Tying Imposition Of Hindi With Nationalism A Bogus Idea: Prakash Belawadi | IT Conclave South 2018
Vložit
- čas přidán 29. 08. 2024
- heatre and film personality Prakash Belawadi today said that tying "imposition of Hindi" with nationalism is a "bogus" idea. "The idea of Hindi imposition and to conflate it with nationalism is entirely bogus," said actor Prakash Belawadi at the India Today Conclave South 2018.
The 2nd Edition of India Today Conclave South 2018 in Hyderabad, brings together reputed Chief Ministers, political leaders, movie stars, business tycoons, artists, thought leaders and news-makers from the south under one platform to discuss, debate and decipher the roadmap of the six southern states.
There are many things that Kannadigas and Tamils don't agree on. But, when it comes to the right to cherish and celebrate ones' own mother tongue, we stand with you my dear Kannadiga brothers.
Bro..im a tamizhan living in bangalore...i feel what u said👌👌
I'm a Bengali. This Hindi Imposition is not to be tolerated.
what about telugu ppl ?
and malayalam people ?
@Ayush Chaturvedi You're a very rare north Indian to find my man & your level of understanding is much more than most of your fellow people & I've never seen a north indian say something like that. We always should respect indigenous cultures.
@Ayush Chaturvedi unexpected comment from a Hindi speaker. Usually North Indians start with cuss words. You understand the feeling in South. But you don't have to be ashamed of your language. Hindi and English have now become the language of India. Try to learn some southern language if you like. Please visit South if possible. Damn. So much positivity from you
Ok we South Indians will learn Hindi but do mandate Kannada in Madhya Pradesh, Tamil in UP, Telugu in Bihar, Malayalam in Punjab or Haryana
Bro I'm a hindi from up. And yes I want to learn tamil. Schooling syllabus should add other indian language too.
Kaushal Ram my friend no one is againt regional language . but dont paint hindi language sign.
chidu super army my dear in south most of people can understand hindi . and hindi is spoken in every part of india . even in karnataka. v about adopt hindi as a all regional language . i m not againt kannad but dont beat people who speek hindi . not u people r demandind your own state flag tommarow u will say separate karnataka from india . rubbish thinking u people have got . dont force some to speek their regional language . and dont beat people u speek hindi . thank you.
chidu super army u people are biggest chutias of india . u will not understand u brainless shit. when a southindian was beaten in north india because of language difference. dont spread lies . u people attach hindi speakind people in your region i think u r living in lala land . do research on google how many attack u brainless people do to hindi speaking people's. and how much v attack u for speaking your regional language . go and research . dont know any thing .
chidu super army i m your daddy go ask your mom . who is your real daddy is. she will tell my name . go go .. go home and ask your mither . still reading your daddy mesg . 😂😂😂
I don't want Hindi in South.
We have greatest launguges Kannada tamil telugu and Malayalam 👌👌👌
also in northeast..
This Hindi vs other languages argument is so stupid , no one is imposing anything..... I have been to kerela & TN and nobody there learns Hindi..................... and in the comment section I saw many arrogant South Indians talking about how poor and uneducated North Indians in my state my immigrants from Bihar comes but we don't make fun of them.............. I don't why we are arguing about it, if this method (English link language) is working then why to change it?
Yes
Thats y u r tamil not indian
@@R.sh02 you are north indian .we love speak marathi
I am from Bengal and i support our south Indian Brother. We should Fight back against Hindi and promote our language
Rightly said bro.
chidu super army of course, after all Hindi is yet another language spoken in northern parts of India, not an official language
Sifu A go pakistan ideot . no one is againt regional language . but dont paint hindi signs.
Why Bengali should not made national Language
Chup bangladeshi
The Anchor himself was relentlessly batting for Hindi. with every one in the discussion panel opposed Hindi , he half heartedly closed the discussion. Racism galore.
Dreams of India Kalapppppa
he says when it is Kaalappa
Kannad He says when it is Kannada
This Anchor was no different from others with a preconceived notion of superiority.
Its just that he was outnumbered.
Please , when will these mainstream television anchors learn to show better body language and demeanour when dealing with Non Hindi panellists.
I have always been referred to as "Madrasi" and asked whether I spoke "south indian" ...!!!!!pathetic..!
As though we are all Padosan stereotypes.......
Absolutely correct
Anchor is upper caste Hindu north Indian...they are most racist and biased peoples on earth....the hindi news channel are controlled by them....
Very correct.
Brilliantly spoken by Prakash..he spoke on behalf of all kannadigas I believe.. thank you sir...
I'm a tuluva,also a kannadiga,most importantly an Indian.
I do speak hindi passably but Hindi was never my mother tongue and never will be.
There's absolutely no point in imposing Hindi on us.
Karnataka itself is linguistically very diverse,we speak Kannada,Tulu and konkani.
Kannada further has over 10 dialects.
We are unique nation because we have been able to embrace such diversity and co-exist with each other.
Imposition will only lead to further division,so be sensible fellas...!!!
Give me an answer why do you learn English?
Aditya Jena because it's a global common tongue.
The entire corporate world uses it, leading to better job prospects.
If you are asking us to learn Hindi rather than speaking a foreign tongue.
Then I'd be happy to see Kannada as my national language,it's an Indian language as well you see.
Mr. Akansh..where u been years back when hindi posters,slogans and used frequently in the capital..?Just because some fringe group polarises the opinion so u felt sudden a proud kannadiga...no one will or can impose the language here or anywhere in any nation ..its just about acceptance....hindi is our always national language..dont go with wikepedia..i agree its writtten as official language in our constitution because tamilnadu didn't accept dis..as they have some issue with dis....so supreme court given some timeframe to change the opinion of TN..but it end up no change....do u think indian politicians made conspiracy in pre independence era that impose hindi in all state..But rage started in 2000s ...how ?? where u been bro till dis time ? its just politics to win elections and show how ur ruling gov care about locals and their jobs...and wants to become saviour..!! now its up to u how u react it !
boy..no one is asking ur opinion keep it with urself...!
Radhika...no one is imposing...this issue raised by whom...?? its u ...u dont want hindi ...hindi ppl never say...dat we dont want kannada..or other languages....u were reluctant to adapt...and that is the reason ppl coming from different parts of country and adapting environment..here.....though let me correct u ,i m not the flag bearer for the hindi language...just feel pity for guys who has no option but to learn new language whenever they go new state and new environment...!!
