Two Thing J.K. Rowling REGRETS About Harry Potter😱
Vložit
- čas přidán 5. 04. 2024
- In this short we discuss two things that J.K. Rowling regrets about Harry Potter. These include not having Harry and Hermione end up together as well as the fate of Remus Lupin and Tonks.
This channel is dedicated to providing the best Harry Potter content possible. I have been a life long Harry Potter fan and try to share interesting facts and theories about the series. If you enjoy this content please subscribe for more!
#shorts #harrypotter #behindthescenes - Zábava
Fred's death because Gorge can't live without Fred
I was going to say the same thing.
It's not true Gorge did move on
But he couldn't cast a patronus after Fred's death as all his happy memories included fred
Cannon: during his first birthday without fred he stayed in his room all day not celebrating his birthday without fred
Canon: Fred's spoon fell off the clock when he died and gorge made it a necklace
Cannon: getting ready for Ron's birthday molly: fred get the chicken out the freezer
I'm sorry gorge. "Honestly women you call yourself our mother
It should have been Percy honestly
I would change Fred’s death or Sirius blacks death
Same
Both
I think losing Sirius then his firebolt and Hedwig were harry losing his childhood and innocence. First he lost that last hope of having a father figure in his life then his first present from hagrid which was also his only link to the magical world when he was stuck with the dursleys and from Sirius which was also his last link to the Godfather he had in his life for such a frustratingly short time
Death of my darling freddie
i think losing Sirius was part of his growth as a character, he needed to be strong enough to kill voldy moldy.
When you read the books, Hermione and Harry are clearly not meant to be together.
They are like siblings.
Ginny's temper is most suited to Harry's personality. Especially to cheer him up.
As Ron and Hermione are already an old couple before their time. It's all the point with them.
Agreed. Although tbf even in the Books, Ron & Hermione pairing is quite bad. Unlike Ginny & Harry; Ron and Hermione aren't compatible at all. Their pairing was simply done so as to ensure that the Golden Trio becomes a Family towards the end of the series.
@@ruturajshiralkar5566 They seemed fine to me. They were easily the most compatible characters in the series to be honest. I don’t really understand where this whole thing about them not being comes from, because they were characters who so clearly liked each other a lot, the entire time. It works perfectly fine in my opinion.
@@ruturajshiralkar5566 I just don’t understand why they wouldn’t be?
They spent all of their time together and clearly liked each other a lot, that’s very obvious in the books. They clearly enjoy talking, debating/bickering, and just generally being with each other. They spend their summers together at the burrow or Grimwald place as well.
And in the books they actually seem to care about each other, especially Ron towards Hermione, he was basically defensive of her to a fault, while this all gets cut from the movies.
It’s probably the best pairing in the series in the books, and I personally quite enjoyed reading it and never found that it didn’t work.
There are quite a few quotes I could put that show why I think it’s quite good anyway.
Thank you finally someone agrees with me
@@dylanelizabeth7712 Possibly. Though I’ve heard many times that she never actually said she regretted what she wrote. Someone would need to find the original quote. Regardless, in the books, it works very well, and a lot would need to be changed for that to not be the case.
A lot of it is just the major changes to Hermione’s character in the films, and the borderline character assassination that happened to Ron.
I want Sirius to be alive
Me too
Yep it’s like :oh yes I found someone who I’ll have fun with him as a family!
He talked about it in the third movie
JK Rowling: yeah… no
I would stop harry from stopping sirius and lupin from killing peter
That would actually save cedric and probably prolong voldy moldy's return aswell
I think with Barty Crouch Jr still in the mix the events of GOF would play out similarly
@@ocuada252barty crouch jr was the G 😂😂😂 Poor malfoy
I agree. A shame they didn't get Peter, but then there would have been no evidence to prove Sirius was innocent either way.
