Nell Irvin Painter: The History of White People

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 25. 11. 2012
  • In "The History of White People," Nell Irvin Painter tells perhaps the most important forgotten story in American history. Beginning at the roots of Western civilization, she traces the invention of the idea of a white race - often for economic, scientific, and political ends. This lecture was presented by The Harvard Book Store and recorded on 3/29/10.
    View more lectures at: / wgbhforum .
    This talk was taped on March 29, 2010.

Komentáře • 1,1K

  • @Anointed012
    @Anointed012 Před 10 lety +98

    @ MrAwrsomeness , Africa isnt a country its a continent.

    • @josephatnip2398
      @josephatnip2398 Před 4 lety +12

      Right Africa is not a country it's a continent but then America also isn't a country it also is a consonant but when you say America anywhere in the world people automatically assume the United States

    • @MegaDiva1999
      @MegaDiva1999 Před 4 lety +3

      thank you and thank you. Cannot believe that people are still this disrepectful and ignorant

    • @ItsNotRealLife
      @ItsNotRealLife Před 3 lety +4

      I've been telling people this for years.
      Most 'Americans' don't even know know that 'America' stretches all the way from Greenland in the North to Tierra del Fuego in Argentina in the south.
      Jamaicans, Mexicans and Candaians are American

    • @uncannyvalley2350
      @uncannyvalley2350 Před 2 lety

      Also Asia, Australia, Europe, Antarctica, wahoo

    • @antonpalmer-smith4829
      @antonpalmer-smith4829 Před 2 lety +1

      @@johnhanson6900 I see you ain't too bright...silly ofay

  • @ymanning2347
    @ymanning2347 Před 2 lety +22

    Let's say a white person can't know black culture but u know black people can be experts in white culture

    • @kudjoeadkins-battle2502
      @kudjoeadkins-battle2502 Před rokem

      Black people live in a white culture. Educated in a white society and constantly fed ideas of white normalcy just like white folks. We live in your world, you don’t live in ours.

    • @jjbentley9
      @jjbentley9 Před rokem +2

      They can't you're right

    • @philipwright9736
      @philipwright9736 Před rokem +2

      NO ONE SAID THAT THEY COULD, YOU'RE REACHING HERE

    • @kudjoeadkins-battle2502
      @kudjoeadkins-battle2502 Před 10 měsíci

      Seriously though I do think it’s stupid to suggest that white peoples can’t empathize or understand black American culture. I mean it is an American culture. I think that sometimes many mainstream Americans don’t want to understand

    • @Lerf8
      @Lerf8 Před 9 měsíci +2

      ​@@philipwright9736 I don't know if someone was to make a speech the opposite complexion of her about the same topi don't know if it will go as well

  • @hperrio
    @hperrio Před 9 lety +47

    Guys, she wasn't "white bashing." Too many people try to input hate where there is none. Chillax.

    • @Oztinfrog
      @Oztinfrog Před 5 lety +6

      She is saying we are a social construct

    • @jbagger331
      @jbagger331 Před 5 lety +6

      No, she was spinning some BS, physical traits are not a concept, they are real and influence the lives of individuals, some people obviously need more sunscreen, that's not a concept or a mere idea, that's manifest physical reality.

    • @dangelo1369
      @dangelo1369 Před 9 měsíci

      @@jbagger331So why don’t you read “The Invention of The White Race”? Or “White Trash: The Hiistory of Race Class in America”? “When Affirmative Action Was White”? “White Fragility”? “The Souls of White Folks”? “White Rage”?And my favorite essay “America’s Problen Is That White People Want To Make It A Failed State.”.
      All of these books and the essay, have been thoroughly researched and they are hard to put down. Imagine your history to be so bad that you want to outlaw people from learning about it? That’s y’all.

    • @Lerf8
      @Lerf8 Před 9 měsíci

      She is just a fool that's all

  • @t3tsuyaguy1
    @t3tsuyaguy1 Před 2 lety +28

    When I was a kid, Poles and Slavs were still very much considered non-white; so much so, that I have friend who hid that she's Polish, at the behest of her father, because she passes for white. The first time I heard someone accuse a Polish person of having "White Privilege" I was totally taken aback and confused.

    • @autochthonoushistory1
      @autochthonoushistory1 Před 2 lety +4

      Those are white people even the pale Asians are white tf 🤣🤣🤣 open your eyes.

    • @youarewrong5523
      @youarewrong5523 Před rokem

      That’s amazing I’m half Polish Italian so I guess I must be hair black that’s hilarious

    • @t3tsuyaguy1
      @t3tsuyaguy1 Před rokem +1

      @@youarewrong5523 ?

    • @Aham-Na
      @Aham-Na Před rokem +6

      Absolutely un real these ppl are here to divide Europeans

    • @jenisejackson5408
      @jenisejackson5408 Před 11 měsíci

      Race is a social construct. That is why when some say racism will die out when the old white men die is completely false. There has been a shift over the past twenty years that some Latinos will be considered "white". Especially since the Latinos are fast growing population in America.

  • @Khadijah459
    @Khadijah459 Před 9 lety +96

    Napoléon said "History is a SET of lies agreed upon"......wow!

    • @MultiEightiesgirl
      @MultiEightiesgirl Před 8 lety +2

      +dijah “Deejay” anwar I love this quote. :)

    • @fednorduclona2921
      @fednorduclona2921 Před 4 lety

      D'facing by him aren't two foot of shits........,

    • @londorsey9626
      @londorsey9626 Před 3 lety

      His mind was warped by his life and dominating spirit. The story of him could be based upon his perception and not an intent to fabricate a story. And the lie is the creation of a future truth for whatever reason as lore, or....

