Video není dostupné.
Omlouváme se.

संवाद # 114: Colonel Hunny Bakshi's unique solution to solve Manipur crisis, message to Manipuris

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 17. 08. 2024
  • Colonel (retd) Hunny Bakshi is a decorated Indian army officer who led the Technical Support Division (TSD), a covert intelligence counter terror ops unit.
    0:00 Full credit to Nagas
    4:58 Tribal conflicts
    6:02 Don’t blame Indian Army now
    8:03 The AFSPA factor
    13:52 How hostile is Manipur territory for Army
    18:00 Illegal migrants & refugees factor
    20:54 Angrez factor
    22:46 ‘Guns from China’ factor
    23:13 The Church factor
    25:19 Bring back AFSPA!
    28:15 China’s investment in North East
    30:18 Meira Paibi - How the women operate
    31:50 Difficult geography makes it hard to do Ops in Manipur
    34:37 AFSPA लाना पड़ेगा - Magistrate model won’t work
    36:07 The Afeem factor
    39:13 No Religious angle in Manipur?
    41:08 The sheer brutality in killings
    43:30 Should NE states be reorganised
    45:41 Women of some tribes have a separate language in NE
    46:35 Manipur violence a huge setback for India
    47:57 North East’s crazy internal fault lines
    52:36 Will UCC worsen NE situation?
    53:32 We treated North East people badly
    55:08 Church has created intense divisions but
    57:07 What Centre Must Do - How to use Army
    1:01:11 Importance of Naga HoHo
    1:02:06 कुछ तो planned था
    1:03:38 Colonel’s message to Manipuris
    1:05:18 पाकिस्तान का तेल ख़त्म - क्या करेगा भारत

Komentáře • 1,7K

  • @arunsingh6342
    @arunsingh6342 Před rokem +283

    Being a Manipuri Meetei,happy to listen a neutral interview keeping everything open secret.Hats off.

    • @tonydcunha5521
      @tonydcunha5521 Před rokem +5

      Very good accurate message hope the Government make a right use of this message.

    • @tonydcunha5521
      @tonydcunha5521 Před rokem +4

      Very good session

    • @ManishPatel-qv3gk
      @ManishPatel-qv3gk Před rokem

      YES ALL 3 community leader should be called - NAGA, MEITEIS, KUKIS - But BIREN SINGH is a BASTARD - I Love younsters - but not in every field - this Idiot is interviewing an ARMY MAN - really Good - but he doesnt know law - ATLEAST BASIC KNOWLEDGE is necessary - no home work on NORTH EAST - little knowlegde is SHIT - see - AID to CIVIL SOCIETY - Army cant FIRE - YES - PEOPLE DIE in FIRING - its serious - WHAT ABOUT POLICE ROLE in MANIPUR - Disgusting - Biren Singh BASTARD had allowed Police ARMOURIES to be LOOTED - what the HELL - no Recovery PLAN for the LOOTED Arms and Ammo - There should be a deep learned person who should be interviewing

    • @fahimahmed6236
      @fahimahmed6236 Před rokem

      ​@@tonydcunha5521a66newes hy677

    • @raosahabni5936
      @raosahabni5936 Před rokem +3

      🙏🙏

  • @langfeitravellers3051
    @langfeitravellers3051 Před rokem +423

    I am a Manipuri. 90% of what the Colonel had said is absolutely true.

    • @AdityaKadamMechanical
      @AdityaKadamMechanical Před rokem +10

      Which 10% part you felt was not accurate?

    • @langfeitravellers3051
      @langfeitravellers3051 Před rokem +38

      ​@@AdityaKadamMechanicalI would like to thank the Colonel for his unbiased comments on the Manipur issue. The Colonel being the supporter of the Indian Army and he belongs to the family of the Indian Army he wanted to impose AFSPA on Manipur. Many of my family and friends are serving the Indian Army, Navy and Airforce. I have a lot of respect for their contributions to the country. However I am totally against AFSPA. AFSPA must be completely revoked from our country. It was imposed since the 11th of September 1958. It has been removed only within the limits of some police stations. However AFSPA is still imposed in a major part of Manipur. If any of the so-called revolutionary or separatists or terrorists movement could not stop by imposing AFSPA since the last 65 years. What is the point of imposing AFSPA in Manipur? AFSPA is still imposed till today where all the major poppy cultivation areas of Manipur. There are many poppy cultivation areas around the 5 kilometres radius of Assam Rifles Camp. AFSPA is still imposed in that area. But why haven't they exposed them to the national media for the last 10 to 20 years? AFSPA is a reincarnation of the British-era legislation that was enacted to quell the protests during the Quit India movement. (1) It has been dubbed as a license to kill. The main criticism of the Act is directed against the provisions of Section 4, which gives the armed forces the power to open fire and even cause death, if prohibitory orders are violated. (2) The people of Manipur have witnessed security forces of having destroyed homes merely on the suspicion that insurgents were hiding there. They point out that Section 4 empowers the armed forces to arrest citizens without warrant and keep them in custody for several days. (3) There are several instances where the armed forces have been found to be misusing the oppressive powers given by the Act like fake encounters, sexually exploiting the women in disturbed areas. What is more disturbing is the fact that the armed forces escape with impunity for their actions since legal suits cannot be filled against them as per the Act. Thus AFSPA clearly violates human rights. (4) AFSPA has failed to contain terrorism and restore normalcy in disturbed areas, as the number of armed groups has gone up after the Act was established.

    • @veesaga9355
      @veesaga9355 Před rokem +11

      ​@@langfeitravellers3051yep, totally agree. Some of the Assam Rifles are involved in the drug trade, strict action needs to be taken against them.

