First Time Watching Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix | Group Reaction
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 06. 2023
- ✘ PATREON FOR EARLY & UNCUT REACTIONS
/ sourtaste
✘ Join Our Discord
/ discord
✘ Twitter
/ sour_tastee
✘ Neel Channel
/ neeldesai
✘ Faxityy Channel
/ faxityyy
✘ Business
dilutedtaste@gmail.com
*Copyright Disclaimer
Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS
#harrypotter #reaction #dumbledore #voldemort #groupreaction - Zábava
Fun fact - people hate Umbridge more than they hate Voldemort. The movies did justice to her character.
Imelda Staunton was just brilliant in his role
@@thatsmemmetrue as it’s the one thing the movie does better imo like I can’t stand her
So true the actress that played her nailed it I can't remember her name but she's also in Maleficent she plays one of the 3 fairies that give aurora gifts and take care of her after she's cursed.
Oh surely i am one of those people🤣🤣
@@watermelonwatsittoyashe was in nanny McPhee
People can't use the "killing curse" all the time because it requires a great amount of malicious emotions and intent specifically directed toward the target in order for it to work. In Goblet of Fire, Professor Moody explains in the classroom that if every one of the students in the room tried to use it on him, they'd basically manage nothing so much as a breeze blowing at him.
Yes, too bad the movie left this one out. This makes movie only watchers confused about the killing curse, sad that we books readers have to explain everytime (more sad bcs majority really dont care even after we explain it)
34:12 Luna is actually being bullied at Hogwarts which is why Hermione first called her Loony Lovegood and the bullies take her shoes and hide them around the castle.
I never noticed until now, I mean I knew people were thinking of her as a crazy freak, but I thought others just shunned and avoided her and not bully BULLY her.
@@firstlast-wr3mn yeah they don’t really mention much in the movies but from what I’ve heard of the books she was considered an outcast for being too weird and talking about things that others didn’t believe in, like with the thestrals pulling the carriages which are only visible to people who’ve witnessed death. She was also an easy target because she never defended herself and didn’t have any friends until the DA club. I’m pretty sure they would hide her shoes and make her things fall out of her bag and I think I heard that for the most part she wasn’t even aware she was being bullied and would blame it on the nargles which were a creature that most believed didn’t exist or had long been extinct (I think, I could be wrong about that).
@@ohmanholyshiit I haven't read the 5th book (only 1-4 and 6), so I don't know, but I always thought that the nargles were the ones that stole her things (and also that they're real) and that people just thought she was crazy, because she's been shown to notice things others are ignorant of, especially magical creatures that people would just overlook and claim don't exist
@@firstlast-wr3mn Just curious, why does someone read only some books of a series? Was the fifth one too big? I mean I get when someone stops at some point completely but not reading the 5th but then the sixth and not finishing the series? What was the reason behind that?
@@resathe6760 My dad got me first 4 books as a present, they came as part of a book deal you get through newspapers, but he then stopped buying it. In the meantime I lost interest in books in general, focused on studies and years later heard that 6th book is soo much better than the movie so I had to check it out. And I must say I was blown away by it and reading it just came naturally. The same cannot be said for the 5th and 7th book. I tried them, but as I said I'm not that much of a reader anymore and quickly got tired of them. I even tried reading the last book from the end hoping it would motivate me to continue, but no. I'm not saying those two were bad, it's just that the 6th one was so frigging good even for the laziest of us
Harry actually did tell everyone about Lucius Malfoy being a Death Eater and being at the graveyard but since the ministry in the minister of magic did not believe him well it was basically business-as-usual
People see and relive their worst memories when they encounter a dementor. Dudley has had a good life though so instead he saw himself from the perspective of the people he's bullied, which changes him as a person
Interesting didn't know that
"dumbledore said calmly" it says in the book but in the movie he's so aggressive with it, that's why everyone wrote that. the movies partly changed things and this is one of these changes
Yeah, it's become a fan joke because in the book it specifically states Dumbledore asked Harry calmly "Did you put your name in the goblet of fire" And then movie Dumbledore spazzes out on Harry "DIDYOUPUTYOURNAMEINTHEGOBLETOFFIRE!" 😂
@@theshadowfax239 HAAAAAAAAARRRYYYYYYYYY@+@@!$@!!
And while it may ultimately be the director's fault and nothing to do with the actor at all, that scene is one of the reasons that people generally prefer Richard Harris's Dumbledore over Michael Gambon's.
I may be in the minority, but i fucking LOVE that scene so much! Dumbledore was terrified & worried bc his name was called, so it makes much more sense to me that he would be very upset!
@@mistyxmarlboro I partly agree actually because as you said he was worried about harry but when I watched it the first time I got so surprised because dumbledores normal demeanour is rather calm and collected, (also it’s just funny to joke about it haha), but I definitely understand your point:)
17:12 the reason people were saying that is because in the books Dumbledore calmly asked if Harry put his name in but in the movies he was yelling and shoved Harry so people like making fun of it.
