What we learned from Ireland's defeat to South Africa | RTÉ Rugby podcast

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 8. 07. 2024
  • Neil Treacy is joined by Bernard Jackman on this week's RTÉ Rugby podcast to recap Saturday's first Test defeat against South Africa, and look ahead at this weekend's final game of the season in Durban.
    Jackman gives his thoughts on the devastating injury blow to hooker Dan Sheehan, and how the Irish scrum and lineout will be affected by his absence.
    We also examine how South Africa's attack in the first half caused real problems for Ireland, and discuss how the Springboks could become a dominant force with their new attacking strategy.
    And the podcast also discusses why Ireland need to work on their communication skills when dealing with referees, with Caelan Doris struggling to get on the right side of Luke Pearce last week.
    Web www.rte.ie/sport
    Twitter: / rtesport
    Follow us on Facebook / rtesport
  • Sport

Komentáře • 262

  • @garethmurphy2978
    @garethmurphy2978 Před 15 dny +37

    Lovely to see Irish fans out in SA. Hope you are enjoying your stay! Looking forward to the game on Saturday!

  • @hanli2011
    @hanli2011 Před 15 dny +52

    From a South-African.
    Great podcast guys! Very open, very appreciative and very informative! Dont take qll the overhype personal. I appreciate the Irish, I have family living in Brey and we love the Irish. I hope for a great game again on Saturday. Win or not.

    • @joemoody7440
      @joemoody7440 Před 15 dny

      Go well bro!

    • @sokirish
      @sokirish Před 15 dny +1

      I live in Bray!! What's they're name and I'll go and shake their hand!! 😅

  • @sdewviljoen
    @sdewviljoen Před 15 dny +53

    A Springbokkie is a shooter of 2/3 peppermint liquer topped with Amarula. You missed out!! Glad you enjoyed Loftus and the Bulls fans. It is a lot!!

    • @CC-om8ze
      @CC-om8ze Před 15 dny +4

      Amarula is super yummy. Get you a bottle before you leave.

    • @LindilechristopherMgqobele
      @LindilechristopherMgqobele Před 15 dny

      😂😂😂😂

    • @kierontreas5971
      @kierontreas5971 Před 15 dny +4

      It's all fun and games until you're throwing up South African flag colours 😂😂

    • @seanbutler7503
      @seanbutler7503 Před 15 dny +2

      "Could've been some of your best work, Neil!" 🤣

    • @CC-om8ze
      @CC-om8ze Před 15 dny +1

      @@kierontreas5971 😂😂😂

  • @lahirimahasaya9271
    @lahirimahasaya9271 Před 15 dny +28

    The way you said uMhlanga beautiful man 🤝

  • @johanschoeman869
    @johanschoeman869 Před 15 dny +47

    Welcome to all Irish fans! Its nice to have all of you here. The next test will be a humdinger and I cannot wait. Here is to a great game and may the best team win.

    • @geoffnelson6756
      @geoffnelson6756 Před 15 dny +4

      Is that irony? SA are fielding it's most capped team ever, while Ireland have lost most of their team to injury, funny that. I have noticed the late tackles, ie Kwagga leaping onto Osborne after he scored his try, sort of obvious why Ireland have half a team, but at least Razzie has manipulated his reputation in SA, so possible career injuries don't really matter.

    • @RikiLouw69
      @RikiLouw69 Před 15 dny +6

      @@geoffnelson6756 Keep crying, bud. While you are at it why don't you order ballet shoes for your Ireland team. FFS, get a life.

    • @teatime6414
      @teatime6414 Před 15 dny +4

      @@geoffnelson6756lol this guy been crying on every channel since Saturday

    • @geoffnelson6756
      @geoffnelson6756 Před 15 dny +3

      @@teatime6414 well If Ireland had rightfully won that game, there'd be thousands of yapping boks fans on here, just giving you a bit of your own medicine. Fun, isn't it

    • @geoffnelson6756
      @geoffnelson6756 Před 15 dny

      @@RikiLouw69 Size 12 please, as they are big tough guys!

  • @nicolaaspretorius6258
    @nicolaaspretorius6258 Před 15 dny +19

    Bernard Jackman gets it right more often than not, class.

  • @LionOnSea
    @LionOnSea Před 15 dny +19

    Kings Park in many ways is quite different to Loftus but an equally brilliant ground to watch a match. Pre and post match vibe is excellent, food and beverage options abound... The stands are really quite steep and the noise of a capacity crowd is deafening.

  • @mthunziphakathi4215
    @mthunziphakathi4215 Před 15 dny +19

    I hope the Irish now realise that the online banter and media stuff exists in a vacuum and is not the state of South African supporters.

    • @LeMerch
      @LeMerch Před 15 dny +5

      So true. Online social media has always been a cesspit. South Africans are good people who love their team. Nothing wrong with that.

