A Labourer Argues Case in HC and Won
Vložit
- čas přidán 30. 05. 2023
- A Labourer Argues Case in HC and Won #MpHighCourt #SupremeCourt #LawChakra
Patna High Court Karnataka High Court Live Stream.
#Patnahighcourt #SupremeCourtofIndia #Supremecourt
Courtesy :- Supreme Court of India
Books on Constitution:- amzn.to/3rqFpbh
Tools Used for editing:- amzn.to/3EelR1r
For business Enquiries:- eqnuire@lawchakra.in
#SupremeCourt#Mussorrie #advocate #lawyer #legal #livehighcourt #indianlaw #law #live #court #argument #criminaljustice #guiltyminds #learnadvocacy #courtlive #justicelive #lawmotivation #beajudge #ias #judge #law #legal #patnahighcourt #justiceashutoshkumar #judiciary #motivation #learnlaw #IAS #supremecourtofindia #IPS #2022 #Patnahighcourtstream #orissahighcourt #SupremeCourt #Orissahighcourt#GujaratHighCourt
#Law #Chakra#JusticeAshutoshkumar
*This Video is strictly for Legal Awareness & Education Purpose only.📚
🙏 Follow us on twitter, Instagram and facebook.
@Lawchakra
👉Twitter
/ lawchakra
👉 Instagram.
/ lawchakras
📑*Fair Use Policy -*
Copyright Disclaimer under Section 107 of the copyright act 1976, allowance is made for fair use for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favour of fair use.
Judge trying to convince the man why he should not go for justice 😂
so that he will get less cases to work on.
The judge is trying to explain to the poor man that instead of wasting his time and energy on court case which even if he won would earn him a penalty of 50k, he would earn that much by working for 2 months instead.
@@greymatter.91konsa majdur 25k kama rha hai mahine ke batana Zara ?
@@ratmaster4012are chalo 3mahine hi pakad li, but at least he will be in peace of mind. Ye court ka chkkar is very stressful, jindagi ki L lag jati hai.
The man is reluctant to work it seems and wants easy money
Why don't the judge sahab join him at his work for a week to get to know the physical requirements for his line of labour.
Exactly
Why is the judge scolding and pontificating to this working man who is standing there in his court looking to get justice due to workplace injury that has made him unable to work in his earlier capacity. The judge has no business lecturing this man. He has never picked up a tool in his exalted life to know what can this man can do and cannot, to earn income. The whole judiciary seems to be full of “Desi Babus” with inflated egos and sense of superiority. The whole of Indian judiciary needs to be reformed wholesale. Very shameful.
Rightly said. Instead of delivering justice. They give sermons. Pathetic courts.
He is not. Judge is making the case for defense which might have been argued beforehand when the petitioner's lawyer was not present. It should be more on the petitioner lawyer who isn't fairly representing the man to the extent that he isn't even present in the proceedings and hence the case was thrown out. Judge did an excellent job in staying the decision for a fair hearing.
Exactly my thoughts! And the judge speaks in singular because he is a laborer.
The biggest problem in India is the judiciary. Fix this and the rest of the things will fall in place. Most Indians have ZERO faith in Indian judiciary
Judge is enquiring his well being and giving some suggestions.
When a small little man is called a lord he starts to think that he is indeed a feudal lord in Victorian England.
This is showing us the strength of common man in the court. Our honourable President was right about changes in judiciary.
The judge is diagnosting the man as if he is a doctor. This is laughable, this is how mahabharat happened. Judge nyay dena nahi chahte hai.
The man wanted nyay not suggestions, diagnostics, tareekh, etc from the judge.
then he says stay kar dete hai chakkar marte raho, which is soo wrong.
Talwana is urdu word for आव्हान (challenge) with process fee form of course.
They will give you everything but nyay.
Judge is acting like a politician.. Pathetic condition of indian judiciary
He is not acting like a politician, he is just trying to understand his situation.
@@hrshvrdhnup agreed
Judge can't utter a single word out of emotions you should understand it it's not KBC or Indian Idol where judges start crying
Instead of scolding labour judge must advice him for free medical checkup and produce health certificate infront of court and then for further proceedings as per requirement
Who will pay for the medical checkup?
Judge is shocking... the poor guy said he can't work due to an accident, but this judge keep on insistinghim to work Rather them helpinghim out.. this is how indian court are run against poor people..
What kind of professionalism is this? He is instructing a victim to forget his pains and work it off!
He lost his efficiency and skills because of that incident. .. and this judge is giving Gyan to this poor man to work on other things.
Shame shame...on the judge 😢
Pehla judge dekha jo khud bol raha hai, "Nyaay ke badle mein aapko kya milega?" 🤦♂
It is pathetic that most of the judges in Indian Courts behave like this but they have no idea how tiring and hurting are for a mid to lower starta people of society for a justice to be sought.
