Why isn’t NATO fighting Russia? Indian army generals respond
Vložit
- čas přidán 26. 02. 2022
- For months now, tens of thousands of US and NATO troops have been positioned along Ukraine’s western borders, with the most sophisticated war machinery in the world. Their leaders have issued thundering threats to Russian President Vladimir Putin. Yet, Russia unleashed air power, tanks and 190000 troops and has invaded Ukraine. Ukrainian civilians, reservists and troops are fighting a valiant but unequal battle, nearly 150 civilians including children have been killed within barely three days. So where is NATO and why isn’t it helping Ukrainians fight the Russians? In an exclusive conversation with Padma Rao Sundarji for Times Online, India’s generals Ata Hasnain and Shokin Chauhan provide the answers.
#ukrainecrisis #ukraine #russiaukrainewar
Subscribe to Times Of India's CZcams channel here: goo.gl/WgIatu
Social Media Links:
Facebook : / timesofindia
Twitter : / timesofindia
Google + : plus.google.com/u/0/+timesind...
Wars
Created by politicians,
Fought by soilders,
Suffered by families.
Fought
@@thebodykeepsthescore2828 Fawt
@@John-ih7gp Fot 😂
Direct result of taxation
Wrong,
World Elitists are the Orchestrators of War, via their payed staff -
Top Politicians.
People believing Politicians & dividing Media are stupid. Fighting for Politicians is what they want.
War is PROFIT for Elitists, wake-up.
The answer is simple: If NATO stepped in, it would be WW3 and would soon turn nuclear. Even a private in most armies would know that.
Ukrainian and Western Journalists don't seem to.
To avoid making things complicated - which can make Putin frustrated as he has gone mad and rouge. the reason NATO has not got themselves involved. plus understanding how Russia is fighting give them the experience and knowledge
We have a bunch of politicians here either talking tough or actually trying to start ww3
why can't people understand what you just said it will go nuclear.
Replace Bide With Trump the war should be over including the next one China VS Taiwan.
Those Lit.Gen are very aware of the situation. The simple fact that they observe the economic aspects of the war already tells you a lot about the knowledge of the Indian Army. Very smart and conscious about all aspects. Congratulations to the India and it's competent army leaders from Brazil.
Lol.sure
The Russians are a weak country with a nuclear hand grenade
Unbelievable but true: there are still people out there worthy of being called humans: they think - they give you real answers (not political bs rhetoric) - and they can see further than the tip of their nose. Respect, generals!
2003 "We are fighting Iraq because they have nuclear weapons"
2022 "We can't fight Russia because they have nuclear weapons"
Jaja lol 😂
@@intenseninja8241 it's not weakness.. it's restraint. It would also be stupid to fight
Western imperialism just got stopped
Damn that’s crazy never thought of it like that
Nato is bullshit
I wish our media in the US was as straightforward and honest…..
Stop thinking corporate media in any country is showing you unbiased news.
They are all bias...watch them all...throw away 90% and work out what they all have in common regarding the story.
@@veshapoochi0.3 They speak about proxy wars, but totally ignored the fact Russia has been running a proxy war in Eastern Ukraine since 2014.
Agenda!
@@veshapoochi0.3 you sound like a pro Putin Russian bot shut up
I wish usa and nato stop expanding there military around the world ... This is result of doing that .... History have shown what is about to come when usa get close to any country boarders ... Americans are good heart people but the government hunger of power makes all the world to get in conflict..
@@yt.personal.identification you are absolutely right, discerning the truth takes level headedness and that isn't gained easily, judging the best course of action and doling out measured punishment is even harder
who do you think is the true instigator according to you? i am a bit curious sir
II liked to listen to the thoughts of these wise and experienced generals from India.
"Economically and psychologically Europe is not ready for war"
As an European I would like to take this as an compliment.
Not sure what your ethnicity is, but, this comment is backhanded af, lol. The compliment being it isn't a 3rd world country? I'm assuming?
SOME PEOPLE!! COME /COME WITH
THEIR EXPRESSIONS!!..SO... BEAUTIFUL!!....give A rating pease?
OK...■ 99%...GREAT FUN HERE!! ■
How true! If authorities and their families needed to fight, there won't be war! It's the poor and commons who fight and die.
Si vis pacem para bellum...
@@jean-martinvonsiebenthal2836 Si vis pacem para virtutes
Wow finally someone is actually speaking facts on this situation unlike any other media ..... thank you India
Didn’t age well for you did it?
what facts???India ain't ready for a war neither n even china n russia ain't ready for a war with NATO n the west, the USA alone will crush them lmfao
@@downzero1028 Didn't age well for YOU did it?
Sitting in Germany.
Media gone nuts.
Looking for realistic assesments of the situation.
Thanks, India ;)
Could you please clarify if you're being sarcastic or not? I really can't tell.
@@prateekbhurkay9376 I think he's being serious. The media in the west is kind of BS, and a bit of a joke. The amount of fear-mongering to gain profit, censorship, etc. is crazy here.
Don't you realize that Russia buys Indian and African commentators to inject the Ukrainian discourse in the world? Unfortunately, propagandist machine knows no border and it's a pity that you've become a victim of it.
No, actually currently India has the only unbiased point, Im living in Europe and Im a russian speaker, it's impossible to understand what is happening here the scenario is Putin is mad, he wants Europe, the showman Zelenskiy is a hero telling fight until you all die, and Russia is noting more different than North Korea ........
@@prateekbhurkay9376
I am not.
What would I have said in your opinion if I had meant it sarcastically?
The two retired generals have spoken.
Now let's see what the generals in the comment section thinks... 😄
🤣🤣
that was good though
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I've never reached the rank of general, but I can tell you any soldier with half a brain could have told you this.
😁😁😁😁😁😁
😂
Those 2 Generals knows their subjects. Thanks
I think that weigh-in from both these Indian Generals was absolutely brilliant and more significant than any other source I’ve heard from since this war began !!!
Very true. The Amerikkkan news about what is going on in Ukraine is propaganda with lies!
That is the absolute straight up truth
Haha
European here. That's pretty much it, those two Generals tell it straight. If NATO crosses Ukraine's border, Russia will go nuclear and so will NATO in return. However, the other way could be fought with conventional forces first, unless a serious move to invade or destroy NATO cities starts. Then you all wouldn't have to file your taxes any more.
By no logic in today's world a war is justified.... But history says Europe always gets involved into it and they are very passionate about destroying each other... Can u ask your leaders there to do something about it?!
@@pappuchak8605 Third Time's the Charm
Can't use conventional forces Putin has made sure to make it well know that he will immediately launch nukes if anyone intervenes in anyway with their military
If Nato intervene its WW3. You cannot deny that Nato's expansion is forcing Putins hand. Also as always US using the media to brainwash people into thinking that this is more that its suppose to be. National security of Russia. Once Ukraine joins Nato it would have been easy for Nato to attack Russia since Moscow is close to the border.
@@GetdonkedOn He only wait for that till somebody from nato cross ukraine border its his only chance otherway hes lost he already dead rat walking
At last two honest military men telling me the truth. Thanks guys. I actually understand what you are saying, without the media hype BS. Australia.
6:26 : Please, change *NATO* with *US Army* , second, US was attacked , so US could ask NATO to act, as "threatening any NATO's member (and 🇧🇷) means threatening all"
NATO means *(N)* orth *(A)* tlantic *(T)* reaty *(O)* rganisation , so, it main duty is to protect the members, the North Atlantic Ocean and 🇧🇷.
When Venezuela was threatening us some years ago, US sent 60 fighter jets to our Northern Hemisphere border (border with Venezuela) *immediatly* .
So, the thing with Ukraine is that 1) It's *not* NATO's member and 2) We don't want WWW3, right? Respect Russia.
Please, understand that one thing is "US Army" and another thing is "US Army as NATO", same Army, different responsibilities.