    • @greatleapforwards
      @greatleapforwards Před 15 dny +5

      and vica versa- online is just toxic, and thankfully not as bad on youtube

    • @altaafkader9675
      @altaafkader9675 Před 15 dny

      Yes but you must understand that there is a level of insecurity and psychological damage that comes with losing 8 world cup quarter finals

    • @LeMerch
      @LeMerch Před 15 dny +1

      @@greatleapforwards no there’s not. The vast majority of them we don’t care about. Because rugby was a tiny sport played in 2 or 3 cities. That was it. These days we know we will beat it, it’s not such a big deal. The media play it up. We met an amazing NZ team who defended for their lives and won it by a held up try. They deserved it. Doesn’t mean we won’t ever get past a QF 🤣

    • @greatleapforwards
      @greatleapforwards Před 15 dny

      @@LeMerch yeah...the media is a big catalyst in pushing this agenda. What a lot of my south african countrymen don't understand is that rugby will always play second stage to GAA. I was going to go watch at the pub, but the hurling semi took centre stage!

  • @Kransduif
    @Kransduif Před 15 dny +17

    Damn, international rugby is so healthy at the moment. SA, ire, nz, eng,fra and maybe scotland wil all be competitive games. Think glasgows win are going to give scotland a major boost

    • @St_AngusYoung
      @St_AngusYoung Před 15 dny

      Scotland? Their opposition are all tier 2 nations. Canada, USA, Chile and Uruguay. Once again, they duck the big guns.

    • @Kransduif
      @Kransduif Před 15 dny +4

      @@St_AngusYoung didnt they beat eng in six nations? And lost to france with a last min kick? I would say they are closing the gap between them and the big dogs.

    • @St_AngusYoung
      @St_AngusYoung Před 15 dny

      ⁠@@Kransduifthey haven’t played NZ in NZ since 2000, haven’t been to Australia in 7 years and last played the Boks in RSA in 2014. They’re ducking the SH big guns.

    • @Kransduif
      @Kransduif Před 15 dny

      @@St_AngusYoung I know but SA Aus and NZ arent fireworks either

    • @Kransduif
      @Kransduif Před 15 dny

      But you have a valid point. Its just that they are 100% better than they always were. Nov tests going to be good

  • @Vlerkies
    @Vlerkies Před 15 dny +18

    Ireland put up a heck of a fight. Out of the 2 teams the Boks certainly looked to be more in control but Ireland never lay down. Both teams missed lots of opportunities, the tmo played their inevitable part. Its test rugby.
    I look forward to another epic clash on the weekend.

    • @nevillepieterse9983
      @nevillepieterse9983 Před 15 dny +6

      Ireland gonna be better
      Boks gonna be better
      So, will be a good game

    • @geoffnelson6756
      @geoffnelson6756 Před 15 dny +1

      That's putting it lightly, Doris try was clearly grounded, so 7 points there, the other TMO calls could easily have gone the other way, so 17 -21 points more to Ireland and 7 less for SA, an honest outcome would have resulted in a comfortable win for Ireland.

    • @dn822
      @dn822 Před 15 dny +1

      ​@@geoffnelson6756clearly grounded but I could see if it was on the line? Did you gat angles we did not get

    • @TheFilmInsomniac
      @TheFilmInsomniac Před 15 dny

      @@geoffnelson6756 Doris's "try" would cancel out Murray's try.

    • @victordastile5204
      @victordastile5204 Před 15 dny

      ​@@geoffnelson6756biased as always. Post a link here that show a clear grounding🤔

  • @NotSoProSpectator
    @NotSoProSpectator Před 15 dny +11

    Ireland are one hell of a team. As a Boks supporter - I love the Irish team. Less so when they play us. But they have some phenomenal players. And just refuse to go away, they do not know when they are beaten!! Also.....Ireland is responsible for some of the BEST rugby in the last 2 years. Ireland v France (2023); Ireland v Boks (2023); Ireland v ABs (2023); Ireland v France (2024); Ireland v England (2024) and Ireland v Boks (2024). Some bloody outstanding rugby!!

  • @kev63inuk
    @kev63inuk Před 15 dny +4

    England fan here hoping Dan Sheenan injury not going to be that bad. Devastating for the lad if he’s thinking no six nations next year. great player and wish him well. Should be a great six nations and love to take on a full strength Irish team in Dublin. Still feel Ireland can win this Saturday, though feel a bit of despondency amongst Irish fans. 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🇮🇪

  • @johannblignaut1966
    @johannblignaut1966 Před 15 dny +5

    As usual a great podcast.Pleasure to listen too.The game itself is the most important.Fair balanced and insightful. Thanks

  • @martmeister
    @martmeister Před 15 dny +17

    I could only wish you got the best possible experience in South Africa. Loftus isn't for the feint of heart, especially as a visiting Rugby supporter. feel like the SA supporters that get all the attention are the keyboard warriors online where SA can do no wrong and could beat any other team with their eyes closed. But in person, the real supporters respect the game and all other teams. One of the things that stands out for me in Rugby is the respect the players have for each other after the game, shaking hands, swapping jerseys, and having a beer. I wish that carried over more and would prevent some of these annoying SA supporters online. We aren't all like that. I can't wait for the next battle at Durban.

    • @neilmontgomery3470
      @neilmontgomery3470 Před 15 dny +3

      I must admit it is rather depressing seeing some of the horrible comments coming from some SA supporters. However, comments like yours are much more interesting and restore my faith in humanity and good sportsmanship.