You know, Harry and Luna were not the only ones able to see the Thestrals. Neville was also able to see them because he saw his grandfather die.
What?? Neville lives with his grandmother...
@@smitefulaxe1344 Yeah, he lives with her ever since his parents were tortured by Bellatrix Lestrange and the other Death Eaters. But his grandmother is a widow who lost her husband (Neville's grandfather) who he saw dying.
Poor Nev 😭
@@smitefulaxe1344 Yes he live with her but he saw his grandfather die not grandmother, and in the movies they didnt said anything, was just in Luna and Harry, that could seen them, Neville, Luna, Harry and a Slytherin boy in the books
Shouldn't Harry be able to see thestrals since the beginning, considering the fact that his mother was killed in front if him when he was a baby?
About that "Dumbledore said calmly" thing:
In the Books Dumbledore is always portrayed as this calm person who always seems to be in control of any situation.
Even when he is serious he is still very calm. He just changes his aura from nice and wise grandpa to very terrifying.
In the movie when he asks Harry whether he put his name in the goblet, he does so very aggressively and pushes Harry even against a wall.
In the books he is very calm and collected while asking. And when Harry denies, he basically sais that he thought so and never truely believed that Harry threw his own name in the goblet.
It's a meme because movie Dumbledore is so drasticly different from book Dumbledore. Especially in that specific scene.
You have NO IDEA how many reactors say "a nose" when Harry says "we have something he doesn't" literally everyone. lmao
ron's lines and many actions get stolen in the movies. i love him so i have to tell you guys, he is the one who stands up for harry in the third movie on a broken leg against sirius, who they thought was a serial murderer at the time. when snape makes fun of hermione and calls her an insufferable know it all, ron stands up for her and asks 'why ask the question if you don't want an answer?' and he gets detention for her. however, in the movies, hermione is the one who stands up against sirius and ron agrees with snape in the movies, like what??? the writer, steve kloves, absolutely hated ron and wanted harry and hermione together. that's why you'll see him being annoying sometimes and harry and hermione seem so close. don't fall for their tricks, i promise you he is a really good character. :)
They really did Ron so dirty.
They cut SO much of Ron content in the movies. It's infuriating! I love watching HP reactions but every time a react roasts Ron, it makes me sad. Ron is the friend we all want in our lives
@@lilyrose0116 i used to have a fanpage for him for a few years and i was such an avid fan of him. this is the first reaction i saw of harry potter movies but it hurt to see the blonde one being sort of rude. i get everyone has their preferences, but i'm trying to show them their hate is unwarranted in most cases :(
@@sebryanbias its a fake character jfc. grow up and get over it
@@mmkay3296 ?? be fr how was i mad in any way? i'm just informing them of what his character was SUPPOSED to be like. and even if he is fake, rupert still gets hate and death threats over the role so pls stfu. i bet ur a draco fan LMFAO go cry
In Movie version they show Dumbledore very less powerful. Here is the book version in short. Please read it
“But Master - he is here - he is below -”
Voldemort paid no attention. AVADA KEDAVRA!”
Harry had not even opened his mouth to resist. His mind was
blank, his wand pointing uselessly at the floor.
But the headless golden statue of the wizard in the fountain had
sprung alive, leaping from its plinth, and landed on the floor with a
crash between Harry and Voldemort. The spell merely glanced off its
chest as the statue flung out its arms, protecting Harry.
“What - ?” said Voldemort, staring around. And then he
breathed, “Dumbledore!”
Voldemort raised his wand and sent another jet of green light at
Dumbledore, who turned and was gone in a whirling of his cloak;
next second he had reappeared behind Voldemort and waved his
wand toward the remnants of the fountain; the other statues sprang to
life too. The statue of the witch ran at Bellatrix, who screamed and
sent spells streaming uselessly off its chest, before it dived at her, pin-
ning her to the floor. Meanwhile, the goblin and the house-elf scuttled
toward the fireplaces set along the wall, and the one-armed centaur
galloped at Voldemort, who vanished and reappeared beside the pool.
The headless statue thrust Harry backward, away from the fight, as
Dumbledore advanced on Voldemort and the golden centaur can-
tered around them both.
“You do not seek to kill me, Dumbledore?” called Voldemort, his
scarlet eyes narrowed over the top of the shield. “Above such brutality,
are you?”
“We both know that there are other ways of destroying a man,
Tom,” Dumbledore said calmly, continuing to walk toward Volde-
mort as though he had not a fear in the world, as though nothing had
happened to interrupt his stroll up the hall. “Merely taking your life
would not satisfy me, I admit -”
“There is nothing worse than death, Dumbledore!” snarled
Voldemort.
