Vocal Coach Reacts to Mariah Carey Vs Beyonce VOCAL BATTLE

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 25. 11. 2019
  • Join my podcast - Podbean, Spotify & iTunes: honestvocalcoach.co.uk/podcast/
    *The Foundations of Singing - My Online Course is available NOW!
    This course is ideal for beginners or those wanting to know more about the technique of singing and have a daily vocal routine. It includes: How we sing, The Benefits of Singing, Warm Up exercises, Registers, Range, Personal Development and so much more. 17 lessons explained in a fun, honest and uncomplicated way. Now includes some extra special content from Robert Lunte, to understand Onsets.
    Take the course:
    www.udemy.com/course/the-foun...
    *Do you want me to critique your singing? Personal Critique or Instagram Reaction
    Go to honestvocalcoach.co.uk/critiq...
    *1-2-1 Lesson via Zoom or Skype - 30 minute or 1 hour sessions.
    Book here: honestvocalcoach.co.uk/1-2-1-...
    *Vocal Exercises to download: honestvocalcoach.co.uk/shop/
    *I now know - Georgina Hill-Brown (Original Song) Stream now: open.spotify.com/track/3onNs5...
    Main channel: / thenewfoundrystudios
    2nd Channel Being a youtuber and how to be successful on youtube: / channel
    Student Channel: / @studentsofthehonestvo...
    Social Media:
    Twitter: / thehonestvocal
    Instagram: / thehonestvocalcoach
    #honestvocalcoach #vocalcoachreacts #vocalbattle
    Who am I?
    I am the honest vocal coach! I have been teaching for 16 years and been singing since I was 17. I teach from my own studio and via Skype. I specialise in teaching children, and teenagers pop and musical theatre but I am trained in all genres of music. I have studied every voice technique there is, including Speech Level Singing, Estill, Bel Canto, Robert Lunte, London College of Music, ABRSM, Ria Keen, Kim Chandler, Stevie Van Lange and many more. I have been around!
    In 2008 I wrote the Vocaltutor Guide, 21 set lessons for singing teachers to get started, learning to teach, and produced 3 vocal exercise CD/Downloads.
    This video is for educational purposes and is not intended to infringe any copyright.
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 1,4K

  • @h.louise4746
    @h.louise4746 Před 2 lety +97

    I'm sorry, but Mariah in her prime was like a holy figure of song. Her gifts were ethereal...almost unbelievable.

  • @codywalsh2075
    @codywalsh2075 Před 4 lety +1704

    The fact that they used clips of Mariah in her 40s 😌💅

    • @slimjam2467
      @slimjam2467 Před 4 lety +108

      Alot of them r from when she was young

    • @nicholasmccarthy7057
      @nicholasmccarthy7057 Před 4 lety +164

      Right... Lol imagine if they just used Tokyo Mariah

    • @queenonikamaraj749
      @queenonikamaraj749 Před 4 lety +33

      Cody Walsh she was in her 20’s in alot of them

    • @harborsadolescentfears9322
      @harborsadolescentfears9322 Před 4 lety +51

      @@slimjam2467 It had a lot of videos of current Mariah too. Don't forget that Mariah is 12 years older than Beyonce and is 10 years more in the industry. They're both excellent.❤️

    • @halfie10
      @halfie10 Před 4 lety +20

      @@slimjam2467 she was over 40 in almost ALL the clips

  • @flowersaint8521
    @flowersaint8521 Před 4 lety +693

    omgs they mostly used mariah's clip in her 40s.

    • @harborsadolescentfears9322
      @harborsadolescentfears9322 Před 4 lety +72

      Finally. We ALL know prime Mariah was impeccable. But current Mariah still slay.

    • @bananamcdonald4916
      @bananamcdonald4916 Před 4 lety +9

      yeah, that's biased.

    • @atolm1
      @atolm1 Před 4 lety +7

      It's totally biased in bs favor, can tell from the volume alone

    • @kng001
      @kng001 Před 4 lety +3

      flower saint literally just one but go off and this was a good clips

    • @Ryan-sd8pb
      @Ryan-sd8pb Před 4 lety +7

      Beyonce's on point 4 to Mariah zero and so far Mariah has been her twenties in every clip...

  • @thehainote1082
    @thehainote1082 Před 4 lety +195

    I love how Beyoncé, the mezzo soprano, obviously win the lower notes, while Mariah - the soprano, win the higher notes. They’re both masters in vocal pedagogy

    • @Mizz3206
      @Mizz3206 Před 2 lety +10

      Mariah isn’t a soprano, watch interviews she said herself she is naturally an alto but she plays with her voice

    • @kennedy_junior13
      @kennedy_junior13 Před rokem +2

      Mariah isn't soprano hahaha 😂😂

    • @lougomes2912
      @lougomes2912 Před rokem +7

      @@Mizz3206 she never said that. And, yes, Mariah is a soprano. The highest type of soprano, actually

    • @audramcdonaldapologist3676
      @audramcdonaldapologist3676 Před rokem +2

      @@kennedy_junior13 she is your speaking voice doesn’t always equate to your singing voice

    • @audramcdonaldapologist3676
      @audramcdonaldapologist3676 Před rokem +1

      @@Mizz3206 alto is a real voice type it’s a choir part

  • @GuyGonzalez27
    @GuyGonzalez27 Před 4 lety +347

    Mariah is vocals , what she does with her voice is insane .. can’t wait for that 19th #1 🎅

  • @jeffreestars
    @jeffreestars Před 4 lety +491

    They did Mariah Carey wrong with some of those clips there is a lot better clips of Mariah Carey

  • @donahanks8733
    @donahanks8733 Před 4 lety +954

    No one will ever touch mariah vocally when she was in her prime! Beyonce is amazingly good

    • @harborsadolescentfears9322
      @harborsadolescentfears9322 Před 4 lety +39

      Agreed darling. She was a phenomenon.