Hats-off Prakash Belawadi, what a strong voice and confidence.
I’m a tamizhan and I respect kannadigas for their language pride.. We tamils also lke u guys more than all I love my Tamil
hats off brothers
Yes bro for every one there mother tongue is is everything ....we south Indians have self respect over our language ..but there people put imposition on us...
Thank you brother🙏🏻😍 We too respect Tamil❤
Iam a malayali.. but I love tamil language... Tamil is the mother of malayalam
Even we kannadigas love and respect all tamilians
@@manojkash4897 beaware your state is slowly eaten by hindi.in tamilnadu more migration is systematically done.
Don't link patriotism to hindi language. People can oppose/ reject hindi and still be indians. Patriotism through your own Mother Tongue.
1. I am a Tamilian who speaks perfect Hindi. After 18 years of being MOSTLY among north Indians (if not in the north), I left the navy/army areas/hindi speaking classmates and came to civil street in Chennai. I learnt good Tamil. I do love hindi, but Hindi vs Tamil, I will PICK ONLY TAMIL. நமது மொழி, நமது பெருமை. It's my mother tongue and it means the most to me.
2. If Hindi is so important, why are Hindi teachers paid so less in India? Be it north or less, the average salary is 20K ish, which is insufficient for all my monthly expenses.
3. Why do foreign language teachers earn more? Why is a French teacher paid 40k? Because there is demand. We created the demand all over India. We wanna go abroad for masters. we wanna globalize.
4. We don't have a problem with hindi. We have a problem when on the name of a uniform link Language, hindi is imposed on us. Many Tamizhans write Hindi certificate exams to work in Government jobs. We watch bollywood films and listen to songs. We do know Hindi and some of us know Hindi better than many north Indians
5. As per the 3 language act policy, Hindi was not supposed to be a compulsory language. English, the state language and a third modern language of the state's choice was the mandate. While kerala, Karnataka and AP followed it, no one in the north gave a south language as the 3rd option. While we gave north languages including Hindi as an option, no one bothered to learn southern languages. Over the years the number of speakers of southern languages have reduced so bad, while hindi has risen. We don't want our languages to die out.
6. Hindi is a derived language. It is derived from Persian/arabic and sanskrit. God forbid if these languages didn't exist, hindi also wouldn't. On the other hand, Sanskrit, Odia, Tamizh, Malayalam, kannada and Telugu are classical languages. we don't need hindi to survive. Tamil is the oldest and the sangam literature has been there for centuries now.
French loves its languages. What's problem with Indians
Sanskrit is the oldest language not Tamil.
Link language debate is not about money , it's about can Hindi become as optional for English as Link language , why not ? If Hindi can't become a link language then no language could . So , don't waste my time to this-that and end with Don't impose Hindi on us , south India, all Non-Hindi speakers are not from Southern part of India.
Being a marathi guy
I totally agree with our south indian brothers
I respect my language marathi
and im damn proud of being an indian and born in marathi family
I am blessed to be a part of such a rich and historic community
Irony of this video is that they wrote 'Kannad'(Kannada being correct) when they are saying that they respect every language equally 😂😂😂
Typical north Indian channel
@@chandraprakash8327
Lkb fuck off
@@chandraprakash8327
ನಿನ್ನಕನ್
Dog Barks for biscuit. North Indian channel taks for hindi
@pranav r I caught you here also
@@VPNJOTHY 😂😂😂😂
Prakash Belawadi take a bow sir.
Respect from Maharashtra.
Our Marathi language is getting killed due to imposition of Hindi.
why you didn't stand for it like Tamilians when imposed?
Pugazh Thamizh We were blinded by over nationalism under India means Hindi tag.
+Suyog Parab nationalism should be confused with HINDI which is a language mix of Persian, Arabic, Sanskrit and local dialect. Nationalism is different
+Suyog Parab that's sad to hear, hope things will change and unity in diversity is preserved in real and not just in books
Tamils support Bakthi language Marathi from that Irani originated language Hindi. Marathi much more sweeter than Pakistani language Hindi.
The more you impose hindi..the more you near to break this country mind it..language is emotion..so dnt play with this fire..otherwise wise whole country would be burned..
agreed
Yes by the surname bhattachariya
Bangaldesh become independent because Pakistan Hindustani/urdu want to bengali use urdu. this india could learn.
@@hulk8384 bhattachariya is Bengali surname bro not North Indian name.
I AM a marathi and married to a Telugu family and live in Chennai for more than a decade, I enjoyed the learning new language tamil and telugu. South Indian have their special culture and rich karnataka music.
It's a great honour for me learn Tyagaraja kritis and its a life changing spiritual experiance. We have to protect the language of land. Do not spoil the great heritage by bringing Hindi and changing its culture. Those who want to learn, they can always learn Hindi but by choice and not by compulsion.
Your husband is Telugu?
What is the contribution of 22 Indian Government official Language in the Indian Cultural Develpment????????
How Many literature Books are published 22 indian official languaage from the year 1947??????.
How many Literature writers are introduced from 22 Indian Offical Language From year 1947???????
How Many Movies are relised from the year 1947???????
Avoid the another Infiltrated words of the State Language is Very Very Important One.
Indian Government Spent 650 crores of Money spent for sanskrit language. Only 27,000 People can able to speak.
Indian Government Spent 8 millian American Doller spent for the Development Hindi in the International Level.
How much of amout money spent for your state language Since 1947.
Tamil Language and Literature developed by 350 International Tamil Associations. Every 5 years once they are organing International Tamil Confrance for the the Development of Tamil.
Before and After Indipendace Indian Government and the State Governments are Publishing Government gazetteerr for the Period of Monthly.
In the Government gazetteer they are updating government policies and important court order information.
After 1967 Tami Nadu Gazetteers Published New Tamil Words Every Month. Tamil Nadu Government contact varies tamil Scholars and collect the new words from the Old Tamil Literature (from Tholkappiam 5000 years back) onwards.
In the year 2022 We are reading the History of the tamil development Dravidan Political movement .
The following other Language words were Destroyed and Introduced new words from Old Tamil Literature.
Tamil Language is Introduced and publish Tamil Nadu Gazetteers Alternative words against Sanskrit, Hindi, Portukal, French, Jpanise, Persian, Bengali, Telugu, Kannada, Malayalam,Urudu, words AND Others.
