Video není dostupné.
Omlouváme se.
Singur vs Sanand - DON'T Make The Same Mistake South Africa!
Vložit
- čas přidán 30. 04. 2024
- What happened in the Indian towns of Singur and Sanand was a lesson on what to do and what not to do to ensure economic development and success in a town or nation.
I hope that this video and the lesson it continues opens our mind on what is the best route for South Africa to take.
.............................................................................................................................................
Please be a Patriot and Join our channel membership here:
/ @citizenconcerned
Please make Donations to help us continue our work here:
Bank Name: Bidvest Bank
Account Number: 21940003401
Branch code: 462005
Swift code: BIDBZAJJ
.............................................................................................................................................
Contact us on INFO@CITIZENCONCERNED.CO.ZA
Links to videos used:
• Ratan Tata: Modi is Of...
• 15 years after Nano ou...
• Double tragedy in Sing...
• New Facility Opening |...
.............................................................................................................................................
#Singur #Sanand #SingurVsSanand #TataMotors #MamataBanerjee #NarendraModi #CitizenConcerned #BewareOfTheComrades #SmartVoters #29May2024
Let's promote this channel please 😊 push it in all platforms
She doesn't understand geo-politics. All she knows is to repeat white rhetoric
If you know about anything you'll understand that capitalism has stolen many ideas from communism
I wholeheartedly agree. !
I am cheering you on.
You do the work that mainstream media will never do. ❤
Yeah!!
You for president Mam!!!!
❤
Never.
Well said ....if only the people gives our country a chance we CAN become the jewel of Africa once again ....bury the past...or the past will bury you ...all by your own choice ...
Excuse me. A Jewel of Africa? Do you call an economy that was built on exploitation and marginalisation a jewel of Africa? More like the scum of Africa if you ask me. Your guys' glorification of apartheid really grinds my pancreas.
Katlego for President Please🙏🇿🇦❤
As people lets not even look at the gender.Female or male, she should run for presidency
My company employs more than 60 people. I've contracted a tax consultancy firm for sars compliance. On a monthly I'd make payments to the firm to pay over vat, uif, etc.
2years later I get sars notices for non compliance. I've sent them all the payments made to that company but sars want to hear nothing of yet. I've been ordered to pay over R2mil in 6months or face imprisonment & the closure of my company. I was told to get my lawyers to fight to recover the monies paid over to that firm, but in the meantime start paying or face the above.
So the government does not really care about unemployment. That R350 grant is their carrot
seems like that tax consultancy firm took you for a ride.. they must provide proof of all the payments they made to sars.. if they cannot, you charge them.. sars just wants their money, they dont want your business to close or you to go to jail..if that happens , they get nothing, they rather get the money.. so its not sars fault here, its this company you were paying.. i would suggest going to a reputable accountant and let them ask sars for a grace period to review and make submissions.. if you work with sars, they will not do anything bad to you..
thats the problem, you want sars to job that is not theirs, it is for you to demand that tax consultancy firm to provide proof of your compliance and if they fail open a case of fraud against the company, and yes you should start paying because when you win your case you can reimburse your accounts, blaming the government makes no sense but just feeds your biases and
I know 2 people that had this exact same thing happen to them.😢
I’m also an employer and I’d lay the blame squarely with you. You should have kept a monthly check direct with SARS instead a blindly trusting a third party. At the very least you should have asked for copies of the SARS receipts to the third party. Expensive lesson you’ve learnt and I do sympathise with you and your family and staff.
@@robbrent very expensive lesson never to be repeated. Thanks for your comment 👍
May your business grow from strength to strength
Good grief, Sis Katlego, I stumbled upon this video, and GUESS WHAT???? I ended up going through eight of your recent videos. I DON'T HAAVE TIME, SISI, TO BE SITTING DOWN AND LISTENING TO YOU! WHAT THE HACK! Why did you hook me in like this? The main thing about you, based on what I have gone through, is that you are very informative and you take the "allegations" that we, as South Africans, are intelligent and that you don't dare insult it. Good for you!
In South Africa, the politics of poverty and unemployment have a bigger support and voice!
Modi is a great leader, i like how he is playing geopolitics on behalf of India!
People forget that 60 percent of Tata is owned by a charity trust and mr Ratan tata is a gem of person he does so much of good in india. Providing jobs not only in india but all over the world. Alot of Indians use the internet we are the second most internet users in the world.