@@aquamastertheonlyone
If you were Ukrainian
How would you feel about NATO shelling your city with tomahawk cruise missles to liberate and protect you from the russians who are also just trying to liberate the non Nazi Ukrainian people from the poo-zionist NATO motherfrackers pimping the country into poking the bear --- in njew world order to falsely justify blaming Putin for starting WW3.
Nobody should be against
Ukraine's independence and sovereignty ---
(as long as no natives need to be evicted first) but the NATO has NO business arming Ukraine to the teeth like they did with the other proverbial 'holy land' ...
Don't poke the bear.
What ever happened to Khasaria?
( now called Ukraine )
Did'nt the khasarian mafia (deceptacon hex-nutz) eventually migrate over to europe to inbreed with the royal debt based banksters ? Ya know that sect of pale imposters that got rid of a big chunk of honest to goodness bronze skin hebrews that adamantly objected to the rebuilding of the temple in Jerusalem until the messiah shows up as according to scripture) in order to hijack Palestinian region and turn it into the genocidal megalomaniac kosher-supremacist den of thieves and tourist-trap attraction it is today ?
Nobody knows exactly How many (US bought) Nukes Isreal has pointing out in every direction to make sure no other insolent 'heathen' nation trys anything funny.
Being hellbent on total world domination is fixing to get funny any day now too... Shlalom motherschuckers !
It is an emergency
For them uppity socialist elitists that tend to grant all those nice 'FRINGE BENEFITS' to their own insider cheater-class accessories to the plandemic hijacking of humanity and gradually increasingly hostile takeover of planet earth ...
Lucifer knows his time is up ! Welcome to the worldwide wireless concentration cramp !
maybe if we'd kiss our corporate cattlerancher state pharmer KINGPIMPS of gangstas pair-o-dice asses hard enough --- they might treat us a little better huh ? (Stockholm syndrome)
We best start sharpening our mental shivs yawl.
Hold fast (intermittent fasting from the poi-zion food and information supply) ,
and stay vigilant (meditation is prayer) --- to achieve Goddesspeed yawl. Time to conscientiously rip the goddamn blindfold MASK veil off Lady Justice --- so she can properly thrash that greedy-sadistic judiciously corrupt fraternity of pig-raping motherfrackers out of the equation entirely. . .
We need to change "good mourning." into "good dawning !" REJOICE for the kingdom of heaven is in play ! FREEK-OUT !
And BIG PEACE to all honest to goodness children of the earth ...
@@jowlorenz9555 I hear you, that was a lot to dissect but the overall is much as I suspected.
How many wars have these two generals won? They can't even take on Pakistan!
@@TheTrebbieFan they won 7 battles,some wars dont remember exact.and you dont want to spend your time killing a failed state like pakistan thats already dead
I appreciate the assessment of the
situation by these Indian Generals.
I know India has to deal with two
hostile nei
Good to hear honesty, glad I’ve found your channel.
50 years ago, in 1971, the USA threatened India to stop the 1971 war with Pakistan.
Kissinger spurred Nixon to send the US 7th Fleet’s Task Force, led by the nuclear-powered aircraft carrier USS Enterprise, to the Bay of Bengal.
When Pakistan's defeat in the 1971 war seemed imminent, America dispatched the nuclear-powered aircraft carrier USS Enterprise towards the Bay of Bengal. The US 7th Fleet’s Task Force also had USS King and USS Decatur.
The move was deemed by India as a nuclear threat.
The USS Enterprise, at 75,000 ton, was the world's largest nuclear-powered aircraft carrier in the 1970s with more than 70 fighter aircraft. A monster.
The Indian Navy’s fleet was led by the 20,000-ton aircraft carrier, Vikrant, with 20 light fighter aircraft.
The USS Enterprise was being dispatched to secure American citizens in Bangladesh was the official American statement. Unofficially, it was to threaten the Indian forces and prevent the liberation of East Pakistan.
India soon got an another bad news.
Soviet intelligence reported to India that a powerful British naval group led by the aircraft carrier HMS Eagle with commando carrier HMS Albion, several destroyers and other ships, were approaching India's territorial waters from the west, towards the Arabian Sea.
The British and the Americans planned a co-ordinated pincer attack to intimidate India: the British ships in the Arabian Sea will target India's western coast, while the Americans would make a dash to Chittagong.
Caught between the British & the American ships was the Indian Navy.
It was December 1971, and the world’s two leading democracies, the US & the UK.. were threatening the world’s largest democracy, India !
*An SOS from Delhi by Prime Minister Indira Gandhi, was sent to Moscow.* The Red Navy soon dispatched 16 Soviet Naval Units and six Nuclear Submarines from Vladivostok, to block the USS Enterprise.
Admiral N. Krishnan, the chief of the Eastern Command of the Indian Navy, wrote in his book, 'No Way But Surrender' that he was afraid that the Americans will reach Chittagong. He mentions how they even thought of attacking USS Enterprise, in a 'do or die' move, to slow it down.
On December 2nd week 1971, the US 7th Fleet’s Task Force, led by the monstrous USS Enterprise arrived in the Bay of Bengal. The British fleet was arriving in the Arabian Sea. The world held its breath.
Unknown to the Americans, the submerged Soviet submarines had overtaken them.
As USS Enterprise moved towards East Pakistan, the Soviet submarines surfaced without any warning. The mighty Soviet submarines were now between India & the USS Enterprise. The Americans were shocked.
Admiral Gordon told the 7th American Fleet Commander: *"Sir, we are too late. The Russians are here."*
Both the American and British fleets backed off.
Today, most Indians have forgotten about this colossal naval chess battle between the two superpowers the US & the USSR, in the Bay of Bengal.
After suffering badly in Vietnam, the Americans were again outmanoeuvred by the Soviets.
people should know the history, Before deciding who to support. Which is why indian government is neutral in this war.
Nice story, didn't knew this
non alignment is fine but we must not go against our friend Russia who protected and suppored us like a big brother in every losing situation, In fact America is our strategic partner only since we both have shared interests. Lets be frank who wants the American Oligarch's to have a grip on our Bharat 🇮🇳
Very long half true story , don't forget that it was the U.S. who helped india in 1962 war with China , otherwise China would have isolated india in a corner , right after the war U.S. realized that Nehru has backstabbed he U.S. about Tibat project which was suppose to be top secret between the U.S. and India , but no, Nehru went to China and leaked out all the secret to China, that's when China attacked india and invaded Tibet. Then u.s. backed off from india. Russia has weapon trading with india with other low level trades, india started modernization after close relationships with U.S. , remember U.S. is the top investor in India as off now, hating the U.S. could bring you back to stone age if u.s. pulls back it's support to india.
@@allamericanslogistics1143 lol
This reminds me of my Indian physics professor in college , they have the ability to break everything down to simple terms
Awesome I hated my chemistry teacher 😂😂😂😂😂😂 that woman was useless. Reading it like it was the Times 😂. But yeah I love the breakdown here clear and makes sense ❤
Theres no world war if the western countries not started to convincing Ukraine to be a members or joint of EU and NATO. U.K. U.S. for what...
Remember what NATO done Iraq, libya , and Syria especially my home land and our beloved President Ferdinand E Marcos..now the heavenly creators appointed a very brave and a good heart President Rodrigo Roa DUTERTE. Hes administration fight against terrible drugs cartels in the Philippines . Now our coming election the USA interfering .now who is dictators???
U.S. U.K. EU NATO. The wester countries start the fire..i believe Russian President Vladimir Putin he is protect his country because if the Ukraine President allows NATO to inter ,its dangerous its easy for them to destroy Russia. Now that is the reason why Putin very angry he need to depended his country and his people..America stealing oil and the natural resources in every countries and killing people because they are great colonizers.
@@lynelgadiama9451 Very true what you said ,just some people don't understand.
@@erentxunlopez6281 you just talked to a bot/AI, Its the same person spamming just about the same things every comment section.
@@Sanif514 I didn't know .
