The future of journalism is digital. It can be bright only if you pay for its present.Take a paid subscription.Nurture the future of digital journalism. theprint.in/subscribe/
@ThePrint Can you share the complete data of people below poverty line that was given in parliament. And also a SUGGESTION : Please give articles or PDFs of data mentioned in the videos always
How Can You say This About Kashmir Sir There Can Be A Point That PDS Is Not Reached There Have You Checked How Many PDS are Active In Kashmir If local Govt Dont Issue PDS Cards How Will They Get That benifit?????
After the abrogation of Article 370, Ladakh got its identity, various development projects are in full swing. A few days ago BRO built the world's highest road in Ladakh
Big projects generally don't help people that's why china's BRI will fail these projects are to enhance political image , they have military/tourist angle to it. You can look at maglev train in China.
@p chatterjee 1st point ladakh isnt a isolated place nor does it lacks tourist, people are going there for a long time , most travel distance is travelled by road which are already well built and 1 long highway isnt going to change that. The isolation is due to massive rainfall and landslide which will not be solved by a highway as you can't build multi lane on hilly area and most blockage problem is due to rocks and snow, construction in hill area is risky and over construction can really be harmful as it can lead to disaster. 2nd point there has been no islimist regime in Ladakh , Right wing religious political party that is elected is not a regime. 3rd ladakh people still has less power through vote than any other State as it will be run a Lt.governer which are very antagonist towards local population. So kuch bolo to phukhne se phle bolo aur dekh lene 3,4 saal iska kitna asar rhta hai.
I remember your comment "if you find yourself in a hole, the first thing is that you stop digging ", and it took the government of India so many years to realize that.. and especially by the Modi government that once called it "Tax terrorism ", but better late than never, I personally think the country will reap rich dividends in the future.. the best news I've heard in a long time..
Despite being a hard core BJP supporter I must say government took too much time. Good thing that they did it. Next step is to complete disinvestment projects. Implement labour laws and new education policy thoroughly.
@@Krishna_gaming_98 People here in Tamil Nadu are against the 3 language formula in the New Education Policy. Some worry it’ll cause unnecessary stress for students while others believe it’ll result in the indirect imposition of Hindi.
@@friendlyperson9691 it's optional isn't it..I get it !! Language holds a part of an individual's lineage and culture, but what's the harm in learning Hindi as a third language..it's not asking you to leave you mother's tongue.
@@Krishna_gaming_98 Furthermore I believe that the opposition parties along with trade unions across India will conduct mass-scale protests if the new labour codes were to be implemented immediately.
Pranab Da be like: "Samne waale ko batting hi nahin karne doonga. Saari batting khud hi karoonga aur agar nahin mante to Bat ghar le kar chala jaounga"!!!
This is applicable to smaller states in NE. If a sates gets 3 times of what it earns and pays less tax people will have liquid money. The day central government sends 3 times the money in addition to what Bihar UP Orrisa earns the whole poor state will become surplus state. SKG should have used the figure in term of per capita government spending before giving tag of “Champion” to these states.
@@neeljavia2965 please check the facts correctly. It’s not. On the basis of per capita it’s lowest. Also migrated people’s earnings doesn’t counted into UP Bihar contributions but to the state whether they are currently currently located. So come out of that notion.
I feel all governments have thrown money in Kashmir via various schemes and developments to win hearts of the locals, hence kashmir has better social indicators. But it is also an irony that despite low poverty Kashmiris are still picking up the gun. Many people associate terrorism with poverty and lack of education but looks like that's not true.
There's a real lack of job there, all money given by center has made corrupt kashmiri ministers and babus richer and people had gone poor as There's no employment opportunity
Most of the people amd valley have houses and land courtesy Sheikh Abdulla who brought land ceiling . They are not poor . But entirely dependent on Tourism Agriculture like sectors
justifying the Kashmir situation is the biggest joke, whole state was terrorism infested and removal of terroists needed an intervention like this. also what about rights of pandits looted ? you have no words to talk about them..
It's funny how you talk about J&K without ever visiting to know the on ground situation. And this is not just you majority of people have some kind of stereotypes. JK is exactly the way it was, no improvement if it was militant infested or no increase if it was not.
Surely no body wants to speak for KASHMIRI PANDITS., this too applies to POLITICIANS, PRINT AND ELECTRONIC MEDIA No courage guts on the part of MEDIA to SPEAK THE NAKED TRUTH. But everyone talks of. ROHINGYAS, PAKISTANI, BANGLADESHI MUSLIM INFILTRATORS in the wake of CITIZENSHIP AMENDMENT ACT. NEVER TALKED A SINGLE WORD for HINDUS PLIGHT IN PAKISTAN AND BANGLADESH, What about HINDUS thrown out of PAKISTAN/BANGLADESH and still NIRASHRITS (Not given CITIZENSHIP since DECADES)) What's the plight of these HINDUS in INDIA. Had any body heard anything from Print/Electronic MEDIA?
@RAVITESH KUMAR no reason to abuse. But just in case if it helps: I am from Jammu and Kashmir. What happened with Kashmiri pandits was unfortunate but has BJP rolled it back? I don't think so. Imagine not having internet for full one year. Police comes up in your house in middle of night and takes away someone without giving any reason, and courts do not hear your issues for months. That's the reality in Kashmir. If this all was for development, then I don't see a single new project announced by BJP, not single new job. I don't think this is problem of Jammu and Kashmir, unemployment and rising poverty is everywhere more than ever. So do I oppose 370 abrogation- No, but I don't support Modi's divisive politics either.
@@byron-ih2ge bro the government has to spend in military otherwise JK will become haven for terrorist..I agree with u they should develop NORTHEAST which is really beautiful n lush green
1.Kashmiri Muslims r always angry 2.kashmir is rich,example:bihar with a population of more than 10 crores will have two AIIMSs,J&K with population of less than 2 crore will hv two AIIMSs
Being a CA final student i have gone through it many a times, but to see shekhar sir explaining it so amazingly reminds me of how great SG is. He's AB develiers i.e. Mr 360° of journalism.
Finally.... This is one hole we've managed climbed out of... On another note, our family has had Vodafone numbers since 2001. Vodafone must survive to give some competition to Jio & Airtel....
Congress are champions of changing game rules when they are lost starting with Indira Gandhi for her defeat from allahbad ruling, Rajiv Gandhi in Triple Talak and now Pranab Da for retrospective tax
And yet the congress is thought of as champion of free rule when in reality it encouraged only one thought process and clamped down on others with the might of the state
@@dranilheroor remember Indra ghandi completely destroyed Indian Economy by License Raj And then they say BJP is not handling Economy properly I am not saying BJP is best in handling Economy We all know how "good" Demonization and Economy management during Covid has been 😂😂 but still they have uplifted the economy at good pace ignoring the year 2019 and 2020 They should just manage Economy properly in the coming three years Before elections and I'll happily vote for them
"Data shows that despite J&K receiving 10 per cent of tax payers' money for one per cent of India's population in the last 70 years of autonomy, its economy has remained fragile, to say the least. Terrorism and debt both flourished even after substantial financial assistance from the Centre." - India Today
The question is where exactly is the money going then? Why not do a CBI probe to find out root of problem and the depth of corruption. I'm not sure what this 10% includes, does it includes the salary of million army and CRPF personnel, not sure, does it includes border roads and infrastructure development not sure, after all the erstwhile state of Jammu and Kashmir shares a big border with Pak and China. I tried to search what this 10% amounts to in metric or for what purpose was it given, I couldn't find anything buy the news article and some obscure PDFs, sounds like typical fake news to me( some truths hidden), I'm not denying corruption, there's too much corruption throughout India, but only transparency can solve corruption. Irrespective of the size of population, the size of jk is bigger than UP and jk shares border with hostile nations unlike UP, so the comparison is flawed to begin with.