This is really a great lesson to any individual or nation that wants to succeed! Thanks for sharing.
SA is not allowed to succed individually because of ppl like Julius Malema
I love the South African youth I work with. They understand when things are explained with logic! That is why your voice needs to be out there! You speak hope! Blessings Katlego 🙏🙌❤
Capitalism works under the premise of meritocracy. Our politicians don’t like that because it would expose their shortcomings. If we’re all going to work hard to get what we need, they will need to be qualified to be in the positions they hold. And we know that the majority of them shouldn’t even be there.
No it works under the premise of liberty. Liberty to start your own thing or liberty to work for who you want. Meritocracy is important but its not the basis in my view.
Is that why settler colonists excluded black people from owning private property, the cornerstone of capitalism? That is meritocracy?
Say ANC politicians not all politicians
Guys let's not forget to watch the adds, our girl is doing an amazing job, so let's support her by watching all the adds.
Magatte Wade did a wonderful explanation of how socialism is killing Africa, on the Triggernometry channel. If you get a chance, I'd love to hear your thoughts on what she says.
Beware of them comrades and keep being so passionate about our country 👏
We need a citizen concerned triggernometry video!
Katlego you reminded me when Navara said " do you agree that the majority rule?"........... the way Navara was so convinced of that statement I thought he was going to add and say
" even when that majority is wrong!". The problem with politics is that in the midst of all these arguments the whole country and its people lose decades and decades of lost time!
otherwise my sister your contribution has surpassed that of those who say they were in exile! please do not stop warning US of the "COMRADES"
Sorry I meant you should be the President of South Africa 🌍
Katlego, as always, your presentations and reasoning are brilliant🤗
Just found your channels. Beautiful. Thank you. 🇿🇦❤️🇳🇮
Why are there so many haters. And negative people. With the right government in place we could be a rainbow nation. You cannot refer to mistakes made in the past, if you want to live in the future. Yes we can learn from our mistakes, but we still need to live for the future, or it's all for nothing. I find most people to be petty, which is why I live on a farm with pets. I know that I can at least trust them.
Great perspective 👏
Katlaho, you're an inspiration to the people of South Africa.
I think it's Katlego...maybe that was predictive text. 🌷✌🏻
Thanks Katlego for a briljante presentation.
Get the economy right. R1=£1. Stop the entitlement/victim mentality. Count your blessings instead of your sorrows. Put God first. All problems solved. Shalom.
That would be wonderful. When we switched from Sterling to Rand, £1 = R2.00, and R1 = $0.75
Either you don't live in SA or you live under a rock, listen to the educated black youth and you'll understand that our children need land more than jobs, they are educated enough to create their own jobs.
These upcoming elections are about our land. Not so much about jobs.
@@biko8229 This is where Messrs Dunning and Kruger come in.
@@maseratifittipaldi Why do you think we care what David and Justin have to say?
To some of us anything with Kruger should never be listened to, those are descendants of the worst kind of criminals that have ever walked in SA.
@@biko8229 you need land? Not jobs? You are a welfare case. Entitlement is your problem. Get a job and work hard for what you want. We paid for the land. So should you.
Thank you for another well presented video. please continue making these videos We can all do something to make South Africa great again, even by sharing these videos with others.
Thank you once again for excellent content and educating our people.
Ain't no way Julius said the system has failed but he's filthy rich!🤣💀.
😂😂😂
Malema is a hypocrite
Love the fact that Julius who is the UBER capitalist and has enriched himself and is living large can sit there with a straight face telling us to opt for socialism. Hmmm...can't help but wonder where he sees himself in that system? I venture a guess that he sees himself at the top and not as one of the poor workers who are basically slaves.
Only because he is a big mouth...and that sells news papers...do we hear of this snotnose qwedeen mal ema so much...irritating...like a child shouting and screaming in an adult gathering.....he is at 10%..stagnant...and losing many many votes to guptazuma...
Can we hear what educated politicians have to say....and not this red overall qwedeen...only 10% of voters believe the 💩💩💩 his been talking..
...
Every worker is a slave .he works Politicians take nonsense
Viva to the multi party charter to rescue and save South Africa and its citizens.
This lady is a God sent angel. She can think and feel for others as she thinks and feels for her self
Katlego - thanks for your hard work and stellar research in putting together such professional, informative and enlightening videos! You bring sanity to a country that is going to the dogs if we don't do everything in our power to prevent the decline. A light at the end of the tunnel!
