Great uncovering the secret of Shindu history! The era of Krishna corresponds to the second era of Hahn emperor You-in in ancient Korean history. The Hahn's duration is from 7197 BCE th 3897 BCE. The first era of Hahn is fron 7197 BCE to 6100 BCE, the second from 6100 BCE to 5000 BCE, and the third from 5000 BCE to 3897 BCE.
Sir...your earlier videos you told that krsna birth day was 17/18 June 5633 BCE...But in this video you told that 27/28 june 5633 BCE...which one is correct sir???...please reply sir🙏
Sir, my question to Oak Sir is as per him what is period of kalyug n when will it end? Any insight? Also as per dates of Mahabharata n Ramayana can we guess the 'kalavadhi' of each yuga?
I have studied astrology and my conclusion is that astrology indicates what all fortunes /mistfortunes are in STORE =possibilities of FATE of that person. But whether that person will get any of the things from the STORE = possibilities of FATE store belonging to him, will depend solely on his KARMAS. The more the karmas the more fortune/misfortune he/she gets out of the various the possibilities STORED for him /her.. Hope I am clear.
Dear Dr. Oak, Namaskar, I wish to place the following before you about the use of modern astronomy simulators in connection with the verification of ancient planetary configurations mentioned in the scriptures. Recently, I came across the dating of Surya Siddhanta, Ramayana, etc., undertaken by other scholars using astronomy simulator(s). My findings with respect to Stellarium Stellarium, the latest version of 2022. 1. Delta T correction is mainly for the motion of the moon. 2. It uses default Delta T correction based on the Modified Espenak & Meeus (2006, 2022) algorithm assured between years -1900 and 3000. 3. It uses an ephemeris tested for years - 4000 to 8000. In addition, In JPL Horizon, the latest version released for researchers published minimum years are 1. Sun [Sol] B.C. 9999-03-20 00:00 same for Mercury, Venus, and Earth 2. Mars 1600-01-01 00:00 Same for Jupiter. 3. Saturn 1749-12-30 00:00 4. Moon [Luna] B.C. 9999-03-20 00:00 Verification of Krishna DoB is beyond the capabilities of this simulator software. Moreover, I have found that planetary positions shown for a specific date by one simulator do not match the data output of other simulators. I am afraid that the results obtained via this astronomy simulator can't be considered final due to inherent incapability of the tool. Similarly, any simulator needs consideration on a case-to-case basis. Kind regards
Namaskar Atul Ji By way of PuraPaksha let me summarize what you are stating. I will respond to your comments after I have confirmation that I understood your points correctly. 1. Moon positions are affected by Delta T corrections and while correction improves the situation, no one truly knows how much to correct for a given millennium in antiquity, especially when we research into deep antiquity 2. Planetary positions shown by various astronomy software do not agree with each other for a given date. 3. For the above reason, you feel that determination of ancient events (timing) e.g. Krishna Birthday and/or Year, Mahabharata War, Rama-Ravana Yuddha, etc. are beyond the capabilities of astronomy simulation software. 4. As a result, the claims obtained based on astronomy simulation can not be considered final. Does this list capture all of your concerns? Feel free to add if I miss any.
Namaskar Dr. @@NileshOak Specifically for your summary, 1. Applicable only in cases where the presentation/calculations involve the determination of specific tithi and or day of the eclipse(s). 2. For those involved in research there is no benchmarked simulator. Invariably, the available astronomy simulators are application-specific and targeted toward research in Egyptian and other concurrent civilizations. There are also limitations due to the personal religious beliefs of the developer of the software. 3. This part summary is grossly general and restrictive. 4. I feel that the capabilities of the astronomy simulator need to be shared in the research document. Kindly note that the words simulator and simulation are different contextually. Hope that this helps. Best
@@Atul.Kumar.Kuthiala Namaskar I was hoping that you would err on the side of being more specific. That is not the case. 1. Delta T has the effect on the Moon's position and thus on the Tithi, nakshatra of the Moon, and eclipses 2. I do not know of any specific instance where evidence from Egyptian texts OR Egyptian monuments (their orientation) was such that precise and accurate astronomy simulation software was required. Granted, the likes of Graham Hancock have made use of them, but his conclusions can be accepted, rejected, or challenged without the use of an astronomy simulator. 3. What is your non-general and non-restrictive assertion here? 4. One may share the capabilities (copy/paste) of the astronomy software from the creator. As such, they are readily available from the makers of this software. An objective and rigorous discussion is possible if someone desires it without the research document listing these capabilities.