@UC5Jop4mY8FvW4zXk-1FNepQ Not sure if you have gone to UP or Bihar or not but it's a fact that living standards in Kashmir are much better than UP and Bihar. Indian govt. has tried her level best to keep the people of Kashmir happy but I am sorry to say Kashmiris have not given much value to it. The truth is very bitter, but it is the religion which the real cause of the problems Kashmiris face. The other day I saw someone say Kashmiris don't need roads and power, they need freedom. I mean freedom from what? Kashmiris have always had the freedom, just live peacefully who is enforcing anything on them. I don't understand why they are not able to see the misery that the people of Afghanistan are going through in the name of Islam. Can't they see how India is building infrastructure there and Pakistan is sending Taliban. Pata nahin kashmiriyon ye samajh kyun nahin aati, islam kya logon ko itna andhaa bana deta hai, ki dost aur dushma ka difference nahin dikhta unhe.
@@spetsnazGru487 well, high terrain roads are mostly built by BRO so there shouldn't be much corruption in making those. I don't see much money being spent in city or villages... I've visited chandigarh through a single lane highway on 2015, and went the same way on 2018 it was 4-6 lanes... Let's be honest Budget alloted isn't equal to money given or used, I think you'd agree that transparency is the only solution. The data here is really odd, up gets 5 times the budget, so if JK got 10%, UP got 50%, maharastra is a big state and gets 8 times of JK, does it gets 80%, so UP and Maharashtra combined take 130% of GDP of India, how's that even possible????... They've twisted the numbers into odd statistics to confuse and polarize the reader.
@@ritaranee4787 you no longer call them red Indians. It it considered derogatory.They are referred to as native Americans. You may already know this. Just saying...
Legacy of late Pranab Mukherji. Unpopular amongst chiefly Cairn energy and Vodaphone . Extremely happy about this retrograde tax being dumped into the dustbin of history .
@@johnvalentino576 SG already answered the reason why it wasn’t done. Your beloved Pappu had accused suit boot ki sarkar. And then falls propaganda about Ambani-Adani will forcefully buy your farm land. Modi sarkar didn’t want to reverse it until the end to avoid these false propaganda.
@@johnvalentino576 do you have any reason how Adani got it unfairly? Elon Musk made about $100 billion in 2020. From 30-35th richest to top 2 in the world. He must be doing corruption 😂
Few prime time shows are as informative on economy updates as CTC. I saw TV news today while having dinner and couldn't find a single mention of such an important development. Kudos to you and your team for covering this 😎👍🏻
Hi Aman. Glad you liked this episode about tax laws. Most important discussion today, considering the wide-ranging implications it will have in the future.
Dear SG - 1% of the population of J&K receive 9% of funds allocated to states by the Center. Isn't this unfair for other states? Also so little money trickles down to Jammu and Jammu has to fight for resources all the time. Blessed are ladakhi people who got rid of Kashmir.
That's because Govt wants to develop Kashmir and Also most of it is also wasted on security What Govt wants is to do something like the West and East Berlin thing so that people in POK get jealous of Indian Kashmir and become Anti Pak and it happens it will be much easy for India to capture because of No public Hindering
@@yasheekatripathi6883 Then what about Jammu. All development goes in Kashmir, flood relief, block development funds. And in return they throw stone at Indian Government. People of jammu should also start throwing stone. Rohingaya are getting free land in Jammu and no one is saying anything. On other hand Kashmiri Hindus faced persecution.
😂UP gets back 400% more in Central funds as compared to taxes that it provides to the centre. Similarly the otherBIMARUstates of Bihar/MP etc... And none of these are border states. And where do they stand in every parameter of development, infant mortality, BPL(below poverty line)/Hunger etc.....
The reality is that Shaikh Abdullah carried out the most successful land reforms Program in India and the average Kashmiri is 10 times better off than average Indian coming from theBimaruStates......whether it is on education, human development indices, finances, creativity, standard of living you name it. They are NOT likeTheBIMARUhungryUP/Bihari/MPstates....
The local Kashmiri recruits are heavily influenced by the institutions run by the religious organizations. No control over them could be exercised due to the state government. Even the school syllabus was tacitly propagating separatism. All those are in the process of being corrected. You don't judge merit of such policy shift so quickly.
@@TheWasim Should India correct the books and peacefully show the Kashmiris how it is in their interest to be in India? Or are you suggesting that all of this is useless, Kashmiris want to be like Afghanistan, in which case India's only option is to suppress Kashmiris with iron hand, like the Pakistanis and the Chinese do to their dissenters?
We need more privatization, not toxic capitalism like USA that uses prisoners for free labour but encourage our young minds to start companies and provide jobs to fellow Indians 👍
There is nothing wrong with capitalism as long aa there is competition. Capitalism becomes a problem when competition dies. A capitalist never wishes for a poor customer.
The thing is I don’t want to criticize USA methods as they are developed but yes, India should follow European model of development rather than USA model
They have done it that is more important, Governemmebt if BJP has done it's of things policy-wise which will help in the long run, India as a country and people has very short-sighted thinking.
Better late than never. Now if the farm law, land-labour laws are passed and reservation & CAA-NRC ideas are removed then this nation can become a heaven for honest people. But that is wayy tooo much to ask for :(
@@bhargavdesai7984 others I do agree on. But farm law is something that is really needed for the marginal farmers brother. Politicisation should not discourage the much needed reforms.
If they had done that, then that would have been opposed the farm laws are being opposed now. When did Shekhar Gupta really start panning the retrospective tax? Not when it was introduced, but when Pranab Mukherjee's book came out and Mukherjee was less than flattering in his references to the other SG. That is when this SG started how awful this retrospective tax was
Half a day!!! Wow you must be really brave sir!! I tried watching some of the clips CZcamsrs made of Arnab Goswami and the ilks for 5 mins and my brain got scrambled!!
@@ThePrintIndia Yes it is!! Considering I am in stock market and this news could act as boon for may companies. Also Voda/Idea share might see some heavy movements in coming few days!!
In total agreement on your assessment on retrospective tax. In fact I thought cancelling retrospective tax would be first move of Modi Govt in 2014, 7 years late nevertheless better late than never.
SG, please start calling the UT/State as "J&K" or "Jammu and Kashmir". When you keep calling it "Kashmir" and when you say "Kashmir is not happy under the surface about 370 abrogation", you keep ignoring Jammu. If Jammu isn't important to "The Print", then you are another "hyphenated" media house.
@@lovesharma4883 It's been done in Bihar, UP, AP, Odisa, TN, MP, etc etc. To start with there were just 14 large States. It was an administrative nightmare.
Good job done by government. Currently China is destroying it's image and business friendly policies. We need to take advantage of it. Just import duties needs to be reduced and we need to join rcep.
@@Amal-os6tt Hope it happens as our Delhi High court stated the dire need of it. But one thing that should be followed would be taking all religious organization as its stake holder thus not creating panic while its implementation.
I now remember and understand this Pranab Mukherjee story in more details now than my course subjects because Guptaji has explained it multiple times and different contexts. I hope this comes in UPSC, Atleast 😂
Shekhar Sir, even Syria's per capita income is higher than India, does that mean their life is better? To begin with, Kashmir started much higher than UP and Bihar. They were not exploited as badly by British as UP and Bihar were.