We must remember that we do NOT HAVE CAPITALISM in South Africa. We have “some kind of bureaucratic nightmare” (as per Mike Sham). This is the first point we need to agree on. (I.E. Julius’ statement is invalid ) THEN we need to discuss the merit of Capitalism vs Communism. And of course globally capitalism has proven the better version
So true I love this woman she's so clever and I just hope we all learn from this
Too late, South Africa has already made the same mistakes, only difference, we continue to make them.
The ANC can't even learn from their own mistakes, there is no way for them to learn from other peoples mistakes.
This cANCer terminated the Rainbow dream.
Forever.
This takes me back to the 80s when Dimbaza Township in Eastern Cape had more than 30 factories and I was working at a laboratory with my standard 10 certificate making chicken vaccines. Oh what an experience using my biology and physical science 😂. I actually started at a printing factory and a clothing factory during school holidays. Today I'm a professional Fashion Designer also doing my little printing hustling in my home garage. Little did I know all that terminology like collating, binding, will make more sense even today. Preach Kat ❤
Great presentation. Keep it up, dear sister. ♥️
Excellent presentation ! Katlego for our first lady President !
You know, you opened a lot of people's eyes, that is the reason the eff anc and jj is not happy, more and more Africans eyes and views opening go on with your good work, don't let them stop you you are amazing
Thanks. I really needed to hear this
*My girl Katlego always tell the truth ( This is why we all like you so much. there's no BS there's no lies with you thank you for that*
Midvaal in Gauteng is a very good example. Where did Heineken & Ferroro Rocher open facories in the end because the DA made it easy and the ANC made it hell.
That's why we need DA to rule 2024 but with madam Zille at the helm
This is so true Katlego ❤
You're so poised and calm
Came back with rapid fire 🔥
Take the good from everyone and everything and make the world a better place for everyone to live happily. This the essence of what this angel is saying
Remember big corporates and the financial sector have been supporting ANC ideology for the poor since 1994. Like Capitalism at the top and Socialism at the bottom. These guys have marketeers who study and implement these things. It is all about profit.
5/6 years ago donald trump secured a $110B defense deal with saudi arabia with multiple us defense companies he created thousands of jobs of this historic defense contract with saudi arabia and need i remind you that these defense companies such as boeing, raytheon and lockheed are all non-state owned companies 👍 thousands of jobs created…point of the story
Hi, same story in Amatikulu KZN, the rural chiefs rejected the Chinese offer to build an economic zone and city. Except they never went to another SA town, they went to amother country! Thanks for the great videos
We need more info on this on mainstream media they have a far more better reach to citizens
Thanks Kat most brilliant uninfluenced free thinker,God bless us with people who care for SA
This lady will run this country better then the ANC i will vote for her
As I am thinking of buying a land that was used for community project farm funded by government back in 2000 now it has collapsed. I know the community won’t agree although the land is abandoned for over 10 years , with trees and no longer use it.
Please make a video of Zimbabwe/Venezuela and what happens when you give the majority what they ask for...
Thank you 🙏 God bless you keep strong 💪
Hi. The biggest disparity between socialism and free markets is north and South Korea
Thank you sister. Continue open the eyes of the deceived and brainwashed black brothers and sisters by EFF, ANC and MK party
Love your beautiful talks. ❤️👍
That’s right Katlego, I have worked in 2 provinces outside of home just to be employed. I would’ve loved to achieve a good life in my home town allowing me to see my family when I should and desire. Am tired of these socialists. Sharing once again.
My family came out of East Germany...they suffered at the hand of the communist state...
And East Germany to this day is still poorer than West Germany.
Dear Malema listen these great facts of life. In life good intentions and eloquence to convince the ignorant masses is not all. Tell the masses of the dishonesty that destroyed our country
I support the lady is very genuine about everything
Excellent conversation!
Perhaps the person who says capitalism has failed in Africa must tell us why it has and also indicates to us were communism has succeeded.
Well said and excellent examples and analogies given by you, Kathlehong . Brilliant. Could be made easier for all people of South Africa and even mankind to understand. In no uncertain terms, Soviet and Marxist ideas doesn't work. It's a botch up. Thank you.
Good work Katlego keep it up
Keep up your good work 🙏❤️
well done... I have watch most of your CZcams video's and I must compliment you on how you bring out those powerful messages to our nation with facts and not just talk. I hope our nation would see the right from wrong that has happened over the last 30 years and make the right choice come 29 May 2024. We need change so that we all can live a better and a brighter future with all that we have in our beautiful land South Africa.
