Was Hadith Written Two Hundred Years After The Prophet?
Vložit
- čas přidán 3. 03. 2021
- Support Me and The Channel:
www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted...
/ themuslimlantern
cash.app/%C2%A3TheMuslimLantern
Follow me on Social Media:
/ chainless_slave
/ chainless_slave
/ themuslimlantern
The way Sheikh Uthman is nodding at Muhammad Ali's explanations tells you something about the soundness of Muhammad Alis knowledge. ALHAMDULILLAH
Same thinking ❤
You realize muhammad Ali is more learned than Uthman right? Have you ever heard uthman reciting the quran?
@@georgexander7170please dont ridicule uthman, hes very educated
@@Akhimed have you heard him recite the quran?
@@georgexander7170What does reciting the quran have to do with knowledge ?
mansur, hashim, ali, uthman, skeptik, best circle in youtube
Woulda been better without skeptic. Fitna chaser
@@sidzahriya9041 that wasn't Daniel the Muslim Skeptic. That was just a random guy who had that name that came on to ask a question about hadiths to which Muhammed Ali was responding to. And yeah I don't like Daniel either.
How do you have over 1 million subcribes when you have videos with 8k and 6k views?(almost all of your videos)
@@Alisalah_24just fell off, sort by popular and you’ll see videos with millions of views from 5 years ago
Syeikh Uthman and Brother Mohammed Ali have good knowledge of Hadist... a good combination with other speaker, In Sha Allah...
Dangerous Duo 🤣
Wallahi.. Am little jealous of you.. How can a person be blessed with so much of intellect, logical and great memory.. May Allah bless you dear brother. All of them in this panel are really great but you are my favourite ❤
Dear brother don’t ever forget to say Maa shaa Allah. May Allah increase him more and grant us as well.
الدعاء بالبركة لأهلها؛ فقد قال ابن بطال في شرح صحيح البخاري: قوله: ألا بركت. فيه أن من رأى شيئا فأعجبه فقال: تبارك الله أحسن الخالقين، وبرك فيه، فإنه لا يضره بالعين، وهي رقية منه. اهـ.
وقال ابن عبد البر في الاستذكار: قوله صلى الله عليه وسلم: ألا بركت. يدل على أن من أعجبه شيء فقال: تبارك الله أحسن الخالقين، اللهم بارك فيه، ونحو هذا، لم يضره -إن شاء الله-. اهـ.
والله أعلم.
its because we are not focused and dont learn. May Allah Swt free us from our Nafs
Subscribed,MashaAllah Muhammad Ali, i always appreciate your morals and patience May Allah bless you and reward you in dunya as well in the akhira🌺🍃
Ameen
May Allah bless you brother. That was such a clear understanding. May Allah guide us as Muslims and keep us on the straight path.
Been waiting for work from u too brother Muhammad, Masha'Allah may Allah preserve u all. Continue the dawah alhamdolilah
Yeah, same here
ALHAMDULILLAH...1st video...upload more muhammad...lots of your video in speakers corner are very good.
Came here after the stream on DawahWise. Congratulations on the new channel. May Allah Make it easy for you to upload beneficial videos. Jazakallah for your works brother
Subscribed after watching Dawahwise when I heard you started a new channel at end of the 5 hour + stream alhumdulillah.
Finally I found your channel , I’ve been watching your video from speakers corner and it was hard to find but alhamdulillah, please post more video regularly
May Allah Subhanaho wa ta'ala reward you for this beautiful explanation. جزاكم الله خيرا
May Allah guide you and guide us, thanks for making a Chanel I have c ur content on other channels and always wanted ur personal Channel. I like ur way of dawah
السلام عليكم
Glad you finally made a channel Habibi, May Allah preserve you and keep your intentions firm. 🙏🏽❤️
و عليكم السلام ورحمة الله
Finally found your channel lol alhamdullilah
Yeah me tooo...🤩🤩🤩🤩
So happy to see your channel , i have watched almost all your videos in corner speaker. Please transfer all your video to your channel as they were so beneficial .
