The problem I have with sailing is I feel it will take years of updates to meet people's expectations, I think it's a little out of reach for the devs but who knows
I agree, but also think it's a necessary evil. If they don't spend the required time we'll end up with a shit skill. They would need some way to procedurally generate new islands and obstacles.
Definetly this, Sailing could be great. Could. It is the most complicated to design, both for the game loop and reward incentives. Shamanism, as somewhat of an invention for osrs, is simpler, and the benefits from getting that high levels are obvious if it enables upgrading gear/tools/weapons a little. THAT would matter a lot. So much easier to balance: numbers up, numbers down. Sailing is lacking that incentive from the skill. They could offer near fossil island better afkable amonyte crabs spots, with more hp, extra rune dragons lair, green dragons dungeon in an isle near karamja, extra herb patches, extra traveling methods around the map. Locking more meaninful areas or training methods for fishing behind this skill would not feel great, but terrible. But then again, that's not as universaly appealing as adding stat bonuses to your gear setup or skilling tools.
@@PkPvre Coding the procedural generation wouldn't take that much time, it's much more about how it's being implemented and making sure it's fun content/good for the game.
Taming sounds like they renamed Summoning, and I wouldn't trust the devs to balance that right (they couldn't even do it in RS2). Sailing is a straight up meme. Shamanism sounds cool but I'm not sure the community would like it.
Taming being involved with combat is automatically a turn off. That will undoubtedly cause many issues. Not a fan of sailing, but it's better than messing with combat
Isn't it odd how even though you've "quit" the main game/mode, people including me, still value your input more than that of 99% of the other osrs content creators. I imagine it's a huge compliment to you.
He's part of the OG's and generally has a level head when discussing things. Only time he says anything questionable is when he's talking about not making things easier for newer players and being against most changes to skilling because he wants people to have to go through what he did.
@@thelegacyofgaming2928 it's not because he wants people to suffer. Thats some dumb reddit shit. He's against actual ezscape because the entire point of osrs is the grind. It's not meant for gamers who want a 50 hour experience with little tedium. There's every other game out there for them. This is a game about grinding. It's a relic from the past before micro transactions. Autumn elegy and other hlc players understand what makes osrs unique and great and they advocate for keeping that flavor.
I actually really dig the shamanism concept of tapping into some obscure spiritual force. People seem to hate the name but I'm actually a fan of the way it's laid out, and I think it would fit well into the game thematically. Lots of opportunity for quest/lore too. Impacting other skills and ruining records is always a bit cringe, but that's par for the course
I agree very much about the issues with sailing. As someone who sailed growing up there are genuine mechanics which should be recreated in the game. Wind, rigging, current, heading, swells, all of these things would take a lot of dev work to get right but it would be super fun to to learn in OSRS if they did it right. If there's no sailing theory involved in the mechanics they bring to OSRS then IMO it would feel like a minigame or like dungeoneering. Sailing IRL is extremely competitive and there's a huge community sailors. Every time I went sailing it starts with rigging based on the wind conditions, then you have to get out onto the water, navigate docks and tides. Then there's the actual sailing aspect, keeping the boat slat, fixing things that break, storing supplies, righting the boat after capsizing, all that stuff should be a part of it IMO and should give bits of EXP. Same thing for de-rigging and storing the boat (could pay NPCs or crew to do this). I just hope it not a "you board the boat and depart... *cutscene/minigame event happens*... navigation choice *** you arrive on a new island and boom thousands of sailing exp. Obviously opening up the map to many new things is what sailing offers, but that's more navigation. I want core sailing concepts to be shown in game!
I could see them going the direction WOW took with mounts for taming..other than unlocking a new area with ur pet or some stat boost, I see taming mainly being used to flex who has the rare stuff.
As much as it would be cool to see a new skill come into this game, I just don't trust Jagex to not pander to the extremely loud people on Reddit who are just gonna want the typical turn your brain off AFK fast XP skilling methods that give you tons of rewards too. They've already shown that if people scream loud enough on there they're bound to eventually be forced to listen. I don't see it turning out too well which is the only reason why I'm against any new skill. There's too much of a risk for it to negatively impact the game short and long term IMO.