All Major Tamil words received from Tamil Literature. Nowadays tamil people using This literature words only in the News paper and all offical purpose.
Because all the Government Gazetteers words are using regualarly by the Tamil Scholars and Tamil Politician in the Tamil Society.
Due to the Latest science and technology and computer technology field Tamil Scholoars Introduced Atificial Tamil Words. These words are Published continuasly in the Tamil Nadu Government gazetteer.
Shameless comments by Mr .Pallam Raju..being a native Telugu speaker myself I feel ashamed that he is supporting these narrow minded people who try to play with Indian diversity...Now I get a sense why Andhra Pradesh really got divided....Proud to live in Bangalore..perhaps one day I will claim Kannada as my mother tongue..love their unity..
pasam kiran teja 😂😂😂 nd you too narrow minded... If you ready to claim yourself kannada after being telgu....then How could you say him narrow-minded if he born in area where urdu/hindi has influence.... Nd no one imposing hindu on you.. Until you are ready to learn it....
Arvind Kumar Well I said I love their unity and had learnt the language by choice..Noone tried to play any childish games like this by claiming so and so is a national language..I chose Kannada by choice and Telugu is my mother tongue No one can change that...If you guys love Hindi..Keep it with you..No thanks.We don't need it..Our Dravidian languages are themselves rich in culture and heritage..Dravidian language Tamil predates this so called Hindi or before you Aryans invaded and started the Vedic Sanskrit,and later Hindi which includes Urdu as well...So my north Indian brother If you are interested you can learn Tamil a true Indian language..We dravidians(true Indians) will preserve all our languages.Hindi will never even touch our foot...All the best...I know Hindi is a beautiful language 😋 So please don't use those beautiful Hindi gaalis or bad words😁 which 99.999 percent of you guys resort to when you guys get agitated
Abusing, seriously? "this *so called Hindi or before you Aryans* invaded and started the Vedic Sanskrit". No body told you "you dravidians". Why use it as a derogatory word? You have problem with Hindi, it's fine but don't demean people.
Aniruddh Joshi Lol 😁 demeaning ppl is in your narrow minded culture not ours . .We are just exhausted in patience....Don't day dream like Germans of Hitler's time that you can rule everywhere ....you will go down to ashes..
pasam kiran teja Whatever you are saying is bullshit. No one wants to rule, you are just a deluded person.
I am a tamil person born and raised in South Africa. I find the imposition of hindi very disturbing. It reminds me of the white apartheid government that tried to impose their language (Afrikaans) on black students. The students revolted which set in motion a chain of events that eventually brought apartheid to an end. In India's case it is even more distressing as more people speak hindi than any other language, but that does not mean it should be imposed on anyone else. All people and their customs, languages etc should be respected and upheld - diversity is india's strength and it should be nourished not crushed.... It is a shame to see this happening in the motherland. Very sad.
Dude, nobody is imposing on anyone...please understand.
He is just asking you to learn as second langague.
When u go to France..won't you learn french?when u go to German. Won't you learn German??
So What is the problem in learning Hindi in India? Just as second or third language....nobody is forcing any one to leave their mother tongue and learn Hindi,no!! Just like English , learn Hindi.
What's wrong in that?
Politicians are politicizing it...Don't fall for that!!
Wow...loka nku aji kali bichitra katha mane paduchi. LOL
@Joal Mohamed you tried too hard to instigate and divide. But failed miserably. Now go back to your master and cry about it.
Invincibly, Me what’s the problem in learning hindi in India? First of all, India is not all about hindi. Other Indian languages are equally important. I will learn it if I want to. You keep saying no one if forcing but you are. Just leave us alone. No one is stopping you from learning anything. Don’t just tell us why we should learn hindi. We know when to learn what. No one has any business telling us to do something.
@@rumibharadwaj1730 so nobody is imposing right? then why do you keep complaining what is the problem in learning Hindi in India? Do you know anything in Tamil or Kannada? we in south know minimal Hindi, we can understand Hindi atleast some words. Biharis and Uttar pradeshis are coming to south for food, so it's them who have to learn the regional language, okay? if i go to Mumbai or Delhi for job ill learn Marathi or Hindi. Do you understand? Why Hindi in Tamil Nadu where not even 2% can understand the language completely?
The very fact that Kannada was written as Kannad shows how much respect other languages get. Sums up the whole discussion for me.
@13:15 that is soo true. Am a kannadathi but I do not know how to read or write kannada as my dad worked in army we were posted to other states and I studies in Kendriya vidayala under CBSE. Will definitely make sure my kids know my mother tongue speak, read and write kannada.
Happy to know your respect towards our Kannada language🙏🏻 one of the oldest and beautiful language😍 ಶುಭವಾಗಲಿ kannadathi!!👍🏻😊
As a Sikh, I respect south Indian leaders for not giving up their mother tung. Us punjabis fucked up punjabi language so bad that probably 50% of Punjab speaks hindi now. i guess there will not be Punjabi songs in 50 years from now that we all love :(
Why? Bro?
See thats the real problem, most on the north indian languages are like immediate siblings to hindi and its easy to learn for north indians. now most native languages are lost within hindi and dethroned them. Look at film industry where are the other woods for marathi, bengali, odia. never heard them.
Jaswinder: it’s still not too late. Sensible educated should fight and work towards it to preserve their regional lang. The metropolitan cities suffer badly today because outsiders won’t learn regional lang and without that they can’t work or communicate with local people who can Inturn highlight and discuss various problem of the city and other cities or villages of that state so that everyone can stand and fight for the betterment. Else I don’t see any outsiders settled in a metro polo tan city caring about any other city and village and people of the state they live in except the regional people. The moment people refuse to learn regional lang saying English and Hindi is enough, one can’t expect such people to help with growth of state nor for betterment of the backward cities nor they are of any help to preserve the regional lang and culture.
@@knowakshayjoshi It’s heart warming to see people like you understand the real problem and discussion of common lang is like discussion and planning of wiping out entire Indian languages and with that goes the culture and traditional and richness of every region!!
@@knowakshayjoshithat's what I am saying, For North Indians Hindi is convenient.