Keep up the amazing video / information you post and be blessed.
LOVE TO LISTEN TO YOUR COMMENTS YOU SHOULD BE IN PARLIMENT LADY AND YOU ARE BEAUTIFUL god BLESS
Well done keep up the good work
Tata is an Indian company...When the British left india they didn't let Anglo British companies continue as usual. Tata is indian and the land issue is in India. Cant compare it to the situation in South Africa.
Capitalism etc + Apartheid can't be blame for the greediness of the ANC Cadre's, that only have one goal in mind and that is to enrich themselves themselves...F the Country and it Citizen's. So, eventually, the Time came to say, F the Government and Vote them out...😮
A mixture of co-op's, and nationalisation, are the basic business structures to move forward. All grow together leave no citizens behind
Your channel is priceless education for our people. Left wing radical politics have brought nothing but poverty for the very people they purport to help. Thank God there's no accommodation for the EFF and MK at national level.
Insightful video! please speak more about political parties that you think are good for SA. I would really like to hear your opinion on this. Your work has shed light on dangerous ideologies in the EFF and ANC, and I think it would be good to know which direction we should go in
This lady should be in Government for sure
The leaders have not been healed, and never will be --- from their GREED.
Please I like to help
Hi there Rathachetty how would you like to help?
You can email us on
info@citizenconcerned.co.za
Brilliant
Malema always think of the end results. Think of the poor masses. Bring back the train services the bus services and educate the taxi owners that every father and mother want to feed their families not only the taxi owners have families to feed. Our whole human race should be looked upon as one big family sharing and caring with all the talents and available resources.
An excellent example indeed
Good, Very Good! ✨️✨️
lovely example 💕
Excellent review !
You absolutely right on that one but when it comes to businesses such as mining sector would appreciate it being under countries people not privatised😅😂, I guess they both have advantage n disadvantages depending on what business and benefit but most importantly location
Communism and socialism looks good on paper. But as people always want to work themselves up and be better than others, this could never succeed.
5/6 years ago donald trump secured a $110B defense deal with saudi arabia with multiple us defense companies he created thousands of jobs of this historic defense contract with saudi arabia and need i remind you that these defense companies such as boeing, raytheon and lockheed are all non-state owned companies 👍 thousands of jobs created…point of the story
Communism and socialism only works till "they" run out of other people's money 😂
You are missing the point, we don't need socialism as it is defined in the books,but it's a fact that South African's economy needs both government intervention and the private sector, for example we can not allow only private sector to run public transport we need both private sector and government to provide transport for South African's workers.
If the government owns the land on behalf of the citizens, we can lease any piece of land to any investor who wants to invest in this country, Malema even makes the example that if you want to invest here the government must lease you land for free and yours as the investor to provide jobs and skills to the surrounding communities.
@@simphiwedlamini8243 your eff fascist malema’s economic policies are doomed to make south africa a banana republic the eff and the government has no bases to seize lands what is this? banana republic mentality only in africa…
You forget that all the local investment is here already, too many regulations in place to prosper and grow for local businesses never mind foreign investment.
If the local people are excluded from the benefits with the burden of damaging the enviroment by those companies it's useless.
The best way is to have a government that work in the best interest of its people.
Most educators, motivational speakers miss the first of 4 steps of competence, which is unconscious incompetence ... defined as "not knowing you are, in the specific area requiring competence, stupid=don't know... When you realize that in order for you to succeed, life long learning is beneficial and required for success competence and personal growth ...
No benefit visualized, no desire to learn ... don't miss the first step.
Very thoughtful as usuaĺ.
And jellytot Julius dares to mention greed. VBS! VBS! still no action
I'm not too sure where this seemingly scaremongering about Communism comes from, especially in SA, we don't an issue with this debate at all. But if its Katlego's pet Communism vs Capitalism debate, let it be. The ANC as a govt is pro-Capitalism, some leaders may say otherwise but as a governing party it has adopted neoliberal economic policies long ago, even though they carry the SACP which is not even distancing herself from such policies because ANC govt is an employer to Blade Nzimandes of this world.