    • @endless812
      @endless812 Před rokem +2

      ​@@langfeitravellers3051well said 👌👌🎉

    • @bickydey7903
      @bickydey7903 Před rokem +6

      ​​​@@langfeitravellers3051assam rifles and indian army are two different organization i hope u know

  • @coloneldatoajayahlawat16th71
    @coloneldatoajayahlawat16th71 Před 7 měsíci +2

    Honey bakshi has always been one of the most upright and daredevil hearted man. May he and his family always shine and stay happy. Proud to have such officer in the Indian army.

  • @kananlaishram1836
    @kananlaishram1836 Před rokem +135

    As a Manipuri I profoundly thanks to you sir and agreed about all the issues you have spoken and reason behind the ongoing violance... AFSPA must be exercise in Manipur but to remind you sir Arm millitants activity in Imphal valley is almost 99% finish since CM IBOBI SINGH times but it must be wiped off from Hills areas also either it may be Naga , Kuki or Meitei Millitants and no SOO agreement with Insurgency under the mask of Terrorists agenda for a prosperous peaceful and bright feature of Manipur...jai hind sir.

    • @loveislove9211
      @loveislove9211 Před rokem +6

      These ethnic fights will take the region 30 years back.

    • @svicky5665
      @svicky5665 Před rokem +1

      Shram from manipur really

    • @Terimaakabhos
      @Terimaakabhos Před rokem +6

      99 percent free in valley?? Seriously?? 😂😂😂

    • @sanjaymaini3537
      @sanjaymaini3537 Před rokem

      You should be shamefull you ppl have nacked and raped a women in front of hundred ppl. You meitei are not human why delhi ppl cal you jangli.. I m frm dehi and frm delhi university..manipuri jungli hi rahega..

    • @MegaPitchblender
      @MegaPitchblender Před rokem +1

      Thibobi systematicaly disarmed and maimed valley instead of making SoO to meitei revolutioneries.

  • @va8085
    @va8085 Před rokem +92

    I was waiting for someone to bring Hunny sir for the Manipur issue. Glad you did, Arihant 🍻

    • @KantaRathore-ri2ir
      @KantaRathore-ri2ir Před rokem

      He knows clear picture of mani pur. He participated in that NE.

  • @realscrewdriver8102
    @realscrewdriver8102 Před rokem +169

    Respect for Indian army has increased 10 folds after listening to this podcast.

  • @purnimakayina214
    @purnimakayina214 Před rokem +27

    Tons of respect for Colonel Hunny Bakshi for his wide range of information and experiences he had of NE particularly Manipur and Nagaland.
    Please bring PEACE to Manipur and restore tanqulity as before. You know the ground reality , Ethenicity and pulse of the people.
    God bless YOU.

  • @Kamikaze-pilot.
    @Kamikaze-pilot. Před rokem +8

    Such a humble and kind hearted Colonel who'd not just speak his mind but the minds of others too.
    And as a Naga i must say the Colonel sahib knows very well that once the Nagas get into this conflict, there's either a Naga or none, the marshal instincts that had done away with the practices of the past.
    God bless sir...

  • @unnatichavan7021
    @unnatichavan7021 Před rokem +23

    Heartly salute to Col Hunny Prabhuji for his straight forward explanation. Thanks to Arihant and his team for this wonderful session.

  • @luluboxpro5553
    @luluboxpro5553 Před rokem +22

    Huge respect to Colonel Sir Bakshi (from Meghalaya)

  • @rs123in
    @rs123in Před rokem +36

    He is a living legend and real life hero. Salute to Hunny Bakshi

  • @anuragdeolia448
    @anuragdeolia448 Před rokem +33

    भारत अकेला देश है जहां आतंकवादियों के मानवाधिकार के लिये सरकारें, अदालतें, संस्थायें बचाने के लिये खड़ी हो जाती हैं...

    • @ManishPatel-qv3gk
      @ManishPatel-qv3gk Před rokem

      Yes Bharat 550 rajya se judkar bana - aur yeh Hindutva Christians and Muslims be beda garad Kiya hai - be Atheist - believe only Truth and nothing else - but everyone wants God - ladou maro

    • @pravinathomas8238
      @pravinathomas8238 Před rokem

      That’s means anybody asking for there religion orientation in this country should be declared terrorist.

  • @dbgurung2219
    @dbgurung2219 Před rokem +19

    Thank you Colonel for explaining the situation of Manipur, I hope people from Manipur hear and adhere to your suggestions. A big salute to u sir, Jai Hind.

  • @harjeetmann9976
    @harjeetmann9976 Před rokem +19

    No participation of Nagas in the conflict also indicates that there is something besides the reservation issue...

  • @tapasmaji1567
    @tapasmaji1567 Před rokem +93

    I am a army person. Army officer gives correct advice, government must follow his advice. Jay hind.

    • @Shoumik222_negi
      @Shoumik222_negi Před rokem

      Sorry

    • @GST_Wallah
      @GST_Wallah Před rokem +2

      Not everyone is perfect and no one does the work or assessment perfectly with zero error..
      Even army officer are bound to do mistake and take decision goes wrong
      We human learn from mistakes and hurdles to overcome obstacles....
      So, Big No
      They have their own weakness and drawbacks
      I don't mean to belittle the Army Officer's
      But it is what it is
      Everyone is unique in their own way
      Sometimes A civilian or non uniform servicemen advice can be more productive and fruitful than the army officers or army personnel

    • @charbak9071
      @charbak9071 Před rokem +3

      @@GST_Wallah Like Morarji Desai (Ex P.M) Speaking/divulging the Secret about our 11 Scientists to Pakistan !Eh ?

