Gravitas: Should India revisit the relevance of reservation?
Vložit
- čas přidán 11. 11. 2021
- Is it time for India to revisit the relevance of reservation? Is Quota holding India's healthcare service hostage? Is reservation killing merit and giving undue advantage to a selected few? Listen in to Palki Sharma.
#Reservation #India #Gravitas
About Channel:
WION -The World is One News, examines global issues with in-depth analysis. We provide much more than the news of the day. Our aim to empower people to explore their world. With our Global headquarters in New Delhi, we bring you news on the hour, by the hour. We deliver information that is not biased. We are journalists who are neutral to the core and non-partisan when it comes to the politics of the world. People are tired of biased reportage and we stand for a globalised united world. So for us the World is truly One.
Please keep discussions on this channel clean and respectful and refrain from using racist or sexist slurs as well as personal insults.
Subscribe to our channel at goo.gl/JfY3NI
Check out our website: www.wionews.com
Connect with us on our social media handles:
Facebook: / wionews
Twitter: / wionews
Follow us on Google News for latest updates
Zee News:- bit.ly/2Ac5G60
Zee Bussiness:- bit.ly/36vI2xa
DNA India:- bit.ly/2ZDuLRY
WION: bit.ly/3gnDb5J
Zee News Apps : bit.ly/ZeeNewsApps
That's why I stopped searching government jobs
Look at haryana, private jobs aren't safe either.
I don't even feel proud to be Indian if the govt itself cutting peoples throat
Clear krne ka dimag b hona chahiye uske liy. Apni nalayki ko chupane k liy reservation k blame mat kr.
Sabse zada corrupt log, tax chor or criminals general category se hote h. Baki sab imandari se kaam krte h qki unko bacahne wala koi ni hota.
Agar talent ki itni chinta h to management quota hata do.
Koi b news paper utha ke dek lena, sare scam, corruption krne wale general hote h.
Caste based discrimination band hoga tabi reservation pe discussion start hoga. Jinhe lagta h ki caste ab matter ni krti to apni behno ki shadi educated n high government post me lage sc st obc k ladko se kr do.
Ni kr skte to chup raho.
Reservation koi garibi hatao scheme ni h, ye hazaro Saalo se socially discriminated logo ko fair chance dena ka ek tarika bus h. Warna general wale khud ko ucha samajte aye h, wo normally kisi or ko age bandne hi ni dege kabi.
Or agar itna hi chinta h to garibi hatane ki scheme lane bol de.
4 din phele up ke hospital me 13 bache maar gye. Uspe zimedaar 4 general category ke doctors hi h.
@@bhaijiimpwale2942 inshort yeh bolde naa ki reserve category se h aur video se jali h teri😆
@@forcat3581 jaal to teri rhi h. Isly yaha ake video dek k hilla rha h.
Jawab dene ko ni h to apne parvarish dika rha h merit dhari.
Imagine this... An ex-classmate of mine, apparently ST certificate holder, was able to secure a seat in my college(VJTI) with 56% while the cutoff was 99.2%.
His sister entered IIM - A with 76% (percentile). Lol.
And their father is/was a chief editor at TOI. Dude was loaded.
Are they economically challenged? No
Were their parent making more than ours already? Yes.
Did they deserve the seat? No.
This whole quota system is so flawed, its just beyond words now.
In my opinion, the core of the problem is the lack of good colleges and universities, even if you get rid of reservation the competition is still going to be cut throat,
We should focus on building more infrastructure first, after that the reason for reservation itself will dwindle and people won't protest if you remove reservation, if you end reservation now, people and mostly poorp people are gonna protest
Actually reservation is benefiting only those who are already taking advantage of this scheme for generations.
If your father took advantage of the scheme then children should not be allowed to again encash this scheme
Exactly even after getting govt jobs also they need reservations for promotions. Like why shall generation after generation will work hard. I am very happy now that most psu and other sector are getting privatised.
@@swarajsonavane8881 it's not about about competition, its about deserving people getting into the university ( financially backward , high achievers) . The caste based system is a baloney. Equality should be based on the current situation, long gone those days of casteism. As, she said caste is a permanent attribute how long you gonna continue this reservation?. There should be open competition and only reservations should be made for first graduates and financially backward candidates.
Reservation was never given on the basis of financial stability , it was given on the basis of social status
Let's suppose a dalit boy and a brahmin girl wants to marry ,both the families have same financial condition ,let's say the boy is little bit more rich . Will they be able to marry .....? answer is "A big NO"
WHY .? where is the logic that both are same if they have same financial condition...? Are they not equal...?
Secondly reservation only gets you into the college ,after that if a high caste and a low caste student graduates both are doctor of equal capabilities because both have passed all the exam required to be a doctor. Let's suppose a society having no reservations in any govt sector be it colleges, jobs , or promotion will the lower caste be allowed to study in premium institutions.......? Ideally yes they should be allowed but actual reality is not so simple .
My answer to the whole BIG QUESTION is reservation will remain until there is caste system
And we are discussing about reservation only not about the root cause "THE EPIC LEGENDARY CASTE SYSTEM" .The whole topic is wrong that's why it is only a topic to be discussed not of a practical use .
THE RESERVATION SYSTEM WILL REMAIN UNTIL THERE IS CASTE SYSTEM
BYE ....!
I’m a student and I know every single students of India in general can feel it😥
What about the people who is still SUFFERING UNTOUCHABILITY??? Visit my village SINKHEDE MAHARASHTRA. THEN YOU WILL KNOW ...
WHAT IS THE IMPORTANCE OF RESERVATION
@@sjdbdbnz poor should get reservation not the rich whatever the caste they are probably untouchable because they are poor and dirty but if they were rich and clean probably no one would do that
@@sjdbdbnz sun bhai tumhara 100-200 case hoga but general ka 10 cr ko problem hota hai...
@@sjdbdbnz If that's the case, make legal actions against those who practice UNTOUCHABILITY.
@@sjdbdbnz every country had slaves and slavery education gave freedom and equality not wuotas
I scored 147.2 marks out of 200 in SSC CGL and din'd get selected because cutoff for unreserved category was 150 while for sc candidate it was only 126. Now i have so much hate for reservation and i started disliking reserved cartegory thanks to the indian constitution and politicians of the country.
Someone had to say this loud and clear, thanks WION for bringing this out.
People had hope with BJP but they also succumbed to this reservation drama.
The only way in which parties like BJP who traditionally have been against this reservation can revoke it is when they get the security to retain the power otherwise why any political party would commit suicide.
The prolblem is not those who will lose the reservation but those woke kids as well who think that BJP is continuing its legacy of the so-called BRAHMINICAL PATRIARCHY.
SC, ST are some of the biggest supporters of BJP you might not see them on social media but numbers speak for themselves.
The only way to overcome this is to replace the system with income-based reservation...to start with.
If any political party do this....they should get immunity from the 1 term election to cool things down and aware the citizens of India.
Not going to improve ever. Any political party who even mentions a single word against reservation will disappear from the govt faster than Thanos's snap 😂
Well you can not completely remove reservation but at least government can reduced % of reservation quota of each caste.Reservation should be given by seeing state development.Why state like Maharashtra,TN, Karnataka,Kerala needs reservation?States like Bihar,UP still needs reservation to breach gap between poor and rich.
It is irony that our country is secular for religion practice but not secular when it comes to its education system.Our education system makes castism alive which eventually led to riots.
Even If we become 5 trillion economy by 2027,I will not call my country developed (or even developing)because they are not treating their own people equal.
@@ajayrathi5082 economic reservation is fine.. but why caste based??
@@rsaraswat5883 I think casteism should be removed completely and then people should be categorised under economical weaker section.Also EWS reservation must be restricted under 15%
She could speak any language but she chose to speak FACTS!!!
Sir is Sharma your name or your caste
@@samanya_jeevi Sharma can be just his identity… does not have to be anything else…
@@yogeshmohan126 ya his caste identity...
Lol my family used Sharma, and we still classify as OBC,
Idk who says that Sharma's are upper caste 🤣🤣
I don't support this reservation openly. Post graduation does not require this reservation
I was pissed off with reservations 25 years ago and decided to do CA which did not need any reservation while my heart was with Medicine. Worst life in this country is of a person who neither has reservation nor money, and yet gets hated.
@@adolfhitler8190 as your name your thoughts are cruel they live with whom they want dont decide with their life.
im facing this problem .today is mbbs allotment and u know the result
Spot on- no reservation, no money and yet gets hated!
@@adolfhitler8190 tera baap Nijikaran aa gaya hai Arakshan khor
@@adolfhitler8190 it seems your caste doesn't have youth with character..so you ppl always try to marry upper caste ppl
Caste based Reservations are the reason why majority of top indian engineers, doctors, scientists, entrepreneurs and scholars are leaving India to settle in Western countries. India's system doesn't respect talent, whereas western countries value talent.
Western countries also have Reservations. They call it DEI.
first of all 40 % of seats are on merit and second majority of them leave because of money and lifestyle not for reservation. Even foreign companies prefer those top institutes
@@desiboys7800Just 40 percent.