UP and Bihar have been gravely violated by the Indian the successive state governments in the past 70 years. Far worse than what has Kashmir faced. For you, terms like exploitation, freedom struggle and their likes are limited only in the spectrum of religion. Had Kashmir been a Hindu majority state/region (like it was 1000-1500 years back), we wouldn't have seen a so called "Freedom movement" in Kashmir at all. The problem lies with the minds of people.
@Mayur Kanth I did not. The OP of this comment thread did. Also, Kashmir per capita income is multiple times that of the Syrian per capita income. Which is why I believe the original comment was disingenuous.
@@fangdog29 Kashmir's GDP per capita is US$ 1342 and Syria GDP per capita is US$ 2032. And if you consider Syria's GDP per capita in the 1980s when it was not war torn, the story is entirely different. In 1996 Kashmir GDP per capita is Rs 8670 while Bihar was Rs.4000. GDP per capita of Kashmir has been higher than that of UP Bihar since independence itself. When Shekhar sir's said Kashmir is not as poor as UP and Bihar, then he must understand that Kashmir was never as poor as UP and Bihar, so his comparison is incorrect. Thoda comment ko padh liya karo achche se, neeche comment karne se pehle. Farasi mein naam dikha nahin ki oppose karne aa gaye bina baat.
I wonder why Maharashtra never appears in any of Mr. Shekhar Gupta's statistical figures. I had earlier seen the one on population where he talked state wise statistics on fertility rate and now this one on poverty.
What is the final conclusion on this issue ? Who will decide this ? As far as common sense goes , 1- Art 370 and Art 35 are gone for ever 2- All laws of Indian Union will be applicable in J & K 3- Governance in J & K is being improved . Local self govt is now functioning well 4- So long as terrorism is not fully controlled and Pandits are not fully restored , there is no question of statehood to J & K . If at all , it will be on Delhi model of statehood . 5- We are not bothered about business of politics by a few families of politicians like Abdullahs . He can go on cribbing and he should ! No one is bothered But politics can go on and on !!
There is frequent question on statehood ... Restoring pandits needs proper planning u just can't go say pandits will live here ...What will u do if something like 1980 happens again. ...Let's few things go slowly
To quote the low free food percentage as a measure of development seems to be misplaced. Kashmir might not have an established PDS mechanism to deliver it.
Not really. Kashmir has a very good economy for itself. Tourism contribution is around 20 percent. The rest from Agriculture and trade. Also a sizeable remittances from Kashmiris in the UK.
The same way Chidambaram changed the law to usurp Raja Mahmoodabad’s properties worth 30K crores. He as an advocate had lost the case in the Supreme Court, but as a minister he changed the law retrospectively to reverse the court judgment.
Today, I finally decided to officially become a CZcams member. I am still a mere student so right now, I can only support through this but I would continue to support. 👍🏻
I appreciate that man. One benefit of subscribing as a cash strapped student is that you care to get the maximum bang from your buck, and the print is a good option since it has quite a few decent news shows. I especially recommend the one with Ila Patnaik.
@@ThePrintIndia Well it is hard to choose, quite a few good answers. But if I had to single out a few shows, I'd definitely like to put a good word in for the younger cohort of journalists who I think are catering to a crucial demographic segment that is often ignored, which is native Indian language speakers who understand and are interested in the wider anglophone policy and culture debates, but process and comment upon those debates primarily in Hindi/other native languages. In this respect Jyoti Yadav and Shanker Arnimesh have been doing quite well. As have the law and science experts. Perhaps a yet uncovered niche might be business news, especially the start-up world.
Vodaphone- "Look, we won't pay you 8,000 crore, there's no such law" IT Department- "Yes there is.." Cairn- "So your bill would be 12,000 crore...Cash or Card?" IT Deparment- "Let me complete the statement...." p.s.- Desclaimer: Before any IT guy reads it and decides to raid me, my CTC is 3.5 lakh..
Ideology apart, Pranab Mukherjee is a legendary character in Indian politics and not to mention, a former President of India. Any respect or circumspection in speaking of him and his legacy is due and warranted.
@@MultiCuldude so we respect the position someone formerly occupied instead of judging them on the basis of actions that had serious consequences? We need, desperately, to get out of the mentality of respecting for the sake of respecting.
@@fangdog29 thanks to our former Finance Minister n former President for having ransacked a business, the company n it's employees while protecting the country thro unpayable tax!!
Something tells me the reason is something more immediate: when the prospect of losing Air India planes (among other assets in France/Europe) to Cairns loomed large, better senses prevailed!
Excellent review on both the topics. My personal experience posted on Kashmir for more than ten years (mid seventies to late eighties) and traveling extensively to the deep interiors, there were hardly any families deprived of basic survival needs like roti, kapda and makan.Thanks once again for the excellent coverage on both topics.
Mr. Gupta has always been an avid Congress supporter or atleast close to the Gandhi family. He would like to inform of the move BJP has made but also would not like to upset Congress and will also tk a step to justify what mindset Pranab M. had while taking such a step.
Shekhar ji's delivery is like Monty Python, in the sense that every time when you feel like the narrative is getting recursive, he reprises himself with an episode of such originality that you're hooked back in again. Wonderful, nuanced episode of CTC
Sir as an Indian from Ladakh I must disagree with you . Yes conditions were better for Kashmir as the leaders spent most of the center money on a small region but it was the people of Ladakh who were suffering . There were no universities , no hospitals ,no infrastructure in Ladakh . Even a small town like Anantnag has better facilities than Leh ..4G network came to Srinagar in 2016 but it took two more years to make Leh 4G ...This is why Ladakh had been demanding a separation from JK since the early 50s and now things are much better New Hospitals are being built , new roads are being constructed and for the first time ever Ladakh has its own university .
Haha finally that damn tax goes away seven years after the promise was made, better late than never 😅 PS- Next up should be the reform of the 2013 land law
Amazing Unbiased balanced analysis. The good and bad both points were nicely kept. If there is one channel which deserves PM Modi's interview it is definitely THE PRINT
Thank you for talking about vodafone case, just yesterday i tweeted about you to make CTC on this recent development i hope print starts a business section soon, as there are limited articles on topic like these related to markets
This is good action. Jaitly should have done it long back but he said it is under supreme court review. After losing in international courts both financially as well as morally, Indian government has finally learnt the lesson.
Modi Inc. Needs 2 centuries to correct past mistakes. So much for their understanding and competence. Yet, we appreciate this belated enlightened in taxation policy.
At least the UPA government acts like a allmighty sovereign even after having a weak numbers. Elected to office and getting to power are different things. Governence take much more confidence, expertise , experience and wisdom.
i become wise by listening each CTC. Shekhar ji voice and thoughts help us to look at issue in neutral way. I read some articles on this but was not able to comprehend it, but with CTC now I can.
Congratulations to modi govt Sanctity of contracts has been restored Would pranab have done it without blessings of NAC gang? Or was it at their instance ? Sharp left turn or Rahul shows that congress is now a communist party
This speaks so loud of your just & fair journalism, SGji. In 99.99 % cases, I'm a doubting Thomas about this Government's legislative misadventures on the strength of majoritarisnism. But mending "Dada retro tax" is the most rational output of this government thus far. Only Modi's political capital & courage can do such miracles.
Maybe the reason for low poverty in J&K is that India invest alot in J&K at the expense of rest of the country? Maybe! Not making any claims. Tell me if i am wrong.
