@@bobafet3953 I think hollywood makes sure there is always a black character in each movie. That is pissing off a lot of Europeans who'd want to see movies with just white people.
czcams.com/video/3Vlhqnn5POQ/video.html Look at this video from Atun-She films (my n@zy roommate) What you said litteral happens in it, exept the fact that he first captured the kitchen and then living room
Pavlov's house stands tall still as a monumnet in Volgograd. I have been there. Russian brothers fought tooth and nail, defended the Stalingrad City and that changed the face of World war II. Love from🇮🇳
@@antares1407 Well done Mate, in that case, Had it not for Czechs occupying Polish Zaolzie since 1920 there would not have been any war at all.... would it?
@@antares1407 Well done, Zaolzie was part of non returnable dowry of Queen Doubravka of Bohemia, and hence ever since had been part of Polish domains, had it not for Czechs to relegate against that deal, there would not have been the need to take control in 1060. ;)
I appreciate this scene because, in a battle as insane as the Battle of stalingrad, with massive casualties on both sides, The soldiers must have been weary af. So good officers who give solid morale speeches is important to keep the troops fighting. It's like motivating a sports team as a head coach in a way. Morale is fragile and could be broken easily.
flownet07 LoL I think you Forgot japan,Italy.Hungary,Finland,Croatia, Spain,Serbia,Slovakia,Romania, Palestine,and Bosnia. All helped the German war machine. 🤦♂️ and they still lost 😂
I was born in 1976. All my life I grew up on the history of my country, on the history of my parents and grandfathers. I know and remember everything about fascism and Nazism. We were not taught in school to love and hate any nation. We were taught that all people are people. We are all the same. And when I hear that some nation considers itself the first class, and another slave, it revolts me. Why America and Europe consider themselves first class people! Who are you to think like that? We people of Russia have never, you hear, never thought like that and are not going to think. On this planet, everyone is equal, and before the Lord. Who gave you such a right to manage our lives? Who gave you the right to show us where the truth is where the lie is and to impose this idea on us? You were entrusted with our life, our way of life, and you twist us as you want. Who are you after this? You are the devil
My great-grandfather died there,and my family and I found his name on a memorial plaque near the eternal flame. I was near this very house, it is even scary to look at it, and what happened in it, even scary to imagine. I think it was actually a lot scarier than it is shown in the movie.
There were many such houses in Stalingrad. The house of the Specialists. The Bank Building. Pavlov's House. The Central Railway Station. More men died fighting for them then for entire countries in Europe.
the most terrible and faimos of them all was the tractor factory in Stalingrad. More soldiers died there than in all the buildings that you mention combined
Stalingrad was one hell of a battle. Both sides, Germans and Russian soldiers fought bravely, the germans trying to conquer the city, the russians defending the city. Hats off to both sides!!!
Dr No no the Wehrmacht didn’t do anything. All of the “murdering” in the east which were the Baltic states were done by the SS or einsatzgruppen. The Wehrmacht were just soldiers.
Dr No ok you’re right the many of the Wehrmacht weren’t innocent as it describes that they took part in mass killing. But let us also not forget that both sides equally committed atrocities as the The Red Army raped and killed innocent civilians upon entering Berlin.
Fun fact: the Krauts lost more soldiers at the famous Pavlov's house in Stalingrad than during the entire campaign against France in 1940. Russians are real badasses. They crushed 80 per cent of the Hitler's armies
they did that at gun point...and it depends which russian armies you mean. in ww1 they didn't not have success nor in the first wave of ww2. it wasn't until stalin brought over the Mongolians at the point of a gun and when winter came that things changed. There was no planning or skill in what they did. Finally, the germans were outnumbered in literally every battle they fought. the kill rations were as follows Germans 1/ Americans 2, Germans 1/ Brits 4, Germans 1/ Russians 12. As recorded by West Point. The germans made the army of 300 look like Girl Scouts.
That is your stupidity at beliving propaganda bullshit. Is no only an outrageous claim by itself but is also miscounting Chuiko´s book "The beginning of the road" page 173 who claims " ... killed more enemy soldiers than the german lost taking PARIS". Which is not big deal since Paris was declared open city and it was not defended at all.
@@marksaldivar4106 Oh boy! Do you study history by comics right? I can't believe that sane person can type such ridiculous Nazi propaganda in 2022. Actually Red Army was outnumbered by Nazis on 1941. Total qty of German troops participated in Barbarossa was 4 millions. Total qty of Soviet soldiers on western part of USSR was 3,5 millions. Just do you math!
Well ya see there's levels for example Saving private Ryan is pro US but shows the brutal reality the second world war very well. So many Americans get killed in that movie you can't call them super men it's practically just the opposite. Where as more Russians were killed in a level in COD World at War then this one scene. It's basically adding to the whole misconception that Russian was invincible in the war. Which if you ask roughly 21 million Russians who didn't survive it obviously wasn't. Yes all war films are bias to some degree but they're not all propaganda. It's only propaganda when it glorifies combat for one side and makes the other look entirely hapless.
@@user-hn2bb5vh5f Не смотри это. Я долго ждал этот фильм и сильно разочаровался. Лучше "Иди и смотри" пересмотреть чем этот цирк. (Фильм Федора Бондарчука - Сталинград).