Hehehe voldy moldy 😜
She also talked about being sad about Fred and how she regretted when she killed him. Honestly i think Hermione and Harry were more like brother and sister since the chamber of secrets. What i would have loved to see in the movie is Draco throwing Harry's wand to him to fight Voldemort. It would have added more of a human part to him and showed he cares for Harry and Hogwarts
Me too and I love that scene
Because it was her idea from the very first book that Hermione and Ron will end up together
I want Dobby to be alive
😭😭when i first read the books i cried myself to sleep bc dobby died😭
True
Fr
🧦
ik i cried when he died
J.K rowling: I wish Harry and Hermione ended up together
Me: Didnt she write the damn book?
EDIT:Omg so many likes you guys blowing up my phone
From what I understand she didn’t actually say that. I think in some interview about the movie specifically she stated that they(Harry and Hermione) might have worked out. I don’t think that’s the case at all in the books, very clearly, but in the films it’s possible. Basically she never said that the Ron and Hermione pairing wouldn’t work, or that she regretted it.
@@3v317 They all seem to make pretty good choices. It’s mostly subjective but I personally think all of the romantic subplots in the series are perfectly fine and the people complaining almost always seem to either have some sort of basic misunderstanding or just be wilfully stupid, having terrible reading comprehension. But whatever, it’s not really that important.
@@3v317 I can’t really think of a bad one other than maybe Remus and Tonks, which wasn’t really developed at all and Remus is like twice Tonks age.
Other than that they’re fine.
Ron and Hermione always seemed like very close characters and clearly spend most of their time together and majorly enjoy each other’s company. They seemed to really care about each other from the start, and there are many, many quotes from the book that support this. Not to mention when they do finally get together at the end of book 6(sort of) it makes a lot of sense and seems like a reasonable and very much hinted at progression, and they act very couple-ey for the entire last book. They do have two big arguments but ultimately they make up completely both times, and they were both caused by outside influences, not some sort of personal incompatibility, it really didn’t come off that they didn’t like or care about each other, and I think that’s evidenced by the fact that they ultimately fully supported the other when they needed it, even during/at the end of these arguments(scabbers/Lavender). So yeah I thought this one makes perfect sense as they clearly deeply like and care about each other in the books, supported by many, many quotes.
Harry and Ginny makes sense as well. In the books they are both consistent parts of each other’s lives, even when they aren’t together, their interests very much align(they both like quidditch etc…). There is also the fact that Ginny is quite tough and doesn’t cry often, which works in Harry’s case as that seems to be what he wants, it is said in the book, and he clearly isn’t great at cheering up very emotional people, so it works. They also clearly very much liked each other, so it makes sense.
So personally I think those main ones are fine and really don’t see why (some small number of) people don’t like them. They make perfect sense, as evidenced by quotes from the books(I could potentially find, but it would be a lot of effort to go through all of the books, they are on my shelf though so I will consider it if this is questioned), and work given the established personalities of the characters. Ultimately it is subjective, but it has to be admitted that the case for them working is equally(and much more) strong than the opposing case.
I guess she wanted the golden trio to end up as a family
I cant speak to what was actually said, but real artists do what the material requires, not what they want to warp it into. That's one difference between meh writing and the sublime.
ps. It also speaks to her incredible integrity and strength of character to say what is true vs lie to protect herself from real life versions of Deatheaters.
By having Ginny be with Harry it allows Harry to be part of Ron's family by marriage. Hermine marrying Ron also makes her a sister to Harry. They are all part of the big wonderful family.
honestly i think ginny and harry were made together because they resemble james and lily because ginny had orange hair
İ don’t think so
I think they were made together but because their personalities matches so much
well it's fine if you don't it's my opinion@@Lemaurasi
I agree with you about ginny and harry being perfect for each other
Fred should jave stayed alive
They should have added harry is the one who kills bellatrix for revenge for sirius
Agreed but Bellatrix also killed Fred and Molly was defending Ginny against her attack.