    • @PrakashKumar-fw3ou
      @PrakashKumar-fw3ou Před rokem

      कुछ भी हो सेना को आतंक कुचलने के लिए बिशेष अधिकार देना चाहिए,

    • @GST_Wallah
      @GST_Wallah Před rokem +1

      ​​​​@@charbak9071does sharing/leaking of secret has anything to do with the army officers or the civilian!?
      President of India, is the Commander in Chief of Armed Forces
      And she too is a civilian and not uniform staff
      What about, who are non uniform staff and did exemplary service to the country
      To name one:APJ ABDUL KALAM,he could have share any secret nuclear capabilities.
      That's your logical example quoting
      Abdul Kalam was also a non uniform staff whose advice is more impactful than most of the army officer's..
      Non-Uniform service person are no less than the uniform personnel
      No doubt army personnel respect is always for their service to the country
      But
      Non uniform service person also serves their country on their own way and equally important and advisable for the countries security and safety...

  • @PK-tq4ms
    @PK-tq4ms Před rokem +52

    Capt Neikezhakuo Kenguruse , Maha Veer Chakra Kargil War , just twenty five years was from Nagaland . Jai Hind

  • @Aashu299
    @Aashu299 Před rokem +49

    Sir is right. I have worked in Delhi NCR and met many NE people. They are very friendly but these Dilliwallas treat them with utter contempt. They often complain about that.

    • @nikhilsharma7
      @nikhilsharma7 Před rokem +16

      Bhai Delhi wallas treat Delhi wallas with contempt.. Log dilpe le jaate hain. But not everyone is like that.

    • @dontlies7665
      @dontlies7665 Před rokem +2

      Not everyone is like that. But what happens is some of them are really awkward. And they all look alike despite of being from different communities of NE. That's why they are all clubbed together. So it is better they prove their worth by their behaviour. And expecting any kind of respect on Delhi roads and buses is a distant dream.

    • @maitobatakhu9389
      @maitobatakhu9389 Před rokem +5

      @@nikhilsharma7 if someone speaks to you in a rude way, of course, you feel bad. And god knows for what thing they are so entitled. It's just northeastern part doesn't have money or investment, yet they outclass any state in terms of living standards and public etiquette. On the other hand, here people have everything yet they do stupid things in the name of culture.

    • @dontlies7665
      @dontlies7665 Před rokem

      Manipuris are extremely unreliable leaving exceptions. I have had both types as friends.

    • @Sunny12-23
      @Sunny12-23 Před rokem

      Delhites are so entitled that they treat everyone rudely. Sorry to say but Delhi probably has the rudest people in the country. The only thing is they are rude to everyone even each other.

  • @rishighosh5099
    @rishighosh5099 Před rokem +13

    Colonel Bakshi sir is a very optimistic and pragmatic person. His experience and his knowledge is unparalleled even by standards of several top army generals who give their advices as experts on defence issues. He is an inspiration for aspiring defence aspirants especially those youngsters who don't care much about how high they go in the rank but how much impact that they can create in their career. Thankyou very much to Arihant Bhai for bringing Bakshi sir on the podcast. Also Thankyou very much to Bakshi sir for his selfless service for the nation and for his valuable insights.

  • @Johnysweekly1906
    @Johnysweekly1906 Před rokem +13

    Huge respect to Colonel sir from Arunachal Pradesh.

  • @Trollji
    @Trollji Před rokem +18

    I have spent 20 years of my life in the north east and have seen people turning from rabbit to lion whenever borders are crossed 😅

  • @apollosingh
    @apollosingh Před rokem +75

    Thank you Colonel Bakshi for explaining the complex situation of #ManipurViolence so clearly.

  • @chatrapatishivajithegreat2998

    When you closely watch affairs in Nagaland and Manipur you feel systemic injustices of Indian constitution against hardworking labours mostly hindus from Bengal Bihar and Assam who are living like beggers for many generation without any rights in so called tribal areas. While well organised rich Christan Kukis and Nagas, having completely western european lifestyle, still opposing UCC on fake ground of tribal customary practice. They are bargaining with govt through well equiped armies inside and outside India, enjoying all benefits of poor tribals of CG, Jharkahnd, Orissa like reservation, exclusive land rights and additionally zero income tax, which is denied to poor hindus of Assam and Meities of Manipur.
    Part of solution is Central govt immidiately needs to stop wasting thousands of crores hard earned taxpayer money for full funding of state budget and bring them to senses by asking to earn their bread and butter. As no development is reaching to ground, almost whole amount is going to insurgents through rampant corruption and underground tax collection. While poor villgers dieing for basic facilites, insurgents enjoying 7 star lifestyle with huge bunglows, fleet of luxury car in cities along with zero income tax, which also used by many marwadis for opening business in bogus propritory of tribals 😆😆😆

    • @manglem10
      @manglem10 Před rokem

      I totally agree ! Christian missionaries have taken kuki issue to European Parliament because kukis are Christians!
      These missionaries think only churches are worshipping place hence they have not reported on kuki burning down of 50-60 important hindu as well well indigenous meitei temples in manipur!
      For hindu meiteis and general meitei every home has temple, they have burned 2000-3000 meiteis houses that's with temples and deities!
      National media has also favored kuki narratives! Kuki are trying to build a seperate land where only Christians lived within India! Militants are fighting in the name Christ!!

    • @FarhanAnwarOfficial
      @FarhanAnwarOfficial Před rokem +1

      RSS terrorist spotted 😂

    • @nagarat7308
      @nagarat7308 Před rokem

      ​@@manglem10these narco terrorists need to be taught a proper lesson

    • @redundancy100
      @redundancy100 Před rokem +2

      Can't agree more

    • @user-dl2dd1je4x
      @user-dl2dd1je4x Před 11 měsíci

      100% 👌🏻 All the points are the actual facts.