True
If only Christians would have all these references to call upon when it comes to authenticity of their bibles
Maesha Allah, just subbed. Really looking forward to many more uploads and live streams :)
JazakAllahu khair akhi❤❤
MashaAllah br muhammad Ali subscribed ❤👍🙌☝
My beautiful brother Muhammed, I have watched all of your videos brother, and I am sad that i have no more videos to watch. And I really don't wanna start my day without listening to you. please share more videos.
we need to write down what we have benefited from brother Muhammad and study this stuff for our own self inshaaAllah. Just listening will not bring US further
really seeing these brothers i feel very confident jazakum Allah kheir.
Really love your videos
شرح جيد ، بارك الله في جهودكم وجعلها خالصة لوجه الكريم.
بارك الله فيكم
Subscribed after watched the stream on DawahWise
Me too..
Me to alhumdulillah
It’s nice to see young brother Muhammad joining the big lions.
He is one of the bigger lions but very well mannered and polite
The Straight Path! He’s our guy we claimed him first lol
What a beautiful group of people.❤️
May god gives all theses men’s the power and fairness to continue spreading the words of Allah , barak allah fikoum
MashaAllah brother, you should be on the Arena on Hamza's Den. You have good knowledge.
Masha Allah brother Mohamed, may God bless you and give you more knowledge
بارك الله فيك!
MashaAlllah... May Allah protect our brothers.
ma shaa Allah. Fantastic explanation
Just beautiful explanation.
Jazakallahu khair
Dua to Fix all your family issues:
رَبَّنَا هَبْ لَنَا مِنْ اَزْوَاجِنَا وَذُرِّيّٰتِنَا قُرَّةَ أَعْيُنٍ وََّاجْعَلْنَا لِلْمُتَّقِينَ إِمَامًا
اے ہمارے رب !تو ہمیں ہماری بیویوں اور اولادوں سے آنکھوں کی ٹھنڈک عطا فرما اور ہمیں پرہیزگا روں کا امام بنا۔
Our Lord! Grant us from among our wives and offspring, comfort to our eyes and make us an example for the righteousness. (Al-Furqan:74)
mashaAllah this is really well explained
2 years later in 2024,Brother Ali,Masha Allah you have come so far.
مشاء الله بارك الله فيك
I would like to see the discussion
Mashallah. ❤️
Mash’Allah
Ma sha Allah tabark Allah
Barakallah feekum.
Soooo happy alhamdulillah to find your channel.. _jazakallahu khayra for this topic and nafaa'llahu bika wa zadaka 'ilman wa tawfiqa.._
If only all muslims listen and comprehend..
It hurts me seeing some people talking without knowledge and contesting Sahih Albukhari (actually fitnat albukhari is not new, but from time to time it becomes a fashion!!)..
No need to talk about the ones who reject completely the sunnah and claim believing only in Quran.. do they not question themselves how the Quran reached them.. :( ?
*I ask Allah swt to show us the Truth as truth and grant us to follow it and show us the Falsehood as falsehood and grant us to avoid it.. Ameen*
Mashallah, baraka Allahu feek
Salaam Alaikum please put subtitles
Masha Allah.....Muslim version of Avengers! 👍🏼👌🏼
May Allah swt reward you all....Ameen
Masha Allah brodah
Sheik Uthman was nodding almost throughout😄
Because this two (ali and sheikh uthman) have the same knowledge and understanding
Please put up subtitles I have a hearing problem.
Do you have links to the other compilations which you mentioned? Are there English translations?
This is some of what i have mentioned in the video that is available online, To the extent of my Knowledge Muwatta of imam malik is available in English (3000) Narrations, For someone who is seeking the Truth 1 Manuscript is enough to admit that they were wrong about the topic.