@@SYG_Aegis Yea I’ve had no faith in that community for a long time, but the Tombs of Amascut meltdown they had after Jagex made balancing changes to prevent people from brute forcing through the raid with Ambrosia made me realize just how much of a lost cause they are. Its already extremely accesible yet these people unironically want to be able to farm the best money in the game in mid level gear without needing to actually learn the mechanics. Give me a break man. They give zero fucks about the health of the game which is why trusting these same people to help balance an entire skill is a hilariously bad idea. I’m already expecting the new prayer book from the upcoming DT2 to possibly destroy PVM. I thought most of the proposed prayers Jagex had in their dev blog were pretty well balanced and fitting for a high risk/reward prayer book. But nah, Reddit doesn’t want chip damage or any punishing mechanics. They just want pure DPS increase cause that’s fun, so Jagex is already reconsidering their version. Uggg.
I think even if sailing is just islandeering i'd still enjoy it if it's done well. im sure the training of sailing is navigating sail routes, and overcoming the struggles to actually GET to the island, but i almost feel like islandeering would be more fun even if its less "sailing".
If the island side of the skill was well thought out, id imagine there would be some really cool island locked series being rolled out which would be great for viewing.
My original thoughts on Sailing were that it would be Dungeoneering on water, but thinking about it more, its probably just going to be temple trekking on water. Which sounds even worse. Worst part is, I dont know that the other 2 are even any better.
We can't just keep introducing things which up the power level of characters without having anything to use them on. There simply is not enough dev time to introduce a level of content consistent with the power level of players without expanding content either sideways (skilling bosses, sailing etc.) or by just introducing stronger content. The problem with just introducing stronger content is that it's so difficult for the devs to balance correctly that it takes them years to release, and then go on to make it imbalanced in the future anyway (stronger items, new prayers, shamanism etc.). Shamanism sounds like a great way to introduce more power rather than the current method of just slapping down some more bosses that drop even better stuff, but the problem that just slapping down more bosses solves is that you need content to use that better stuff on. What did you do after completing CoX? More CoX. ToB? ToB. ToA? ToA. If there were sufficiently challenging content, Shamanism would be fantastic, but there isn't. Sailing, on the other hand, does what bosses do - creates its own content whilst also making new uses for old content. Taming at least tries to combat this problem by not making you stronger but by making your ability to get stronger easier whether that's by increasing trip times or some other method. If Shamanism went this route, I wouldn't really have a problem with it, though I'd still prefer Sailing due to it explicitly adding content to use old content on as well.
What i want most is dungeoneering , as for the 3 choices , im leaning towards sailing , as the pokemon skill doesnt intrigue me that much and shaman.. i think i'd like to see more before I even think about it
Sailing feels like it doesn't really do much beyond offer resource gathering, pets, maybe new travel methods. It's kind of like agility for macro travel whereas agility impacts your movement. I just can't see sailing going wrong. Sailing or shamanism.
a little ironic to focus on the potential harm sailing could have while ignore that taming and shamanism would introduce new "BIS" for literally every activity in the game with the pet abilities and gear augmenation/totems
Shamanism, to me, would be more interesting than prayer. I feel like prayer is the organized religion aspect of runescape and shamanism could be like the pagan varieties.
Bard would be cool. Sailing sounds like a minigame. Taming doesnt sound any better than pets. shamanism sounds like magic 2. Bard would be a unique skill. Craft instruments. play them afk for tips from npcs or something.
sailing exp should be given as a bulk exp drop like the end of wintertodt. You receive the sailing exp after completeting the mission (ex. getting to the end of a dungeon in an island). Sailing exp should be seen as a way to measure your prowess in completing missions, not as something that needs to be trained by literally "sailing"
Sailing sounds like Slayer for other skills. You get a task of "Go do this mission" which could include getting rid of some island orcs, fishing or hunting something and then you get XP based on completing your sailing mission. With some boat steering included.