I know several dozens of people that settled abroad due to reservations in India and not because of lifestyle.
@@krishmishra514 what about ews?
@@krishmishra514 can you abolish caste based reservation in temples?
i lost my potential admission at an NIT. but my OBC friend with 24 marks less than me in JEE mains did get it, not to forget that he doesn't need to pay any fees irrespective of how much his family income exceeds mine. thank you India.
OBC's required to pay fees. ST SC and EWS dont
I had 9463 rank in IIT advance 2015, couldn't make into an IIT, but my SC friend with 13k rank got admission in IIT Guwahati, an obc friend whose CRL was 7.5k but category rank was 1.4k and he got into IIT Bombay. There are millions like you and me now. But it's ok. This shouldn't be an excuse, if there's one seat, someone unreserved is going to qualify for it, and it's our duty to try and become that one ! 🙏💯
OBCs have to pay fees. Get your info right.
Chacha OBC ko fees deni hoti hai ....pdhai likhai krlo thodi
Obc can apply for scholarships and compete refund of fee. People In private sector irrespective of their income apply for obc certificates
All entrance exam students feel this...absolutely agreed
BJP has increased reservation to an all-time high and even crossed the Supreme Court quota of 50%. BJP hatao desh bachao.
Democracy doesn't work for poor and uneducated countries like 3rd world failed banana republic state India you know 😂😂😂😂
@@codejunkes4607
gandhis created this problem
@@abbujaan Typical uneducated product of reservation, just search your history book or internet, both Mahatma Gandhi and Nehru were against reservation.
@@codejunkes4607
gandi family did it
I have friends across all categories, I never use to judge people on the basis of their caste, but recently I have noticed, I always make sure to read surname of a doctor before visiting him. Thank you reservation to keep the caste based judgement still alive in our minds.
I will never go to a reserved doctor. It is the matter of lives and health after all
Well ur a hindu so its expected from u 🤷♂
What if the general doctor has done it via private college funding??
@@jinfin221 he is ten times better than SC
@@SOURAVKumar-gp9bzbut what if a general category doctor does not have caste name as their surnmae 😢
In my college, I'm paying 40,000+ fees and the same fees for them is 3,500 and they are using luxurious cars and living lavish lifestyle as compared to mine & btw 80% of them is paying 3,500 and we who are paying more than 10× fees have to sit with them. Even my scores are better than them.
This is true India.
True😢
Then ban the caste system
Then abolish caste system, that's the best solution which will give 2 results.
if you look at the data from SECC (socioeconomic caste census), the poverty among SCs is 33.3% ST is 50.6% and generals is 15.6%, most of the sc and st who didnt fall under poverty line were barely above, what you are going through is sad but sadly most sc and st are not rich
Exceptions don't make the rules, if you know a couple of people from the reserved category who are rich, doesnt mean that most are rich or well off. Poverty is still more prevalent in reserved class.
All throughout my school life I never bothered to think to which caste my batchmates belong to. To me all of them were my friends, all of them were Indians.
Fast forward to me attempting entrance exams, not securing any government seat but my friends who scored way lower than me got in. It baffled me, it just didn't make any sense. The caste I never discriminated against suddenly got planted in my head as the 'students who got in with reservation, they killed my merit'. It has created unnecessary hate in my mind for them. And that is... India's reservation policy for you. Reservation divides you more. Period.
Same things happened 2 me and I felt same like you 😔😔😔
It has created a divide and dts a fact all those who are unreserved now hate reservation and those who are reserved my batchmate who was a reserved and way below average is now a govt employee enjoying his life where i am still studying day nd night on top of resevation there is money envolved and seats get booked. We have a very poor system if this continues india can nevet be a superpower. The lollipop which has been given to us..
Please take that period word out
Same with me, never cared abt caste. But after seeing someone with Lower rank getting better college with better branch. It hurts. And it makes me feel every sc/st/obc are underserving. It might be wrong but it's human emotions can't help it
Exactly.
*Indian politics runs on reservation quota. This is a bitter truth and many eligible candidates do not get jobs because of it.😢😢*
Politics should not be seen as a job. Reservation should be done away with.
And many qualified people are leaving the country, causing brain drain. The system is ruining the country.
@@minithankappan1226 There are so many castes and religions and so reservation was implemented. You must be from Kerala, it seems.
Thats why the best people are going abroad.....
True
Recently in Odisha, teachers have been appointed with 2 marks and students who scored 50+ were ignored
R.I.P Education System
Let me say this I'm a general category person . Majority of my relatives have left India and gone to Canada US or UK or Australia( all are Gen.).And remaining few relatives are planning to do the same (again all Gen.).My friends who are general are also planning the same .All my loved ones are leaving this country
.This reservation thing being one of the reasons . I will call this pure discrimination An ST whose parents income is 90K monthly and a general whose parents earn is 20k monthly .The general student could not get a medical seat in government college but The ST who was more than 300 ranks behind got the government medical seat in state qouta(Based on a real story) .That day the general student cried like hell .I knew both of them. Now people judge where is India going where... well I've an answer ....gravitational force
Nice Shreya 😊
I think you people didn't get a clarity about reservation. Get coeared by watching MP Kanimozhi about reservation.
After high school, I made sure that my education was affiliated to a Western country, it might be expensive but it’s worth it. Believe me, India will remain under developed af for a long time. Better get on the winning side because India really is against us.
Clarity??
1 month ago even us abolished reservations
You are reserved one you will never
Know how much a poor general suffer
@@praveenbalajibalasubramani116 go and ask your ancestors why they didn't rebeled
Reservation is one of the key factor that starts creating hate for SC, ST category. If a guy with 1000 rank doesn't get admission and a sc/st category student get admission in same college for 10k rank. This morally hurts that students and sometime a it develops sense of hate towards those category students .
😊
@@watchtolearn3668 It's core hate lol
I got 1700 rank in a competitive exam and I was not able to get admission.
Sc/St category students with 12000-13000 rank were able to get admission in the same course.
I was better than those students still I was not able to get admission. This incident triggered a sense of hate for sc/st category .
non creamy general caste have lower cutoff than backwards , but still many top post occupied
No wonder...Person belongs to SC, ST being hated before reservation and even after reservation....you cannot dare to hate rest of the community who also enjoying this reservation, instead you are accepting them...this is our fate born in this religion
@@watchtolearn3668 your story doesn't make sense it's baseless and unexplainable, first of all it's dream for most of general cast to travel through plane and you are telling because of he got plane that why he is selected in interview. Your greed never going to stop if you depends on government charity instead of doing hardwork.
@Reverted it's illogical to punish the descendants for the crimes of their ancestors.
Instead of uplifting the poor, it is harming the merit and letting them out of India
The casteists want racism to be maintained and reservation to be abandoned. First you leave the caste.
@@ratheeshkr8974 oh yes we are the people who always do it first 🥇 ......you are asking me leave my ancestors pride ........the big head of y'll gets higher rank jobs due to reservation .....
@@nirmalrajput3921 ha ha ancestor pride.. first of all scientifically if you compare Indians from both lower caste and upper caste they all are mixed of more than 3 races.. so you are already a mixed product.. unless you can prove scientifically you are not!!! Second of all.. your ancestors did something 1000 of years ago and you have to take pride on that for which unfortunately you contributed nothing.. same like sonam Kapoor saying I am lucky to be born as Anil Kapoor daughter...ha ha what a bunch of desperates..keep chest thumping one of your ancestor also must have killed a dinosaur somewhere in Africa... add that to your pride list...
@@ratheeshkr8974 remove the reservation, caste system will automatically be gone
@@arjyadebsengupta8159
It has been only seventy years since the beginning of reservation, but 4,000 years since the beginning of the caste system. That is to say, the caste system continued here without reservation. Reservation is not a barrier to caste abandonment.
Thanks to reservation I am now Canadian citizen. Enjoying life to the fullest with my family. Keep increasing reservation to increase brain drain!!
Iam also planning to leave the country
Very nice now keep spreading your caste system there
@@y1.5 I always praise talent and hardwork. It's you who is running behind caste. All the best 👍
@@ashisdash1976 bro is wokeism spreading there
If you'd have tried to abolish caste system
1000 problems for general category people , but only one solution
Just leave this country 🙏🙏
No politician is going to take a public stand against reservation because they know it would drop heir popularity
The casteists want racism to be maintained and reservation to be abandoned. First you leave the caste.
@@ratheeshkr8974 first you leave caste and reservations then preach others.
@@godofwar5517
The caste was here before the reservation began. So let those who say no to reservation first leave the caste.
@@ratheeshkr8974 I have no problem in leaving caste but first ask those to leave reservations.
@@godofwar5517
Do you think you are a genius ? it has nothing to do with tactics. Reservation will end when everyone leaves the caste and has a mixed marriage. Can racists think that.
Coming from Kerala I know exactly how stupid it has become the no of grants, reservations which the state offers to minorites whom makes up 44% of the population is unbelievable.
🥲paranjitt karyam illa
44% Are they still minorities?