No compensation were given for internet blockade for over a year, you have no idea how many young people lost their internet entrepreneurship opportunities and yet you think the govt was giving the JK more than rest of the country.. when the package is given it also includes infrastructure needed by the army as when convoy uses the roads common men aren't allowed to use them. More than thousands of crores were lost in transportation sector only, and yet no compensation was given. compensation was given
Manmohan Singh is an amazing politician- 1. He gets credit for 1991 reforms where PVNR had bigger role, MMS was just implementer 2. He doesn't get any bad press for retrospective tax, all blame goes to Pranab, while MMS was PM
It is good that bad law of retrospective tax has been reversed. There was one more cade of ITC Ltd, who won excise case in SC. Mr. Chidambaram was FM. He changed law with retrospective effect. Company lost some 700 Cr refund from GOI. That wad equally bad. Now Govt should declare that no tax will be changed retrospectively. Any change should be prospective.
The decision by the government is outstandingly good...of all the decisions taken by Pranab Mukherjee this was the worst and had the effect of undoing all the good work done by Narsimha Rao and Manmohan Singh. However this was not the only bad decision taken by him and because of his pre eminent position of the Congress party. He said on the floor of the house that orop was not technically, administratively and financially feasible. So though the Modi government has not given a perfect orop it is a vast improvement on the policy of the Congress party and I don't thinl any defence person serving or retired would grudge the government knowing inherent financial constraints. So on the issue of retrospective tax being withdrawn the Modi government deserves full hearted praise
A public demonstration of the pathetic business environment in India ... Govt acting as local gunda demanding hafta arbitrarily and now scurrying to back off after companies refusing to be bullied. UPA era law could have been repealed years ago but the BJP milked it to benefit Ambani's Jio and Anil Aggarwal's Vedanta. The statement is clear, to do business in India, you better suck up to the Government. No wonder global manufacturers decided not to invest here despite the pandemic and situation in China. Irrespective of who is in power, India will have a perpetual "STAY AWAY" sign for businesses.
Sir it’s like a honey into my ears listening to you!! Thanks a lot for this enlightening analysis leaving nothing behind ……You truly show what journalism is supposed to do and instill indomitable faith in the good journalism!!
Also you didn’t mention good work on Infrastructure (road, rail, power) happening there. Your own reporter who interviewed LG was able to draw out good things happening there. please watch that interview ;)
Excellent episode, I come here for true stories, without any cover, and to gain deep knowledge, and so far not got disappointed. Excellent work, keep it up👍
One reason for the poverty index being low in Kashmir is the enormous amounts of money pumped into that state disproportionate to the other Indian states. I expected a person of Sekar Gupta's calibre to bring that out also.
The future of journalism is digital. It can be bright only if you pay for its present.Take a paid subscription.Nurture the future of digital journalism. theprint.in/subscribe/
Ban BJP
💩🐮
@ThePrint Can you share the complete data of people below poverty line that was given in parliament. And also a SUGGESTION : Please give articles or PDFs of data mentioned in the videos always
How Can You say This About Kashmir Sir There Can Be A Point That PDS Is Not Reached There Have You Checked How Many PDS are Active In Kashmir If local Govt Dont Issue PDS Cards How Will They Get That benifit?????
The data on BPL is of 2004-05.
Gupta ji's Camera Quality has become exponentially better then before.
from Iphone to DSLR with laser focus!
Than.
@@hmeffect7117 I realised that late. Now the edit will remove the super Like. Can't have that 😅
Looks like Gupta ji has finally started to earn something :)
Meanwhile Ndtv still using 2000 era camera with no color calibration
After the abrogation of Article 370, Ladakh got its identity, various development projects are in full swing. A few days ago BRO built the world's highest road in Ladakh
Big projects generally don't help people that's why china's BRI will fail these projects are to enhance political image , they have military/tourist angle to it. You can look at maglev train in China.
If we provoke China further we might not have a Ladakh to 'develop'
Didn't you see Omar's interview on Times Now or were you sleeping?
@p chatterjee 1st point ladakh isnt a isolated place nor does it lacks tourist, people are going there for a long time , most travel distance is travelled by road which are already well built and 1 long highway isnt going to change that. The isolation is due to massive rainfall and landslide which will not be solved by a highway as you can't build multi lane on hilly area and most blockage problem is due to rocks and snow, construction in hill area is risky and over construction can really be harmful as it can lead to disaster. 2nd point there has been no islimist regime in Ladakh , Right wing religious political party that is elected is not a regime. 3rd ladakh people still has less power through vote than any other State as it will be run a Lt.governer which are very antagonist towards local population. So kuch bolo to phukhne se phle bolo aur dekh lene 3,4 saal iska kitna asar rhta hai.
@@g1y3 you're saying infra doesn’t help giving example of BRI.
Why don't you give example of how china developed so much through infra only
Privatisation. And good education policy yes. India has so much potential it is a shame it has not been able to explode in the world👍
Bjp is worst
@@disabled9502 Yeah no.. Just want to know ur reason for it.
@@ShubhamBa bjp is destroying the country
@@disabled9502 Ok, i get that.. but facts, details and their sources. At least give something other than comment.
@@ShubhamBa he has nothing
I remember your comment "if you find yourself in a hole, the first thing is that you stop digging ", and it took the government of India so many years to realize that.. and especially by the Modi government that once called it "Tax terrorism ", but better late than never, I personally think the country will reap rich dividends in the future.. the best news I've heard in a long time..
@Krishnapal Seth Well hope they do good and if they do my vote For BJP
Despite being a hard core BJP supporter I must say government took too much time. Good thing that they did it. Next step is to complete disinvestment projects. Implement labour laws and new education policy thoroughly.
Privatisation. And good education policy yes. India has so much potential it is a shame it has not been able to explode in the world👍
Complete divestment is not possible in certain sectors like railways and nuclear.
@@Krishna_gaming_98 People here in Tamil Nadu are against the 3 language formula in the New Education Policy. Some worry it’ll cause unnecessary stress for students while others believe it’ll result in the indirect imposition of Hindi.
@@friendlyperson9691 it's optional isn't it..I get it !! Language holds a part of an individual's lineage and culture, but what's the harm in learning Hindi as a third language..it's not asking you to leave you mother's tongue.
@@Krishna_gaming_98 Furthermore I believe that the opposition parties along with trade unions across India will conduct mass-scale protests if the new labour codes were to be implemented immediately.
Sir, this move to repeal retrospective tax issue is indeed a great confidence booster for those looking at investing in India 👍
Pranab Da be like: "Samne waale ko batting hi nahin karne doonga. Saari batting khud hi karoonga aur agar nahin mante to Bat ghar le kar chala jaounga"!!!
I am the sovereign. I am Bharat sarkar.
Hahaha. Very well put. Congress' socialist mindset display at it's best.
People are always accusing Modi of “fascism” but it is other parties who have tried to bypass court judgments.
True.
However this doesn't justify BJP'S actions.
This is applicable to smaller states in NE. If a sates gets 3 times of what it earns and pays less tax people will have liquid money. The day central government sends 3 times the money in addition to what Bihar UP Orrisa earns the whole poor state will become surplus state. SKG should have used the figure in term of per capita government spending before giving tag of “Champion” to these states.
@@nainao4 BS.
UP and Bihar already get a lot more than they contribute.
@@neeljavia2965 please check the facts correctly. It’s not. On the basis of per capita it’s lowest. Also migrated people’s earnings doesn’t counted into UP Bihar contributions but to the state whether they are currently currently located. So come out of that notion.
