India Rising, China Reversing?
Vložit
- čas přidán 10. 12. 2023
- 📽️ Subscribe to the History Mapped Out channel now! Check out many cool animated videos here: / @history_mapped_out
📌 Support GTBT on Patreon! / gtbt
➡️ Paypal: www.paypal.com/paypalme/GoodT...
Production: Hubert Walas
Research & analysis: Shankar Ananth - McKinsey management consultant turned author of "Utopia: The Next Step in Human Evolution"
Video production: Kacper Machniowski
Voiceover: Hubert Walas
Music: Michael Vignola - Mislead
Business inquiries:
goodtimesbadtimes@lighthouseagents.com
Channel Angels:
Prodjekt: www.prodjekt.co/
🗺️ Maps: aescripts.com/geolayers/?aff=90
⚪ GTBT Polish - / @goodtimesbadtimespl
🟤 GTBT на русском: - / @goodtimesbadtimesru
🟣 GTBT France - / @goodtimesbadtimesfr
⚫️ GTBT Deutschland - / @goodtimesbadtimesde
🟡 GTBT Україна - / @goodtimesbadtimesua
🔘 GTBT Arabic - / @goodtimesbadtimesar
🔴 GTBT Español - / @goodtimesbadtimeses
🐦Twitter - / hubertwalas_
📘 Facebook - / good-times-bad-times-1...
#india #china
📽Subscribe to the History Mapped Out channel now! Check out many cool animated videos here: www.youtube.com/@History_Mapped_Out
📌 Support GTBT on Patreon! www.patreon.com/GTBT
➡ Paypal: www.paypal.com/paypalme/GoodTimesBadTimes
Both India and the People's R. of China are socialist authoritarian countries and India is far more tyrannical than Communist CCPland.
India will always remain remarkably POOR.
Albania is in the 1st world and has lower incomes and gdp per cappita than china which is in the second world. and all 3d world countries in the middle east and europe has among the highest in the world. !st 2nd and 3rd world is a political term of alignment and thus has nothing to do with wealth per se.
China will just create a virus to take care of their elderly population. They don’t care about human life
This video has better explanations.
czcams.com/video/smB6Blc-6oc/video.html
As an Indian, I really thank China. Because growth of China pressure our leaders to start making changes.
well said my friend! hope one day our countries will be friends again, peace!
Yea dream on 😂
@@Dorae-ur-momdreams are becoming a reality my dear friend
@@henrystevens3993 I do feel that India and China will solve their Problems. I have met many Chinese Tourists here in Mumbai and they r so friendly
@@Dorae-ur-mom whatever hamas terrorist
As a Bangladeshi i really hope India becomes a prosperous nation . They don't lack anything in particular .
But I'd say your country looks destabilize by Western powers unfortunately after Sri Lanka
as bangladeshi-american i hope our mollah regime gets abolished. Religion is our biggest problem. If We give actual basic human rights to every bangladeshi, our country can be economically powerful as malaysia and singapore. we can be bridge between india, china and America. We need to focus on education to our youth. We need talents to create IT sector, healthcare, government. Wish Hasina rewrite the constitution. Human rights over religion. freedom of speech. sametime if you do hate crime, you get punished. A country cant improve where young students take priority on madrasa over school.
We Indians don’t have oil
@@ayushkumar-bg1xf Its right next door in the Persian gulf and passes India as the first stop on its way to East Asia, India also has a decently large navy and thus could just confiscate oil on its way out of the persian gulf, Indians have the power to oil rather than the domestic supply.
rest aside, is your profile picture from "senryuu shoujo"?
you & Caspian Report are my 2 favorite geo-political analysis channels, much love for all the hard work you do to remain neutral!
Neutral? xD
Polishcentric... xD
@@HladniSjeverniVjetarlol whyyy hé is azeri 😂
@@oldbordergeeknot him, the Good times Bad times are polish
They're better than others. And CR is old.
I never knew what either were, but enjoy them regardless. ❤
India just need to focus on education,health and prosperity of india for next 30 years. After that we should focus on global affairs
wow.. you must be the graduate of whatsapp university ..
@@BlacqueJacqueShellacque thank God I'm a graduate not a nursery fail like you
If you leave global affairs and defense to trash cans, then there will be no one left to educate or prosper.
its not that simple.
India needs to focus on manufacturing, because we have large unskilled labour. Education is not that necessary, skill is important. We already have huge population with graduation degree but lack skills. With more manufacturing, focus will shift to labour skill development, which will support rapid economic growth.
Weird how Democratic India was more socialist than communist China, India really missed the train of Industrialization, even to this day getting land for factories and managing more than 99 people invites all sort of bureaucracy that it discourages people from setting up shop.
India was never socialist, they only had social democracy (or a mixed model). China is still socialist.
Democracy is merely about how representatives are chosen. There is nothing about democracy - or even the US Constitution - that defines the economic system it is paired with.
Also, communism and socialism are not the same.
India went through first wave of industrialization in 1970’s when steel, petrochemical, fertiliser plants and other heavy industries were setup in mass rate but the population skyrocketed from 1960’s to 1990’s we went from 300 million to 900 million population within 30 years
Democracy is shit in India. Democracy is the thing that is stopping India to grow as fast as China
You are confusing governance and economic models.
As a south Korean, i think someday india can be a glober leader. Super potential people, no language barriers, depth of math and science, Increasing population and young generations. Every situations about india make stronger.
In addition, against to one china policy, india can help china but also can threat to china. India can choose it optional and Every circumstance and situations are going well. Sometimes so jealous about india as one of a Asian.
There are so many things to learn from India. Most of Westernized countries like South korea, japan, maybe US also are looking forward to greeting for India.
GOD BLESS YOU INDIA,
From south korea 🇰🇷❤🇮🇳
你还是考虑喜欢朝鲜吧
U r not South Korean. Every one in South Korea knows the tragedy of POSCO’s investment in India.
@yeetian2774 i think maybe you don't watch the news, bro. Every korea companys, economic expert, professior do study about india. India have a super potential.
@@user-vj5zc9ev7h I watched news. That’s why I know POSCO failed big in India. Since u don’t know that it proved u t not Korean.
@@yeetian2774 머라는거지 대체.
넌 코리안임?
