DJI Pocket 3 vs Action 4: A Detailed Comparison
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 07. 2024
- Check out the pocket 3 here: geni.us/ID0oA (affiliate links)
Action 4: geni.us/62ZmiS (affiliate link)
Buy my LUT pack for the DJI Pocket 3: geni.us/T9f2v
The DJI Osmo Pocket 3 is a fantastic small gimbal camera with a 1" sensor, but how does it compare the one of the best action cameras the DJI Osmo Action 4? Let test and compare the DJI Pocket 3 and Action 4 to see which one of these cameras might be the right camera for you. We will compare image quality, photos, stabilization, low light and the user experience.
Learn how to use and fly your drone to create professional results by taking my course here: www.solocreatoracademy.com/store
Find my favorite camera and drone tech here:
www.amazon.com/shop/jakesloan (affiliate link)
I use Artlist for all my music: geni.us/kqV9l (affiliate link)
Join my patreon to see behind the scenes content and more!
www.patreon.com/jakesloan
Connect on:
Facebook: / jakesloanpage
Instagram: / jakesloan
Twitter: / jakesloaninak
Jake Sloan
PO BOX 212445
Anchorage, AK 99521
DISCLAIMER:
Jake Sloan is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.
This video and description contains affiliate links, which means that if you click on one of the product links, I’ll receive a small commission.
00:00 Intro
00:11 Action 4 uses
00:57 Pocket 3 uses
02:14 Image Quality
03:14 Field of View
03:33 Stabilization Comparison
03:46 Active Track
04:00 Low Light Video
04:55 Photo comparison
05:33 Timelapse and modes
05:49 Vertical VIdeo
06:18 User Interface
07:27 Physical Differences
08:01 USB-C Microphones
08:55 Battery Life
09:19 Pricing
09:40 Outro - Věda a technologie
Thanks for the video Jake. This helped me out a lot.
Glad it helped!
Thats the video I was waiting for. Thanks, now I get the differences. Greetings from Switzerland, Benjamin
Glad it was helpful!
Thanks, Jake. This was very helpful and informative I just got a Pocket 3 a few hours ago and look forward to using it. Have a great day! 😀
awesome! I'll have a setup and settings guide coming
@@JakeSloanWe all know you will do an awesome job! Have a great day!
It’s good in low light because of the pixel size of the 1” sensor, not just that it’s a 1” sensor :) that’s why I got it over the action. Great overview! It was super helpful in helping me decide.
glad to hear it!
excellent video, question the setup i saw you had carrying the inspire 3 on your back, can you do a video on that aswell or let us know how you set it up?? thanks
I have a few videos coming on the inspire 3!! I've been working on them for a while!
Thankyou sir! 🤜🔥🤛
I like everything about the Pocket 3 and compared to my Pocket 2 it's no brainer to get one. However, even though the Pocket has a bigger sensor, I like how the Action 4 holds well the hightlights and shadows. I know you can always set up to manual mode and use ND for the Pocket as well. Great job with these comparisons. Look forward seeing more from both of these cams. Thanks!.
thanks!
@@JakeSloando u recommend cameras that does better in color and in battery life than go pro (any action cam that allows charging while being used)
Thank you Jake - You helped make up my mind and just as an FYI - used your link.
glad this video helped and thank you!
This is a great video. The comparison showed some features that no one else has shown. For example the background blur. Well done on a good video. I think the Pocket 3 is a great tool!
Thank you!
was waiting for this!!
I hope it helps!
Jake, this was a fantastic comparison. Thank you so much.
My pleasure!
I was wondering which one would do the job for me. Now I know for sure! Amazing review! 👏👏
Awesome!
I just got and very happy with my OA4. Maybe this will he a future purchase! Thank you for the great comparison review!
you're welcome
Thank you for this I own both! That pocket 3 is so amazing I love them both.
You write like a 4 year old child. Jesus..
You are so welcome!
Hi, great comparison! But I have a question regarding the panorama photos. Does the OP3 utilizes the full sensor in taking each photos for panorama? And how's the final resolution size of the still photo?
it does and then stitches them together but you can also have it save the raw files so you can stitch them together later in post
Jake, Thanks for the comparison!! Have you found a need for filters (Pol or ND) on either the Action 4 or Pocket 3, given the outdoor video & still photography you do?