Most people don't know what "fascism" means. Fascism is not Nazism. Hitler was NOT a fascist. They are two completely different idealogies.
I feel all governments have thrown money in Kashmir via various schemes and developments to win hearts of the locals, hence kashmir has better social indicators. But it is also an irony that despite low poverty Kashmiris are still picking up the gun. Many people associate terrorism with poverty and lack of education but looks like that's not true.
Same was done in up, bihar but with no benefits like kashmir.
It is another toxic stuff that is the reason - the primitive Arabic ideology - the religion of peace
And you cannot do anything to win minds.. just control the effects of it.
There's a real lack of job there, all money given by center has made corrupt kashmiri ministers and babus richer and people had gone poor as There's no employment opportunity
Most of the people amd valley have houses and land courtesy Sheikh Abdulla who brought land ceiling . They are not poor . But entirely dependent on Tourism Agriculture like sectors
Yet again 5 th August proves to be historic (this time in the field of sports)
It's a pious day
Bjp is worst
@Aman Verma or UCC
@@disabled9502 🤡🤡🤡
justifying the Kashmir situation is the biggest joke, whole state was terrorism infested and removal of terroists needed an intervention like this. also what about rights of pandits looted ? you have no words to talk about them..
It's funny how you talk about J&K without ever visiting to know the on ground situation. And this is not just you majority of people have some kind of stereotypes.
JK is exactly the way it was, no improvement if it was militant infested or no increase if it was not.
Surely no body wants to speak for KASHMIRI PANDITS., this too applies to POLITICIANS, PRINT AND ELECTRONIC MEDIA No courage guts on the part of MEDIA to SPEAK THE NAKED TRUTH.
But everyone talks of. ROHINGYAS, PAKISTANI, BANGLADESHI MUSLIM INFILTRATORS in the wake of CITIZENSHIP AMENDMENT ACT.
NEVER TALKED A SINGLE WORD for HINDUS PLIGHT IN PAKISTAN AND BANGLADESH,
What about HINDUS thrown out of PAKISTAN/BANGLADESH and still NIRASHRITS (Not given CITIZENSHIP since DECADES)) What's the plight of these HINDUS in INDIA.
Had any body heard anything from Print/Electronic MEDIA?
@RAVITESH KUMAR no reason to abuse. But just in case if it helps: I am from Jammu and Kashmir.
What happened with Kashmiri pandits was unfortunate but has BJP rolled it back? I don't think so.
Imagine not having internet for full one year. Police comes up in your house in middle of night and takes away someone without giving any reason, and courts do not hear your issues for months. That's the reality in Kashmir.
If this all was for development, then I don't see a single new project announced by BJP, not single new job.
I don't think this is problem of Jammu and Kashmir, unemployment and rising poverty is everywhere more than ever. So do I oppose 370 abrogation- No, but I don't support Modi's divisive politics either.
You forgot to mention how kashmir (with 1% of Indian population) receives 10% of funds from centre.
Ya thats an entire mess of its own !! And the sad fact is all that is not going even in the development.of.kashmir..its all about military
Imqgine if that 10 perfent went to the northeast how heaven like that region would look..
@@byron-ih2ge bro the government has to spend in military otherwise JK will become haven for terrorist..I agree with u they should develop NORTHEAST which is really beautiful n lush green
@@sweet-old-days well it is still a heaven for terrorism
@@sweet-old-days things r just getting worse the locals r just becoming more and more jihadi
1.Kashmiri Muslims r always angry
2.kashmir is rich,example:bihar with a population of more than 10 crores will have two AIIMSs,J&K with population of less than 2 crore will hv two AIIMSs
Being a CA final student i have gone through it many a times, but to see shekhar sir explaining it so amazingly reminds me of how great SG is. He's AB develiers i.e. Mr 360° of journalism.
I literally scrolled 30 times just to check if I have missed today’s CTC notification. It came really late today.
Same happening with me !!
Finally.... This is one hole we've managed climbed out of...
On another note, our family has had Vodafone numbers since 2001. Vodafone must survive to give some competition to Jio & Airtel....
Enjoy binge all night
@@lokeshkumarahuja5661 😂
Vodafone sucks. Cant Choose it above Jio and Airtel.
@@YadviGalaxy bro JIO is the same buy JIO fiber it's really good
But jio SIM is worst
Congress are champions of changing game rules when they are lost starting with Indira Gandhi for her defeat from allahbad ruling, Rajiv Gandhi in Triple Talak and now Pranab Da for retrospective tax
Match haarne lgo to Bat lekar bhaag jao🤣🤣🤣
And election har gaye to ..EVM hack 😂😂 and jit gaye to sab kuch thik...
And yet the congress is thought of as champion of free rule when in reality it encouraged only one thought process and clamped down on others with the might of the state
@@dranilheroor remember Indra ghandi completely destroyed Indian Economy by License Raj
And then they say BJP is not handling Economy properly
I am not saying BJP is best in handling Economy We all know how "good" Demonization and Economy management during Covid has been 😂😂 but still they have uplifted the economy at good pace ignoring the year 2019 and 2020
They should just manage Economy properly in the coming three years Before elections and I'll happily vote for them
"Data shows that despite J&K receiving 10 per cent of tax payers' money for one per cent of India's population in the last 70 years of autonomy, its economy has remained fragile, to say the least. Terrorism and debt both flourished even after substantial financial assistance from the Centre." - India Today
The question is where exactly is the money going then? Why not do a CBI probe to find out root of problem and the depth of corruption. I'm not sure what this 10% includes, does it includes the salary of million army and CRPF personnel, not sure, does it includes border roads and infrastructure development not sure, after all the erstwhile state of Jammu and Kashmir shares a big border with Pak and China. I tried to search what this 10% amounts to in metric or for what purpose was it given, I couldn't find anything buy the news article and some obscure PDFs, sounds like typical fake news to me( some truths hidden), I'm not denying corruption, there's too much corruption throughout India, but only transparency can solve corruption. Irrespective of the size of population, the size of jk is bigger than UP and jk shares border with hostile nations unlike UP, so the comparison is flawed to begin with.
You're dead wrong
@UC5Jop4mY8FvW4zXk-1FNepQ Not sure if you have gone to UP or Bihar or not but it's a fact that living standards in Kashmir are much better than UP and Bihar. Indian govt. has tried her level best to keep the people of Kashmir happy but I am sorry to say Kashmiris have not given much value to it.
The truth is very bitter, but it is the religion which the real cause of the problems Kashmiris face. The other day I saw someone say Kashmiris don't need roads and power, they need freedom. I mean freedom from what? Kashmiris have always had the freedom, just live peacefully who is enforcing anything on them.
I don't understand why they are not able to see the misery that the people of Afghanistan are going through in the name of Islam. Can't they see how India is building infrastructure there and Pakistan is sending Taliban. Pata nahin kashmiriyon ye samajh kyun nahin aati, islam kya logon ko itna andhaa bana deta hai, ki dost aur dushma ka difference nahin dikhta unhe.
@@kukulkhaan infra development in Kashmir is costly.India is spending on infra in Kashmir which is more costlier than elsewhere in India.