Thanks Generals for your professional insight. So glad we in south africa can tap into your news programmes and see things as they are in an unbiased way.
Excellent analysis. Thank you.
The most basic reason NATO isn't fighting back is because none of the member nations have been attacked. The next reason is the risk of nuclear war from Russia if the US or NATO nations interfere.
You just saved me 13 minutes of my life.
Thank you
You look at the history. NATO has interfered into the wars without being attacked to them, so you are wrong with your basic reason.
Yes, excellent synopsis, don’t need a book
Yup, what a stupid ass title like NATO have a choice.
@@DSW2022 yes but not with someone like Russia they are not going to risk all out nuclear war. You are over reasoning and actually believe they would do anything. It all comes down to nukes, its very simple you don't have to over think it.
As an Afghan vet (airborne). - i say these India army generals know what they're talking about. They've commanded troops in high risk situations- they're warriors. They're much more near to Russia & a conflict would draw them in quickly.
As an Afghan vet, you should know how Russia's invasion of Afghanistan went. I was there in 2002 so I was definitely able to get some perspective as the people that my unit, also airborne, came into contact with still had memory of the Russian invasion.
Sorry, but these two clowns completely missed the mark. They clearly do not understand the Ukrainian mentality, nor do they take history well into account.
Russia supported an insurrection in Ukraine in 2014, read up on "little green men". He also annexed Crimea. This was in direct response to a massive protest in Ukraine that ended in the Ukrainian head of state, a Russian puppet similar to Belarus's Lukashenko, being removed in favor of a west oriented government of liberal democracy, wanting to join EU and NATO.
Look at Putin's stated goals, acceptance of "russian sphere of influence, give up the notion of western alignment and "denazification". This is not some "special operation as he's calling it. He's looking to "liberate" Ukraine from its western dream. He wants them pining for the glory days of the USSR. If you have a netflix account, check out a documentary called "Winter on Fire".
Putin did not expect global attention or stiff resistance. This was a carefully laid trap (by the CIA probably) to get Russia stuck in a quagmire where they'd waste blood and treasure and be of no use to a belligerent Communist China. Ukraine has more stingers and Javelins than Afghanistan had in the 80s. This is the reason why Ukraine wasn't allowed to join NATO after 2014 when they were begging to join. If they'd been in Nato, Russia would not be stuck in this mess. because they would not have invaded, which was exactly what we wanted them to do.
It's payback for his recent nonsense like offering bounties on our boys in A-stan a couple of years ago and probably Havana Syndrome.
Some of our bretherine are definitely "volunteers" in the Ukrainian foreign division. People think Russia is so mighty and since they're near, that Ukraine has no hope, but the assymetry was even greater in Afghanistan in the 80s. This is going exactly as America planned.
@@carlosviajes So, 10 years of Russian invasion sit well with you? Vs. 20 years of US and NATO(same sugar) invasion? Ukraine is not A-stan. Yet it was conducting a war on its own citizens for 8 years(14 thousands killed) and shown no desire to stop it. Neither US and any other country except Germany and (to some extent) France. That's ok with you, right? 'Western dream' right? How's that working in other countries, Haiti, Honduras? Or they don't count?
@@carlosviajes Dios mio, you've served to long.
To your question why NATO is refusing to join Ukraine to fight Russia arguing Ukraine is not a NATO country while NATO faught in Iraq and Afghanistan. Why?
It doesn't take more than a 5th grader from school to give the answer. Russia isn't Iraq nor Afghanistan.
It's so refreshing to listen to non western medias, we get to understand what is really happening, than the usual attack attack Russia only from western medias. These two Indian Generals are well experienced in war scenarios. Enjoyed listening.
Yes
Should have tons of experience thanks to suppressing civilians in Kashmir don't you think???
@@stevenhull5025chuup bowsadekay
These Indian Generals are very wise, pragmatic and fantastic communicators.
Says who? Anyone with a normal or higher intelligence understands this without any help from some general. It's sooooo basic knowledge.
@@arturama8581 Not basic for idiots who do not use critical thinking, ever. Only emotions
@@arturama8581 future guerrilla warfare leading to perpetual Russian headache and loss. Was an eyeopener.
Well rest as you said is basic knowledge.
If these guys get a weekly one hour podcast, I'll listen. The interview exceeded my expectations.
Indians always give the best and most straightforward breakdowns and analysis. They aren't like western media whom are full of bullshit propaganda.
The guys were informative but I think they should've kept some of this close to their chest.
But the line of questioning wasn't good. In Iraq & Afg, NATO were the invaders & they weren't going against Russia. Russia didn't go & back Syria directly against US' Syria intervention coz they'd be attacking NATO then.
Find another source PLEASE !!! EVERYTHING here is Wrong !!!!!!!!
They are talking about balakot.. idiots ask from abhinandan :)
How about USA invading 33 countries since World War 2?
What Zelenskij is crying about?
He made this mess himself!!!
How an actor can be a president?
He will resign to USA with good a "retirement" sum.
West paid him millions, unlike simple people.
You should pray for 40 people burned alive in Odessa by UKRAINIANS, you should pray for targeted and bombarded by UKRAINIANS russian children peacefully playing on the beach, you should pray for thousands other people tortured and killed in Donbass by UKRAINIAN Nazis!.
Or your media doesn't disclose to you this information about genocide of russian people over last 8 years in Donvass and Lugansk?
This is plain clear straight up truth!!!!
“Where is nato, why isn’t it fighting back?”
Ukraine is not a nato country, you’d think a media organisation would know that
NATO knows if they enter ukrene it's directly invading Russia,they will be NUKED to oblivion......believe it or not....
@@kamalramdass1429 Ukraine is not Russia
As a Pakistani I have to tip my hat at these Indian generals for this excellent and accurate analysis of the current European conflict. Let us hope, for the sake of humanity that it can be resolved before it turns into a world war.
Well all thanks to your country tho 🙂
Pretty unlikely having a ww3 over the Ukraine, at best it will be like Korea or veitnam.
Waqar Smith. Are you a rice bag convert?
It will not be a world war but an European or North American War. Europe no longer occupies colonies in Africa, South America or Asia.
Trust me, we in the United States feel the same. Most here believe this is a war to stop the New world order. Billions of U.S tax payer dollars laundered in Ukraine by our corrupt politicians. Guess what else Russia is targeting, USA funded biolabs! Don't believe the media coming from the states, everything is literally the opposite they portray. Love to our Indian family on the other side of the world. We must fight to rid ourselves of politicians who promote a hidden agenda!
Hmmmmm Im not Indian nor asian but frankly I have learned alot today. Salut to these generals very wise men. We need more rational thinkers.
6:26 : Please, change *NATO* with *US Army* , second, US was attacked , so US could ask NATO to act, as "threatening any NATO's member (and 🇧🇷) means threatening all"
NATO means *(N)* orth *(A)* tlantic *(T)* reaty *(O)* rganisation , so, it main duty is to protect the members, the North Atlantic Ocean and 🇧🇷.
When Venezuela was threatening us some years ago, US sent 60 fighter jets to our Northern Hemisphere border (border with Venezuela) *immediatly* .
So, the thing with Ukraine is that 1) It's *not* NATO's member and 2) We don't want WWW3, right? Respect Russia.
Please, understand that one thing is "US Army" and another thing is "US Army as NATO", same Army, different responsibilities.
Thanks so much for the infor
Excellent thank you!
These Indian Generals have explained this in ABC terms for people to understand clearly. Thank you India
How daft must you be to need their explanation to get it?
@@arturama8581 a moment of silence for your conclusive arrogant statement and a salute to your unknown intelligence.
I agree, most if not all of the politicians are being very mealy-mouthed in their responses about their support of the Ukraine people. While most of the western Generals have been muzzled by their politicians. I have received text messages or emails from friends in Poland and other neighbouring countries stating that they and other soldiers are even wondering why they are there if they are not allowed to do anything even it's just to protect refugees making their way out of Ukraine.