    • @ucanthandledatruth01
      @ucanthandledatruth01 Před 3 lety

      @@londorsey9626 eurocentrism itself is based upon the perception and consciousness of Europeans. it sculpts our own perceptions and consciousness, I believe. and the psychology in total is warped. psychologists and psychiatrists have officially recognized it to be psychopathic, which mesns it produces sociopaths

    • @jmilk5051
      @jmilk5051 Před 2 lety

      ucanthandledatruth01 right

  • @Wooddweller
    @Wooddweller Před 8 měsíci +5

    Glad that this popped up on my feed. So many informative videos have been coming up. That’s awesome.

    • @eyeam2123
      @eyeam2123 Před 6 měsíci

      Ying yang. Vise versa.

    • @dpm2515
      @dpm2515 Před 18 dny

      what simple, effective & biting sarcasm. It made me chuckle... to appreciate & be excited about this & other "informative" vids popping up in your feed lol... that's analogous to me appreciating and being excited about the "vitamins / nutritional benefits" associated with shoving/popping a duralog (insta fire, paper wrapped wood log) up my @ss

  • @carlhayes1972
    @carlhayes1972 Před 8 lety +75

    I find it unnecessary to discuss sophisticated topics of humanity with anyone unwilling to study. The result of trying to discuss topics such as race with someone not studied will resemble the comment section. I would recommend that a person stay clear of this type of subject matter if not educated on the topic. Go on and live your life. Learn from the people you meet as you move through your community. Do not waste your time on topics that require knowledge that you are unwilling to acquire.

    • @dapperblue1764
      @dapperblue1764 Před 6 lety +4

      Fantastic comment!

    • @coleslaw1196
      @coleslaw1196 Před 5 lety

      How about some TRUE super-advanced black African civilization? makeagif.com/gif/the-founders-of-civilazation-qFh2xX czcams.com/video/M5__rWswzbo/video.html

    • @Tigerbythetoe
      @Tigerbythetoe Před 5 lety +4

      I think that discussion about this topic with those people who may not be as educated as yourself is the way to further understanding. Obviously Ms. Painter knows a whole hell of a lot more than I do for instance. That doesn’t mean that I have no reason for agreeing or disagreeing with her or anyone else, because of my limited understanding, since there are plenty of other people speaking on this topic with contradictory viewpoints. We have to risk insulting people to further our ability to think and speak about things, like race, which are potentially inflammatory. So we should risk being wrong to discover the truth. No one knows all there is to know about the topic of race, and education is relative.

    • @jbagger331
      @jbagger331 Před 5 lety

      And if somebody had acquired it you would immediately say that that individual hasn't correctly interpreted scripture.

    • @flatearth9140
      @flatearth9140 Před 5 lety +2

      LOL YOU SOUND LIKE A STUPID PERSON TRYING TO SOUND SMART !!!!!!!

  • @sunflowersneed8631
    @sunflowersneed8631 Před 10 lety +5

    where do u think classical music originating from?

  • @nataniellek
    @nataniellek Před 11 lety +52

    The illusion of inclusion.

  • @TickTockIsrael
    @TickTockIsrael Před 10 lety +11

    im at 17.00 whens the good part?

  • @scottswindle1623
    @scottswindle1623 Před 2 lety +8

    Good video. Informative.

  • @BaddieLuvsBaddies
    @BaddieLuvsBaddies Před 8 lety +1

    book is on Audible...

  • @derekdrake8706
    @derekdrake8706 Před 2 lety +77

    "She finds out she has one drop of black blood and thinks her life is over, do you think that would happen now?"
    That actually reminds me of a video I saw where a girl reads her DNA test results and finds out her ancestors were primarily from Europe and not Africa then she breaks down into tears lol.

    • @jade20156893
      @jade20156893 Před 2 lety +6

      I'd like to believe I wouldn't but I'd cry myself to sleep lol

    • @theend3541
      @theend3541 Před 2 lety

      @Daruki Neo right here buddy czcams.com/video/0FnZOGB4C-c/video.html lol it’s pretty funny. I think the girl deleted it after posting because she was getting backlash. And for good reason. You can’t change your race, just get along with people but clearly she has an issue being white lol

    • @mbormann6046
      @mbormann6046 Před 2 lety +17

      There goes the free College and affirmative action preferences in jobs.

    • @stupidgenius924
      @stupidgenius924 Před 2 lety

      @@mbormann6046 only “non-Black” people qualify for “free” college, if they attend an HBCU. White women are the first “marginalized” group of people protected by affirmative action, Civil Rights, or any other legislation.

    • @brittanyhayes1043
      @brittanyhayes1043 Před 2 lety

      Lol what a snowflake.

  • @fenixfloeimobent.988
    @fenixfloeimobent.988 Před 9 lety +3

    who was europe named after

    • @Amenclass8
      @Amenclass8 Před 9 lety

      fenix floe imob ent. Its supposed to be named after no one in particular, actually Europe describes the terrain of how the mountains rope u in

    • @Huganis
      @Huganis Před 9 lety +6

      fenix floe imob ent. Europa from the greak myths.

    • @terrycoker2862
      @terrycoker2862 Před 5 lety

      From Jim Bob Europe

  • @SyndromeStock
    @SyndromeStock Před 11 lety +1

    Can anyone tell me which movie she's referring to @26:10 ?

  • @emilyschmidt5630
    @emilyschmidt5630 Před 3 lety +1

    Too bad this isn't properly captioned. I can't use it class without proper captions.

    • @j.rebekah8605
      @j.rebekah8605 Před rokem +2

      You shouldn't use this as a teaching tool. Are you shaming little kids into thinking they are racist. Shame

    • @emilyschmidt5630
      @emilyschmidt5630 Před rokem +2

      @@j.rebekah8605 I teach college, and I'm not shaming anybody. I simply refuse to pretend racism doesn't exist and isn't part of US & world history.

    • @jesssingleton1200
      @jesssingleton1200 Před 10 měsíci

      ​@@j.rebekah8605that's exactly what schools are doing, they want white kids to feel shame and guilt for being born white and if you're white you are automatically deemed guilty for everything and anything another white person has done.