Hey I'm a Bengali, and if our South Indian brothers and sisters want to learn a third language, please learn Bengali, skip Hindi, you will get to read great literature, watch great movies, may be can get married to a sweet Bengali, skip those Hindi goons. Also, I would like my children to learn Kannada or Malayalam or Tamil as third language, not Hindi.
sottiki super👌
Yeah☺ that's a good Idea😁.
I personally think Bengali should have been made national language in 1947. Its closer to Sanskrit than Hindi. Its also very pleasing to the ear.. More so than Hindi
I will take your advise and start learning it as soon as I can! :)
They will learn Bengali Kaala Jadu Tonna....#RheaChakorBorty
I m punjabi..can speak nd read hindi as well..but i love my punjabi language..i totaly agree tht hindi shud not b imposed on south indians..they hv their own very rich languages..Tamil, kannada, malyalam, telgu.
Good Tink Mandeep Singh
I"M Krishna Acharya@ Form Benglor South Indian
Agree
He never imposed Hindi..he just said learn hindi as second language. Next to your regional language.
It is only good for people knowing multiple languages.
Some idiotic politicians politicizing it for their benefit...and some people falling for it.
Learning hindi will help us in official transactions.
Bottomline : No one imposing on any one...just asking to learn.
When u can learn and speak English (who enslaved us 400 years) why can't we learn Hindi?
P.S I am from Karnataka.
I'm Maharashtrian and agree to it Mandeep.
@Mandeep: Ok
But when you have/learnt Punjabi and Hindi, when Maharashtrian can Marathi and Hindi, When Gujarati can learn Gujarati and Hindi......why can't Tamilians can learn Tamil and Hindi, Kannadiga can learn Kannada and Hindi.
It is only for our benefit. Even I am not for imposing Hindi...but I don't understand the logic behind refusing it.
Learning other languages as 2nd language will not affect our mother tongue.
When we go to German for job or study..they impose us to learn German...we happily learn and do certification on that.
But why when it comes to India..we fight?
It is very simple yaar, we are asked to learn Hindi as 2nd language for our benefit..our nation benefit.
Politicians politicizing it...thats it
I am a north indian but i truly believe that no language should be imposed. Every language has its own beauty. And English is a common language which not only connects Indian's north with South but the whole world. Thank you
Please don't abuse me, respect my views and i respect yours
Very true
yes you are very very correct
I agree your words bro super
Perfect not just correct, you deserve best respect
If you were deprived of formal education due to poverty and you earn your livelihood from South Indian states then think what difficulties you have to face
Why does the onus of National Integration lie on the Southern States? Let Haryana teach telugu, let Bihar Teach Kannada etc. Why does only south has to pitch in whether taxes or language ?
Hariyana board give options for Telugu and Tamil in mandatory mode
Make malayalam the national language
@I Love Cookies we don't need a national language unless 100 % of indians can understand and speak it ..
@I Love Cookies unity in diversity is our strength
also all bank forms/ railway tickets should use Tamil/Telugu/Malayalam/Kannada scripts and should not use devanagiri scripts just how they treat our fellow south indians. they will know the pain.
Prakash belwadi was incredible! Loved his words❤️
nidhi D Gowda yep, and he's very unbiased.
Hello! I would like To know if gowda from karnataka and gounder from tamil nadu are the same people ?
Belawadi was the only a sane ,urbane and sensible voice in the panel.
I could see that the anchor, gradually realising that his well prepared and curated questions were going to look out of place , took a conciliatory stand.!!!!
Spend your time gainfully on other issues. was the best answer.Belawadi gave.and ,I hope the centre takes it seriously. !!!
Hi nidhi niv tik tok madtira alva
True that
Well said ...Prakash belawadi sir....proud kannadiga
Being a Bengali,I prefer to learn other classical languages other than Hindi!! Learning Malayalam is my dream
Hindi ain't no classical language. No one speaks pure dialects like Brajbhasha, Shekawati, Awadhi and Bhojpuri much anyway. Prakrit is a little obscure but one can try to learn. Malayalam can be termed 'classical' since it "moved away" from Tamil in the 7th - 8th century. Kannada and Telugu are both classical with the former much more older around 6th - 7th century; Telugu around 9th - 11th century. Modern spoken Tamil and Telugu are quite perverted these days, Kannada is following suit; but you'll have to go to literary works. Modern Malayalam is a great idea since the people want to retain it the way it is (still uses extensive vocabulary from Sanskrit and classical Tamil that have fallen out of favor), but that's coming soon too. Your best bet is taking the literature route to any/all of the languages.
Being an indian, i prefer to learn the classical languages other than bengali. Learning Gujrati is my dream
Bengali Go back to Bangladesh
@@arrrrr1689being an india I prefer not to learn hindi I prepare to learn bengali
This debate can go on for another 100 years. Still nothing can change the love and pride South Indians have for their mother tongue and we will still stay strong and united towards our regional language. Pride tamilian.
If a 6th class kid in Delhi don't learn Tamil ..
Why should a 6th class kid in Madurai should learn Hindi ?? 🤔😶
Because Hindi and English are OFFICIAL LANGUAGE.
English is an International LINK LANGUAGE.
HINDI IS AN INDIAN LINK LANGUAGE.
P.s search the meaning of link language
@@adityanayak872 but its not the case in south India right? Hindi is not a link language in south india!...may be in north. But still hindi was imposed on other states and made as link language..waah!
@@adityanayak872
When english can link international level, why we need this bullshit called hindhi? 😂
Erase Hindi from South India for ever.
Erase mallu kallu porn producing states.
First erase your name Joe Mathews that's also not south indian
@@chandraprakash8327 you have no clue what ur talking about... it is a south Indian name Sir. We Christians have english name.. is that your problem..
Yes, this is what will happen if You Impose Hindi on the non-hindi speaking people. Non Hindi speaking People will try to wipe Hindi from their life.
@@chandraprakash8327 Stop hare
ಜೈ ಕನ್ನಡ ಜೈ ಕರ್ನಾಟಕ 💛❤️ remove hindi. Nicely said Prakash. Kannada is not political, its our blood. Send that reporter or interviewer to me.
I am a BJP/RSS supporter from Karnataka and i agree with the 4 men on the panel. I will always support BJP but me and many people in my area will force local BJP MLA to put pressure on State govt if hindi imposition continues. I encourage my fellow kannadigas to do the same.
I stand for my language Kannada. I don’t want to speak Hindi at any cost.