I generally don't use filters on action cameras as it can mess up the stabilization, I will definitely use them on the pocket 3 as soon as I can get some
Thx for the important comparison! btw What would you recommend the values for the sharpness and noise reduction?
I like sharpness on -2 and noise reduction on -1
Great video! I’m still stuck on which one to get I like how stable the pocket 3 is when filming but also I’ll be doing like vloging / activities for filming an worried the pocket 3 might break
I think it will be ok unless you are doing action stuff or stuff in bad weather
Have the Action 4 and my Pocket 3 Creator Combo is ordered and on its way!
awesome!!
Great review. Which do you suggest for an upcoming world tour. Mostly cities except for African safari. I’m bringing a 600mm lens bridge camera for stills (and shoots video) but it’s chunky and my iPhone -4 pro. Not sure which would compliment these for travel and which accessories needed. Thanks.
oh I think the pocket 3 would do fantastic for that
Excellent video, thank you so much!
You're very welcome!
I have both and they are both very excellent cameras. Each has specific strengths and weaknesses for different use cases and they complement rather than replace each other.
agreed
Which one is best for running?
@@cryptofitnessandgaming-cfg I'd say the Action 4. Much easier to use with a selfie stick (if that's what you want) or to mount on a pack's shoulder strap or use with a hanging neck mount. And the Pocket is not for use in rain.
@@davidleighsparks Merci!
Question: Do you know if the battery pack on the P3 will work if the battery in the P3 is completely dead. Basically will it power right up or will it need to charge teh battery a bit.
Im asking because of the non replaceable battery in the P3, if the battery dies and the battery extender can still power it, then it iwll have a lot more longevity over the years of use.
when used with the extender it will use the power from that first and then the internal battery
Thanks Jake. Another good, no-nonsense job.
thanks!
I’ve ordered mine since release day. Still waiting for it to be delivered. Very excited about it for daily vlogging home films. Sort of excited about possibly using it as a C cam for weddings and wondering how well the timecode might work. Would love to see if tentacle sync might work with it as I’ve seen some examples
It does! I’ve used it a few times and show it working in my initial review video! You can see it here: czcams.com/video/W2quvhjhecQ/video.htmlsi=ZYKQCvQUZzuz_SDC I used this cable to jam TC: geni.us/pAdB5u
Excited for you! I got mine day after launch (BH Photo rocks!) and have really been enjoying it. Lots of nice little features that make this so convenient to use. I can jam sync it with my R5C and it’ll stay in sync for an hour (haven’t used it longer than that). Really interested in replacing my old go pro with Action 4 now for the timecode support.
This think has so much possibilities for weddings on a monopod tracking to get those dolly shots or on 2x zoom with tracking on bride to get dynamic camera movement quick and easy.
Me too! Can you tag me on the tentacle sync examples? Are they jamming timecode or? @houseofren
Me too! Can you tag me on the tentacle sync examples? Are they jamming timecode or? @houseofren
@@Puddlegrapher I jammed TC with my tentacle sync using this cable geni.us/pAdB5u (affiliate link) it does seem to only work correctly when plugged in one way so if it doesnt work at first flip the cable over and try again
Hi Jake, as always spot on. It actually was the first question I had upon release of the pocket 3. Thanks for the indeep comparison! One more question: does it work with the Rhode mobile 🎤 series too?
definitely, just need to plug it in via USB-C
Thanks!@@JakeSloan
Hi! Thank you for the vid:) can you use the mic that comes with the creators kit on your other cameras / smartphone?
not currently
Thanks for the comparison. You hit on so many points of curiosity for me. Still wishing DJI would integrate the MIC with these products. Maybe with the next version. Thanks Jake!
Hopefully! Thanks brother.