The Manuscript of the Tabee Kharash Ibn Abduallah In Berlin Num1552, and In Library Of Sahed Ali In Turkey Num 539 (You can email the Library for a Picture of the Manuscript from the Following Link) t.me/ALIPASHA2
صحيفة التابعي خراش بن عبد الله. مخطوط في شهيد علي 539، وفي برلين (1552.)
www.alukah.net/library/0/79183/
The Hadith of مثني بن عبد الله Died 150 Ah
www.alukah.net/culture/0/139062/
تفسير ابن جريح Died 150 Ah
waqfeya.net/book.php?bid=1825
كتاب المناسك سعيد بن أبي عروبة died 156 AH
www.alukah.net/library/0/100596/
Muwatta of imam malik Died 179 Ah
What i hear alot is not about the hadiths or tge books but ppl i speak to are confused about the role of hadith they are nor rejecting hadith as a supplement or context to Quran but they are hesitant to accept that it was from the beginning meant to be foundational to the religion in the way it is.
Can you upload the whole conference, please?
The Link Is In The Description
@@TheMuslimLantern shukran... ❤️
@@TheMuslimLanternI can't find it
Masha ALLAH tabaraka ALLAH
Wow this two are very strong in dawah.i wish muhammed ali and sheikh uthman would make dawah on the Street together
Maa xaa Allah
Allahumma Barik
Manuscripts. When are the earliest physical copies?
Look up the definition of manuscript
Alhamdulillah
Salamalykum Ustad. Which part of Arab are you. MashaAllah I like your accent
Wa alykom Aslam wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuhu
It's a mixture of different accents
Allah protects his religion. May he raise everyone of our ranks
And those whom came before us, and after us. Ameen
Assalamu alaikum brother. I have a few questions about the manuscripts to these hadith collections and books containing hadith. Do we have the original manuscripts to them? If so where can I find those? Are there books that have photocopies that I can look at?
Where can I get the full video of this discussion?
ALL THE LEGENDS HERE!!!!!
I love this guy
Sahih Al-Bukhari's authentications of Hadith make easy for common people to acknowledge & understand as for who doesn't have any sense of authenticity of hadith in previous books where they didn't mention any authenticity
Ma sha Allah. Muhammad Ali is a wealth of knowledge.
Sallalahu Alayhi Waalihi Wasallam
Very cool
NewWarrior 🌸❤️
Have taqwa and be sincere, seek knowledge and apply what you learn my siblings, Allahu Akbar!
Anyone got the list that Br Muhammad Ali mentioned? Sometimes his accent I can't catch what he said.
Love you Mohammad Ali ❤❤❤❤
This is a very important point.. No matter how many books were written before Bukhari. It is important that the ummah has approved Bukhari which was written 200 years after Muhammad. So all hadiths in Bukhari should be accepted and a healthy criticism is good.
Why should they all be accepted? Please tell me brother.
@@BitMan1010 Its like saying I accept the Quran but only 90% of the verses. How can the ummah accept Bhukari as a trustworthy scholar but only accept hadiths that you like and reject others. Ae you more scholarly that Bhikari? Did Bhukhari not have the wisdom to reject those hadiths?
I thought it had been just corrupted
@@BitMan1010Because majority of scholars have classified it as authentic. With the exception of a few scholars
One question I never get an answer. Did the prophet approved these writing and if so why is not in the Quran ? When it comes to the gospel especially with Paul we are very critical about but we basically doing the same it’s very contradictory when there is also weak a fake Hadith. Who are we following Allah or scholars?
Anyone know where I can watch the full thing?
Bukhari is one of the greatest persons in history and will remain so until the end of times.
Other than the Prophets (saw and as) their companions and people mentioned in the quran
But 👍
There isnt even a manuscript of bukhari
Try not to reject this hadith from the so called "most authentic hadith book in the world" Sahih Bukhari 7:67:393 . I have more because the book itself is full of it it's just and example. And these careless scholars hide it.
@@NotrandomlikeyouVolume 7, Book 67, Number 393:
Narrated Adi bin Hatim:
The Prophet said, "If you let loose your hound after a game and mention Allah's Name on sending it, and the hound catches the game and kills it, then you can eat of it. But if the hound eats of it, then you should not eat thereof, for the hound has caught it for itself. And if along with your hound, join other hounds, and Allah's Name was not mentioned at the time of their sending, and they catch an animal and kill it, you should not ea: of it, for you will not know which of them has killed it. And if you have thrown an arrow at the game and then find it (dead) two or three days later and, it bears no mark other than the wound inflicted by your arrow, then you can eat of it. But if the game is found (dead) in water, then do not eat of it." And it has also been narrated by 'Adi bin Hatim that he asked the Prophet "If a hunter throws an arrow at the game and after tracing it for two or three days he finds it dead but still bearing his arrow, (can he eat of it)?" The Prophet replied, "He can eat if he wishes."