Namaskar Dr.@@NileshOak Many astronomy simulator creators share the requisite information with the buyer only. You almost said the same thing that I wrote about, i.e., the standardization of the use of simulators to take care of interoperability. At this stage, I propose to leave this thread here only, as we may not be able to reach any conclusion. Regards
नीलेश जी जय श्री कृष्ण में सिख हु ओर कनाडा रहता हूं आपको बढ़ी दिलचप्सी से सुनता हूं मेरे विचार से अगर आप अपनी खोज को हिंदी में भी पोस्ट करे तो ज्यादा लोगो तक उनकी पहुंच बन सकती है और वो वेहमो भेदों से निकल सकते है मुझे पता है आप मराठी भाषी है और हिंदी में सहज नही है फिर भी सर , लोगो की भलाई के लिए यह जरूर करे
Namaskar. Sat Sri Akal Thank you. I am also a Canadian. Your point is noted. I do speak in Hindi occasionally (Jaipur Dialogues, Neeraj Atri, Madhu Kishwar show(s)). I hope to collaborate with Hindi speaking intellectual Kshatriyas to create programs in Hindi.
@@NileshOak धन्यवाद ,निलेश जी आपने मेरी हकीर सी बात का उत्तर दिया पहली बात में टोरंटो रहता हु ब्रेम्पटन आप कहा रहते है मुझे तो यह अंदाजा था की आप ह्यूस्टन रहते है जान कर खुशी हुई की आप भी कनाडा रहते है दूसरी बात कोई और अपनी बात सिद्ध करने के लिए यूट्यूब से कमाई के लिए आपको आमंत्रित करता है उन्हे आपके ज्ञान से कोई इंट्रस्ट नही क्यू नही आप अपने ही प्लेटफार्म से इसे शुरू करते इसके लिए आपका समय जरूर खर्च होगा पर आपकी बात उन तक जरूर पहुंच जाएगी जो इंग्लिश समझ नही पाते आप तो जानते ही है इधर फाल सीजन शुरू हो गया है आपकी कुछ बुक्स मेरे पास मोजूद हैं पीडीएफ मैं जिन्हे आती सर्दियों मैं पडूंगा सबसे पहले आपका फिर से धन्यवाद सतश्री अकाल और जय श्री कृष्णा
When i was checking krishna's birth time, for 12am it was showing 18:30 utc. Why is this half hour error happening? Also the krittika has not crossed horizon. Please help🙏
Thank you for you reply🙏🙏. I am now trying to analyze Krishna's chart and hopefully I may corroborate events of his life, till now he surely has a strong chart for a spiritual, enlightened person and for a kshatriya who rules in foreign lands. Thank you for all you're doing🙏
@@vishnu6464 Did you create Krishna's chart based on 27/28 June 5633 BCE and analyzing it? If yes, I would love to see your predictions (DrNO.5561BCE@gmail.com) I had created one (the basic one.. exclusive of Mahadashas and such) and ran as double-blind experiment with 1-2 astrologers. It was a great exercise. thanks
you have used position of mars as described in MAHABHARAT, to be your bvasis of calculation. How does that fare with other planetory positions ?? Do their position also converge to SAME DATE, or some other date ?? specifically e.g. arundhati & vashishtha twin star system, it is mostly vashishtha leading & arundhati following, but there is some shlok in MahaBHarat somewhere which says that during MahaBharat war arundhati was leading vashishtha. Pls answer. Also, there is another shlok somewhere in MahaBharat that says that vasant ritu has come, and Vasant ritu time period was way different then. Pls elaborate the above 2 points. Thanks
it is a complicated answer but is hall try my best for this question. When the earth revolves around the sun, year by year the position of the pole star varies. the current pole star is druva nakshathra. during the time of mahabharatha war, Druva was not at the centre like today. you can imagine the whole earth tilted about 90 degrees to the left and compare the sapta rishi mandala along with vasishta and anuradha. So, now you can clearly map that the anuradha will be leading the vasishta. I hope I cleared your question.