    • @mikezog1030
      @mikezog1030 Před 13 dny

      @@neilmontgomery3470 In general most rugby supporters have supported rugby all their lives and in SA that means living the ethos of rugby. Enemies on the field, brothers off the field. These nasty keyboard warriors ruin the game online.

  • @cornedenecker1636
    @cornedenecker1636 Před 15 dny +4

    I heard Bongi mention to the ref a few times that the irish pull back in the scrum. Like after the hit the would pull back instead of hold so the boks couldn't set up for the hit

  • @stevedavidson666
    @stevedavidson666 Před 15 dny +3

    If you think watching rugby at Loftus is something special, wait until this Saturday at King's Park. As someone who lived for 24 years in Durban and used to be a season ticket holder, all I can say is 'wait for the after party'! All the cars parked on the outer fields having braaivleises, it;s really something. Health warning - if the Boks lose, the party will close at about 2 in the morning. If they win, the party could still be going on at dawn. Or later.

  • @cornedenecker1636
    @cornedenecker1636 Před 15 dny +2

    It makes me happy to hear you enjoyed the time in Preroria and the people were good to you. I hope you have the same experience in Durban.💪

  • @malcolmcuthbertson3359
    @malcolmcuthbertson3359 Před 15 dny +12

    You missed out springbokkies is mint liquor and amarula cream shot , and should always accept the hospitality , the afrikaaners are incredible hosts loving all visitors , even if you support the wrong team , they will buy you a drink and share their biltong with you . Even if they loose they are so passionate about the sport , and love the contest pointing out their teams flaws and your good play ore the other way round if they win .

  • @gdd2959
    @gdd2959 Před 15 dny +5

    I don't think Ireland showed a lack of energy in the first few minutes. I just think they were caught off guard with the pace and accuracy the springboks attacked the wide channels. And I think Osborne just underestimated Arendse's speed at which he can change his direction of running. It was a very intense test, both sides felt the pressure.

    • @ciaranbrk
      @ciaranbrk Před 14 dny

      Yeah he was playing your position as well. But he really grew into the game. he just overshot on defence and arendse easily stepped him.

  • @arabicred
    @arabicred Před 13 dny +1

    We were at Loftus last week as a family all with Irish tops and flags and had a great time. It was intimidating and very loud but never threatening. A Bok test at Loftus should be on every rugby fan's bucket list.

  • @HS-mo2wz
    @HS-mo2wz Před 15 dny +1

    Glad you had a great time at Loftus.. South Africans were recently voted the friendliest nation on the planet and we are happy that you experienced some of that. Welcome to SA and enjoy the rest of your stay 🇿🇦

  • @snakeplisskin8696
    @snakeplisskin8696 Před 15 dny +8

    Spent a lot of time in Umhlanga Rocks. Nice place, ja?

  • @mthunziphakathi4215
    @mthunziphakathi4215 Před 15 dny +3

    The Casey incident was a rugby incident, hence the reaction from all players. Very unfortunate for Casey.

  • @kierontreas5971
    @kierontreas5971 Před 15 dny +1

    Earned my subscription from 🇿🇦 great chat fellas!

  • @clarencejacobs4186
    @clarencejacobs4186 Před 15 dny +2

    May the best team win a warm welcome to the Irish such a great loving rugby nation just like south africa

  • @danielg8001
    @danielg8001 Před 15 dny +6

    SA trying to play like Leinster backs, Leinster trying to play like the old SA! 😂😂

  • @PhillipDawson10
    @PhillipDawson10 Před 15 dny

    Excellent podcast. Bernard Jackman is a legend. Thanks Neil for hosting. Hope you find some good craic in Durban as well.

  • @mikezog1030
    @mikezog1030 Před 13 dny +1

    I was with a Welsh friend when we went to watch the Welsh play the Boks at Loftus and he was wearing a red jersey. The Welsh lost 95 - 3 or something like that. He never bought a drink all night after the game as these huge Afrikaners kept coming up to him and saying "Ag shame man... let me buy you a drink". He was blitzed at the end of the night.

  • @yeayou1221
    @yeayou1221 Před 15 dny +11

    RG Snyman made a legal tackle. You can’t penalise players for making legal tackles even if the outcome was unfortunate.

    • @geoffnelson6756
      @geoffnelson6756 Před 15 dny +2

      He was offside so not legal, the tackle was not necessarily dangerous but 6'8 v 5'5, its only going to have one outcome.

    • @BaneofBalor
      @BaneofBalor Před 15 dny +2

      I don't really have a problem with the tackle. I was just a little disappointed that he didn't show any concern for a player he had just knocked unconscious. He's obviously under no obligation to do so, but to play on after potentially seriously injuring a player you've spent the last 2 years or so playing with was just a little sad to see.
      It's test rugby at the end of the day, but part of what makes it special to me as a fan are those moments of sportsmanship where players look out for each other when things go wrong.

    • @yeayou1221
      @yeayou1221 Před 15 dny +1

      @@BaneofBalor Agreed. Truthfully I haven’t watched it back so I’m not 100% sure if he knew he was knocked out but if he did he should atleast make the ref aware of the situation so the game can be stopped.
      If I was going to try and defend his actions as if he knew he was knocked out I’d say potentially if Ireland weren’t in the springboks 22 he may have shown more concern but I can’t know if that would be true or not.