Sure when you come to do Business in Delhi and Mumbai and even Hyderabad which is an South indian City...dont speak Hindi at any Cost. We also dont want people who have hatred in their mind to speak Hindi ....you dont deserve it.
@@ANKITSAGARSINGH : I will come and do the business in Delhi but speaking English. I am not hating Hindi at all. What I am saying is you don't force me to speak.
@@samhunsur6141Kannada is an Indian Language and so it is like my mother....but what is this ....I will not Speak Hindi at any cost...will come Delhi and not speak Hindi.....who is asking you....don't speak Hindi...what arrogance you are showing ....respect people bhai
@@ANKITSAGARSINGH: Have you been living in Karnataka?
@@samhunsur6141 I am living in India and as a Indian I respect all my languages and Cultures...and same I think is duty of all the responsible citizens and not divide India
If
Tamil, Malayalam, Telgu, Kannada = Regional language
Hindi = Regional language
There is no such thing as national language.
I have worked in New Delhi for a year and I was outrageously discriminated against for being a South Indian (they call us Madraassis) despite the fact that I was quite fair and handsome, well educated, well-articulated, and very well versed with the Hindi language as well. I was horrified by the attitude of North Indians against us and I was brutally treated like a third-class citizen
Average delhites are laking of general knowledge...just watch their interviews in youtube..u will get a clear view .
@@kaushikkar1421 just shut the fu#k up , nd stop beliving in stereotypes
These north indians are always like this
Not all states from Beth demand hindi. It’s only people from Hindi speaking state go to every state and fool uneducated people and half educated stating Hindi is the national language where it says it’s official and they shake their heads with them. Everywhere they go they take their lang and refuse to speak in any regional lang in north too. So please be sensible as all are not same. Only educated are commenting here while 98% of population do not know about imposing Hindi nor will they agree.
When some called me madrasi I immediately asked r u Bihari .. 😅they be like how can u call me like that without knowing which state I’m from.. I would say how can u call me madrasi without knowing which state I’m from
I want to touch on something no one did. The fact that cities like Bengaluru, Chennai, Hyderabad,Trivendrum,Kochi etc have been the heart of IT industry and thus became a seeping ground to many Northern fellow Indians is well known. The real problem starts when this minority hesitates to adapt via learning the language..Most of them easily escape that difficulty using English Or Hindi...without attempting to learn the local language(I have massive respect to the ones that have learnt the local language). Imagine the reverse scenario...can I or anyone from South start speaking the local dialect in a city up north?? Hell no! We cant use English as well! Its not that we are rejecting your language or anything..its just about demanding the much needed mutual respect. I respect Hindi for what it is...but never more than my mother tongue(which quite frankly has better literature, a cinema industry which is by far better than Bollywood, better sounding insults etc). If the case was reversed and say my mother tongue was to be imposed on some non speakers.. well that's the closest we can get to the nazism and that's bullcrap!
🤣🤣super bro..ur absolutely crct...what is ur mother tongue
@@Novanova-bo6fu Kannada macha. Aana tamil nallave theriyum, inka telugulo bargain cheyadaniki asal em problem ledu, Hamare Hindi to bahut shareef hain ji...ek minute...Cheta Green tea undallo??
Bangalorean brother! A proud one.
exactly bro i wanna say this piont i live in hyderabad and yes northerns reject our local language and making money for our cities
Respect bro your point are damn correct
@@chevvachandana4665 many Telugu people these days started to complain about Bangalore and Chennai saying people don’t let outsiders to speak in their MT and they hate them and they speak in support of making Hindi common in all south states not just AP and Telangana. Why will one come and stop you when you are talking in you MT with your friends and family. 😂Localities uneducated would stop you only when one tries to speak with them in another lang which they don’t understand and they will ask you to speak in their lang so that they can understand and if you can’t they will still try to understand. But your tone matters. But with Hindi people they go straight in Hindi knowing they don’t understand and obviously they get irritated and shout back 🤣 it’s not that they hate you. They have work to do and can’t sit and learn Hindi or understand those who expect them to learn instead.
how many north indians are learning southern indian languages???????????????????
I'm a bengali person nd i respect all language but one nd only hindi language united all indians
I can speak fluent telugu.
Subhranta Khatua only telgu ,sankrit can united India
Mohyal for humanity only one state speak telegu.yah sanskrit can united indians.also hindi nd sanskrit similar .nd sanskrit is the more scientific language.
Subhranta Khatua sorry hindi forced us remember mughuls era .... Ganga yamuna tehzeeb bullshit ... sankrit, Tamil both r ancient language ,
As a Punjabi, I'm angry about the Hindi signage being given primacy in Punjab - and this despite the two languages being neighbours and actually sharing some similarities. I can't imagine how furious our South Indian friends must be that their language and culture is being bulldozed by the "Hindi-Hindu-Hindustan" philosophy of the BJP-RSS.
I second that
Fight it guys there is no way u r gonna preserve who you are
@@rajendrachandel, why is every proud Panjabi a Khalistani for you people? You should be worried about Hindu Rashtar, not a non-existent Khalistan. And people like you have been predicting our end for hundreds of years. People don’t defeat us. We defeat people.
Go ask your Modi.
look at the problem of this country! people,! persons like him and have several separatist sentiments, some on Religion, other on langauge, race color. The responsibility of the maimlanders is how to bind all these people running in all dierction like headless checkens, just thinking about them selves, even how small entity they are.
Yes brother. I mean when it comes to signages we have both english and regional language on it. Most indians learn english( even hindi speaking person) because it links with many countries as it is one of the international link language. So introducing hindi is a burden or a wasteful effort. I mean i personally know Tamil, english and hindi. And i use english and tamil often. Even all these comments are mostly in english. Actually i never used hindi ever even if i speak with a hindi speaking person. I am comfortable with english more. English is much simpler than hindi to learn. Even if you know punjabi, i am sure that the dialects in hindi is a little different from punjabi, just like languages in the south. But south indian languages are different and dont you think its a burden for us. I am not opposing hindi but its just i dont need it in my daily life. India is a diverse country so lets embrace and accept everything as it is. Each regional language in india is a national language too and each of those represent the culture of those people. I from tamilnadu dont oppose learning hindi or any language but oppose imposion and compulsion to learn it. It will only leave a bitter taste at the end. As indians we all pledged ourselves as brothers and sisters. So lets understand each other more. Thanks for your support and understanding brothers.👍🏼👍🏼
HINDI - HINDU-HINDIAN parties should be thrown out of South......
bjp will do it, rest r just tail.........