“You are quite wrong,”
“Indeed, your failure to un-
derstand that there are things much worse than death has always been
your greatest weakness -”
Dumbledore never failed down in book version. Voldemort was nervous entirely while face Dumbledore. Voldemort go inside Harry coz he failed to face Dumbledore.
Fun fact: this movie takes place in 1995 and begins with a reporter saying that it's "too hot" and that there's a drought going on. And there was actually a heat wave and a drought at the United Kingdom that time, so the movie was very accurate about it.
The drought is in the book too, but I think it was coincidence. JR Rowling has admitted she's bad with math and dates but we get a timeline of events by way of Nearly Headless Nick's deathday party in Chamber of Secrets.
In the beginning of Goblet of Fire Harry is writing a letter to Sirius and makes mention of Dudley breaking his Playstation, which didn't yet exist.
So I think coincidence there, but a very nice one none the less.
@@cjg8763 the first playstation came out the same year though, admittedly only in December but I think the same year is close enough
Also confirms that Margaret Thatcher was the one who nearly threw Cornelius Fudge out the window.
oh boy, Umbridge is certainly one of the least liked teachers at the school, think Stephen King himself described Umbridge as the scariest villain of the series
Stephen King said that?!!
She's probably the scariest because she's the most "real". There are people out there actually like her.
@@DragonLaserBreath2023He said she's "the greatest make-believe villain to come along since Hannibal Lecter".
@@DragonLaserBreath2023he has a great apreciation for the world JK created
I hate Delores Umbridge more than Hannibal Lecter, Voldemort and the guy who killed John Wick's dog put together. I couldn't watch this movie for a while because of how unhealthily angry she would make me. I think it's because she is so relatable. We have all run into that smug, smarmy teacher, bureaucrat or supervisor that smiles oh so sweetly as they screw you over.
6:25 I dislike how the movies did it. This one was a turning point for Dursleys. Where Vernon was furious - Petunia understood what Dementors were. And then she got a letter from Dumbledore - reminding her of what she has promised by taking Harry in. One of the few moments where she sternly goes against Vernon and tells Harry to go to his room. It's also much less comedic, as Dudley was seriously affected - especially as he was close to getting kissed. This becomes the moment when Dudley starts treating Harry well, because he basically got saved by him.
6:40 The only thing they got ok, was that Petunia was terrified - they were never supposed to be in actual danger and here she almost lost her son.
9:50 Also sad they cut out portrait of Sirius' mother. After Tonks stumbles - she wakes up Mrs. Black who starts screaming slurs right and left.
26:20 They also totally cut the part where Ron and Hermione were picked to be Prefects for Griffindor. Cause this whole argument happened in their bedroom and Ron was totally about to abuse his new power to defend Harry.
27:25 Another change movie made/got wrong - only one Patil twin was in Griffindor, the other one should be wearing blue tie as Ravenclaw.
30:15 Such amazing acting.
38:30 So Umbridge is like Niel - extremely racist against non-humans and magical creatures (that's why she treats Hagrid badly and questions Flitwick's parentage - cause he could be half goblin/elf). This scene is even better in books, because Umbridge is ready to hire another Ministry employee instead of Trelawney. But as Dumbledore had to get notice of her dismissal - the moment Umbridge kicks her out he hires new teacher. The best part is that it's the centaur from the first movie - being the worst nightmare for Umbridge.
Chad dumbledore
@@painvillegaming4119 Dumbbelldore
The actress who played Umbridge absolutely hated the role, because she's normally a very sweet person. Theres some behind the scenes footage of her and Maggie Smith (McGonagall) joking around and laughing
1:24:40 it's rumoured that the scene is only muted because Harry's screams were so genuine that the film crew were crying. IIRC, Daniel Radcliffe was dealing with a real life death, and channeled the acting in to that scene.
Oooh I always wondered why they muted his scream
About Harry's screams, you can kinda see it in Helena's face. She breaks character for a very brief second before smirking again.
@@NateLeonhart Oh man I never noticed that but it totally makes sense! She looks genuinely concerned for just a moment
@@HarukaLPsi really thought it was good acting and she was scared
I heard as well Emma's screaming in the Deathly Hallows part 1, when Bellatrix was torturing her, was so real that Daniel and Rupert ran to see if she was okay.
It made me so happy when you noticed Ginny looking at Harry. Like finally. Someone notices lol
gotta say Rowling did an amazing job writing Umbridge's character, and Imelda Staunton did an equally good, if not even better, job portraying her
there is absolutely NO WAY you can feel anything but pure hate for Umbridge, because she's just so terrible you'd rather befriend someone like Voldemort and ask him to watch your back
Cambridge is the delusional villain
She has no redeeming qualities and that is why she is hateable
Even Stephen King said that Umbridge is the best and most evil written villain ever :D
Sometimes, my nightmares only consist of a string of unending "hem hem"...
yeah.. But even with all her awfullness and no redeeming qualities, i don't think she deserved to be gang raped by the centaurs, i wouldn't wish that on anyone. It is satisfying though that she spent the rest of her life in prison 😅 so much for her climbing the power ladder
@@apet6752 there is no proof that Umbridge experienced what you state. she is only described as traumatized, but that doesn't mean rape is automatically what generated the trauma
Everybody went quiet when Hermione introduced Luna because she slipped and said, "This is Loony Lov...Luna Lovegood", accidentally saying the mean nickname people called her by. Luna is a little weird, so Harry's friends are the first to really accept her. The same with Neville Longbottom, and it's noticeable in the book.