The Indians did a lot of self sufficiency for a long time. This was bad AND good. It meant that they wouldn't get picked apart, but it also meant that innivation lacked. They're late to the game on trade and were overly regulated, which was stifling. Now, however, they have a population of 300 million, tech savvy youth under the age of 25. The growth there will be slow, but steady, which is better for the health of the society.
@@spiritualseeker410I see ur point but what he said isn't wrong, China for 2 deacdes grew steadily at 10% growth rate, India's growth is more limited to 6-8% per year but it's more stable
@@NovelTuber atleast, we think that, but even economic predictions 30 years into the future can be very very misleading.
Imagine a country with 1 billion europeans, biggest superpower of the world 1:39
@@anonymerdude4501Yet Europe itself is fading.
"...they have a population of 300 million, tech savvy youth under the age of 25 ..."
42% of Indians under the age of 25 are unemployed.
Claiming that China could collapse is the dumbest thing I have heard for a while. Congrats.
No one is claiming that China is going to collapse. The reality is that China's rapid growth is now over.
It's a 20 trillion behemoth, it can never collapse, unless they start waging wars and sh/t. For now it's a wet dream.
@@charvaka5705 are you aware these stats are made up?
Hell even a chinese official said that the data is made up
they have a long history of manipulation of data.
the actual economy is around 8 or 9 trillion USD.
Funny how people like you think everything is forever, things change and it's known dictatorships are hurt the most by change the majority of times.
fr😂
China and India aren't really reversing roles, yes China is slowing, but it will still remain as the largest asian economy for a while. India is growing very fast, but it will still take time for it to catch up with China. Peter zeihan predictions are more fantasy than reality.
我以马来西亚人的角度来看 印度是不可能赶上中国 因为现在的印度还没发展起来就已经对中国充满敌意， 印度对中国的敌意已经让西方人看见了 每当印度经济超过7万亿美元就会被西方国家各种各样的打压 。
Housing Market CRASHING So Fast
czcams.com/video/cNb1zYQAgQo/video.html
India is currently treated favourably by the West because it's not challenging them. Don't expect the same when India does reach China"s present position.
India is treated fairly because they have to now. India still remember 71 war and sanction after nuke testing in 90s. Even now Canada and USA are actively protecting criminals and giving citizenship to them in name of separatist asylum.
Well you see west doesn't like someone who tells their hypocrisy
China's economy continues to grow while Westerners curse it, while India continues to be poor almost entirely while Westerners praise it, hahaha.
people like you are the reason why some in the West are skeptical of India
Well, we know that very well 😆
I think as a country India might catch up to China (as its population rise and China decline) but as average personal income it will not. Sort of like what people thought of China vs USA in the last few decades.
Indians can't do what East Asians did but the populations are still declining in India. India and China are fundamentally different. The worst part is that India has an absurd level of corruption, an awful amount of protectionism and is mostly anti-business.
According to some historians who have come up with some estimates for GDP of nations or empires the Indians had the largest economy for the last 2500 years of 3000 years but per capita income was never really high. I don't have any idea if this actually true.
Probably, especially with robotics and AI coming into place
Technically Chinese perception of India is old colonial perception not the modern state. The old colonial perception came from translation of British works which showed balantly racist opinion of Indians, depicting them as a fallen race or fallen land
of western slaves. But India has long since almost completely de colonized, especially with Modi and BJP, and Its a very different country since the time of British Raj, if China wants to engage with modern India, it will have to update its persotive by at least 100 years
@@advaithramesh6697 protectionism is pretty good example of a colonial hangover.
Yeah catch up 😂 Can’t live in Delhi these days because it’s so overpopulated, thanks to migrants from Bihar and UP who are exploding like bunnies. There’s something known as standard of living. Just boosting the economy artificially with cheap labour doesn’t guarantee success.
🌏 The video discusses the shift of global power from the British and American centuries to the rise of Asia, particularly India and China, in the 21st century.
00:23
The 21st century is referred to as the Asian century due to the rapid rise of China, India, and other East Asian economies.
India and China are expected to be the driving forces of global growth, despite facing their own unique challenges.
Both India and China have experienced significant economic growth, but they also face fundamental problems and uncertainties about their future.
🇨🇳 In the 1960s, China's centrally planned economy led to inefficiencies and man-made disasters, but after Mao's death, Deng Xiaoping implemented reforms and opened up the country to foreign investment.
04:48
China had a centrally planned Soviet-style economic model with rigid controls, leading to inefficiencies and disasters like the 1959-1961 famine.
Deng Xiaoping took over in 1978 and implemented reform and opening policies, including allowing product ownership and foreign investment, and normalized diplomatic relations with the United States in 1979.
📈 The video compares the economic development of China and India, highlighting the significant difference in their GDP and growth rates.
09:47
China's GDP was roughly five times the size of India's, with a much higher GDP per capita.
Chinese economy experienced explosive growth, doubling in size every 8 years, while India's growth never approached China's peaks.
Chinese growth story was built around a low-cost manufacturing boom.
📉 The video discusses the unfinished policy reforms and privatization in India, compared to China's more effective reforms but challenges with population collapse.
14:33
India's reform process is still ongoing and hindered by lack of political will and opposition to privatization.
China's effective reforms have led to economic growth, but they now face the challenge of population collapse.
China's advantage of a young trainable population is fading as the population ages and is not being replaced at the same rate.
📉 India's economic challenges, including weak infrastructure, trade protectionism, and foreign investment barriers, hinder its growth potential.
19:16
India's weak and inept infrastructure, lack of financing, red tape, and bureaucracy are hindering its growth.
India's trade protectionism and refusal to join global trade agreements limit its ability to benefit from global technological growth.
Indian protectionism has disallowed the nation to benefit from global technological growth.
good AI
Bot comment
The Chinese exponential growth was due to speculations in the construction sector, while democracy is generally slower it's also safer when it comes to prevent huge/gigantic economic mistakes and corruption cases (and the real estate bubble was borderline corruption made).
One may argue that the 2007 US real estate bubble was also government made but I disagree, it was actually a lack of statehood and rules that enabled the banks into speculations.
So we have the 2 extremes in the 2 biggest economies causing similar problems, maybe we will learn from it and find some kind of balance to avoid committing the same mistake for a 3th time
You're a socialist
100% agree. There is a lot less external speculation and interference within India's economy, leading to slower yet safer growth. Such is the nature of democracy. Not to discredit China's amazing rise, but I'll always be more worried by the slowly rising tsunami than the restless coastal waves.