Бондарчук не плохой режиссёр, но погоня сейчас голливудскими штампами, зрелещностью и безумными эффектами портит всё. Лучшие фильмы о войне бесспорно были в СССР. Там всегда раскрывался внутренний мир героя, а не погоня за количеством спец эффектов. К тому же сценарист писал сценарий под лёгкими наркотикам))) безсмыслица полнейшая)))
idiot comment, the movie is based on Pavlov's House (Dom Pavlova) in which the soviets held the house for 60 days against a huge wermacht offensive. actually i guess they had IRL plot armour ;d
I dont think that house last that long. Lot of people doing researched about that. German didnt priority that place on the early-mid time assault because they wait another team from another side to cross but it arrived pretty late before they clear those area.
Ussr has lost 30 million people during the fights. There was only 40 million people living in France en 1940 I'd rather give up during the France campaign than be forced to fight until death in Stalingrad Soviets were real cannon fodder
@@1112rayquaza that number is way overinflated. It was closer to 20 million. Every year the number seems to get bigger. I've seen low estimates from 19 million and the highest estimate at 27 million. I'll say 23 million because it's the median but 30 million is way over.
@@1112rayquaza I know that, I study history. I'm sure you do to. However you should at least be accurate with your numbers. Don't round up because it undermines the point your making and makes people question other facts you say. Also my comment was facetious and was said as a joke. No need for the over analysis.
Facsinating scene. An excellent demonstration of the complete futility of war. Just a minute ago, a bunch of guys were healthy and they had a future, but some hell, one of them needs to take the destroyed house, and the second to protect it, although there is nothing of value in the house. A minute has passed and there are no guys, no future, no fathers, brothers, sons...War is senseless and merciless. Old people send young people to die for their obsessive complexes. People should send old people to hell early to stop the madness
Вы много не знаете. Сталинград надо было защищать до последнего. Если бы он не важен был, то его оставили бы. Он давал проход на Кавказ и другие просторы. Там была нефть, газ, и другие полезные ископаемые. Благодаря Сталинграду, немцы не захотели брать Ленинград. Они понимали, что после ещё одной такой битвы, они останутся без армии. Так что защищали не дом, а защищали выход на полезные ископаемые.
@@Thesturmgever коллега, повторяю тем, кто в танке - мой пост совсем не об доме и не об том, кому надо было защищать выход к Кавказу. Мой пост о бессмысленности войны, которая убивает молодых парней, которым насрать на есть выход к Кавказу или нет, которые оказались в военной форме, с оружием, в незнакомом месте не по своей воле, а были призваны исполнить" долг" старыми маразматиками. Властные старики не сидят в окопах, но им все мало своей земли и они хотят заграбастать еще у соседей. Один убил миллионы и застрелился, другой убил, сгноил, умертвил миллионы и умер в луже своей мочи - зачем было войну устраивать? Сразу нельзя было застрелиться?
@@Archibald787 ваще мнение итак понятно, без пояснений. Но для тех кто в бронепоезде с тележкой, я объяснил на сколько важен был этот город и для тех и других. А так, по моему для детей младшей группы детского сада и так понятно, почему война эта безумство.
This short movie is about Standard, the city on river Volga. If anyone interested about the story of this house, please search "Pavlov's House" to find out more information about what actually happened there.
According to modern Russian directors, this is how WWII actually happened. More explosions in the manner of Western films and a love story must be present. War without love did not exist. And if you did not have love during the war, then you did not fight at all. *facepalm
And he is Avengers: Age of Ultron as well. As that Hydra Baron who experimented on the Twins. And yes he is in Victoria movie as King Leopold I of Belgium
Extremely realistic. This is so close to reality, now that I've seen it I can't even tell if reality is more realistic than this. It really represents the quality of Soviet propag...ehm sorry, Russian film making.
@@gaodacheese4691 possibly yes. Still, this comment was directed towards thr Russian propaganda machine. I'd also like to point out that, unlike the USA, the Soviet Union was a terrible dictatorship that even outperformed Germany in genocides and executions.
@@MQuaritch I don't know if you could compare soviet with germany, noone outperformed the other. Both terrible. Soviets massacred for political power, Germans massacred for that too and also for ethnic cleansing, which is a disgusting motive. And if we're talking about present. I think out of all these three the USA is doing most of the bad things that are happening TODAY, multiple wars and deaths around the world after WW2, video games and US propaganda made most Americans think they are helping lol, when it's actually all about political poeer, the war industry and enriching the elite.
and what prevented other countries from defending their homeland? For example, France, Ukraine, etc. Maybe the problem here is not in the geographical location, but in the people themselves? at the same time, one Pavlov house lasted longer than the whole of France, Estonia, Latvia, Ukraine combined
Какую бы парашу иностранные режиссёры не сняли, а всё равно дом Павлова не сдался. ВЕЧНАЯ СЛАВА ГЕРОЯМ!!! Спасибо вам большое наши деды за то небо которое вы подарили нам ценой собственной жизни. Молюсь на вас. АМИНЬ.
This scene shows the famous Pavlov's house, it is based on real facts, the house that was under Pavlov's command was so resistant that the German army marked it on the map as a place where no troops should pass.
@@jonathanallard2128 Then read about it. The accounts of Stalingrad are harrowing. Like the fight to the death at the grain elevator, losing whole divisions 24 hours after crossing the Volga, the AA gunners who met the Wermacht when at the fringe of Stalingrad. It was D-Day, every day for 6 months. Read Antony Beevor's Stalingrad book.
@@toshirox2 I read a lot about Stalingrad because it is a battle I'm completely fascinated by. I did read Anthony Beevor's Stalingrad and many of his other books too (D-Day, Crete, and the fall of Berlin which was ''my favorite''. I read it twice, and I just about never read a book twice.) I find him easy to read. He includes many small testimonies in his narrating and those are my favorite parts. Your mistake is assuming that the reason why this scene is a joke to me would be because it was too brutal or deadly. I watched it a year ago and I won't watch it again, but it surely ain't that. If you have read some good books written BY veterans, I'd love to have more of your suggestions. Cheers!