1:12:55 "He's got Padfoot. He's got Padfoot at the place where it's hidden". Snape says he has no idea what that means. Sirius being held by Voldemort at the ministry.
Yet the Order of the Phoenix gets there to save the day. Remember that Snape told the Order to go get Harry and company for your next reactions.
Yes, Kreacher is not Dobby. However, Dobby, the house-elf, does appear as a recurring character in every book after his introduction in Chamber of Secrets (excluding year 3-Prisoner of Azkaban). Unfortunately, his ongoing side plot and adventures, along with numerous other elements such as quidditch matches, different classes, events, and backstories of various characters, were omitted from each of the movies.
For instance, Percy Weasley appeared in the first three movies as a Prefect (the head house boy in the first two movies) but was absent from the remaining films because his character graduated in Prisoner of Azkaban. In the books, Percy's story continues with his defection from the Weasley family due to ridicule for their benevolent nature and lack of ambition, despite being pure bloods (and member of the "Sacred 28" pure bloods no less). After the last Goblet of Fire, he was hired by Fudge for a junior position to gain a connection to Harry and Dumbledore; though due to his naive arrogance, Percy believed the job position was gained solely through merit.
So we miss Percy's falling out with family, the argument with his father (who called him out and even flat-out told Percy why Cornelius Fudge hired him), his attitude towards his younger brothers, and his unpleasant behavior toward his mother. He was even writing to Ron and Ginny, trying to convince them to ditch Harry. His appearance alongside Dolores Umbridge and the Minister of Magic is seen as a final act of betrayal, and the whole family (minus the mom-who is always in tears) wrote him off after that. This depth in Percy's character was cut from the movies, although he does make an appearance in Order of the Phoenix. Most people recognize the actor as the redhead holding Harry at 1:01:42. He was also in the background behind Cornelius and other scenes and can be seen as the scribe in Harry's Ministry trial.
The fight between Dumbledore and Voldemort was far more dynamic, as rather than being stationary, they were apparating (teleporting) around and Blasting each other with spells, bringing statues to life, and all sorts of other things which would have quite frankly destroyed the movie's budget.
In a similar vein, during the encounter when Ministry Aurors went to confront Dumbledore in his office, he displayed incredible prowess by defeating all of them in a duel single-handedly. Afterwards, he escaped by teleporting away with Fawkes.
Annoyed they cut the scene where Hagrid literally gets taken prisoner by ministry aurors, getting multiple Stupify's cast upon him, then Mcgonogall tries to figure out what's going on and gets hit with five stunners at once. It's absolutely brutal and makes us hate Umbridge and the Ministry more.
Also it's super annoying that Percy's subplot got cutoff since we miss one of the best scenes in the seventh book. "Minister, I think I'll resign!"
The reason we were talking about said calmly is because in the book was written like that while in the movie its totally different thats why
The 'burnt off' Blacks were: Sirius, Arthur Weasley's mother, Andromeda (a sister of Belatrix) and her daughter 'Tonks'. Belatrix's other sister is Narissa Malfoy and Sirius had a brother who is dead. Avada Kedava is not intially used as it has to be verbally cast and has 6 syllibles. A non-verbal, shorter syllible spell would beat you before you completed the curse (see 2nd film ending where Lucius is beaten by Dobby as he tries to cast the spell on Harry). This film had a different screen writter who more effectively portrays Ginny like book Ginny. It's back to the original screen writer from now on and Ginny returns to being a 'sop'.
Crucio and the killing curse you have to WANT to torture or kill, if you don’t the spell doesn’t work. The power Harry has isn’t outwardly explained but it’s in things like love and friendship, Voldemort was conceived with a love potion so the idea is he can’t feel that
48:20 Yeah, the movies don’t do too good of a job conveying it, but Ginny is an extremely powerful witch.
Damn... I don't think Neels heart is going to survive the next three films lol.
His Hufflepuff heart is way too sensitive
the scene where the order pulls up is still my favourite across all 7 books/movies
Ginny IS mad powerful because she's the seventh child in a pureblood family. The number 7 is the most magically charged number
I think it's safe to say Harry has PTSD after the events on the graveyard last spring.
edit:
not to mention there are other reasons too, for Harry's stress,
but we don't know about Voldy intruding into Harry's mind before he sees Nagini attacking Mr Weasley.