    • @FrancoisCoetzee
      @FrancoisCoetzee Před 15 dny +1

      @@geoffnelson6756After reviewing the tackle the referee decided to take no action. Just wanting the player to be offside, does not make it so.

    • @henripienaar4253
      @henripienaar4253 Před 15 dny +3

      Legal tackle, I relayed and rewatched, you can definitely see RG's eyes were focused on the maul and not the player under him. He didn't realize he was out, the first person to realize was the Irish prop infront of them, the ref that was standing the closest to the action didn't even realize. Bad luck, we all, including RG, are hoping the Irish scrumie is OK. We demand the ultimate determination from our players, we cannot then go and say "He should have held back"

  • @CC-om8ze
    @CC-om8ze Před 15 dny +2

    South Africans are super friendly. Glad you had a good time.

  • @readesiun988
    @readesiun988 Před 15 dny +4

    I would agree with Bernard, Herring much better at lineout and scrum

  • @maxfortuin5359
    @maxfortuin5359 Před 13 dny +1

    Ireland is great team and is not going down without a fight springbok supporter bring it on 🇿🇦❤🏉

  • @neilshrekpurves4521
    @neilshrekpurves4521 Před 15 dny +4

    Springbok drink is creme peppermint liqueur and Cape velvet, enjoy 😊

    • @papsphaks4408
      @papsphaks4408 Před 15 dny +1

      No! It's peppermint liqueur topped with amarula or Bailey's

  • @jeffreykgatitsoe627
    @jeffreykgatitsoe627 Před 15 dny +1

    Welcome Ireland and her people. Good game this past weekend. Looking forward to a more open game this weekend. I hope it becomes a humdinger of a match and both teams go tongs and hammers at each other. Loftus Versfeld is our citadel thus the atmosphere is so intimidating to visiting teams and fans. The Springboks are us and we are the Springboks, thus we are rugby mad.

  • @stevenburrow8804
    @stevenburrow8804 Před 15 dny +1

    29:40
    I'm a Springbok fan, but above that, i enjoy good rugby, and i habe to say, i think Ireland was very clever at scrum time!
    Good podcast guys. Thanks

  • @getridofneocons
    @getridofneocons Před 15 dny +3

    The shark tank best rugby atmosphere at kings park, the braais are legendary then the drinks continue at durban country club.

  • @citedcanvas85
    @citedcanvas85 Před 15 dny +1

    I expect Ireland to come back stronger this weekend. Love the battle so far. Go Bokke

  • @rassienortier5096
    @rassienortier5096 Před 14 dny +1

    You guys rock. Like the pod

  • @brucebeath9548
    @brucebeath9548 Před 15 dny +1

    From Cape Town. Great discussion.

  • @ilollipop100
    @ilollipop100 Před 15 dny +1

    That Robbie Henshaw WASN'T sent for a HIA after his collision with Kolisi was appalling.

  • @themadpants781
    @themadpants781 Před 15 dny

    Very enjoyable podcast guys.

  • @andrewmcnulty6815
    @andrewmcnulty6815 Před 14 dny

    The Irish defence was very resilient, brave , hard tackling by us.

  • @grantwagner558
    @grantwagner558 Před 15 dny

    well balanced chat overall. but the RG Snyman tackle was fair. There seemed to be a bit of mumbling on this point. The Irish players did not react adversely which confirms is was a good tackle.

  • @lawLess-fs1qx
    @lawLess-fs1qx Před 15 dny +4

    20 min discussion on snyman tackle was a waste of air. gave up on this

    • @patrickoleary2862
      @patrickoleary2862 Před 15 dny +4

      Casey-Snyman discussion spanned 19.00-22.00 i.e. exactly 3 mins / not sure if you were having an episode or what.

  • @mikezog1030
    @mikezog1030 Před 13 dny

    Fantastic crazy environment at Loftus- I love it. But the Kings Park pre and after party is something else because the women there like to wear the skimpiest they can. It goes LONG into the night...

  • @seans6042
    @seans6042 Před 15 dny +2

    BJ's right. Irish players have gotten into the terrible habit of continuously chatting in the ref's ear. Maybe it sways officials for the odd decision. But I think the overall effect is irritating. It's annoying just to watch sometimes.
    Going up and telling the likes of Luke Pearce he got the last decision wrong is not going to help your team. If he feels you're questioning or undermining his authority, he'll turn against you straight away. You really just want to get him to alter the way he views a similar situation in future. You need a good rapport to do that. But I would agree that Pearce turned against Doris very quickly on Sat. Dismissive to the point of disrespectful.

    • @ciaranbrk
      @ciaranbrk Před 14 dny +1

      The problem is that they’re not forceful enough they keep saying okay sir. Rather than saying look there on the wrong side the slowing The ball down and the game down we wanna play fast would like you to deal with this. If the ref says okay I’ll keep an eye out for it perfect if not then inform the ref that any person got on the wrong side from here on out is getting studs. he either in forces or you will . We have to stop coming off as whiny though and be more forceful with the ref.