  • @dfro3723
    @dfro3723 Před 9 lety +40

    I'm only about ten minutes in and it seems she has a recurring contradictions in terms she doesn't seem to contest the biological differences in races but at the same time denies the existence of race. I think we all can agree that judging someone on the basis of race shouldn't be done. But burying your head and denying that any differences at least biological exist.

    • @greeny202ab
      @greeny202ab Před 9 lety +12

      This is a very misunderstood area. There is no biological justification for the concept of race amongst Homo Sapiens, we are all too genetically similar but to deny differences between groups is absurd.

    • @1611kjvbibleone
      @1611kjvbibleone Před 9 lety +3

      Greeny202a DOCTORS CAN TAKE A SKULL AND TELL WHICH RACE IT IS....OUR BLOOD IS DEFFRENT. ADAM WAS THE NEW WHITE MAN....... THERE WERE PRE-ADAMITES AND THEIR CHILDREN ARE STILL HERE.....

    • @greeny202ab
      @greeny202ab Před 9 lety +16

      1611kjvbibleone
      There is no biological justification for the concept of race amongst Homo Sapiens.
      Give me one trait that is carried by any of the so called races that is carried by all members of that so called race and is not carried by any others?
      Also writing in capitals will not give your horseshit any credibility.

    • @1611kjvbibleone
      @1611kjvbibleone Před 9 lety +5

      YES THERE IS.. BUT YOU SATANIC PEOPLE WANT EVERYBODY TO BELIEVE [ EVRYTHING IS THE SAME ] , [ WE ARE ALL ONE..] BUT IS A LION AND A COW THE SAME ? NO IS A SNAKE AND A EAGLE THE SAME ? NO WHY IS IT THE DOCTORS CAN TELL RIGHT OFF WHICH RACE A SKULL IS... IS A HUMAN AND A PIG THE SAME RACE ? NO BUT THEY HAVE USED PIG PARTS IN HUMAN'S AND THEY USE COWS TO PRODUCE HUMAN BLOOD. LOOK IT UP. AND MUCH MORE....

    • @greeny202ab
      @greeny202ab Před 9 lety +2

      1611kjvbibleone
      If you cannot give me a trait that is shared by every member of a certain race and that is not carried by any others then you cannot argue for races amongst homo Sapiens.
      Just stating that there is in block capitals just makes you look like a fucking idiot.

  • @RebelRampant
    @RebelRampant Před 11 lety +5

    I don't disagree with the crux of this statement: I don't accept "white" for a racial designation. "White" is a racist term which dilutes the history of those of us of European dissent and I think that consequence is accomplished purposefully. "Black" is a term Ive been forced to use though. Growing up in BK, using any other term than that or African-American meant you were fighting. So the Black community needs to decide what they want to be called. But haplogroup subclads dictate race. Period.

    • @Musick79
      @Musick79 Před 2 lety +2

      Whites did not originate in Europe but in Asia.

    • @uncannyvalley2350
      @uncannyvalley2350 Před 2 lety +1

      Races don't exist, we are all the same species, that's why the term racist denotes ignorance and bigotry, the belief that we are different sub species, when we are all just different populations of the same species

    • @RebelRampant
      @RebelRampant Před 2 lety

      @@uncannyvalley2350 lmfaoo

    • @uncannyvalley2350
      @uncannyvalley2350 Před 2 lety

      @@RebelRampant well you convinced me, Professor Derp
      🤪👍

    • @brittanyhayes1043
      @brittanyhayes1043 Před 2 lety +2

      I di t mind bei g called white as I'm uses to being called white by everyone. I love being of European decent.

  • @mega-lomart7154
    @mega-lomart7154 Před 2 lety +2

    I must be getting too spicy on CZcams because it keeps recommended me things like this

  • @shannondamnit4544
    @shannondamnit4544 Před 3 lety +10

    I love how their are no hecklers, love this and love that rooms Energy

  • @stopdestroyingeverything1968

    Shes bonkers

  • @bestbet8794
    @bestbet8794 Před rokem +2

    Caucus mountain where they come from

    • @NacerDeArriba
      @NacerDeArriba Před rokem +1

      Yeah. From mount aratar where noah ark landed. All noah descendatns were whyte.

  • @RebelRampant
    @RebelRampant Před 11 lety +5

    Thats not what Haplogroup/DNA dictates.
    There most definitely ARE distinct races. A race does NOT have to be 100% absolutely 'pure' in order to exist. "Black" ppl do not have a genetic predisposition to Sickle-cell disease because of ideology or poverty. The hypocrisy in claiming that 'race' is an ideology while suggesting this 'no-race' position ISNT an ideology is hysterical & absurd, not to mention divorced from the science & reality .
    I don't know what YOU are, but I know who I am.

    • @uncannyvalley2350
      @uncannyvalley2350 Před 2 lety +1

      You're referring to different populations of the same race, there's only one race, humans
      That's why it's called a haplotype, not a race

  • @NPC-fr6wo
    @NPC-fr6wo Před 5 lety +10

    9:12
    Nice watch, is that swiss?

  • @malcolmjelani3588
    @malcolmjelani3588 Před 3 lety +4

    Is she reading the entire book?

  • @meis
    @meis Před 8 lety +5

    31:09 People in Mediterranean (Italy, etc.) can also be "white tan", not just pink-ish.

  • @robertwilliams9115
    @robertwilliams9115 Před 7 lety +14

    To the negative comments here...she is a qualified historian that educates one on the existence of white slavery during the course of time...some of you whites always claim that whites were slaves...well she sharing thru her videos thru her extensive research the validity of the part of history

    • @venetia6296
      @venetia6296 Před 6 lety +4

      Robert Williams ....exactly. Nell Irvin Painter is an American historian notable for her works on southern history of the nineteenth century. She is retired from Princeton University, and served as president of the Organization of American Historians. (Wikipedia)

    • @voidisyinyangvoidisyinyang885
      @voidisyinyangvoidisyinyang885 Před 5 lety +3

      yes it's a fascinating, well-researched book.