@@r.arulkumar7349 not really
in karela de moost edugated state, it hapens when idiot goffons run state.
14% reservation for the largest minority (peacefool30% of Kerala) , 4% reservation for SC groups. The double standards. All they care about is votes.
Chota bheem spoiled life of general
As bada bheems soiled the lives of millions of people with their 100% reservations by looting and exploiting them. And no one has spoiled the lives of general folks they blame reservations if they are unable to get into a University or a job.
To bolo jai manu maharaj ji ki , jai sri ram , har har mahadev.😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Br ambedkar ji ne 10 years tak reservation rakhne ko kaha lekin sarkaar ki laparwahi ke karan ye equality ka target pura hua nhi is wajah se reservation ko lamba khinch diya sarkaar ne
And what about general people who get reservation about 1000 year and make a good wealth for there generations. It just only 75 year and you all start crying about it. What about discrimination still happen after 75 years
My father used to work in government job around 20-25 years back and he is general category and experienced a lot of discrimination, not just with recruitments, but also in promotions and growth opportunities so he resigned from government job and works in corporate job now, he dosen't regret resigning one bit
Reservation should exist until all upper caste and obc people cleans sewage
@ADOLF HITLER, If OBC and Upper Castes get there, we will strip you of reservation and get reservation for ourselves. Dont be nasty to communities who had to suffer so you can get into a better school or job despite exhibiting mediocrity.
@@divyathotapalli he is true you ppl can't do anything to us you just give us dhamki like goons 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@adolfhitler8190 tere reservation k liye tax hum bhi dete hai ter maje marne k liye sun lo bheek pe pal rahe ho mehnat pe nahi
@@adolfhitler8190 this is an ignorant statement. The issue is very complex and you statement is ridiculous.
Sadly, this topic will never come in politics...
I remember IIT students protested over quota system, clapity clap they were branded, forced to broadcast an unconditional apology.
God bless their souls....
Which year
@@samarthvan1789 if I am not wrong it was 2006-07...
@@humangasourous , Sir you know , how IIT system select his student ? Here to type of reservation work . Any cat student can book General seat but General can't.. even cat seat vacant left ....
Do you have any data what percentage of under privileged ST,SC,OBC,MOBC are lucky enough to study in IIT, Go to an IIT college and count , Now even general cast are getting 10% reservation as EWS ..
you will not talk about remove castism and untouchability in northern India, but you have problems with reservation.
How lower cast people are treated by upper cast . You will never know that because you are also upper cast. Still today Upper cast parents will not give their daughter in marriage to a lower cast, or never let their son marry a lower cast woman.
Their parents will choose to hunt them down and kill them both , thinking that it will be shame form them in society. Why don't you come up with data,
What percentage of General,ST, SC, OBC,MOBC are literate . And what percentage of General,ST,SC,OBC,MOBC age holding government jobs. PERCENTAGE Economy status of general,SC,ST,OBC,MOBC.
@@pradipyein2587 ALL YOUR POINTS ARE POINTING TOWARDS ONE THING THAT IS RESOURCES .....
Reservation should be one basis of RESOURCES NO ONE IS DENYING THAT
And should be till UG only not in PG OR FOR LIFELONG OR SHOULD BE GIVEN TO ONE GENERATION ONLY
If Modi bans this system, then I will vote for him forever
Others would stop voting , so i doubt any politician would do ☹️.
@j_t well i hope before he retires he do that.
I hope he does that.... I wish...
No political pary has guts to do this
Modi is one of them.he has extended it for another 10 years.
The reason why India has the worst beurocracy in entire Asia. Because here people are selected not on the basis of their merit but on the basis of their caste.
Sare beurocrats reservation wale hai bas 10% hi merit dhari hain India mai hai na 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Reservations must end
Nah
Reservation is the only reason Indian talent goes to Western countries.
Definitely you score a 250 in NEET PG and see students who scored 5000 go to better colleges .. so the other option is try other countries.. in the end mediocrity breeds mediocrity
Given a chance even a reserved category student will also go to abroad
@@baburaobean3232 Its better if SC STS are back ward and there population is 75 cores out of 125 ... ...costing total 75 cores and say bye bye to this reservation for ever ....I am not saying don't compensate them but in different way not ...with key positions leading by talent less and spine less people this would hamper India Governance
Mujhe toh laga general category sirf twenty five percent hai bhai
@@richasharma1888 actually politician's showing arrogance and the victim card you want next generation to carry on ? This people have pleasure in carrying social injustice and victims cards ? You don't want to settle the matter right now ? If you think twice Iam offering an solution ? life time solution
2.3k dislikes by children of doctors/judges/IAS/IPS/MLAs/MPs etc (selected through quota) who still want reservation even toh their parents come in top 0.5% of Indians and they have all the facilities which we common man can never think of🙏
People already placed 10m ahead in the 100m race will not understand poor people behind them.
@@risirisinath caste system is not based on finance. Period.
Reservation is doing severe injustice to all those deserving candidates.
@@Uniknown121 No
@@Uniknown121 NO...... CASE on point 2016 UPSC CSE topper Tina Dabi, belongs to SC Category, her father is an IAS, she relied on her category cutoff to go through prelims that year.
That,s why ..general category students leaving India.. ex sundar pichai
7.5 lakh students go abroad every year . Majority don't come back.
Let the Govt give 100 percent reservation as merit would have no value for young students
Modi raised the Medical quota to such extent that a general category average kid can't dream to be doctor anymore.
It has become next to impossible to become a doctor from the General caste. General caste students are becoming increasingly dejected. This will have severe social, psychological and moral implications. India needs best doctors and not mediocrities.
It wasn't all sweet even before.
@Betelgeuse it has been for years, sadly.
Modi just increased it by 10% for financially weak "General Category"... I don't understand how you are blaming Modi for this.
Operation was successfull but the patient died.😂🤣 Doctors under reservation quota.
Finally a Indian media raised the real problem in this country.Thank you WION
Sabse zada corrupt log, tax chor or criminals general category se hote h. Baki sab imandari se kaam krte h qki unko bacahne wala koi ni hota.
Agar talent ki itni chinta h to management quota hata do.
Koi b news paper utha ke dek lena, sare scam, corruption krne wale general hote h.
Caste based discrimination band hoga tabi reservation pe discussion start hoga. Jinhe lagta h ki caste ab matter ni krti to apni behno ki shadi educated n high government post me lage sc st obc k ladko se kr do.
Ni kr skte to chup raho.
Reservation koi garibi hatao scheme ni h, ye hazaro Saalo se socially discriminated logo ko fair chance dena ka ek tarika bus h. Warna general wale khud ko ucha samajte aye h, wo normally kisi or ko age bandne hi ni dege kabi.
Or agar itna hi chinta h to garibi hatane ki scheme lane bol de.
4 din phele up ke hospital me 13 bache maar gye. Uspe zimedaar 4 general category ke doctors hi h.
Not Indian media
WION is international media
@@bhaijiimpwale2942 hey, if you can't compete without the help of reservation despite having it for multiple generations, most would consider you incompetent.
Typical upper caste media
@@jeetkumarchittoria9713 saying truth is upper cast media🤔
When 64% of your jobs and top institutes are reserved this is bound to happen. Last year in the civil services there were around 320 seats left for open competition. Mind you this is open which means all obc,sc,st etc everyone can compete. This is the so called elitist exam which selects all ias,ips etc. With around 6 lakhs appearing for the exam look at the chance of making it through
@Mehaboob khan what ? Majority of reserves don't appear in open category? Really, any reserved category student who gets under AIR 50 applies under open category.
@@abhinavpratapsingh8431 and they block the open seat they don't have to pay the fees yet they block the general seat
All political parties are promoting reservation & now a days Congress crosses all limits☠️☠️☠️.
Wish the politicians in India have the guts to look into this issue with rationality... Fact is rich students from reserved category are now milking the reservation game.... The real unprivileged one's are left out.....
politicians cannot do so, a mere supreme court judgement on anticipatory bail caused riots, you think any government can even think about removing it?
But isnt it the same for literally every other category too? ... The richer exploit??? So then give preference to poorer section across all categories
@@77ranjanis62 for that there are poverty alleviation schemes why reservation then?
So true... Reservation should be one time benefit ..not be allowed for generations
@@prakhar6549 Reservation is not a poverty alleviation program
Finally Media is raising right question🙋... Pls carry on. We together need to end this biased approach.
Need some other major media houses to come forward
It won't be easy though.
It's not foreign media. It's totally CASTEIST INDIAN MEDIA led by CASTEIST PALKI SHARMA UPADHYAY who btw needs 2 brahmin surnames for herself. In one point she says that progressive countries like Norway has 40% reservation for women & that's good but caste based reservation is archaic as she with her casteist mindset can't tolerate lower caste people reaching good positions. This is the level of dumbness of this anchor.
@@srijandas1450 if she points out valid point she becomes dumb. What a hypocrisy
Gender based and caste based reservations are completely different.
My OBC friend called me an idiot not to take up the USA visa when he is there already. He claimed that India is not a place for forward category anymore 😞😞
Reservation is a really big problem of modern india
As a wise man had once said, "We are a country of the reserved ones, not of the deserved ones".