@@spetsnazGru487 well, high terrain roads are mostly built by BRO so there shouldn't be much corruption in making those. I don't see much money being spent in city or villages... I've visited chandigarh through a single lane highway on 2015, and went the same way on 2018 it was 4-6 lanes... Let's be honest Budget alloted isn't equal to money given or used, I think you'd agree that transparency is the only solution. The data here is really odd, up gets 5 times the budget, so if JK got 10%, UP got 50%, maharastra is a big state and gets 8 times of JK, does it gets 80%, so UP and Maharashtra combined take 130% of GDP of India, how's that even possible????... They've twisted the numbers into odd statistics to confuse and polarize the reader.
Said everything about Kashmir except Hindu genocide.
Has it happened in last 2 years?
Douchebag bag spotted..
He is secular
Red Indians were pushed to the brink of extinction and are still oppressed.... It's a global thing
@@ritaranee4787 you no longer call them red Indians. It it considered derogatory.They are referred to as native Americans.
You may already know this. Just saying...
"Crown must win" - Queen Mary
"State must win" - Pranab Da
Yeah
People must win
"Beta must win"--Sonia Vinci
Legacy of late Pranab Mukherji. Unpopular amongst chiefly Cairn energy and Vodaphone .
Extremely happy about this retrograde tax being dumped into the dustbin of history .
@@johnvalentino576 such orders take time to reverse . Better late than never .
@@johnvalentino576 SG already answered the reason why it wasn’t done.
Your beloved Pappu had accused suit boot ki sarkar. And then falls propaganda about Ambani-Adani will forcefully buy your farm land. Modi sarkar didn’t want to reverse it until the end to avoid these false propaganda.
@@johnvalentino576 do you have any reason how Adani got it unfairly?
Elon Musk made about $100 billion in 2020. From 30-35th richest to top 2 in the world. He must be doing corruption 😂
@@johnvalentino576 wait for my reply !! 🤣
@@johnvalentino576 you are right. It became too embarassing for GoI.
Few prime time shows are as informative on economy updates as CTC. I saw TV news today while having dinner and couldn't find a single mention of such an important development. Kudos to you and your team for covering this 😎👍🏻
Hi Aman. Glad you liked this episode about tax laws. Most important discussion today, considering the wide-ranging implications it will have in the future.
Dear SG - 1% of the population of J&K receive 9% of funds allocated to states by the Center. Isn't this unfair for other states? Also so little money trickles down to Jammu and Jammu has to fight for resources all the time. Blessed are ladakhi people who got rid of Kashmir.
Exactly. You have said it!
That's because Govt wants to develop Kashmir and Also most of it is also wasted on security
What Govt wants is to do something like the West and East Berlin thing so that people in POK get jealous of Indian Kashmir and become Anti Pak and it happens it will be much easy for India to capture because of No public Hindering
@@yasheekatripathi6883 Then what about Jammu. All development goes in Kashmir, flood relief, block development funds. And in return they throw stone at Indian Government. People of jammu should also start throwing stone. Rohingaya are getting free land in Jammu and no one is saying anything. On other hand Kashmiri Hindus faced persecution.
😂UP gets back 400% more in Central funds as compared to taxes that it provides to the centre. Similarly the otherBIMARUstates of Bihar/MP etc... And none of these are border states. And where do they stand in every parameter of development, infant mortality, BPL(below poverty line)/Hunger etc.....
The reality is that Shaikh Abdullah carried out the most successful land reforms Program in India and the average Kashmiri is 10 times better off than average Indian coming from theBimaruStates......whether it is on education, human development indices, finances, creativity, standard of living you name it. They are NOT likeTheBIMARUhungryUP/Bihari/MPstates....
The local Kashmiri recruits are heavily influenced by the institutions run by the religious organizations. No control over them could be exercised due to the state government. Even the school syllabus was tacitly propagating separatism. All those are in the process of being corrected. You don't judge merit of such policy shift so quickly.
Stop making false assumption about Kashmir, local militancy is only growing over the years.
@@TheWasim Should India correct the books and peacefully show the Kashmiris how it is in their interest to be in India? Or are you suggesting that all of this is useless, Kashmiris want to be like Afghanistan, in which case India's only option is to suppress Kashmiris with iron hand, like the Pakistanis and the Chinese do to their dissenters?
@@truthbringspeace9798 Kashmiri want like Afghanistan another assumption grow I suggest you. 👎
@@TheWasim I was asking you a question, not giving you my assumptions. If you can answer it, we can talk further.
@@truthbringspeace9798 and I was correcting his false assumptions not here to debate.
We need more privatization, not toxic capitalism like USA that uses prisoners for free labour but encourage our young minds to start companies and provide jobs to fellow Indians 👍
There is nothing wrong with capitalism as long aa there is competition. Capitalism becomes a problem when competition dies. A capitalist never wishes for a poor customer.
The thing is I don’t want to criticize USA methods as they are developed but yes, India should follow European model of development rather than USA model
india needs to follow the scandanavian model, not the american model.
That retrospective amendment in Tax Law was Shahbano of Taxation word. 😀
at last the govt. has done this. they could have done this much more gracefully earlier.
They have done it that is more important, Governemmebt if BJP has done it's of things policy-wise which will help in the long run, India as a country and people has very short-sighted thinking.
Better late than never. Now if the farm law, land-labour laws are passed and reservation & CAA-NRC ideas are removed then this nation can become a heaven for honest people. But that is wayy tooo much to ask for :(
@@bhargavdesai7984 others I do agree on. But farm law is something that is really needed for the marginal farmers brother. Politicisation should not discourage the much needed reforms.
The problem with bjp is that they always take too long to implement but I would prefer late implementation rather than no implementation
If they had done that, then that would have been opposed the farm laws are being opposed now. When did Shekhar Gupta really start panning the retrospective tax? Not when it was introduced, but when Pranab Mukherjee's book came out and Mukherjee was less than flattering in his references to the other SG. That is when this SG started how awful this retrospective tax was
People of ladakh and Jammu supported abrogation of article 370.❤️❤️
Lmfao, to be honest, I can get more knowledge from watching half an hour of CTC than from watching half a day of TV news
Half a day!!! Wow you must be really brave sir!!
I tried watching some of the clips CZcamsrs made of Arnab Goswami and the ilks for 5 mins and my brain got scrambled!!
@@jayantjolly did you like this episode on tax laws? Far-ranging implications, don’t you think?
@@ThePrintIndia Yes it is!! Considering I am in stock market and this news could act as boon for may companies. Also Voda/Idea share might see some heavy movements in coming few days!!
In total agreement on your assessment on retrospective tax. In fact I thought cancelling retrospective tax would be first move of Modi Govt in 2014, 7 years late nevertheless better late than never.
Modi is too slow but Modi is the only option 😑
Lets hope Vodafone bounces back as the 3rd proper competitor to jio and airtel.
Waiting for the "farmers" and enlightened opposition to start protesting about this now
SG, please start calling the UT/State as "J&K" or "Jammu and Kashmir".
When you keep calling it "Kashmir" and when you say "Kashmir is not happy under the surface about 370 abrogation", you keep ignoring Jammu.
If Jammu isn't important to "The Print", then you are another "hyphenated" media house.
bhai jammu has already experienced demography change. so j and k is correct.
Why not then just bifurcate J from K.
@@syedtalhasxr why not keep them together, and take care of both provinces? Both need attention, not just any one. Isn't it?
@@lovesharma4883 It's been done in Bihar, UP, AP, Odisa, TN, MP, etc etc. To start with there were just 14 large States. It was an administrative nightmare.
@@syedtalhasxr dil milne chahiye, administration toh ho ji jayega. 😊😊🙏🙏
Good job done by government.
Currently China is destroying it's image and business friendly policies.