Is it possible to change the subject tracking sensitivity? It seems to follow you really quickly, when I'd prefer it to be looser and just keep you in frame. Also are there any zebras/overexposure warnings displayed on the Osmo screen? Is it tough to get a good exposure? Thanks for the video
the exposure values are very easy to get and quite accurate to what you see on the screen I don't believe there are zebras/over exposure warnings as an option. Tracking speeds cannot be changed
How is the frame rate options on these? Im going to use it combined it with NikonZ with 25 frame rate. Do you need a filter with the pocket camera?
great both have 25 and 50 fps options. I'd recommend ND filters for the the pocket 3 for sure
Thanks for the video. I love the idea of the pocket 3. Does it have voice controls?
it does not
Interesting and the lines look "straight" as well even that coming from Action 4. It begs a question though: can you possibly compare the "dewarp" from Action 4 vs "linear" on GoPro 12?
they are very similar but the action 4 still has a wider FOV
I just got the Action 4 with a rota polarizer and Smallrig case. I'm hoping it'll serve my purposes recording out the front window of a moving vehicle at night. And I hope you got the affiliate credit for it since I used your link.
Thanks!
Good comparison video Jake
Thank you
DJI Pocket 3 is better for low light due to the large 1' sensor. But Action 4 provides a larger sensor than the Action 3, and is waterproof and can safely use at the beach even with sand blowing around. Having both gives you better flexibility. I sold my Action 3 and will get the 4. But will keep my Pocket 2 and get the 3. Use for 4k walk videos. Action 4 also has swappable higher capacity batteries you get 3 of them with the Adventure Combo version. Pocket 2/3 no one knows you're recording cause its small. The Action 3 struggled in low light which is why I sold it.
there you go.
I like pocket 3 but since I also Mount my go pro 8 on helmet i might have to get DJI action 4. I will have to compromise on night shots. Now to add more confusion we have insta ace Pro 😂😂
Waiting for 13 gopro , should i go for pocket 3 or dji action. Or waiting gopro 13 is best , any leaking news guys do share...
Market exploring and detailed video of shating shop wholesale and retail markets to public including shop owners conversation including same time all product should also should be clear view
If osmo have cenematic blur 1 person active mode i think gopro is best for complete focus all
What lav mic can you recommend for action 4? For cycling videos on an ebike in the city or nature. Looking for a clear voice and some ambient souonds. Recording with two mics possible?
I’d recommend getting the DJI mic 2 transmitter. I’m not sure about 2 mics at the same time on the action 4.
Do they only shoot 10 bit in d-log m?
Do you have manual shutter/iso?
That low light from the pocket 3 is extremely impressive
they only shoot 10bit in D-Log M or HLG (the pocket 3 only) and you can manually control the ISO and shutter speeds as well
Thanks a lot for the great review. Can I know which one will you suggest if I want to get one of these for taking travelling footage (mostly on taking scenery)?
I would get the pocket 3 for that
@@JakeSloan Thanks a lot man!
Hi Jake, when i walk and talk to the Pocket 3 the footage comes out very jittery and looks like its "hacking". I have not got the ND-filters yet. What settings do you recomend to get smooth footage when filming yourself walking?
first make sure you are walking smoothly as that is important, ND filters will help some but walking smoothly will help the most.
@@JakeSloan Thanks. Yes i know that ND-filters will help. Unfortunately I’m still waiting for them to arrive. 😊 I was hoping you had some tricks up your sleeve for settings without NDs. 😀
Thank you for such a detailed review. One question. If you have the DJI mics do you still need the longer battery to connect the transmitter to on the Pocket three or can you plug the mic transmitter directly on the Pocket 3?
For the original DJI mics you must connect the receiver to the pocket 3 via USB-C
@@JakeSloan thanks
Great video! Which one would you use to capture footage for a woodworking business both at the workshop and on site?
if you have a good dust collection system (to keep the air clean) then the pocket 3 could be very nice but otherwise I would get the action 4 for your use
@@JakeSloan thanks Jake! Appreciate the reply. I think I’m going to end up with both!
Wow. What a video. Not many youtubers have shown the photo comparisons of the two. Really appreciated that part of your video.
Glad it helped!
Your the first person I hear confirm that the DJI Mic 2 will have internal 32bit float! Nice! Great breakdown. I just got the action 4
Thanks!!