@@zants_ doesnt even need to be part of a skill, we dont need skills to raise cats. although yeah, it'd be good to give people more ways to level up farming
@@thelegacyofgaming2928 who said it can't be used in combat? it hasn't been decided yet. they said right in the video that is one of the things we will vote on
sailing is just gonna be similar to slayer, you'll pick up contracts ranging from easy to hard, with masters based on sailing level, i.e tasks such as hunt x monster, or find x treasure in x region
Man you should make a HC when the auto-tele feature comes out. We know you crush skilling but your PVM excellency arc would break youtube tbh. whole community would love to see it!
Honestly I just don't want a new skill in the game. Shamanism and taming would both have massive implications in bossing and combat. Sailing really can not be done well in the game
Shamanism seems like a complete bait. Training method will be afk, and any buffs the skill creates can impact every single level you train other skills. Sailing has the ability to be actually engaging, and is somewhat limited to introducing new areas and items.
Taming should just be added to the hunter skill idk. Hunter is kinda meh and needs a rework. There’s only like 4-5 things to do (birdhouse chore, chinchompas, herbiboar or like implings or monkeys?) idk. As you get higher levels there’s like nothing really new to do.
as somebody who plays both games i have to say sailing looks the best for me. taming sounds to be basicaly PoF from rs3 which is part of farming not a separate skill. and shamanism sounds too much like divination. but what do i know, i just want something unique not a reskinned rs3 content
The theme of shamanism is bad IMO. Sorcery, Cursing: black magic to imbue tools, gear and do other stuff, not about a spellbook (just like runecrafting isn't about spells). Could be themed around mahjarrats, which, unlike tribal hippies, are pure hype lore wise. Enchanting/Bewitching: white magic, imbuing tools, gear. Cons: more boring, still better than tribal shit.
Sailing seems like the best fit for old-school. On top of that, it was rumored to release way back in the day, so sailing would have that nostalgia factor that the other skills wouldn't.
I would like to see a skill for like Artistry. Something like Mahogony homes + Giants' Foundry where you go around and create "art" (like paintings, custom armor, etc). As you level up, you can create player owned customized gear, custom art for your POH, etc. Or something like riding skill, that allows me to traverse the world at increased speed.
Sailing being like a modified Slayer for skills could be cool. Almost like a clue scroll effect, potential for artifact items. It's hard to imagine what sailing will do. Does the XP drop hit when a voyage ends and you've collected resources and whatnot? Who knows exactly, but it seems promising.
I feel like Jagex put Sailing with 2 weaker proposals because they really want Sailing. Jagex probably has a bunch of assets they created for sailing that they want to use. I would much prefer to have Bard as an option.
Sailing is the most interesting to me. It has the most room for expansion. Shaman is just more about weapons. We already have a power creep. Make more personalized stuff
Personally I’d like it if Jagex implemented something like inscription from WoW, where players can make scrolls that they can equip to give their character consistent permanent buffs
@@SYG_Aegis no they are not copy pastes they are not similar to summoning, it isn't a temporary companion, and we have great control over how it turns out. we can make the pets fight with us, but require food to heal, and we can make it so they die permanently and need to be bought back to live, and we don't have to have any inventory expanding pets ect ect
@@007kingifrit No interest in further discussing with you, when your entire response proves my point of calling you out of touch. If all you can name is Summoning as an example. Look into RuneScape 3 if you want to see what's happening to OSRS' direction.
All new skills are disgusting there is no point for them to exist in osrs, redditors with 1200 totals just want more "content" even though they interacted with less than 10% of what the game has to offer, they just hate the game and anyone that enjoys the game
Sailing: Sounds like temple trekking turned into a skill except with boats. Furthermore, it doesn't sound like you'll be able to interact with the rest of the game/world with the skill. Overall, sounds like a minigame rather than a skill. Not a big fan. Taming: Looks like an improvement from summoning while maintaining the benefits. Adds interesting abilities that'll likely be useful while training other skills. More interactions throughout the world. Sounds very solid, fits the concept of a skill, and has a lot of potential. Shamanism: Sounds by far the most convoluted of the 3. The core gathering aspect overlaps with crafting and rewards you with power creep on gear. The training aspect sounds like it overlaps with runecrafting. Overall, the skill sounds like it won't add anything other than powercreep on gear.
the only point im not a big fan of that you make is that IF you want 200m's its bad to have sailing give passive xp. there are probably less than 200 people that problem applies to and there are like 40 people that have 200m all already so meh.