6:26 : Please, change *NATO* with *US Army* , second, US was attacked , so US could ask NATO to act, as "threatening any NATO's member (and 🇧🇷) means threatening all"
NATO means *(N)* orth *(A)* tlantic *(T)* reaty *(O)* rganisation , so, it main duty is to protect the members, the North Atlantic Ocean and 🇧🇷.
When Venezuela was threatening us some years ago, US sent 60 fighter jets to our Northern Hemisphere border (border with Venezuela) *immediatly* .
So, the thing with Ukraine is that 1) It's *not* NATO's member and 2) We don't want WWW3, right? Respect Russia.
Please, understand that one thing is "US Army" and another thing is "US Army as NATO", same Army, different responsibilities.
4:46 most important line of the interview.
"Conventional operations are being outsourced"
There you go, why the US wants India in QUAD & warmed up to India recently. To be pawns if China comes knocking.
There is a fundamental misrepresentation of facts here: NATO did not go into Iraq and Afghanistan; those involved alliances of nations including several NATO members - but they were not acting under the unified NATO structure.
THANK YOU! scrolled wayy to far to find this
"Coalition of the willing" they called it if I remember right.
India is pro Russia so misrepresentation of facts is predictable unfortunately
why would you even think you are more informed in such matters more than major generals? 🤫🤔🤔
@@ahmedm7292 being informed does not make you honest.
Very nice and clear statement of the war at Ukraine, and the cover up, although very open war of NATO and United States on UKRAINE.
INDIA & RUSSIA IS A TRUE & REAL FRIENDS OF THE FILIPINOS AND ALSO JAPAN❤🇮🇳🇮🇳🇷🇺🇷🇺🇵🇭🇵🇭🇯🇵🇯🇵✌✌✌👍👍👍
Great video. As an American, it is nice to hear well thought out questions and answers. We don't really get that from our media.
Yeah. And it was your president that started this Man. Congrats
@@gilblax8764 BS!
Maybe you should watch other News Stations then. I'm watching some 5-6 TV stations at once, from EU and US and apart from small differences they all check out. Unless you are watching the sewer journalism of Fox, AON, Sky Australia and such garbage, you're getting reasonably correct news.
@@gilblax8764 how? Because Ukraine wants to join NATO?
As an Americans, I'm ashamed of this broadcast full of misinformation. Disgusting!
These generals have more insight in one tv segment then I've seen for 2 months. Props to them.
They don't know anything
@@tuckersabath2099 hey War analyst tell us it seems u know more
More like they are blind
@Red Folgers yup,putin is gonna nuke the world. Too bad he doesn’t realize we have active defense around the globe 24/7 ready to shoot down nuclear missles from where they launch, causing a back fire 😎
@@davidseifferleinfilm it doesn't matter where they blow up. If Russia just self-destruct all their nukes on their own land it will still end the word. That American way of thinking is so stupid lol. Extreme ignorance has always been pounded into your heads.
Let's rephrase it now, Putin did a gambit to check mate NATO, but seems now to be about to be crushed by connected pawns.
These two Generals needed to sit in the international media. Very sound analogy.
It's just a pity that neither they nor their Country have condemed Russia' invasion, aggression and murders of civilians. Two fine generals ? I think not.
@@philyew3617 True..
@@philyew3617 Indian PM appealed president Putin to stopped the war and solved the issue diplomatic way. India as a state can't condemn Russia nor vote against 'em bcoz 70% of our military weapons are purchased from Russia
@@philyew3617
The West has invaded Iraq and killed 208,000 civilians, and invaded Afghanistan and killed 22,000. They have shown plenty of aggression towards many countries from South America to Asia, leaving plenty more civilian deaths that the West should be held accountable for.
India is remaining neutral towards the situation and have abstained in the UN vote regarding the Russo-Ukrainian Conflcit, so they shouldn't be criticised for doing so.
@@dallasschwalger1963 The West invaded Iraq and Afghanistan in response to terrorist attacks on several NATO countries. I'm not defending them, but the NATO attacks were not unprovoked. The Russian invasion of Ukraine was unprovoked. An attempt by Putin to deter Ukraine from becoming a NATO member and to prevent the country from developing a more western European economic structure.
“I know not with what weapons World War III will be fought, but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones.” Albert Einstein
@@BrightthgirB like your mom
He knew what weapons would used.
@@BrightthgirB still better than your leaders . Or any leader tbh .
@@BrightthgirB ??????
Yea because the nuke was created using his work .
Brilliant analysis
Thanks India, good job ..
This is the most civilized war I have ever seen Russia has only used 10% of their forces and they got cought on CCTV stopping at red lights letting local traffic move
Really?
It`s a russian bot ignore it
@@guyd7924 when its actually reversed......all the bots posting about how much courage people of Ukraine have and that they have to resist! wtf....war mongering at its finest..
This is true. There are many videos where locals shout at russians in anger who just ignore them. The only thing that Putin wants is a Ukraine that is not in NATO and which is not hostile to Russia.
@@Cchrist Yup i just saw it yesterday on youtube its a small clip where they are respecting the civilians and allowing them to move as te convoy keeps stopping for them to leave...The orders must be from higher officials to not disrupt the civilains and just execute your orders
As an American and very upset of what is happening to the Ukrainian people, it’s insights from these respected generals that give us pause to take a realistic view of what we can and cannot do. Since this war started I’ve read a lot of history about Russia, Ukraine, and American foreign policy in dealing with Russia and I keep coming back to the missed opportunities we had when the old Soviet Union collapsed. Why we didn’t attempt to work closer together and tried to build some kind of trust between us. Instead we came up with a policy to allow former Soviet states such as Georgia and Ukraine to join NATO right in the backyard of the Russian bear. Russia protested all these policies, but we kept pushing and now Putin is pushing back. Even the NATO allies at that time when President George W. Bush was president thought that wasn’t a very good idea but went along with it. Now we can’t protect those people and they’re being slaughtered on the streets and when it’s all over, the Russian will have achieved two objectives. One, bringing Ukraine back in line and part of Russia and finally the Ukrainian people will remember NATO and the United States abandoned them and will hate all of us for that. If the U.S. was in the same situation and Russia decided to let Mexico into its sphere of influence, do you think we would just sit by and allow that to happen? Hell no! Yep, we screwed the pooch on that one. God help us all if cooler heads don’t prevail. God bless the Ukrainian people
Correct
As a fellow American and Republican I completely agree. No more fighting foriegn wars to make the military industrial complex Deepstate parasites leech off American middle class blood. These sociopaths who overthrew our government with rigged elections now want to start NUCLEAR WW3.
America should have never been involved in the first place...Biden fault🤣
Yes, usa is no better than russia . Look at desert storm and operation Iracy freedom. War crimes there too
We are no better than Russia that is true but America is a different animal when attacked. Ukrainian had opportunity to join NATO and stalled. Bad move in my opinion. America did not want the land in Afghanistan they hide terrorist. Putin is a land grabbing dictator. This is not over one bit even if Ukrainian is won by Russia this hour. We will not forget, we will not forgive until it is time.
Quite objective analysis. SOUTH AFRICA
The mere fact the discussion is going this far and appearing normal , makes it almost certain than a full blown conflict is more likely than unlikely .
It’s amazing that America is supposed to be a free country and shining example for democracy and free speech. Got some of the best universities in the world… but your news shows a competency that’s lacking in American news. It’s not just a bunch of childish bickering and propagandist spewing lies and misinformation… I wish you guys success.
Facts it's the exact same here in Australia there news is so much better then ours an unbiased educated and factual report very rare to get one of those in Australia or most western countries tbh
Its just all propaganda
American and European news is more like George Soros's private channel. They cannot get out of their own created mess. Most of these printed newspapers can be used by Soros as toilet paper.
@Forfun62
You don’t think other countries would do this given the chance?