Witch one is better for slow motion features? I want to take golf swing videos and I was wondering witch one is better than other?
Either one but for what you want to do I would probably go with the action 4
Great video, I have ordered my Pocket 3 and I'm eargerly awaiting it.
Minor mistake at @5:00, you say that the Action 4 take 12mp photos, but the on-screen label says Pocket 3.
Oh dang! Thanks for that
Im looking for a camara to record my gym, daily and my golf rounds (this is probably where I will use more). I want something small and easy to carry. My first idea was the Pocket 3, do you think will work nice? Also I want to use the camara for my trips
I think it would be a great camera for that
Recently got the Action 4 for cycling/vlogging. Perfect camera!
awesome
Are the colors the same when using both cameras, and composing a single viideo froom them?
They are very similar
Thanks, finally a clip that includes stills. you have no idea how i have ransacked the internet ooking for videos that also looked at the camera's capabilities on stills
thank you!
Great comparison! Does the new mic 2 only works with Pocket 3?
currently yes
I just bought a gimble for my Action4 and am debating whether to get a pocket 3 or not ( mainly for vlogging). Do you think its worth it?😮 Thx
I do and use mine a LOT for videos on this channel and elsewhere as well
Hi. which one will you recommend for Low light concert videos recording?
the pocket 3 for sure
Great review. As you say, they have different roles. I didn't think the low light footage from the action 4 wasn't at all bad and you could put it on a tracking gimbal like the holhem I steady to get the follow mode. Maybe I need both 😂
just maybe...
Jake I now have both is it possible to get the same video look out of both ie use the action 4 as a b roll? Thanks
it is color wise but the action 4 doesn't have any shallow depth of field so it will always look a little different
@JakeSloan yes more color, I get there different cameras the 4 seems almost thicker if you get what I mean. So if you edit fro pocket3 to action4 as b roll its noticeable
Nicely done video. I am finding the battery handle drains when left connected to the camera but turned off. Anyone finding the same?
Slightly but I believe it also depends on what features you have turned on
Thanks for the reply. When the battery handle is connected, both batteries 100%, camera turned off. When I next turn the camera on the handle is at 80%, camera still 100%.
So not sure if camera battery drained and was topped up by handle as it is designed to do or the handle battery drained.
Disconnected them last night and this morning both had lost just 1%, which is fine.
Now going to leave them connected for a similar length of time and see if them being connected is part of the problem.
Thanks again for the reply.
Why are you rotating the Pocket 3 for vertical? In the settings you can make the gimbal rotate for full resolution vertical footage
you can do it either way
Which one do you reckon for Real Estate Videography? I believe the Pocket for its low light capabilities? Other ideas?
pocket 3 for sure!!
Killing it with this sucker! Nice job Jake!
Thanks Russ! These videos have been going gang busters!!
I need a cam for youtube , some cinematic outdoor shots, gym shots and a webcam . which on would be better osmo pocket 3 or osmo action 4 . I need an all round camera since i have the budget for only one cam
I would get the pocket 3 UNLESS you plan to do stuff in bad weather (rain snow etc) or if you plan to wear the camera on you in the gym playing basket ball etc then I would get the action 4.
@@JakeSloan thank you so much for your quick response!!!. Guess ill have to order pocket 3 it from ebay USA as it's out of stock across India
Damn Jake! You're soooo good at convincing me that I need the Pocket 3 when I've already got the Action 4. I'll have to get the wife to watch your video hahaha.
hahahahaha
Which one is better for recording outdoor cooking videos in nature/forest, ocasionaly indoor, but the main focus is outdoor ? Thanks
I would use the pocket 3 for that!
Interesting that it will shoot 3072×3072 for 1:1 video or 3072×1728 16x9 mode which I am assuming is the vertical mode when holding the Pocket 3 vertically. I wonder what the sensor crop-factor is for this mode and if it's more-than or less-than the full 4K 3840x2160 mode.
I have mine on order right now so I guess I'll find out soon by testing if nobody answers me here.
the sensor size is very interesting
@@JakeSloan I'm wondering if the 3072x3072 actually uses more than or less than the sensor than 3840x2160, at least in one dimension of the sensor.