    • @freebree7739
      @freebree7739 Před 4 lety +56

      Dona Hanks nah Beyoncé supported range is wider her voice is more agile

    • @freebree7739
      @freebree7739 Před 4 lety +24

      And her lows and hv are better and in consistently too

    • @freebree7739
      @freebree7739 Před 4 lety +13

      But only transitions go to Mariah

    • @orlock20
      @orlock20 Před 4 lety +3

      She didn't do well when she tried to sing rock songs.

  • @giulianacr2638
    @giulianacr2638 Před 4 lety +394

    Although I prefer Mariah, Bey is an amazing singer and I love her too... so 💓💓

  • @Miguelperry411
    @Miguelperry411 Před 4 lety +208

    MC is 11 years older than Bey.

    • @teew4496
      @teew4496 Před 4 lety +10

      Allegedly...

    • @SweetTikTokLife
      @SweetTikTokLife Před 4 lety +1

      omg rlly I didn’t know 😮

    • @wilfredomejia9221
      @wilfredomejia9221 Před 3 lety +5

      Así es mariah es más grande de edad que Beyoncé.y es una leyenda increíble y hermosa voz para siempre

  • @nate8525
    @nate8525 Před 4 lety +224

    Mariah for me but bey is definitely a great vocalist as well.

    • @rashonnahall3854
      @rashonnahall3854 Před 4 lety +18

      And a great performer at that.She's far from boring on stage.

    • @mooblink4ever899
      @mooblink4ever899 Před 3 lety

      @@rashonnahall3854 shut up kid! You don’t even know what a great technique is. So stfu

    • @vg6761
      @vg6761 Před 3 lety

      @@mooblink4ever899 comment reported

    • @thebestcicinmage4485
      @thebestcicinmage4485 Před 2 lety

      @@mooblink4ever899 you doing to much

  • @resurgam75
    @resurgam75 Před 4 lety +53

    MariahPrime was simply untouchable in my book.

  • @georgiarose9932
    @georgiarose9932 Před 4 lety +141

    Let's not sleep on the fact bey was rolling around on a damn piano and still hitting notes 💅💅💅

    • @christivnbaker
      @christivnbaker Před 4 lety +37

      EXACTLY. “I don’t know what all that rolling around on the floor business was.” Ma’am. It was a piano first off 🤣 and then she immediately gave Mariah the point after that incorrect statement like it had anything to do with the note 💀

    • @mooblink4ever899
      @mooblink4ever899 Před 3 lety +6

      @@christivnbaker I was so mad ☠️🤚😭

    • @aaronnewman7573
      @aaronnewman7573 Před 3 lety +5

      @@christivnbaker she gives very much entitled white woman sometimes…

    • @lukeplays1813
      @lukeplays1813 Před 3 lety

      aaron newman mariah is black but ok

    • @ysguthiofoberatos
      @ysguthiofoberatos Před 3 lety

      @@aaronnewman7573 umm that was unnecessary and irrelevant

  • @unomaster6828
    @unomaster6828 Před 4 lety +883

    Obviously Mariah wins, you guys might of heard this before, but Mariah at her prime was unstoppable.

    • @codywalsh2075
      @codywalsh2075 Před 4 lety +104

      Most of these clips weren't even Mariah's prime.

    • @omjayboy
      @omjayboy Před 4 lety +46

      This video includes videos of mariah way past her prime too

    • @popland1977
      @popland1977 Před 4 lety +30

      @Brooklyn Bey Beyonce is epic but her Bb2s are not real notes, they are vented air amplified by a microphone

    • @SamSam-rv6xd
      @SamSam-rv6xd Před 4 lety +31

      Brooklyn Bey fair but Mariah’s upper register was superior to Beyoncé’s in her prime regardless if she chose not to sustain upper belts. I blame nodules? I’d still put Mariah as the superior vocalist.

    • @ramonpadilha9987
      @ramonpadilha9987 Před 4 lety +6

      @Brooklyn Bey Mariah, Whitney, Beyonce, Celine neither of them is perfect. In anything. They are human beings. They can be good, great, excellent never perfect. Mariah is excellent. Even these days with 50% with her voice.

  • @bananamcdonald4916
    @bananamcdonald4916 Před 4 lety +200

    The fact that they used Mariah's clips from her 40's and beyoncé's more prime vocals. Anyways both are legends!

    • @kng001
      @kng001 Před 4 lety +23

      banana mcdonald They just showed one Mariah clip from her 40’s and it was a good clip. And they showed a clip of Beyoncé at 37.

    • @jhiion4
      @jhiion4 Před 4 lety +1

      Oh stop

    • @jacobkirk7298
      @jacobkirk7298 Před 4 lety +9

      banana mcdonald but beyoncé’s prime has been 06-19

    • @JCole-fg3rr
      @JCole-fg3rr Před 4 lety +16

      These weren’t prime Beyoncé vocals though lol

    • @jasontillett
      @jasontillett Před 4 lety +1

      KNG N they used more than one clip

  • @merayahcarey9390
    @merayahcarey9390 Před 4 lety +193

    Mariah in her prime was unmatched! Both are equally amazing but I love Mariah more cuz she's a musical genius

    • @ClassicLegend-iy3su
      @ClassicLegend-iy3su Před 4 lety +20

      No they’re not equally amazing! Mariah is better and there’s absolutely no comparison between them

    • @Michelle-hu3zn
      @Michelle-hu3zn Před 4 lety +2

      @@ClassicLegend-iy3su lol

    • @asmrlilvezzy6601
      @asmrlilvezzy6601 Před 3 lety +4

      Saiful Pulau besar wrong technique wise Mariah in her prime was better cause every last note was effortless and she has a 6 octaves voice the only thing that’s messed mariah up was her nodules and age

    • @cameronburgess4955
      @cameronburgess4955 Před 3 lety +1

      @@asmrlilvezzy6601 her prime she was much more inconsistent than Beyonce 💀 Beyonce in her prime was perfect

    • @EliteKaki
      @EliteKaki Před 2 lety +4

      @@cameronburgess4955 1998-2008 Beyonce??? PFFT please that gurl yelled outta her lungs. Only on some performances she sounded good.