  • @manjujain9864
    @manjujain9864 Před rokem +4

    नागालैंड लैंड की वर्तमान समस्या का सच्चा और समग्र हाल बताने वाला अति सुन्दर, बिश्वसनीय इंटरव्यू। सुनते हुए ऐसा महसूस हुआ मानो हम स्वयं हिमालय के इस क्षेत्र में घूमकर सबकुछ अपनी आँखों से देख रहे हो।अफसोस होता है कि आजकल मीडिया बिल्कुल पंगू जैसा हो गया है जिससे जरूरी सूचनाओं से भी आमजन वंचित रहता है।

  • @makutheowl1366
    @makutheowl1366 Před rokem +11

    Well analysed matured speech thank you all of you love from Manipur meitei community

  • @manibalasingh4591
    @manibalasingh4591 Před rokem +10

    Humara Manipur bhi same franch ki tara ban gye hai .Jada pyar de Diya refugee log ko . snake pal ne se khud pe duste hai..

  • @AS_7419
    @AS_7419 Před rokem +17

    The best explanation of Manipur, Salute to Colonel Bakshi sir 🙏

  • @arunban
    @arunban Před rokem +20

    Profoundly interesting insights by Col. Bakshi. Helped me to understand the entire dynamics of the Manipur crisis.

  • @nabarundey1150
    @nabarundey1150 Před rokem +12

    Col Sab I lived more than half a century in North East, you have highlighted the real issue in the current conflict without being biased or bigoted. Salute to you for letting people understand the real issues.

  • @premicism9955
    @premicism9955 Před rokem +20

    as a manipuri many of the things the gentleman says are true. what is needed is to suspend all agreements with militants and come down heavily on them. both in the hills and the valley. roll the tanks.

  • @kaushikshah4903
    @kaushikshah4903 Před rokem +120

    Huge respects for Colonel Hunny Bakshi. Jai Hind.

    • @sukundakujur8714
      @sukundakujur8714 Před rokem +1

      Lp

    • @bindupahan688
      @bindupahan688 Před rokem +1

      कर्नल बक्शी ने बहुत ही सुन्दर तरीके से मणिपुर के आदिवासियो के सामाजिक, संस्कृतिक, शैक्षणिक, आर्थिक और अन्य पहलूओं को रेखांकित करते हुए शांति बहाल करने का सटीक सझाव दिया जिसकी अपेक्षा दूसरों से नही की जा सकतीहै। आप दोनो को हर्दिक जोहार !

  • @prakashpillai5320
    @prakashpillai5320 Před rokem +20

    Colonel Bakshi is always so humble in his descriptions

  • @kananbalasainik4846
    @kananbalasainik4846 Před rokem +9

    Big Salute to Colonel Bakshi Sir.. Jai Hind 🙏

  • @gaganreyat6548
    @gaganreyat6548 Před rokem +25

    Such a fresh breath of joy. Salute to Col. Bakshi. We need to hear more from him.

  • @sophykhuman1437
    @sophykhuman1437 Před rokem +38

    Huge respect to you sir👍.
    But one point Manipur valley area had become relatively peaceful area for last 10-15 years . Most of the insurgents surrendered or number became minimal just before this present violence. During first initial days of this present violence meiteis were without defence/ weapons/ underground. Many Villagers were killed mercilessly. They had to defend themselves only with stick/knife. But as violence prolonged meiteis are also trying to get weapons either by looting/ other means. Otherwise we all will be killed if we don't defend. On the other hand trucks and trucks of weapons are coming to kuki militants from Mynamar. When govt want to dearm it should not only focus on looted weapons but also consider to other side where tremendous weapons are coming to support kukis.
    About meira paibis, govt failed to protect unarmed civilians, only help they are getting protection is from these their own community village defence force, when they were crying for help, govt failed to do that. All their houses burnt. Many unarmed meiteis villagers kinapped and killed mercilessly. That's why they are saying if any action like combing operation/ any measure it should be done on both side.
    You may or may not believe it but it is the fact.

    • @raosahabni5936
      @raosahabni5936 Před rokem +3

      Bhai 🙏🙏 intellectuals know what's happening there and why but political parties has made issue
      And why reservation can't be given to minorities and few months ago on the order of the Govt. defence Forces destroyed 400 acres of Afeem in hilly areas. Govt took concern for security and all this started happening

  • @sanjaysinghnews
    @sanjaysinghnews Před rokem +3

    This interview is eye opener. Col. Bakshi is a great army officer. He has very deep insight about Manipur problem and provided some crucial clues to handle the situation. Govt should heed. Thank you for giving totally new percspective. General public and media is not aware of the problem.

  • @user-ud4tz1fs2r
    @user-ud4tz1fs2r Před rokem +11

    Huge respect for colonel sir;lots of love from nagaland india🇮🇳

  • @Surgviolinist
    @Surgviolinist Před rokem +29

    They should make AFSPA and NRC asap . Mayanmar border should be sealed now .

    • @verjeshnarzary9514
      @verjeshnarzary9514 Před rokem +1

      You can't seal Myanmar border due to terrain, also same community hain on both side of border,
      Border are divided b/w villages, infact some people sleep in india and eat in Myanmar basically Ghar keh through border divide hota hain that's how it is...
      The only solution is get and occupy Myanmar Chin state aur Naga state into India. Then India have fully control over the terrain of purvanchal range, and administration of manipur, nagaland will be super easy..

