Ranking Every Madden NFL Game From WORST to BEST!
Vložit
- čas přidán 24. 03. 2020
- In this Madden 20 video, I'll be ranking every Madden NFL game from best to worst. We'll be going up the best Madden games, and the worst Madden games of all time. We'll be going over classics like Madden 2004, Madden 2005, Madden 2006, Madden 2008 and so on. We'll also cover Madden 10, Madden 12, Madden 25....and more! For more Madden 20 gameplay, news, tips and tricks, money plays & more...be sure to subscribe! #Madden20
▬ My 2nd Channel: / @instantreplay6375
▬ Check out PLAYBOOK GG - www.playbook.gg/20/gameplans?...
FOLLOW ME ON SOCIAL:
▬ Twitter: / ericrayweather
▬ Instagram: / ericrayweather
For Business Inquires: contact@tablerockmanagement.com - Hry
![tattoo printer tutorial[제품단순선물]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/g40_GwEJak0/mqdefault.jpg)
If you like Fantasy Sports & Pick Em Games, check out Underdog Fantasy and use code RAY to double your first deposit up to $500! play.underdogfantasy.com/pc-BCezXrjizx
EricRayweather they should bring back rushing attack
EricRayweather also, bring lobby back and to be able to play rank game picking your own matchup not random
EricRayweather can’t stand random play
EricRayweather madden 06&07 was my favorites
Bro I was agreeing with you was 90% of it Madden 12 should be in Goat tier but besides that how you going to say Madden 20 has a better franchise mode out of all the Madden since Madden 12 that's a lie Madden 17 has a better franchise mode then Madden 20
The early Madden versions also had real stat simulating meaning if you had a scrambling quarterback, he would have at least 600 yards rushing by the end of the season
Idk, sometimes Mike Vick would rush for 1,800 yards in a season in those old maddens.
spiderman< what new stuff is there in the new madden games? i have not played this for a couple of years now... is it all the same?
@@metalgearsolidsnake6978 nothing, they removed a lot of stuff and only are slowly adding it back, but still no create a team or true career mode, and franchise is very shallow
@@blackanimelover18Right, he was THAT Good man. The simulation also ran more QB designed runs for him
@@metalgearsolidsnake6978 brah? they got cool color shoes, and dolphin dance
Real ogs remember in madden 10 fight for the fumble mini game
Dawuan McGowan is sucked at it my brother would always get the ball
PepsKnowsBest _ not really I feel like it was fair unlike today’s madden if there’s a fumble
I wish it could come back
When you had to spam buttons
@@ttv_rafa yessir😂😂💯🔥
I miss being years deep in a NCAA dynasty while drafting everyone of my classes to madden and watching them prosper into NFL stars or busts.. i may never have a gaming experience like that again in my life 😔🥺😢
That was so fun! I miss NCAAF
FluGame Nasty it’s coming back. Sort of.
FluGame Nasty sane with 2K football. But sort of. lol
@@U9005p that 2kfootball will be non simulation so it's going to arcade style. Back yard stadium/ big head player type stuff. If they make another ncaaf, it will be totally different. It would do nothing but tarnish my nostalgia lol.
I still play my copy of NCAA 14 on the 360. I suggest going out and getting it if you’re able to. It’s still a great game to play.
All Madden's on PS2 was the best of all time 💯💪🏿
Dominick Ferguson Absolutely. PS2 era had more depth and better gameplay than today’s game which is sad and embarrassing enough.
Ps2 was a goated system
Honestly if mini camp came back in a new madden I think I'd get it just for that alone, if implemented right. it'd be cool if you could use your MUT cards to upgrade players with it but we all know that's a long shot cause EA.
I agree
Agreed
Madden 08 Goat. Had everything, gameplay, franchise, specialist, and Vision Cone! Vision Cone is what separated great QBs to average ones. It took actual skill to use. Same with D. Been playing since most of you where born. Started with the original Madden pc 1991.
M Sar cool
ok boomer
Not even close to being the goat bruv
Scott the Woz?