Mostly the judges from Cow belt states and HCs from the Hindi belt states do that (Ofcourse, a lot of exceptions exist).
@@anuran.chowdhuryi sense racism here.
3:26 Judge saying "NIYAYE THODI MILEGA"
*Shame on these judges*
As an advocate it made me emotional when he asked for
' justice ' .
Judge ko aise case politely Sunna chahiye because ye bahut hi aam garib nagrik hai court procedure ,ligal knowledge inko utni pata nhi hoti ,ye is bharose se aate hai ki nayayalay me judge unhe sunege or nayay denge
These types of judges should be suspended they sit with their ego and atitude on chair
Yeah this man should work, afterall a Mistri works in an air-conditioned room with a comfortable chair and moreover such work can easily be found just outside the doorstep, right?
Felt sick watching this.
The judge is dumb enough not to know inorder to be mistri it take several years firstly by being helper , even then it isn't sure the helper would be mistri cuz some mistri won't allowed help to learn any work technique
The person is asking for Justice, then give him Justice. Why is the Judge comparing the Justice to the monetary benefits. the attitude and behavior needs to improve.
Really sad for the common man.
shocking statements by the judge. The labourer should ask for compensation, regular income, health facilities and schooling for kids… the judge is not a doctor to understand what he went through. very sad
Garibo ko insaaf milna bahut muskil h.
Everyone hating the judge, please note:
Judges give a verdict based on proof of evidence. The labourer has no medical proof at his disposal that he has suffered an irreparable injury. His advocate isn’t present and he possesses half information. Judge has done his best in present circumstances to give him a better chance and stay the order and give him an opportunity to present his witnesses. Hence asked him to deposit the fee for witnesses called as Talbana.
The judge asking him repeatedly regarding doing some other work is basically an enquiry to assess the injuries suffered by him and severity of such injuries.
At the same time he is recommending him to keep working and not wait for payment of Damages in case he wins the case, as it won’t be enough to sustain him. He is suggesting and ensuring that this isn’t the intention of the petitioner.
You see the labourer pleading, please also see the patience and efforts taken by the judge to present him an opportunity instead of telling him that he is wasting court’a time and resources and abrogating the case or declaring it ex parte and adjudging based on the half information presented, only to cause more harassment to the labourer later or making him appeal the case later.
It's the judge's job to ask for medical evidence, not to conduct a clinical examination. It's the judge's job to seek EVIDENCE about an injury, not question a man's career path. It's my, the citizen's, expectation that the judge be courteous and respectful, which frankly, he fucking is not.
The common man has no knowledge of court proceedings, so they give adverse comments
Judge just giving opinions and lessons
But, that does not give the judge any right to say to the worker that "Nyay leke kya milega aapko", it is not the duty of the judge to decide that. It is the duty of the Judge to judge the case. Apart from that the Judge lives in such delusion that he thinks that a mason can earn 50k in 2 months. These people live in an ivory tower and sit in AC rooms and have no real life struggles such as those faced by the poor people of the country.
1:26 khud mast se ac mai baitha h usko gyan de raha h
Pathetic condition of indian judiciary😢
Sadly, half of India is still on the condition of this person. It's a great lesson. But people in power should be more sensitive to make them empowered. The judge seems logical but lacks empathy.
Instead of providing justice, judge is lecturing the victim. Shameful condition of judge that he keep on pressuring the victim to withdraw and discourage. This country will never improve unless judiciary System improves.
Sad. The judge seems to be trying to tell the poor man to not want justice. Such judges show why Indian courts are incapable of granting justice. The judge is not interested in the right and wrong of the occurrence but on technicalities. Shame.
that is what courts have been reduced to, agents of themselves (Law and it's theory, formalities) etc rather than JUSTICE and the rich only can exploit them fully.
I think it's the judge who needs a new job.
"Niyay chahiye" strong words
Now the judge is doctor....that's why I called them Sarbajanta
is it not a joke that, judge says he will get a compensation of 25k, which is equivalent of his two month salary.
Meri didi accountant hai uski 2 mahine ki payment Mila ke 24k hai 😢😢😢😢
@@rishavprasad1248 in today's world its hard to survive in 12k/mnth. Agar salary hike nhi ho rha, suggest her to upskill in Data Analytics by watching CZcams videos, she be dealing with same numbers and statistics but IT sector pays more and even gives flexibility of work from home.
@@rishavprasad1248 in today's world its hard to survive in 12k/mnth. Agar salary hike nhi ho rha, suggest her to upskill in Data Analytics by watching CZcams videos, she be dealing with same numbers and statistics but IT sector pays more and even gives flexibility of work from home.
I don't like how judge argued with him. Just look at his condition !!