3rd world war says we have not.
The USA having less regulation than Europe has had and is having better growth and a MUCH bigger economy per capita. You can't judge an economic system by the worst mistake it had in the last 70 years.
And going back further, the USA had an even more open economy and was ahead of the rest of the world before WW2. The biggest mistake being govt interference which was the main cause of the severity of the great depression. Federal reserve policies which they have now admitted and apologized for, and other issues like excessive tarrifs.
It's just bizarre to me how people look at the richest large country by far and say that economic policies of much less successful comparable countries are better.
What we need is Democratic Socialism with Chinese-American characteristics.
Great video
Congratulations
Great visuals and good explanation 🎉
india is dreaming ... india gdp is 3 trillion and chinese gdp is 19 trillion
Learn about compounding kid
For now, India is no where close to China. Even with China's weak growth percentage, the moeny it adds to it's gdp is higher than India. Unless India gets a very high growth rate, touching China is not possible.
As for the population, time can only tell if have 1.8 billion people in the age of AI and robotic will be more helpful or hurtful.
Truth..
Even the percentage growth the difference is minimal.
What's the difference between 5 and 6 percent
Fr
AI helps in manufacturing. Manufacturing for whom? AI 2?
When the whole world is growing old and dying who is going to consume in an economy?
@@muditbothra3266 World growing old and dying, that is correct but the world is getting richer as well with millions of people reaching middle class status. There is a reason why US and western eupore consume so much more than the rest of the world even though they have low percentage of population compared to the rest of the world. Consumption relys more on the wealthy of the people rather then just the number of people. Billions of people living in poverty will not consume more than ten thousand millionaire.
Thus, if the people have more purchasing power, they will consumer more.
thats the aim of india to achieve 9-10% growth rate
Good video! Keep up the good work.
Thank your
Indian demographic dividend is non existent, India's avg IQ estimate falls between 76-80, while that of China is 105. A large section of Indians are unfit for complex jobs
These IQ trademark is idocity how can they measure up 1.4 billion people country IQ
HDI, Quality of Life can be measured but IQ can,t
That's not true. Most people have the same IQ. But in China, people pay more attention to education. Their parents will try to get their children into better schools, and the government will build schools in remote villages. This is the reason for China's success.
Have the same IQ? Lol, not even close. India has a smart fraction but that's miniscule, but also has a large aboriginal population, which brings down the avg IQ score to 76.
@@shreyanshsingh7257National avg IQ measurement is not some mystery, if you actually know how it's measured.
Those studies about IQ are western propaganda....have you ever met an Indian professional?..
Lol.....top most earning diaspora in the US n UK..
India reminds me of Mexico, these countries are on the rise but their governments and historical dysfunction make me skeptical.
True
Will u invest or will u not?
And I see it as a huge problem, their dysfunctional governments could cost them a position in world power. Just look at Brazil.
@@rustyshackleford234india had a dysfunctional party and government for the last 55 years of 76 years of our independence. That party lost majority of its power. The current party is not dysfunctional. It is here to stay for at least the next 20 years because of how incompetent our opposition is.
India best achievements so far
India's Hunger index
2013: 63rd rank
2022: 107th rank
India's Happiness index.
2013: 111th rank
2022: 136th rank
India's press freedom rank
2013:79th
2022: 150the the fourth pillar of worlds largest
democracy is no more
India's unemployment rate
2013:4.9%
2023:7.5%
Unemployment rate never increase in growing
economy.. india is growing only on paper and by
loan
India's Debt
before 2014: ₹55 lakh crore
2023: ₹155 lakh crore
India's GDP from 2004 to 2014:
$709 billion to 2.04 trilion (almost triple)
India's GDP from 2014to 2024:
$2.04 trillion to 3.6 trilion (expected)...not even
double
If India makes better more solid products they will do well. Chinese always try to cut corners to maximize profits. If India acts with due diligence it will succeed
We don't need westen perspective
Lmfao is that why all the “high quality iPhones” or “tesla’s” are made in China and not india. In india, 50% of the iPhones were poorly made so they had to shut the factory down. China in 1990 is not China in 2023
It could never happen, comparing China with India is stupidity, China has always been a strong state compared to colonial dump, i.e India
@@dkbros1592 Then you probably shouldn't be on CZcams.
Western products are worse than Chinese products at the same price.
Another banger.
The difference between China and India can be explained in one word, Infrastructure. Anyone who has visited India can tell how bad the infrastructure is. That needs to be fixed before any talks about this or that.
Although what you said is true, india needs to maintain this for a while to see results. what im afraid is people counting the goose b4 they hatch, celebrating b4 results are seen and become complacent and corruption rising.@@spiritualseeker410
@@spiritualseeker410 Peak sarcasm isn't constructive.
@@spiritualseeker410 I don't agree with him either.The difference between China and India can be explained in one word, arrogant.
China's investment in high-speed rail alone has exceeded US$100 billion, and its total investment in other infrastructure has exceeded tens of trillions of US dollars.
@@spiritualseeker410 Being a crybaby and delusional won't help anything, as i said look at the current reality of both countries and you see the clear divide. Talking about possible future development does not change that fact.
@@spiritualseeker410 Will your magical Modi make all this happen perhaps? Keep dreaming.
China Gdp 2023 : 17.4 trillion
India Gdp 2023 : 3.75 trillion
That's the correct status India Now has 25 years of 7 % growth rate chance and 10 years of 5% growth rate potential china has 5 years 5 % growth rate potential and 2 to 3 % rest of the life time if it survives
I like everyone in this comment section is expert in india all of the sudden
U don't know what how is India
U know india from ur own western media perspective
start with a sarcasm about arrogant, end by arrogantly thinking everyone else is from the west.
gonna cry that we can look up all this information?
Why do y’all keep saying this west bullshit shut up y’all annoying😐
i actually agree with and believe a large part of content in this video, but in the back of my head wonder whether video like this aim to just get the growing Indian and Western anti-China viewers engaged
I guess yaah. I think Kraut made a great video on India vs China and India and Pakistan was more about society and culture which explains it much better.