@@AutumnElegy Bummer! i have been trying to work out a way to get a tiny client that overlays the main client i use. The work around i have is super jank and involves using an application called Deskpins to pin the window to the top
Borderless Gaming *might* have an option to resize the resolution of a window relative to its size change? Despite having the program, I haven't used it much. If not, I'm sure there's something out there that lets you do that. As for just making it borderless and floating: Borderless Gaming + Always on Top (PowerToys utility). There's likely freeware versions of Borderless Gaming as well, that's just the one I'm familiar with.
If shamanism comes out I bet more people quit the game than join it long term. Ill be unsubbing the day they decide to release divination and invention under the guise of shamanism. Great way to kill osrs.
Finally I can have an opinion on the new skill
Also if you vote Taming you are a furry 👍
@@kvatch agreed
yooo bo selecta hey :)
@@KempQ good evening sir
@@KempQ cheeky kempq on some random comment nice
Revamp shamanism to engineering.. is something i can get behind. Can be a dwarven/goblin type of connection there with dorgeshkaan orso
I have zero faith that the new skill will not be either completely useless or utterly damaging to the game as it exists
The problem I have with sailing is I feel it will take years of updates to meet people's expectations, I think it's a little out of reach for the devs but who knows
I agree, but also think it's a necessary evil.
If they don't spend the required time we'll end up with a shit skill.
They would need some way to procedurally generate new islands and obstacles.
Definetly this, Sailing could be great. Could. It is the most complicated to design, both for the game loop and reward incentives.
Shamanism, as somewhat of an invention for osrs, is simpler, and the benefits from getting that high levels are obvious if it enables upgrading gear/tools/weapons a little. THAT would matter a lot. So much easier to balance: numbers up, numbers down.
Sailing is lacking that incentive from the skill. They could offer near fossil island better afkable amonyte crabs spots, with more hp, extra rune dragons lair, green dragons dungeon in an isle near karamja, extra herb patches, extra traveling methods around the map. Locking more meaninful areas or training methods for fishing behind this skill would not feel great, but terrible.
But then again, that's not as universaly appealing as adding stat bonuses to your gear setup or skilling tools.
Then wait years for the skill to be finished. Not like there isn't content to do. Get your diary cape.
@@AImighty_Loaf as a maxed player with a diary cape, I would prefer to not wait years lol i’d prefer they get it right the first time.
@@PkPvre Coding the procedural generation wouldn't take that much time, it's much more about how it's being implemented and making sure it's fun content/good for the game.
Always appreciate your opinions on the direction the game is going in king
Taming sounds like they renamed Summoning, and I wouldn't trust the devs to balance that right (they couldn't even do it in RS2). Sailing is a straight up meme. Shamanism sounds cool but I'm not sure the community would like it.
Taming being involved with combat is automatically a turn off. That will undoubtedly cause many issues. Not a fan of sailing, but it's better than messing with combat
Isn't it odd how even though you've "quit" the main game/mode, people including me, still value your input more than that of 99% of the other osrs content creators. I imagine it's a huge compliment to you.
He's part of the OG's and generally has a level head when discussing things. Only time he says anything questionable is when he's talking about not making things easier for newer players and being against most changes to skilling because he wants people to have to go through what he did.
@@thelegacyofgaming2928 it's not because he wants people to suffer. Thats some dumb reddit shit. He's against actual ezscape because the entire point of osrs is the grind. It's not meant for gamers who want a 50 hour experience with little tedium. There's every other game out there for them. This is a game about grinding. It's a relic from the past before micro transactions. Autumn elegy and other hlc players understand what makes osrs unique and great and they advocate for keeping that flavor.