I think your main grievance is its the USA who saturates the news domain with its number of outlets. You do have the choice not to watch these, and it’s here where democracy sits not in these news outlets content.
Absolutely correct!
I love Indians, they give it to you straight
No they don't, they're usually attempting to steal your credit card details....
@@blehmeh3790 west has a problem when india develops it's own master card .. sad affairs.
I'd get on board and believe it, but you're just a nation of scammers.
@@blehmeh3790 will take that anyday in place of being called a nation that wages war on the name of democracy only to bomb babies not even having the guts to fight soldier to soldier
Taliban has guts atleast, u Americans hv it only in the movies
@@blehmeh3790 , 😂 scamming is common in all countries ...India has good IT development which are used by some bad guys to loot the money by scammers...
I suggested to Indian generals, please ask diplomatically to UK to return Indian holy diamond
Absolutely.....its true facts
As a Brit. It was refreshing to hear these two generals speaking. Sound common sense. In the west however, we're too concerned
about the lack of progress on gender-neutral school uniforms to bother about the Ukraine. Sorry.
In America Our Military Leaders more concerned with diversity of soldiers and which bathroom they should be using.
Both of you are ridiculous
To be fair, most of the west doesn't have school uniforms at all.
America is on its last leg and will topple over now that we have many enemies within our government and are hell bent on destroying us. American's are to blind to see what's under their own nose. We are no longer the big boss on the block. Our government is corrupt and just a bunch of criminals who live by their own set of rules and take what they want and pay no taxes. We are divided by race, class, religion, cultural and political parties and beliefs. We are a failing nation that is for sale to the highest bidder and our politicians are for rent. Come one come all. Well at least the world can use us for an immigration dumping ground. Inflation is out of control and the Arabs are bleeding our economy dry by jacking the price of oil so high. We are in for a big fall. Russia and China are the real superpowers and the rich OPEC countries can buy and control any of these whores they want.
We are ignoring heads of state freezing bank accounts of people they regard as rightwing terrorists
I *HIGHLY* admire this Lt. General Shokin Chauhan. Very insightful comments! Earned my respect right off.
6:26 : Please, change *NATO* with *US Army* , second, US was attacked , so US could ask NATO to act, as "threatening any NATO's member (and 🇧🇷) means threatening all"
NATO means *(N)* orth *(A)* tlantic *(T)* reaty *(O)* rganisation , so, it main duty is to protect the members, the North Atlantic Ocean and 🇧🇷.
When Venezuela was threatening us some years ago, US sent 60 fighter jets to our Northern Hemisphere border (border with Venezuela) *immediatly* .
So, the thing with Ukraine is that 1) It's *not* NATO's member and 2) We don't want WWW3, right? Respect Russia.
Please, understand that one thing is "US Army" and another thing is "US Army as NATO", same Army, different responsibilities.
A very precise, and thoughtful discussion, given the administration in USA, Ukraine may have to wait for regime change, before peace is possible.
I picked up some very good information here
OMG these indian Generals are very smart and know there war game and also know how the Russions fight and think ESPECIALLY when it comes to nucleair war and threats bravo 🎖️
Really how you guys know so much about India's military operations when it is not known to the general public is remarkable 🙄🙄
China has tried several time to take over our land and we have beaten them back every time. And we are smart enough not depend on others for our protection. They have never helped us before and never will. Our army, navy and airforce are more than capable enough. And read your news correctly, we are not with Russia or against Ukraine. We are NEUTRAL. You understand the meaning don't you? Because this whole scenario cannot be solved by continuing this war, but only through finding common ground and diplomacy. It's the people who are suffering and their protection and safety is paramount, which will not happen if the war drags on. Maybe always jumping into the field guns blazing should not be the first solution. Ever thought about that?
@Dylan Martinelli read about Galwan valley clash and why India refused to participate in winter Olympics held in China. It was even in your news 🙄🙄
The way you guys show your ignorance to all and sundry is just mind boggling. 🤣
@@bushman1492 russia has given there position on india china loong time ago kid
Thank god we have smart people like them on our side 🇮🇳💪💯🔥
As of today war update you should start disowning them. LOL.
Russia is not iraq, where American & NATO can invade .
Times good for India, Business is booming, International relations, chest cards play. India cannot be neutral, but i respect the well thought wisdom of the generals. Let us see what happens in coming days.
Well NATO is not being attacked so it’s not NATO’s fight. That’s the simple answer
Simpler answer is they are afraid of his nukes and his chemicals. Otherwise they would have wasted Russia long ago. If Ukraine already has fighters and aren't using them they best think twice.
Yes, and the fear of a third world war. India and China support and are supported by Russia
WRONG, thats a Manipulated NATO war made by America and the play field is Ukraine. Ukraine is the key point to start a war with russia and divide it in 6 Countrys.
@@standardname4022 finally someone who has a brain in this comment section. you are 100% on point!
This war is planned and instigated by NATO... it's simple
Utmost respect and gratitude to the highly esteemed Generals for their objective and meaningful enlightenment. Thank you
6:26 : Please, change *NATO* with *US Army* , second, US was attacked , so US could ask NATO to act, as "threatening any NATO's member (and 🇧🇷) means threatening all"
NATO means *(N)* orth *(A)* tlantic *(T)* reaty *(O)* rganisation , so, it main duty is to protect the members, the North Atlantic Ocean and 🇧🇷.
When Venezuela was threatening us some years ago, US sent 60 fighter jets to our Northern Hemisphere border (border with Venezuela) *immediatly* .
So, the thing with Ukraine is that 1) It's *not* NATO's member and 2) We don't want WW3, right? Respect Russia.
Please, understand that one thing is "US Army" and another thing is "US Army as NATO", same Army, different responsibilities.
@Bas Tra what this has to do with Russia ?
Yes ! No one else has better understanding & knowledgeable of Rus & Ukr than these 2 hounourable Great Generals . Honest truth . To the West , please take these 2 generals advices , to save face & ego to pull out , May peace come from these 2 great generals .
That sums it up. These generals get it.
India have given the best unbiased report's on this situation! Subbed and liked .
Peace from 🇬🇧
Ali, you beat me to it
100
No they haven't. Nato will f Russia up.
@@jimmiesmith5590 there will be no winner in a nuclear war between NATO and Russia
@@wallingnaga6563 YEA we know.
I'm not talking about a nuclear war. I am speaking in general regarding war alone.
Great analysis by two Indian generals. Russian generals have the experience and the expertise too. Putin is NOT the idiot that the western media propaganda depict him to be. If the Indian generals are able to see the picture clearly, what makes you think that the Russian experts are not (able to see).
Have fun with your sanctions and your genius Putin. Try to use a ATM lately?
I dont think anyone is thinking putin is an idiot. He is mad but he isnt stupid.
@@Mynipplesmychoice hes taking a country and the cost is the ATM not working for a day or 2, sanctions dont mean shit, we have weak leaders in the west, prepare for hard times
@@charleslovegrove834 He must be mad if he is threatening Nuking everybody if NATO starts fighting.
@@willwozniak2826 he has not threatened nukes, you have just taken what he said as nuking
I'm sure I just talked to those two generals the other day when I called customer service but got a call center in India instead. LOL
How do you know you wouldn't be fighting just Russia and not its allies too?
WORLD HYPOCRACYWhy the whole world responds like that in the Ukraine -Russian Conflict. Turkey invaded Cyprus and nobody gives a shit about it. Half of Cyprus is under Turkish occupation Now!! Nobody even comments about it! Is it because Turkey is a member of NATO. I just feel sorry for the ordinary people of Russia and Ukraine
Recall the illegal false flag operations that America created to attack Vietnam. Millions dead and injured. A whole country inflicted with Chemical weapons. Abnormal Babies still being born. No war crimes against the USA so far. The same story in Iraq and Libya, Serbia. All illegal wars. Iraq destroyed. A million dead, half a million children dead. Perpetual civil war. Hurrah Precision bombing. But we come in peace says America.