BJP has increased reservation to an all-time high and even crossed the Supreme Court quota of 50%. BJP hatao desh bachao.
Stop calling yourself a wise man ok Indian doorboy 😂😂😂😂
If Modi takes reservation out of India who will vote for him? This may become a plus point for congress to take out Modi government. That's not an easy job until congress vanishes out of India
Were we not having reservations in ancient times where only Brahmins could study and other have to follow the occupations of their ancestors. Why were the deserved ones neglected then ?
@@gmchander142 do you know the history of our country ancient education system, your comments are showing that you don't know the history of our country
Reservation has been haunting my dreams since childhood. And i am literally tired of it ..Thank you Palki....You spoke my heart
Same bro 😪 😕
भाई तू दलित बन जा भंगी या चमार का सर्टिफिकेट बनवा ले,या दिव्यांग बन जा
@Siddhartha dash ews waloo ko vhi to 10% reservation mila hai
Only 2% is gov job but remaining 98 % is private job
Indian army , navy and airforce does not have concept of reservations
@@memematerial4205 i support reservation in jobs but badhiya educational institutions mai dikkat hai lekin agar seat badha de toh thik hojaiga
Greatest achievement in India is, LEAVING INDIA & SETTLING ABROAD.
lol its funny to me how govt. is discriminating against general people for being more capable, more civilized, more intellectual and more deserving while these are the people who are the cream of a nation, experts in their fields and would do wonders for nations development 🥴
And it you speak anything against it, they begin with their "saar you didn't let us drink water" rant. It's funny, the government is doing every possible thing they could to kill merit. Mfs increased reservations to 80 percent somewhere lol
Hats off to this lady who finally spoke about reservation in postgraduate medical fields..
No reservation they are killing merit and country.
By privatisation only this will stop no govt has guts to do it.
@@edge4367 manmohan sing gov did that but everyone was against him . Now modi is doing the same and everyone is against him now. But bjp will never remove the reservation system if they do they will lose half of their votes same goes for all the political parties in India
Ya really amazing yr m about to give the pg exam and this thing makes one anxiety
Shivi Jain u have to understand in those era people from FC were only made to study medicine and other high professional courses. Also people from the upper middle class in urban can afford high class trainings from coaching centers and can afford higher education. So the main agenda of reservations is to provide equal opportunities to all the communities from all the nuke and corners of the country. So, even when u apply for any courses u going to compete with the candidates from the communities in your category and not from others.
That's a brave subject. No politician or political groups even dare to say anything against reservation. The only answer seems to be "Privatization".
The moment they open their mouth, there goes their next election. Politicians will die a thousand deaths, before giving up their seat.
You can do privatisation of govt jobs ..but what about govt colleges ?what about the reservation there ?the iits nits medical colleges…i dont think they will ever become pvt ..else there will be a lot of fees hike …there has to have something else in these insittuions rather than privatising them …
Answer is annihilation of caste
Caste can never be annihilated …and nvr will be ..its better to educate people and provide all of them with equal opportunites ..at every level ..education should be free and schools should be top class with all eduxation facilities ,,,,that is the things tht needs to be done ,.but no politician would do tht …else they will lose their vote bank if evryone. Gets. Educsted
Caste can definately be annihilated. Politicians won't annihilate caste 'cuz of their vote banks and upper caste won't annihilate caste 'cuz its their identity and also 'cuz that will require removal of caste from religious texts.
This is degrading our Country and the very reason we General Category are leaving this Country to die in the hands of it’s Constitution Makers. Let them be doctors due to reservation but they won’t be able to treat their own and die their own death same way. We ll choose a country that values.
Leaving this damned country soon because of reservations. Let the dalits live in peace👍Brahmins and Kshatriyas deserve better abroad.
Caste system hatao desh bachao . if you want benefit convert into lower caste why ppl don`t say abolish caste system and give certificate of caste only Hindu problem will solve but nobody will talk right things
@@menPeopleunite how caste system is related to reservation
She is very brave in bringing this up. Let us share this video more and more
BJP has increased reservation to an all-time high and even crossed the Supreme Court quota of 50%. BJP hatao desh bachao.
Democracy doesn't work for poor and uneducated countries like 3rd world failed banana republic state India you know 😂😂😂😂
@@yangleezhao908 do u have brother or sister? because of 1 child policy
@@yangleezhao908 comment with your original account Abdul
@@yangleezhao908 CZcams is not banned yet?
UP is best example. Everyone wants govt job there because most of them get quota but don’t even think of private job because they can’t compete.
sweetheart, I agree with you about the quota thing, but when you are talking about removing quota we should also talk about how are lower caste people treated, will you treat those people equally? if you think yes ! then your point of view regarding quota is correct, but if you still look at maids and sweepers as lower that you , then that's a bit hypocritic ? isn't it ?
@@mayank0508 ok i agree with you i dont see ĺlower caste people as maids aor anything else but as equal to everyone but quota is just too much
@@mayank0508 reservation is ok but in field like medical why there is quota kisi ki jaan jaa sakti hai usse
@@Knowledgetherapy277 yeah exactly what i meant a person with higher score has more chance of saving a person than with less score
@@prabhdeepsingh1 abb kon samjhaye inhe
Reservation doesn't just affect govt jobs, it affects every citizen.....You have to trust your health in hands of quota doctors in hospitals.......
As someone who missed UGC NET for 1% while someone got it with marks 10% less than me, I'm not going to be sorry to hold grudge.
U deserve to hold a grudge but remember its going to do nothing ....my friend who was too from general category told me ...as a student id u want to succeed in an exam then do not think about the atrocities happening with you coz of no reservation ..instead think that u are getting more challenging task to beat the meritorious students .....so remember that u were just 1 % behind the most meritorious students of the country ...and thankfully the private sector recognizes merit and not reservation ...so lets keep our mind off this trash and let them eat what the sow now by overusing reservation
@@sukumarsawant you're right, I have faith in my own qualities. I can easily have EWS quota since my father is a retired government employee, and if I had it I would have passed the exam flying colours. The cut off for EWS was 6% less than what I have scored. But I choose to fight. I'll qualify the exam, it was my first attempt and I was youngest one there, as the others taking the examination said. But yup, it hurts a bit.
@@ihope2504 so do you hold grudge for all of those 6% less meritorious ews students?
@@sukumarsawant when 70+% of class 1 posts are occupied by generals,only 16% by obc, 7% by sc and 4% by St, what is your definition of Over Use of Reservation?
@@sidharthapatra4296 definitely I do. I can myself have EWS if I try. And if I had it I would have qualified (scored 18 marks or 9% more than EWS cut off). But I would rather fight in an open condition. And yeah in my field the reservation is 63% (SC+ST+OBC+EWS+PWD +TRANSGENDER) and the open category seats occupy only 37% of the total space.
Instead of reservation, more govt school must be opened offering free education.
@Ashish Kumar That's whar Saksham is talking , education means quality education that too state sponsored
@@Robin-il4ev he only stated free education not quality education. I dont know if this is the case in whole india but i have seen atleast 2-3 undeserving people who getting govt jobs just because of reservation with no motive to even actually put in hard work in job. When people like these are getting govt jobs how can you imagine the quality getting improved?
@@dynoarts5778 Free education too abhi bhi hai 🙄 .
No one comes in already open govt. schools. What is the benefit of opening more.
@@dynoarts5778 Reservation is not for those few people who do not work faithfully. It is for those people who want to work faithfully but they can't study for that like the students of upper castes as they economic background is soo poor. Even their ancestors didn't have that much money that upper castes have.
If you will calculate, you will definately find(even written in ncert school books) that majority of poor population in india belongs to the lower castes, then why should their studious students don't get reservation?
Even in upper castes, their are lots of students who just waste their parents money and don't study.
Regain your data!
OMG. cant believe wion did a video on this topic. No news channel has the guts to do the same. I bow before you Palki Sharma ! 🙏🏼🙏🏼🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥👌👌👌
Hats off to Palki Sharma Upadhyaya 💕
Palki just reads the news
I cleared JEE Mains and Advanced. Got merit scores. I was not selected because reservation gave ceats to reserved candidates. And bar for score was increased. Those reserved candidates who scored 1/4th of mine were selected.
Broo 😢💔
@@Allabovethesky reserved candidates get reserved seat,not your seat. If you failed,that's not their fault.
Why reserved seat when both are of same age ? they may have same economic situations>..tbh these things will never change and people having merits will be hired eventually ....also u wont understand the pain of a jee aspirant ....no more to argue ..we prove ourselves by merit....and no need to babbly of how u were opressed for 100yrs and deserve reservation coz my replies are off and u wont get any entertainment @@sidharthapatra4296
@@sukumarsawant
@sukumarsawant reserved seats are reserved or Secured because if they are not, they will be snatched by the forward caste people in power. Education and employment are fundamental rights. But for some vulnerable community especially in this country, it's not possible to exercise these fundamental rights without the rights being secured constitutionally. What a shame.