I actually really dig the shamanism concept of tapping into some obscure spiritual force. People seem to hate the name but I'm actually a fan of the way it's laid out, and I think it would fit well into the game thematically. Lots of opportunity for quest/lore too. Impacting other skills and ruining records is always a bit cringe, but that's par for the course
It's too close to magic for me. My first thought was Lunar Quest when I heard about this skill.
It's just too similar to stuff we already have
Shamanism is a combination of divination and invention from rs3
Anybody who has played sonic adventure and utilized the choa gardens sees the true potential of taming!
plus i can tame my boss pets
Good talk, appreciate your honesty and perspective.
I agree very much about the issues with sailing. As someone who sailed growing up there are genuine mechanics which should be recreated in the game. Wind, rigging, current, heading, swells, all of these things would take a lot of dev work to get right but it would be super fun to to learn in OSRS if they did it right. If there's no sailing theory involved in the mechanics they bring to OSRS then IMO it would feel like a minigame or like dungeoneering.
Sailing IRL is extremely competitive and there's a huge community sailors. Every time I went sailing it starts with rigging based on the wind conditions, then you have to get out onto the water, navigate docks and tides. Then there's the actual sailing aspect, keeping the boat slat, fixing things that break, storing supplies, righting the boat after capsizing, all that stuff should be a part of it IMO and should give bits of EXP. Same thing for de-rigging and storing the boat (could pay NPCs or crew to do this).
I just hope it not a "you board the boat and depart... *cutscene/minigame event happens*... navigation choice *** you arrive on a new island and boom thousands of sailing exp.
Obviously opening up the map to many new things is what sailing offers, but that's more navigation. I want core sailing concepts to be shown in game!
Milking is best suggestion I've heard n I don't want a new skill
Milking those udders
there would not be a lot of variety of islands. it would boil down to the same repetitive grind after some time, the scope is too large
I could see them going the direction WOW took with mounts for taming..other than unlocking a new area with ur pet or some stat boost, I see taming mainly being used to flex who has the rare stuff.
👍 appreciate your input
As much as it would be cool to see a new skill come into this game, I just don't trust Jagex to not pander to the extremely loud people on Reddit who are just gonna want the typical turn your brain off AFK fast XP skilling methods that give you tons of rewards too. They've already shown that if people scream loud enough on there they're bound to eventually be forced to listen. I don't see it turning out too well which is the only reason why I'm against any new skill. There's too much of a risk for it to negatively impact the game short and long term IMO.
the OSRS reddit should be closed until the dust is settled , they've skewed way too many things in OSRS already.
@@SYG_Aegis Yea I’ve had no faith in that community for a long time, but the Tombs of Amascut meltdown they had after Jagex made balancing changes to prevent people from brute forcing through the raid with Ambrosia made me realize just how much of a lost cause they are. Its already extremely accesible yet these people unironically want to be able to farm the best money in the game in mid level gear without needing to actually learn the mechanics. Give me a break man. They give zero fucks about the health of the game which is why trusting these same people to help balance an entire skill is a hilariously bad idea.
I’m already expecting the new prayer book from the upcoming DT2 to possibly destroy PVM. I thought most of the proposed prayers Jagex had in their dev blog were pretty well balanced and fitting for a high risk/reward prayer book. But nah, Reddit doesn’t want chip damage or any punishing mechanics. They just want pure DPS increase cause that’s fun, so Jagex is already reconsidering their version. Uggg.
@@Forged4War206 Couldn't have summarized reddit OSRS any better. Preach.
Bard would've been cool but there isn't a place for a healing/song buff class in the game with currently. The proposed skills make sense.
Can’t wait for pirate battles
I think even if sailing is just islandeering i'd still enjoy it if it's done well. im sure the training of sailing is navigating sail routes, and overcoming the struggles to actually GET to the island, but i almost feel like islandeering would be more fun even if its less "sailing".
