Professor DN Jha with Teesta Setalvad
Vložit
- čas přidán 26. 11. 2015
- Teesta Setalvad, of Communalism Combat interviews Professor DN Jha on Dietary Traditions in Early India, the calculated mis-representation of Early Indian and Medieval History by the present government under the direct control of the Sangh Parivar and the ‘dark age ‘ of Superstition and un-Reason being promoted by the current political dispensation
Thank God this man is no more.
R.I.P Sir🙏
An eminent scholar with a backbone! Thank you Prof Jha for illuminating people on these issues. Thank you HilleleTV for bringing this interview. Please keep up the good work.
Sir is right
Sir is fake
Thanks dear comrade for support
@@sumanpatra6011 if u feel so than please read his work... never wrote or spoke without proof...read his work
@@prachijha26030 I have read his book madam...
The great professor Mr. DN jha sir
He has much guts to speak truth I have never seen any person like him.... Great man...
LOL he is a communist and communist are known of distoritng the history🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I don't think so
My salute to great historian.
एक निडर और साहसी इतिहासकार को मेरा नमन 💐💐⚘⚘😓😓🙏🙏
भाई आर्य होकर अपने ही धर्म को बदनाम करने वाले को तू नमन कर रहा है
लज्जा आनी चाहिए तुझे
Kabhi padha hai is k baare me itihas ko badalne vaala zooth ka pulinda hai ye dono hinduo k dusman hai
Very true professor saying, we are experiencing it
भारत का बिका हुआ तथाकथित इतिहासकार। क़यामत की रात का इंतज़ार करे।
तिस्ता जी और झा सर को 🙏🏼
तीन चीज ज्यादा देर तक नहीं छुपाया जा सकता है सूर्य,चन्द्रमा,सत्य
"बुद्ध"
शत् शत् नमन एवं भावपूर्णआदरांजली
🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
💐💐💐💐💐💐💐
Iove you so much sir ❤❤
Truth shall prevail. Such a learned person. Respect. Satya MeV jayate
He said 5 year ago that india will moves into darker phase when modi is primeminister. He was a visionary . RIP.
महान इतिहासकार
Great information for me. Thank you sir!!
More content like this is much needed.
Wll done guruji
More content like this is needed
You are great historian and speak truth.
Inki ek ek baat sach hai... Such a great historian
☸️🌿 सत्यमेव जयते 🌿☸️
R I P 🙏🙏🙏
Ram Nam Satya Hai 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Tumari ram ek jooti kalpanik vyakthi tha.
Jha sir
Bahut gahre aur nikspachh h
Revolution hai AAP sir
Salute him
Aapki aatma ko shanti mile
fearless and avowed great historian
mera aap sabhi se agrah hai, ki jisne bhi hindu dharm grantho ka adhyan kiya hai itihas ka adhyan kiya hai dharm grantho me sirf rmayan mahabhart ya gita nahi balki purne samay se leke abhi tak me to kewal wahi tipanni kare ye sobhniye hoga nahi to apne aap ke upar ye kahawat na sach kare.. kala akshar bhais barabar
Such a sensitive personality prof. Jha and the way he demolishes the hypocrisy of hindutva as propagated by RSS is very rarely seen in today's INDIA. JAI BHARAT.
One communist praising another one
🎉जय श्री राम 🎉
Respected Historian... 🙏
🙏🙏🙏
Jay bhim
Prof. Arthur Basham (d. 1986), the leading authority on ancient Indian culture and Oriental civilizations, writes about ancient Indian codes of war that *‘In all her history of warfare, Hindu India has few tales to tell of cities put to the sword or of the massacre of non combatants.* The ghastly sadism of the kings of Assyria, who flayed their captives alive, is completely without parallel in ancient India. To us the most striking feature of ancient Indian civilization is its humanity.’ - _The Wonder That Was India_
सर आप का बात काफी फैक्ट्यूल रहता है। और हम युवाओं को लॉजिकल व्यू से सोचने को प्रेरित करता है। आप ऐसे ही मार्गदर्शन करते रहिय सर। हम युवा छात्र कुछ नया कर के दिखाएंगे। (धन्यवाद सर)
rip sir
Jha sir u r great u point out gud issue recently in kerala they celebrated beef festival on road they slaughtered and cooked cow on road
spread more lies. Kerala used only beef meat , not cow meat. Also what the problem of using cow meat. Can you do the same thing - if i say all plants are my GODs and never hurt or eat them 🥴
Our real enemy is bharmavad
Dhanybad sir🙏
The beef has been part of Indian food since Vedic era.