Also, he's a teenager...and that comes with a whole bunch of hormonal rage
36:00 I love the scene on the stairs between M and U. U steps up a step to exert authority and M steps up to say “no we’re on the same footing”. Then u threatens and M backs down a step and U step up one more to declare victory.
.
.
M= McGonagle
U= Umbridge
Exactly
McGonagall steps down when they talk about disloyalty. For me, that's her saying "when it comes to disloyalty, you certainly have the victory".
@@erikperhs_damn savage
Luna lovegood is my favorite character. Fun fact about luna. The actor did such a great job that Rowling began writing luna more like her movie version in the later books
Uhmm, that's not true, the 5th movie came out in 2007 and the last Potter book came out in 2007, so your comment is invalid. But Rowling (and every book fan) did say Evanna Lynch, was a perfect cast for Luna.
@elanor2006 I found this statement online.
Evanna was also the character that J.K. Rowling was inspired by directly and confessed to have written the rest of Luna's role keeping Evanna's portrayal and voice in mind.
3:54 this was not explained in the movie but Deloris Umbridge sent those dementors to attack Harry
Yeah which is actually an amazing peice of layered writing because Dumbledore uses it as evidence for Voldemort's return but because they know that the ministry sent the dementors it reinforces their beleif that Dumbledore and Harry are lying.
Something about Unforgivable Curses: they are not just forbidden, they are extremely hard to cast. With all the magic here you not just point with a wand and say some words, it's complicated process and some spells are easier, some spells are harder to produce (that's why you need study magic and that's why there are like "levels": smth that first-years could do and smth that not every grown-ups can perform). And for real killing, or torturing or even controlling people is very very hard, and for the spell works wizard FOR REAL need to mean take someones life, need to fully understand it and have no guilt. And those direct evil-act-levels are not always reachable even for "bad wizards".
So that's why not just everyone, but even not every Death Eater use Unforgivable Curses. (And also that is why those curses are unforgivable and lead you straight to Azkaban: if you can cast them on humans - you are freaking maniac and already proved yourself guilty).
Hope that helped.
Dumbledore is just buying time for the auror to arrive that’s why he only did is a defensive magic. and also In the book Dumbledore mops the floor with Voldemort. Lol.
Hermione saying Voldy's name took so much courage ❤
In the books Cho and Cedric didn’t just go together to the ball, they were actually in a relationship so she is still mourning the death of her boyfriend in the books and her and Harry have such a toxic relationship
"We have something Voldemort doesn't. Something worth fighting for."
"A nose!"
Bruh. 💀💀
Fun fact: Stephen King made the following comment about Umbridge.
"The gently smiling Dolores Umbridge, with her girlish voice, toad-like face, and clutching, stubby fingers, is the greatest make-believe villain to come along since Hannibal Lecter."
for those curious the snake Voldemort makes is a spell called fiendfyre.
The power the dark lord knows not is love. That is made very clear in the book. There's an entire chapter of just Harry and Dumbledore talking after the events at the ministry, and Dumbledore reveals a LOT of information in it while Harry, angry as ever, destroys his office.
In the book, "stupefy" renders the victim unconscious. I don't know why the movies had to make pretty much every spell make people fly backwards and that's it. lol
and of course shortly after posting that I get "proven wrong" about what the movies did to the spells but think back to other movies, many of the spells just made their targets fly back.
To be fair they had Expelliarmus throwing Lockhart across the room in the 2nd movie. Same with 2 of the spells Harry and Draco used.
@@toodlescae yes that is one of the examples of this that always sticks out in my head. The other, completely different spells Draco and Harry threw at each other in the same scene also had the same effect.
@@cjg8763 I guess it was cheaper because of the cost of the cgi involved in making different spells have different effects. Much cheaper to have most of them do the same thing.
Luna is a Ravenclaw, the house of intelligence, wit and creativity.
why hermione is not in rawenclaw?
@@albertjoefrancy7309 because intelligence isn't her BIGGEST quality. Also, she's very close minded! She only believes in things that are written in books. One of the biggest ravenclaw traits is being creative and open-minded
@@erikperhs_ thnx mate, also when Harry's parents were killed why the 'order' didn't use timeturner to go back and save them?
@@erikperhs_ is it possible to use time turner to go to past, even it is more than 10 yrs
In the book Umbridge admits that she set the dementors on Harry and Big D.
I don't know if anyone has explained why the muggles don't notice the magic, but in the book a big part of this is explained away as areas that are high traffic magic having anti-muggle / anti-detection charms on them. So for example - not anyone can just wander into hogwarts if they haven't been accepted / invited. If a muggle, or even another wizard, were to stumble upon the location of hogwarts, it would look like smoldering pile of rubble or something equally as unappealing, and they would feel a strong urge to look away or turn around or suddenly feel like they had an urgent appointment to get to. That's how most of the areas with magic work. So the muggles don't notice them going onto platform 9-3/4 or the knight bus going through town or any of the magic things that occur around them, because there are anti-detection charms in place.