I know for sure soon or later Putin going to kiss every country ass especially united state of America
Russian economy going down real guickly
He make huge mistake to attack Ukraine
Now he going to pay the price.🤔.
The real matatan.🤔.
Yup all a smoke screen for the bigger picture
Nope. Turkey has also faced with similar sanctions at that time. The real hypocrisy is that The US & UK never get sanctioned for even worst actions.
The Indian people have garnered a lot of respect from me in recent days, very smart and logical people.
still they did not vote against Russia in UN, among China, North Korea etc
Indian people would likely side with Russia in WW3 since Pakistan likely side with US.
NATO doesn't go into Ukraine because it would set off WW3, right now it's just Russia vs Ukraine.
Until you receive an indian scam call
@@leonung7019 they're just out here trying to get money 🤷♂️
@@lookdawg187 bro u seriously believe pakistan will side with US? like come on you aint even trying. Pakistan will for sure 100% allign with russia. Doesnt matter how bad enemies pak and india are, no way in hell are they gonna allign with USA since country's interest is before anything and russia is our best partner for regional peace.
Game not over after 58 days...Mr.
What are you talking about ? NATO has been fighting Russia since 2014 !!
Respect to these Generals,with all my heart i hope they are right.Prefer peace to war,specially WW3.We live now under the threat of both.
These guys haven't a clue what they are talking about. It's funny listening to them,though.
How about USA invading 33 countries since World War 2?
What Zelenskij is crying about?
He made this mess himself!!!
How an actor can be a president?
He will resign to USA with good a "retirement" sum.
West paid him millions, unlike simple people.
You should pray for 40 people burned alive in Odessa by UKRAINIANS, you should pray for targeted and bombarded by UKRAINIANS russian children peacefully playing on the beach, you should pray for thousands other people tortured and killed in Donbass by UKRAINIAN Nazis!.
Or your media doesn't disclose to you this information about genocide of russian people over last 8 years in Donvass and Lugansk?
So, why is situation s"suddenly" danger? Maiby of yours closed eyes
@@rosemarin4750 "How can an actor be a president?"
AFAIK Arnold Schwarzenegger is an actor an governator of Califórnia and i didn't see people botheted by it, how can one affect the other negatively
@@rosemarin4750 It's possible to be impartial and yet stand for peace, I dont think it's healthy to shift blame. I personally hope both sides can come to a peaceful conclusion.
That armored personnel carrier running over a car turns out to be a Ukrainian APC accident circulated as Russian brutality. Let’s remember that truth is the first casualty of war and it’s our responsibility to take it all with a grain of salt.
That was russian you want the whole video?
I keep wondering why there are all these "lone wolf's" apparently deep inside enemy territory just allowed to go about their business like they were back in Russia, all by them lonesome selves, but if it's Ukrainian it makes sense for it to be alone in city streets 🤔
@@cornebod they were retreating in this particular case, there is another vehicle in the complete video where the russian soldiers are death (1 mt. from the other apc running over the civilian car)
That giant Z on the side of the APC seems to indicate it was in fact Russian.
ZzzzzzZzzzzZ
The real problem with NATO is that it had so many new members in the last decades and it makes difficult to a person from some countries to accept that it can be nuked because of a coutry that has nothing to do with is culture.
I am from Portugal. I think it would be more difficult to me to accept the risk of being nuked because of Ukraine instead a polish person. On the other hand, I must recognize that my country manages one of the largest exclusive economic zones, from our shore almost to America's EEZ and NATO's "umbrella" is a precious resource!
Peace ✌️ is the answer
Thank you to the Indian generals that appear to have actual in-the-field experience. I appreciate your insight.
While in the U.S. Navy I participated in war game scenarios at the Naval War College in Newport, Rhode Island. In separate rooms, each force would monitor the actions of the other, strategize, then react to the evolving situation. Its a lot easier done in a classroom atmosphere than it is in reality with lives and countries on the line.
And who are u fools ?😂
6:26 : Please, change *NATO* with *US Army* , second, US was attacked , so US could ask NATO to act, as "threatening any NATO's member (and 🇧🇷) means threatening all"
NATO means *(N)* orth *(A)* tlantic *(T)* reaty *(O)* rganisation , so, it main duty is to protect the members, the North Atlantic Ocean and 🇧🇷.
When Venezuela was threatening us some years ago, US sent 60 fighter jets to our Northern Hemisphere border (border with Venezuela) *immediatly* .
So, the thing with Ukraine is that 1) It's *not* NATO's member and 2) We don't want WWW3, right? Respect Russia.
Please, understand that one thing is "US Army" and another thing is "US Army as NATO", same Army, different responsibilities.
They stated the obvious. Well done captain obvious and general malaise.
@@aquamastertheonlyone
If you were Ukrainian
How would you feel about NATO shelling your city with tomahawk cruise missles to liberate and protect you from the russians who are also just trying to liberate the non Nazi Ukrainian people from the poo-zionist NATO motherfrackers pimping the country into poking the bear --- in njew world order to falsely justify blaming Putin for starting WW3.
Nobody should be against
Ukraine's independence and sovereignty ---
(as long as no natives need to be evicted first) but the NATO has NO business arming Ukraine to the teeth like they did with the other proverbial 'holy land' ...
Don't poke the bear.
What ever happened to Khasaria?
( now called Ukraine )
Did'nt the khasarian mafia (deceptacon hex-nutz) eventually migrate over to europe to inbreed with the royal debt based banksters ? Ya know that sect of pale imposters that got rid of a big chunk of honest to goodness bronze skin hebrews that adamantly objected to the rebuilding of the temple in Jerusalem until the messiah shows up as according to scripture) in order to hijack Palestinian region and turn it into the genocidal megalomaniac kosher-supremacist den of thieves and tourist-trap attraction it is today ?
Nobody knows exactly How many (US bought) Nukes Isreal has pointing out in every direction to make sure no other insolent 'heathen' nation trys anything funny.
Being hellbent on total world domination is fixing to get funny any day now too... Shlalom motherschuckers !
It is an emergency
For them uppity socialist elitists that tend to grant all those nice 'FRINGE BENEFITS' to their own insider cheater-class accessories to the plandemic hijacking of humanity and gradually increasingly hostile takeover of planet earth ...
Lucifer knows his time is up ! Welcome to the worldwide wireless concentration cramp !
maybe if we'd kiss our corporate cattlerancher state pharmer KINGPIMPS of gangstas pair-o-dice asses hard enough --- they might treat us a little better huh ? (Stockholm syndrome)
We best start sharpening our mental shivs yawl.
Hold fast (intermittent fasting from the poi-zion food and information supply) ,
and stay vigilant (meditation is prayer) --- to achieve Goddesspeed yawl. Time to conscientiously rip the goddamn blindfold MASK veil off Lady Justice --- so she can properly thrash that greedy-sadistic judiciously corrupt fraternity of pig-raping motherfrackers out of the equation entirely. . .
We need to change "good mourning." into "good dawning !" REJOICE for the kingdom of heaven is in play ! FREEK-OUT !
And BIG PEACE to all honest to goodness children of the earth ...
@@jowlorenz9555 And Elvis. Don't forget Elvis!
Iraq and Afghanistan were not being actively invaded by Russia when the US entered with coalition forces. Hence they would not come into direct conflict with another nuclear power. This is the ultimate checkpoint of this argument. Do you want two nuclear powers fighting each other directly?
@Visalakshi Mahadevan bot
@Visalakshi Mahadevan Bot
@Visalakshi Mahadevan bot
Yes
@Visalakshi Mahadevan bot
This aged really well huh?!
It's in the court of UN to fight Russia not NATO
I do respect these generals points of view and military experience. Very honest and direct. So salute to them both.
Yes they are not bl**dy politicians. That’s why they are speaking the truth not beating about the bush.
India stand is clear, let their be peace in the whole world, the USA and Russia are close allies of India. We appeal to both Ukraine and Russia to restrain from involving in nuclear conflict, they should immediately conduct peaceful talks, and deescalate the tension.