  • @masibulelemadasa7207
    @masibulelemadasa7207 Před 14 dny

    Proper stuff, here. Well come to eMzansi mgita!!!

  • @johnwagenhauser9835
    @johnwagenhauser9835 Před 15 dny +2

    Irish have a quality side. They managed to break the SA defense and produced tries out of nothing. I think the second test is equally unpredictable as the first. Bok supporter.

  • @bobmorgan6333
    @bobmorgan6333 Před 14 dny

    There's a distinct lack of leadership across the team. They can't even make a decision to kick for the corner or take points. A proper leader would also stop some of this unnecessary showboating that led that ridiculous decision by Lowe to try and catch the ball in touch.

  • @Hrodwulf9
    @Hrodwulf9 Před 15 dny

    Pretoria is definitely quite unique even in South Africa with the strong Afrikaans culture still alive here. I see a lot of people complaining about online discourse being toxic and whatever, people come on, have you just now learnt about the internet? Things are tame compared to when it was unregulated in the wild west early days on forums.

  • @barbarawright7983
    @barbarawright7983 Před 14 dny

    South Africans are extremely friendly . Enjoy your time in our beautiful country

  • @mikezog1030
    @mikezog1030 Před 13 dny

    You are VERY mistaken if you think that the best AB teams didn't have the forwards - I think that is WHY they were the best AB teams. Look at the forwards of the teams from 2011 to 2016 - absolutely world class. When they got the forwards to match their backs they were almost unplayable. They were playing total rugby. From a Bok supporter - we can recognise class when we see it.

  • @darrellw.matodes6898
    @darrellw.matodes6898 Před 15 dny

    Boks will be 40% better this weekend. Don't think Pollard will miss any kicks this time.

  • @grahamshaw3802
    @grahamshaw3802 Před 15 dny +1

    Snymans last thanks to Munster

  • @unleashedmystery
    @unleashedmystery Před 15 dny +1

    I think rassie plans on playing this boks starting team until their 60 years of age

  • @riverwolf654
    @riverwolf654 Před 15 dny +5

    Ireland need to get more physical with SA and stop taking shit off them, they're soft underneath

    • @HenryBaggins-rz7mq
      @HenryBaggins-rz7mq Před 15 dny +2

      James Ryan is no captain. He gives the impression that if someone hit him he'd cry.

    • @riverwolf654
      @riverwolf654 Před 15 dny

      @@HenryBaggins-rz7mq all the south africans are on drugs...fact

    • @trevorsammons8179
      @trevorsammons8179 Před 15 dny +3

      Don't mistake braai pap for soft....soft is covered next week.....the breakdown is ours...

    • @piet0004
      @piet0004 Před 15 dny

      Yes just like that , prove that they are soft even though you are softer

    • @gavinkeown6488
      @gavinkeown6488 Před 15 dny +3

      Really? Hard to see any evidence for that. We lost to a good side, in difficult circumstances, but stayed in the fight.

  • @SB-wh9kf
    @SB-wh9kf Před 15 dny

    According to comments above the springbokkie is as diverse as the South African demographics, different comments different recipes 🙂. The basis of the drink is liqueur in equal parts. One half peppermint and one half cream. The cream part is where the population splits 🙂. Some use Cape Velvet (the ignoramus) and the rest use Amarula (the initiates). Delicious both ways but left you drunk as a skunk.

  • @notenoughstones3873
    @notenoughstones3873 Před 15 dny

    I disagree with Jackman that the great ABs team weren’t strong up front. They were very strong up front with Woodcock, Moody, Coles, Mealamu, Franks brothers, Retallick, Whitock, Thorn, Kaino, McCaw, Reid.
    People only remember the flashy wins but they won a number of matches playing direct rugby and dominating up front with a strong defence and kicking game.

  • @faithkaroki6536
    @faithkaroki6536 Před 14 dny

    The thing with Casey was purely a rugby incident. It was unfortunate he got his head but there was nothing there really …

    • @patrickoleary2862
      @patrickoleary2862 Před 14 dny

      Are you actually having a laugh? Guy comes from an offside position, tackles scrum-half with ball literally nowhere to be seen driving scrum-half backwards as hard as he can + knocking him unconscious in the process - oh yeah, all literally under Luke Pearce's nose. You're obviously destined for international refereeing cos yourself + Luke were apparently on the same page i.e. nothing to see here - anyone with critical faculties would describe it as a late + dangerous tackle off the ball. Then again between them Pearce + Whitehouse didn't deem it worthy of even a cursory review. And people wonder why parents don't want their kids playing this game SMFH

  • @kristian762
    @kristian762 Před 15 dny

    Lol a springbok is a shooter, its peppermint liqueur and amarula/baileys cream. Its considered quite "tame" as far as shooters go, compared to say jager or tequila

  • @___JWM
    @___JWM Před 14 dny

    Genuine question: precisely what did RG Snyman do wrong?

    • @patrickoleary2862
      @patrickoleary2862 Před 14 dny +1

      He came from an offside position, tackled Casey with ball literally nowhere to be seen driving Casey backwards as hard as he could + knocking him unconscious in the process, all literally under Luke Pearce's nose. So a late + dangerous tackle off the ball / however between them Pearce + Whitehouse didn't deem it worthy of even a cursory review - go figure.