Some stuff that weren't adapted:
The full prophecy is "The one with the power to vanquish the Dark Lord approaches... Born to those who have thrice defied him, born as the seventh month dies... and the Dark Lord will mark him as his equal, but he will have power the Dark Lord knows not... and either must die at the hand of the other for neither can live while the other survives... The one with the power to vanquish the Dark Lord will be born as the seventh month dies...". Thing is, the prophecy could very well have been about Neville, as he also matched the first two conditions. It was only when Voldy attacked Harry (the third condition) that the prophecy being about him and Harry was set in stone. Also, the person that made the prophecy was Trelawny, thus why Dumbledore was so insistent that she remain in the castle.
A Death Eater overheard the prophecy and told Voldy, which is why he attacked the Potters. He chose Harry instead of Neville as Harry was a Half-Blood, just like himself. Thing is, the Death Eater only heard half of the prophecy, which is why Voldy has been trying to get it so badly all year. He wanted to know what else it said, to ensure he would not make the same mistake again.
There is a bit more to Snape's memory that was left out. As he was being bullied, Lily (Harry's mum) came to Snape's rescue, chastising James for ganging up on Snape. Snape, in his anger and embarrassment, retorted that he didn't need help from a mudblood. Harry later found out from Sirius and Lupin that James matured after this and while his rivalry with Snape continued, he stopped bullying him and eventually managed to redeem himself in Lily's eyes, thus beginning their relationship.
Neville's parents were tortured into insanity by a group of Death Eaters that included both Bellatrix Lestrange and Barty Crouch. Bellatrix was the ringleader of the group. Neville's parents are now permanent residents in St Mungo's Hospital of Magical Maladies in the ward for those permanent spell damage. Neville visits them with his grandmother every year, but they don't recognise him. Also, Lockhart's there as well.
Harry had won 1000 Galleons for winning the Triwizard Tournament the previous year, which he gave to Fred and George entirely. By the time they ditch Hogwarts, they've already secured premises at Diagon Alley for their joke shop.
Percy had a terrible falling out with his family, as he chose to believe the Ministry over Dumbledore. This mostly came as a result of anger at his father for telling him that being promoted to Junior Minister was not by his own merit, but to use him as a spy and embarrassment at his father choosing to continue working such a mundane, low-paying job, essentially believing that his father was scoffing at his ambition while having no ambition of his own.
Hilarious him taking the title as Taking order from the Phoenix bird.😂😂
A dragon IS an option for a Patronus form! It's pretty rare. Mine is a Chow Chow Dog according to the Wizarding World quiz.
I would have chosen a panda, obviously 😆
It's never what we want it to be, is it? Suppose that's cause our favorite animal and our "spirit animal" aren't usually the same. I was hoping for a fox, cause they're awesome. It's a swan according to the quiz.
@GiuseppeDAntelmi The description of what a Chow Chow Patronus means is actually very accurate. Just not the animal I was expecting 😆
They never say this in the film but Umbridge sent the dementors after Harry
And Neville’s parents were one of the worst wizarding crimes because they were tortured for info even the death eaters knew he didn’t have and after the war was technically over
I was looking forward to your reaction, and it was great :)))
Thank you!❤
Already know this is going to be amazing
Movie never explained the room of requirement as good as the books and that always bugged the hell out of me because it played such a crucial role in multiple chapters of the Harry Potter story but it’s hard to notice all the dots to even connect them. One of my favorite add ons
I would like to thanks the reactors and also commenters💜💜💜 I've watch Harry Potter since I was a kid, but there's still a lots of things that confusing me, I can't understand complicated things😅 watching this on the CZcams together with the reactors and reading the comments really help me to understand about what actually happened, because I can never understand this by myself.. so thank you😭😭 highly appreciated💜🤧
The Weasley twins were, in fact, not expelled for the fireworks stunt. In the book, they officially withdrew themselves from school before engaging in their grand exodus. To be expelled from school includes having your wand confiscated, broken, and you no longer being allowed to practice magic. Hagrid was expelled during the first chamber of secrets fiasco. In the first installment, he ignited the fire with an umbrella that had his broken wand hidden inside. Then he told Harry, "strictly speaking, I'm not supposed to do magic." It's also why Hermione, after first encountering Fluffy, said something like, "...before one of you have another cleaver idea that gets us killed. Or worse, expelled."
fifth book has always been my favorite coz Harry rages so angrily in here. shouting everywhere....there were so many side plots that have been lost in the movies
The faces that had been erased or blocked on the Black family tree were of those who had rejected the family's 'pure blood' ideology. Another face that had been erased was that of Andromeda, sister of Bellatrix and Narcissa. She was disowned for marrying a muggle - Ted Tonks.
Ted Tonks was a muggle born wizard.