If the island side of the skill was well thought out, id imagine there would be some really cool island locked series being rolled out which would be great for viewing.
My original thoughts on Sailing were that it would be Dungeoneering on water, but thinking about it more, its probably just going to be temple trekking on water. Which sounds even worse. Worst part is, I dont know that the other 2 are even any better.
We can't just keep introducing things which up the power level of characters without having anything to use them on. There simply is not enough dev time to introduce a level of content consistent with the power level of players without expanding content either sideways (skilling bosses, sailing etc.) or by just introducing stronger content. The problem with just introducing stronger content is that it's so difficult for the devs to balance correctly that it takes them years to release, and then go on to make it imbalanced in the future anyway (stronger items, new prayers, shamanism etc.).
Shamanism sounds like a great way to introduce more power rather than the current method of just slapping down some more bosses that drop even better stuff, but the problem that just slapping down more bosses solves is that you need content to use that better stuff on. What did you do after completing CoX? More CoX. ToB? ToB. ToA? ToA. If there were sufficiently challenging content, Shamanism would be fantastic, but there isn't. Sailing, on the other hand, does what bosses do - creates its own content whilst also making new uses for old content.
Taming at least tries to combat this problem by not making you stronger but by making your ability to get stronger easier whether that's by increasing trip times or some other method. If Shamanism went this route, I wouldn't really have a problem with it, though I'd still prefer Sailing due to it explicitly adding content to use old content on as well.
What i want most is dungeoneering , as for the 3 choices , im leaning towards sailing , as the pokemon skill doesnt intrigue me that much and shaman.. i think i'd like to see more before I even think about it
Sailing feels like it doesn't really do much beyond offer resource gathering, pets, maybe new travel methods. It's kind of like agility for macro travel whereas agility impacts your movement. I just can't see sailing going wrong. Sailing or shamanism.
I missed this format of videos. Reminiscent of the Hexis podcasts.
how do you make the mini second account like that?
a little ironic to focus on the potential harm sailing could have while ignore that taming and shamanism would introduce new "BIS" for literally every activity in the game with the pet abilities and gear augmenation/totems
Shamanism, to me, would be more interesting than prayer. I feel like prayer is the organized religion aspect of runescape and shamanism could be like the pagan varieties.
I'd like shamanism to be like invention
Bard would be cool. Sailing sounds like a minigame. Taming doesnt sound any better than pets. shamanism sounds like magic 2. Bard would be a unique skill. Craft instruments. play them afk for tips from npcs or something.
The legend returns once again
Sailing could be a tab like kourend has and could be fun as well. I like shamanism, but I think taming is a bit weak
sailing exp should be given as a bulk exp drop like the end of wintertodt. You receive the sailing exp after completeting the mission (ex. getting to the end of a dungeon in an island). Sailing exp should be seen as a way to measure your prowess in completing missions, not as something that needs to be trained by literally "sailing"
vote for sailing , you can be the pirate king and find the one piece
Sailing sounds like Slayer for other skills. You get a task of "Go do this mission" which could include getting rid of some island orcs, fishing or hunting something and then you get XP based on completing your sailing mission. With some boat steering included.
no
God Barding was such a missed opportunity
Love the idea of having a pet taming expansion without a new skill.
Like what RS3 did with Farming?
@@zants_ doesnt even need to be part of a skill, we dont need skills to raise cats. although yeah, it'd be good to give people more ways to level up farming
that would be horrible, we need new skills to level
Skilling is so relaxing
Taming will not be relaxing unfortunately, especially because it can be used in combat.
@@thelegacyofgaming2928 who said it can't be used in combat? it hasn't been decided yet. they said right in the video that is one of the things we will vote on
Shamanism sounds like it could be interesting from a pve standpoint if it were thoughtfully balanced. Easier said than done I’m sure.
sailing is just gonna be similar to slayer, you'll pick up contracts ranging from easy to hard, with masters based on sailing level, i.e tasks such as hunt x monster, or find x treasure in x region
Man you should make a HC when the auto-tele feature comes out. We know you crush skilling but your PVM excellency arc would break youtube tbh. whole community would love to see it!
a hyrbrid of sailing and dungeoneering if anything.