We need to take advantage of it.
Just import duties needs to be reduced and we need to join rcep.
5 August must be declared as Big Design Day 😂
2019 abrogation 370
2020 Ram Mandir
2021 retrospective tax null and void
Why ram madir Savarkar ji?
@@neeljavia2965 modi lay Foundation of ram Mandir by him self
i was expecting Uniform Civil code decision today..may be next year Aug-5
@@Amal-os6tt Hope it happens as our Delhi High court stated the dire need of it.
But one thing that should be followed would be taking all religious organization as its stake holder thus not creating panic while its implementation.
@vikas Tell that to the fake id Savarkar.
I now remember and understand this Pranab Mukherjee story in more details now than my course subjects because Guptaji has explained it multiple times and different contexts.
I hope this comes in UPSC, Atleast 😂
If J&K poverty is only 5.4% , does this not mean that all insurgency is only Islamic ?
China level ki development bhi ek politically unfree logon ko khush nahi kar sakti
Ssssshh.... Pappy and Co will get offended😆😅
Exactly...Commies always say poverty leads to terrorism...jand k nullifying the theory once again...pandito ki property loot k kb tk khaoge..
PRANB MUKHERJEE be like "Its my BAT.. Therefore Only I get to BAT".
I be like : "You are telling that NOW??"
@Manish Singh That's exactly why the "BAT" analogy. "I have to always WIN attitude.
I was going to request a CTC on this very topic. Shekharji's delivery is better than Dominoes!
Smart
Good one, Prasson- had us tickling with laughter!
But Manmohan was a great prime minister with all finance acumen...
This proves it...
how
Shekhar Sir, even Syria's per capita income is higher than India, does that mean their life is better? To begin with, Kashmir started much higher than UP and Bihar. They were not exploited as badly by British as UP and Bihar were.
UP and Bihar have been gravely violated by the Indian the successive state governments in the past 70 years. Far worse than what has Kashmir faced. For you, terms like exploitation, freedom struggle and their likes are limited only in the spectrum of religion. Had Kashmir been a Hindu majority state/region (like it was 1000-1500 years back), we wouldn't have seen a so called "Freedom movement" in Kashmir at all. The problem lies with the minds of people.
BS statistic. Calling it right now. Go look up facts. Also, reporting the comment.
@Mayur Kanth I did not. The OP of this comment thread did. Also, Kashmir per capita income is multiple times that of the Syrian per capita income. Which is why I believe the original comment was disingenuous.
@@fangdog29 Kashmir's GDP per capita is US$ 1342 and Syria GDP per capita is US$ 2032. And if you consider Syria's GDP per capita in the 1980s when it was not war torn, the story is entirely different.
In 1996 Kashmir GDP per capita is Rs 8670 while Bihar was Rs.4000. GDP per capita of Kashmir has been higher than that of UP Bihar since independence itself.
When Shekhar sir's said Kashmir is not as poor as UP and Bihar, then he must understand that Kashmir was never as poor as UP and Bihar, so his comparison is incorrect.
Thoda comment ko padh liya karo achche se, neeche comment karne se pehle. Farasi mein naam dikha nahin ki oppose karne aa gaye bina baat.
@Mayur Kanth Whether you like it or not but Kashmir is war torn.
I wonder why Maharashtra never appears in any of Mr. Shekhar Gupta's statistical figures. I had earlier seen the one on population where he talked state wise statistics on fertility rate and now this one on poverty.
Probably because it's just average. Not at the very top of the list and neither at the bottom.
Now , all laws of Indian constituent is applicable in Kashmir ❤️❤️🇮🇳
What is the final conclusion on this issue ? Who will decide this ? As far as common sense goes , 1- Art 370 and Art 35 are gone for ever 2- All laws of Indian Union will be applicable in J & K 3- Governance in J & K is being improved . Local self govt is now functioning well 4- So long as terrorism is not fully controlled and Pandits are not fully restored , there is no question of statehood to J & K . If at all , it will be on Delhi model of statehood . 5- We are not bothered about business of politics by a few families of politicians like Abdullahs . He can go on cribbing and he should ! No one is bothered But politics can go on and on !!
There is frequent question on statehood ... Restoring pandits needs proper planning u just can't go say pandits will live here ...What will u do if something like 1980 happens again. ...Let's few things go slowly
To quote the low free food percentage as a measure of development seems to be misplaced. Kashmir might not have an established PDS mechanism to deliver it.
Not really. Kashmir has a very good economy for itself. Tourism contribution is around 20 percent. The rest from Agriculture and trade. Also a sizeable remittances from Kashmiris in the UK.
I miss those days when a cabinet minister won't heed to Prime minister's concern 😂😂
The same way Chidambaram changed the law to usurp Raja Mahmoodabad’s properties worth 30K crores. He as an advocate had lost the case in the Supreme Court, but as a minister he changed the law retrospectively to reverse the court judgment.
Today, I finally decided to officially become a CZcams member.
I am still a mere student so right now, I can only support through this but I would continue to support. 👍🏻
I appreciate that man. One benefit of subscribing as a cash strapped student is that you care to get the maximum bang from your buck, and the print is a good option since it has quite a few decent news shows. I especially recommend the one with Ila Patnaik.
Welcome to the fold, Ishan! Thank you for subscribing and supporting us.
Akshat, what other shows do you like?
@@ThePrintIndia Well it is hard to choose, quite a few good answers. But if I had to single out a few shows, I'd definitely like to put a good word in for the younger cohort of journalists who I think are catering to a crucial demographic segment that is often ignored, which is native Indian language speakers who understand and are interested in the wider anglophone policy and culture debates, but process and comment upon those debates primarily in Hindi/other native languages. In this respect Jyoti Yadav and Shanker Arnimesh have been doing quite well. As have the law and science experts. Perhaps a yet uncovered niche might be business news, especially the start-up world.
India will improve its ease of doing business ranking.
Vodaphone- "Look, we won't pay you 8,000 crore, there's no such law"
IT Department- "Yes there is.."
Cairn- "So your bill would be 12,000 crore...Cash or Card?"
IT Deparment- "Let me complete the statement...."
p.s.- Desclaimer: Before any IT guy reads it and decides to raid me, my CTC is 3.5 lakh..
What is CTC 3.5 lakh?
@@g1y3 Cost to Company. In simpler terms his salary per annum😊😊
@@jayantjolly thanks 😊
🤣🤣🤣
epic
Shekar is modest due to his ideology on Pranabda about the most stupid retrospective tax!!
Ideology apart, Pranab Mukherjee is a legendary character in Indian politics and not to mention, a former President of India. Any respect or circumspection in speaking of him and his legacy is due and warranted.
@@MultiCuldude so we respect the position someone formerly occupied instead of judging them on the basis of actions that had serious consequences? We need, desperately, to get out of the mentality of respecting for the sake of respecting.
@@fangdog29 thanks to our former Finance Minister n former President for having ransacked a business, the company n it's employees while protecting the country thro unpayable tax!!
Something tells me the reason is something more immediate: when the prospect of losing Air India planes (among other assets in France/Europe) to Cairns loomed large, better senses prevailed!
If poverty is low then why is Kashmir is cribbing? This state is the most pampered state. Why is the government spending so much money
BJP has decided to play fearlessly now. Like Sehwag. They have seen the worst behaviour by opposition and do not fear anymore.