@@jonathanallard2128 I believe you with the scene. I saw the guy screaming as her fired the MG and said "nope!". Then looked back at the Germans standing before the attack -- 4 out of 10 held Russian weapons -- in 1942? Doesn't sound right. But movie makers can have it the way they want it. Crete was interesting because the German paratroop corps was crippled and never revived by Hitler who came to the conclusion that a paratrooper attack could not get the element of surprise, when really it was that Enigma had been compromised and the Brits knew the where, when, what of the attack. Did highlight the strengths of the Gemran Luftwaffe and the Brit Royal Navy.
Немцы к октябрю уже взяли Сталинград, только маленький плацдарм оставался на берегу Волги Советам, где окопались части Чуйкова! Немцев подвели на флангах союзники, если бы на флангах стояли Немецкие части то котла и не случилось бы! Кто знает!
@@jonathanallard2128 yes, looks similar, but another meaning. Christendoms should be ready to fight at any time. Russian saying nobody should even try to fight with them, only peaceful relationship is accepted.
@@user-gx3oz7gj7p Do you know how hard it is to acquire close combat days, to acquire sufficient even for a Bronze clasp is no easy feat, I have not seen one period photograph of a German soldier in Stalingrad with a CCC badge. If you have one produce sir, produce. I have seen many photographs of germans in Stalingrad with the Infantry Assault Badge.
@@ExRhodesian I don't argue. I live in Stalingrad now (in Volgograd, of course). I know a couple guys who are digging, looking for the bodies of forgotten soldiers and study history of that period, they know better than me. I will ask them.
@@user-gx3oz7gj7p Living in Russia you must have lost some ancestors during the war, I now feel we all lost that war, no matter which side our families were on. WW2 was like WW1 a waste of good men and women for the benefit of the bankers and their pals. The same scoundrels who are up to no good now.
@@ExRhodesian I agree. During ww2 my father's father lived near Novorossiysk (another Hero-city). And my mother's father lived in occupied Ukraine. I think something similar is happening in the world right now. Most of civilians dont want war. For example, in eastern Ukraine or the middle east, people die for other people's ideas and other people's money... Where are you from?
While I do find this scene to be quite interesting, I would love it if you could put subtitles next time. Individuals that are part of the Deaf community may find it difficult to understand what they are saying especially since they are not only speaking another language but switch midway through to yet another language. If adding subtitles is too much of a hassle, then you could try adding the transcript feature to make it easier to understand for everyone.
They might have flinched and stopped playing dead for a few seconds. It's not actually shown and the german soldiers were ducking for cover so couldn't see.
@Neptune I have a lot of respect for those Germans, as after all I can't say I disagree at all with the idea of destroying communism. What a different world it might have been.
Title: English
Story: Germany
Dub: Russian
Me from Asia: Yesn’t
I’m British and this is confusing isn’t it
Mr Worldwide
ah haaa best comment. !
...@ least u never had Hitler...
@@wudzah what exactly disappoint here ... the dubbing ?
That moment when the German is translated to Russian but you dont speak either lmfao
That moment when us foreigners watch an American movie with nothing but blacks in it and need subtitles 😹😹
@@Sigueme1 lmfao also "blacks?"
@@bobafet3953 He meant that there are too many black people in American movies.
@@lukebruce5234 Really? I dont really see many.
@@bobafet3953 I think hollywood makes sure there is always a black character in each movie. That is pissing off a lot of Europeans who'd want to see movies with just white people.
That guy plays so many German soldiers , at this point I swear he actually fought in ww2 and just didn't age
Thomas Kretschmann is his name.
Yeah, I think he was the only actor in both movies about Stalingrad. He was good in 'the Pianist' also.
@@akken2112 and he was the Ship's Captain in KING KONG with Jack Black lol
@@allanalt8958 He's a versatile dude. lol
also in Valikiriye (2008) film, german officer
I didn't realise WW2 was fought in slow motion... this is why the war lasted for 6 years.
It's a movie what do you except 💀
Как фильм наз-ся,подскажите пож-ста
@@siracorucov3761 русское пропагандонское кино .
Correct, and it was also in black and white. So this movie is not entirely realistic.
@@huskvarnarymd8337 yeap, that's one of the reasons why it took so long. Everything was grey and quite difficult to see anything
"sir, we've captured the living room, but were still fighting for the kitchen!"
We gotta capture point f also known as FRIDGE
Comrada Comissar, the soldiers are starting to miss water, we need to take the bathroom quickly.
czcams.com/video/3Vlhqnn5POQ/video.html Look at this video from Atun-She films (my n@zy roommate) What you said litteral happens in it, exept the fact that he first captured the kitchen and then living room
Yeah, that's about it. Stalingrad was literally a fight house to house room to room. It was really brutal.
Student days.
This house lasted longer than whole Europe.
Eastern front decided all
Yeah
@@teutonicorder6284 xDDDDDDDDDDDDDD
UK lasted 1939 -45.
@@Stakan79 I think Britain is a separate part of Europe. I said about eastern-central Europe.
Pavlov's house stands tall still as a monumnet in Volgograd. I have been there. Russian brothers fought tooth and nail, defended the Stalingrad City and that changed the face of World war II.
Love from🇮🇳
czcams.com/video/7z14mLRCkys/video.html
Kid, hitler gived India independence.
Had it not for Russia and their Nazi best buddies in 1939 invasion of Poland, WW2 probably wouldn't happen at all or lasted that long.