Great uncovering the secret of Shindu history! The era of Krishna corresponds to the second era of Hahn emperor You-in in ancient Korean history. The Hahn's duration is from 7197 BCE th 3897 BCE. The first era of Hahn is fron 7197 BCE to 6100 BCE, the second from 6100 BCE to 5000 BCE, and the third from 5000 BCE to 3897 BCE.
Namaskar
Can you provide me additional reference books in English that provide details on these 3 Korean eras.
Thank you.
This Channel is Gold.
|| हरे राम हरे राम राम राम हरे हरे
हरे कृष्ण हरे कृष्ण कृष्ण कृष्ण हरे हरे ||
Best offering to bhagwan shree krishna...very beautiful sir
Many many thanks
Great presentation, thank you, namaskar, Hare Krishna
🙏
Big fan, watching from Nepal.
Jai Sri Krishna sir
Jai Shree Krishna 🚩🚩🙏
Great... what a precious presentation
You are so kind
🙏🏽
Thanks for the Video Sir. I was expecting this...❤❤❤ Happy Janmastami❤❤❤
Most welcome 😊
JSK
Nice Amazing! Plz share how Krishna looks like as been discussed in old videos
You must read all granth on Krishna.
Sir...your earlier videos you told that krsna birth day was 17/18 June 5633 BCE...But in this video you told that 27/28 june 5633 BCE...which one is correct sir???...please reply sir🙏
@nileshoak, what was Krishna paksha called before Krishna was born?
😂. Vadya Paksha
Is there no textbook in your opinion which gives the position of planets, nakshatras etc. at the time of Shri Krishna's birth ?? Kindly update us.
Sir, my question to Oak Sir is as per him what is period of kalyug n when will it end? Any insight? Also as per dates of Mahabharata n Ramayana can we guess the 'kalavadhi' of each yuga?
1. Kaliyuga began on 2 November 5561 BCE
2. Historical Yugas have no fixed durations.
You are the most learned person in my knowledge I would like to know the answer to a question from you ...Can fortune be judged by astrology?
Namaskar
1. I am not an astrologer.
2. There are a few good astrologers and they may be able to answer your question.
I have studied astrology and my conclusion is that astrology indicates what all fortunes /mistfortunes are in STORE =possibilities of FATE of that person. But whether that person will get any of the things from the STORE = possibilities of FATE store belonging to him, will depend solely on his KARMAS. The more the karmas the more fortune/misfortune he/she gets out of the various the possibilities STORED for him /her.. Hope I am clear.
🙏🏽🚩🛕🚩🙏🏽
Dear Dr. Oak,
Namaskar,
I wish to place the following before you about the use of modern astronomy simulators in connection with the verification of ancient planetary configurations mentioned in the scriptures.
Recently, I came across the dating of Surya Siddhanta, Ramayana, etc., undertaken by other scholars using astronomy simulator(s). My findings with respect to Stellarium
Stellarium, the latest version of 2022.
1. Delta T correction is mainly for the motion of the moon.
2. It uses default Delta T correction based on the Modified Espenak & Meeus (2006, 2022) algorithm assured between years -1900 and 3000.