I would rather have had Neville do it as it would be more ironic, since he’d defeat Bellatrix while Harry defeated Voldemort.
Bellatrix tortured Neville’s parents out of their mental state while Voldemort killed the Potters. That’s why that would have been the best.
@@rihamraza4427 Neville had cause to kill Bellatrix after what she did to his parents!
@@rihamraza4427Then hermioneand ron would've died from nagini. I think molly is already good enough to destroy bellatrix as if after killing her son she tries to kill her daughter too, neville is good enough to kill nagini and get revenge from voldemort
@@louiseislam7424bellatrix was probably ordered by voldemort to torture his parents.
I think harry and hermoine represent that friendship is the most important and beautiful thing in life.
I want Sirius back, he'll makes a great father figure for Harry
They'll be a great family
If i can, i think i wanna change the first scene of Harry and draco have ever meet. As we know, in this scene, Draco wants Harry as his friend, but Harry, who sees Draco's attitude towards Ron, becomes pessimistic and rejects the size of his friendship. If I could change just one scene in the Harry Potter story, that would be the scene I would change. I would change Draco to ignore Ron and focus on Harry, so they can be friends. I know that Draco is a big fan of Harry Potter, he always wanted Harry as his friend. But Harry destroyed it. I think the change in this scene will make a significant change to the whole story, Harry and Draco will become friends, and the story will be more exciting or maybe more boring? That this story will completely turn into a story in another universe
We need Hedwig 🥺🥺🥺
I think the scene where Draco should’ve had defended harry and fighting off Voldemort should’ve had been kept in the last movie in part two
Fred staying alive, Sirius staying alive, these are all parts of the story that need to happen, it wouldn’t be the same without
The only thing that can add charm to the series is the last scene of draco passing wand to harry that has been cutted
Otherwise this series is magical❤
I want Fred alive and well happy with his brother
Fred's death hurts so much. I'd change that 100 times
FREDS DEATH OFC😭😭 George cant live without Fred i litterally balled my eyes out when he died😭
When they took out the part of Draco fighting Voldemort with Harry
I agree
I think that they are talking about the books
Samee
Draco didn't fight Voldemort with Harry. However, he helped Harry escape Voldemort by not positively I.D.ing him.
That wasn't even in the book 😅
She regreted because in the books everyone was fine with ron and hermione but the movies were more famous and lot of movie fans wanted harry and hermione
The death of Sirius black, I hated that part, that and Remus death. Also Fred I hated that to because of George
fred's(george can't live without him),dumbledore(he shouldn't have died)sirius (only caring family harry have left)tonks,lupin,dobby(it broke my heart💔) hedwig,and everyone who didn't deserved it😢
The fact that Umbridge still lives.
Harry and Ginny are the best fictional couple ever you can’t change them bring back Dobby, Hedwig, Snape, and Fred
I would chace the fact that harry didnt stay at the bank longer before first year and had gotten a inheretence test to know how to act and that he got the muggleborn book pack:(
Umbrieg dies , she ran from the fight and was killd by bellatrix after 5h of toutor
Dobby's death..Fred..Lupin..Serious.. Severus also..No for Harry and Herminie
THE PART WHERE FRED DIED DUHHH
I wish that all the good people in the movies dont die.
It's very heartbreaking
I wanted hermoinie and Draco to end up together
I want snape to be alive so harry can thank him, mcgonagall can apologise for duelling him and calling him a coward, and to perhaps receive an order of Merlin for his efforts
I dont regret Harry not being with Hermione that would suck also Remus was okay I was pissed about tonks
Yeah but I don't want Ron ending up with lavender brown
I want to change the part where j k thinks Harry and hermione should have end up together😊😊😊😊
She never regretted hinny/romione
Period.
Love the series always thank u J.K it’ll never disappear
A want Fred and Cedric alive
I would change the whole night bus thing. Doesn’t make sense to me
The best way to deal with things not turning out like you wanted is to write a fan fiction. I couldn't change the fact that Fred died, so I brought him back as a ghost.