The beef was eaten by the Brahmins in the vedic time.
.....correct bro ......we were also powerful then and we ruled parts of Afghanistan too......
Yes....and Krishna and Balram are not from yadavs....Arvind bhai...samaj gaye....
खा लें
martyrdom is slowly being converted to partyrdom . 😱
Nice good work
So, he is saying that before islam all this happened. Can this old man explain how this transition took place ? and the thought which is totally opposite to his imagination became so widespread.
I will explain all your questions. What transition are you talking about.?
read his work....he is not talking about Islam ....
he is trying to say in his book that all of sudden we offended the same meat we were forced to consume just to support Hindu parties acc to him we knew that there would be a bjp party and us have to support them lets start drama like 1000 years ago!!! lollll
Jha is arban naxaly,,
I think this old person is writing his own history.
We will request him to write 'your history', okay?
@@asmitaapardesi405 Exactly that's how you want to work.... dividing history between I and You.
For me History is beyond I and You. History is fact that it happend. And also you can't just move away by telling the history the way you like.
@@dataviz9243
That's what I said.
You will accept the history only if it goes in your way.
If you are not in support of that line you won't have any problem to understand the historians like Dr. D.N. Jha.
इसे कोई नहीं पूछता अगर इसकी किताब का नाम होता "The holy cow"
इनके बातो से स्पस्ट हो गया कि राजनीतिक के ही तहत इन्होंने इतिहास लिख डाले जो आज विद्यार्थि भी समझ नहीं पाते हैं कि सत्य क्या,?
Historical society cannot continue without reading
R.I.P sir
Harimi maanus
👍❤
D. N jha sir is great.... 🙏🙏
Urban naxal
Aap log apne naam se pahale vampanthi likhna bhool kyu jate ho.jaibhim, jaihind.
HONEST MAN
Eminent historian.... Gets confused between baktiar khilji and allaudin khilji.... And these people were in decision making places for so long
Yese hi arban naxaliyo se desh kamjor Hua hai
Ford's foundation ke dalal
Great historian
There are two opposite ideologies working in india. First R C Muzumdar, Jadunath sarkar, Sitaram goyal, Arun shouri Minakshi jain etc. Second includes Pandit Nehru, Romila thaper, Irfan habib, DN zaa, RS sharma etc. Both having different perspective. The true historian must be honest, free from biases and nonpolitical. Here the second group doesnot fit. they are communist ideologue and even party members.
👏👏
👍
his all talks might be right!!!! but the hypocrisy in his talks I see here is he trying to convey that we Hindus have an obsession with pushing Hinduism as back as possible to make it look as old as possible just to look like a true native here whereas Muslims don't belong here first of all old man we know the difference between Mughals and Muslims u just mixed both!! we knew Mughals came and people converted into Muslims otherwise Muslims and I had the same ancestors so this line pure bogus!!! and while condemning us to make Hinduism push back old as possible arent he digging way too old history of dietary of this land !! and putting it onto our head like look this is waht u use to weat u r dramatising enough! like maybe in crises and maybe in too many sacrifices Hawans people might have consumed onto some flesh we know prohibited haven't vegetarianism Hinduism was proposed and accepted way older haven't people retarded that idea of sacrificing such big animals!! u urself digging the oldest things!!!
These historians turned history into mythology and made their own history.
Bilkul sahi bol rhe 🙏🙏
Looks more like self hatred.
History can not be left to these types of historian
Dn jha is criminal
Kabhi tarik fateh ka interview kar we know ur reality
Tarek Fateh konsa itihaskar ya buddhijivi hai.
Wo sirf hindustaniyon ko chutiya banake yaha maal khana chahta hai.