3. It uses an ephemeris tested for years - 4000 to 8000.
In addition,
In JPL Horizon, the latest version released for researchers published minimum years are
1. Sun [Sol] B.C. 9999-03-20 00:00
same for Mercury, Venus, and Earth
2. Mars 1600-01-01 00:00
Same for Jupiter.
3. Saturn 1749-12-30 00:00
4. Moon [Luna] B.C. 9999-03-20 00:00
Verification of Krishna DoB is beyond the capabilities of this simulator software.
Moreover, I have found that planetary positions shown for a specific date by one simulator do not match the data output of other simulators.
I am afraid that the results obtained via this astronomy simulator can't be considered final due to inherent incapability of the tool. Similarly, any simulator needs consideration on a case-to-case basis.
Kind regards
Namaskar Atul Ji
By way of PuraPaksha let me summarize what you are stating. I will respond to your comments after I have confirmation that I understood your points correctly.
1. Moon positions are affected by Delta T corrections and while correction improves the situation, no one truly knows how much to correct for a given millennium in antiquity, especially when we research into deep antiquity
2. Planetary positions shown by various astronomy software do not agree with each other for a given date.
3. For the above reason, you feel that determination of ancient events (timing) e.g. Krishna Birthday and/or Year, Mahabharata War, Rama-Ravana Yuddha, etc. are beyond the capabilities of astronomy simulation software.
4. As a result, the claims obtained based on astronomy simulation can not be considered final.
Does this list capture all of your concerns? Feel free to add if I miss any.
Namaskar Dr. @@NileshOak
Specifically for your summary,
1. Applicable only in cases where the presentation/calculations involve the determination of specific tithi and or day of the eclipse(s).
2. For those involved in research there is no benchmarked simulator. Invariably, the available astronomy simulators are application-specific and targeted toward research in Egyptian and other concurrent civilizations. There are also limitations due to the personal religious beliefs of the developer of the software.
3. This part summary is grossly general and restrictive.
4. I feel that the capabilities of the astronomy simulator need to be shared in the research document. Kindly note that the words simulator and simulation are different contextually.
Hope that this helps.
Best
@@Atul.Kumar.Kuthiala
Namaskar
I was hoping that you would err on the side of being more specific. That is not the case.
1. Delta T has the effect on the Moon's position and thus on the Tithi, nakshatra of the Moon, and eclipses
2. I do not know of any specific instance where evidence from Egyptian texts OR Egyptian monuments (their orientation) was such that precise and accurate astronomy simulation software was required. Granted, the likes of Graham Hancock have made use of them, but his conclusions can be accepted, rejected, or challenged without the use of an astronomy simulator.
3. What is your non-general and non-restrictive assertion here?
4. One may share the capabilities (copy/paste) of the astronomy software from the creator. As such, they are readily available from the makers of this software. An objective and rigorous discussion is possible if someone desires it without the research document listing these capabilities.
Namaskar Dr.@@NileshOak
Many astronomy simulator creators share the requisite information with the buyer only.
You almost said the same thing that I wrote about, i.e., the standardization of the use of simulators to take care of interoperability.
At this stage, I propose to leave this thread here only, as we may not be able to reach any conclusion.
Regards
नीलेश जी
जय श्री कृष्ण
में सिख हु ओर कनाडा रहता हूं आपको बढ़ी दिलचप्सी से सुनता हूं
मेरे विचार से अगर आप अपनी खोज को हिंदी में भी पोस्ट करे तो ज्यादा लोगो तक उनकी पहुंच बन सकती है और वो वेहमो भेदों से निकल सकते है
मुझे पता है आप मराठी भाषी है और हिंदी में सहज नही है
फिर भी सर ,
लोगो की भलाई के लिए यह जरूर करे
Namaskar. Sat Sri Akal
Thank you. I am also a Canadian.
Your point is noted. I do speak in Hindi occasionally (Jaipur Dialogues, Neeraj Atri, Madhu Kishwar show(s)).
I hope to collaborate with Hindi speaking intellectual Kshatriyas to create programs in Hindi.