She’s also said she hated killing Fred and dooming George to a lifetime of constant grief. Hard agree on that one. Fred should have survived. she did Molly dirty. Molly is LK one of the best characters in the HPverse, but she was in a supporting role the whole time. JK needs to write a Molly novel.
I wouldn’t have had Harry and Hermione end up together. But I think it would be expected, due to the stress and pressure caused by being on the run from Voldemort and his Death Eaters and dodging snatchers after Ron leaves them in the Deathly Hallows book. That their bond grows stronger and they end up having a moment where they are intermit with each other and become each others first times. It could’ve been that the horcrux locket saw that and replayed for Ron just before he destroys the locket.
I agree with Joan on point one. Harry and Hermione were made for each other.
I would either stop harry from telling remus and sirius not to kill peter, or have harry kill bellatrix before she could kill sirius.
Dobby and Fred’s death 😢
I think Hermione should have been with Harry. Ron isn't near her intellectual equal. She will have to forever take care of him and make all the decisions....while he chases gnomes in the garden.
I would have changed Tom Riddles backstory a little bit, come from a family that hates muggles but wasn’t dirt poor. His mother was the outcast of the family and she ran off with his father. Merope keeps slipping the love potion to Tom Riddle Sr until their son is born. Then she stops slipping the potion to him. He falls out of love with her, then Merope dies of a broken heart. Tom Riddle Sr doesn’t think Tom Marvolo Riddle would suit well in their family, so he gives me up to the orphanage and lies about who he is, and says to the orphanage that the parents died of a car crash (irony right). Tom Marvolo Riddle finds out it, at a young age, but during his 4th year, when he’s learning about Horcrux’s and his family’s history, he finds out his father is very much alive, he goes to the house of Gaunt between year 4 and 5 during the summer, finds out where Tom Riddle Sr is located, Kills him, and uses the Gaunt Ring to make his first Horcrux.
Also, the 3 Gaunt family members attended Hogwarts, all in Slytherin house, and Morfin always talks about how he couldn’t get a female because females thought he was a creep because of his looks and that he could speak Parsletounge.
All good people should not die 😢
I think the story line lay down is perfect though, that is what make it a modern world classic.
Ron and hermione together
The one part in Harry Potter that I would change is Hedwig dying
I would change the part where Sirius Black was killed. I love Sirius Black, and his death was an extremely hard pill to swallow.
no ron and hermione were perfect
I know Ron is good in different ways then Harry
@evelin9914 Maybe, but not for Hermione. It just feels really out of character for both of them. More like a fantasy than an actual healthy relationship.
@@nielsnielson5844 Not really at all. They were easily the closest characters in the series. They did basically everything together and clearly really enjoyed each other’s company, as well as immensely cared about each other. I can never understand how people don’t seem to come to this conclusion if they’ve read the books. In the films, yeah it wasn’t really developed at all, but it was a really quite good part of the books.
@@imperialinquisition6006 Ron is a terrible fit for Hermione. Harry has much more in common with her than Ron ever has.
@@Geno2733 Completely untrue. If you actually paid attention when you read the book you would know that this just isn’t the case. If you are talking about the movies, maybe, but the books are completely different.
Anyway it’s ultimately about how much people like to be with each other and how much they care for each other than some sort of checklist of how much they have in common. And they still had more in common if you actually paid any attention.
The death of Doby was 100% unnecessary....
...Doby is a free elf 🧦
A lot of the deaths were unnecessary.
@@Geno2733
Except Bellatrix...
...the "B...H" deserved it 👏...
...go Ms Molly
freds alive and the scene where petunia tell harry that he didnt lose a mother that night, she lost a sister is not deleted
I want fred, Harry's parents, and dobby back
Pretty sure they got together when Ron was away in Deathly Hallows. That RJ person needs to read between the lines…😵💫
I would change that the wisely twin that died, didn't. It's was very sad for me because the other lost his best bud and brother
Fred had to survive
I'm adding the deleted scene in deathly hallows where Draco passes harry his wand.