Yeah the blatant Anti-socialism/ Anti communism kept him from making some obvious analysis that was missed here. It's definitely purposeful with the anti-China rhetoric, don't wanna be the tin foil hat guy but I think the Feds incentivize ($) pro US state department narratives for popular content creators.
Its literally this, any video from serious persons would demonstrate that the arguments here holds for many societies, but you do not see they yelling that everyday like is to china.
If you look up in google, newsletters and nowadays youtube are flodded since their existence with "tomorrow China will crumble", "the last days of chinese economy", "CPC failed", "crisis in China, its the end?", and things like that.
Chinese people in the other hand are seeing massives improvements in their lives, by PPP standards, US was passed since 2014, in 2020 China reached 0% of its population in extreme poverty, whereas US has 1% still, 96% of Chinese population are home owners, and jobs are getting more complex since this generation is starting to work later because they are graduating more, China is already the biggest producer of IP in this world, they also are leading EV, Nuclear energy, 5g and 6g, bullet trains, civil construction, naval construction, batteries, and many more.
I'm not even saying China is perfect, because it is not, far from it actually, but they do are improving by each year at large paces in many scenarios, whereas west is in the exact opposite direction, even in the demographic growth issues, west is seeing an high engagement of "not let those immigrants come anymore", but they demographics are literally tanked by this influx of people. But, instead of looking at those problems at home they are bombing countries in the other side of the world.
bother, every time I open your video, I first like it and then watch... keep doing the great work, can't wait to see another video of yours! 🇵🇱🇷🇸🇺🇦🇺🇸
China's economic model that is investment-driven isn't longer suitable at this movement, as China has more college graduate workers than ever in its history who will avoid working physically exhausting jobs in the manufacturing sector.
Indians trying to give Chineses lessons on economic development. I can't breathe haha.
But China is moving up the manufacturing and production supply chain. Their manufacturing exports have become higher grade like Nevs and phevs, solar panels, electronics etc.
You basically described every Western Nation as well with your statement.
Despite low birth rates, China still has an enough base population to bounce back, it’s probably going to trail behind India by the time it recovers,
@@1mol831 it is impossible that China can "trail behind india". if you have deeper information (and importantly the level of intelligence to understand geopolitics) - the upcoming demographic burden (and nightmare) for this world is india (including the origin of that poster .. PH). they has such an excessive population contributing nothing to this world that the human development index and institutes need to constantly press help towards them due to lack of sufficiency. excessive labour (idians), lack of work opportunities. which is why most of them constantly press themselves to be part of construction jobs in Qatar, saudi arabia and UAE. (You can look up what is happening to them, no payments and worst than prison living conditions.) Best part of all this year they became the most populous country on earth. I don't even know what else am i supposed to say for such a country.
Re: 6:08 - Normalization of relations between US and China was already underway when Mao was alive. It was one of the few genuine achievements of Nixon & Kissenger at the time.
At 2:39 Advanced Wars is such a great game!
China demonstrated it's military might, compelling India to modernize its armed forces, which in turn enabled India to successfully counter Pakistan's misadventures in 1965 and ultimately led to the events (Liberation of Bangladesh) of 1971.
Overall, it was a win-win situation for both countries involved, in my opinion
Just in case you don’t know, Pakistan attacked us right after they got independence in 1948. So China had no role in rethink our military strategies.
@@Aashu299中国在军事战略方面从来没把印度当敌人
Most of the manufacturing is going towards Mexico, Indonesia, and Vietnam. When India manufactured iPhones for Apple almost 50% of them were faulty.
Apple actually did so well in India they've said they'll do the research for their next iPhone in India, have announced they'll start manufacturing the batteries of Iphones in India too now and have set a goal for 25% production of Iphones in India in next few years. Where do u get your data from?😂
@@spiritualseeker410Apple is worth 3/4 of your entire economy, I think they know how a factory should function on what timeline
When walking along the streets in India you have to be careful as you will step on human faeces
Lol bro I never saw this even after 21 years living in India
Mark my word The Features of World will depend On China & India....
I have successfully marked your words Sir.
GDP (PPP): China $23,309, India $9,183. Source: IMF
India has so many poor people. I hope India experiences rapid growth that takes people out of poverty, but I'm skeptical.
yeah it is a valid point but you also have to keep in mind that in India the cost of production, supplying and buying of goods is way less than 95% of world including China so it seems as a big difference in PPP but in reality its not ................. Also there is lot more we have to catch up
@@praveenlodhi3332 cost of living is factored in, that’s why it’s purchasing power parity (PPP). The gap is much larger if you compare GDP nominal.
China 17.70, India 3.73 (trillions USD)
No one cares what some bot says
Go back to begging
India has a massive blind spot: india has proven incapable of building manufacturing, so number of jobs has remained the same in the past 20 years.
There was almost no effort of manufacturing before 2014 and all surveys were done around 2011
Could you please make a video related with the rise of Vietnam and its ambition. Thanks
vietnam is nothing comparable
Day dreaming is just like this 😢
@advaithramesh6697
0 seconds ago
Technically Chinese perception of India is old colonial perception not the modern state. The old colonial perception came from translation of British works which showed balantly racist opinion of Indians, depicting them as a fallen race or fallen land
of western slaves. But India has long since almost completely de colonized, especially with Modi and BJP, and Its a very different country since the time of British Raj, if China wants to engage with modern India, it will have to update its persotive by at least 100 years
Blablabla. Keep blaming the West for your own failure. With that mentality your country will stay poor.
India best achievements so far
India's Hunger index
2013: 63rd rank
2022: 107th rank
India's Happiness index.
2013: 111th rank
2022: 136th rank
India's press freedom rank
2013:79th
2022: 150the the fourth pillar of worlds largest
democracy is no more
India's unemployment rate
2013:4.9%
2023:7.5%
Unemployment rate never increase in growing
economy.. india is growing only on paper and by
loan
India's Debt
before 2014: ₹55 lakh crore
2023: ₹155 lakh crore
India's GDP from 2004 to 2014:
$709 billion to 2.04 trilion (almost triple)
India's GDP from 2014to 2024:
$2.04 trillion to 3.6 trilion (expected)...not even
double
I still believe China can catch up to the US. Its just that their economy and growth are becoming matured. They only need to maintain a 4-5% growth rate annually. This whole demographic crisis is way overrated, i believe human labor in the future will be less in demand and in value due to the advent of automation and Ai. This will eat away a lot of labor intensive sectors and shrink them. The real estate crisis was due to come and i believe the chinese economy can absorb the losses. The bubble needs to be burst before it becomes too big and cripples the economy.