Drxpped are you angry boomer?
I’ve owned every game since Madden 01... and 100% agree with your Madden list. I absolutely loved the Madden games from 04 through 08.. my favorite Madden is 2004 as well. Favorite NFL game overall is def ESPN NFL 2K5 ☝🏼
Travis Lucas The truth has been spoken!
Fax and NFL 2k5 is the goat. NFL 2k is the 🐐 period no argument
NFL 2k5 is the best playing game. It was the most life like. Now in terms of best madden my favorites were 05’ and 08’. Personally I like franchise mode.
Which madden game in the last 5 years would be the best to purchase? Not overly familiar with the franchise and it's changes aside from graphics (I presume) but in terms of general playability (if there's such a term for a game) and graphics, what would be the one to go for?
Madden 16 is the younger generations king
madden 12 is goat level to me
I had it on the Wii and the five on five mode was so fun
And 11
Madden 12 was my all time favorite, GOAT level to me
Madden 12 On Ps2 was G.O.A.T , was the Last of a Dying Breed 😂😂
@@eastwoodrufus3763 I liked that one game mode but i forgot what it was called when u play against the kickers, the monsters etc
I thought this guy was crazy because he said madden 20 was good but then i found out he was talking about 2000
i feel like im the only person who feels this way, but I've played every madden since madden 25 and my favourite if all time is madden 20. I think its amazing but everyone always shits on it
@@matthollingsworth5943 I mean if you like it fine but I can definitely see why people shit on it I kind of like it but not that much its OK to me
Madden 2003-08 on xbox/ps2 was a fantastic run of games. There were big improvements and fine tuning done every year to an already great system. I miss those days!
Dropping passes is so bad in Madden 20
Carson Ward omg so what happened today was I threw it to a WR and it looked like he caught it but he was running with the ball with his knees
I hate the fact 99 overall receivers with 99 catching still drop passes, and letting average corners lock them out.
The animation is so inaccurate
Yeelicious - I feel that. Had a career going with a 99 receiver and he was going up agains Deandre Baker (a 74 overall I believe) and he blanketed me in coverage. Knocked the ball away too
@@yeelicious-6232 still not as bad as 79 overrall cornerbacks bullying like 97 overrall receivers
You've hit the nail on the head with Maddens 04-07. My personal favorite is Madden 07 but I would play 04,05, or 06 in a heartbeat. Little did we know how good we had it back then. My last Madden I purchased was Madden 09 before I picked it up again with Madden 18, so a sizeable gap between play but today's Madden just doesn't compare to the ones they were spitting out in the mid 2000's. Im glad 2K sports is back in the mix. That will only force EA and 2K to up their games, no pun intended.
Me too, 08 felt easy to win compared to 07, I also liked the new feature of joystick in field goals.
spiderman< what new stuff is there in the new madden games? i have not played this for a couple of years now... is it all the same?
Madden 25 is underrated. It had a lot more customization and features than any madden after. The graphics might not be the best but its nice on my book.
Madden 10 brings back soooo many memories. Mann..
Great video. Great list. Madden 10 was one of my favorites. Madden 95 was a fun game most people never played
I remember playing Madden on Sega genesis.....passing back then was so hard because instead of seeing the whole field there would be 3 windows lol
President Carter I remember that dawg lol
Yeah, I remember that as well. That is what made Madden 97 so different when it came out on PS1. My staple football game for SNES was the Tecmo Super Bowl series. I had the first and third games in the series and still play them quite a bit. Now with emulation, I mostly play Tecmo Super Bowl on NES with updated rosters but still I miss some of the old school games. I just tried playing Madden 99 and it doesn't hold up quite as well as some of the others.
The Frostbite engine ruined the game
Really enjoyed this video, very insightful. I'd like to know where you rate each year bracket of Madden games on the same spectrum you used. I mean you can kinda tell how you'd rate them but I'd like to see a follow up video that has you placing each Madden into it's respective era, not necessarily based on graphics but more of what it offered and how well received it was. Such as 99-01, 02-05, 06-12, 13-20, etc...