If let Sirius live. Not because hes my favorite character or anything, but that it was just so unfair to give him such a life and such an ending.
I would like Fred and Sirius to be alive, and Draco realising he’s with the school and throws Harry his wand from the deleted scene.
That Harry destroy one horocrux per book. Harry defeats each death eater one by one, if there was more than seven books. Hermonie in Ravenclaw. Harry’s mother still being alive.😊
I wish Dobby Sirius Fred Snape and Dumbledore didn't die 😭
Tonks Is my favorite character
How can the person who created the books be so far off? Harry and Hermione 100% should not have gotten together. Them staying friends is makes so much more sense
I’d have Belellatrix kill Ginny to fulfill that aspect of the Weasley family and Harry losing that irreplaceable figure, which was narratively important to Add gravity to the battle of hogwarts. But instead of killing Bella defending Ginny have Fred and Bella duel in the great hall so Molly can still have her Warrior Mom moment defending Fred, who should have lived.
I really want that scene of draco giving wand to harry in deadly hallows 2 which was deleted..😕😕
i always thought hermione shouldve ended up w harry and bring back dobby/hedwig/george and uh kill dolores/lucius
I would change Fred’s death dobby death and that deleted deathly hallows scene with Malfoy and Harry
The only thing that confuses me is that Cedric diggory was a fifth year when he participated in the triwizard tournament and instead of him being 15 he is 17 years and 9 months
first Hermione and Harry had to end up together second they didn't have to kill Sirius
The one Draco and harry deleted scene.
I change dobbys death
Wouldn't change the books as they are great but would change the movies to get rid of the traitorous cast that have bad mouthed her for her opinions
I need harry Hermione and Sirius back to life
Order of the phoenix where unlike the movie they don't have a happy reunion (harry and suris)
I don't want to change anything! The series is so fascinating,unique and emotional as well as inquisitive because of how it was written. All the sad and happy moments make the series what it is 😅
Hedwig
I want Fred and Sirius back 😢
I would change instead of using magic they use flamethrowers
I would change it so that I jump in at the last second and save the day; making me the random new character that beats Voldemort. 😂😂😂
This is big cap. There's no way J.K Rowling wanted Harry to end up with Hermione. It's forshadowed from book one that Ginny and Harry were meant for each other. Also, it's common knowledge that she wrote the last chapter of the series very early. So, she had always envisioned Harry and Ginny.
I'd like to see j.k do a book about peverell brothers,henry potter or fleamont potter?
Petter petigrew caught and serious black removed from all guilty actions
Dobbys dead because I love Dobby and Dobby is so cute, nice and fantastic.
Sirius, Lupin, and Freds death
Harry and Hermione are the best couple ever. Ron and Hermione don’t make sense at all, she wanted to kill Ron at some point. The weirdest couple ever: Harry and Ginny: shoelaces
SHE WROTE THE BOOKS!!!!!
Snape should have lived and grown closer to Harry after the battle of Hogwarts
I would change siriuse's death because that was Harry 's only family and i would have changed that harmione and Harry end up thogether
Fred's death and Dumbledore's death 😢😢😢😢😔😔😭😭😭💔💔
I would change Fred’s death and Severus and Lilly secretly got together but Harry real dad was james
I would change Fred and hedwigs death. And do us death. And Tink’s and lupin death. I would’ve had Draco not be so sad and be good in the end and give Harry and wand changing sides during the final battle.
Sorry I want to change a lot of things. But they all made me cry😭
me being like: THEN WHY DID YOU KILL OFF ONE OF THE BEST COUPLES OF HARRY POTTER?!
Honestly ,,there was no chemistry btw Harry and Jinny. I think Rowling should have written their romance better.
Harry and Luna works as well.