@@antares1407 Well done Mate, in that case, Had it not for Czechs occupying Polish Zaolzie since 1920 there would not have been any war at all.... would it?
@@antares1407 Well done, Zaolzie was part of non returnable dowry of Queen Doubravka of Bohemia, and hence ever since had been part of Polish domains, had it not for Czechs to relegate against that deal, there would not have been the need to take control in 1060. ;)
I appreciate this scene because, in a battle as insane as the Battle of stalingrad, with massive casualties on both sides,
The soldiers must have been weary af. So good officers who give solid morale speeches is important to keep the troops fighting.
It's like motivating a sports team as a head coach in a way. Morale is fragile and could be broken easily.
He was talking about that Hitler is their god and that in India every whore have 6 hands...
...typical nah-tzees in russian movies
I could only imagine that the real fighting in Stalingrad was 100 times more barbaric than in this clip.
It was most likely like this but with less drama and more gore
Look at movie clips of islamic state from iraq or syria...
Yeah it was real
After the war that's why they drank every day I would
@Forest Leech they had great uniforms
The German army was one of the best trained armies in the world. It took the world to defeat them ...
Russians are just enough.
8
flownet07 LoL I think you Forgot japan,Italy.Hungary,Finland,Croatia,
Spain,Serbia,Slovakia,Romania,
Palestine,and Bosnia. All helped the German war machine. 🤦♂️ and they still lost 😂
@@Foolishdog5888...
@@fynnoleianson8802 du bist deutscher ne?
I was born in 1976. All my life I grew up on the history of my country, on the history of my parents and grandfathers. I know and remember everything about fascism and Nazism. We were not taught in school to love and hate any nation. We were taught that all people are people. We are all the same. And when I hear that some nation considers itself the first class, and another slave, it revolts me. Why America and Europe consider themselves first class people! Who are you to think like that? We people of Russia have never, you hear, never thought like that and are not going to think. On this planet, everyone is equal, and before the Lord. Who gave you such a right to manage our lives? Who gave you the right to show us where the truth is where the lie is and to impose this idea on us? You were entrusted with our life, our way of life, and you twist us as you want. Who are you after this? You are the devil
Why are you in Ukraine?
Lame ruski
Saya selalu mendukung Rusia untuk mengalahkan hegemoni Barat....
Urrraaaaaaa
Fascism is devil's religy!
When the final circle lands perfectly on a house.
Thomas Kretchmann seems to play german soldiers a lot. He was perfect in “The Pianist.”
Tom G
He fits the typical german soldier role so
also in valkry
He was also in King Kong lol
FEGELIEN
Even in Das Boot Tv series season 2 he also plays!
*Fegelein in Stalingrad, Circa 1943*
FEGELEİN FEGELEİN FEGELEİN
NHAAAA
Desertor
Stimmt 😉
@@elfuhrer8384 "Desertor" vor allem. Wenn die Grammatik der Führer sehen würde...
@@thomasdereinzigwahre2315 en español wey
Q: How much slow-motion do you want, Mr Director?
A: Yes.
The meaning of 'living room' on a whole new level...
Lol awww man that's a good one😁
What is the name of the movie, please?
The actors are always older and fatter than the real documentary soldiers.
I remember Sven Hassel's books. The leader of his unit was called "Old Man", because he was little more of 30 years old.
To me it’s the other way around lol
A lot of farm boys in those times
True that. I found a 1945 photo of my grandfather with a couple of his friends recently. He was 24 then and he is the oldest man on the picture.
The real soldiers were emaciated due to lack of rations, these guys had a buffet during tea time.
My great-grandfather died there,and my family and I found his name on a memorial plaque near the eternal flame. I was near this very house, it is even scary to look at it, and what happened in it, even scary to imagine. I think it was actually a lot scarier than it is shown in the movie.
Did he fight for the germans?
@@Francisco-FX no, he was a Russian soldier. I have four great-grandfathers who fought in this war, and two of them did not return.
@@Francisco-FX Lmao the dude named Oleg Silkin, and u asked if he is German blyat
Russian PLAGUE, zombies, not soldiers.. just poor people who was killed by germans and NKWD
@@Acaquowara почему ЧУМА? Русские хорошие солдаты, не хуже немцев.
I’m just loving these videos. So realistic. I was stationed in Germany two times . I for one just loved the language.
It's from a movie called Stalingrad from 2013
This German officer gave the most epic speech before battle
I love how americans call this russian propaganda but hollywood movie show how the american army really fought
Yeah but we are more used to it so we don't do it as much now and Russia isn't going to show a movie showing them bad they band the death of stalin
@@jaywilliams9294 nah they don't, most people still won't say it but stalin IS hated
@@lincolndexter9514 They did ban the movie CZcams it
@@jaywilliams9294 what movie
@@lincolndexter9514 The death of Stalin
Slow motion: exists
Russian director: *This is free real estate*
* roommate enters my side of the kitchen
Me: "And I took that personally."
There were many such houses in Stalingrad. The house of the Specialists. The Bank Building. Pavlov's House. The Central Railway Station. More men died fighting for them then for entire countries in Europe.
За все страны Европы это вряд ли , Югославии пожалуй побольше погибло
the most terrible and faimos of them all was the tractor factory in Stalingrad. More soldiers died there than in all the buildings that you mention combined
Stalingrad was one hell of a battle. Both sides, Germans and Russian soldiers fought bravely, the germans trying to conquer the city, the russians defending the city.
Hats off to both sides!!!
Geoffrey Devore hats off to nazis?! wtf...
they werent all nazis. my ucle died in the soviet union. he was NOT a nazi.