Usne pehle Pakistan ke humkrano ke khilaf acchi ladai ladi.
Par ab sirf kori bakwas reh gayi.
Teesta setalvad is taking interview... nice
Marxism will go from India...
Jai Shri Ram
If he is such eminent... Why he was not able to prove that Baburi masjid was not build on Ram Mandir... In Supreme Court.
He had submitted his research on that matter with 3 other colleague including eminent historian ram sharan sharma. But supreme court rejected that by commenting "ram mandir was not build over any hindu temple" is their personal opinion.
Rama was never born.Your Ramayan is just a fictional epic, mind it communal morons
The ideology to which Mr.Jha belongs is the most imtolerant and fascist.eg.We can see china and Russia where communism is practised.
There is a difference between ideology driven government and historiographical methodology. Marxist Historians use methods developed by Karl Marx to study the society not the form of government he prescribed. As far as I can understand, the governments in China and Russia don't follow the original Marxist way of governance.
Prof. D.N. Jha recently wrote a book and several articles to prove that ancient semi-Nomadic Aryans, who according to him invaded India about 1500BC, used to eat beef. (in his book, The Myth of the Holy Cow, Verso, 2002). To prove his points he has committed fraud and misinterpretations.
He has quoted from Rig Veda, (VIII.43.11) as " Agni ...is one whose food is the ox and the barren cow".
This is a wrong quotation. The exact quotation should be " Let us serve Agni with our hymns, disposer, fed on ox and cow, who bears the soma on his back" (in Griffith’s translation of Rig Veda).
It does not mean ancient Aryans used to eat ox and cow, but Agni can dispose of any wealth, ox and cow used to be the symbol of wealth.
He also has quoted from Rig Veda( X.79.6) as " Cow was cut up with a sword or an axe".
This quotation is totally wrong. The exact quotation should be, " Agni, hast thou committed sin or treason among the Gods? In ignorance I ask thee, playing, not playing, he gold-hued and toothless hath cut his food up as the knife a victim"(in Griffith’s translation of Rig Veda).
It does not say anything about cutting cows or ox. Using these false quotations he has tried to prove Aryans used to eat beef.
thanks for this information
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏....thanks...
Thanks ....
Thank you sir
Your's is a Sangh parivar line of distorting history.
The meaning of Vedic hymns is not same in different commentaries and translations. Try to learn a little bit, atleast.
Filth of first kind.
what is so wrong in vegetarianism? isnt it aligns with the teachings with all religions.
ek paoun kabar mai our ek kele ka chilke par.....
Sunil Puthan
Woh kabar men Jai ya na Jai ya kele ke chilke pe phisle na phisle, tumjaise sare bhadkhau already khud ki khodi huwi kabron men ja chuke ho apni f' ked up thinking ki waja se. Maki chut tumhari
तीस्ता क्या है, यह भारत के हिन्दू अच्छी तरह जान गए हैं। शीर्ष अदालत ने भी इनको सजा दिया है।रही बात झा की, यह पुराना कम्युनिस्ट है।
he is serial liar as Archologist KK Muhammad said that claims need to be backed by archeological evidences not Narratives
He is uttering lies through his teeth and nothing else
Bakhtiyar Khilji ne destroy kiya tha, makkar aadmi. Babri masjid case mein court me jhutha statement de kar aya tha ye Maowadi.
Plastic surgery was 1st introduced by Sushrut in 600-700 BC, But these so called historians don't want to know beyond Delhi Sultanate..Bloody liars!
BILKUL HE WAS COMMUNIST INSPIRED MARXIST HISTORIAN
Seetalwar is bad charactor,
Brahmano ke nam pe kalank hai ye dn jha
सर कम से कम ऋषिओ को बदनाम ना करे इतना झूठ बोलकर कहा जाओगे
और कब कहा था ऋषि यागवलकया ने की वो मीट गोस्त कहते थे।
झूठ बोलने की भी सीमा होती है।
Lagta है आपने अभी तक ग्रंथ नहीं पढ़ा
two terrorists
Being a Jha ashamed of you
No one wants to declare India a vegetarian country. Stop propagating falsehood.
2 hypocrites on same platform