  • @roccogrupillo2217
    @roccogrupillo2217 Před 2 lety +116

    mariah is one of the best vocalist to ever walk down the earth. but i have to say that beyonce is the ONLY contemporary mainstream artist that comes close to the vocal trinity technique wise.

    • @novaharerra2329
      @novaharerra2329 Před rokem

      Um kele Wyatt??

    • @SamanthaD89
      @SamanthaD89 Před rokem

      True, Mariah is my favorite singer of all time but I love beyonce as well. but as the person above mentioned KeKe Wyatt is amazing and very underrated. Her range is crazy!

    • @Ajth3gamer
      @Ajth3gamer Před měsícem

      Who​@@novaharerra2329

  • @xpinksweetcheeksx
    @xpinksweetcheeksx Před 4 lety +70

    It’s not always about “more strength”. Each singer has her own style, technique and delivery. Mariah wins her voice is magic

  • @igotagoodforehead6114
    @igotagoodforehead6114 Před 4 lety +37

    After this vid:
    *It's time to buy a new wig*

  • @josiahbutler2254
    @josiahbutler2254 Před 4 lety +72

    I was about to say a C5 is mariahs signature note its outstanding 😍, anybody else see that mariah is number 20 on spotify 😩?

  • @ricmont_6
    @ricmont_6 Před 4 lety +311

    They’re both legends in honesty Beyoncé has had a slightly better technique in preserving her voice though at the same time Mariah has nodules that get in her way a lot but still both amazing voices better than most singers today. 💓

    • @juancastillo2139
      @juancastillo2139 Před 4 lety +23

      of course you can preserve your voice if you lipsync and use prerecord tracks throughout your whole career, no hate Beyoncé is amazing and one of my idols but she does that as well as Mariah lipsyncs out of her prime and also dubbed some of her televised performances

    • @ashtonb7931
      @ashtonb7931 Před 4 lety +70

      Juan Castillo no...beyoncé literally has perfect technique lmao. y’all are weird

    • @brenttmiller93
      @brenttmiller93 Před 4 lety +55

      Juan Castillo this is why people look at mariah fans weird; you can dislike Beyonce, but mariah clearly lip syncs FAR more than Beyonce... lol

    • @touka7317
      @touka7317 Před 4 lety +45

      I know many people say Beyoncé has definitely better technique than Mariah. I just hate how she isn't seen as someone in the same calibre as Whitney, Celine, & Mariah because she is definitely up there. Beyoncè is just perceived as this dancer/performer with mediocre 'overrated' vocals and people think Adele is better than her smh. No offence to Adele. I'll still prefer Mariah though purely because I stan her lol

    • @cr3413
      @cr3413 Před 4 lety +24

      Mariah had superior technique. Her vocal decline was due to the nodules...not technique.

  • @CyprusHot
    @CyprusHot Před 4 lety +52

    Mariah Carey of course ! Her voice can not be replicated ! Her tone is unparalleled !

  • @royalisaac7787
    @royalisaac7787 Před 4 lety +105

    This was hard because they are both phenomenal 😂😂 they both are my favs vocalist

    • @ramonpadilha9987
      @ramonpadilha9987 Před 4 lety +6

      They're vocal Stars. ❤

    • @harborsadolescentfears9322
      @harborsadolescentfears9322 Před 4 lety +4

      I like Mariah better. Vocally, musically but Beyonce can slay too.❤️❤️

    • @denzellucas609
      @denzellucas609 Před 4 lety +5

      PLSSSS Beyonce isn't even in the top 10 greatest vocalist of all time. Mariah ate her up and this isn't even a competition

    • @toshiro8997
      @toshiro8997 Před 4 lety +7

      @@denzellucas609 u wish

    • @denzellucas609
      @denzellucas609 Před 4 lety +2

      @@toshiro8997 There's nothing to wish here. Mariah is a better vocalists than her. What's not clicking ma? 😂😂😂😂😂

  • @Otokage007
    @Otokage007 Před 4 lety +15

    you know when a young mariah clip is used, it's so obvious who's gonna get the point

  • @aaronwillis6035
    @aaronwillis6035 Před 4 lety +328

    Not gunna lie, these clips are slanted to Beyonce. Who ever made that comparison video has not used clips for Mariah where she would win each time, especially those low notes.

    • @xyxcvi6001
      @xyxcvi6001 Před 4 lety +22

      Beyoncé's better clips as well so I don't think so.

    • @JCole-fg3rr
      @JCole-fg3rr Před 4 lety +46

      That’s just not true. Whoever made this video chose THE WORST F5 for Beyoncé. Mariah wasn’t ever going to beat Beyoncé in low notes anyway.

    • @qxyzzz
      @qxyzzz Před 4 lety +25

      J. Cole And Beyonce was never gonna beat Mariah's super resonant F5s anyway, her placement is scarier than Christina Aguilera's screamed notes 🤷🏻‍♂️

    • @MatiiT
      @MatiiT Před 4 lety

      Exactly.

    • @toshiro8997
      @toshiro8997 Před 4 lety +21

      @@qxyzzz
      F5 Beyoncé > Mariah
      F#5 Mariah > Beyoncé

  • @nicholasmccarthy7057
    @nicholasmccarthy7057 Před 4 lety +28

    Mariah Carey ❤️

  • @ofclshn
    @ofclshn Před 4 lety +120

    I prefer Beyoncé because of her control and technique.

    • @khalidahmed8852
      @khalidahmed8852 Před 4 lety +1

      Rashaun agreed

    • @federicoraggio8111
      @federicoraggio8111 Před 4 lety +33

      Her technique is unbelievable but ain't no one that controls a voice like Mariah does and especially did in the '90's. Her voice is an instrument, one second she's singing in the second octave... the second after she's speaking with dolphins.