  • @prithvirajrajpurohit2851
    @prithvirajrajpurohit2851 Před rokem +10

    बहुत सुंदर विश्लेषण। पूरा देखे बिना छोड़ने का मन नहीं करता

  • @jvs9797
    @jvs9797 Před rokem +4

    Hatts off to colonel sir to admit that Christian missionaries have done a great job in this hill areas .After the conversion to christianity the Nagas and kukkis became so educated, civilized ,cultured, became doctors, army officers and big celebrity players in Indian sports eg sunil chedri, mary kom etc.
    There were big allegations against the Christian missionaries on conversions. His sincere words are a big slap on the face of fanatics who are crying against Christian missionaries. 😊

    • @homelesslavie_vlogs9600
      @homelesslavie_vlogs9600 Před rokem

      Sunil Chetri isn't from NE, his father was from Nepal who worked in the Indian Army and settled in India and lived across the India. Neither he is a Tribal.... Chetri is a Khstriya caste among Nepali Hindus.

    • @user-nr1oe6bh2j
      @user-nr1oe6bh2j Před 4 měsíci

      Very poor try to defend missionaries
      missionaries are threat to northeastern culture

    • @user-nr1oe6bh2j
      @user-nr1oe6bh2j Před 4 měsíci

      ​@@homelesslavie_vlogs9600right bro

    • @jvs9797
      @jvs9797 Před 4 měsíci

      @@user-nr1oe6bh2j Ignorance has no limits

  • @theconqueror1010
    @theconqueror1010 Před rokem +65

    Truly respect this guy. He had a vast knowledge of North East and its problems 👍

  • @prakashshashi
    @prakashshashi Před rokem +22

    Appreciate Col. Honey's🍯 choice of words, eloquence, easy to understand language and empathetic approach for resolution of Manipur situation is really commendable. Thanks Col. You have our support & blessings 👌👍👏🙏🇮🇳

  • @sunnypant9107
    @sunnypant9107 Před rokem +50

    Col Hunny Bakshi needs to be appointed as spl Advisor to the Govt for NE affairs.

  • @mhasekhopuro9559
    @mhasekhopuro9559 Před rokem +3

    Thank you VAAD channel! Salute ke saath Jai Hind Saheb Col.Hunny Bakshi for ur briefing , Advice and support us Naga Pride.

  • @Malemleima485
    @Malemleima485 Před rokem +3

    Namak ni .....poppy haina .....😂 kya baat kahi sir,thnk u very much ❤

  • @tweetuber
    @tweetuber Před rokem +14

    Finallyyyy, Someone told the REAL reason oof Manipur....... Thanks Hunny Bakshi ji.... !!!

  • @peace373
    @peace373 Před rokem +8

    My dear Colonel you should also please tell the people of this country How Army misused AFSPA to rape many women and killed many innocent people in Manipur.. What happened to Thanjam Monorama?? She was raped and and was shot 16 times in her private part.. Dont say half truth and portray people of Manipur like a villian..

    • @Coffee8388
      @Coffee8388 Před rokem

      U heard he talking about gens? Is it gens of peace? Also he talk about how he felt about burning of young kids. which gens it is. Army do not have magic stick to deal with people's having gens headhunting gens. Surrounded by human right sharks.

  • @goutambora5480
    @goutambora5480 Před rokem +45

    Col. Hunny Bakshi, thank you for showing such a matured analysis of Manipur situation!

  • @girishcjoshi937
    @girishcjoshi937 Před rokem +5

    जो भी स्थिति थी सरकार की तरफ से कोई पहल नहीं की गई । केवल दर्शक की तरह देखते रहे । बात तो करनी पड़ेगी जितनी जल्दी बात होगी समस्या भी उतनी जल्दी खतम होगी।

  • @ramakumar71
    @ramakumar71 Před rokem +7

    If Manipuri Kukis got converted into Christianity, how and why are they getting Reservation? Is it not against the Reservation policy as per Indian Constitution?

  • @deepak-dhankhar
    @deepak-dhankhar Před rokem +27

    Always a delight to watch Col Bakshi Sir 😄♥️👍👍

  • @tejmani5559
    @tejmani5559 Před rokem +9

    Very truly analised sir.👍 Every one should listen🙏

  • @keepsmiling1603
    @keepsmiling1603 Před 11 měsíci +3

    I usually never comment on any CZcams video but this one is just extraordinary. Hats off to you as there r many Podcasters out there who interrupt the guests constantly and don't let them complete sentence but this was less of a podcast and more of a conversation. U let him speak his heart out. May u grow fast brother. God bless. ❤

  • @ALC0A021
    @ALC0A021 Před rokem +24

    Colonel Hunni really opened our eyes related to huge presence and contribution of northeast youths towards Indian army. Really thankful sir ji 🙏

  • @biswadeepdas9613
    @biswadeepdas9613 Před rokem +7

    Lots of respect to Hunny Bakshi Sir,has been lovely hearing his views on NE since long ,respect from a corner of Assam ...

  • @hansrajyadav9340
    @hansrajyadav9340 Před rokem +8

    Excellent discussion Sirs. Army and Para-Militsry must be protected. One military soldier is equillant to 100 civilians.

  • @huyam414
    @huyam414 Před rokem +15

    I am from Manipur and this is 100% true.

  • @herojitloushambam5111
    @herojitloushambam5111 Před rokem +20

    This video melts my hearts and gives a hope to bring peace. We needs such leader .