@@coronateststation241
It was orally transmitted. Get a book, read, rather than reading your daily Bible which you've become too numb to realize is filled with contradictions.
😮😮😮
AlhamduliALLAH
Quran 6:145 Say: I DO NOT FIND in that which has been revealed to me anything forbidden for an eater to eat of except that it be what has died of itself, or blood poured forth, or flesh of swine-- for that surely is unclean-- or that which is a transgression, other than (the name of) Allah having been invoked on it; but whoever is driven to necessity, not desiring nor exceeding the limit, then surely your Lord is Forgiving, Merciful.
Q16:115-116 And do not say about what your tongues assert of untruth, ” This is lawful and this is unlawful” to invent falsehood about Allah .
Now ask yourself the question. Did the prophet after reciting the above verses to the people around him went ahead to spread falsehood about Allah ?
I cant find the full video
link to full vid pls?
Salaam Alaikoum Muhammed Ali, I have a question brother, when the Hadiths were checked by Bukhari ra7imahoulah, did this happen hadith by hadith? Or was it also possible that a bundle of hadiths were checked at once?
Wa Alaikum Assalam Wa Rahmatu Allahi Wa Barakatuh.
Ofcourse, it was hadith by hadith, and it wasn't only checked by Al-Bukhari رحمه الله alone but with his scholars also, and it was checked through time by many scholars.
People used to travel long distance (it takes a long time, sometimes months) just for one hadith
all lies@@AL-FATTAH_servant
@@br4885
Source: what's app university
👏🏻👏🏻👍🏻
I once watch a video it happened In Malaysia a layman asked for dalil from some local famous ustaz, but they got mocked and humiliated and was label wahabi.
Watching this we understood that asking for dalil ask been a practiced since the time of the sahaba.
DawahWise 😎
Oh ok Rise of Lantern started from here😂😂
The Thinking Muslim Podcast: Jonathan Brown episode is recommended.
ohibbukum fillah...sheikh Uthman, bro Hashim, bro Mansur, bro Jake n sheikh Muhammad
Bhukari should’ve never been translated in the English language because it’s soo confusing to the no Arabic speaking laymen like me, I mean, I got a book of shahih bukhari and it mentions Hadith which have been abrogated like the muta Hadith yet it never mentioned that in the book! 🤷♂️
2024
4:33
I'm still struggling with these statements, pls help me :
1. "Hadith believers are unconsciously insinuating that Prophet Muhammad made a MISTAKE of not asking his companions to write down his sayings and actions and CHECK the writings HIMSELF by asking the writers to read them, just like he did with the Quran"
2. "If How we do Salat is fundamental to islam, then why didn't Prophet Muhammad made sure it was written by his companions accurately and check it? No such instructions were made in his lifetime. And why didn't Allah SWT put it in the Quran? The only possible answers to these questions are;
a. Allah SWT made a mistake
b. Prophet Muhammad made a mistake
c. Both of them didnt make a mistake because it was a man made doctrine added after Prophet Muhammad passed away
Good summary of arguments, and yes (as you already know) the correct answer is (c).
As for 1. Prophet Muhammad (saw) himself instructed the companions/people to erase anything that you are writing which is not the Qur'an. (i.e. only write the Qur'an from me). It shows how hadith or even Sunnah was never meant to be in a written form, otherwise Prophet (saw), among the 10,000s+ of so-called authentic hadiths we have would have instructed to "Document my Sunnah" ... Never! Not once. Not even in a weak hadith.
As for 2. It's unfortunate that they throw this question (without knowing its answer) and "assume" that Oh so if prayer rituals/instructions are not mentioned in the Qur'an then certainly we need another "Book" as a source to learn Islam!? That's the most illogical conclusion, and goes directly against the Qur'an. Allow me to explain...