Hey Eric! Love your videos man. Great content. Very engaging and your explanations are clear and straight forward! 2 questions I would love to see you address. 1. Explaining Salary Cap, Cap Penalties and how this is effected in trading. 2. How do you successfully trade up in the picks in the draft? ( It seems when I try to do so the trades are mostly denied even when I provide better than good value.
Madden 07 on PS2 was my favorite, it was just tougher, the CPU would go for it on 4th&2. Also joystick on fieldgoals was a good new development.
Great video, my personal favorite is hands down Madden 2006 PS2/GameCube. I played about 15 seasons in franchise mode it was fun.
Madden 04'-Madden 08' was my era and when I really played. Loved the hit stick at the time on 07'. Damn Madden use to be good
I still play Madden 10 almost daily to this day lol
Best Madden ever, for sure! That’s a perfect football game, in my view.
Madden 12 is the best in my opinion
Interesting point of view. I'm strictly a Franchise Mode player. I have been since Madden 99. Everything else they ever added to the games over the years I could care less; especially MUT. I love being my own personal make-believe GM/Coach and take a really bad team and build them up to be a dynasty.
With that said, for me I had a ton of fun playing Madden 09 on 360. I had the 20th Anniversary Edition, and really enjoyed it. I loved it so much I did what I almost never do and I went out and bought the very next year/iteration in Madden 10 for PS3 and loved it as well. After that, I didn't play another Madden until Madden 25 for PS3, and again, loved it as well. I had the most fun with that version than any Madden in a while. I actually hated 15. I bought that on PS4, and sold it after a month of playing it.
I bought 16 a long time later for about $5 in a used bin, and ended up loving that Madden. I ended up buying Madden 12 for PS3 used after I got bored with 16 because I read on several forums that was the best Madden of that generation, and I'm playing that one right now, and for the most part I'm digging it. Scouting is broken in that game, but the gameplay is pretty solid. I played 08 on PS2 recently and enjoyed it as well.
Maybe it's nostalgia but for me the two best Maddens of all time for me were Madden 2005 on PS2 and John Madden Football '93 on SNES. I had the most fun on those Maddens than any Madden ever, and I've played just about all of them. I have to say Madden 2000, 2003, and 07 all on PC are damned awesome Madden experiences as well. There was a time where I was playing my football games exclusively on PC simply because during the PS1 and PS2 era the PC versions were FAR superior in both creative categories and gameplay and of course graphics.
As a kid I never knew there were next gen versions of 06 - 10. I was mine blown when I saw footage of them. Those games on PS2 looked, more or less, the same to me even though I enjoyed them
I always enjoyed the ones where you could import your draft classes and you could see the players you play with and against become big NFL stars on become just benchwarmers. The best part of Madden 05-12 is drafting and watching them progress and flourish and become stars, like taking an 78 overall running back or linebacker and turning him into a stud by about his second or third year in the league by putting him on ground attack and chase and tackle drills respectively. I enjoyed that aspect of the game. When they took out the import classes, it really killed franchise for me.
Idk why but madden 15 just hits for me I can still hop on and enjoy it
From the PC player perspective, Madden died after 08 when it disappeared from PC. Then wow its back for 19 and oh dear, all the customisation is gone ... its not fun and MUT has taken center stage ??? RIP Madden ... it was a great game. still the greatest is 05 and while my PC can play it in some way, it'll keep getting a run.
Moz of Oz facts
Still play Madden 07 for Gamecube almost every day.
I agree I love the Franchise Mode on Madden 20 (favorite PS4 Madden) because that’s mostly what I play with online matchups being so expensive for the PS4 compared to the PS3 online days for free. My top maddens of all time: 1. Madden 2005 2. Madden 10 (PS2) 3. Madden 11 4. Madden 25 (2nd fav PS3 game) 5. Madden 20
Hey bruh thanks for the great content you continue to post. Question what’s the deal with not being able to pick uniforms in online play? Is this a issue or do I have to fix something in my settings?