@@jaihindvandemataram4043 Russia can surrender and retreat out of Ukraine. Russia started the war of aggression.
@@TorianTammas Wrong. Ukraine did it with repeteadly flouting Minsk and shelling Donbas, eastern pro russian Ukraine and killing 14k.
6:26 : Please, change *NATO* with *US Army* , second, US was attacked , so US could ask NATO to act, as "threatening any NATO's member (and 🇧🇷) means threatening all"
NATO means *(N)* orth *(A)* tlantic *(T)* reaty *(O)* rganisation , so, it main duty is to protect the members, the North Atlantic Ocean and 🇧🇷.
When Venezuela was threatening us some years ago, US sent 60 fighter jets to our Northern Hemisphere border (border with Venezuela) *immediatly* .
So, the thing with Ukraine is that 1) It's *not* NATO's member and 2) We don't want WWW3, right? Respect Russia.
Please, understand that one thing is "US Army" and another thing is "US Army as NATO", same Army, different responsibilities.
6:48 It is incomplete . He actually said "Anyone who tries to interfere with us, or even more so, to create threats for our country and our people, must know that Russia's response will be immediate and will lead you to such consequences as you have never before experienced in your history". 🥶🤒 After this no one would dare .
Putin lang SAKALAM
Putin doesn't want that war. US would annihilate Russia so fast that it wouldn't be funny.
@@znothingfacez5681 Is anyone supposed to WANT war?
@@znothingfacez5681 it would be mutually assured destruction. But Russia has less to loose.
I would not bet my next military
shipment on that, "shaky"
Right from the start. That tank riding over that car was an Ukrainian tank. Research it.
Even ukraine is not ready for war. But when you NEED to defend and protect everything you love, that changes the game. ✌️✌️✌️
Ofcourse when there is question of existence you are going to fight not the case with nato tho rn
You're a clever little spunkbubble aren't you?
Even a farmer can fight (There's a video about a Ukrainian farmer towing away a Russian tank with his old tractor...😅).
War can be avoided by just saying No to NATO. Unnecessary war written on people life. Political issues not handled properly leads to wars like this.
Zelensky is a big fool u should admire the fact....he should immediately sign peace treaty with Russia as NATO has shown their true colors to save innocent lives....in any case he has to do that sooner or later...willingly or forcibly
Great Commentary:
1) The fact that Putin has played the nuclear card already shows that he is nervous.
2) Nato is playing it smart. Let the Russians get bogged down in an unpopular war while resupplying the Ukrainian forces/insurgents.
You nailed it. This isn't about winning by fighting them directly but rather giving them enough time to fail properly so that change can happen from within.
Ofcourse making Ukrainian the 😭 scape goat . USA played dirty pushing Russia so far that they retaliated.
@@nayakpaswan Best and Most truthful comment on the thread.
You could be right if Putin was a regular guy... I don't think one second that he is nervous. Most people forget. Russia has nothing to loose while the west has lost pretty much everything in the past few years. This militay action has actualy little to do with Ukrain!
@@nayakpaswan the biden guy is looking like a fool already...he has been tagged the weakest president
The game isn't over, not by a long shot. As long as the Ukrainian army is fighting, resisting and outperforming the attacking Russian army, the game is still on. Ukraine at least is making excellent use of the weapons and other equipment given by the NATO countries and other countries in the world. What has India done or have it given any support for the Ukrainians, even after the atrocities done by the Russian army to civilians in Mariupol, Bucha and other Ukrainian cities and villages? The NATO might not yet be ready for a full scale war but that doesn't mean it is powerless. War isn't only about manpower and numbers, it is also about equipment quality, training, resolve, command & control, tactics and intelligence. At least the Ukrainian and also NATO soldiers knows what they are fighting for if it comes to pass, does the average Russian soldier knows it too?
You think all of that could happen without a nuclear response
I am living in the West and am very proud to see Indians having such great depth and understand of this situation.
unbiased too. That's why I'm here. All western media is very biased.
Indians are some of the most intelligent people I ever met. I remember a classmate named Ikball till today. I still have love for Pakistan too. [ I'm A Haitian man who grew up in Bridgeport Connecticut]
And yet only 1 of 4 countries to abstain from condemning the Russian invasion at the UN. Disgraceful, regardless how much they depend on Russia
So please tell me India what's is it you have done ?? ZERO !! and you always do Zero !!
There people to they understand.
How to find un-biased media during war time? Look for a part of the world that has no stake in it, and is neutral. In this case India fits the mark.
Awesome analisis!
WRONG! India is actually very buddy buddy with Russia. I wouldn't trust anything right now, except common sense. Oh wait Putler threw that out the window too.
India supporting Russia. CNN, FOX, DW, etc support Ukraine. You want to see un-biased media? Try Wakanda tv
India is biased towards Russia, they are both part of BRICS
Indian media is too much biased. You are self praising. Besides all the biasness, Indian biasness against Pakistan without any failure comes out at any platform or any situation. Everyone knows Pakistan and India are nuclear armed neighbours so why did you bring this here (at 9:34) as it seems irrelevant in Russian/ Ukrainian situation. On top, you saying India successfully stroke Pakistan but you didn't tell your audience that you carried out those strikes in night at random place. However Pakistan gave you fitting reply during broad day light, shooting down Indian airforce jets, capturing your pilot and releasing him as goodwill gesture after serving him fantastic tea. Also your own ground forces shot down your own helicopter.
@@izzaqazi4183 we invaded your airspace at night. And your "SUPER POWER'' air force couldn't even stop us violating your air space. Pakistan said .. we couldn't able to see them at night. Thats pakistan airforce
In 1945 America and its allies were dealing with 3 countries(Italy,Germany and Japan) but today they know that it will be more than 50 countries to deal with. And 50 countries, you know, America would loose
did you forget that the USA and Europe left Afghanistan with their tails between there legs
In this western media blocked out balanced information about what really happening in Ukraine, Indian news front providing the needed information with smaller bias than the western counterpart.
Gonna be honest, Rusia abusing its veto power was one of the dirtiest moves of the book.
Rússia targeting all civil areas including hospitals and now Nuclear power plants is the most irresponsible course of action I have seen.
Is hard to be imparcial, but so far I was just giving facts. One more thing pointed out, Nato doesnt have weapons as pointed out by the generals, I wonder of what a bit of the threat they could be.
Voting for their interest is abusing power. lol
Bet you didn't whine when we (US) bombed hospitals, cultural sites, etc in Yugoslavia, even an embassy. Bet you haven't whined about the loss of civilian lives in the second Iraq war, or those between the two. Bet you didn't say anything when Ukraine accepted their far right into their govt, nor when that far right massacred the other civilians.
What BS, western countries even show Russia state propaganda and the effectiveness of their constant lies on much of the Russian population.
Russia is claiming to be threatened yet you heard it ... they outnumber Ukrainian forces massively and NATO isn't tasked with defence of Ukraine.
@@Yvtq8K3n Russia is not targeting civil areas, they want to spare the civil infrastructure. They know they have to restore it in the future. Many Russians have close relatives in Ukraine. Of course they don't want to kill them. Dont' listen to propaganda. Ukrainians nazis aka "Azov" were killing russian speaking civilians in East Ukraine. They were bombing cities in Donbass, thousands died. Western media doesn't cover it because it's following NATO agenda.
@@anabona4764 Thanks for replying. I did quite alot of investigation;) It is really hard to be impercial, but bare with me.
If something feels bias, please correct me;)
History:
1) The Puppet State
It all started when the president refused to sign a "great" deal with European Union and instead signed with Russia. This led civils to started protesting, originating diferent moviments including the avoc. After a while the protests gave raise to a civil war, and the president ran to russia.