  • @AD-Human
    @AD-Human Před rokem +12

    AFSPA targeted/affected the life of only meitei community in the past. Now today the issue is totally different. Its about illegal immigrants Chin kuki mizo they called themselves and then illegal staying and its poppy cultivation. What steps or what has Army been doing on this current issue.
    I dont know how AFSPA will solve this issue by controlling the meitei militants when the actual issue is illegal myanmaris Kuki refugees

    • @ShambhaviK-ki2nu
      @ShambhaviK-ki2nu Před rokem

      Meithai also have so called terrorist s not just kukki meithei women protected 12 who attacked dogra regiment in 2015 army have to release them women acting as shield watch that vedio

  • @ritaamodia4520
    @ritaamodia4520 Před rokem +5

    Very nice suggestions government should interfere in this serious matter of Manipur and should talk with Army chief because all tribes r there so it should be solve and can nothing is impossible

  • @sauravbhattacharjee9842
    @sauravbhattacharjee9842 Před rokem +6

    Being a native of north-east Varat I am happy that the over-all shadow of terrorism has been diminished after the arrival of Bjp in central

  • @KingStark-lb4do
    @KingStark-lb4do Před rokem +21

    Correction: AFSPA is limited to the valley region which have been removed... The hills side especially Kuki dominated area is under SOO which is still intact.
    One thing to note is that Armed Pressure Group from both side is demanding for autonomy of some sort but the valley pressure armed groups are the one which is demanding for separation from the Union of India.

    • @madhulikanegi319
      @madhulikanegi319 Před rokem +5

      Seperation from India ?? They want to allign with Mynmar ?? what a joke😂

    • @KingStark-lb4do
      @KingStark-lb4do Před rokem +1

      @@madhulikanegi319 u high?.. Laughing at ur own joke

    • @anant5369
      @anant5369 Před rokem

      What is SOO.. please elaborate on the whole situation from an aboriginal point of view ... and further any suggestions towards maintaining peace..

    • @KingStark-lb4do
      @KingStark-lb4do Před rokem +1

      @@anant5369 it's basically a cease fire agreement.. With talks over a separate autonomy with the GOI.

    • @andiemutum
      @andiemutum Před rokem +1

      ​@@anant5369 Colonel has already explained about SOO in the interview

  • @nandiniv.7974
    @nandiniv.7974 Před rokem +7

    Best and most unbiased interview on manipur crisis, thank you col bakshi for your excellent analysis on this situation, hope and pray that this beautiful state of manipur is back to it's peaceful days.

  • @AshaCachar943
    @AshaCachar943 Před rokem +1

    Thank you Sir apne 100% sahi baat bola he ..Sir mei bhi ek meitei hu ..Assam se hu..jabse ye video viral huwa he all India ke under se hum meiti longon ko gali dena suru krdiya he rapist kehta he har koi sawal krta he.. bahot hi dukh lgta he plz ...kuch to solution nikallo..plz plz Hummare Manipur khatam hojayega.🙏

  • @satyajeetdhakhada4920
    @satyajeetdhakhada4920 Před rokem +3

    जिन लोगो में जमीर जिंदा है यें मणीपुर के बारे में बोले वरना नफ़रत की राजनीति पुरा देश को जला देंगी यें बात अपनी डायरी में लिख कर रख लेना 🇮🇳😭😭😭😭🇮🇳

    • @sampathi9515
      @sampathi9515 Před rokem

      Aur Bengal, Rajasthan, Bihar ke baare me chup rahe, hai na?

  • @vibhavagarwalla8718
    @vibhavagarwalla8718 Před rokem +3

    Col. Bakshi's humility is refreshing. Instead of outright finger-pointing, blaming spreading, he says "Even I misjudged the situation".

  • @sharan50000
    @sharan50000 Před rokem +8

    what a brilliant interview. Col Sahab is a star. This is real educational for us guys. Fantastic. AFSA is for sure required in Manipur. 🤔🙏🏽🇮🇳

  • @sulabhthakur5132
    @sulabhthakur5132 Před rokem +1

    एक फौजी तन से, मन से कितना मजबूत और हृदय से कितना निर्मल हो सकता है इन्हे देख कर पता चलता है

  • @rinko7687
    @rinko7687 Před rokem +5

    Col sahib Jai hind ……beautifully explained ….the govt should appoint you as special officer in charge think you can sort out better than politicians

  • @gk021176
    @gk021176 Před rokem +22

    Bharat became Bharat not from fighting but getting along together. That doesn't mean that there were not wars. But there were also long lasting peace, which give opportunity to people to grow economically and get there children educated. Which led to more economy. But this was not the same in North-East Bharat. However, this is the golden opportunity for them to get along themselves to get out of age old traditions at least from fighting between villages, tribes in the name of egos. They have to come up with systems which gives there people long lasting peace and prosperity.

    • @doreenfernandes2431
      @doreenfernandes2431 Před rokem +1

      🌿🌻 What people who are suffering, their houses burnt, no proper food and shelter need healing and comfort. Start praying for their traumatic lives to normalise. Fellow Indians should have a compassionate heart. Prayer is Powerful and God hears and answers prayers from a sincere heart. God is watching and is in control and He will not spare trouble makers because God is love. ❤

    • @skariaa.v2835
      @skariaa.v2835 Před rokem

      The perpetrators will be defeated soon. Indians are not fools. Ruling parties must understand this that power in India is not permanent.

    • @ALC0A021
      @ALC0A021 Před rokem +1

      @@doreenfernandes2431 sounds like a typical pastor

  • @rg6340
    @rg6340 Před rokem +6

    This video needs to become viral!!😢😢😢😮😮😮

  • @mysterioussingh8270
    @mysterioussingh8270 Před rokem +3

    Assam Rifles is the main conspirator of Manipur unrest. Assam Rifle got a share from all the popi cultivated in Manipur which are done by Kukis.