  • @Hellsconsort
    @Hellsconsort Před 9 lety +36

    Whether race is real or not, it still exists as a political, abstract concept; and the people saying 'race doesn't exist! Racism is wrong!' are typically the people supporting affirmative action/positive discrimination - i.e. racism, and treating people different based on race. Supported in droves by blacks and women.

    • @lisaspeakstruth4646
      @lisaspeakstruth4646 Před 5 lety +5

      Supported by blacks and feminist women.

    • @flatearth9140
      @flatearth9140 Před 5 lety +1

      SO YOU THINK RACISM IS OK ?? TO SAY ALL BLACK PEOPLE ARE BAD IS OK ?? OR EVERY SINGLE SAIAN PERSON IS CHEAP ?? YOU ARE A TYPICAL RACIST !!

    • @uncannyvalley2350
      @uncannyvalley2350 Před 2 lety +7

      And yet using the accident of birth as some kind of advantage or right over others is about as weak minded as weak minded gets. People don't have an issue with people being different colors, the issue comes when self righteous bigots think it gives them an excuse for excluding other people's rights based on arbitrary claims

    • @brittanyhayes1043
      @brittanyhayes1043 Před 2 lety

      Supported by people who are racist to white people and no respect to history.

    • @geekmeee
      @geekmeee Před rokem

      “Exterminate All The Brutes”
      czcams.com/video/dQ4r3Qdrqmo/video.html

  • @mrs.morris5506
    @mrs.morris5506 Před 4 lety +3

    Did this entire video consist of reading a book?

    • @mrs.morris5506
      @mrs.morris5506 Před 3 lety +1

      @Alex Israel
      The point is... I can read the book myself. It's a waste of a video to spend the entire space reading to the audience. Painter is usually a better presenter.

    • @DroppinJewelzz
      @DroppinJewelzz Před 2 lety +1

      @@mrs.morris5506 never a waste...

  • @juliewoods6534
    @juliewoods6534 Před rokem

    what is your point?

  • @lastlevel3457
    @lastlevel3457 Před 3 lety +7

    Her aura is great ❗️

  • @PastaPatate
    @PastaPatate Před 2 lety +4

    “White" is simply a pseudonym for those who identify Europe as their ancestral origin.

    • @Hyberlol
      @Hyberlol Před 2 lety

      And then.....I guess black is simply a term for those who identify as being from Africa?

    • @salimapeacejoy
      @salimapeacejoy Před 2 lety

      @@Hyberlol black is a term whites in power gave to identify those who origins are from Africa.

    • @Hyberlol
      @Hyberlol Před 2 lety

      Wrong. White is a biological condition. Black is a biological condition. Yellow is a biological condition.

    • @pamedarix8814
      @pamedarix8814 Před rokem

      Etymology....
      Whi=To ask who what where, childlike (hebrew)
      Ite= A native

    • @kudjoeadkins-battle2502
      @kudjoeadkins-battle2502 Před rokem

      @@Hyberlolyes

  • @ilm_seeker
    @ilm_seeker Před 7 lety +14

    This was a really good discussion. I think I will go and buy her book. Thanks for posting.

  • @mindfulmoneymojolifestyle
    @mindfulmoneymojolifestyle Před měsícem

    Her voice has a similar tone to Alice Walker.

  • @taritabumbray1683
    @taritabumbray1683 Před 6 lety

    change
    reach for sky by change

  • @generalpurpose9735
    @generalpurpose9735 Před 2 lety +7

    We have made every effort to clearly say, and prove, that the so-called White, and White-like, rulers and ruling elite in the former lands of so-called Black civilizations, are not who they claim to be. Specifically; those of Egypt are NOT Egyptians, those of North Africa are NOT Berbers, those of Arabia are NOT Arabs, those of Palestine are NOT Hebrews, those of Lebanon are NOT Phoenicians, those of Iraq are NOT Mesopotamian's, those of Iran are NOT Persians or Elamites, those of Turkey are NOT Anatolians - THEY ARE ALL CENTRAL ASIAN TURKS! By ways of Georgia Russia through the Caucasus mountains going back to ancient Petra.

    • @elindioedwards7041
      @elindioedwards7041 Před 2 lety

      Please. You are promoting Afrocentric and /or Hebrew Israelite nonsense that is easily debunked. Ancient civilizations left some pretty good evidence as to what they looked like. With the exception of maybe Egypt none of the civilizations you mentioned were black. As for this lady and the passive PBS centric audience listening to her I think we all can identify white people for the most part. Yes, what is defined as white has changed. But caucasoid morphology can readily be identified. The Greeks, Sythians, Romans may not be white per se by 19 century standards but they were easily identified as caucasoids who spoke Indo European languages, shared caucasoid morphology, and carried paternal markers r1a and r1b. No amount of wokeness and political correctness will change that.

  • @michelleradford5956
    @michelleradford5956 Před 2 lety +5

    😊 Love this woman 🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾💯💯💯

  • @RebelRampant
    @RebelRampant Před 11 lety +6

    To say that I am no less black than someone who just immigrated here from subsaharan Africa is absolutely insane.
    I'm not inclined to having ongoing dialogue with someone who can't even admit what their own minds clearly see but insist on forcing them shut to perpetuate such ignorance.

    • @NeedMorePlebs
      @NeedMorePlebs Před 2 lety +4

      you wrote this comment 8 years ago 😳 are you still alive?

    • @kudjoeadkins-battle2502
      @kudjoeadkins-battle2502 Před 10 měsíci

      What does less black mean? There is no such thing as a black race either.