Excellent review on both the topics. My personal experience posted on Kashmir for more than ten years (mid seventies to late eighties) and traveling extensively to the deep interiors, there were hardly any families deprived of basic survival needs like roti, kapda and makan.Thanks once again for the excellent coverage on both topics.
an acquisition like this would make the Global minimum tax rate a reality😅
Finally Govt of India has shown some courage and made the right choice.
No criticism for Congress, that passed such a law.
Mr. Gupta has always been an avid Congress supporter or atleast close to the Gandhi family. He would like to inform of the move BJP has made but also would not like to upset Congress and will also tk a step to justify what mindset Pranab M. had while taking such a step.
Shekhar ji's delivery is like Monty Python, in the sense that every time when you feel like the narrative is getting recursive, he reprises himself with an episode of such originality that you're hooked back in again. Wonderful, nuanced episode of CTC
By passing retrospective law, Pranab da shuts the door on many investers from democratic countries and open the doors to chinesse investers.
Sir as an Indian from Ladakh I must disagree with you . Yes conditions were better for Kashmir as the leaders spent most of the center money on a small region but it was the people of Ladakh who were suffering . There were no universities , no hospitals ,no infrastructure in Ladakh . Even a small town like Anantnag has better facilities than Leh ..4G network came to Srinagar in 2016 but it took two more years to make Leh 4G ...This is why Ladakh had been demanding a separation from JK since the early 50s and now things are much better New Hospitals are being built , new roads are being constructed and for the first time ever Ladakh has its own university .
Haha finally that damn tax goes away seven years after the promise was made, better late than never 😅
PS- Next up should be the reform of the 2013 land law
Had the law been repealed earlier people would have said govt has favoured corporate sector by repealing the law when cases were still in arbitration.
Amazing Unbiased balanced analysis. The good and bad both points were nicely kept. If there is one channel which deserves PM Modi's interview it is definitely THE PRINT
Thank you for talking about vodafone case, just yesterday i tweeted about you to make CTC on this recent development
i hope print starts a business section soon, as there are limited articles on topic like these related to markets
This is good action. Jaitly should have done it long back but he said it is under supreme court review. After losing in international courts both financially as well as morally, Indian government has finally learnt the lesson.
M just watin for Chidambaram's article on Indian express condemning this move 😂😂😂..lol
Modi Inc. Needs 2 centuries to correct past mistakes. So much for their understanding and competence. Yet, we appreciate this belated enlightened in taxation policy.
Well, let’s just say I am glad my investment was worth it😉👍
Note: investment= vote, nothing else
Finally Vlad is glad
The only unbiased channel i see on the internet! Great work guys!
At least the UPA government acts like a allmighty sovereign even after having a weak numbers. Elected to office and getting to power are different things. Governence take much more confidence, expertise , experience and wisdom.
UPA is nothing but a mum trying make here kids future by all means even tho. He is useless. Filled with nepotism
Quality Journalism!! Thank u Shekhar sir for explaining so clearly along with the history of things.
Thank God we have a Modi gov. In the center!
"Who do you think you are, I am Bharat Sarkaar" - Nice One
This CTC should follow with a CTC on Kashimiri Hindus history
i become wise by listening each CTC. Shekhar ji voice and thoughts help us to look at issue in neutral way. I read some articles on this but was not able to comprehend it, but with CTC now I can.
Congratulations to modi govt
Sanctity of contracts has been restored
Would pranab have done it without blessings of NAC gang?
Or was it at their instance ?
Sharp left turn or Rahul shows that congress is now a communist party
I only watch this to see your honesty to work and how excited you still are after such a long career in journalism
Hi Bhavya, do keep watching #CutTheClutter.
That's why clear mandate is must ....
Retrospective tax law was the last gift by Congress to India and its business community.
August 5 is a pious day
This speaks so loud of your just & fair journalism, SGji. In 99.99 % cases, I'm a doubting Thomas about this Government's legislative misadventures on the strength of majoritarisnism. But mending "Dada retro tax" is the most rational output of this government thus far. Only Modi's political capital & courage can do such miracles.
Maybe the reason for low poverty in J&K is that India invest alot in J&K at the expense of rest of the country?
Maybe! Not making any claims.
Tell me if i am wrong.
No compensation were given for internet blockade for over a year, you have no idea how many young people lost their internet entrepreneurship opportunities and yet you think the govt was giving the JK more than rest of the country.. when the package is given it also includes infrastructure needed by the army as when convoy uses the roads common men aren't allowed to use them. More than thousands of crores were lost in transportation sector only, and yet no compensation was given. compensation was given
Been searching for this info...finally, I have acquired a comprehensive understanding of this complex issue. Wow, sire 👊. The dude abides.
Manmohan Singh is an amazing politician-
1. He gets credit for 1991 reforms where PVNR had bigger role, MMS was just implementer
2. He doesn't get any bad press for retrospective tax, all blame goes to Pranab, while MMS was PM
It is good that bad law of retrospective tax has been reversed. There was one more cade of ITC Ltd, who won excise case in SC. Mr. Chidambaram was FM. He changed law with retrospective effect. Company lost some 700 Cr refund from GOI. That wad equally bad.
Now Govt should declare that no tax will be changed retrospectively. Any change should be prospective.
Before Vodafone, there was Hutch, even before it was Orange
The decision by the government is outstandingly good...of all the decisions taken by Pranab Mukherjee this was the worst and had the effect of undoing all the good work done by Narsimha Rao and Manmohan Singh. However this was not the only bad decision taken by him and because of his pre eminent position of the Congress party. He said on the floor of the house that orop was not technically, administratively and financially feasible. So though the Modi government has not given a perfect orop it is a vast improvement on the policy of the Congress party and I don't thinl any defence person serving or retired would grudge the government knowing inherent financial constraints. So on the issue of retrospective tax being withdrawn the Modi government deserves full hearted praise
A public demonstration of the pathetic business environment in India ... Govt acting as local gunda demanding hafta arbitrarily and now scurrying to back off after companies refusing to be bullied. UPA era law could have been repealed years ago but the BJP milked it to benefit Ambani's Jio and Anil Aggarwal's Vedanta. The statement is clear, to do business in India, you better suck up to the Government. No wonder global manufacturers decided not to invest here despite the pandemic and situation in China. Irrespective of who is in power, India will have a perpetual "STAY AWAY" sign for businesses.
Sir it’s like a honey into my ears listening to you!! Thanks a lot for this enlightening analysis leaving nothing behind ……You truly show what journalism is supposed to do and instill indomitable faith in the good journalism!!
SG should cover Hockey performance in Olympics after the women's bronze medal match tomorrow.
Not a basket case at the expense of all other states who were receiving less money all these years. Justice has been done. All citizens are special.
Also you didn’t mention good work on Infrastructure (road, rail, power) happening there. Your own reporter who interviewed LG was able to draw out good things happening there. please watch that interview ;)
Excellent episode, I come here for true stories, without any cover, and to gain deep knowledge, and so far not got disappointed. Excellent work, keep it up👍
We used to have Hutch sim card back in the days. Remember the scratch card with Rahul Dravid's sweep in the front of it?
Der aye durust aye. Good to see that this abomination of a law has been rolled back and govt is trying to settle the cases.
Dada was savage🤣. He poked the bear in the eyes and then beat his ass with the bat.🤣🤣🤣
I liked this quality of guptaji. He always judge govt on merit.
did anyone notice some negative points that SG highlighted are the same highlighted by Hurriyat yesterday.
One reason for the poverty index being low in Kashmir is the enormous amounts of money pumped into that state disproportionate to the other Indian states. I expected a person of Sekar Gupta's calibre to bring that out also.