I'm really torn between the 2. I like the FOV of the action 4. Is it possible to change the FOV setting of the pocket 3 to match what the 4 has? I'm going on a family vacation & I'm not sure which would be the best to purchase. This is one of the best videos that explains FOV. On the pocket 3 just to pickup & shot, In Your Opinion, how would you say it shoots as a general video camera?
you cannot change the FOV in the settings, but you can add the wide angle lens however the action 4 still has a much wider FOV in any of it's settings
@JakeSloan Thank You
dji products are amazing.i wonder why dji didn t develop an 1 inch sensor stacked compact vlog camera..market has many gaps in this easy to use area consumer friendly pocket cameras with a wide to short tele lens and a good battery life..regular features knowadays are 10 bit video,4k 50fps,phase detection, full sensor readout and an uhs ii slot.wishlist maybe but many amateurs want a small camera to express their moments easily and pros an everyday tool for creations.Excellent presentation as always, greetings from Greece
Thanks. Cheers
This is the comparison I wanted to see, and the Pocket 3 is the one to pick. My only concern is the battery life, since I am a beginner and most of the times it takes hours to finish a single video. Is the battery removable? I mean, can I get more batteries for the Pocket 3? Excellent video. Thank you.
the battery life is exceptional and you can easily keep it charged using a USB-c Battery bank
I really love my action 4 i would really like to add the pocket 3 with my air 3 . It would be the best creative kit .
GREAT creative kit
The 20mm lens is a bit limiting, I have to get food video clips, I think it would probably distort the product.
the 20 actually has pretty minimal distortion but the wide lens adds a fair amount
What’s a good camera for just recording my family when they are just messing about in the park
Pocket 3 or realistically your phone lol
@@JakeSloan thanks. I was thinking the same thing. But I have iPhone 11pro (old) and I don’t like the idea of trying to capture 20/30 mins of video and not needing to use my phone inbetween and iPhone can’t record and pause and then continue
Please, DJI. Make your Action 4 (or 5) work with the Mic2 in the future. Would be awesome to pair it to the pocket 3 or Action.
It would be amazing to have wireless audio with the action 4
This is a good video, kind of insane how not even close it is.
Thanks
Is there any option not to blurred the background?
No. It’s physics
I am gonna start travel vlogging soon. my budget is around 800 dollars for purchasing gears(camera and stuffs). what should I buy? or buy a phone as a beginner and upgrade after some months or year?
Sony Pro I or s23 ultra ,PLUS GIMBAL
Honestly if you have a recent model phone I would just start there
If you are clumsy, go action 4. Less stress.
@@51Pegasi otherwise?
Can we use DJI mic 2 on Osmo Action 4?
no not at this time
The Action 4 is the "GoPro killer". Thanks for the FPV footage... want to see more.
you're welcome
Is the zoom optocal or digital on pocket 3?
Digital ? 🤔
digital
The Pocket 3, can we turn off the background blur?
Nope as I said in the video it’s physics
They really need to put that 1 inch sensor on next action camera...and it will be the best buy and also competition for insta 360 who have 1inch
that would be cool
Really like the three, But i want to vlog on my motorbike and adventure travels. As well as in the nightlife areas of southeast asia while walking around but for now can only afford one camera while starting my channel. Action 4 best all rounder?. Itravel in rainy season and rainfall is very heavy in the tropics and south east asia
I would start with the action 4 then
If only the combo microphones was working without attachment on the pocket 3!
Otherwise I’m so happy with this products I might take it!!
agreed!!
I’d love to see a simple colour grade tutorial on log or hlg for fcxp 👍🏻
I'll see what I can do
@@JakeSloan thanks! Yet to see a simple explanation of it as I’m a lazy colour editor
Can the pocket only record self shots
Nope can record any direction
I prefer the OP3 if being used more vlogging style when you want to focus on the person, but the OA4 much better if where you are is more important. OP3 seems to work ok in a studio setting if needed too. Different tools for different needs. A late comment, but another great video. Btw I thought the OA4 didn’t do too badly in most of the low light examples.