    • @million_mac9835
      @million_mac9835 Před 4 lety +4

      Beyonce is everything

    • @uiteren2845
      @uiteren2845 Před 4 lety +4

      Federico Raggio Mariah can never do staccatos, subito pocos, transitions, and messa di voces as precise and as accurate than the likes of Beyoncé and SoHyang. Beyonce having different approaches on notes whilst maintaining support up to E5 consistently speaks volumes of her control. Mariah is only better at legato phrasing but even in that SoHyang is arguably better in legatos.

    • @dalidaregina
      @dalidaregina Před 3 lety

      @@uiteren2845 check her cover for over the rainbow, and live "the one".

  • @renniakanak
    @renniakanak Před 4 lety +194

    I prefer Beyoncé! She's my queen! But I appreciate Mariah :)

    • @christinamilian91
      @christinamilian91 Před 4 lety +20

      Mariah is the best no doubt

    • @federicoraggio8111
      @federicoraggio8111 Před 4 lety +6

      @@christinamilian91 I prefer Mariah too, by far. But it's ok not to like her style or to prefer someone else. What's undeniable is her superiority ofc

    • @michaelbruno1330
      @michaelbruno1330 Před 4 lety

      You must really enjoy being mediocre then

    • @danllyodsambajon5914
      @danllyodsambajon5914 Před 3 lety

      Sameee

    • @Marc004
      @Marc004 Před 3 lety +17

      @@michaelbruno1330 Beyoncé is many things, mediocre is not

  • @xmv1404
    @xmv1404 Před 4 lety +9

    Pétition for "Honest vocal coach" Georgia to sustain an A5 live thanks babe

  • @hausensdaydream9319
    @hausensdaydream9319 Před 4 lety +132

    There's a reason why Mariah is the most successful female artist of all time

    • @nicolasmordechai139
      @nicolasmordechai139 Před 4 lety +9

      Who told you she's the most successful woman in music? What about the queen celine?

    • @Hakakuno
      @Hakakuno Před 4 lety +24

      Madonna has sold more. don’t equate sales to talent.

    • @keauntv3543
      @keauntv3543 Před 4 lety

      Nicolas Mordechai billboard did.

    • @nathanieljohnson5908
      @nathanieljohnson5908 Před 4 lety +9

      @@keauntv3543 billboard is US only, not worldwide. Madonna is worldwide and Mariah is 4th behind Madonna, Rihanna, and Celine dion

    • @chenseler85
      @chenseler85 Před 4 lety +2

      Yeah but although I love me some Madonna, if you think she’s a better vocalist than any of them, especially Mariah (and Celine), you’re dreaming lol.

  • @crystalmorisson4810
    @crystalmorisson4810 Před 4 lety +78

    What I really love about this is noticing how natural it is for Mariah vs Beyonce having incredible scaling techniques. Beyonces voice has always been strong to me if anything id compare her to Whitney instead of Mariah

    • @arslanferatovic135
      @arslanferatovic135 Před 6 měsíci

      check Mariahs live performances from 1990-1996 where she sings far from the mic but still outsinging choirs etc. Mariah has a huge voice, especially in her mid belts e.g. I cant LIIIVE if living is without you, etc. She has many qualities of her voice so she doesnt always go for powerful belting, but that doesnt mean she cant sound solid, strong, powerful...even Whitney the Voice was intimidated before they became friends, check If Its Over live or You need me or Theres gotta be a way :)

  • @noah.creative
    @noah.creative Před 4 lety +131

    i don't care what you say. Mariah Carey is the best vocalist to ever walk this planet.

    • @truegrit2011
      @truegrit2011 Před 4 lety +1

      🤤 🤔😂

    • @ilovepiano3333
      @ilovepiano3333 Před 4 lety +2

      Love her as well but unfortunately the vocals did not stay at a high level up to today

    • @peachy2236
      @peachy2236 Před 4 lety

      Agreed!

    • @harborsadolescentfears9322
      @harborsadolescentfears9322 Před 4 lety +8

      @@ilovepiano3333 Vocal Nodules darling. But they used a lot of her recent vocals here.

    • @Solo-vh9fm
      @Solo-vh9fm Před 4 lety

      In her prime definately. There was literally (and this is true today on a good day) nothing that Mariah couldnt do, she had every register and she was one of the best in every single register (including head voice which is extremely underrated), and has probably the best agility

  • @ravioli8959
    @ravioli8959 Před 4 lety +1

    Love how these comments are mostly positive towards both artists (even if you prefer one over the other). We need more of this ❤️!

  • @omarhuete704
    @omarhuete704 Před 4 lety +25

    I love Mariah Carey.

  • @yourmajesty7604
    @yourmajesty7604 Před 4 lety +90

    I love Mimi but Béy is *the* definition of a vocal technician. She has mastered her craft and rarely will you catch her off. Love them both!

    • @keauntv3543
      @keauntv3543 Před 4 lety +16

      I can’t take you serious 😂😂🤦🏾‍♂️ nO. Mariah is the definition of a vocal goddess

    • @neutralman9124
      @neutralman9124 Před 4 lety +10

      @@keauntv3543 Can't take a different opinion to yours? Sad. A

    • @damienshyboy
      @damienshyboy Před 4 lety +5

      Lmao I dont like any of them but the fact you say beyonce is the definition of vocal is insulting in every single way lol

    • @amira2809
      @amira2809 Před 4 lety +5

      nah, you probably didnt see mariah in her prime. Bey is in her prime now, but if we compare bey to mc in her prime, bey will lose.

    • @brenttmiller93
      @brenttmiller93 Před 4 lety +10

      idunnoman ? We’re talking about vocal technique... Mariah’s prime was short because although her voice is amazing, her technique is questionable... Beyoncé’s technique is far better than Mariah’s, which is why her prime has lasted far longer than Mariah’s.