    • @HeeniKeke
      @HeeniKeke Před 13 dny +2

      @@patrickoleary2862Saffas are blind when their players are in wrong, yet cry a river when same done to them

    • @fallschirmjager0000
      @fallschirmjager0000 Před 11 dny

      probably that dangerous tackle

  • @BarryHawk
    @BarryHawk Před 15 dny

    Beirne should be captain for this year. Doris will come good though.

  • @mybadgaming6786
    @mybadgaming6786 Před 15 dny +1

    Have a look at the U20 Boks line up. Some exsta Bomb sqaud members is coming soon!!!!

    • @myshepspud1
      @myshepspud1 Před 15 dny

      What's your take on why they underperformed so much against Argentina?

    • @Blindside_Flanker
      @Blindside_Flanker Před 15 dny

      ​@@myshepspud1A team can be weak but that doesn't mean there aren't individual players that stand out. Couple those with the right players and it will paint a different picture... I'm pretty sure you could have answered that yourself.

    • @lzb1363
      @lzb1363 Před 14 dny

      ​@@myshepspud1honestly I think SARU drug their feet assigning an U20s coach. He was only appointed in March and the team is not faring well under him. You would expect them to have improved since the U20 Rugby Championships but they seemed to have declined. While al the other teams from that competition have improved markedly. So although he is still in his first year, there doesnt seem to be much progress with the young team. So will see if he gets a full year like the new 7s coach before he gets booted or if it will happen sooner. Seeing as these lads will need to go into SA A side within 2 years, I'll bet he doesnt get that long with the lack of performances so far. We'll see.

  • @bolgert911
    @bolgert911 Před 15 dny

    POM has had his day don't see why where clinging on to him would like to see tadgh bernie play six, 9 and 10 replacements have become major weak points. Frawley needs to be looked at, still way to early for Prendergast and Gunn but need as much exposure as possible

  • @chucklombardo8167
    @chucklombardo8167 Před 15 dny +2

    Gibon park a massive loss

    • @geoffnelson6756
      @geoffnelson6756 Před 15 dny +2

      If we had either JGP or Hugo Keenan for this game I think we win. With those 2 plus Hansen it's game over.

    • @jzkramer
      @jzkramer Před 15 dny

      @@geoffnelson6756 If? If the dog hadn't stopped for a shit, it would have won the race.

    • @geoffnelson6756
      @geoffnelson6756 Před 15 dny +1

      @@jzkramer er, think you are lost, we are on a rugby discussion not greyhound racing, but such an eloquent use of words, you should be very proud of yourself.

    • @TheFilmInsomniac
      @TheFilmInsomniac Před 15 dny

      @@geoffnelson6756 They would have won by 50 points easily...

    • @chucklombardo8167
      @chucklombardo8167 Před 14 dny

      @@geoffnelson6756 ya 100 percent my friend with those 3 players we win personally though the boks were lucky I can see us pipping them Saturday

  • @douglasdejager8450
    @douglasdejager8450 Před 15 dny

    Way better than OTB

  • @davidshekleton9908
    @davidshekleton9908 Před 15 dny +1

    Interesting fact. If Ireland and England lose by even one point on Saturday, New Zealand will move up to second and Ireland down to 3rd on the rankings

    • @malcolmcuthbertson3359
      @malcolmcuthbertson3359 Před 15 dny +1

      It is hard for an Irishman to cheer for England , almost as hard as it is for a bok to cheer for the ab's

    • @myshepspud1
      @myshepspud1 Před 15 dny +4

      @malcolmcuthbertson3359 I feel you though. 😂. We as Saffers even though I'm "English" South African, would much rather cheer for NZ than for England any day of the week.

    • @jle42
      @jle42 Před 15 dny

      We do cheer for the ABs. We respect our greatest foe of all time, its like a dysfunctional relationship: miss them when they're gone, hate them when they are on our doorstep. Ireland is starting to enter the love triangle 😂 On a side note: a team that receives banter or "abuse" from Springbok fans is a team we see as worthy to argue with. It's a compliment. In a weird way.​@@malcolmcuthbertson3359

    • @benpiek4428
      @benpiek4428 Před 15 dny +1

      @@malcolmcuthbertson3359 We all support the AB's unless they play against us. UP the South.....

    • @corryf-eq6nz
      @corryf-eq6nz Před 13 dny +1

      I'm an Irishman and I'm shouting for England every day no matter the rankings. English rugby fans are generally humble even considering our rivalries.
      Six Nations time is probably the best atmosphere.

  • @EditMovie17
    @EditMovie17 Před 14 dny

    I can say the Irish ☘️ team is good definitely 3rd in the world I don’t think they better then SA or New Zealand that’s just the facts of the game if you look up the past games overall and the fact they haven’t been to a final yet just says they aren’t number 1 yet

  • @stiofain88
    @stiofain88 Před 14 dny +1

    Don't engage with them unless you enjoy a toxic atmosphere?