  • @ziggi08able
    @ziggi08able Před 11 lety +10

    Viva-la-difference; variety being the spice of life 'n' all. I can't be racist because I don't believe we belong to different races. Different ethnicities certainly -with sub-straters of said ethnicities- but not multiple races. We're animals that have adapted to our respective environments and look the way we do as a consequence - can't argue with that. The terms black & white to categorise Africans and Europeans are figurative not literal. They are mean't to divide and denigrate, ie: racism.

  • @Ksickle2008
    @Ksickle2008 Před 4 lety +8

    The statement about light and dark is quite questionable. The question is who asked that. Let me guess. Karen

  • @valkeryie11
    @valkeryie11 Před 8 lety +8

    great informative video

  • @mendali
    @mendali Před 5 lety +8

    she's great!

  • @awbonn
    @awbonn Před 9 lety +4

    good summary of the Book which must be read slowly!!!!

  • @mimi-thevirtuousqueen-ofcl1927

    Christ Jesus said it himself judge not according to appearance but judge righteous judgement!- in John 7:25!

    • @mmccrownus2406
      @mmccrownus2406 Před 2 lety +2

      People liked the idea of judgment based upon character, until people start to judge them based upon their character. Then they change it to wanting to be judged upon their species aka race.

    • @augustusbrown5320
      @augustusbrown5320 Před rokem

      @@mmccrownus2406 ❤

    • @jjbentley9
      @jjbentley9 Před rokem +2

      Yes Jesus was a caux😮 you warship us

    • @do-notuse3821
      @do-notuse3821 Před 11 měsíci

      " EAT ME,FOR THE PASTA IS YUMMY"
      - THE FLYING SPHAGETTI MONSTER 3:23 😂

  • @NPC-fr6wo
    @NPC-fr6wo Před 5 lety +37

    5:56 - 6:01
    That has to be some of the thickest irony on CZcams right now hahaha.
    So, who's inventing cultural fantasy?

    • @victoriankambe3070
      @victoriankambe3070 Před 4 lety +2

      D Nicole you wish

    • @dominicfaison5889
      @dominicfaison5889 Před 3 lety +6

      I don’t know why you time stamped this but pointing this out to make some unfounded assertion means you have missed the whole point of this presentation

    • @r.salisbury133
      @r.salisbury133 Před 3 lety

      you

    • @carpejkdiem
      @carpejkdiem Před 3 lety +4

      Occult science so called scientists puppets for the elite from all nations under the UNITED NATIONS FLAT EARTH BANNER from the polytheist OCCULTISTS returning vailed religion called SCIENTISM that ironically pushes Helios the sun 🌞 deity globe earth worship & the blind faith forced indoctrination religion of racist savages program called EVOLUTION 🤔 under the lie that atheism provided isn't a religion. HaSatan is the father of lies & master of deception.
      Look into who started the space programming and predictive programming & the fact that what was science fiction when I was a child you all now are sold its science fact = predictive programming.
      Then look up who was used at the same time as the space programming to start the TAVISTOCK INSTITUTE AGENDA.
      Then look up here on yt a video called - The TAVISTOCK INSTITUTE AGENDA & take notes.
      Then look up the Beatles & all the bands created by the TAVISTOCK INSTITUTE to shape the minds of the masses through the muse that makes us sick industry.
      Who shapes what we think how we think what we dress like each generation whats pop cult 🤔 culture ect..
      Then look up the
      ● HEGELIAN DIALECTIC METHOD DEVIDE THEN CONQUER METHOD
      Then
      ● www.Threeworldwars.com
      ● www.StoptheCrime.net
      ● AGENDA 21/2030
      ALICE A BAILEYS PRE-PLANNED
      ● 50 YEAR 10 POINT PLAN
      ● The GREAT WORK

    • @Stony_daGodfrmjerz
      @Stony_daGodfrmjerz Před 2 lety

      @@carpejkdiem you a caucusoid trying to get there soul when you transcend over to the higher demison for telling that truth 💯👁

  • @goingbonkerswithmyhonkers9374

    What about the Barbary slave trade? The slaves were white... Just a century ago

  • @stilllookingforthetruth4465

    I love learning props

  • @wiltonsimons3951
    @wiltonsimons3951 Před 10 lety +6

    I am going to assume that you are white if I am wrong then correct me. I am a black male that reads a lot of social issue and generally the books do somehow come back around to blaming white people for a large portion black problems. I have to say that you are right and much as it pains to to say that. There are a lot of black that get degree in black studies instead of sciences and maths. There are reasons why but not going to get into that. Your post is one of the few that makes sense

    • @jokullmanii3674
      @jokullmanii3674 Před 4 lety

      bruhh you are awesome

    • @uncannyvalley2350
      @uncannyvalley2350 Před 2 lety

      Yes, because enslaving a people for several centuries while your communities accrue wealth from stolen land and privilege is totally not a thing 🙄

  • @mustafael-amin9163
    @mustafael-amin9163 Před 2 lety +6

    Sheeple:do you think the devil is gonna invite someone who’s not going to tell a sanitized version of THEIR SCRIPT?She has a plate of butter biscuits too...they’re just warming!

  • @stevenhoskins7850
    @stevenhoskins7850 Před 2 lety +1

    I'm gland science didn't get in the way of the ludicrous premise.

  • @sandrasackey4851
    @sandrasackey4851 Před 2 lety +1

    Million times you tell people Africa is not a Country but a Continent

  • @eddiegilbey3846
    @eddiegilbey3846 Před rokem +3

    Well at least we’ve got a history 👍

    • @kudjoeadkins-battle2502
      @kudjoeadkins-battle2502 Před rokem

      You missed the point. There is no “We”. What people we refer to as white who lived in Ancient Rome had nothing to do with people we would call white from the British isles

    • @kudjoeadkins-battle2502
      @kudjoeadkins-battle2502 Před rokem +1

      But we as have history

    • @SultanMuhammad-vc3do
      @SultanMuhammad-vc3do Před měsícem

      Yall barley have a history
      Yall don’t have a history past 6,000 years so shh

  • @philiproyd6563
    @philiproyd6563 Před 10 lety +5

    Good point!