  • @stevealvyzak288
    @stevealvyzak288 Před 4 lety +189

    Mariah for the Win.

  • @mikhaellockhart4925
    @mikhaellockhart4925 Před 4 lety +5

    This made my day just to see both legends. I don’t even care about the competition. Great video! Great surprise!

  • @whitepaper5241
    @whitepaper5241 Před 4 lety +35

    As a huge fan of both artists, i would choose the best notes for each artist. The owner of the video chose some of not-so-good Mariah's notes, and some of Bey's notes aren't good either. Making a comparison video means you have to showcase the best notes from each singer so that the comparison can go neck-to-neck. Especially star-rated vocalists like Mariah and Beyoncé, whose vocal abilities are unmatched.

  • @crazycatpetera1404
    @crazycatpetera1404 Před 4 lety +59

    Beyoncé is a fantastic singer with great technique. Where as Mariah’s voice is a gift from God! Mariah is one of the greatest singers of all time! Beyoncé is great too, but not on the same level as Mariah 🙌🏻🙏🏻

  • @MrTheLionKing1986
    @MrTheLionKing1986 Před 4 lety +120

    1sttt and.... MARIAAAAAH

  • @SKMRify
    @SKMRify Před 4 lety +75

    *Mariah's timbre will appeal to more people; and her ability to switch between different parts of her voice is unsurpassed (and seldom equaled). Beyonce is more consistent, and has a more impressive arsenal of complex **_fiorature_** and vocal dynamic structures. The End.*

  • @eltonsouzasantos4875
    @eltonsouzasantos4875 Před 4 lety +168

    Mariah the best vocalist ever!

    • @nicholasmccarthy7057
      @nicholasmccarthy7057 Před 4 lety +5

      Facts

    • @orlock20
      @orlock20 Před 4 lety +2

      When it comes to the style of R&B that she sang, but she stumbled outside of that genre.

    • @avilik13
      @avilik13 Před 4 lety

      @@orlock20 she wasn't really r&b. She was pop.

    • @federicoraggio8111
      @federicoraggio8111 Před 4 lety +5

      @@orlock20 she is INCREDIBLE also in Jazz, Pop, Contemporary R&B and even Rock, her version of Bringin On The Heartbreak is insane.

    • @cr3413
      @cr3413 Před 4 lety

      Stumbled outside of r&b? Lol, the delusion. Mariah had the most versatile voice.

  • @akmal1306
    @akmal1306 Před 4 lety +158

    Mariah WINS! There's just something about her voice that can't be explained with words. Her tone is just... not boring.

    • @4cory
      @4cory Před 4 lety +32

      neither is beyoncé’s lol

    • @Perseus99
      @Perseus99 Před 4 lety +13

      I agree. Beyonce's voice is so boring.

    • @user-eh2ty4mv3e
      @user-eh2ty4mv3e Před 4 lety +14

      And Mariah doesn’t over sing every freakin note lmao 😂

    • @ashtonb7931
      @ashtonb7931 Před 4 lety +8

      KS Moore beyoncé doesnt oversing now...at all..lmao

    • @Rubyru177
      @Rubyru177 Před 4 lety +1

      Mariah can whistle with her nodules on the cords hi is an alto

  • @shivensrivastava4933
    @shivensrivastava4933 Před 4 lety +68

    I would say mariah in her prime edges Beyonce out. That being said, Mariah now cannot be compared to Beyonce now, and Beyonce still has more to give us!

    • @taylorharris1796
      @taylorharris1796 Před 4 lety +3

      Shiven Srivastava Mariah won his battle using clips from outside of her prime. I think that says that she still can outshine Beyonce vocally.

    • @mariahcareyxqueenburke9440
      @mariahcareyxqueenburke9440 Před 4 lety +2

      Shiven Srivastava obviously you haven’t seen her Christmas performance from two nights ago, once you watch it you’ll see

    • @Matt-hn4zc
      @Matt-hn4zc Před 4 lety +3

      Shiven Srivastava beyonce is only 38 and her voice has changed. Mariah was pumping out actual billboard #1 hits at that age still. Mariah is now almost 50

    • @runbarryrun9815
      @runbarryrun9815 Před 4 lety +2

      Have seen Mariah singing recently? In a lot of her performances now, she sounds great. No hate on Beyonce though, she's great too.

    • @spiritguidethee9992
      @spiritguidethee9992 Před 4 lety +5

      Lol Beyonce aint got SQUAT on ol skool Mariah with that being said, 2019 Mariah Absolutely cannot sing better than New Skool Beyonce because Beyonce's technique has gotten better & better.

  • @jesussheep07
    @jesussheep07 Před 4 lety +79

    OFC Mariah was going to win, nobody touches her, she is queen!

  • @CKFIERCE1
    @CKFIERCE1 Před 4 lety +94

    Did you really just say that Beyonce's head voice was "hooty"?
    It was well rounded and well supported...

    • @mkluna9513
      @mkluna9513 Před 4 lety +13

      It was hooty!

    • @ferdynand2402
      @ferdynand2402 Před 4 lety +6

      It is hooty

    • @factpreacher5691
      @factpreacher5691 Před 3 lety +2

      I'm thinking the same thing, it's more supported it almost like operatic singing.

    • @hutchrivers2912
      @hutchrivers2912 Před 3 lety +2

      Yes it was supported but it was still "hooty". That's all Beyonce does when it comes to those sorts of notes. Beyonce always starts with that "hooty" sound. Beyonce has loads of agility, but she is still one dimensional when it comes to head voice.

    • @MartyMusic777
      @MartyMusic777 Před 3 lety +1

      That's lovely for opera, but she's singing pop.

  • @montezbagg
    @montezbagg Před 2 lety +6

    comparing beyonce to mariah is like mixing oil with water. they both have there own vocal technique that cant be compared and they 2 are one of the best vocalists that walked this earth.

