the doctor that I was rotating with told me to do right over left, left over right, right over left, left over right. does this match with you explanation?
+Ariful Islam From a strength standpoint, a slip knot or even a series of them is weaker. one string wrapped around the other stationary strand a bunch of times puts much stress on the straight string increasing the chance of failure. hence square knot, AKA surgeon's knot in medical field.
Hello David... If you use only index finger, youl will end up wit several simple knots on top of each other. They do not hold well, will slip and twist easy. The Square knot is strong because the second knot is in reverse. Both knots are tying each other together. The symmetry of the two strings coming out of the loop, is the build you are looking for. Hope you found out, made some knots and got the difference. Look for these Guys: animatedknots dot com
Still, I find that there are much easier techniques for doing square knots than this- by simply doing a right-over-left, and the a left-over-right. I find that this sort of technique makes it much tougher than it really needs to be to get the same sort of knot. Mind you in actual practice, you would be using needle holders to do this more than likely, in view of sharps safety. I get that we're trying to use a "one-handed" technique, but I don't see why this is necessary or functional- it just seems to make things harder to do in general.
You have to alternate to get enough friction and stability. One use of NOT alternating knots could be the slip knot. You will use two throws of the same direction to get the ability to push the knot into the depth of wound. but you still have to fix it with alternating knots afterwards for a permanent strenght.
This is the most complicated way of tying this knot that I've ever seen. Can people really not remember right over left then left over right or visa versa?
![One Handed Surgical Square Knot with Explanations [UndergroundMed]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/-1m87_1D_jc/mqdefault.jpg)
Thank you! Now I understood, you explain very very good.
oh my word - you're a genius! I could never tie properly, thanks a mil!!! :D
Thank you. You've made things so easy for me
THANKS!! my first right surgical not was done successfully
Thanks this was super helpful!
your genius .... i could never figer it out but thanks to im getting it right 😍
Thank you so much,
Seen other videos, but this is the best🙂
I watched half a dozen of these videos and didn’t get it until now!
thank u very much!It was really helpful!
Thanks, I thought I had it down, but I kept throwing slip knots until your video showed me where I was messing up!
How can we cross the hands intra operativ.?
amazing amazing amazing amazing technique
thanks!
the doctor that I was rotating with told me to do right over left, left over right, right over left, left over right. does this match with you explanation?
why doctors use square knots during the surgery? can any one answer my questions please
+Ariful Islam From a strength standpoint, a slip knot or even a series of them is weaker. one string wrapped around the other stationary strand a bunch of times puts much stress on the straight string increasing the chance of failure. hence square knot, AKA surgeon's knot in medical field.
I was taught to prevent the thread from being cut during strong knotting
thanks! very helpful
thank you from the future
Why do we alternate between the index finger and the thumb at all, couldn't we just continually use the index finger?
Hello David... If you use only index finger, youl will end up wit several simple knots on top of each other. They do not hold well, will slip and twist easy. The Square knot is strong because the second knot is in reverse. Both knots are tying each other together. The symmetry of the two strings coming out of the loop, is the build you are looking for. Hope you found out, made some knots and got the difference. Look for these Guys: animatedknots dot com
Still, I find that there are much easier techniques for doing square knots than this- by simply doing a right-over-left, and the a left-over-right. I find that this sort of technique makes it much tougher than it really needs to be to get the same sort of knot. Mind you in actual practice, you would be using needle holders to do this more than likely, in view of sharps safety. I get that we're trying to use a "one-handed" technique, but I don't see why this is necessary or functional- it just seems to make things harder to do in general.
maybe some videos in our channel will support your style of knotting.
You have to alternate to get enough friction and stability. One use of NOT alternating knots could be the slip knot. You will use two throws of the same direction to get the ability to push the knot into the depth of wound. but you still have to fix it with alternating knots afterwards for a permanent strenght.
You are making it So complicated...
So basically it’s just like tying a shoe lace
I realy want to be a surgeon so bad
loop-connect-push-pull....
Great video now I can tie my girlfriend up without her escaping! :D i mean- this is great for my medical studies 8)
This is the most complicated way of tying this knot that I've ever seen. Can people really not remember right over left then left over right or visa versa?
All wrong. First you get your knitting needles out......