It was interesting to hear one interviewee just near the end of the clip, Mr Adi Godrej saying something like 'other states have less factionalism... coalition leads...Gujurat state is a ONE party state, things tend to move faster' does that mean SA needs to be led by a one Party state to achieve it's economic goals, what becomes of multiparty democracy then. Does that mean the Chinese model works better because of being a ONE party state or is Coalition government going to help us at or as Adie Godrej put it that other government systems lead to factionalism and delays? I want to believe that these are pertinent questions that must be dealt with since they are relevant to our present political landscape.
The issue of trading rural land for development is another debate that is not informed by Communism vs Capitalism broad brush. It's communities themselves who are skeptical of the 'capital' in their land hence we have the Xholobeni Issue in the Eastern Cape where Amadiba Crisis Committee objected to mining in that space. Another rural community that is doing the same is Somkhele in the Northern KZN where Tendele Mining company extract coals, messing up with drinking water fro Mfolozi River. One prominent environmental activist, Fikile Ntshangase lost her life. In all these incidents not one political party has been involved but poor communities standing up for what they believe is not in their interests. In both case studies, Gwede Mantashe sided with investors. This notion that the ANC is pushing a Communist agenda is false. I'm not even a member of the ANC but we need to be factual, not raise irrelevant far off cases when relevant cases are here in SA.
I want to believe that these
True, the ANC is not pushing the communist agenda but they do make people depend on them. People will not care about making their lives better if the government will take care of them. And that screams communism.
But to be fair, they are not openly promoting it. They know what will happen if they go full blown communism and respect that🤣.
They do have some socialistic policies for sure (which I don't mind. Some people can't help themselves) but too much government is not good for anyone.
Good work keep it up
You should be our next President❤❤
Amin!!!
“If you are paid well” that’s the issue in many capitalist society people are rarely paid well. Capitalism is good but the way it is implemented today also has major issues which means the issue goes way deeper than these systems.
What if land owners would lease the land for some 20 or more years to industrial developers? Any factory after 10 years needs recapitalisation with new tech which is done via sale and not by reinvestment. So the problem is not with the industrial development per se but with the way the resources are redistributed., by the very politicians.
Iam 73 years old to make a Difference
I seem to be missing something! The majority of the farms are owned/run by Afrikaners but the Dutch/Holland did not colonise SA. The British did! So why 'ki LL the boer'? The anti-Rhodes demonstrations a few years ago quickly died when there was a threat to all the Rhodes scholarships ending! So the money was more important than the 'anti colonialism ' ideology which points to the need/desire for money. Surely this proves a leaning towards capitalism - no?
Go and read South African history especially the rise of Nationalist Party and who was their main priority.
Can jou also send these mess is outer langgwiges
I feel for the children.
Glad I don't have any.
The reason why the profit motive is harmful is because of the fundamental contradiction between the interests of capitalists and workers, as capitalists want to pay their workers as little as possible and work them as much as possible to increase profits, whereas workers want to be paid fairly and have their increased ...
In a capitalist company you're able to rise and get promoted. You're able to get skills. You're able to even start your own company. The profit motive is why you see these phones we still use to this day. It is the reason we see the planes . It's the reason the internet reached us in our countries. It's the reason why the standard of life is higher everywhere you find capitalism.
The profit motive does not only benefit the owners of the company.
It benefits the supervisors managers accountants etc so those people started at the bottom as laborers and assistants . This is the system where someone who was born poor is able to rise from nothing to become a millionaire just from having the right job or learning the right skills or selling the right products.
Being profitable allows for more factories to open without profit how do you buy more machinery. We can't have politicians who've never run sustainable companies telling us how to run an economy. Look at Cyril. He is rich but he has no clue how to make a company is made rich... Why? Because he didn't get rich from his own sweat. He didn't invent hence he is as useless as all of them
Capitalists will pay more if you're more skilled and more valuable. We can't have people who are unskilled earning millions of rands. In a capitalist system you earn what you eat.
That's a merit system.
@@CitizenConcernedI think there's a lot to be admired with a capitalist system. In countries like the US, it promoted competition which lead to innovation and further employment for its people. However the same system gave rise to monopolies which kill innovation by swallowing smaller companies reversing some of the earlier gains from the same system. The UK and US at present are dealing with the onset impacts of income inequality, high crime rates, big disparities between the top 1 percent and the working class, with an eroding middle class. All in this to say, a purely capitalist society without government intervention does not seem to be the answer. These countries have shown us what happens when you do that. Ours is to really study all these systems and come up with something that will not only bring prosperity for a certain period but one which will sustain that prosperity.
Thank you 😂😂