Fuck bjp
Watcher Node: well said
BJP is Muslim Pakistani language party posing like Hindu. HIndi is Muslim origin language. Halal meat is Muslim custom meat nothing to do with Hindu. Amit SHAH, Narendra MODI the last name is Muslim name. These people are fake Hindu people speaking Muslim language Hindi. Al Dua is BJP operated Halal meat company. It is TACKIYA in action.
Mudinchi vanthu parda ulluku 😂 you funny fellow.. your BJP LEADER MODI came here and spoke in TAMIL.. 😂 THAT'S THE POWER OF SOUTH.. 😂 PODA PODA POI POZHAPA PARUDA
14:25 WHY HINDI WHY NOT FRENCH.....Awesome Sir.
Hindi cannot be imposed if so Tamilnadu will be isolated from India we will have our own state independent
😂😂 please
NSA 😀😀😀😀
@vinay desai we like India not Hindia
Also W.Bengal
Support from andra
Thats Not ಕನ್ನಡ್ (Kannad)
That is ಕನ್ನಡ(Kannada)
naanu adanne andkonde nodid takshana...naavu inemele handi anta kariyona hindi badlu :)
Bro in Hindi kannada is pronounced as Kannad...
The same way there are many other words which are pronounced without A in the end or A stands silence...like Ram for Rama, Mahabharat for Mahabharata, Ravan for Ravana, Ramayan for Ramayana and so on....
Who cares. If north India have to learn they will learn Tamil only.
@@Kapil.Yadav.7392 then there is need for Hindi speaking population to learn Kannada and not the other way around...
@@ub1701 my point was every language has a different style of pronunciation...I was just referring that kannada is pronounced as kannad in Hindi and there's nothing wrong in that...
Also it's very good initiative to learn as many languages as possible...I personally can speak 10 regional languages including kannada...
Love how much respect South Indians have for their languages, respect from a Bengali speaker নমস্কার🇮🇳
I love my kannada வாழ்க தென் இந்திய மொழிகள் 🤙
and putting ಕನ್ನಡ್ instead of ಕನ್ನಡ ...this is what you know ...and this is how u respect us
F
Kalappa = Kaalappa pronounces as Kalllappa
It may be a mistake..
Haar cheez me fault kaise khoj lete hai aap..
Salute to South Indian brothers and sisters for their love towards mother tongue.
South Indian hate their mother tongue language
@@sid.7146 lol we hate our language thats why our languages are standing as independent languages today unlike your home restricted languages.
Hindi imposition is real. I studied in a CBSE school in Maharashtra and being a Marathi, I never studied Marathi in it but Hindi, Sanskrit and English.
As a result, I'm more fluent in Hindi. I couldn't speak a single sentence in Marathi couple of years ago, Only recently i have started learning Marathi... So, Just imagine the state of Marathi language in its home state, Maharashtra.
I hope, Hindi will be rejected by all the non-Hindi states.
Sir you are not talking about english language.just imagine the state of Maharashtra home land of Marathi . private and government sector don't allow Marathi job seekers in there office as employees.
north Indian : learn Hindi South Indians
South Indian: no thank you!
North Indian : why can't you learn? How dare u learn English and not Hindi? No we will not force you, we'll print your currency in Hindi, we will put up sign boards in HINDI ..
south indian : but you are imposing Hindi now...
North Indian : but we never forcefully imposed it... But still.. Why can't u learn Hindi??? Why are u speaking Tamil and English??
South Indians : wait... Do these ppl have an IQ problem ???
vidhya pillai and then your so called iq stops you to rise in national politics 😂😂😂😂 people who understand the power hindi.. Now has become Vice president and defense minister of india
Well said
+Arvind kumar isn't that the exact problem that is addressed by +Vidya?....at this point i am not sure if this is arrogance or ignorance?.
Even people who speak Hindi aren't united through language, i have experienced four different variation of Hindi vocally and since it does not have it's own script all four of them spell the same word differently. I guess logic is really hard to grasp for some!.
suresh kumar i don't understand what you wanna to say
+Arvind it's better you stop trying, i don't want to be responsible for your brain death. You will have several opportunity in future.
BTW are you catching the irony?. oh that's right you don't seem to be aware of the one which you made :p
Prakash belawadi sir nailed it, he was professional.
Prakash belwadi your super sir, being a kannadiga I accepted your words. Kannada is a classical language and other South languages also. We protect, respect, and fallow our langauge. Why some government peoples are hiring Hindi in southern states.
Moderator: why not learn Hindi.
Mr. Moderator , I don't think you understand the issue. why waste time and resource in learning something that has no use?
my telugu is sweetest to me. iam not stupid to learn when i live in telugu areas
Stop pallm , Telugu people don't need Hindi
but why every hyderabadi shows off in Hindi ? Mundu adi correct cheyi ...
ptj1 ptj1 adi dakhni anna hindi kaadu deccan region lo dakhni matladedi hindi kaadu
Don't say telugu.. Andhras don't need Hindi... Telengana ppl will speak Hindi
@@tekiprashanth5020 we telanganites dnt need hindi too...we want telugu to be imposed in every educational instituttions
@@tekiprashanth5020 hello we never learned to speak in hindi.because of immigrated hydrebad labour,Urdu people and telangana village people going to gulf made many people hardly learn to speak in urdu not hindhi.
Get Lost, we don't know Hindi.
Hindi Teriyadu poda.
Hindi Teliyadu pora.
From south India.
Pallam Raju is waste fellow.
yes brother. The person who is representing my state could not defend the imposition of hindi in AP & TG.
Down with hindi, long live the republic.
@@amartyasengupta604 Please no. Hindi is one of India's language. For a vibrant Republic all our languages are precious. I am against the spread of Hindi into non Hindi speaking areas like they did it in Mumbai and destroying the local languages. BJP is a menace that keeps the people of BiMaRU states without skills, education, trade schools etc forcing them to multiply population due to poverty and making them migrate to other states and earn a meagre wages with out the ability to learn the local language. This destroys the cohesion of India and the multi language mosaic of India carefully woven by our Constitution. So while I sympathize with your anger I want Hindi to thrive in its heartland.