Well if indias growth is dependent on foreign companies too much , they can hault it if they want ,like what we see in China now
We even get channel ads now? What has youtube come to
China's economic growth is amazing.
All due to their ridiculous investment in construction. And their construction is poorly made. Check out The China Show they will go into detail. China is the worlds worst polluter.
Mexico, selling to the US, and West Africa, selling to Europe, are more likely than India to pick up China's business. That is, providing Europeans realize that honest partnership with West Africa will alleviate migrant pressure, supply the same lower costs as did China, and create a far more energy-efficient, more geographically proximate trading block.
They gotta fix their corruption AND cartel problems before they think about becoming a world power…
Mexico is not making more stuff lol. They are just reselling Chinese product to US 😂
Why don't you'll show the complete map of India ??
7:11 Why are all the trucks driving backwards? 🤣
china is the future with BRI leading the way...
Japan, South Korea, Taiwan are the focus and China is angry seeing them succeed.
🤣 go back to watching anime kid
you heard it first from the anime girl geopolitical analyst
what? xDD
As a Korean Canadian, Japan Taiwan, and S Koreans are struggling.
Japan, Korea succeed 😢 . Are you kidding
The Resurgence of India and China: Implications for the Global Order
This is the research paper describing how two of these oldest civilizations were always the top powers of the world. After a dip, the power centre is shifting itself towards both and history is repeating itself.
High top marginal tax rates do not discourage growth, this is a myth of neoliberal economics, some of the highest growth rates in the US were under comperable top marginal rates. Nordic countries STILL have comperable rates and experience plentify growth. The problem was simply the difficulty in starting buisnesses, the Nordic countries are considered the easiest countries in the world to start a buisness in both in the speed and low cost, the exact opposite of the 'permit raja'.
Bro just thought, why India looks so poor when its economy is booming and then made an entire video on how bad India is compared to China to justify that notion🤣
Even his last video about India, more accurately presented India's real current status. This is way too half-baked and really really bad click-bait. To the point, I seriously doubt how did this guy get so many subs with his half-assed research.
"India Rising, China Reversing?" is the title, but majority of the video is parroting same old data about China instead of focusing on new developments in India. India has limitations as a democracy but its progress is nothing short of remarkable. India started 12 years late in opening up its markets and today its GDP has already surpassed China's 2007 economy, which means India is just 15 years behind China. Just because it doesn't look like it, doesn't mean India is a failure or something.
India will complete its first bullet train line by 2028 and maybe even a 300km section might be operational by 2026. At the same time, currently 200+ semi-highspeed trains(operating at 200+ km/hr) are going to be manufactured in India through state companies as well JVs with Alstom and one other Russian company. The first prototype is to be completed by early 2024. By 2028, there should be like 400+ semi-highspeed trains operational. At the same time, India's economy will be 5-6T. That will be the 2nd hype wave and at that time you will realize how inaccurate and dated the research in this video is.
Is it because Indians have never gone to school? I know that India’s literacy rate today is not as good as China’s a few decades ago. But I think even a three-year-old child knows the meaning of one moment and the other. The economic aggregate in 2007 was completely different from today. In 2007, the total economic volume of the United States was only 14 trillion. Today there are 23 trillion.
@@user-so3ll9sq4t Lol, pick up a better translation software you chinese bot!
This channel really blew up in subscribers after the Ukraine war started - and he predicted the collapse of Russia...
That's all you need to know about his " expertise".
He's probably salty about India not joining sanctions against Russia 🤷
India should not practice Western democracy. This system is not suitable for developing countries, such as India. Multi-party competition and fierce parliamentary fighting will make it impossible to implement national policies and seriously affect national development. No developing country in the world has successfully implemented Western democracy. The reason why China has been able to develop rapidly is because it rejected the Western democratic system, which enabled China to implement correct national policies. China is not a dictatorship. China's national policies are collectively planned by think tanks and are not decided by the president alone. As long as the policies are beneficial to the country, China will be able to implement them smoothly without any opposition parties standing in the way.
Fact: The gap between India's GDP and China's GDP keeps on growing.
Its already 500℅ gap between both gdp but they still compare both 😂
Support India from Singapore
India economy is now 4 trillion dollars💪💪🇮🇳
What's the gdp per capita?
@@harshul5358 about 2,800$ 7 times when we were just measly 400$ in 2004
@@shreyanshsingh7257 India best achievements so far
India's Hunger index
2013: 63rd rank
2022: 107th rank
India's Happiness index.
2013: 111th rank
2022: 136th rank
India's press freedom rank
2013:79th
2022: 150the the fourth pillar of worlds largest
democracy is no more
India's unemployment rate
2013:4.9%
2023:7.5%
Unemployment rate never increase in growing
economy.. india is growing only on paper and by
loan
India's Debt
before 2014: ₹55 lakh crore
2023: ₹155 lakh crore
India's GDP from 2004 to 2014:
$709 billion to 2.04 trilion (almost triple)
India's GDP from 2014to 2024:
$2.04 trillion to 3.6 trilion (expected)...not even
double
@@jacksmith-mu3ee Leaving Happiness and Hunger Index
let,s expose Khangressi SAAR🤡🤡
India Unemployment rate
2013-8.04%
2023-7.50%
🤡
India GDP to Debt ratio
2013-51%
2023-58%
India Inflation rate
2013-9.90%
2023-5.5%
Cheap Tactics of increasing GDP and making people suffer
🤡🤡
India GDP
Congress
2004-709 billion
2013-1.86 trillion dollars
BJP
2014-2.04 trillion dollars
2023-4.09 trillion dollars
You can check Wiki and search country rank by GDP
With 2 years of complete lockdown and Pandemic 🔒 and Ukraine war for 1.5 years
🤡🤡🤡
Both countries have a lot of issues to resolve.
As if west have no issues to resolve 😂
China best nation
@@rajibchakroborthy4181 which country is named west ?
@@jacksmith-mu3ee europe and usa and canada
@@rajibchakroborthy4181 so that's not west . That's europe usa Canada ..