@@NileshOak धन्यवाद ,निलेश जी
आपने मेरी हकीर सी बात का उत्तर दिया
पहली बात
में टोरंटो रहता हु ब्रेम्पटन
आप कहा रहते है
मुझे तो यह अंदाजा था की आप ह्यूस्टन रहते है जान कर खुशी हुई की आप भी कनाडा रहते है
दूसरी बात
कोई और अपनी बात सिद्ध करने के लिए यूट्यूब से कमाई के लिए आपको आमंत्रित करता है उन्हे आपके ज्ञान से कोई इंट्रस्ट नही
क्यू नही आप अपने ही प्लेटफार्म से इसे शुरू करते
इसके लिए आपका समय जरूर खर्च होगा
पर आपकी बात उन तक जरूर पहुंच जाएगी जो इंग्लिश समझ नही पाते
आप तो जानते ही है इधर फाल सीजन शुरू हो गया है आपकी कुछ बुक्स मेरे पास मोजूद हैं
पीडीएफ मैं
जिन्हे आती सर्दियों मैं पडूंगा
सबसे पहले
आपका फिर से धन्यवाद
सतश्री अकाल और जय श्री कृष्णा
@@barinder32 I used to live in Canada. I lived in Edmonton, Calgary, Vancouver and Toronto area.
When i was checking krishna's birth time, for 12am it was showing 18:30 utc. Why is this half hour error happening? Also the krittika has not crossed horizon. Please help🙏
Namaskar. Answer is Delta T correction.
@@NileshOakI don't know about what correct value to enter for delta T. By default it is automatic.
@@vishnu6464
Accept an error of +/- 2-3 days....for 6th millennium BCE and move on
Hope this helps.
Thank you for you reply🙏🙏. I am now trying to analyze Krishna's chart and hopefully I may corroborate events of his life, till now he surely has a strong chart for a spiritual, enlightened person and for a kshatriya who rules in foreign lands.
Thank you for all you're doing🙏
@@vishnu6464
Did you create Krishna's chart based on 27/28 June 5633 BCE and analyzing it?
If yes, I would love to see your predictions (DrNO.5561BCE@gmail.com)
I had created one (the basic one.. exclusive of Mahadashas and such) and ran as double-blind experiment with 1-2 astrologers. It was a great exercise.
thanks
you have used position of mars as described in MAHABHARAT, to be your bvasis of calculation. How does that fare with other planetory positions ?? Do their position also converge to SAME DATE, or some other date ?? specifically e.g. arundhati & vashishtha twin star system, it is mostly vashishtha leading & arundhati following, but there is some shlok in MahaBHarat somewhere which says that during MahaBharat war arundhati was leading vashishtha. Pls answer.
Also, there is another shlok somewhere in MahaBharat that says that vasant ritu has come, and Vasant ritu time period was way different then. Pls elaborate the above 2 points. Thanks
it is a complicated answer but is hall try my best for this question. When the earth revolves around the sun, year by year the position of the pole star varies. the current pole star is druva nakshathra. during the time of mahabharatha war, Druva was not at the centre like today. you can imagine the whole earth tilted about 90 degrees to the left and compare the sapta rishi mandala along with vasishta and anuradha. So, now you can clearly map that the anuradha will be leading the vasishta. I hope I cleared your question.
U r son of prof pn Oak..??
No. brothery connection via the last name!
Hello sir i have a question
About ramayan
Pl. Can you speak in hindi ? Which would better service for Bharatiy people.
🙂Sir,
If you are true then why can't we find any archeological evidence that old?
Which fool told you that we don't find archaeology evidence as old or older than 5663 BCE and 12240 BCE?
You are not a Brahmin?
पण आज जैसलमेर चे राज घराणे हे श्री कृष्णाची १५२ वी पिढी आहे.साधारण एक पिढी ही २५ - ३० वर्षे असे गृहीत धरा.