U don't want to compete U want to simply cry
That's why people who leave India never cone back! Reservation itself a discrimination but this is allowed in a so called country where any kind of 'Discrimination' is strictly prohibited 🚫 What kind of logic is this ?!
She has not touched one very important point. Once a person or generation gets the benefit of reservation, the next generations continue to get the benefit as their birth right depriving the real needy people from the same reserved categories.
Yes u r right ... Wion need to pay attention to this too
Sabse zada corrupt log, tax chor or criminals general category se hote h. Baki sab imandari se kaam krte h qki unko bacahne wala koi ni hota.
Agar talent ki itni chinta h to management quota hata do.
Koi b news paper utha ke dek lena, sare scam, corruption krne wale general hote h.
Caste based discrimination band hoga tabi reservation pe discussion start hoga. Jinhe lagta h ki caste ab matter ni krti to apni behno ki shadi educated n high government post me lage sc st obc k ladko se kr do.
Ni kr skte to chup raho.
Reservation koi garibi hatao scheme ni h, ye hazaro Saalo se socially discriminated logo ko fair chance dena ka ek tarika bus h. Warna general wale khud ko ucha samajte aye h, wo normally kisi or ko age bandne hi ni dege kabi.
Or agar itna hi chinta h to garibi hatane ki scheme lane bol de.
4 din phele up ke hospital me 13 bache maar gye. Uspe zimedaar 4 general category ke doctors hi h.
@Average Joe tum jeso ko apni caste k karan room rent pe lene ki prblm ni hoti.
Hume hoti h. Ye bus ek example h. Varn vyavasta k karan or jatiwadi mansikta k karan humare sat jan bhuj ke bedwav hota h. Interview me kaam no dete h
Tum khud kch pado iss bare me. Tab samaj ayga
@Average Joe well said 👏👏
This is critical, I too have commented
"He belongs to the General category, Obc, sc and St"...... Yesterday it was the Caste system but today it is the Reservation system which is dividing India...
Reservation is because of caste system... If u people are able to vanish castes and caste based inequalities from villages to every area in India..then caste based reservations will get vanished
@@nikhilwankhade4634
Caste based discrimination does not exist for, say, a doctor. Why should he get a reservation? Why should his children get reservations? Yes, it should be caste based, but people above a certain income should also be cut off.
@@nikhilwankhade4634 both are discrimination in their own way
Reservation is made for upliftment of backward class causes by caste discrimination
But today reservation is also became a caste discrimination system because it uses the caste to reserve which is actually a discrimination
@@kakalimukherjee3297 firstly reservation policy is not a poverty removal scheme....and EWS is for those general public who have low income they can apply now...
@@nikhilwankhade4634Wankhade then justify caste-based reservation. support reservation (up to 20%) on financial basis not on caste basis.
Yes, reservation should be scrapped, but only when, when we see upper caste people cleaning sewages. Then we can say India has changed.
Or when we can lower caste lazy and incompetent PPL come and fight without reservation 🤭🤭
India has 65% of reservation 😂😂😂. This means, out of 100 seats, 65 seats are taken by the people who don't deserve it/ worth of it
"Certain seats have become 'UNTOUCHABLE'."
True to the point words.
Ya you can give that terminology to that becz that what you have been feeded
Yar saheebola
@@user-pr8nq1zl5z aagaye sc/st🤣🤣
@@stardust3511 hann bro 🤣🤣🤣
Yeah you are true the 50% seats reserved for Brahmin and upper caste has become UNTOUCHABLE
Once a person has used a "reserved quota", his/her descendants must automatically be ineligible for any further SC/ST quotas. Meritorious students from still truly disadvantaged classes can be provided all educational/hostel facilities (at public expense), so that they can study as comfortably as their peers, of higher social status, but the entrance-level scores at medical, engineering colleges should not be lowered. If exams are held only with an anonymous roll number, the possibility of favoritism can also be eliminated: that'd be a real level playing field for all.
The problem isn't reservation, it's the caste system, easy to call reserved when she itself wouldn't leave her caste tag would she? I am general, the kind of disgust people feel on SC/ST is dumb, the EWS, OBC etc are all reservations only, why is that people see the 20% of the seats they get as a problem despite MOST SEATS not getting filled. All you circus clowns and right wing aholes talk about equality, what equality are we talking about? Everyday ppl get killed for caste, how r u going to solve it? What even is caste? Awesome, please keep talking about unreal problems, let's not address the elephant in the room, the caste system, this same woman said woman's reservation should exist. By the same logic, why? I see a lot of women do well in life, why should they? See this is the issue, you don't address a system, you address opportunities in the system
If you had actually watched movie like jai bhim you would know that those tribes were discriminated despite the fact that they didn't even have Ration cards , let me explain because you clearly don't have the intellect to understand. But that also meant they didn't have a community certificate, they were killed brutally and still harassed to this day. Do you think the community certificate was the reason when they don't even have one, you guys are FOS
@@yethir7327 How is reservation a solution to anything that you mentioned above? We should definitely enable them and provide them all the possible facilities at public cost however reservation doesn't solve any problem rather increased social divide. Everyone is demanding reservation, there will b a time when only Brahmins will be left out and then they will also start demanding. Reservation doesn't work in the long term period. Finalise a time line and phase it out.
@@Prat2023 no it doesn't, you say it like reservation is the cause to the equality conundrum, reservation is a representation tool, there is still not enough representation of the down trodden population, this country has 60% below or just above poverty line, the problem is that you need to be concerned more about lack of opportunities than reservation, the problem isn't 20%of seats, it is the abysmal number of opportunities for most people. EWS and OBC are reservations, I do not understand why none of the people here say those are wrong, how is 8 lakh per annum economically poor when only 0.5 % india earns more than 8 lakh per annum, is this what you call "economically backward"m
@@yethir7327 I don't support any form of reservation including OBC reservation. In terms of representation in politics is concerned there is some merit to having certain seats reserved fot SC/ST. However in terms of education and govt jobs there shouldn't be any place for reservations. There should be constructive tools like additional classes/reduced fees etc at public costs.
Best example was IAS Tina daabi for her current marks her ranking will be around 390 to 430 but she got 1st rank because she belongs to SC even though her parents are rich. I have small doubt about her sister also but I don't know her marks.
Mandbuddhi jiske bare me baat kar rha hai reality to jaan le.
Can you score even that much?
@@aradhyasalve and those who scored more than her what about them? they did scored more than her
the only thing about Tina Dabi was that in UPSC prelims she benefitted from SC category cut off mark but in final result she had first rank because she did really well in UPSC Mains and personality test which is more difficult than UPSC prelims and rank is not given based on caste but based on marks.
@tiger9lily She didn't harm any general caste candidate but harm to a poor SC candidate
But you don't want to say that
I'm a beneficiary of OBC quota in Undergraduate. That time as a 12th std student I didn't have any understanding about caste system. In school Many of my friends were from unreserved category and we still stay as besties forever. But I saw their dreams crushed into dust because of this quota system. I finished my UG and made sure I enter Post-graduation only under unreserved by working so so hard. It made me respect myself. And when I looked at my intelligent unreserved friends, they left this country and living happily in a foreign nation. I can't imagine what they would have gone through. Some stayed back and still struggling. This is new - inequality system. I will never ever utilise quota system in my life and I'll make sure my future generation will excel being unreserved.
Person like u are needed in every nook and corner of this country
Thank you so much. Thank you so much. Really can't thank you enough for having such a mindset.
@@chandrayeedey7462 That's supposed to be a normal thought process for every one. Nothing extraordinary. So pls don't say thanks. 👍🏼
Though your intentions are right, but even that doesn't help us, but harma us more. As that 1 precious open seat is taken by a category individual and his empty seat is made available to his own category person with a lower rank.
So it's better for us if you opt your own category seat.
@@Skinsalus Open category is for everyone and I chose to give up my caste identity. I don't want to belong in a reserved category because I know what I'm capable of. One should see it like, one precious seat taken by a deserved individual and not a reserved individual.
Finally someone is bold enough to speak on this topic...
Hats off to WION👍👍👍
BJP has increased reservation to an all-time high and even crossed the Supreme Court quota of 50%. BJP hatao desh bachao.
Democracy doesn't work for poor and uneducated countries like 3rd world failed banana republic state India you know 😂😂😂😂
@@yangleezhao908 atleast we are not hiding our asses to type the comment on youtube.... India will not be lectured on democracy by Chinese people plz
@@codejunkes4607 be more louder I can't even hear you.
@@yangleezhao908 apne hi comment ko like karta hai tu
India will RIP and go backward with these reservations system continued indefinitely.
I got 452 in NEET UG in 2019 as an general category.. Lost the govt seat by 1 mark... And many people who were SC, ST and OBC got govt seats just with 350 marks... Made me suffer a lot!!!
Really disheartening to hear this😑😖
OMG 😣🙏
How are you doing right now..?I hope u are studying medicine
It is sad to hear about it. But brain drain is major bug which is eating India's development and for yourself and family it is better to move abroad for better life and better opportunities
Sad to hear ☹️
*She could speak any language but she chose to speak FACTS....!*
The system is designed for equality but it's promiting Inequality.