Harry is dealing with a lot this year. PTSD & survivor's guilt from the graveyard, people calling him crazy or a liar, he's being kept in the dark, Umbridge is torturing him and he has visions of what Voldemort's feeling and doing in his head even when he's asleep on top of teenage hormones.
James was not as bad as Malfoy and Snape wasn't always alone. He had all of his Slytherin friends who all became Death Eaters the same as Snape. James was a conceited a** as a kid but he did change and even saved Snape's life at one time when Sirius pulled a nasty, potentially deadly trick on Snape.
In the book that fight between Dumbledore and Voldemort wasn't even close. Dumbledore was kicking his butt six ways from Sunday until Voldemort possessed Harry.
The reason Harry doesn't want to tell Dumbledore about Umbridge's torture, is because she represents the Ministry. The Ministry has the power to change rules at Hogwarts, and also to fire Dumbledore if they want to. They have all the power. By telling Dumbledore, Dumbledore would have stepped in, and the Ministry would have interpreted that as opposing the Ministry and gotten the excuse they needed and were searching for, to fire Dumbledore. You saw how quickly the Ministry interfered once McGonagall spoke up against her methods. Harry is fully aware of this, so he keeps quiet and continues to let himself be tortured daily to protect Dumbledore. Like he said, "What ever this is, it is anything but simple". He knows how important it is to keep Dumbledore at Hogwarts, so he endures it to not get Dumbledore in trouble.
The funny thing is if Dumbledore said no to them who is gonna stop him
@@painvillegaming4119 no one could, but that would make him exactly what the ministry was afraid of. it would make him a dictator, a tyrant, someone who sets himself above the ministry who are the elected officials of the wizarding world. even Dumbledore has to follow their laws and regulations, even if he is powerful enough to not have to.
@@huldradraco yeah I know and this is why I find this funny
They know how powerful he is and think they can do anything against him if he was truly trying to repel
1:00:49 I'm gonna need Neel and Fax to do a "find your Patronus" quiz after this is all done :)
Also do the houses too!
1:27:09 About the fight btw dumbledor and Voldemort, in the books dumbledor is clearly more powerful (he was literally toying with Voldemort) but as the movie begun to greatly differentiate themselves from the books, they have to make voldemort more powerful in the movie for keeping their story consistent for the next movies. Some fans trying to apply the book logic to this scene always make me laugh. We clearly see that voldemort had the upper hand (dumbledor literally finish this fight on the floor in the movie version) + the famous « dumbledor didn’t try to kill him » (in the books he didn’t) but dumbledor literally try to drown Voldemort in this fight, if that’s not a murder attempt I don’t know what it is. And finally in the books Harry’s possession by Tom (Voldemort) at the end of the fight is a lame ass move he did while trying to flee bc he lost but in the movie it’s more like an ultimate insult directly to dumbledor to try to assert his dominance to him, that’s why possessed harry said: « you lost old man ». I will always say that’s a fucking A.D.A.P.T.A.T.I.O.N, since the fourth movie the story takes a real turn about the characters. Book Dumbledor and Movie Dumbledor ARE NOT the same characters (the same goes to Voldemort)👍🏿
Your logic is flawed
Dumbledore*
And fans apply book logic, because the books are so much better.
@@erinn5055 Yeah the books are better I don’t deny it, but it clearly two different stories at this point so you can’t apply book’s logic
perfect timing! I am rereading 5th book right now
Umbridge sent the dementors to Harry & Dudley at the start of the movie
Yes, this is never brought up in the movie. They skipped over so much. I understand they have to for time though, but having all that detail would have been cool. Can't wait for the tv series. It's supposed to be much more true to the books.
"I have no enemies"
I'm still waiting for Vinland Saga 2
HECK YEAH i just started my lunch break for working from home, perfect timing
you guys better like this video!! I want to finish HP Series with them 🥹
The meme "dumbledore asked calmly" is the difference as to how Harry was interrogated. In the books, Dumbledore handled it in 'calm' and supportive manner. While in the movie, he fucking tackled him 😂
great start to my morning
Extra Context: umbridge sent the dementors after harry at the start of the movie.
Hermione called her a mean nickname by accident, "Looney" instead of "Luna".
The first four movies were light and fun. The fifth is dead Sirius.
Did you recognized the voice in the prophecy it was the divination professor being possessed again well it actually was the 1st time she was possessed she not at Hogwarts for her subject she is really there for her protection. That's the real reason she can't leave the school grounds.
We heard about Harry's mom in Prisoner of Azkaban from Remus Lupin, He said Lily is a good person who would always see the good side of people even if that person doesn't see it. And then he talk about Harry's dad being a rule's breaker😂
Nicholas Hooper's soundtrack is amazing!