Early 2000s is when I started. Marshall Faulk on hb off tackle was absolutely unstoppable
Madden 2002 was probably my most played madden on both PS1 and PS2 and I enjoyed it a lot. It was the one got me into Madden as I was mostly a NFL Gameday fan during the PS1 days, I then got my first taste of NFL 2K3, first 2K football game I played and since then I haven’t really found any enjoyment out of madden since, I stilled played them for certain game modes I did enjoy, but outside of those modes, the gameplay has never held my attention for long.
The 04-08 (6th gen versions) were so good, especially the soundtrack and menu
for me Madden '08 for the original Xbox was the best.
+The most in depth Franchise Mode
+Commentary where they said your created players names
+Combine
+Realistic stats
+Tats, haircuts, and agents for your superstar
The first game on ps2 blew my mind! The step up from ps1 to ps2 was incredible.
Madden 12 being the last really great Madden is so true. That was the last game that had the Create a Team feature and I really miss that. I loved creating my own franchise and trying to win a Super Bowl.
Ultimate Team RUINED Madden:(
No. EA’s greed ruined Madden. MUT was fun before micro transactions
DrewC41 now the only way you can get a good team without not wasting money in not having a life
Not really
Mut 16 and 17 were very fun and I think 20 is the first good one since
Facts
Mike Vick was like Bo Jackson in Tecmo Bowl
Madden 08 is my absolute favorite and also my first madden. I played it on pc for about 5 years! until i got an xbox with madden 13... still sometimes played the 08 game tho bc i had built a few 99 ovr teams in franchise mode by that time lol
The problem with game play is the randomness and what seems to be predetermined animations or outcomes.
Madden 03, 04 and 05 are my favorites. Madiden 2003 has a special place in my childhood though, it was the year you can use madden cards during franchise mode. So you could bring back players like Barry Sanders and play them in your franchise. 🔥🔥
and the best soundtrack of any madden game
I’m from New Zealand and the first madden I really got hooked on was madden 04 on Xbox great game alsome soundtrack joe budden always got me pumped up😂 never knew much about the sport/rules of gridiron until I learnt through the tutorials on madden on how to play lol. Over the years I would buy every 2nd edition of the game now I’m downloading M20 at this very minute😅
Love this video. Madden 10 was by far my favorite simply due to nostalgia. It was my first madden game and I played it for two years before finally getting madden 13 which was a great game for me as well. Good memories man, good times.
Good man
Madden 10 was trash because you could not trade for next years draft pick. 11 was the same. You could only trade for the current years draft picks.
AllDay28 fr man. Good times.
Gavin Stutler that’s pretty wack. I didn’t quite get into the franchise mode until madden 12 unfortunately as I was a lot younger so my reasons for loving the game was simply nostalgia.
@@alkafelts I understand that. I feel the same about the 1989 version of Madden. The ambulance used to run over the opposing players when one of you guys got hurt. haha
@ericrayweather I use the 49ers offense and defensive playbooks...any tips on plays on both sides of the ball? More so on defense
“Why madden 18 19 and 20 will be the best madden ever”
Eric-before each game realease
What can I say, I was optimistic. Not doing it this year though.
EricRayweather I don’t blame you and tbh I was excited too
I enjoyed madden 16, even as an offline gamer at the time.
Pretty good list... Madden 04 is my personal favorite, I'm a big franchise guy and Owner mode was a huge deal at the time. Had an awesome soundtrack too
I do really think that if there are no OP plays in Madden 21, they fix some abilities and add more, have a much better career mode, and make franchise much better, then Madden 21 has a good chance of being in the “good” category. Since some of this might not happen though, I’m expecting it to end up in the “ok” category
21 Has a chance to be good but with the new consoles coming out we will most likely be taking another step back in 22.. probably never have a great one anytime soon
@@WrathOfTheSpectre NFL 2k is coming back though next year and it'll bring competition for madden.