Thank you WION.... *"JAI HIND"*
Please don't blame reservation system for the feeling of caste that exists in our society motivating descrimination towards lower classes. It's purely because of caste based pride that people have. Unfortunately we are talking about removing reservation system without understanding the root of the idea of reservation that Dr. BR Ambedkar gave. It's not just economical upliftment of an upressed class but social upliftment. Have we achieved social upliftment of these classes yet? Is there nowhere where people carry pride against their so called caste? While these Illness still exists , people should still raise their voice against removing caste based pride in the society, social harmony, before having the courage to remove reservation system.
Social harmony should be a prime concern over wealth of a country. A rich nation with ill social condition is a waste achivement, sickness to mankind.
@@erenyeager098 I agree with some of your points too. But just look at the comments section you will see the hatred towards a class that has suffered and still suffering social inequality and injustice.
Those who really have that courageous to raise their voice against reservation in this country must first raise against social injustice and agianst the pride over one's caste which is in no way kind to humanity.
@@erenyeager098 and brother when you think you know about Indian culture and Indian history, how can you presume ambedkar had no knowledge about Indian culture and Indian history come on brother you are being insanely prejudiced.
For your knowledge I am a core patriot of my culture and Indian history, I read Gita, I am well aware of my religion. Anyway brother since you seem reasonable, just try to read, know about inequalities that still exists in our country (not just inequality in seats and promotions). Many people start raising their voice when a problem hits their home, while they keep quite when thousands of other houses face thousands of other problems. We all must have the courage to speak up for problems that others face too.
Social injustice is a serious social evil, sickness of mankind. Which hasn't been addressed or realised even today.
Where was your comment when a dalit girl was raped and killed only because she was a dalit girl? Where was this comment when untouchability among indians was active back in days?
@@erenyeager098 imagine you being told you are inferior because you were born in a certain community. Imagine that being written into your very dna by virtue of it being passed on for generations. Imagine you having to look around before whispering im a dalit. Imagine covering in shroud and that becoming a part of your psyche like your second skin. Imagine being made to feel ashamed even though you are a human being like everyone else. That sense of helplessness, the question of why was i born this way. Nobody apart from a lower caste person can understand this. Im not a dalit but i have witnessed a prominent rich dalit politician friend of my father refusing to come to a function at our house and eat because ..... well its been etched into his dna that he shouldn't eat with the rest. He has money but he still feels inferior because he is made to feel that way at every step of his life. Reservation is to give him that status and empowerment. Till when? you ask. Till the day you marry a girl without bothering she is a dalit and till the day you willingly get your daughter married to a dalit boy (if she so desires) without a second thought. That is a metric for equality imho.
Reservation for privileged families in SC, ST, OBCs must be stopped.
@@aryamayugankar759 most controversial
Plz correct ,OBCs have also economic barrier of 8 lakhs income just like Generals for being in EWS.If an OBC person's parents income in more than 8 lakhs,they r in general category.
Not sc st. But anyone who are not privileged
@@abhishekraj5187 if the parent works in organized sector and monitored income (basically gov job) then it is apply to them, if they work in own or private sector , if in comapnies then it is also apply, if they work in unorganized sector say shops or has own business then it is not no matter how much they earn , as falsified documents are made.
So upper caste can again discriminate against lower ?
Reservation is one of the major reasons why our talents are going outside of the country. We need to rethink about it.
Exactly this is one of the main true reason why our talents wants to go outside
@@apurva.parida 85000 MBBS seats are there but lakhs of aspirants. Even without reservation many lakhs will not get a seat and will go to Russia or China. How reservation is responsible? False allegations.
False Allegations...
@@sushilkumaryadav9737 exactly.
I support reservation.🚩
Let me tell you the real story. My batchmate got admission based on caste reservation with 60% marks in engineering college where I struggled inspite of having 80+ did she deserve the reservation? Definitely not. Why. Because her father was mechanical engineer graduate from IIT Bombay. While my dad couldn't even complete hua graduation due to financial background. This is just one example
When an Govt. Gazzeted officer daughter from reserved caste got seat in IIT Seat with no idea what's electromagnetism in physics her score in jee advance is very less than me, makes me depressed who scored 105 marks in jee advance in open category studying 10 hours a day...makes me leave the country and shift to other countries by hook or kook by taking bank loans
Hook or crook
I feel you bro . You should also take all your friends along with you. US is waiting for your arrival .
@@MCSE-cz2vd i don't have financial capacity to go abroad for masters
Common getting in IITs is really tough even for reserved categories. She might have left the electricity and magnetism portion entirely.
@@pandeyom6877 she got half of my score,so do u think still she is eligible
Reservation should be based on economic basis...and should be updated every 5 years or so.
Yes totally agree🙏🏽🙏🏽
@@user-wj3nf5qo7p and only one generation should get reservation
Yes
Nope, no reservations.. help with scholarships, not reservation, again that will create similar problems... I belong to EWS, but I support financial help than reservation. That way, always those deserving will get the equal opportunity.
Nope, not on an economic basis. Will you give a beggar a job? It should not even exist in the first place.
After Arun Shourie wrote his book “Falling Backwards “, criticising reservations, you are the only other journalist who has spoken about the evils of reservations. This is a major cause of India’s mediocrity. Politicians of every single political party are guilty of perpetuating this evil system. Your boldness is laudable.
More than 2000 years not equal to 75 years
@@AJ-ru7ub so what do you want another 2000 years of reservation?
Central government employees 2019-2020
SC/ST/OBC POPULATION - 70%
SC/ST/OBC EMPLOYEES - 44%
GENERAL POPULATION - 30 %
GENERAL EMPLOYEES - 55 %
SOURCE - DEPARTMENT OF PERSONAL AND TRAINING REPORT (2019-2020)
Group A post general category employees more than 60%(IAS, IPS,IFS etc)
I don't want 2000 years of reservation atleast the time equal the gap. Then the time will came to remove the reservation
I appreciate WION for having the spine to say that...
Phele caste based discrimination n violence ke khilf bolne ki spine laa
Sabse zada corrupt log, tax chor or criminals general category se hote h. Baki sab imandari se kaam krte h qki unko bacahne wala koi ni hota.
Agar talent ki itni chinta h to management quota hata do.
Koi b news paper utha ke dek lena, sare scam, corruption krne wale general hote h.
Caste based discrimination band hoga tabi reservation pe discussion start hoga. Jinhe lagta h ki caste ab matter ni krti to apni behno ki shadi educated n high government post me lage sc st obc k ladko se kr do.
Ni kr skte to chup raho.
Reservation koi garibi hatao scheme ni h, ye hazaro Saalo se socially discriminated logo ko fair chance dena ka ek tarika bus h. Warna general wale khud ko ucha samajte aye h, wo normally kisi or ko age bandne hi ni dege kabi.
Or agar itna hi chinta h to garibi hatane ki scheme lane bol de.
4 din phele up ke hospital me 13 bache maar gye. Uspe zimedaar 4 general category ke doctors hi h.
@@bhaijiimpwale2942 please limit the whatsapp knowledge to yourself
@@bhaijiimpwale2942 mjhe bs 1 baat btaa india ka konsa institution yeh list/ index nikaalta hai, jaah btaata h iss category ke logo ne itna corruption kiya!. 😂😂 jaah se tune data liya hai !. Curious to know 😂
@@abhishekjoshi748 arey merit dhari, news paper pad liya kr daily.
Usme culprit konsi caste k h dek lena. Mp vyapam scam me sab log general category k t for example.
Sare Business man tax chor hote h. Moslty general category ke.
Atlast somebody talked about this. Atlast someone has gathered all that courage !!!! Big respect.
😀 It takes no gutts to discuss poorly researched pieces like this one.
Please don't blame reservation system for the feeling of caste that exists in our society motivating descrimination towards lower classes. It's purely because of caste based pride that people have. Unfortunately we are talking about removing reservation system without understanding the root of the idea of reservation that Dr. BR Ambedkar gave. It's not just economical upliftment of an upressed class but social upliftment. Have we achieved social upliftment of these classes yet? Is there nowhere where people carry pride against their so called caste? While these Illness still exists , people should still raise their voice against removing caste based pride in the society, social harmony, before having the courage to remove reservation system.
Social harmony should be a prime concern over wealth of a country. A rich nation with ill social condition is a waste achivement, sickness to mankind.
@@trilokg4123 but what about the deserving students. And i think your an ST Or Sc.
@@mugambo5505 brother why should that matter if I belong to upressed classes SC or ST, does it make my point invalid?
All I am saying is that feeling of caste or pride over caste that motivates descrimination towards the lower class is the real evil our nation is facing even today. We have a problem in our house we worry we raise our voice and stay mute over the problem that is existing from decades in somebody else's house? Come on brother let us understand the real problem and act against it, not just fight for our problems while we don't care to even study or know problems that many houses in this country face in the name of caste.
Pride over caste, that every house embraces is a threat to society not reservation. Society should achieve social harmony over economic luxury.
Social justice should be considered first over economic justice. That's what uplhelds humanity.