The Qur'an instructs us to do Sacrifice of Animals.. but doesn't detail exactly how (and many similar examples). Because that is a common knowledge. Likewise, the months of Hajj are (as Qur'an says) "well known" and doesn't mention them in the Qur'an.. meaning that "secondary" source of information is simply the ongoing Sunnah. Whether someone documents it or doesn't, it will always be known.
Documentation of hadith simply made things worse. It's equable to what Christians did with the Bible. Hadith books (including Sahih) includes blasphemous, absurd, vulgur content that the mainstream has no shame in ascribing to the Prophet (saw). Many contradicts with the Qur'an, let alone contradict each other. Many degrade women,.and mock Prophets. Many doesn't even has "Sunnah" some are just random stories of monkeys and rocks.
How is that become a mainstream source of Islamic book? It's insanity.
Islam = Qur'an and Sunnah.
And Sunnah is certainly not "hadiths". Allah (swt) warns us (in 45:6) against following any hadith after the Qur'an, by saying:
"These are the verses of Allāh which We recite to you in truth. Then in what hadith after Allāh and His verses will they believe?"
اقرا اقوال العلماء
@@user-kx1tf4vx1i Thank you for your wise words and advice.. May I know which part(s) of my comment bothered you the most and why?
All I reinforced was: "Islam = Qur'an and Sunnah" ... do you not agree?
Hadiths are commonly regarded as "Sunnah" by the majority, whereas "Sunnah" has not originated from Hadiths.. rather hadiths were compiled from "some" of the Sunnah, while some hadiths are misleading and unauthentic, including the Sahih hadiths. Prophet (saw) made sure to deliver and teach the Qur'an, so any hadith that helps understand the Qur'an, we should accept, and any Hadith that contradicts the Qur'an, or is irrelevant, absurd, vulgar (whether it is in Sahih Bukhari or wherever) we should fear Allah (swt) and 'not' ascribe any falsehood on our beloved Prophet (saw).
Yes, Sahih hadiths (around 150 of them) include absurdity, vulgarity, and/or blasphemy.. many Contradicts the Qur'an... But yes majority Sahih hadiths are ok. If you haven't studied all the Sahih hadiths (or if you don't know which Hadiths I'm referring to) then don't bother lecturing me.. Thanks!
@@Hasan... ربما بسبب الترجمه لم أفهم الكلام جيدا ظننت انك تنكر سنة النبي علية الصلاة والسلام والاحاديث لذلك اذا فهمي خطأ اعتذر
It is sad, people are judging between the speakers. Take what you choose / like or shut up.
don't take what you like
take what makes sense
Shiekh uthman is like < Yea we got an upcoming schoolar mashalah
1, Sahifah Hamman bin Munabih 719 CE / 748 CE (born 87 years after mohammad death)
2. -Musannaf of Ibn Jurayj 80/699 and died in 150/768( born 67 years after mohammad died)
3. Musannaf of Ma`mar bin Rashid (b.714 CE) (born 82 years after mohammad death)
4. The Muwatta' of Malik bin Anas: Malik bin Anas ((711-795) (born 79 years after Mohammad death)
5. The Musannaf of `Abd al-Razzaq al-San`an(744-827 CE,) (born 112 years after Mohammad death)
6. Musnad Abu Dawood Tayalisi (751-750-1 CE) (born 119 years after Mohammad death)
7. Musnad Imam Shafa'i (767-820 CE) (born 135years after Mohammad death)
8. Musnad Humaidi d. 841 CE
All these people wrote down the hadith 100s and 200 years after muhammad death.
If you throw all the books in the world in the fire right now. We have a Quran and a Saheeh Bukhari together. You don’t understand that the transmission was originally oral. A person can change a piece of paper just as easily as he can change speech. So where is the Gotcha of having Ahadith written down at a certain time. They might as well could not have been written down at all. It would be the same.
@@Bilal-ys6dfBecause oral transmission of the Quran was guaranteed by Allah… and the Quran was compiled throughout the life of the prophet S.A.W.. how can Bukhari be sound orally when there are thousands of Hadiths that were doubtful
When you have all your favourite teachers on the same day at school.
May All of u go to Jannah :), all look like Super hero Muslim Marvel :)