2) Anexation of Crimea
In response, Russia sized this opportunity to anex Crimea(not judging here;)) In retaliation the ukranians closed Crimea ONLY water supply, forcing it to drought. This conflit fuel even more the nationalist spirit of ukranians. I belive at this time, the bombardements of Dognbas(sorry if I misspelled it;( ) started between pro-west and pro-russians.
3)"Russian Agression"
After years of conflit, russia decided to invade ukrain by force when ukrain was about to join Nato. The Article 5 of Nato, would prevent russia from helping the separatist regions and with an attempt to prevent Ukrain from joining Nato, it initialized a full scale attack. At first it just target the "pro-russian regions", but in a full scaled operation it attempted to sieze kyev and touple the legitment government.
Retrospective: Putin "invasion" of the pro-russian regions of Ukrain seems "acceptable". However, attempting to touple a legitment government to force the adoptiong of a puppet state that serves the interest of russia, is where I have to draw the line. The claim of "neo-nazis" shouldnt be an excuse, Putin should have attempted a diplomatic resolution.
It's enlightening to have these two Indian generals sharing their insights and well thought reasoning over the issues relating to the Russia-Ukraine current war situation. Salute to you Sirs.
Selensky from the time he is elected v know this comedy will play out..... It was just the appropriate time... Nato uses comedians to thr bidding from Poland to Bulgaria, just coz they r the agents for publishing the dollor
@@DK-sg3oe Russian bot , you feeling those sanctions yet bro ? Pssst it’s only going to get worse . Get out of Ukraine , get rid of that tyrant that is hurting your country and things will slowly go back to some sense of normalcy. Glory to Ukraine ! 🇺🇦
@@DK-sg3oe lol he spelled dollar wrong...haha...they never gonna see another one!!
I would also add as an American they speak clearer and better english than I do.
@@DuVey64 no American dollor from sanitary tissue 😎😎😎😎😎😎... Use ur intellect capability occasionally... If ur a Ukraine u can't drag ur ass near American continent so what's better either u want 2b bring nato to Russia doorsteps which nato wishes 2 spread its dollor so that ur country can become its slave and just for the feeling u get that u have become invincible...... But the issue is they will not publish dollor just for ur fun all the time.. So either get rid of ur stupid comedian and the joke ur becoming u can fight no doubt but beleive me ur future is tied to ur region unless u pack ur bags to US... Irrespective of what.... Making urself a puppet in the hands for a few doesn't mean much when u look at history and history repeats itself so either way stay on the right side of things..... Consider this an opportunity 2 correct.... Ukrainians nd Russians... I am neither.... Have a shared future and same places to go either today or Tom dont for a few dollors pleasure get things wrong... But then I am no one 2advice 😎😜😜😜😜
To show how powerful russia is. 2 months later. Ukraine.......hold my beer.
Looks like since then Ukraine has proven the generals wrong.
Listening to 5minutes of these war experienced general's analysis is 100 times better than 1 hour of Arnab or Rajdeep rubbish.
Please do tell what war have they experienced? PlayStation doesn't count.
I'm sorry but what war have they experienced I'm mean really what experience do they have at all
I wouldn't exactly call those generals "war experienced".
@@zzzubmno2755 There is this old well known all over the world rule that generals like to fight previous war... Generals often are stuck in times when they were captains or majors and were actualy in field and young.
Ukraine got modern Piorun MANPADs from Poland and modern NLAW to destroy tanks and armored vehicles and Turkish armed drones... On top of that Russia have crapy logistics and strong believe in own propaganda(one of the worst thing in the war).
Russia plan was to get Kiev in 48 hours and instal pupet government in less than 72 hours.
They have no Kiev, no government, no air-superiority and forces are out of fuel and suplies....
Or the mindless warmongering that you get from American generals.
Very Interesting to hear an analysis from two general officers from India. It gave me some things to consider that I am unlikely to hear in the US.
Exactly my thoughts. The western response has been WAY too extreme - Way too quick, Way too optimistic, Way too blatantly anti-russian, Way too pro-unkranian, Way too uncharacteristically united - to be real. It's all a huge, planned propaganda campaign. Why? Because we know how this kind of conflict plays out. It's happened a hundred times over the past 2 decades, here there and everywhere.We know the response from international organizations like the UN, We know the Media coverage, we know the US response, We know how the conflict plays out. This conflict has WAY exceeded anything close to normal reaction, despite being a relatively normal military conflict. The exact same thing happened in Crimea in 2014 and Georgia in 2008, to Drastically different responses. Why the explosive backlash this time? Because it's been planned, coordinated, staged, and a executed by the west - governments, media, and businesses - for a long time. This was the perfect trigger for this plan of action, long in the making, And they've overdone it, which for me really takes away any authenticity of any of the western response. You don't care about the people of Ukraine, If you did you'd have helped Ukraine join NATO years ago. You're drooling over how perfect of a situation this is for shaping public opinion about Russia - The greatest threat to the US's (and western world's) current, and fading, global dominance. "Ohh man, Those poor Ukrainian people, Look at how awful Russia is, Russia's really terrible, Can we all agree Russia is awful and everyone do everything they can to hurt Russia economically and technologically and financially so we can eliminate the risk them overtaking us as the world's dominate superpower? That'd really help us stay in power, and the Ukrainian people too, Remember this is totally about them, and not at all about us trying to hurt our greatest rival."
The icing on the cake is how the EU is trying to ban RT and other Russian news sites. Gotta love that commitment to Freedom and Democracy ! If you start hearing factual, Not emotional, arguments about the situation, it might undo all the propaganda the west has gotten from this golden situation , I mean Horrible Situation for the people of Ukraine.
@@Stone_624 very true 👍
@@Stone_624I'm confused. You pro Russia, or Ukraine?
And what does the U.S. have to do with Russia invading Ukraine?
these are pro Russian so it is quite biased! he got the 30% Russian support wrong (as did Putin), the majority in Ukraine still remember and live the aftermath of the Soviet era, If they give up they may as well be dead so why not fight to the death, the human factor is so important in a war as are the soldiers, Russia's mainly conscript army (mostly teenagers) are no match for those fighting for their lives. Putin may take the gas reserves but he will have to exterminate millions to take control of the country that the Russian people wont be able to swallow.
@@Yroc5000 us is the most influential member of nato
Tens of thousands of Nato troops in Ukraine western border
? I never heard that
The best weapon for war is {°peace°}
Nice assessment of the conflict.May there be peace in the world.
🔥🔥 Since the game of COVID began, I've began to doubt and question everything happening around the world from wars, to protests, to threats, to almost everything.
COVID game has just open our eyes to realise at what extent the criminal elites and businessmen are willing to brainwash the masses with fake narratives, suppressing dissent, creating fake images to spread fear, banning, censoring and controlling the News and media , all for their Power, Position and Profits.
Now everything happening in the world must be looked from that perspective if what we see in the news and social media just about everything is the real whole story? Or is it just what the criminal elites want us to see and think to shape our mindset as per their agenda?
There is always something different and contrasting happening behind the screen than whats on the screen. Every tiny piece of information we see and hear must be cross-questioned.
Question always. Dissent is what keeps the humanity and honesty alive..
Global peace can be achieved after the belligerent West, as history has shown, is contained. The process has started in Ukraine!
6:26 : Please, change *NATO* with *US Army* , second, US was attacked , so US could ask NATO to act, as "threatening any NATO's member (and 🇧🇷) means threatening all"
NATO means *(N)* orth *(A)* tlantic *(T)* reaty *(O)* rganisation , so, it main duty is to protect the members, the North Atlantic Ocean and 🇧🇷.
When Venezuela was threatening us some years ago, US sent 60 fighter jets to our Northern Hemisphere border (border with Venezuela) *immediatly* .
So, the thing with Ukraine is that 1) It's *not* NATO's member and 2) We don't want WWW3, right? Respect Russia.
Please, understand that one thing is "US Army" and another thing is "US Army as NATO", same Army, different responsibilities.
@@aquamastertheonlyone 🎆🎉🙃