Judge does not know ground reality
Such an uncouth judge. He seems to be the son of Marie Antoinette
People, having the knowledge regarding law and labour law , can they explain what should be the compansation provided to a person, who lost his livelihood because of an accident happened to him on his workplace while the person is on-duty?
Only 2 months wages?
Or this should include the harrasment from the police, the boss of the labou, and even from judiciary system for being financial incompetence and not having proper education?
Judge saying Majdoori me Vajan thodi uthta hai... So pathetic, Tumko zyaada pataa hai ya Majdoor ko zyaada pataa hai majdoori k baare me.
When he said I need JUSTICE, Judge be like bhai kuch or maang leta yeh kya maang liya
Those who are blaming judge these judges are sooooo knowledgeable that they are fighting a case for same sex marriage, and they know it will lead them to peaceful retirement so that they don't have to work on critical case where their brains are put to test.
It's so heartwrenching
He should get justice. Sir apko nahi pata shareer ka jalna kaisa hota hai
Whom to believe the judge or the law😢
Unfortunately he is just a laborer if he was a wife filing for Alimony / Maintenance he would had received millions by grace and mercy of judge. By the way judges why don't you all also find some other noble profession rather than wasting publics time and money.
Horrible judge.hardly did any labour in his life and scolding poor man
सभी अदालत में इस प्रकार के कैमरे लगने चाहिए
इन सब से अच्छा तो बाहुबली और गुंडे न्याय दे देते हैं
In this case of electrical shock accidentally resulting in physical injuries to the complainant. A complete assessment of injuries and present physical health status should reviewed by constituting a Medical Board and complete medical case history as well as present health status should be done by medical board and submitted to the relevant authorities/ labour court. Quantum of compensation should be calculated on basis of the findings of the medical board. Prima Facie case is of accident occurred in work place and daily wage employers i.e. construction contractors should be held responsible for not providing a safe working environment, thus grevious injuries sustained by the petitioner a mason by profession. Therefore the contractors should be summoned to the court and on basis of all observations and reports of medical board the compensation should be awarded as per the law.
न्याय मांग रहा है सलाह मिल रही है। वो कुछ करे या न करे ये तो उसका निजी मसला है गरीब का जो न्यायपूर्वक उसका हक है दिलवाना चाहिए
Wonderful
vakeel ki wajah se isko dikkat ho rha hai
Why don't the judge's take the same view in maintenance case, shame on judiciary.
😂😂 Simba man
His veins are dead
Judge soul is also dead
The judge is more sensible regarding this matter. He is trying to convince the person to perform some other work which is not labor intensive. Which is good currently. He might get some compensation but how come it will be sustainable for him in long run.
Who makes people like this as high court judge
Maine suna tha ki judge bik jate hai aaj dekh liya
Shameful!!!
This judge i have seen in 2 3 cases he won't let the lawyers make their point and in this video too just by hearing his voice i knew kuch kand hone wala h
I wouldn't want this judge to take my case
I don't know why but i prefer watching American court proceedings.
judge sahab chinayi karte hue bhi ite uthani padti h, kya aapko ye tak nhi pta
जज ह् बो ऐसे हि नहीं बन गए उनको सब पता है ।2,3 किलोग्राम कि ईट होती ह् वाह भी नहीं उठेगी क्या ।।
The entitlement of this guy is ridiculous!
Poor man telling his inablity to do work!
Judge needs to be Empthatic and Humane to the Poor Common Man....
Otherwise
न्यायालय से भरोसा उठ जायेगा
Very few good judges in India. I take my hats off to these gentlemen.
It is a matter after dismissal in lower court due to absence of counsel,
For restoration of case and stay this drama by labourer in person was necessary and the director of the drama is his advocate standing outside court.
As a lawyer i understand behind the scene, judge knows that this was a drama by advocate do he behaved like that with labourer,
Judges and judiciary never can be bad, they are trained to justice giving
Everyone who is suggesting that the Judge should not have questioned him regarding the case, or should have helped him because he is poor and not educated, should remember that it is not the job of a judge. If a rich person/ a government employee was questioned in this manner, all of you would have praised the Judge or even criticize them for a lenient line of questioning. When we ask for equality we should ask for equality, not privilege. When you romanticize the poor and demonize the rich, it has dire effects on society. Being born poor is not in anyone's control but being poor in your middle age is based on one's actions. Being uneducated is not to be celebrated at all, one should not be empathetic towards someone being under-prepared. I am not saying underprivileged and privileged are on equal footing but after 75 years of independence, the least a society should expect is for everyone to be out of poverty, or at least be educated (basic education, not suggesting the formal education).
Shameless judge
The judge could have been a bit more sensitive to the plight of the poor labourer instead of being judgemental.
