that goes "God whispered and Mozart made its music", "The only music yet written that would not sound out of place in the mouth of God.", and by age of 35 this was known about him during his time - " God whispered straight into Mozart's ear."
- Career/Dream.
I picked up the guitar in my late teens. It was an easy choice for me. Music over everything. I spent hours getting better, becoming better, stepping everyday through patience and discipline towards mastery. Sacrificed easily everything easily I tell you easily friends, possible dates, grades, develop relatives, social life; easily and still do it too. Then you begin to notice and realize some have it so easy and take their gifts for granted. I got over it. Made peace with it. But it still doesn't change the reality that your efforts is nothing compared to a genius. Mind you people say that there aren't much geniuses but there are. In any field you will find these outliers and they change, they change the entire field you are in.
Check out the contemporary musician - Jacob Collier. He had it all. Parents who were musicians themselves, raised in a musical family, has "Perfect Pitch" which you can guess the note by hearing it instantly. Years of childhood training to improve his technique, Lastly to add insult - Good looks.
Here I am constantly criticizing my own music, every little inflections considered trash, second guessing my techniques, dying to even compose one great material. Make it worse an Asian at that.
Conclusion:
Salieri showed us where the path of envy will lead us. Even though he calls himself "Patron Saint of Mediocrity" the deed he did is Evil and wrong. Call it what you maybe "Will to Power" from Nietzsche. Still he crossed the line. I believe he indirectly tells us we can live differently and there is some satisfaction, some pride to take when you produce or create anything in life that included all your efforts paying up. And admire Geniuses when they come along. Yes it will be hard but we can pave way for them so they can influence the world. As painful it may sound, giving a chance to future Mozarts geniuses, affects and influence the industry and the world as a whole. Everyone knows and loves Mozarts music and countless are influenced by him, not to mention Music in itself.
Some thing I envy about Salieri is how his sight reading is top class, his efforts of training payed off when he looks at music sheets and imagines the music. That is a skill learnt through hardwork. So appreciate and allow geniuses to pave their way and change the world, know that in whatever field you are - you will come out short no matter how hard you try. Make peace and learn a thing or two from them if you can.
Add less suffering to the people who inhabit after you.
Mozart was so brilliant, he was a boat rocker and, was brashly young. The establishment could not stop his talent but, they sought to control it…at which point Mozart should have realized that no matter how hard he bashed his head against their wall, the wall wasn’t going to budge, even for his unmatched talent. He should have pulled up stakes and gone to where he would be truly appreciated…and could make a good living. He stuck it out to his demise.
I hope this is accurate-- thank you. I've never read a biography on Mozart, and if you have any suggestions, please post them. much appreciated.
Um flme maravilhoso ! F.Murray Abraham e Tom Hulce tiveram um desempenho perfeito ! Esta flime se tornou eterno !
thank you.
Excellent analysis. Thank you
you're welcome.
It’s about salieri anger towards god for giving him the desire to reach the greatness and talent of Mozart and most important for giving him the knowledge that he will never attain that greatness.
agreed. thank you.
mozart was perhaps the most natural super creative genius of all time. for salieri or anybody else to compare themselves to Mozart, is just absurd. salieri was wasting his time and energy being jealous of Mozart. he should have instead appreciated the fact that he recognized just how great Mozart's music was. even the best of musicians need audiences in order to survive. i myself know that as much as i like great music, that i will never write music of Mozart's quality. meanwhile, though, i can enjoy listening and appreciating Mozart's music
salieri at least envied the greatest. almost everybody envies some small-time person, the local leader, an authority figure, someone with a little bit of money. Same horrible problem but on a pathetically smaller scale.
that is why one of the Ten Commandments is to not envy other people. and in fact, according to Jewish tradition, that Tenth Commandment is said to override all the others, in the sense that it really includes all of the other nine commandments. in other words, at the root of almost all evil done, is done from the motivation of jealousy. the Five Books of Moses is filled with incidents of one episode of jealousy after another, each resulting in tremendous damage to our world
Really enjoy this movie & it's aged well. Historical issues aside yes it seems to be about people & relationships & the human experience for better or worse...with great music. Nice analysis. Now if we could just get a blu ray or 4k of the theatrical cut not the inferior directors cut only.
yes, the director's cut is not as good. why the original can't be released in some way is beyond me.
The Majesty Acting is also really good!!
This is in strong contention for best movie of all time for me
"the dustbin of history" ... I love that clche
1:36 Just saw this movie with the Cleveland Orchestra playing the music. And this scene was AMAZING as the actual flipping orchestra came to life on Mozart's command (also Cleveland is one of the Big 5 orchestras, so don't poo poo it )
My favorite movie. Watch it 4-5 times a week.
That's a lot.
@@LearningaboutMovies Weird. I know a woman who watches Jaws 4-5x a week though. I just re-watched that this week. Not as good as I remember. Of course I saw it as a 7yr old in the theater and loved it. Scared me shitless. Now kinda campy looking. Richard Dryfuss is cringeworthy
I loved this play and movie. The relationship between the two I liken to the story of Hamilton, and more recently, Elvis. A figure who is ambitious and talented, taken advantage of/betrayed by a supposed friend. It makes for a compelling story even if not historically accurate
My favorite movie of all time…. I tell everyone I talk about with… if you don’t like classical music… you will after
Very good movie.
yes!
What a great movie.
yes!
Just realized that this is a Cain and Abel story.
I enjoyed your video and also love Amadeus just wanted to make a correction that the harem theme is in Mozart’s “Abduction of the Seraglio” not the Marriage of Figaro. Thanks !
good correction, thank you.
Interesting take. I think Salieri's is gifted in being able to fully hear and appreciate Mozart's music. And I think his (the playwright's) description of said music is more exquisite and transcendent than even the music itself. He's not a horrible character to me, just a hobbled one.
thank you
It's envy created from the clash between the 'hard worker' vs the 'naturally talented'.
yeah, and there's people who are so naturally talented that they far surpass, on that alone, people who are striving as hard as they can. I read once that Carl Lewis, at his peak, worked out five hours a week!