Да конечно, перед фашиками шляпу снимать. Может еще колено преклонить? Хуюшки!
Dr No no the Wehrmacht didn’t do anything. All of the “murdering” in the east which were the Baltic states were done by the SS or einsatzgruppen. The Wehrmacht were just soldiers.
Dr No ok you’re right the many of the Wehrmacht weren’t innocent as it describes that they took part in mass killing. But let us also not forget that both sides equally committed atrocities as the The Red Army raped and killed innocent civilians upon entering Berlin.
holyshit i didn't know russian grenade was explosive as artillery shot
it's just a movie effect
Lol
better than those grenades with little damage and underwhelming explosions.
Massi Army whoooooosh
elektron117 u too whooooosh
Fun fact: the Krauts lost more soldiers at the famous Pavlov's house in Stalingrad than during the entire campaign against France in 1940.
Russians are real badasses. They crushed 80 per cent of the Hitler's armies
they did that at gun point...and it depends which russian armies you mean. in ww1 they didn't not have success nor in the first wave of ww2. it wasn't until stalin brought over the Mongolians at the point of a gun and when winter came that things changed. There was no planning or skill in what they did. Finally, the germans were outnumbered in literally every battle they fought. the kill rations were as follows Germans 1/ Americans 2, Germans 1/ Brits 4, Germans 1/ Russians 12. As recorded by West Point. The germans made the army of 300 look like Girl Scouts.
That is your stupidity at beliving propaganda bullshit. Is no only an outrageous claim by itself but is also miscounting Chuiko´s book "The beginning of the road" page 173 who claims " ... killed more enemy soldiers than the german lost taking PARIS".
Which is not big deal since Paris was declared open city and it was not defended at all.
@@mamailo2011 чтобы вы не говорили мы спасли вес мир от истреблении!
No shit Paris was declared an open city
@@marksaldivar4106 Oh boy! Do you study history by comics right? I can't believe that sane person can type such ridiculous Nazi propaganda in 2022. Actually Red Army was outnumbered by Nazis on 1941. Total qty of German troops participated in Barbarossa was 4 millions. Total qty of Soviet soldiers on western part of USSR was 3,5 millions. Just do you math!
Pavlov's House, no doubt.
Feggelein third time in Stalingrad 😁
Its Fegelein
Fegelein Fegelein Fegelein!
Best actor in films like this!
Fegelein’s like “I’m getting too old for this shit, I need to get a nice office job in Berlin, preferably in the Fuhrer’s bunker”
The speech felt like the opening cutscene to an operation in battlefield one
Is this "Stalingrad" directed by Fedor Bondarchuk from 2013? Thanks.
Isn’t that the same German officer from the 93 Stalingrad movie??
Yesit is. He frequently plays a WW2 era German.
Hans von witzland? Absolutely.
Yes, but then as Leutnant, here as Hauptmann, if I recall correctly.
He is also the German officer that saves the guys life in The Pianist.
He is also FEGELEIN!
“This is propaganda, watch this movie instead” *insert propaganda film* literally every film about the war is propaganda one way or another.
Exactly..what war movie doesn't have propaganda bias in one form or another?
Idk, Stalingrad 1993? Best war movie to me at least
Well ya see there's levels for example Saving private Ryan is pro US but shows the brutal reality the second world war very well. So many Americans get killed in that movie you can't call them super men it's practically just the opposite. Where as more Russians were killed in a level in COD World at War then this one scene. It's basically adding to the whole misconception that Russian was invincible in the war. Which if you ask roughly 21 million Russians who didn't survive it obviously wasn't. Yes all war films are bias to some degree but they're not all propaganda. It's only propaganda when it glorifies combat for one side and makes the other look entirely hapless.
A Bridge to Far. Don't hit me with that BS.
@@mrjroc318 Band of brothers ,generation war
Сегодня началась страшная война! Голод, холод, смерть выдержал народ! Вечная память советскому солдату!
Как этот фильм называется?
@@user-hn2bb5vh5f Не смотри это. Я долго ждал этот фильм и сильно разочаровался. Лучше "Иди и смотри" пересмотреть чем этот цирк. (Фильм Федора Бондарчука - Сталинград).
@@XOXOl222 *(&^^&*(*_)(_*^T&E$@T*^(U)*&(UJH*Tuiy785*(&u*%578868
wandqdobd10h1jf019hr98da0wf90hy18br293erbn81e2h
@@user-hn2bb5vh5f пропаганда.
Один из самых неудачных фильмов о войне
Бондарчук не плохой режиссёр, но погоня сейчас голливудскими штампами, зрелещностью и безумными эффектами портит всё.
Лучшие фильмы о войне бесспорно были в СССР.
Там всегда раскрывался внутренний мир героя, а не погоня за количеством спец эффектов. К тому же сценарист писал сценарий под лёгкими наркотикам))) безсмыслица полнейшая)))
А как он называется?
luckily for the russians they wore thick plot armour
lol
idiot comment, the movie is based on Pavlov's House (Dom Pavlova) in which the soviets held the house for 60 days against a huge wermacht offensive. actually i guess they had IRL plot armour ;d
@Fantassin de Guillaulme due to superior numbers and resources
I dont think that house last that long.
Lot of people doing researched about that.
German didnt priority that place on the early-mid time assault because they wait another team from another side to cross but it arrived pretty late before they clear those area.
Never knew that a regular red army platoon is more skilled than the green berets
Nah their just Russian
@Facts, Not Feelings BF 1
@@Weed_Nose42 they’re all Russian until someone brings up Afghanistan.
House defense lost 58 days by 25 men, by the way.