  • @christiansantos6115
    @christiansantos6115 Před 4 lety +28

    Mariah Carey!! Amo

  • @rowlandcollins7768
    @rowlandcollins7768 Před 4 lety +2

    You look Amazing! Love your hair color!

  • @DuyLe-qg1gb
    @DuyLe-qg1gb Před 4 lety +4

    Love both, they're among the best voices left in today's contemporary music

  • @rydbthatsme
    @rydbthatsme Před 4 lety +122

    Mariah hands down👌🏼

  • @noah.creative
    @noah.creative Před 4 lety +1

    was a really fun video to watch thank you

  • @pavelbens354
    @pavelbens354 Před 4 lety +3

    My 2 most favourite singers in the world, thank you for this

  • @rubyred2874
    @rubyred2874 Před 3 lety +5

    Both are very talented. I grew up with Mariah and find her honey sounding voice very relaxing and beautiful plus she has a wonderful stage presence.

  • @chanellopezzzz
    @chanellopezzzz Před 4 lety +29

    I’m ready asf

  • @luisorlandoleoncarpio2235

    It’s insane doing a comparison like that that actually works! Firts of all, it’s quite easy to cheat on if you have a preference by choosing random clips from the Internet. Do you know how many time each singer sings a song in a tour? Docens! Sometimes great, sometime just good! Sometimes each one slays, sometime each one not that much! A real comparison is taking both singing the same song in the best time of each one! In mu opinion that’s the best way to see the particularities! And yet, ay the end, all depends of styles and things like that! (Sorry for my english, i do my best)

  • @MissUnderstoodasAlways

    I love these fun videos. People should relax. It’s a battle. We win some we lose some. No one disputes the people chosen are amazing in their own way.

  • @uchihaitachi5905
    @uchihaitachi5905 Před 4 lety +13

    Mariah has more resonance from around Bb4 upwards.

  • @tchakakhan5939
    @tchakakhan5939 Před 4 lety +88

    of all the F5s they could’ve chosen for Beyoncé, her money note. Tragic

    • @thedivasofsupreme6190
      @thedivasofsupreme6190 Před 4 lety +13

      Yall Are Going to JAIL. PERIODT. That F5 that was used for Mariah was so unexpected like wtf is that, not even one of her top 100 best F5’s

    • @qxyzzz
      @qxyzzz Před 4 lety +2

      Yall Are Going to JAIL. PERIODT. Dahling you haven't even seen the wrath of Mariah's incredibly resonant F5s lmao, don't even get me started there.

    • @ImaniLai
      @ImaniLai Před 4 lety

      RIGHTTTTT

    • @heated2382
      @heated2382 Před 4 lety

      If only they chose the note she hit at Mrs carter when she didn't decide to do the CIL run

    • @bleak1244
      @bleak1244 Před 4 lety

      @@heated2382 or of they chose one of her many F5s that she hit in 1994 in that Joy to The World performance. Both queen sof F5s we stan them.

  • @joaopauloneves1832
    @joaopauloneves1832 Před 4 lety

    as I always loved your criticism❤️ and you look beautiful in this video❤️

  • @stylestar07
    @stylestar07 Před 4 lety +12

    I feel a vocal battle between Celine Dion vs Mariah Carey would have been more fitting as they both started around the same time and are real musical peers, based on longevity in the business. Beyonce musical peers are Fantasia Burrino, Jennifer Hudson, Carrie Underwood, and Kelly Clarkson.

    • @christopherpagan8781
      @christopherpagan8781 Před 4 lety +1

      theCreator Great point.

    • @AP-mb8cu
      @AP-mb8cu Před 4 lety +4

      True but Bey is way better than any of her peers which is why she is out of a category cause she doesn’t fit in the 90s divas but demolishes any vocal competition from the 2000s or 2010s

    • @ashtonb7931
      @ashtonb7931 Před 4 lety +6

      theCreator beyoncé is far better than any vocalist you mentioned besides mariah. literally FAR better. it’s not about generation and decade love lmao

    • @neutralman9124
      @neutralman9124 Před 4 lety

      @@AP-mb8cu Not Kelly Clarkson. That woman can do astonishing things with her voice.

    • @reonwright4217
      @reonwright4217 Před 2 lety

      Those are not Beyoncé’s peers.

  • @jacobalbrecht759
    @jacobalbrecht759 Před 4 lety +15

    There are several clips of Mariah in her 40’s though..

  • @Alfonso-es6ze
    @Alfonso-es6ze Před 4 lety +47

    Beyonce is in her vocal prime right now. Mariah was in the 94. Right now in 2019 beyonce is a more consistent vocalist, but if we compare prime beyonce vs prime mariah i think mariah win. Both are amazing vocalist with really strong technique, but I think prime mariah is unmatched. And the fact that mariah in 2018 (as some clips) can battle with a young beyounce says a lot to me.

    • @personalyt6728
      @personalyt6728 Před 4 lety

      Mariah is a soprano and beyonce is a Mezzo soprano. The comparison is kind of pountless.

    • @whatdidisay564
      @whatdidisay564 Před 3 lety +1

      @@personalyt6728 mariah is an alto according to her

    • @novaharerra2329
      @novaharerra2329 Před rokem

      Beyonce was not in her vocal prime and isn't now...she can't even go as high as she use to.

    • @darrellnichols6548
      @darrellnichols6548 Před rokem +1

      @@novaharerra2329 Beyoncé can still sing tf is you talking about 🥴

    • @angels8920
      @angels8920 Před rokem

      @@novaharerra2329 😂try again maybe🤕

  • @Antboogie0828
    @Antboogie0828 Před 4 lety

    Love the bangs

  • @kylee1006
    @kylee1006 Před 4 lety +2

    Love your new hair do❤️

  • @daniadam4661
    @daniadam4661 Před 4 lety +37

    Mariah, dahhling....🤩🤩

  • @alexandervelez9507
    @alexandervelez9507 Před 4 lety +7

    i love both. in terms of where they are currently i would give it to beyoncé but i can easily admit 90’s mariah was incomparable.