India best achievements so far
India's Hunger index
2013: 63rd rank
2022: 107th rank
India's Happiness index.
2013: 111th rank
2022: 136th rank
India's press freedom rank
2013:79th
2022: 150the the fourth pillar of worlds largest
democracy is no more
India's unemployment rate
2013:4.9%
2023:7.5%
Unemployment rate never increase in growing
economy.. india is growing only on paper and by
loan
India's Debt
before 2014: ₹55 lakh crore
2023: ₹155 lakh crore
India's GDP from 2004 to 2014:
$709 billion to 2.04 trilion (almost triple)
India's GDP from 2014to 2024:
$2.04 trillion to 3.6 trilion (expected)...not even
double
China is a rival, but not an enemy. We are inspired by China's growth, we are trying to achieve that in our own ways.
1:37 i hope he doesn’t leave out India’s extraterritorial assassinations in Canada, USA, UK.
China has advantages that India does not have. Firstly, as a single ethnic and religious country, the level of unity and stability of the Chinese people is higher than that of India. Secondly, the geographical location is closer to other major economies in the world than India. On the left of China are the United States, Japan, and South Korea, on the top are Russia, and on the bottom are Taiwan, ASEAN, and Australia. China is clearly more conducive to import and export trade.
Geographically speaking,
India is more geographically closer to the Gulf countries and ensures energy security.
Moreover, Chinese waters are surrounded by long Island chains of hostile nations so it can't exercise it's naval capabilities .
While India controls a extreme choke point for Chinese energy security via Andaman and Nicobar Islands.
According to current trends, India's trade would increase exponentially with the inception of IMEC. Meanwhile, East Asian countries are stagnant in Economic growth.
Actually China has the most dangerous and difficult set of neighbours possible to have in the world.
China is ethnically diverse and has many different languages spoken.
@@samuelmorales2344 China is a Mono-ethnic Nation. Han-Chinese constitute 92% of the population. The other ethnicities are suppressed and forced into learning Mandarin and other Han Chinese practices. Currently, Speaking Tibetan in Tibet is illegal.
@@Senku_Ishigami_1Speaking tibetan in tibet is not illegal where did you get that from? I was literally in tibet this winter and plenty of people spoke tibetan.
Exactly! Japan became one of the wealthiest countries in the world before its economy stalled. China never reached a wealthy status and therefore, China is entering the middle income trap. Given China's demographics, breaking out of the middle income trap will likely be impossible.
It may be that China is barely middle income. Li Keqiang, the former premier of China and a top economist, said that China's GDP numbers were inflated by 20-50%. Hu Jintao, previous president, had made comments that seem to back this up IIRC.
I think Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan all grew in a unique window of technological change. The electronics revolution was timed exactly when South Korea and Taiwan had authoritarian governments that made the right moves for growth and quite uniquely stepped back and let things grow.
@@recoil53very well thought out comment
@@recoil53isnt it amazing that when whatever they speak fit into your narratives, it suddenly uncontested, while other time they are all liars, ccp fake news and sort.
Idiot, the fundamental reason why China is not wealthy is that there is too much population and the labor force is not worth it. Only with a low birth rate and an aging population can China significantly reduce its population, making it prosperous because there will be more real estate and heritage. Fortunately, China's urbanization has led to a decreasing birth rate, and in the future, China's population will experience a cliff like decline, which is a good thing for the Chinese people. Do you think China's development needs to rely on the hundreds of millions of farmers from the past?
@@recoil53 Idiot, the fundamental reason why China is not wealthy is that there is too much population and the labor force is not worth it. Only with a low birth rate and an aging population can China significantly reduce its population, making it prosperous because there will be more real estate and heritage. Fortunately, China's urbanization has led to a decreasing birth rate, and in the future, China's population will experience a cliff like decline, which is a good thing for the Chinese people. Do you think China's development needs to rely on the hundreds of millions of farmers from the past?
Thanks!
China's GDP is ~ $10B, Not $19B.
Despite similar population number at 1.4b, India only have 672m workforce vs 931m for China. 48% Indian worked to support the others 52% unproductive population vs 66% Chinese worked to support the others 34% unproductive population.
*India:*
Population 1.4b
Male 700m = 73% labor force participation rate
Female 700m = 23% labor force participation rate (On par with Somalia, Pakistan, Palestine)
Total workforce = 511+ 161 = 672m
Literacy Rate = 69%
*Educated workforce = 463m*
Grain production = 330 million tons
Grain Reserve = 700 million tons
Comparing *India to China* is akin to comparing *Pakistan to Japan* , *Bangladesh/Nepal to South Korea* , *Sri Lanka to Taiwan* . One group is influenced by Chinese civilization, the others group is influenced by Indian civilization. Two different class. One is Yellow the others is Brown/Dark. One uses chopsticks, the others uses bare hand. The most developed country in ASEAN is Singapore, a nation populated by predominantly Chinese an East Asian origin people.
One group collectively & consistently ranked within the world top 10-20 in IQ Test, PISA Score, University Rank, International Collegiate Programming Contest (ICPC) & Mathematical Olympiad standing shoulder to shoulder with western world ....while the others group collectively & consistently ranked somewhere in the middle out of 100+ participant nation standing shoulder to shoulder with some failed states & banana republic.
It's like comparing some Africans countries with Europe. No developed countries exist outside of Western & East Asian world.
LOL
So what you are claiming is that Africans, Indians and Central Asians are dumb compared to Western world and East Asia?
cope
Just say you're a racist lmao
+1000 Social credits have been added to your account, you are now eligible to purchase bus tickets.
As for your blatant racism of Indians, you are dead wrong. You have a 80s view of India. You will be updated soon when the 2nd Indian hype wave hits the world. I will just leave you with one stat.
India grew from 450B in 2000 to 3.7T in 2023(8 times growth). If it continues this growth, it will be 30T in next 20 years.
To all China haters: let’s meet here in ten years and see who wins 😊
I'm from India even after 10years both countries stays where they are today.
lmao India won't even get close to China in 10 years, let's be realistic here.
Make video about british decline after WW2
And also please case study about Europe and america 😂😂😂😂
I stopped watching when the video says "China is reversing". Reversing means recession and decline. But despite its slowing economic growth, China's economy is still growing at 5% a year and it continues to rise in technology, politics and soft power. So China is still rising but they are rising in a more even fashion where the growth is all round and not just the economy.