Shamanism is divination + invention.
Honestly I just don't want a new skill in the game. Shamanism and taming would both have massive implications in bossing and combat. Sailing really can not be done well in the game
am i the only one who thinks shamanism and taming kind sound like the same thing?
Summoning for president
Why did you come back to osrs after quitting? Do you still gym?
I didn't 100% quit for too long, I just played
@@AutumnElegy I’d watch the hell out of that vid
Shamanism seems like a complete bait. Training method will be afk, and any buffs the skill creates can impact every single level you train other skills. Sailing has the ability to be actually engaging, and is somewhat limited to introducing new areas and items.
why are u training mining when ur already 200m exp??
i'm mining daeyalt which is used for runecrafting
Taming should just be added to the hunter skill idk. Hunter is kinda meh and needs a rework. There’s only like 4-5 things to do (birdhouse chore, chinchompas, herbiboar or like implings or monkeys?) idk. As you get higher levels there’s like nothing really new to do.
they should come out with dungeoneering for old school
That's the only one that might interest me in playing again
Literally everybody asks for this but they don't care
i loved dungoneering , and no id on't want it as a minigame, i want it as a skill
sounds like they're still ripping content from rs3, taming sounds like player own farms, sailing sounds like player own ports
I can't look past sailing being a meme and take it seriously.
Pretty underwhelming skill ideas tbh, they all sound either boring to train or will have a bis method that will make everything else dead content.
Sailing is kind of boring, but it won't affect the current game negatively
Sailing will win because of the meme value it has
sailing comes across just like ports in rs3 and if its anything similar it wont be fun
rip to everyone with a max cape or on the front page of total xp.
good, its important to shake things up
as somebody who plays both games i have to say sailing looks the best for me. taming sounds to be basicaly PoF from rs3 which is part of farming not a separate skill. and shamanism sounds too much like divination. but what do i know, i just want something unique not a reskinned rs3 content
Shamanism is just sophisticated summoning, would rather have sailing
except....without anything being summoned?
Sailing again? I haven't played runescape in like 5 years, but Jagex has wanted to do that for decades it feels like.
It was a meme back in 2016.
@@thelegacyofgaming2928 it was a meme back in 2005
So player owned ports from rs3, summoning from rs3, or invention from rs3, sick.
right because vague similarities is the SAME thing. when will you people learn osrs is an alternate history of rs3, not a time capsule
pog
The theme of shamanism is bad IMO.
Sorcery, Cursing: black magic to imbue tools, gear and do other stuff, not about a spellbook (just like runecrafting isn't about spells). Could be themed around mahjarrats, which, unlike tribal hippies, are pure hype lore wise.
Enchanting/Bewitching: white magic, imbuing tools, gear. Cons: more boring, still better than tribal shit.
Sailing seems like the best fit for old-school. On top of that, it was rumored to release way back in the day, so sailing would have that nostalgia factor that the other skills wouldn't.
It was actually a meme back in 2016 (which honestly seems like just yesterday) but it would be cool to see the meme become a reality.
they should have picked a diff name for shamanism
I would like to see a skill for like Artistry. Something like Mahogony homes + Giants' Foundry where you go around and create "art" (like paintings, custom armor, etc). As you level up, you can create player owned customized gear, custom art for your POH, etc. Or something like riding skill, that allows me to traverse the world at increased speed.
Osrs needs Divination fr
#sailing
Sailing being like a modified Slayer for skills could be cool. Almost like a clue scroll effect, potential for artifact items. It's hard to imagine what sailing will do. Does the XP drop hit when a voyage ends and you've collected resources and whatnot? Who knows exactly, but it seems promising.
I feel like Jagex put Sailing with 2 weaker proposals because they really want Sailing. Jagex probably has a bunch of assets they created for sailing that they want to use. I would much prefer to have Bard as an option.