Putin was there all those years ago !!!
Pavlov's house lasted for 8 and a half weeks. France lasted only 6.
More Germans invaded Pavlov's house than invaded France in 1940, fact!
Ussr has lost 30 million people during the fights. There was only 40 million people living in France en 1940
I'd rather give up during the France campaign than be forced to fight until death in Stalingrad
Soviets were real cannon fodder
@@1112rayquaza that number is way overinflated. It was closer to 20 million. Every year the number seems to get bigger. I've seen low estimates from 19 million and the highest estimate at 27 million. I'll say 23 million because it's the median but 30 million is way over.
@@jordanmorris5827 even with that number, 20 million is the half of France population in 1940. There is no comparison
@@1112rayquaza I know that, I study history. I'm sure you do to. However you should at least be accurate with your numbers. Don't round up because it undermines the point your making and makes people question other facts you say.
Also my comment was facetious and was said as a joke. No need for the over analysis.
Facsinating scene. An excellent demonstration of the complete futility of war. Just a minute ago, a bunch of guys were healthy and they had a future, but some hell, one of them needs to take the destroyed house, and the second to protect it, although there is nothing of value in the house. A minute has passed and there are no guys, no future, no fathers, brothers, sons...War is senseless and merciless. Old people send young people to die for their obsessive complexes. People should send old people to hell early to stop the madness
Вы много не знаете. Сталинград надо было защищать до последнего. Если бы он не важен был, то его оставили бы. Он давал проход на Кавказ и другие просторы. Там была нефть, газ, и другие полезные ископаемые. Благодаря Сталинграду, немцы не захотели брать Ленинград. Они понимали, что после ещё одной такой битвы, они останутся без армии. Так что защищали не дом, а защищали выход на полезные ископаемые.
@@Thesturmgever коллега, повторяю тем, кто в танке - мой пост совсем не об доме и не об том, кому надо было защищать выход к Кавказу. Мой пост о бессмысленности войны, которая убивает молодых парней, которым насрать на есть выход к Кавказу или нет, которые оказались в военной форме, с оружием, в незнакомом месте не по своей воле, а были призваны исполнить" долг" старыми маразматиками. Властные старики не сидят в окопах, но им все мало своей земли и они хотят заграбастать еще у соседей. Один убил миллионы и застрелился, другой убил, сгноил, умертвил миллионы и умер в луже своей мочи - зачем было войну устраивать? Сразу нельзя было застрелиться?
@@Archibald787 ваще мнение итак понятно, без пояснений. Но для тех кто в бронепоезде с тележкой, я объяснил на сколько важен был этот город и для тех и других. А так, по моему для детей младшей группы детского сада и так понятно, почему война эта безумство.
The Russian people were going to be enslaved, worked to death, or slaughtered. So fighting back wasn't "futile" for them.
Ich bin froh und glücklich, das nicht erleben zu müssen! Mir tun die Soldaten auf beiden Seiten sehr leid!
Dieser kreig ist nicht zu fassen... über 60 millionen tot.
Gotta love the transitions that it does for both sides.
Favorite toast of Field Marshal Paulus: - "so that only good people always surround us!"
Защитникам Сталинграда,советским солдатам посвящается!!! Вечная память погибшим в этой войне советским солдатам!
С этим домом что то непонятно . Неужели у немцев не нашлось одной авиабомбы ,чтоб стереть этот дом
цыка блять
Если бы немцы победили, мир был бы лучше
It seems Witzland got one hell of a promotion.
01:03 "House, Clauss, Schloussen, Flouss" or something like that. 🤣
Could make that into a song lol
Can you explain what movie the videos are from?
Pavlov’s house is epic
This short movie is about Standard, the city on river Volga. If anyone interested about the story of this house, please search "Pavlov's House" to find out more information about what actually happened there.
The auther Michael K. Jones nailed it with his new book on Stalingrad. The book is called Stalingrad. A real page turner.
Soviet soldiers:
-We just fight for Katya.
"Clip clop clip clop clip clop" - hooves
Katya Clover?
According to modern Russian directors, this is how WWII actually happened. More explosions in the manner of Western films and a love story must be present. War without love did not exist. And if you did not have love during the war, then you did not fight at all. *facepalm
That thumbnail looks glorious...
La brutalidad de esa batalla ninguna otra gerra lo igualó...
Como se llama la película
Bakhmut Ukraine 2023 Russia wins again👍🇬🇧🇷🇺
@@fabianrodrigue1889 Stalingrad
Ah, Fegelein. What a hell you went through.
Yeah, every time I look him in a movie, he remind me of Fegelein 😅
boedix83
He is the actor of Fegelein lol
And he is Avengers: Age of Ultron as well. As that Hydra Baron who experimented on the Twins.
And yes he is in Victoria movie as King Leopold I of Belgium
category: *CARS & VEHICLES*
Extremely realistic. This is so close to reality, now that I've seen it I can't even tell if reality is more realistic than this.
It really represents the quality of Soviet propag...ehm sorry, Russian film making.
Yeah not like there are bunch of American propaganda movies lmao
@@gaodacheese4691 Not arguing that, either. Stupidity doesn't stop at borders...
@@MQuaritch True. But USA is number 1 in propaganda. Basically every single shooter game is US propaganda, too.
@@gaodacheese4691 possibly yes. Still, this comment was directed towards thr Russian propaganda machine.
I'd also like to point out that, unlike the USA, the Soviet Union was a terrible dictatorship that even outperformed Germany in genocides and executions.