It did quite well considering! But definitely have their uses
Thank you
You're welcome
you should have a section for conclusion, like a final take home point.
I'll consider that for future videos
@@JakeSloan than you
Some other differences - the Action 4 has a nice remote control accessory (works well - I have one) whereas of now, the Pocket 3 does not. The Action 4 works well with a selfie stick, the Pocket 3 does not as it just has the 1/4" threaded tripod mount at the base of the handle or battery grips. The Action 4 has easily swappable batteries; the Pocket 3 does not, though it does have the optional battery grip. The Pocket 3 itself does recharge more quickly than the Action 4.
excellent points
Just a follow-up - I just learned that you can use the link button on the Mic 2 as a remote trigger for the Pocket 3, either in video or camera mode.
@wmc6811 Action 4 does not need an external mic but ability to use if desired is nice. The Action 4 works in low light but is nowhere as good as the Pocket 3
Action 4 is sold out everywhere in my country.. I have to wait for restock.
dang!
nice compare all is good.
Thank you 😊
I like your reviews. Pocket 3 looks great but I think it is a pity to intentionally blur these beautiful mountains in the background! Depends on the purpose of course~
it does depend on the purpose however the blur is due to lens design and physics, not something that can just be turned off
@@JakeSloan Thanks for the reply! yes, blur is a "feature" of the camera, and is probably mostly aimed at "cinematic" users. IMO vlogging dos not need blurry background, we know what is the main subject, no need to separate it, and if the is to show around, blur is not really best. Only my opinion. for hiking, I used Pocket 1, then Pocket 2, when there was no action cam that I liked (did not like Action 1 and gopro). Now after using Action 2 and 3, have Action 4 and very happy with it. Action 3 was very good too. Still have Pocket 2 but do not use it much any more. I find it too long to switch on fully (align included) when need to quickly film on the fly. Keeping it for "low light".
Does pocket 3 support gyro data ?
no because it's using a gimbal
woah 32bit recording... looking foreward for the dji mic 2
You and me both!
DJI MIC 2?! When did it come out?
with the pocket 3
I'd have bought the pocket 3 but i really dont like the bokeh blurred look for hiking/walking vlogs (which weirdly is what I see everyone doing with the pocket 3). Bokeh is great for interviews, products and portraits but I really dont get the appeal when you're out in incredible landscapes.
if thats the case maybe mount it on a shot tripod to move the camera away from you a little farther?
Which one is recommended for travel like beach, city, driving , for insta reels ?
I'd go with the pocket 3 personally
Im waiting for the action 5 with 1” sensor
that could be pretty sweet
Is normal color 8 bit or 10 bit?
I read the Pocket 3 is 10 bit.
Normal Color is 8bit
Thank you @@JakeSloan
Why is noone talking about the unsharpmask filtering on the action 4 (and worse the gopro).
Probably because it’s not a thing
@@JakeSloan Well there is definite onboard image processing happening. Look at the unrealistic textures. They look smoothed then edge enhanced.
i have already watched around 14 videos for this comparison between OP3 and OA4. To be concluded, if you shoot more on LOW LIGHT condition, be sure to take OP3. It will work better, lot better. But if you don't, I think OA4 would be sufficient and more practical (size and battery wise, since OP3 can't change battery like OA4).
absolutely correct
I'm actually thinking about swapping my Iphone 14 pro to the pocket 3.
I use dji mobile gimbal with my iphone but with this new sensor and the footage I have seen the osmo pocket 3 actually provides descent guality.
ps I hate that the iphone doesn't give me other than 25 fps in PAL format. Super annoying or even impossible to make slowmo videos in artificial lighting in PAL areas.
oh Wow I did not realize that about the iPhone!
I am going to keep my Action 4 for Mtn Biking and Motorcycle shots and use the Pocket 3 for vlogging and B-Roll. I think it's the perfect combo to have. I then have a Sony A7siii mirrorless for my office talking head shots.
it's a tiny combo when you use both!
Which has the best camera ?
pocket 3
I own both ✌
nice