Go Knighthawks Go NFL 2k will bring almost no competition for madden because NFL 2k will be a completely different game. It will be a game like NFL street, it won’t be a simulation style game.
There will always be op plays due to youtube.
Not a chance in the world the physics are horrendous. I love watching these old games videos cause it reminds me that receivers used to understand how not to just drift out of bounds and blockers would actually look for blocks to make. Madden 07 is my all time favorite I wish they would bring back a real superstar mode and ditch the bs narrative thing.
I have played every single Madden. Madden 93, Madden 95, Madden 97 and the Original are worth playing. To me Madden 2005 was the GOAT! 2004 was a beast! 2017 was GOAT. Madden 09 & 2010 were great games. 08 was a monster smash!
Do a video on the rise and fall of nhl hockey games
Same here for Madden 2002 that's when I started playing Madden I fell in love with it
Had the most fun with Madden 11 by far. Never played online, but had a blast playing it weekly against friends in college. The last time I could really fully get into Madden tbh. I'm a NCAA guy.
Easily best presentation in madden 11
Me too 😎
07 was my first madden game and the first game I ever played on the xbox 360. I loved it, but it stopped working after a couple of years. The 09 was the 2nd one I played and I LOVED it
Ps2 were the best days. I miss the Two Minute Drill mini games and i think that's what they were trying to capture with super star ko mode
I think madden 08 was my best madden to this day gameplay, online play the mod, etc. these new madden games the guys run like their floating and a whole lot more in my opinion.
Thats very True.. That trailer had me thinking this was gonna be the best Madden ever
Yaw tripping!!! Madden 25(360) is the best PLAYING madden there is. The best physics. The best running. The best player movement by far. It lacks modes but to play, it’s the best. Plays just like NCAA 14. Still play it to this day. Again, the 360 version.
Players tripped on each other all the time after plays lol
CodeAtlas but during plays it was smooth lol
i played Madden on ps2 until 2010 by choice because the franchise mode contained so much more substance, better than the next gen consoles... in my opinion.
Same here
07 is my goat. Franchise was good and superstar was at its peak. I liked the fact that you didn’t get to pick where you were drafted. 2005 was good too
I appreciate the input
Madden 07, 12, 18, are my favs.
18 has the all legends for each team my fav and 19 21
I remember playing with Philly being unstoppable. I didn’t care about Vick and the falcons, probly bc I had already been running with Philly. Vick was dope tho but they never scared me
In madden 12 there was an arcade like game it was really fun. I remember playing it on the Wii
You have some great pics Eric. For me Madden 20 was good this year I was pleased with it. The best Madden to me was 12. The rest of madden from 13 to 19 to me was bad.
I played Madden 08 with my friend a lot !! Classic game ! Haven’t played a lot of Madden the past 10 years, 17 was the last game I played I’m unsure when to buy the next game...
Madden 11 commentary was legendary
Yea
Who Dat Nation
07' on 360 was fine to me. Just played my friend all the time in college and loved it
Hi, Where do you place Madden 21, 22, and 23 now? BTW I really like Madden 16 and the soundtrack in that game :)
Madden 64 is still one of my favorites. Just bring back so many memories. When it first released I remember going to Walmart and buying it.
Sad that the madden in mid 2000s still play and animate smoother then then it’s counterpart 15 years later.
Yeah you're right.
Madden 07 & 08 on PC were 🔥🔥🔥 I’ve never had more fun
Fun, but virtually the exact same game.
My brother and I loved madden 09😂 I’ll admit tho ur right about overpowered plays but me and my brother really enjoyed it
2006 on PS2. Absolute favorite Madden of all time. Still have tournaments with my friends playing it nearly 20 years later.