@@MQuaritch I don't know if you could compare soviet with germany, noone outperformed the other. Both terrible. Soviets massacred for political power, Germans massacred for that too and also for ethnic cleansing, which is a disgusting motive. And if we're talking about present. I think out of all these three the USA is doing most of the bad things that are happening TODAY, multiple wars and deaths around the world after WW2, video games and US propaganda made most Americans think they are helping lol, when it's actually all about political poeer, the war industry and enriching the elite.
Там недописано маленько,С нами бог-поступил несправедливо!Вот полная надпись на ремне!
"adolf gitler!" - russian translator
You heard that too😂😂 even in death, the Russians still hate the man lmao
yes no it’s one of the accents in russia, of Moscow i suppose
There is no letter 'H' in Russian. So Hitler's name in Russian is pronounced with a 'G', therefore, 'Gitler'.
It's not only Hitler, every name that starts with an H is translated with a G in russian. Victor Hugo becomes Gugo, for example.
@@1981Badfish it's little bit false)
Soldiers from both sides were brave.
The Russians were defending their homeland, which gave them a advantage.
and what prevented other countries from defending their homeland? For example, France, Ukraine, etc.
Maybe the problem here is not in the geographical location, but in the people themselves? at the same time, one Pavlov house lasted longer than the whole of France, Estonia, Latvia, Ukraine combined
@@xopowozedon't forget that ussr retreated more lands in the begining of war than Ukraine, France, Latvia, Estonia etc combined
@@ItsTakesTwo AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAA🤡
@@xopowoze why did you sent your picture?
Officer: i want status report
Nco: We're right behind the couch, just about to assault the coffee table, enemy is still at large in the kitchen!
Слава Великому Советскому народу! Слава Родине!
Guys,dont watch Stalingrad 2013!! Watch Stalingrad 1993
Stalingrad 1993 is more realistic
No. Stalingrad 1993 filmed on the Nazi side.
German officer yells at soldiers
Russian translator speaks calmly like sitting in his couch comfortably
imagine coming home the second time from the second war, in a literal camp, only to find dead bodies in ur bed lmao
Is this taken from Vasily Grossman's book?
Какую бы парашу иностранные режиссёры не сняли, а всё равно дом Павлова не сдался. ВЕЧНАЯ СЛАВА ГЕРОЯМ!!! Спасибо вам большое наши деды за то небо которое вы подарили нам ценой собственной жизни. Молюсь на вас. АМИНЬ.
только фашисты пробрались к нам в тыл
Когнитивный диссонанс от твоего коммента, большевики были безбожниками так то))
@@cryptoden3708 а вы по нагорной проповеди живёте что - ли божник .
Баран эту хуйню снял Бондарчук
Дед служил в СС, у внука мерседес
Às batalha mais sangrenta da segunda Guerra Mundial foi no solo Rússo!
want to ask a little whether war films like this and others work with the two countries between Russia and Germany??
One Russian soldier is able to kill many German soldiers with all German soldiers just dancing it off. What an IQ of the director.
Those are some battle hardened Germans.👍🏻
@@mrtrolly4184 yes they did.
@@mrtrolly4184 true, they were 1st rate soldiers.
ah yes, the battle of slow-motiongrad
my sides
What movie is this scene from?
This is how Major Remer got his close combat badge
This scene shows the famous Pavlov's house, it is based on real facts, the house that was under Pavlov's command was so resistant that the German army marked it on the map as a place where no troops should pass.
This scene is a joke. That's what it is.
@@jonathanallard2128 Then read about it. The accounts of Stalingrad are harrowing. Like the fight to the death at the grain elevator, losing whole divisions 24 hours after crossing the Volga, the AA gunners who met the Wermacht when at the fringe of Stalingrad. It was D-Day, every day for 6 months. Read Antony Beevor's Stalingrad book.
@@toshirox2 I read a lot about Stalingrad because it is a battle I'm completely fascinated by. I did read Anthony Beevor's Stalingrad and many of his other books too (D-Day, Crete, and the fall of Berlin which was ''my favorite''. I read it twice, and I just about never read a book twice.) I find him easy to read. He includes many small testimonies in his narrating and those are my favorite parts.
Your mistake is assuming that the reason why this scene is a joke to me would be because it was too brutal or deadly. I watched it a year ago and I won't watch it again, but it surely ain't that.
If you have read some good books written BY veterans, I'd love to have more of your suggestions.
Cheers!
@@jonathanallard2128 I believe you with the scene. I saw the guy screaming as her fired the MG and said "nope!". Then looked back at the Germans standing before the attack -- 4 out of 10 held Russian weapons -- in 1942? Doesn't sound right. But movie makers can have it the way they want it.
Crete was interesting because the German paratroop corps was crippled and never revived by Hitler who came to the conclusion that a paratrooper attack could not get the element of surprise, when really it was that Enigma had been compromised and the Brits knew the where, when, what of the attack. Did highlight the strengths of the Gemran Luftwaffe and the Brit Royal Navy.
Возле "Дома Павлова" немцев полегло больше чем при захвате Франции!
Ha. Ha. Fransh..... In the WWII most bigest collobriant. And wight flag contry. Hello from Lettland. Germans brothers
А русских в Ржевской операции - аж 1,5 миллиона, а в Зееловской- Берлинской - 0,6 млн. Вот такая "Победа" .
@@user-eg6ef1pb9j а ты сам то кто?
@@user-eg6ef1pb9j Вот именно, победа, за немцев почти вся европа воевала и полегло их под Ржевом не меньше.
@@Himick93 немцы воевали на три фронта против 52 стран мира. Я ещё не нашёл Норвежских и Шведских девизий. Вы пи здите товар - ищи.