    • @rakeshbarman3486
      @rakeshbarman3486 Před rokem

      bullshit 😂 AR unit is controlled by mod ,

    • @redundancy100
      @redundancy100 Před rokem +1

      Exactly

    • @mysterioussingh8270
      @mysterioussingh8270 Před rokem +1

      @@redundancy100 and it’s a pre plan from chin kuki illegal emigrants from Myanmar for their kukiland and trapped all the military first and most of their wives are chin kukis and their child in good position military jobs and not only they r enjoying quota benefits and government high rank jobs. And the poor are farming poppies…,

  • @bijayantioinam275
    @bijayantioinam275 Před rokem +8

    Thank you col Bakshi.. For giving such a unbiased interview unlike others.

  • @Sameer-wf3fc
    @Sameer-wf3fc Před rokem +8

    Thank you for giving the root cause of the current issue and more importantly a solution to resolve the issue.

  • @nganthoibayengkhom2869
    @nganthoibayengkhom2869 Před rokem +1

    Sir,you are absolutely right, you are the only person to know details about the Manipur.I this channel.

  • @grandindianews9136
    @grandindianews9136 Před rokem +1

    एक सैन्य अधिकारी के अनुशासन में आस्था को देखकर कुछ भरोसा होने लगता है कि हमारी सेना जज्बेदार है,सैल्यूट टू ऑल

  • @abhisheksharma4996
    @abhisheksharma4996 Před rokem +24

    If Christian Church is allowed to operate in Northeast why not allow sanatan dharmic groups to improve the situation and guide them to better future.

    • @watanabe00738
      @watanabe00738 Před rokem +1

      Rss and its affiliated organisations are shit bro. I am from northeasts. Here rampant conversions are going on everyday. I am trying to get help from these org for many years . No one responses. No one fucking cares. We hindus are way way far behind in term of protecting our people.

    • @er.priyankasharma8367
      @er.priyankasharma8367 Před rokem +7

      Nehru ji ki hrkte padh lena

    • @peace373
      @peace373 Před rokem

      we don't need your RSS in Northeast.. Don't ever come to Northeast🙏🏻

    • @helsreach001
      @helsreach001 Před rokem +3

      Ha lakin problems ye hai sanatan ke saath , bramhan koun banega aur dalit koun 😅😅😅 .
      Bhai thoda aisa bhi socha Karo .

    • @ALC0A021
      @ALC0A021 Před rokem +1

      @@helsreach001 thts not sanatan to be honest these degradations to sanatani culture came later and to resolve such issues many spiritual gurus like Buddha, mahaveer, nath yogis, adishankaracharya, Sankardeva, Kabir, nanak, Swami Vivekananda many many came

  • @watanabe00738
    @watanabe00738 Před rokem +44

    This is a conflict between christians and hindus i must tell you. I am a tribal from tripura, and i am seeing how christian missioneries are making their bases for future conflicts in my state.

    • @doreenfernandes2431
      @doreenfernandes2431 Před rokem +9

      🌿🌻 Stop talking nonsense...and letting your imagination run riot. Dont be.ungrateful ... if it were not for them you would still be an ignoramus. We must praise and thank God in all circumstances.

    • @Vyom4676
      @Vyom4676 Před rokem

      ​​@@doreenfernandes2431bible thumpers are showing their knowledge in africa (by banning gay rights)and other countries(america and it's racism),stop hijacking secular western achievements for the church duffers,we had our knowledge systems and interactions with others resulting in creation of scientific literature starting from 1715 by sawai jai singh and others (you just like your lord are the biggest duffers ever)so you homophobes and dead worshippers should shut up.😂

    • @watanabe00738
      @watanabe00738 Před rokem

      @@doreenfernandes2431 i dun care man, lf riot sparks out or not.riots are bound to happen here If not today, may b tomorrow. I m only speaking truth, wht i ve been seeing for last 3 decades.

    • @Mark___933
      @Mark___933 Před rokem

      Are you nuts? Stop talking bullshit…People are dying here

    • @boulevard7863
      @boulevard7863 Před rokem +1

      Churches have a role in insurgencies. Everyone knows that . National Liberation Front of Tripura was a baptist funded insurgency group.

  • @KishorKumar-qc3tl
    @KishorKumar-qc3tl Před rokem +1

    मै कर्नल साहब की सोच व सुझाव का पूरा समर्थन करता है। मैंने भी चार बर्ष सेवा दी है।1981से1985 लेकिन मेरे दिल और दिमाग मे आज भी दर्द है।

    • @KishorKumar-qc3tl
      @KishorKumar-qc3tl Před rokem +1

      अलापा जो कहेगा वही अच्छा है बाकी बेकार है लेकिन इस में चीन की पूरी मदद करता है यह शीत युद्ध है मेरे 14 भाई बलिदान दे चूके हैं।

  • @jena7387
    @jena7387 Před rokem +3

    Colonel Hunny Bhakshi, Jai Hind Sir, first time I'm hearing you but liked your way sharing your experience.

  • @AbhishekSingh-qs2rj
    @AbhishekSingh-qs2rj Před rokem +21

    Col. Hunny bakshi ji jindabad. The way he answers the questions is awesome. To the point and fact full

  • @sudheersmehta
    @sudheersmehta Před rokem +8

    What a thorough, deep, exhaustive explanation, congratulations 🎊 👏

  • @ikotovyeptho8547
    @ikotovyeptho8547 Před rokem +3

    From Nagaland. May God bless you good health Colonel

  • @bijoykhaba5760
    @bijoykhaba5760 Před rokem +2

    Thank you sir Colonel,aap ne Manipur ko har kahani,sistem share duniya ko asli kahani sunadiya isliye bahut bahut dhanyawad.