  • @krlauf5307
    @krlauf5307 Před 15 dny

    No frills at Loftus you say ... typical euro-centric comment. Otherwise, great podcast, you guys are class. Dear Irish scrum, Kelleher, Ryan, Flier and co. ...ouch, more to come!!

  • @Deletthis-gp7yy
    @Deletthis-gp7yy Před 15 dny

    One does not simply decline a springbokkie 😂

  • @nox6885
    @nox6885 Před 15 dny

    So many injuries and the Boks didn't play their normal physical game 😂. I'm stupid I'm sorry lads

  • @wam9289
    @wam9289 Před 15 dny +1

    Cmon Springboks lets get this done. Looking forward to playing Wales or Scotland again 😅. Clearly some teams just cant handle the world champions. I say we dont play England as well for what they tried to do before the wc final😂😂. Smh

    • @patrickchilds2987
      @patrickchilds2987 Před 13 dny

      What did England try and do before the rwc final ?
      As a neutral, England played well and lost in the final minutes to the Boks by a single point in the Semi in Paris . They played well against NZ
      Why wouldn't you want the Boks to play them ?

    • @wam9289
      @wam9289 Před 13 dny +1

      @@patrickchilds2987 Uhmm Curry tried to spread lies about Bongi, trying to disrupt the whole team chemistry before WC with NZ. Which was so Classless IMO

    • @patrickchilds2987
      @patrickchilds2987 Před 13 dny

      @@wam9289
      So you think a racial slur allegation between Curry and Bongi in the fame was a deliberate attempt to disruption the chemistry within tje Bok team 😁❤️
      Which are you stupid or really gullable 🤔

  • @matthewvanrensburg3824

    Ok, you Durbs? Need to get you a chips, cheese and double mutton gravy johnnies roti before you leave!

  • @fredperry523
    @fredperry523 Před 15 dny +1

    You can be grateful you did not get a dubbel Klipdrift brandewyn en coke from the supporters you bumped into.

  • @geoffnelson6756
    @geoffnelson6756 Před 15 dny

    In the rugby 7's SA were gifted 7 points, scoring a try from a dead ball, thankfully justice was done in that game and Ireland came away with the win, just a pity we didn't get a fair shout at Loftus.

  • @joewhelan5018
    @joewhelan5018 Před 12 dny

    These boys play rugby on paper and not on grass

  • @user-qe1tv1bu2f
    @user-qe1tv1bu2f Před 15 dny

    15 plus points this weekend to boks. Its a thumping been coming a long while

    • @fallschirmjager0000
      @fallschirmjager0000 Před 11 dny

      Smashed, mighty Ireland triumphs yet again! Only 1 victory in 8 years against us, pathetic

  • @vincenthutton5488
    @vincenthutton5488 Před 15 dny

    I am not surprised with your narrative on Doris's captaincy, Murray Kinsella who apparently is in your journo bubble also made the same commentary, the reality is far more nuanced. The ref / captain relationship is a two way street, to many refs giving legendary playing captains like McCaw an armchair ride and Doris been given tetchy treatment from refs who are still getting to know him and his style of leadership. Also Doris is not being helped by O'Mahoney starting as captain even though everybody including the referee knows O'Mahoney will not finish the game. Starting O'Mahoney as captain in these circumstances undermines Doris's credibility with the referee from the off and establishing a repour mid match for even the most seasoned of captains is not as easy as it is being betrayed by echo chamber of Irish Journalism.

  • @altaafkader9675
    @altaafkader9675 Před 15 dny +1

    No mention of porters illegal scrummaging?

    • @ciaranbrk
      @ciaranbrk Před 14 dny

      Because he wasn’t scrummaging illegally there was a big thing about porters hips being out he fix that and used his power to completely drive The Springbok pack backwards even though the Springbok tighthead kept binding on porters arm.

    • @altaafkader9675
      @altaafkader9675 Před 14 dny

      Drive the springbok pack backwards? You mean from the 5m line to over the try line for a penalty try?​@@ciaranbrk

    • @fallschirmjager0000
      @fallschirmjager0000 Před 11 dny

      two wrongly disallowed tried for Ireland and an incorrect try awarded to kolbe. Anyway, today justice was served

  • @jadenphilander8799
    @jadenphilander8799 Před 15 dny +8

    You learned that even a rusty South Africa, who didnt play since the wod cup final, experimenting with a new style of play beat Ireland.

    • @cjmyers1654
      @cjmyers1654 Před 15 dny +14

      Listening to Neil it sounds like South Africans are really nice......except the crowd that keep showing up in the comments section of Irish podcasts obviously.

    • @jadenphilander8799
      @jadenphilander8799 Před 15 dny +3

      @@cjmyers1654 Bow down to South African rugby, you were the ones that were chatting shit and arrogant these past 2 years.