Sailing is just a meme it shouldn’t be real. I think it would be weird to actually be in RuneScape
Sailing is the most interesting to me. It has the most room for expansion. Shaman is just more about weapons. We already have a power creep. Make more personalized stuff
Honestly no new skill bc they will throw anything in as reward as a scapegoat if it’s part of the new skill
this comment makes no sense
Tldr; Vote Shaman
Smartest redditor brain
Autumn low energy strikes again 😂
Personally I’d like it if Jagex implemented something like inscription from WoW, where players can make scrolls that they can equip to give their character consistent permanent buffs
Just bring back dungeoneering
They promised a new skill with new concepts, and I honestly don't feel any of these three fit that criteria
then you're a bit spoiled , these are all new
@@007kingifrit You're a bit out of touch, these are literal copy pastes from runescape 3..
@@SYG_Aegis no they are not copy pastes they are not similar to summoning, it isn't a temporary companion, and we have great control over how it turns out. we can make the pets fight with us, but require food to heal, and we can make it so they die permanently and need to be bought back to live, and we don't have to have any inventory expanding pets ect ect
@@007kingifrit No interest in further discussing with you, when your entire response proves my point of calling you out of touch. If all you can name is Summoning as an example. Look into RuneScape 3 if you want to see what's happening to OSRS' direction.
@@SYG_Aegis taming will be an excellent edition to the game. stop looking at rs3 if you don't like it
All new skills are disgusting there is no point for them to exist in osrs, redditors with 1200 totals just want more "content" even though they interacted with less than 10% of what the game has to offer, they just hate the game and anyone that enjoys the game
Facts
Go back to mopar scape
😂😂😂
Will there be a vote for no new skills? Leave osrs alone 😩😒
I believe so, but I also believe the way the process is structured now will convert people into voting yes regardless
this vote already passed, you had a chance to vote no, it was 80% yes for a new skill
New skill bad
Sailing: Sounds like temple trekking turned into a skill except with boats. Furthermore, it doesn't sound like you'll be able to interact with the rest of the game/world with the skill. Overall, sounds like a minigame rather than a skill. Not a big fan.
Taming: Looks like an improvement from summoning while maintaining the benefits. Adds interesting abilities that'll likely be useful while training other skills. More interactions throughout the world. Sounds very solid, fits the concept of a skill, and has a lot of potential.
Shamanism: Sounds by far the most convoluted of the 3. The core gathering aspect overlaps with crafting and rewards you with power creep on gear. The training aspect sounds like it overlaps with runecrafting. Overall, the skill sounds like it won't add anything other than powercreep on gear.
i disagree with you on shamanism, the name makes alot of sense in terms of pagan history and runescape is built on english history.
all laughable
Second
third
first
Jagex always finds a way to ruin the game. Been this way for 10+ years.
probably a p2p skill so who cares
the only point im not a big fan of that you make is that IF you want 200m's its bad to have sailing give passive xp. there are probably less than 200 people that problem applies to and there are like 40 people that have 200m all already so meh.
Can someone please explain how he gets the borderless 2nd client down there and how he makes it that small!?
it's just a recording view. that's not how it looks on my screen
@@AutumnElegy Bummer! i have been trying to work out a way to get a tiny client that overlays the main client i use. The work around i have is super jank and involves using an application called Deskpins to pin the window to the top
Borderless Gaming *might* have an option to resize the resolution of a window relative to its size change? Despite having the program, I haven't used it much. If not, I'm sure there's something out there that lets you do that.
As for just making it borderless and floating: Borderless Gaming + Always on Top (PowerToys utility). There's likely freeware versions of Borderless Gaming as well, that's just the one I'm familiar with.
Elegy will want the grindiest, most boring skill progression possible no doubt.
😂😂😂
damn im 200m all in rs3 and didnt know about this "animal husbandry"???
If shamanism comes out I bet more people quit the game than join it long term. Ill be unsubbing the day they decide to release divination and invention under the guise of shamanism. Great way to kill osrs.