Umbridge released dementors and book tell after death of sirius this property was given to harry in his wish and also kreacher(elf u saw) but since there is a enchantment that only pure blood can own it so half ownership is with harry and half with bellatrix. Very sad at 19:53 as she would die soon after in the last episodes(i didn't spoil anything as she wasn't in movies so doesn't make plot difference) Btw Harry's father was a bully for in starting and he improved when he started liking lily and movies doesn't tells about snape's bullying
Both of you hating on Umbridge and trying to figure out the worst fate for her after just one third of the movie is so funny to me. It also is a great example for how the fandom sees her. I think its the one topic where Potterheads are the most united. Everyone hates Umbitch
MY MOMENT!! ❤❤❤ MY FAVORITE MOVIE
The scenes in the ministry were so cool in the book, I always feel the movie didn't do it justice. At least the effects in Dumbledore v Voldemort were cool, but again the book did it better.
The actress for Bellatrix is spot on. She's fucking NUTS in the books and her actress brought that insanity out so well in the movies.
This is the best movie of them all
Pretty sure it was in this movie that they said everything about Trelawney and Harry and Neville, right?
Neel just knows it all 😂
17:04 So, pretty much, in the books, Dumbledore says the line “Harry, did you place your name in the goblet of fire” calmly, but, in the movies, Dumbledore got super pissed and everyone calls it out because everyone imagines Dumbledore as a really calm and quiet wise old wizard in the books whereas him being loud and not-calm-at-all wise old wizard
Looking at y'all's pace, you must be planning to upload the last part by Christmas 😆
"Dumbledore said calmy" 😂😂😂❤
"a nose." i freaking bursted out laughing 😂
After being to london all i can think when they use that red phone box to enter the ministry before Harrys hearing is 'yeah, AS IF theres a red phonebox in London not surrounded by tourists queing for a photograph!' even right next to the big ben clock, torusists were opting to take pictures with the phonebox instead xD
Luna is from the Ravenclaw house and Ravenclaws are smart sttudents that is why Luna is in there.
The fact that Harry said Voldemort doesn't know love is actually true. He can't feel love because he was conceived while his mom used a love potion on a muggle man. People born from love potions are unable to love. Technically not a spoiler since it's not mentioned in the movies and it's just giving some context to Voldemort
idk how thet can make so many jokes like its a comedy movie or something when its literally such a dark and sad show xD but alright
plus 23:30 Luna Lovegood best girl,both movie and book
Thinking for even a second that Bellatrix Lestrange could be on our side is hilarious
That whole "...Dumbledore says calmly..." is a run on joke among fans of the books. Goblet of Fire is the point where the producers of the Harry Potter movies not only leave a lot of things out (for good reason because the novel is super long) but they also change certain moments. Dumbledore was always a very calm, cool and collective person through out the series. Even when in a dangerous situation he alway spoke with a level head. So the fact that they protrayed him as someone blowing his top, loosing his cool and acting so aggressively is way out of character. Dumbledore is calculating and carefully analyzes all situations. He doesn't explodes with emotions. Even if there is a good reason to do so it's just not what he does.
🧙♂️🪄🧘♂️✌️🤙👍
Everything Harry heard about his father up until now was from his friends, so of course he had a spotless image in his head. But here he saw his father was a bully, and came to realize that his parents were also just people and not the perfect martyrs and parents of the chosen one. In fact we know very little about his father and mother, I think a lot of people just have many headcanons about them instead. They died really young too.
Someone surely mentioned it under the Prisoner of Azkaban video, that the fact why Snape is so focused on revenge against Sirius is the fact that yes, James and Sirius (two very wealthy, popular boys) were his main bullies while Remus Lupin did not stop them, but Sirius also sent Snape as a "prank" into the Shrieking Shack where Lupin was during his werewolf phase. It's just so funny right... Lupin would either kill Snape or turned him into a werewolf too, and idk how he would feel about that when he would came to himself again. I just think the Marauders are too glorified by HP fans, I think it's much more interesting to read them as flawed and human characters.
Have you two tried the official Wand and Patronus tests ?? I’m curious as to your houses also.
The killing curse it not that simple. Actually, any spell you must be willing to do it so it works. Like really willing.
35:55 I like they way you think
voldemorts nose is supposed to be like the heat pits on snakes, so he might have a whole extra sense
What I really dislike about the movie is that they made the Dumbledore vs Voldemort fight look even and makes new people get worried about Dumbledore when in the books Voldemort could barely handle him. Dumbledore was way more powerful and he was the reason why Voldemort could not just simply attack Hogwarts.
Umbridge is a Really² KAREN in the wizarding world😂
The thing I dislike about this movie is how they changed the story to have Umbridge break into the room of requirement. It's impossible to break in. The room exists in an extra-dimensional space. She'd simply be blasting out a Hogwarts wall for nothing.
My patronus is a dragon, dude suddenly said his would be a dragon i was like 😮
Omg when professor umbridge goes around and judging all the professors controlling all the school as she measured the short professor teach music that’s a violation!! 😂😂 like why!? you are NOT Professor Dumbledore