    • @brianbarbarich1401
      @brianbarbarich1401 Před 15 dny +6

      Welcome to Umhlanga Rocks. Enjoy your time in Durban.
      Let the best side win on Saturday.
      Cheers from Umdloti
      (close to Umhlanga)
      🇿🇦🇮🇪🏉

    • @superbowljoel01
      @superbowljoel01 Před 15 dny

      Pay no attention to the keyboard warriors. They don't represent us ​@@cjmyers1654

    • @the3rdtruth211
      @the3rdtruth211 Před 15 dny +7

      @@jadenphilander8799 A man telling Irish fans to bow down in veneration of SA rugby while accusing others of being arrogant? Outstanding logic you got right there ya absolute hypocrite. Pundits are the ones doing the talking, not the average fans

  • @FrancoisCoetzee
    @FrancoisCoetzee Před 15 dny

    Don’t vermouth a Springbokkie! That is like insulting the principles of an extremist religion and may start a holy war 😂😂😂😂 Make sure you have one before you leave South Africa. Most bars and pubs serve them here.

  • @CC-om8ze
    @CC-om8ze Před 15 dny

    Actually you were wise to walk away from drinking with a South African. 😂

  • @stevedavidson666
    @stevedavidson666 Před 15 dny

    Honestly, games like Saturday's - and of course the RWC - do so much for rugby union. Hats off to all the teams - even the ABs(!) - for showing how great the game is. Onwards and Upwards!

  • @garethmaybury5218
    @garethmaybury5218 Před 14 dny +1

    It's so hard to listen to Bernard Jackman saying 'ehm', 'eeehhh', 'eeeehhmmm' after every second word. I can't listen to him anymore. Infuriating.

  • @kurukoei
    @kurukoei Před 13 dny

    What have you learned? Well, Boks are the world champions. Ireland still haven't learned how to win a quarter final 😂😂😂

    • @readesiun988
      @readesiun988 Před 13 dny

      I know right, we are a very poor team, last Saturday we played so bad it was just embarrassing, that is why the world champions, the best team in the world the number 1 thrashed us by such a high score, bravo, you must be so proud.

    • @taintabird23
      @taintabird23 Před 11 dny +1

      And today you learned a little humility.

    • @kurukoei
      @kurukoei Před 11 dny

      @@taintabird23congratulations on the last minute drop doal victory. Well deserved. We just didn't pitch up in the first half. Simple as that. Just one question, has that changed the fact that we are back to back, four time and current world champions? Nope. Has Ireland ever won a world cup quarter final? No. See how it works? You have to win when it matters. A drawn series is what it is. Just No 1 v No 2 belting it out for 80 minutes. Sleep tight

    • @taintabird23
      @taintabird23 Před 11 dny +1

      @@kurukoei It mattered today, and you lost. In your own back garden. You have to win when it matters.
      Congratulations on your world cups, they are obviously very important to South Africans as they can't stop talking about them, but you lost today, again, against a team you have no respect for.
      You're supposed to win every time, South Africa are supposed to be the best. You can't even beat the Irish when it counts - at the world cup.
      See how this works? We know about our shortcomings, and you cannot accept yours.
      Its not good just winning the world cup, you have to be able to back it up. Lets see you coming second in the Rugby Championship again, and claiming to be the best in the world with a 66% win rate under Rassie.
      Farrell has no world cups, but he has a 75% win rate against South Africa alone!

    • @fallschirmjager0000
      @fallschirmjager0000 Před 11 dny

      And yet here we are, Ireland battered you yet again. 1 victory in 8 years against Ireland. Pathetic.

  • @sandorclegane3658
    @sandorclegane3658 Před 15 dny +2

    Ireland to be humbled (again) like it's a quarterfinal.

    • @Sineadmcd
      @Sineadmcd Před 15 dny +3

      Why are you so negative 😂all the other saffas in the comments are lovely/ this isn’t a World Cup and ireland were not humbled ffs. It’s unfortunate the guy on the left is saying how nice the SA fans were and here you are giving them a bad name

    • @lizzyhanahoe4197
      @lizzyhanahoe4197 Před 15 dny +2

      Irish people, in general, are humble. I just hope we don’t gift you another game.

    • @sandorclegane3658
      @sandorclegane3658 Před 15 dny

      @@Sineadmcd so if I say Ireland will lose I'm being negative? Ahh ok.

    • @Sineadmcd
      @Sineadmcd Před 15 dny

      @@lizzyhanahoe4197 what 😅😅

    • @Sineadmcd
      @Sineadmcd Před 15 dny

      @@sandorclegane3658 no you can say that.. but you said humbled and brought up a wc qf.

  • @Natedawg38
    @Natedawg38 Před 15 dny +1

    South africas motm a 3 way tie between the ref, the tmo and James lowe.

  • @paddyryan6113
    @paddyryan6113 Před 15 dny

    It's far from irelands best performance,
    Missing key players from the start with the boks fully loaded
    Massive respect to irelands defense and a last minor point , if Crawley had his kicking boots on it would have been a draw .
    Huge heart from ireland ,
    This weekend I believe will be a mountain to climb with our new injury list , respect to both teams for one hell of a game

    • @notenoughstones3873
      @notenoughstones3873 Před 15 dny

      If Pollard also had his kicking boots, that another 9 points for SA so can’t really count one and not the other. Think both teams weren’t at their best but still produced a great game. Think this weekend will be better.

  • @mthunziphakathi4215
    @mthunziphakathi4215 Před 15 dny +2

    The Casey incident was a rugby incident, hence the reaction from all players. Very unfortunate for Casey.