@@trilokg4123 agreed!!!
The first example of inequality is when the students passes 10th exam and then realizes different cut offs based on caste. Even good friends become enemies due to this caste based system. Instead it should be on family income based, but who cares ? Atleast thanks WION for taking this long awaited issue on board for discussion.
End casteism, End reservation!
@@sushrutjadhao8495 end discrimination, end casteism
@@sushrutjadhao8495 casteism is alive because of reservation
Article 14 15 16 17
Sc st act
There is so much to end casteism
Caste based politics
Caste based reservation are there too
But nothing for the generals
@@sushrutjadhao8495Reservation introduced me to the caste system.
I don't feel like staying in this country because I am not treated equally. I was not given equal opportunity.
Does this sound similar to what we all cried before independence?
Politics is thriving on caste based division..
Its true
I just experienced this after neet results. This is injustice against us.
Same, I want to leave this country as well. I am a dalit and this country is grossly casteist.
Same. I also wanted to leave this Country and settle in European country
Finally you covered it wion . Students and the young generation hate the caste system and the reservation system .
Those who hate caste system mostly are those who enjoying being in reserved category
Go marry an uncivilized junglee tribal if you don't like the caste system.
@@son_of_chowdary2858 I belong to that "reserved category " and while it does have advantages ,I have seen general category students struggle like hell to get into iits and aiims just becuz they belong to certain caste . Reservation should be there where needed . It's not needed in cities
@@son_of_chowdary2858 tf do you even mean lmao
@@AnonymousAlien2099 anything for quota innit
Oh where do I start!! Ok I'll choose the hits of my career:
1. I scored 695 out of 800 in PMT exam back in 2010. Needless to say I didn't get any mbbs seat whatsoever. While an ST/SC had to score just 450 to get a seat in the best mbbs college in our state.
2. Now that I was forced to choose other healthcare field, one of my best friends (Same social status as our middle class family) from school got admission into IIT owing to his reservations. Don't get me wrong, I don't blame him for the country's poor policies but some years back he got a _EXTREMELY_ good paying job and bought a ravishing car. He got married, and is now living a textbook happy Indian life. I just bought a second hand scooty and can't get married bcz no girl wants an underemployed boy.
I don't wanna point fingers but I would clearly blame the reservations.
3. I just found out that our profession is in HIGH demand in developed nations. I _choose_ to leave India and get settled there. Atleast my childern will not face such shit there.
_Thanks India for giving me a reason to leave. Now when you complain about brain drain, keep me in mind._ 🙏
This doesn't end here , after this his children will also get the same reservations while your protest would be called out as privileged opinion
Leaving nation is not answer.
If everybody will leave then who will change thinks .
Yes I agree with thinks reservation is killing talent but there will always be demand of engineer and Doctors in some country but that's not why you should leave country then how will nation develop.
So much injustice....merit seems to have no place
@@sandeeptiwari7157 tbh if this guy doesn't leave India, he won't get the life he deserves..... it's been so many years since people are protesting against reservation and literally nothing's happening, I have seen my brother suffer infront of my eyes because of this, all his sc st obc friends from rich families are now in a better place than him....... Same things happened with me aswell... I went to take admission in a prestigious government school a few months back, they had 95 Percentage cutoff for general and only 80 percentage cutoff for reserved category..... My life would be over before the system even starts to change and that's why I have already started to learn German because I intend to go to Germany for further studies and stay there for the rest of my life........
@@hank561 Its your choice brother I don't to dominate your choice by saying your wrong or write .
As you said it is true that getting sets in government college is almost impossible and even there are lot of students from OBC ,SC,ST community how average and who score 80% and still didn't get sets .
Reservation is killing talent albut at the same time overpopulation also exist it is also hurting ,less number of private colleges and schoolship for talent is also less but all this need to be talen down by people itself.
For you go to Germany and learn and earn some and come back if possible if you think for the nation etc.
Or else you can stay there .
Germany has its own set of problem too may be rascism or something else I am not sure but that's how every country is.
Leaving your country for 1st world country is like leaving your parents for a sexy girlfriend.
Best of luck but if you think your situation is critical or its life and death situation then leave india.👍
Bangladesh dismissed all the reservation in govt jobs after fierce protest from the University students.
Ironically Femals students protested against reservation despite ths fact that they enjoyed 10% reservation.
why not we become bangladesh too?! just gotta pump those rape numbers right?
@Reyhana Zia thanks for reminding me that why left India. i never said anything about reservation( i just mentioned how this person think Bangladesh is better than India so i just agreed with him!) but good that u just assumed that i am from some category that took advantage of reservation. This is prime example why both sides are at fault not only the one getting reservation
Dude i get reservation still i hate it to core. I faced no discrimination just bcoz my grandparent or their parents might have faced something i just get the cake oof others right? How us this justified. Well i still opt for reservation coz i dont want to take a UR seat and lessen your chances
@Reyhana Zia you Too got minorities quota and BJP government is working Uniform Civil code and indian muslims and Christian are alredy opposing It
@Reyhana Zia abe chumtiya ambedksr said it should be temporary but congress made it permanent ....get educated before talking nonsense .
And don't forget you too are enjoying minority quota even tho you people are second largest majority in india .
Only because of this reservation , who aren't getting a seat in prestigious institutions like IIT , NIT, AIIMS , genius minds of India is going out of India to study abroad , for jobs etc.
Thank you wion for this video.
according to your argument those who are getting admission from open category, might be ultra genius and should have made india a superpower by now.
@@SumantXD u better know that if one can get seat in Abroad he/she can easily get seat in India ( afcourse without Reservation )❤️
@@SumantXD correct !! If 100% is for general, then India might become a superpower by now. 65% reservation has eaten India up. And whatever India has achieved, it is because of hard work by general students.
@@epistimi5565 completely baseless argument, there's no reservation in sports, bollywood, judiciary, CA, private sectors, etc . still india is performing below average in these fields. btw check the name of all the biggest scammers in india's history and the category they belong, you will soon know who is the real destroyer of indian economy.
@@TarunTiwari108 what a foolish logic. That's not really true!
The only reason I am planning to leave India is this pathetic 70 years old reservation policy.
CANADA, UAE and EU countries are extremely good and lucrative options.
Good luck, fortunately they don't discriminate anyone based on their castes.
@Siddharth Suryavanshi mind ur language when u talk about India's forefathers. Also Canada has reserved 50% of its cabinet for women. In future it will come to jobs also. Think carefully before selection of ur other county. Best of luck.
Really???
Most of the indians leave India because of shittier economy, infrastructure,job oppertunities etc
@@anujpathak6327 So what if its a brahmin surname? what will it accomplish??
@@anujpathak6327 ya I know
Finally someone has raised our issue, it takes lot of courage & willpower to speak on negative effect and injustice of reservation, thanks a lot WION and Palki Sharma Upadhyay Mam to cover this.
Palki Sharma Upadhyaya take up issues for discussions selectively and still claims that the World is One - WION.
@@gmchander142 hypocrite understand nothing
@@gmchander142 Sc-St h kya tu 😂
@@ashishpradhan5436 Reservation is given on the data of 1931 census, more than 90 years old data is not accurate now.
@@ashishpradhan5436 In my district SC ST are more developed then all other sects. They are given all the privileges and facilities but still they spend it on alcohol and other wasteful things. It's time we start reservation based on economically weaker sects rather than the old conventions.
If a person once avails reservation, then he should be the last person to avail the reservation in his family i.e. his kids should lose reservation but not his brothers or sisters. This helps the real deserved candidate to get reservation so real upliftment of that particular community happens. How can a community develop if only few families again and again avail reservation?
Absolutely right Wish it gets implimented along with norms that could prevent financially well off people from using reservation for their benefit.
Sounds like a good solution
Yes, diversity indeed...
That’s a good idea
That why we have ncl category in obc. Obc whose income is more than 8 lakh won't be under ncl rather he will treated as general(creamy layer). But sadly this is not available in sc st quota.
Being a general male is the worst possible thing for an entrance exam
But is there any way we can change it.
@@mahendrakergaurav5867 privatisation, bussiness karo babu bhot paisa h
Exactly this happened to me, I've got 95%tile in JEE Main, my OBC friend(85%tile) my SC friend (92%tile) all three of us have same annual income but I'm waiting in councelling for a good college and the lattar have already got an IIIT Kalyani CSE and NIT Raipur CSE which closes too early for us open category students is this fair?
And even if I in college they both have enough funds to pay whole tution fees but there is a fee waiver for them but for us open category students paying full fee is the only option with no scholarships.
The system is rigged and needs a change.
i can understand.This, reservation is a hurdle for an all round development of our country and us individually.
ब्रो तेरे साथ बहुत नाइंसाफी हो रही है तूने EWS वाला सर्टिफिकेट नही बनवाया है क्या, चिल कर ब्रो को सब नीच जात वाले हैं तू ऊंच जात का प्राउड कर तू private college se भी बीटेक करेगा तो भी उनसे आगे जायेगा
@@urutiwari9044 ब्रो तू कैलाशा चला जा वहां कोई रिजर्वेशन नही है
2000 years of caste based discrimination cannot be cleared within 74 years. Better to remove the cast system.