  • @BharatS7749
    @BharatS7749 Před rokem +37

    Colonel saheb 's dialogue is much more than a conversation for podcast. Every word true about Manipuris.

  • @hd6497
    @hd6497 Před rokem +6

    I must say that Colonel understanding of NE is sound and 100% accurate

  • @coloneldatoajayahlawat16th71
    @coloneldatoajayahlawat16th71 Před 7 měsíci +1

    Being uneducated is not a problem. The problem is that people are educated just enough to believe that what society does is right.
    In the world where wrong conduct is widespread, correct judgement is difficult.
    We are not educated enough to question the wrongs of the society.
    It is like being given light to see the path, but not enough to question where it leads.
    The real challenge is knowing ‘how’ to think, and not to follow blindly.
    Super dedicated and top line officer. Very few nowadays. An officer with balls. Rarity nowadays. Keep it up buddy.
    The Rissala.

  • @lilybadwar8980
    @lilybadwar8980 Před rokem +4

    Sir Bakshi you showing and explaining the picture of North east is so commendable thank you so much for sharing yr views and suggestions so atleast people can understand the ground reality 👍

  • @aryandahiya8506
    @aryandahiya8506 Před rokem +6

    It was thoroughly interesting and enriching.
    Thnx Arihant bhai and huge respect to Colonel saab

  • @ankitmishra9422
    @ankitmishra9422 Před rokem +14

    Everybody mostly watches any podcast to listen to the guest’s answers but on this channel even the questions asked by host are 👍

  • @gpschottuwala8253
    @gpschottuwala8253 Před rokem +4

    Thanks for your support and efforts 👏👏👏

  • @sianzou4428
    @sianzou4428 Před rokem +9

    For those who don’t know what sir had spoken on illegal migrants..The southern portion of Manipur was inhabitated by KUKI/ZO tribes along with Mizoram in India and chin state of Burma and Chittagong of Bangladesh since pre Independence..But when the Britishers came they divided them along an irregular lines separating the ethnic ZO/KUKI tribes (as sir has said divided along a straight line separating one from the other) without their consent. So I won’t term those who came over to which either side as illegal since those Belt or territories were theirs to begin with…And Manipur was carved out by the British and given to meitei king who doesn’t have any authority over the Nagas nor Kukis/ZO

    • @Bunk536
      @Bunk536 Před rokem

      Chup haothu

    • @sianzou4428
      @sianzou4428 Před rokem

      @@Bunk536 ngari, actor, liers, rapist, schedule thieves u shut up

    • @Oppenheimerh2732
      @Oppenheimerh2732 Před rokem

      Nice try . But I can read and research and it’s false

    • @sianzou4428
      @sianzou4428 Před rokem +1

      @@Oppenheimerh2732 Ive done my research and its true...

  • @khumukchamgopen6397
    @khumukchamgopen6397 Před rokem +5

    Respect u very much Bakshi sir. Ur indirect words hit all sections specially Burma border people.🙏

  • @swastiksolutions760
    @swastiksolutions760 Před rokem +8

    Major Ralengnao Bob Khathing
    He was a Tangkhul Naga and India pays SALUTE to Him

  • @sanjaygaikwad9949
    @sanjaygaikwad9949 Před rokem +7

    "किसी भी समाज का असली माप इस बात से पता लगाया जा सकता है कि वह अपने सबसे कमजोर सदस्यों के साथ कैसा व्यवहार करता है।"🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏🙏

    • @rohitadhatrao6877
      @rohitadhatrao6877 Před rokem +1

      Kai faltu comment marta, he sagle foreign quotes aahet, bhartat saglyat kamkjor samaj aaj hindu aahe, karun toh ati sahishnu jhala mhanun, north east madhe church chi mujori chalte

    • @udesinhroz1005
      @udesinhroz1005 Před rokem

      *Sahi bat he.Sirji..pranamji
      * Jine ki ichha( Marji)vale Nirdosh Gay-Bakri.....
      Pashu-pankhi-janvar ke sath Ham kesa vahevar
      Karte he. isse SAMAJ ki
      Pehchan hoti he...ise..
      Markar khakar Dakkar khanevale insan par DAYA
      nahi karte......pranamji..
      *Shakahar +Sanskar +Shist =SANATAN DHARM
      Insaniyat...Hindu sanskriti
      He tab tak Manavta he...
      * if we are HINDU MUSLIM SHIKH ISAI or anything else we are Different by body not by soul... Bharat Bhumi me
      Janam milna hi Hamara
      Bada NASEEB he....
      Sabko Pranam Sabko salam..Namaskar..

  • @amritdebbarma2528
    @amritdebbarma2528 Před rokem +4

    No one is talking about Tripura. We are facing the same illegal influx problem. We are standing at merely 35% of the total population according to 2011 census.

  • @ojasyadav9020
    @ojasyadav9020 Před rokem +6

    I wanted to hear his commentary on this critical topic. Thanks for bringing him .❤

  • @PareshPatel99
    @PareshPatel99 Před rokem +16

    Salute to Col. Bakshi Saab. Jai Hind

  • @mahavirbisht2307
    @mahavirbisht2307 Před rokem +2

    Colonel Bakshi must be heard for the peace of Manipur...his suggestions are very very important and genuine...

  • @gulapiokram3613
    @gulapiokram3613 Před rokem +1

    With due respect to the channel and Colonel,for bringing the truth in open.

  • @ismaildaimari5553
    @ismaildaimari5553 Před rokem +6

    Col. Sahab has rightly said....Indian Army be allowed to act according to thei command & wish....🙏❤️❤️❤️