  • @sirgeorge152
    @sirgeorge152 Před 4 lety +3

    Now That's What I Call a vocal battle.

  • @Willlll1m
    @Willlll1m Před 4 lety +80

    They are both incredible but let's be honest Beyonce herself would admit that she doesn't compare to Mariah in her peak

    • @Ryan-sd8pb
      @Ryan-sd8pb Před 4 lety +29

      Beyonce is a better vocalist in terms of technical ability. I care for the tone of Mariah's voice more but if you're comparing weight, resonance, connection, support etc, Bey is going to win every time.

    • @rydercdaniels4475
      @rydercdaniels4475 Před 4 lety +25

      Oh please. Objectively Beyoncé’s vocal technique and a miles better and she’s vocally way more consistent than Mariah ever was or ever will be

    • @federicoraggio8111
      @federicoraggio8111 Před 4 lety +22

      @@Ryan-sd8pb are you serious? Mariah has BY FAR the most skills ever!! And resonance?! Bey is insane but still far from Mariah's resonance. Mariah belts with the tone of an angel and the resonance of a ringing bell.

    • @lindokuhlemnqayi6656
      @lindokuhlemnqayi6656 Před 4 lety +5

      Willlll1m Maria has no energy

    • @playlistkweentv7421
      @playlistkweentv7421 Před 4 lety +2

      @@lindokuhlemnqayi6656 plus stuck in one place ....yer bey be doing the most and still deliver every note

  • @mateophillips5606
    @mateophillips5606 Před 4 lety +22

    I feel like Mariah has such a beautiful natural tone. Beyoncé is a wonderful singer, she has been beautifully trained.

  • @AndreyLepher
    @AndreyLepher Před 4 lety +12

    I prefer mariah but Both are true singers everybody knows that !!

  • @lucasgsellier
    @lucasgsellier Před 4 lety +1

    I really love you ! You are a queen

  • @benjamineleazar
    @benjamineleazar Před 4 lety +1

    Love them both!

  • @thomasyewcic3520
    @thomasyewcic3520 Před 4 lety +3

    When I saw this title I was SHOOK

  • @axelito6342
    @axelito6342 Před 4 lety +19

    The fact that we are here comparing a soprano vs a mezzo is a proof that Beyoncé is one of the best singer ! Both amazing

    • @abraham__810
      @abraham__810 Před 5 měsíci

      Beyoncé is more like a heaping can of trash

  • @IAMMOVIN4WARD
    @IAMMOVIN4WARD Před 4 lety +1

    Nice makeup Georgina!😍😉

  • @reallove16121969
    @reallove16121969 Před 4 lety +1

    I LOVE THEM BOTH. THEY ARE GREAT SINGERS WITH AMAZING VOICE.

  • @wilfredotomas6236
    @wilfredotomas6236 Před 4 lety +32

    Of course mariah carey is the best the any artist never compare👏👏👏👏👏

  • @Solo-vh9fm
    @Solo-vh9fm Před 4 lety +10

    Beyoncé’s “D3, Eb3 and E3s” were actually Eb3, E3 and F3 respectively
    Apart from that I would have said (with different clips) pretty much every note would be tied with the exceptions of Beyoncé’s head voice slightly beating Mariah’s and Mariah’s upper belts being slightly better (plus she has a G5). And we don’t have to talk about the extra thing Mariah has

    • @troy7835
      @troy7835 Před 4 lety +2

      Solo12313 ...don’t even say slightly beating for the head voice aspect, Beyoncé hv is much better than Mariah as Mariah is more falsetto and whistle

    • @kingc1468
      @kingc1468 Před 4 lety +1

      @@troy7835 Well Beyoncé is dancing between these clips so add that.

  • @KiaRoane
    @KiaRoane Před 4 lety

    I love a shady expert. Subscribed!!!

  • @chrism6636
    @chrism6636 Před 4 lety

    Love your videos! You're so entertaining and insightful. Would love you to cover a recent steps live performance!

  • @antoniofaroppa4347
    @antoniofaroppa4347 Před 4 lety +5

    Georgina love your work. I think you should pick the clips from your self cause you are judging someone else choice. With your ears you would take instead a better and a more equal choice. I know it's a little more work but it worth in the name of the work s quality isn't?

  • @AshleyS60
    @AshleyS60 Před 4 lety +48

    Beyonce is good but come on Mariah is EXCEPTIONAL! Mimi in her prime was beyond unstoppable and most of clips used here were of Mariah in her 40s...that shouldn't have been such a close score imo
    It's simple, there's Mariah Carey and then there's everyone else.

    • @butterflyszn2342
      @butterflyszn2342 Před 4 lety +11

      AshleyS60 beyoncé is better than “good,” she’s the definition of a vocal technician

    • @nathanieljohnson5908
      @nathanieljohnson5908 Před 4 lety +3

      Prime Mariah isn't perfect. I would say prime Aretha and Whitney are better

  • @jikookietings2507
    @jikookietings2507 Před 4 lety

    I hope you’re feeling well, Georgina!

  • @jaelespinoza5062
    @jaelespinoza5062 Před 4 lety +1

    such a hard battle, both women are just superior in every way

  • @isaiasgomez4388
    @isaiasgomez4388 Před 4 lety +42

    Well, I prefer Beyoncé as artist cause she have amazing shows where we can see that she also is super talented for dance

    • @banheesos
      @banheesos Před 4 lety +5

      Ikr, you'll surely get the performance your money's worth.

    • @rashonnahall3854
      @rashonnahall3854 Před 4 lety +1

      And she's creative!Other than Madonna,Prince and Michael J.

    • @aartlaurel1059
      @aartlaurel1059 Před 4 lety +8

      beyoncé a better artist? entertainer sure but artist wise? lol didn't she got sued for claiming she wrote a song?