Power of India lies in her Spirituality. More powerful India the more spiritual people in the world will become and more spiritual people will be more peaceful and blissful people will roam on streets
Most of them are stupid uncivilized and indiscripline
religion is a barbaric cancer to humanity and progress, but ok buddy
Long way to catch up and in every way.
The Indian nation still has to grow a lot. Because of the western colonization of around 250 years. The only thing we need to do is now don't go inside other people's wars and matters and focus on growth.
Although it may take a long time here in India because of elections and such but if good people are in power we will eventually develop and I can guarantee you we will not be the world bully like China.
China's GDP growth rate is indeed slowing down in recent years(projected to be 5.2% this year). However, due to its size is more than 5 times that of India's. The gap between two countries is widening, not narrowing. In other words, India is growing faster than China now, but not fast enough to catch up.
a very enlightened being, Swami Vivekananda said over a 100 years ago that the 20th century was US's but the 21st century will definitely be India's.
India's GDP could surpass that of China some time this century
but climate change might disrupt that.
In particular drought, heat waves and the loss of glaciers that provide a steady
supply of water could pose serious problems.
Then there's that dam that China built on a major river that flows from
China to India.
Apparently, as well millions of people in India are expected to be displaced
by sea level rise.
Let’s see if India can really make it.
India faces another hurdle. It’s one of the most vulnerable country to the global warming. There are now yearly heat waves of fifty degrees Celsius. Keep your hand under hot tap water to understand what it means. It’s not just an environmental problem, it has also economic consequences. And the worst is yet to come.
India has very diverse climate throughout its geography, u can't put it all in one basket, if there's 40° in one part, there's 25° in another part and there's 0° in another part
China also has deserts with high temperatures, but in fact, where there are many plants, the temperature will not be so hot.
@@NovelTuberagreed
India best achievements so far
India's Hunger index
2013: 63rd rank
2022: 107th rank
India's Happiness index.
2013: 111th rank
2022: 136th rank
India's press freedom rank
2013:79th
2022: 150the the fourth pillar of worlds largest
democracy is no more
India's unemployment rate
2013:4.9%
2023:7.5%
Unemployment rate never increase in growing
economy.. india is growing only on paper and by
loan
India's Debt
before 2014: ₹55 lakh crore
2023: ₹155 lakh crore
India's GDP from 2004 to 2014:
$709 billion to 2.04 trilion (almost triple)
India's GDP from 2014to 2024:
$2.04 trillion to 3.6 trilion (expected)...not even
double
@@jacksmith-mu3ee do tell me your mechanisms for the Hunger index and Happiness Index, how TF so u calculate it? Those indexes have Pakistan (country living with n aid and poverty over 40%) over India, and Afghanistan higher in happiness index than India like be serious 💀 these indexes are targeted to make India look bad since u can just post it with no means to verify, same with press freedom tell me ur criteria? All these indexes made by western bodies with no credibility, press is as free as ever in India but it won't run with the west's new narrative of painting India as facist since it has a strong leadership now and refuses to follow west blindly , unemployment rate increased temporarily because of Covid as it did in many countries including China and USA and many countries in Europe, India actually has one of the least spikes in unemployment rate after COVID, and India's GDP is 3.7t already and will pass 4t in 2024, so update your data, that's doubling the GDP, and I don't know how 2004-2014 data is any way used to discredit it, it just shows India's has been silently growing for some time now and now since it has become big and visible people have started talking about it, talking about future too India is currently largest growing major economy and has been predicted to remain so by every major financing body like IMF and Goldman Sachs
@@jacksmith-mu3ee talking about debt that's a very normal thing, every major economy have debt related to their GDP size, America have 2x the debt of their GDP, that's how countries grow
Edit: I wrote this before watching the video, the author mostly agrees with me, so disregard my arrogant remarks. When China "stagnates" (like this year) they grow by more than 5%. When the us "grows" they grow by 3%, at 2% inflation while their national debt grows by 10%...
In general it's a better strategy at analysis if you stick to facts instead of putting analysis behind your hopes and dreams. China might not become a global hegemon like the US, due to obvious great power balance, but India will never catch up. They want to do everything themselves, which turns foreign investment away.
No country can catch up without that, as this is the most efficient way of industrial growth and technology transfer. Having the largest population means nothing when ~40% is still employed in agriculture, most of them plocking the ground with sticks, selling low yield and quality produce at subsidized government prices. Then we didn't even talk about the inefficient bureaucracy, undeveloped financial sector, major environmental problems, (appearing before significant industrialization), backwards legal system, cast system being a major blockage to social mobility, state wide religious and ethnic conflicts/tensions. Badly educated, low added value workforce... Can't even list all the problems here. By the time they'd get to the level where foreign capital wants to flow into the country population decline will have already started by then which won't allow the Chinese development model to work.
A rising India will be good for us all
Hindi got so hard-working Chineese' eyes weidenned.😂
I haven't seen any evidence that China's AI is far advanced. Can someone link to source material that illustrates this?
Their public surveillance system?
Their public broadband system?
czcams.com/video/Pattftit914/video.html
Actually,now I live in China.And the AI is quite popular here.For example,if u r in a hotel,and u need something from the hotel reception.There will be a robot help u to carry things to u.That's quite intersting.Because the robot is so cute and u can interacte with them.And that's such a unique experience.
Ur just painting ur westen perspective on india and china
I don't know anything about India
Ur jus going with old rant of Western media welth adani this that a tax
U don't know anything
Congrats INDIA from Philippines.
I have been watching❤ this channel since the beginning of the russo-ukrainian war and I'm wildly impressed still. Keep up the good work!❤
从军事和综合上看中国和印度都有绝对的影响力，但一个事实可以看出来印度最富的州甚至不如中国中部的省份，如今的中国确实陷入经济泥潭中，但经济增长率仍不逊于欧美，相信未来印度会成为和中国一样的世界新一极
Every coin has two benefits. China is becoming a super power and india is also increasing its economic activities very well.
Just positive With our hard work we can achieve anything 💪
India best achievements so far
India's Hunger index
2013: 63rd rank
2022: 107th rank
India's Happiness index.