What series is this?
The pep talk & warm up before a solid round of Hell Let Loose lol.
A study showed that, on average, a German soldier was equivalent to 1.4 soldiers of Allied armies. So just think: You were fighting A MAN AND A HALF
id like to see said study. Cause sadly your claim isnt backed by any science now is it ?
Самый длинный город в мире,это Сталинград! Немцы за пол года одну улицу не смогли пройти....
Немцы к октябрю уже взяли Сталинград, только маленький плацдарм оставался на берегу Волги Советам, где окопались части Чуйкова! Немцев подвели на флангах союзники, если бы на флангах стояли Немецкие части то котла и не случилось бы! Кто знает!
По ходу и ты самый тупой!
The whole effort of taking Stalingrad was a big mistake that costed many lives and the Germans could've focused on capturing Moscow instead.
If only the Nazi regime didn't have Cooking With Chef Luc, military tactical master, on their side...
@@Sleepyjackable Why don't you shut the hell up Simnoly Jacky boy
모두가 전쟁의 피해자들 저들도 누군가의 가족이며 원치 않는 전쟁에 참여...슬프다
Немцы шли к нам за рабами и землёй,они шли с радостью,не надо их жалеть.
I remember this map from COD for some reason
Why restart the movie in slow motion at 4:19??
To keep from copyright.
Me: Knows a bit of German, could probably understand the plot...
Me hearing an annoying Russian voice: CAN YOU SHUT UP ALREADY?
What movie are these scenes from?
In Russia we are saying: anybody who came with a sword will die by the sword.
Looks like the whole of Christendom has been saying that for thousands of years.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Live_by_the_sword,_die_by_the_sword
That's a bible quote though?
@Pantelis Tzimas learn the history, my friend. Russia was at war with China and won it. Moreover Russia liberated Beijing in 1900.
@@jonathanallard2128 yes, looks similar, but another meaning. Christendoms should be ready to fight at any time. Russian saying nobody should even try to fight with them, only peaceful relationship is accepted.
@@TheKnave2000 Ryan George voice* OoOoh! Very different!!
The Hauptmann must have taken part in a lot of close combat as he has a Close Combat Clasp which was only instituted in late 1942.
Battle of Stalingrad (23 August 1942 - 2 February 1943).... huh
@@user-gx3oz7gj7p Do you know how hard it is to acquire close combat days, to acquire sufficient even for a Bronze clasp is no easy feat, I have not seen one period photograph of a German soldier in Stalingrad with a CCC badge. If you have one produce sir, produce. I have seen many photographs of germans in Stalingrad with the Infantry Assault Badge.
@@ExRhodesian I don't argue. I live in Stalingrad now (in Volgograd, of course). I know a couple guys who are digging, looking for the bodies of forgotten soldiers and study history of that period, they know better than me. I will ask them.
@@user-gx3oz7gj7p Living in Russia you must have lost some ancestors during the war, I now feel we all lost that war, no matter which side our families were on. WW2 was like WW1 a waste of good men and women for the benefit of the bankers and their pals. The same scoundrels who are up to no good now.
@@ExRhodesian I agree. During ww2 my father's father lived near Novorossiysk (another Hero-city). And my mother's father lived in occupied Ukraine. I think something similar is happening in the world right now. Most of civilians dont want war. For example, in eastern Ukraine or the middle east, people die for other people's ideas and other people's money...
Where are you from?
Почему вначале на видео обычная школьная линейка в Иванофранковске? ;)
Братан спасибо, хоть улыбнулся))
While I do find this scene to be quite interesting, I would love it if you could put subtitles next time. Individuals that are part of the Deaf community may find it difficult to understand what they are saying especially since they are not only speaking another language but switch midway through to yet another language. If adding subtitles is too much of a hassle, then you could try adding the transcript feature to make it easier to understand for everyone.
It's from a movie called Stalingrad from 2013
Two whole grenades flew into that building and not a single one flinched or broke out of playing dead lol, that’s some serious discipline 😂
also somehow the guy by the hole didnt get blown to bits
They might have flinched and stopped playing dead for a few seconds. It's not actually shown and the german soldiers were ducking for cover so couldn't see.
Hey! Pavlov's House!
Cam somebody help me ,whats the name of this movie
I love how they picked the same german actor who also played the captain in the german movie Stalingrad from 1993.
Немецкий вариант лучше нашего. Хотя и там не без греха.
3:49 when the soviets are the ones defending over German swarms
And looks at his facial face thats awkward , why he is smilig 🤦
An allmost complete Heinkel 111 between the houses. Kinda strange...
Don't tell me you never tried modelism, :D It was quite popular in the Eastern Block.
p.s.: the whole movie is... cheesy
Holy crap did anybody notice the holy aura surrounding the Captain's face when he says "Gott mit uns"?
@Neptune I have a lot of respect for those Germans, as after all I can't say I disagree at all with the idea of destroying communism. What a different world it might have been.
@@KillerKrieg You nazi
0:34
"Remember, no russian"
У капитана явно с головой уже не то про индию про шесть рук.
RRN RRN, просто в Индии верят в разные божества, одна из них женщина с шестью руками. Их рисуют и делают статуи.
Он думал выиграет войну и доберется до Индии .А в Индии шестипалая будет ему яйца мять и все прелести минет и т д.
@@user-hv1lx3mz8o Это Кали вообще-то, она людей убивает и прибор бы ему отламала бы точно
This is a video in a language that I don't understand, translated in a language that I definitely not understand
Its gratifying, and refreshing to see an Allied view of WW2 other than the Brit version, or the Hollywood take on it.
What film is this?