That's not hindi it is handi🐖🐖🐽🐽🐷
Imposition of Urdu resulted in free Bangladesh. Good to learn from this. Imposition divides and diversity unites
I love how india is discussing this issue, meanwhile we in the Philippines, a lot of us were already brainwashed that tagalog language is the language that would unite our diverse archipelago. Btw tagalog is the language of one of the ethnolinguistic group in the Phil and it was implemented and forcefully imposed to be taught in all schools including the non-tagalog regions. And setting aside non-tagalog languages. It is a fucking imperialism and im sad that our country is silence about the issue. I believe we should just only focus on english.
Mother tongue is your identity once you loose it you loose your land as you cannot know who is who .
I am Hindi speaker and I feel that imposing Hindi over regional languages is outright unpatriotic. Diversity and Pluralism are the core values of our nation and we should be wary of politicians who try to divide us along sectarian and linguistic lines. Cutting across lines of language, ethnicity and religion we should all come together to preserve our languages. Being an Indian, Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam, Punjabi, Bengali and all the other languages and dialects spoken across our country are as dear to me as my mother tongue is.
Where's a person representing Tamil nadu,the state which was the first to fight against Hindi imposition way back in 60s if someone from TN like Thirumurugan gandhi was part of the debate then he would have teared this Hindi imposition rascals
What kind of a debate is this where there is no one to speak on behalf of Hindi that everyone is disparaging? Completely one-sided.
A fair debate means every side is represented. Here the accused Hindi goes totally unrepresented. Tried and pronounced guilty in absentia.
பிராபாகரன் தமிழன் there is no word TEARED in english dictionary... Hahha
Rahul Dev insecure south indians do it Sir.. we don't have to spread false information and wrong propaganda for our language..
Well what is it you found unfair, Rahul?
Simple equation for the kids to succeed.
Mother tongue
English.
Science & Math
Arts. ,....... Thus is more then enough for survival.
Without father's child😀😀
@pranav r true
If Hindi is imposed in South India, then we need separate country which includes only southern states...
We dont need separate country
Stop this bullshit
@@sadanandpoojari5811 stop bullshit of imposing hindi in souther India states
@@kartiktangirala5440 who has impose hindi on south state ??
Definitely!!
I'm from andhrapradesh ..I'm a telugu speaking person nd i love my language .... Because it's a classical nd oldest language in South nd also in whole world...
It's not oldest language in the world or even in the south for that matr
@@Novanova-bo6fu tamil, telugu, malayalam,kannada languages are dating back more than 3000 years each and evry south indian language is older than hindi
@@chevvachandana4665 yes that I agree👍
@venkat butiful is telugu
@venkat it's typo*
hindi is a Pakistani language... boycott these foreign language
Yes. Hindi SHOULD NOT be imposed on any one. It is NOT our National language. Let's NOT impose hindi on the Non-hindi speaking population !
Prakash belawadi sir is right and we need local language to give importance in that state. kannada in Karnataka.
I am a bengali and i am very proud of my language and i also feel proud to have various other languages in my country.
Do other states also have Kannada language in their government schemes then why should we have hindi...... People who migrate to any state has to learn the regional language this must be made compulsory..... In Karnataka most of them speak Hindi Telugu Tamil so on stop this doing that all time if people are here for more than 3 months then they have converse in Kannada.... kannadigare modlu bere bhashe mathadodu and movies encourage madodu Bidi .....Kannada Kalsi Kannada is not tough language its was one of most beautiful language
akhil a t do you think it's something wrong to learn the language of the place you would be visiting ....
I request you to please read my msg again I have said they should speak if they stay for more than 3 months .....
akhil a t I haven't insisted anyone.... neither anybody ... once u come to Karnataka u ll know how many of us speak Kannada and other languages ......
😂😂😂👏👏👏 nd then they spent whole of their life to just learn languages.....
Hindi sounds annoying and unappealing for me. sorry I would rather learn Spanish or French.
Prakash Belawadi is the smartest personality I've ever seen or heard on political TV. He has a good foothold on things and speaks intelligently, with a lot of well-placed passion, and logic. There are very few in the National stage with such a presence. He has a great future in Indian politics whenever he so decides.
I support kannada we should encourage regional languages
not kannad guru kannada
manu sk stop talking in Hindi and protect the language
Proud to be Kannadiga
ಕನ್ನಡವೇ ನಿತ್ಯ
ಕನ್ನಡವೇ ಸತ್ಯ
#Makekannadanationallanguage
In short., to a Tamil guy, Hindi is as foreign as English. Hindi is similar to Manipuri and Tulu. Hindi is also not helping to gain money. Non Hindi states do much better than Hindi states. What is the point of learning Hindi. Stop homogenizing and leave others in peace.
Yes hindi people comes to our state for job so they should learn our language
Really, why does the Government of India spend so much money to promote Hindi ? Whose money are they spending anyway? Imposition of Hindi works against national integration. Pakistan imposed Urdu and all its languages lost relevance and half of the country separated. Is this what the Hindi lobby wants? Why blame our neighbor when the Hindi lobby is here to work for them for free ?.
Rola Pola boss don't divert subject
Urdu Bangla issue was one of the first reasons of scuffle between east and west pakistan but the same was more or less laid to rest in 1956 when both Urdu and Bangla was declared state languages of Pakistan. The main reason of Bangladesh's creation was the refusal of west pakistani establishment to give people of east pakistan their due rights including right to spent their revenue on themselves, lack of development in east pakistan, development projects in west pakistan on the expense of revenue generated by east etc. The regional languages in present day pakistan are spoken by people in their homes (they are also taught in schools in their respective provinces except in punjab where punjabis themselves prefer Urdu over punjabi, which has been the case since the british era when urdu was the official lang of the province). However when they want to conversate with a person from another province then they use urdu and we pakistanis are comfortable with that as we know that no one language of the country can be imposed on others while Urdu is a neutral languages understood (Even if basic) through out the country giving comfort to everyone when they want to communicate with people from another ethnicity. We dont have issues which hindi faces in india.
MS R: Your contention that the issue was more or less laid to rest in 1956 is possibly a bit on the optimistic side. There is no reason for a Bangali to accept Urdu as his/her national language - and that was the war cry of the Bhasha Andolan which saw the Dhaka University uprising and police brutality. But it was easy in your case - Urdu and Bangla are very different and separation is not difficult. My knowledge about other original languages of Pakistan loosing their relevance gradually (and moving into oblivion) is based on the various interesting Pakistani TV shows that I watch (off course that includes Tarek Fateh). yes, we have a bit more difficult problem and the founding fathers got it right - but the new zealots are trying their luck - they will loose..