    • @michaelbruno1330
      @michaelbruno1330 Před 4 lety +2

      Okay both things that you've just mentioned as a reason for liking her has actually nothing to do with her vocal ability

    • @laug1576
      @laug1576 Před 3 lety +2

      But Mariah produces and writes

  • @BrownEyedGirl.
    @BrownEyedGirl. Před 4 lety +44

    Beyoncé is so good, but let's be honest, it's moronic to say she's better than the song bird supreme. Kind of shady to put videos of Mariah at her 40s. Anyways...
    Love them both.

    • @simonamukushu8521
      @simonamukushu8521 Před 4 lety +14

      I wouldn't say it's moronic
      Beyoncé is regarded as a master vocal technician and the points suggest that they are almost on the same plain field.

    • @BrownEyedGirl.
      @BrownEyedGirl. Před 4 lety +2

      @@simonamukushu8521
      But they're not.

    • @qxyzzz
      @qxyzzz Před 4 lety +1

      Brad jones I mean not really, Mariah has a unique voice that has nodules, so her technique is gonna be completely different to Beyonce's. Style wise vocally they are similar tho.

    • @ashtonb7931
      @ashtonb7931 Před 4 lety +5

      Spoonie Girl moronic...? absolutely not. beyoncé is literally a vocal technician

    • @federicoraggio8111
      @federicoraggio8111 Před 4 lety +2

      @@simonamukushu8521 yes nowadays! but when Mariah was in her prime... omg the girl was inhuman.

  • @mateoc5184
    @mateoc5184 Před 4 lety

    Editing queen

  • @rifqiachmad1355
    @rifqiachmad1355 Před 4 lety +1

    They were friends. And they are amazing. Love Mimi

  • @NasHackss
    @NasHackss Před 4 lety +10

    Mariah all the way... i love both but if we're talking about vocal agility and range..Mariah is 🙌🙌🙌

  • @jackwulfric8019
    @jackwulfric8019 Před 4 lety +3

    Nice video!!
    This is one of those cases where the winner doesn't matter. Both are THE best vocalists in the game (alive) and the artists and fans both love each other cause we stan talent 💜

  • @guilherme-pk7hx
    @guilherme-pk7hx Před 4 lety +1

    thankfully i stan both of them

  • @SilentAssassin01234
    @SilentAssassin01234 Před 4 lety +1

    That G#5 clip are both headvoice. Mariah belts an Eb5 before hand but the headvoice/falsetto afterwards is the G#5.

  • @OMGitsAmora
    @OMGitsAmora Před 4 lety +34

    so because she rolled on the floor , she didn’t sound good 😭😭😭

    • @hallislay9025
      @hallislay9025 Před 3 lety +14

      obviously biased 😂 whenever Beyoncé won she gave them a point each. didn’t even play Beyoncé’s last clip

    • @bale4534
      @bale4534 Před 3 lety

      @@hallislay9025 yeah i already know this gonna happen

    • @aubrey_reignz5484
      @aubrey_reignz5484 Před 3 lety +2

      @@hallislay9025 I noticed that too 😂😂 Beyoncé clearly won this battle but if we gonna be fair most of mariahs clips were from past her prime

    • @unknowngaming0000
      @unknowngaming0000 Před 3 lety

      @@hallislay9025 OMGG IKRR u can tell she enjoyed it because she smiled and she still said point each

    • @ismaelm.mbaangue9147
      @ismaelm.mbaangue9147 Před 3 lety

      Com'on you clearly can't compare beyonce to Mariah Lmao. She did more points to beyonce first in the lows without hear mariah's note so🤷‍♂️

  • @parisyourhot
    @parisyourhot Před 4 lety +5

    Beyoncé’s live vocals have SO much reverb in the microphone, she doesn’t need all that she can sing.

  • @danedodds5930
    @danedodds5930 Před 4 lety +1

    You are hilarious. Love this.

  • @ryantan341
    @ryantan341 Před 4 lety

    I love both ladies they both have incredible voices

  • @xhboots1967
    @xhboots1967 Před 4 lety +80

    Beyonce has WAY MANY MORE EXCELLENT CLIPS. These Beyonce clips here are mediocre. They dont really highlight her vocal dexterity.

    • @cloroxbitch2491
      @cloroxbitch2491 Před 4 lety +14

      Okay but Beyonce's mic has vocal effects which makes her sound so much better. Meanwhile Mariah doesn't use vocal effects often when singing live.

    • @zalenahquaddy4354
      @zalenahquaddy4354 Před 4 lety +6

      @@cloroxbitch2491 And literally all Mariahs clips besides a few were mediocre clips, they're good but Mariahs has done way better, and they kept using Mariah clips past prime( which she slayed in) but was still biased towards beyonce...

    • @cloroxbitch2491
      @cloroxbitch2491 Před 4 lety +7

      @Dude Cipher Beyonce can sing. But Beyonce vs Mariah acapella.... Mariah wins easily.

    • @WElppp
      @WElppp Před 4 lety +2

      Colin Travers Beyoncé was in her 30s on most like Mariah lmao

    • @unidentifiedflyingbiatch6268
      @unidentifiedflyingbiatch6268 Před 4 lety

      That's just the way Beyonce sings. Mariah sings differently when she was younger.

  • @andiisepulveda5554
    @andiisepulveda5554 Před 4 lety +5

    MARIAH CAREY QUEEN THE QUEENS!!! I LOVE YOU. Saludos a todos desde Chile 🇨🇱🇨🇱🇨🇱

  • @Gabe-jq4gk
    @Gabe-jq4gk Před 3 lety

    you just had me laugh my lungs out whe. U said rolling on the floor business😂😅😂😅

  • @ReginaLynnavatar
    @ReginaLynnavatar Před 4 lety

    Loookin like a Glamor Girl!💅💃✨