  • @happygucci5094
    @happygucci5094 Před 7 měsíci

    This was a subtle quietly brilliant- BRILLIANT and elegant formation of a beautiful bridging argument of so many different threads of the history of the expression of human consciousness and relationships - and the psychoanalytic hermeneutic as well as the scholarship of historians, philosophers, sociologists anthropologists, political science, jurisprudence, ideology- this framework adds a real hermeneutical subtlety and nuance - she is describing a phenomenon tracking it through history- she is not taking on the responsibility of taking a position on how it was constructed- this is brilliant. I am looking for her book tomorrow!
    Thank you for the upload

  • @user-wm4mo6zb3v
    @user-wm4mo6zb3v Před 10 měsíci +1

    Why are all the researchers regarding Caucasian/Indo-European/White people all non-caucasian?

    • @JohnnyJackson746
      @JohnnyJackson746 Před 3 měsíci

      Caucasian is a area not a race of folks. Euro is more accurate.

  • @MoseMuSa
    @MoseMuSa Před 8 lety +22

    Hey if she thinks that all whites are in good position maby she needs to come in Europe and study, her we are held in isolation.??How beautiful is that..

  • @jessgee8373
    @jessgee8373 Před 9 lety +3

    So excited to see this!!!

  • @leeloominai2088
    @leeloominai2088 Před 4 lety +2

    Ty for this.

  • @futurechild1202
    @futurechild1202 Před 9 lety +3

    The unschooled don't kling to race. Intelligent people can be race realist or race protectionist.

  • @thecelt471
    @thecelt471 Před 3 lety +11

    Race is a fact not an idea.

    • @raamyasharahla535
      @raamyasharahla535 Před 2 lety +1

      So is stupidity 😝

    • @thecelt471
      @thecelt471 Před 2 lety +1

      @@raamyasharahla535 Aye she displays plenty of that too.

    • @uncannyvalley2350
      @uncannyvalley2350 Před 2 lety

      @@thecelt471 lmfao, so is there a race for blonds, and a race for redheads? Or just when it suits you? You clearly don't understand white people came from the same stock as dark skinned people, but local populations adapt to local environments, they dont change species. For example a Northern Crocodile is different to a Southern Crocodile, but that doesn't make it an Alligator, halfwit

    • @SumOneSomewhere
      @SumOneSomewhere Před rokem

      Well these are the same people who think men can be women and gender is a social construct so logic really isn’t on their side

  • @murumariesattigit9783
    @murumariesattigit9783 Před 2 lety +6

    I do not like this whole business of “we are one race”, and I’m honestly not entirely sure why. But I think perhaps because it’s effect is to ignore the large body of contributions blacks have made to the so-called human race.

    • @theend3541
      @theend3541 Před 2 lety +15

      There is no racial contributions, only individual. I don’t take credit for the guy who made bitcoin. Nobody is ignoring black inventors. Just name them and show the proof. That’s a lesson. Picking random inventions and attributing them to a race is insulting to the people who took the time to do it.

    • @davruck1
      @davruck1 Před 2 lety

      @@theend3541 history is written by a murderous empire that takes credit for everything

    • @NeedMorePlebs
      @NeedMorePlebs Před 2 lety +1

      ​@@theend3541 you have big brain 😳

    • @overtonpendulum2071
      @overtonpendulum2071 Před 2 lety +3

      What contributions? You mean stand up comedy?

    • @timelessvickdamone
      @timelessvickdamone Před 2 lety +1

      @@theend3541 that was great!✨🙏🏼

  • @stevenmcgillivray9283
    @stevenmcgillivray9283 Před 2 lety +2

    There's nothing wrong with differences. I just wonder if she hates Western and European Civilisation?

    • @davruck1
      @davruck1 Před 2 lety

      western civilization is puure trash. look at the world. who will the west blame this time?

  • @elpashathe7royalmoabites627

    It is not erroneous to approach the phenotypical characteristics of a people from a historical/ antropoligical stand point. However to approach the concepts of peoples as crayon is highly erroneous and misleading, when "White" is a status. So called white people ( pale races of fixed lepers) are collectively European! This is a legal dissertation not an historical one.
    White: A person having origins in any of the peoples of North Africa, Middle East or Europe. This is not referring to a skin pigment distinction or relating to crayon colors!

    • @brittanyhayes1043
      @brittanyhayes1043 Před 2 lety

      White people are not lepers.

    • @mgacy2957
      @mgacy2957 Před rokem

      Nobody cares about your erroneous Afrocentrist hypotheses.
      Save your realhistoryww garbage for Egyptsearch where all the other pseudointellectual nobodies post.

  • @nataniellek
    @nataniellek Před 11 lety +5

    The illusion.

  • @waynefisher9847
    @waynefisher9847 Před 8 lety +18

    I came to this video with the idea of (oh great an intellectual white slap down) I was happily utterly wrong.
    I really enjoyed this and I'm going to by this book.

  • @susandaye8146
    @susandaye8146 Před 5 lety +3

    Take the Cauc- -Asians ,you have Asians.

  • @justme-cr3xe
    @justme-cr3xe Před 3 lety +2

    you lost me at including to "darwin'..

  • @jkhall9665
    @jkhall9665 Před 5 lety +22

    Truth is always hard to hear over the screams of fear. ☯️

    • @martinperez3922
      @martinperez3922 Před rokem +2

      It is hard to learn knowledge when One’s mind is full of pride 🪷

    • @juliomiguel6597
      @juliomiguel6597 Před 10 měsíci

      She did not proffer a single truth.

  • @carmealpalmer4589
    @carmealpalmer4589 Před 4 lety +3

    2020🇬🇧🇯🇲 knowledge is power and the truth hurts but we have to set the record straight by exposing the all the barbaric behaviour for greed with lies people still believe to this day because they don't want to accept their ancestors past .