Mustafa Alam: If you are from Pakistan - I pity you since you do not even know that Urdu is your national language which was imposed by your founding fathers and the resulting disenchantment resulted in the language movement etc etc. Do you really have to use profanity - is that a way to ascertain your level of intellect .
You are not from Pakistan (sure?) and yet claim to know why Urdu was enforced by Jinnah as Pakistan's National language. And your knowledge of history tells you that it was for ease of communication ... in a language that only 3% of the people spoke - take a hike !! You have been trolling in the social platform far too long. Also, lets stop discussing any further - your affinity for using foul language implies a terrible inferior level of human intellect - the type that I do not wish to interact with. Thanks.
I am a Hindi speaking person who was taught only Hindi in school. I wish while growing up we were allowed to take Malayalam, Tamil, Marathi, Bengali etc. at least for a year or two. Then we would have been introduced to the rich and beautiful literature and culture of these languages much earlier.
Prakash Belawadi - Respect for you man! You are 100% right. Imposition is a form a violence. You can never deny that. It's wrong
Ban and let's Keep out BJP out of Karnataka and Rest of South India.
Prakash belawadi is so accurate in speaking reality.
I am tired of this Hindi nonsense everywhere
Now also I am tired😞😞😮😮
Prakash Belawade is a wise scholar ... kudos
Pls dont compare Kashmir and Karnataka in regards to Flag.. We always say Jai Karnataka and Jai Hindustan so pls keep Karnataka away from this divide and rule... We are proud Indians Proud Kannadigas...
Midday meal was Mr.Kamraj"s Idea and implementation
Introduce by Justice party before independence. Done on a larger scale by Kamaraj, changed into nutritious meal scheme by MGR.
E... you are a dumbass! It is Mr Kamaraj who introduced Mid-day meals scheme not MGR
Mid-day meals scheme was introduced by Kamarajar, but yes MGR period it become well known by in others States.. and he named as Sathunavu Thittam. I give credit for both CM's and thanks for Brijesh sir to show casing some good examples from South we did..
It's Written Kannad(ಕನ್ನಡ್)...It's Kannada(ಕನ್ನಡ)
BJP, when in Maharashtra, along will allies, put Marathi up front. Now, why is this hypocritical approach in Karnataka? Different ideologies in different states? If people of Karnataka put Kannada upfront, what's wrong in it? Also, If we go on to BJP's 'Indian/not-Indian' philosophy, I think Kannada is more Indian then Hindi, as kannada has more sanskrit words. Hindi, nowadays is is a mix of Hindi and Urdu.
Dear friend, Hindi directly descends from Sanskrit.. its just the linguistic nature of Hindi that it naturally assimilates the words of other languages. We need to be proud of it.
Regards
Kaushik
kaushik mishra all Indian languages are descended from Sanskrit and Malayalam has more sansakrit word than hindi becoz Shankaracharya is from Kerala
Not all Indian languages are descended from sanskrit...Tamil is totally different...And Malayalam is a mixture of Tamil and Sanskrit.
kaushik mishra nope ,70%of hindi and urdu is same , in fact the one who knows urdu he easily learns hindi
@Ayush Chaturvedi rss is not marathi organization even its most of members are non maharashtrians .u brahmin make rss
free south India from the Delhi occupation
What the fuck are you talking about..
I have been living in Bangalore for quite sometime and have learned Kannada. Now this has made me a complete polyglot apart from my command in other European languages not just three!!!
Instead of bringing Telangana minister, getting Telugu Laurette into panel would have given the right perception of Telugites.
shrihara Palanetra yes brother what u said is wright
He is not Telangana minister. He was a union minister from Congress and from present Andhra Pradesh. This discussion is politically biased trying to speak against BJP with an undercover of south region. BJP speaks for all identities and is against appeasement to only certain religions, may be that’s my view. And I’m firm supporter of pan India with native identity which can be religious too.
shrihara Palanetra .he is nt a minister .
You should have invited someone from andhra who can represent our language
Naan kannadiga🔥
5:41, one isn't a proud Kannada, but a Kannadiga.
6:01, spot on.
you fools think you can remove regional languages from bank , railway tickets and all exams..and tell Hindi is one that will put us together....never will we think that
Emmm railway tickets do not use regional languages
விஷ்ணு கார்த்திக் yes all dravidians must rise against these immature gang ....they contribute less but make more noise...Hindi my foot...Jai Kannada,Telugu,Tamil,Malayalam..all national languages of constitution
Invincible Dr Lol don't make jokes There's no local language in India...All south Indian languages are national languages.You Hindi kiddos fail to understand your roots.You came from outside we are original Indians much older than you...and yea bring it on your agitation is more fun to confront..We all know who is childish when they hold such non sense debates and dream the impossible.
Invincible Dr if you don't know we south Indians already learn our native language as a second language with English as first. We love English because it makes us global ..Wt can Hindi do😁...just lurk around making a fool of itself by penetrating the impenetrable
I know bdw my dear highly educated north Indian folk can't even utter a single English word prop...All you know is this stupid hindi
Every language like kanada ...❤️has certain unique identity for that regions which has Been spoken by far for many many decades into that regions .....
I love kannada 😍 Karnataka my nation is kannada 😎 kannadiga 💪
In South India language is a culture, Tamil is an ancient language than sanskrit, its not good to impose hindi in South India
Sanskrit is older than Tamil.
Belawadi was awesome
don't call us the fringe group its the group that imposes hindi supposed to be called FRINGE!!!
Dear Host, the forceful imposition starts from schools...where kids do it for marks...simple.
I am a malayali. We learn all the languages that come our way. We are not opposed to learning Hindi. In my opinion Hindi is a beautiful language. Of course, we will study English. English language is behind all the success keralites have had so far.
Where is representing person for tamil nadu..?.. Tn is the first state to oppose the Hindi opposition
That's why they ignored us
They know about us
He was afraid getting teared apart. Prakash Belawadi was out of the syllabus and he kept his mouth shut.
Prakash Belawadi and Brijesh Kalappa were very balanced.