While listening to the Judge sahab I had a feeling that he is having a really good entrepreneurial sense and then I read his surname :P
6:00 aree ye peeche to vhi didi baithi hain jinse judge sahab bahut impressed the😂
Yahan kyun aaye ho?
Nyaay chahiye Sir Mujhe...
Tears rolled down 😢😢😢
This judge is extremely good. He seems hard but is fighting for the poor man indirectly. Other judge would have thrown the mistry out.
Real face of Judges......... public watching the Ego of judges and their behaviour with poor people ,shame 😢😢😢😢😢
British legacy, where justice was deliberately denied for poor people .
Now I understand why the selection of judges is such a difficult process. Most of you folks in the comments section are emotional fools who will simply flow in emotionalities like poverty, gender, family etc rather than following the correct process of justice. The process of justice requires hearing both sides, looking at evidences, ascertaining whether the evidence is admissible, weighing the arguments and the evidence and finally giving a decision based on principles of equity, fairness and justice. A judge cannot allow his personal sentiments to overtake the due process. The process of justice is there to ensure that no one is unfairly punished.
Here, we as viewers, who are making judgements about the court do not know the facts of the case and are making judgements based on only what we have heard from the labourer. What if the judge takes a judgement on emotions and gives a favourable judgement to the labour, when in fact he was lying? That would he injustice to his employer and would set a dangerous precedent
Advocate ke absent hone se applicant ke adhikar khatam nahi kiya jana chahiye .
Kioki ki applicant ko apna patch rakhne ka adhikar hi , isse advocate ke rahme , na rahne se fark nahi parna chahiye. judgement deni chahiye .
This judge need to be suspended.
Yar ab log court kyun jate hai,mauj ke lye kaya? Judge ajib bat puchta hai.. kyu aye ho ... Sidhi aur saaf baat hai ..NYAY ke lye
Judge को एक बार मिस्ट्री का काम try करना चाहिए। सब समझ आयेगा कितनी मुश्लिल होती हैं।
Kaha hai justice yeha pe ....
👆👍👌
same logic doesn't apply to married women.....
no one tell them ki kaam karo muft ki alimony kyu chahiye
5:03 sunny deol
Poor judge. Looks is in bad mood today.
Judge ko suspension order de do 😂 judicial system mazak bana ke rakha hai
Judges are real godd
Gods
Gorib ka koye nehi hota😢
Judge: yaha kyun aaye ho
Me: vadapav kharidne
Shameful
Judge saab, respectfully you should step down from the bench. Shame on you. I did not expect the judge to speak to an illiterate in such manner
First line me respectfully, next line me shame on you. Ekdum se waqt badal dia jazbaad badal die tne
may be Judge always try to examine parties, whether he/she are stating true or false..!
Horrible labour conditions in MP
Judges need evidence, witnesses and strong arguments. People tend to think a court works like Hindi movies where emotion is king - it is not. Although the Judge can exercise some discretion, he is not God, he has to follow the law. In the video, he is looking at the papers, he knows the chances this man has of getting a compensation. We do not know what the Judge knows, we do not know any facts. We just see the guy's emotions. Even if a compensation is awarded, there will be a counter lawsuit, then another etc. This labourer will spend his life going to and coming from court because he cannot afford to pay a competent lawyer.
Also, these Judges did not start sitting on such high chairs suddenly. They were trainee lawyers, then lawyers, then lower court judges and then reached this spot. They have seen the worst of the worst criminals, perverts and frauds. They do not get emotional easily. They do not trust easily. And it should be so. The law should rule based on facts, not emotion.
That said, I hope this labourer lives a fulfilling life.
This judge is corrupted seems like he is defending the other party ?? If not doesn't this guy deserve justice ? Asking fr better working condition is crime or asking for compensation for injury at workplace.We are doomed unless we get our judiciary reformed.
Lower is currept
Judge ne contractor se pahele hi paise kha liye h.. Saraki nolari m esa hadsa hota to pension alag sarkaar ko bhi lakho ka muaavja dena padta.. Isko nahi pata ki mistari ka kaam bhi bahut thakane wala hota h.. Current lage mistri ko koi thikedaar nahi lega kaam pe
Pathetic judge. Who gives him the right to suggest an alternate source of income to the complainant.
Eha to theke daar ka chlega
These clips must be stopped. Either stream it completely for entire day or proceedingor stop it all. Courts are not tik tok etc to create hype by such thumbnail. do it like SC is doing
Getting compensation because of electric ⚡ shock 🤯 is his right, not some prize. Judge is so dumb.
Gzb gzb k log h bhai... Bechare ko topi pehnana chahte h zbrdsti kaam kro kaam kro😂
Never do a thing yourself but lecture others . Wow! How Empathetic
Yes judge ko o kam karne ko bolo