  • @commando0110
    @commando0110 Před 8 měsíci

    oh god. there are at least 3 indas, 2 egypts and "indian corn" if from the americas.

  • @williamspringer9447
    @williamspringer9447 Před rokem +1

    Read "Race, Evolution and Behavior " by Rushton, and you'll a better idea of what is hidden here.

  • @olddays6733
    @olddays6733 Před 2 lety +10

    I like her. She is very well versed in her research.

    • @neglectfulsausage7689
      @neglectfulsausage7689 Před rokem

      shes full of crap. bet she believes the black race is real. bet she values black ethnic groups and their cultures. shes an angry old racist pos.

  • @CoachDeeFree
    @CoachDeeFree Před 2 lety +3

    Pure Irony 😂

  • @MrSoSoul
    @MrSoSoul Před 8 lety +1

    but not a history of ................a perspective view of race/creed

    • @dominicfaison5889
      @dominicfaison5889 Před 3 lety

      Have you read the book? It’s based solely on historical accounts

  • @ngkthermos3650
    @ngkthermos3650 Před 3 lety

    800

  • @magicsinglez
    @magicsinglez Před 6 lety +4

    Fair presentation . . but I like how she so casual and laughing in regards to her hatred and defamation of Whites. . it's so funny! I suppose she's not laughing about whites being killed. But that's where these ideas lead! Those in the audience should be aware of these dangers, but they don't see to be educated in regards to the issue, or this reality.

  • @demetriuscogdell9378
    @demetriuscogdell9378 Před 2 lety +3

    Im learning so much I want to learn it all and want her books im 75 black man im learning so much I love her

  • @johnhill9445
    @johnhill9445 Před rokem

    Teach The Youth The Truth. No Book 📖📚 Bans NYC

  • @taritabumbray1683
    @taritabumbray1683 Před 6 lety

    reach for the sky the group change

  • @clintonthe4th245
    @clintonthe4th245 Před 10 lety +10

    fantastic! Now I can go talk about race with everyone!

  • @lyntonhse
    @lyntonhse Před 10 lety +10

    Very enlightening!

  • @SteveXNYC
    @SteveXNYC Před 8 měsíci +1

    The white race was coin by Helena Petrovna Blavatsky. The white race are Aryian(india) Hindus of north India. There never was a white race before Helena Petrovna Blavatsky. She claim there are five race. The highest(superior) race is the luminaria race. A spiritual being. Upon view, race is the intellect of the human mind and not a color or appearance.

    • @Spock_Rogers
      @Spock_Rogers Před 7 měsíci

      Her life story is very interesting. I read her biography a few years ago and enjoyed it.

  • @theend3541
    @theend3541 Před 2 lety

    Wrong, Johan Friedrich Blumenbach coined FIVE races in 1779, not three. He was the German who invented the concept of race in the 18th century.

    • @oliviamonteque6407
      @oliviamonteque6407 Před 2 lety

      He was the non-brainer that invented a "myth" to fit his pale arse.

  • @LeedsLyons
    @LeedsLyons Před 4 lety +14

    She obviously has never learned about Indo-European people and how wide spread they were throughout Europe, Asia, Middle East and even the Indian sub continent.

  • @MattVarner
    @MattVarner Před 9 lety +14

    Man, I am embarrassed that this scholar's work isn't even read or listened to before the knee-jerk squad ambles out and vomits up their fundamentally ignorant diatribe...in 2015. Do you have to agree with every thing any writer writes? No. Should you at least formulate your thoughts into a critically-cohesive blurb before making an ass of yourself in front of the whole world? ...nevermind. For trolls, that's rhetorical.

    • @jumpyourbone
      @jumpyourbone Před 8 lety +2

      +Matt Varner what's fucked is this reaction is pretty clearly just based on the title of the book-- the work itself is entirely non-polemical. the title uncomfortably reframes "white people" and whiteness more generally as something to be put under a microscope and closely examined, as if that's not exactly what gets done to everyone and everything else, very often _by white people._ it's like grow tf upppp

    • @justgivemethetruth
      @justgivemethetruth Před 8 lety

      +Matt Varner
      The modern equivalent of the neanderthals.

  • @miketrimm3914
    @miketrimm3914 Před 2 lety +1

    l noticed that too ! Tiger is getting ug.lier and balder also

  • @YePapoteGlobal
    @YePapoteGlobal Před 5 lety

    🖒🖒🖒🖒🖒🖒

  • @newlife6434
    @newlife6434 Před 5 lety +5

    God sed his people was going to call all kind of name in there captivate

  • @nicolemitchell528
    @nicolemitchell528 Před 2 lety +6

    I’m glad I’m an Israelite

    • @uncannyvalley2350
      @uncannyvalley2350 Před 2 lety +1

      Egyptian? Israel is the Phoenician word for Saturn, or El, Fruit of Isis and Ra, it's a reference to Serpentis, the Sunsign of September, the Egyptian Celtic Jewosh and Assyrian New Year. Israel was a collective of tribes of all shades shapes and sizes, it has no defining features

    • @marcusmuse4787
      @marcusmuse4787 Před 10 měsíci

      you're not but I bet it makes you feel better to think you are now doesn't it?

  • @thegreatunknown333
    @thegreatunknown333 Před 2 lety

    None better than the other. Woof woof. We are dogs. Same species. Different breeds

  • @the-great-awekener
    @the-great-awekener Před 4 lety

    So is this the history of white people or white americans? I just started the video

  • @newlife6434
    @newlife6434 Před 5 lety +3

    So we know who we are but people dont happy for us because are god people.

    • @tfyouwanthuh..5649
      @tfyouwanthuh..5649 Před 3 lety +2

      @Daniel 2FLY no one liked your comment and it's been 8 months, it appears he is more literate than you

  • @Shyeena
    @Shyeena Před 10 lety +3

    Why not eliminate the race question in its entirety because it shouldn't matter. My daughter is Filipino Hispanic white and black- her genealogy is diluted. When she applied for school she checked the other box on the line allowed for her to list her race she put all of the above! Seriously I am sure that blacks hate to be lumped into one category or mentality... And I being white with a very colorful background hate to be lumped into a white racist mentality by others. Can't we all just be equal humans?