2013: 111th rank
2022: 136th rank
India's press freedom rank
2013:79th
2022: 150the the fourth pillar of worlds largest
democracy is no more
India's unemployment rate
2013:4.9%
2023:7.5%
Unemployment rate never increase in growing
economy.. india is growing only on paper and by
loan
India's Debt
before 2014: ₹55 lakh crore
2023: ₹155 lakh crore
India's GDP from 2004 to 2014:
$709 billion to 2.04 trilion (almost triple)
India's GDP from 2014to 2024:
$2.04 trillion to 3.6 trilion (expected)...not even
double
To the people who say Oh India is poor, so slow, they will never overtake china or the usa, there is always beaurocratic obstacle, they takes decades to develop their infra & so on as shown in the video = its clear that you people don't know enough about the history of the Indian Subcontinent, This area has always had Slow Growth for their lifetime existence basically for thousands of years we have always worked slow like this 😊
Your comment makes no sense. You just confirmed what people are saying is true that India is slow, yet you accuse them of not understanding India’s history. Lmao
While at the same time america and europe declined in economy because jnflation
As a india we know our previous govt was corrupt and have muslim appeasement politics. They never focus on the development of india. Our present govt is doing very good work and try to rapidly develop india. We have also a neighbour like terrorist pakistan. And its easy for a communist country to work on infrastructure than a democracy where every project get challenge in the court by environmentalists and foreign funded NGOs.
Modi has been PM of India for almost 10 years now. You cannot blame Indias bad economy on a previous government and on the fact that India is a democracy. The fault lies 100% with the ruling party that a) prevents foreign investments b) is not able to build up infrastructure c) is more concerned with "muslims" than with actual economics.
I definitely prefer India. Although this country is facing many challenges, indians have better work life - balance. Chinese ate too obsessed with money and production.
Indians do want work life balance but India has no jobs for its educated class. So, whoever gets the job has next to no work life balance as his value as a worker is low coz there are millions to replace him and managers eat you.
Endian hallucinations lol
Smear China doesn’t help Indian economy to win the competition with China
May India rise to prosperity. Jai hind 🇮🇳
Britain killed 4 million Indians in Bengal in 1943 by imposing a famine
The usual lies are spouted here? Great. 🙃👎
@@manwithamask7276 the issuing of statements without the clear context thst includes actual mismanagement from the regions hit haed by famine. To the harsh reality of the war that did not allow grain shipments because Burma, the Philippines and other regions to get supplies was either in enemy occupation or the ships needed to deliver supplies were so lacking that Churchill himself asked FDR to free up ships to deliver food to Bengal.
India's external debt at end-June 2023 was placed at $629.1 billion, recording an increase of $4.7 billion over its level at end-March 2023 according to data released by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) on September 28.
According to the Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy (CMIE), India's unemployment rate was 8.11% in March 2023.
The latest 'Accidental Deaths and Suicides in India' report by the NCRB indicated that 32,457 individuals succumbed to heart attacks in 2022, a notable increase from the 28,413 deaths recorded in the previous year. Heart attacks account for 28% deaths in India, govt submits ICMR report in Rajya Sabha
Crimes against women rose 4% in 2022 compared to 2021 according to the annual report of the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB)
India is the world's second most polluted country. Fine particulate air pollution (PM2.5) shortens an average Indian's life expectancy by 5.3 years
According to the recent Bloomberg report that references data from the Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy (CMIE) for July, the overall unemployment rate in India is 7.95 percent as of July 2023.
Wake up!
space economy is something worth infinity, infinity of resources are out there and india is not lacking behind USA and china in space, in fact india have potentially to beat them in space, when humans will start mining on mars and importing those metals, elements from mars or moon to earth, india might become first or best if not first in space mining, that will change india and human civilization forever, world will be really different place in 2050 than it is now and some new trillion dollar sectors will grow rapidly in world GDP, space tourism and space mining might be new trillion dollar sectors and not every country can do what india, china, USA can do in space, and only these 3 countries will share these trillions of dollars sectors, trade through low earth orbit (space) instead of ocean is also concept which is very real and possible, you know what trying to say? space in future of human civilization and no one can challenge USA, china, india in space, just like no one was able to challenge britishers and europeans in ocean 500 years ago...
India is rising very slowly and China is not reversing.
India growth rate ~7%
China growth rate ~4.5%
Source-: World bank
@@SHVTR their 4.5℅ is our 504.5℅ because of gap in sizes of gdp's that is 5 times india's gdp.
@@akshaysharma3809 have you heard about compounding? We can surpass them with that growth in 50 years
@@akshaysharma3809 their 4.5 % is not our 505% pls check your calculations
@@akshaysharma3809 it's ~20%
China is growing at 5.4% rate this year and within this decade China has potential to grow 7-8% similar to 2021 any body who is saying that China is declining is actually a myth 😅
China most likely won’t hit its 5.4% growth target this year, and it’s predicted growth for the rest of the decade is less than 5% per year. Chinas period of rapid growth is over and it will likely stagnate like Japan
@@Alex-fm5ke😂😂You clown is totally talking nonsense. I work in China. China is completely different from Japan. It is not an American dog and can develop independently. Unlike Japan, which is suppressed by the United States everywhere, the situation you are talking about cannot happen at all. China does not need so many people, because many factories have already realized automated production, and India can only brag about it in the media, 😂😂😂
But China is still growing at 5% for 2023?? 😅😅
India is growing around 7 percent since a decade
@@SHVTR In 2020, due to covid, China growth rate was at 2% while India's was at -6.6%
@@Jacktan9203 recovered very easily . Less COVID deaths too
@@Jacktan9203 in 2022 9.10 %
@@SHVTR With a simple Google search, it says India is ranked 2nd in COVID deaths and cases.
Keep fantasising India. It doesn't cost anything to fantasise.
😂
On the contrary, China's expansionist fantasies are going to cost it a lot.
Just saying, there is no reason China and India should compete for the scraps and trimmings of the west. China recognizes this and tryin to move upmarket and this is why the US is targeting China. India should do the same, more upmarket and not trying to become the next cheapest labor
India, just like China is ALSO focussing on AI, quantum computing, space technologies, green energy and high grade manufacturing.
China had to follow a transition because all these things just didn't existed when it started.
India is doing everything at once.