Man I love madden 08 it just made me and my cousins have the best times
In the last decades of maddens madden 10 25 (Xbox 360) is one of my favorites
I only played 5v5 on 09 i played that all the time as a kid that was my game
I remember when i went from 09 on wii to 13 on wii u me and my brother couldnt figure out how to kick
My favorite Madden was 03 and 04
@JoylessTunic738 I hope you mean 2K5; make sure to turn on multiple hot routes
@JoylessTunic738 For a linebacker qb spy:
Hold L2
Press the button of your desired spy
Release both L2 and your desired spy's button
The desired spy should still have his button icon above his head
Press R1
That's it. For a DB to be spy use R2 instead of L2.
Special tip: Spy doesn't work very well in 2K5 so you might just want to manually control a linebacker.
Madden 16 was my very first Madden game so I don’t care how good it was, that one is always gonna be S tier for me.
I agree. The best gameplay imo on this generation of consoles.
Yeah, I definetly agree with that. The gameplay took such a good step, they added new things, and so much more.
It's actually a good game. Great graphics and fun. But if you're into retro, definitely check out Madden 05 and NFL 2K5
my favorite was madden 2003 because you could make your own plays and i really enjoyed making passing plays
My top 5 - Madden 2010, Madden 2005, Madden 18, Madden 13 and Madden 16
Madden 13 was so stiff and the group tackling was lacking hard.
it was trash
From madden 10 and onward the series has gone on a decline
Yea i only played the only version, and they were good! i loved them! I have not played the new madden games, so have they go better or is it just the same with new players?
8:44 Seahawks fans at the divisional round this year know this feeling.
10 is my favorite. But I loved 08 on psp. 12 is up there for me as well. And 13.
Rest In Peace John Madden. You made all of our lives better.
‘06 also had that QB vision, which was....interesting. I didn’t hate it, but didn’t love it...unless I had Peyton Manning. That dude had x-ray vision.
I like Madden 25 i had a lot of success online rank madden 19 was not good but some success in online tournaments Madden 20 is good but I've only played franchise mode which is good they could do so much more but online Head to Head ranking system needs a big over haul really bad and fix the pursuit angles throwing motion of the QBs needs to be turned then it will almost be good
Good list. My only objection is put madden 11 higher. Awesome sound track and first year of teamplay/squads. My favorite mode
The thing I didn't like about 11 was the controls changed
Shifting defense and kicking field goals became different buttons
Also the lighting was too dark
Madden 04 & 05 was goated I loved the 06 for the quarter in the pocket juke System They had
I started with 05 and ended with 11.
Madden 06 I think was the start of the greatest because one thing that changed was you can run with your qb during a pass play. You can run with Vick as well but also it didn’t have to be a qb sneak play
Madden on the psp was low key so fun. It was ps2 madden but downgraded just a little.
09 on ps3 was weirdly fun with so much crap in the game. 10 was solid nothing fancy. 11 I just couldn’t get into another madden and that’s when I stopped.
I can see how people really like 07 just because of how smooth the gameplay feels.
i have been playing madden since the beginning
Bro the very first madden on Xbox 360 was the worst. I remember almost crying because I was so hyped, stayed home from school and everything and it was so disappointing. I was shook it was so bad
Lol I liked Madden 18. Probably because I just cheesed stretch run plays with Leveon Bell online and went like 300-61🤣🤣🤣🤣
I like 05 more than 04 because of course graphics and gameplay advanced and although 04 was the breakout year but 05 was more balanced and not as vick heavy.
I have no idea how people hate 19 more than 20. If you know someone is running stretch right and there’s nothing you can do to stop it because of abilities then that makes a game awful in my opinion.
19 is a good madden game and 20
1. Madden 11. 2. Madden 12 3. Madden 16 4. Madden 17 5. NCAA 14 . Madden 11 has the best commentary, sound effects, franchise mode, edit rosters, no connected careers, fantasy draft, fight for fumble, AI, and gameplay, and great pregame show.
Looking back on it Madden 18 was terrible but for some reason I have so much great memories on it and really enjoyed it
18 might b the best to me
Which madden had classic & all time teams from each franchise built in game ..?
I remember the 90's madden had them but dont remember which ones