I can feel you bro..I'm also victim of this reservations..
IAS officer who belongs to sc and st their children also get reservation quota..
Bro they are at creamy layer
Society failed them thus it should pay ------
Words of SC ( GRAND MINDS OF INDIA )...
Dabi family.
@@arshjordan5455 really dude?? So now u r saying it's the general that are benefiting from it?? What else?? Those who take reservation benefits are general disguised as SC ST... Blame the crime rate on them too.. Blame everything
Society failed them so they need it
@@arshjordan5455 MD medicime seat rank for reserved category is at 55k for a general category its around 4k .
Use brain to talk .
What a daring Wion , for discussion on such a sensitive topic with clarity😀
Dalits have been tortured by the ancestors of this anchor for the last 3000
Years and we assume that gap can be filled in 70 years
@@akshatkumar9032 i can understand ur lack of knowledge and british propoganda education with multiple bootlicking degreeessss
@@saikatsen8037 what I said is absolutely correct with no doubt and I'm sure you don't understand because you live in city where people don't care about cast. But you need to go to village to understand the situation
@@akshatkumar9032 Okay, for a moment I agree with you that caste system is relevant in villages but the million dollar question is how can Reservation help to end caste system? Reservations can help to change the financial status of a person. How will it raise your social status??? Even if you become a doctor or a Professor through reservations, still some sick mentality people will treat you according to your caste. Reservations can't help to erase caste system, only proper education and increased levels of awareness can help to eliminate Caste System. Reservations help to fuel Caste divide and fill the hearts of people with anger for unreserved categories
@@aryan_bhat so we need more creative and practical solution I agree
"Discussion on reservation in india produces more heat than light. "
- Shayad, RC guha
Uske naame me sach me shayad tha ?
Maybe Shubhra Ranjan notes 😎
Excellent Analysis. This issue must revisited.
Govt gets vote on this.. no govt has guts to reduce percentage reservation, let alone remove it.. sad state of affairs.. just like religion is the election card in Pakistan... reservation is in India..
@@ramv7314BTW Religion also plays major role in indian politics.
@@ramv7314 then we will lost talent permanently in India. No one young generation want to live this type of stupidity while western countries are encouraging them. This is the real reason why India lacks in defence industry. We have to buy so expensive weapons from other countries , even those weapons have some Indians hand with us or Europe tag.
@@lulu4494 but one more thing we need to finish is caste discrimination. In rural areas where lynching still exists how can we assume that equality can be ever brought
Reservation system can't be ended in India bcoz of Article 15. The best way to deal with this issue (legally) is to give reservation to all sections of society.
There should be reservation but not on the basis of caste , it should be on economical status and disability . There should be only EWS and PWD. The whole system needs reformation.
I agree to this point.
There should be no reservation, what so ever, the only criteria should be the merit.
Economic reservation can't address backward caste . backward caste people will be ignored and cornered.
Give reservation to whom so ever.. but the percentage of total reserved seats should be less then 30%
@@sanjanapatil1399 this is also good solution. Yess.
When I wrote MBA entrance exam ,the cut off was 60 marks ,but for sc and st it was 0.students who got 59 marks were not even eligible and the reserved category candidate were getting seats,now you can think what would be the quality of managers .My heart stops when I think of professions like doctors being churned out and how mediocre they might be.
Wtf? 0 really 😨 that will be like just go for exam and don't even answer anything u are selected
@@vedbhobe9420 yes the exam was for 2hrs and some students went out of the exam hall after 10min.when I asked how come they completed so early,then I was informed that they were sc st .they only needed to write their names and roll no correctly.,,
Wtf 😡
Challenge this matter in supreme court. Anyways supreme court is busy dealing with stupid ngo petition on environment vs national security.
A big reason for the almost total collapse of govt hospitals is the disproportionate presence of quota doctors as they can't compete in the private sector.
Why do politicians not get their surgery done from students who hv got admissions in quotas
Exactly. It'd serve them right and make them see what dealing with mediocrity feels like. When bridges collapse, buildings fall, it's the common man who're hurt, and not them. That's why they've no idea.
@@chandrayeedey7462 Bridges collapse due to reservation?? Due to political corruption or due to contractors...Chances are both belongs OC.
Not all general category student are the son of Einstein.... Grown up..... Upsc topper Tina Dhabi top the most difficult exam upsc and she is from sc category
@@TravelerBk90 yea stupid that's what the video is about and that's what we want for people to do things on their merit and not through reservation
Some people think marks make you better at something, clearly you don't have real world experience. If they can pass the course then they are surely well enough to do the work. This prejudice is the reason why reservation should exist.
Currently only 38% seats for General category in bank jobs in India. This is so frustrating.
That's on paper, it's more less
Not only seats fee for exams also we can't even compare
The Right to Equality......... A goddam joke.
Please check how much percentage of people come under general category
@@swathinagarajan13 so? You'll hire donkeys , just cut they're abundant and breed like rats ?
All GENERAL students know this properly, Sometimes we feel as minorities because of these. Give reservation for backward communities who need it, not to someone who is taking advantage of quota from 2-3 generations
you must understand what is equity and equality. Developed countries also have reservation acts for its black, Hispanic and native communities. Germany have reservations, England has reservations. These are reaffirmation actions. I don't see any problem in their development or economy or anything due to these reservations? Why the hell should India need to have a problem with this? More than 90% of SC/ST category people are poor and doesn't get the chance to have good education and opportunities. Reservation is their only chance to get these. It is not because those people are less talented or less smart than you, it is because the opportunity to get better education is less for them compared to you.
Wion is sponsored by BJP, whose main aim is to bring back casteism.
Consider this,
You belong to a higher class's, so consider yourself as a tall person. You can see a cricket match (oppourtunity) across the fence (you get prefered more because of your caste) because you are tall (social advantage). And a short person comes ( socially and economically backward SC, who when there is no reservation won't get a chance to see the steps of a school. It is not because he or she is less intelligent but the people will never prefer them due to low caste). He/ she will not be able to see the match because he or she lacks the resources to develop themselves to attain that level. If that person is given a stepping stone to stand so he can reach your level of height, then he can see the match. This stepping stone is called reservation.
You are projecting your anger onto SC/ST without any valid reasons.
You should know that when only 8 to 15% is reserved to SC ST which comprises about 50% of Indian population, about 55% is reserved to general category which only comprises about 23% of India's total population.
Don't be so ignorant and stupid.
@@btsimagine8186 My whole point was that people who belong to SC/ST or OBC categories and whose families are well above the Poverty line should be treated equal as the GENERAL people. Reservations should only be there to help people who really need it, otherwise its unfair.
For your other question, I have suffered a same incident where a classmate of mine got into NIT just because of his QUOTA and I couldnt make it even after having significantly higher score than him, he is from a well to do family, unluckily for him he couldnt do much in NIT and now works in Wipro for a measre salary
Democracy doesn't work for poor and uneducated countries like 3rd world failed banana republic state India you know 😂😂😂😂
@@btsimagine8186 I am in Germany..Studied here ...only judged by merit...Go and research more. Being a general merit student in India, I was always in disadvantage...Giving quota on the basis of economic situation is understandable but on the basis of what our ancestors did is idiotic ...And you assumed that all General students are rich!!
@Betelgeuse 99 % of people unreserved seats are open category
Wion touched the most sensitive topic of India.
Caste system in Hinduism. This is reality of India.
@@vijayjagadhane4896 nobody wants caste in this modern world. It is just politicians who divide In the name of caste .and irony is the person who is against caste system is talking about ban education for open caste .really such biased you are .
@@vijayjagadhane4896 caste is not even Hindi word
@@ojasvashishtha4453 caste is english term of jati df
"Reservation is harming India not helping it....."
सही कहा ब्रो रिजर्वेशन नही होता तो इंडिया वाले अबतक मंगल ग्रह पे घर बना लिए होते और अमेरिका पे कब्जा तो कर ही लिए होते अब तो EWS भी आ गया है अब इंडिया का क्या होगा ब्रो
@@saurabh2372 bhai humkonsa ews le rhe hai yeh saale rajniti hai tu mera bada bhai mujhe kuch lena dena nhi caste se nah caste ho na reservation
Reservation for equality is like F''ing for virginity
😂
.
😂😂
Hahaha bahot dank . Ironically bahot irony ho rhi
I got 1700 rank and i was not able to get admission. I felt sad when a student 13000 rank got admission for same course because he was ST .
😀
Thank uu great Indian education system 😊
Millions of Indians had to endure that same pain
I had the same situation with me.
I know what that feels like... My rank was 6k and I have seen people with 13k join better colleges.
Sad to hear 😭 even I missed an admission in a college of my choice due to reservation
Dalit Scholar Anand Teltumbde is of the opinion that caste based discrimination is a very recent phenomenon. It were the shudra landlords who oppressed and harassed the Dalits. But it is only the Brahmins who are made to feel guilty into believing that they were the real oppressors.