    • @ucanthandledatruth01
      @ucanthandledatruth01 Před 3 lety

      equal as in all nations arent destablised and made dysfunctional? because I'm sure that's not what you want. why not just advocate for the end to all oppressive operations instead of advocating for s delusional state of mind.

    • @uncannyvalley2350
      @uncannyvalley2350 Před 2 lety

      That was literally the premise of this entire video, clearly you weren't paying attention

    • @davruck1
      @davruck1 Před 2 lety

      capitalism wouldnt work

    • @staywhite6332
      @staywhite6332 Před rokem

      "...her geneaology is dilluted."

  • @AlexD-fq5zm
    @AlexD-fq5zm Před 2 lety +1

    Nationality - American (born in America)
    Race- Human (I am not animal so I am human)

    • @HonchoHundo
      @HonchoHundo Před rokem

      Humans are a species of primates which are mammals
      Race has literally nothing to do with that

    • @HonchoHundo
      @HonchoHundo Před rokem

      What you would be arguing is we are different species rather than race

    • @AlexD-fq5zm
      @AlexD-fq5zm Před rokem

      @@HonchoHundo we are human not monkey.. unless you want to speak for yourself.
      If you are born in America your parents were born in America and you are black you are not African American you are American you can call yourself a black American but Africa has nothing to do with you being American nationality American not African what is your race does that matter are you first why you last no you are human not primates not chimpanzee not some kind of fish human

    • @HonchoHundo
      @HonchoHundo Před rokem

      @@AlexD-fq5zm again humans are a species of primates.. just like snakes and toads are both different species of reptiles
      Our closest living relative is the chimpanzee
      And if you remove the hair on a chimp their skin pigment is pale white
      Scientist believe roughly 1.2 million to 1.6 million years ago chimpanzees migrated to Africa and lost their hair
      And the intense UV light played a major role into our ancestors developing melanin in the skin to prevent skin cancer

    • @AlexD-fq5zm
      @AlexD-fq5zm Před rokem +1

      @@HonchoHundo I see you think that we evolved.. and I believe we were created. .. so where is the mixed animal. Like the reptile mammal. Or any sign of evolution ever even to this day... I guess I could say it's still happening but that won't be true because things usually get better not worse and the human race is not getting smarter just dumber and dumber . There have never been any half breed creatures ever found so far fish bird lizard cat or any mixing between what about the monkey person where is where is our ancient ancestors that would have taken hundreds of generations to change from one to the other but they don't exist we were created

  • @philiproyd6563
    @philiproyd6563 Před 10 lety +1

    Oh, so he was a Dutch Black? Interesting.

  • @RebelRampant
    @RebelRampant Před 11 lety +7

    Question... would you really want a complete homogenization of all the worlds races? Dont you LIKE the concept of living in a world with variety? Its funny, because to me, your position actually seems racist. I like living in a world w/diff races, don't you? Wouldnt it be boring if we all looked alike & didnt have any unique physical manifestations of our genetic inheritance?
    Im a member of the Human race also; but Im not threatened by the subcategories of the Human race which we fall into.

    • @GirlsRuleTheWorld2023
      @GirlsRuleTheWorld2023 Před 2 lety +2

      She is 100% racist and hurts multicultural family’s like mine.

    • @mario7frankielee
      @mario7frankielee Před 2 lety

      @@GirlsRuleTheWorld2023funny 🙈

    • @uncannyvalley2350
      @uncannyvalley2350 Před 2 lety

      Lmfao, we are the same race you toilet, different populations, but all the same race, that's why get called a racist, because you believe we all have differences in ability and skills based on classifications that don't exist

    • @uncannyvalley2350
      @uncannyvalley2350 Před 2 lety

      Also it's families*

    • @RebelRampant
      @RebelRampant Před 2 lety

      @@uncannyvalley2350 “there’s no such thing as populations! We’re all part of the same population!”
      You have the aptitude of a child and shouldn’t be speaking with any authority on this subject until you at least discover what haplogroup dna is.
      You deserve to be laughed at for taking pride in your incoherent blabbering.

  • @dbf421
    @dbf421 Před 10 lety +3

    If you think race is anything other than the result of environmental adaptation, and the names we give them, you don't have a clue.
    Now if you want to say there are significant cultural differences between groups of people that lived in different parts of the world for a long time, and so, different looking groups behave differently I'd say, you're right.....but the differences are purely cultural....their appearance is irrelevant.

  • @emilyschmidt5630
    @emilyschmidt5630 Před 4 lety

    I would love to use this video in my classroom, but since its not close captioned, I can't.

    • @nucleus2851
      @nucleus2851 Před 4 lety

      @ForceDimension y2mates downloads

    • @deadsouls72
      @deadsouls72 Před 4 lety

      You will find these videos educational: czcams.com/channels/FjBfjNAA28YWl0RhLZugvw.htmlvideos

    • @chestgolden
      @chestgolden Před 3 lety

      Yes do so! Download it

  • @dadedowuh
    @dadedowuh Před rokem

    The first baby in America was Peregrine White, by Susan White in Cape Cod Bay, 1620. Just saying..

    • @kudjoeadkins-battle2502
      @kudjoeadkins-battle2502 Před rokem +1

      Nonesense 1587 Virginia Dare. Not to mention Anna Burres child born about 1611 in Jamestown also named Virginia.

  • @ojberrettaberretta5314
    @ojberrettaberretta5314 Před 4 lety +10

    so many inaccuracies its unbelievable

    • @uncannyvalley2350
      @uncannyvalley2350 Před 2 lety

      Triggered racists who can't construct an actual argument be like...