Redstone Thieves PART 2 - Gamers React and BBlocks RESPONDED!
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 05. 2024
- PART 3 IS HERE! • This Minecraft World S...
Patreon: / purplers
Discord: / discord
Twitter: / purplersmc
In this video I have more info on ShulkerCraft, as well as well as updates on Gamers React, BBlocks and Derpy Jhomes c: Steveee, ShulkerCraft Megamanny, PrakxisTheRedstoner, Skrynnik Dima and Derpy Jhomes didn't respond though :c
Need a Minecraft Server?
Get 25% OFF MCProHost using promo code: Purplers
mcph.to/purplers
Server IP: mc.synergyserver.net
Resource Pack: Vanilla Tweaks
Timestamps:
0:00 - Intro
0:36 - Acknowledgement
1:00 - Additional info on ShulkerCraft
2:55 - Small update on Derpy Jhomes
3:21 - Update on BBlocks
5:45 - Update on Gamers React
6:34 - Gamers React Discord weirdness
Music (in order of appearance)
Gareth Coker - Master Builder (Minecraft: Battle & Tumble OST)
TrackTribe - Running Errands
Patrik Patrikios - Know Myself
Joel Cummins - Looping Ascent
Freedom Trail Studio - Tempos Vari
Geographer - Alley Cat
13ounce - OKAY
Arcadia by Kevin MacLeod
Link: incompetech.filmmusic.io/song...
License: filmmusic.io/standard-license
LiQWYD - Night Out
Joe Bagale - Until We Meet Again - Hry
![[柴犬ASMR]曼玉Manyu&小白Bai 毛发护理Spa asmr](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/0TsXQ7z2Dh4/mqdefault.jpg)
Since the 13th of December 2020 all the tutorial videos are with credits and permissions from the original creators.
We can't change the past, but when we realized what we were doing wrong, we immediately changed that. We found it out by seeing some public posts on social media, instead of having the original Creators reaching out to us personally through DMs or emails to solve this.
Even the gold farm tutorial you showcased at 2:19 had permission from Gnembon, but you showcased it as we just took it. This is false. So we all make mistakes, but we learned from those and improved.
EDIT: As some people have pointed out in the replies, there are several examples after 13th December 2020 where you didn't ask permission. ShulkerCraft, you flat out lied. Do better.
As you said, we cannot change the past. However, one of the TMC community's main problems with your channel is that you wouldn't be where you are now without the people you ripped off. Sure, you may have tried to reform yourselves, but that doesn't change the fact that your brand was built off stealing, and your content strategy still bypasses the whole "designing" part, and goes straight to the "making a video" part. Most of your tutorials, both past and present use other people's stuff, which is why you are disliked at a fundamental level by many TMC members.
It's fair enough if you had Gnembon's permission, my bad there. However, you did not have ilmango's permission.
I honestly think no one has a problem with you making tutorials as long as one doesn't already exist. If one does who are simply stealing someone else's content
How about Vktec's mob switch which was uploaded on June 2021 ? There's a pinned comment on Vktec's video, where he claims that the tutorial was made without permission. Vktec also said that he had asked you to remove the video, which you didn't. Blatantly lying does not help the case.
Edit : The mob switch video seems to be removed after I posted this comment. I did check that video for the upload date before posting this comment.
And then there's Ilmango's bee farm, for which you uploaded a tutorial on March 21st 2021, which is way after December 2020. Knowing your relations with Ilmango, I can pretty confidently assume that Ilmango's design was taken without his permission.
@@Purplers Exactly. A businesses made from stolen money now works honestly is still a somewhat illegal business as it is where it is from the stolen money. In ur tutorial on Ianxo4's wither skeleton farm, u did ask for permission but u had made a flaw in the tutorial. Another way to give more credit to the original creator is to repeatedly credit them in the tutorial to make the viewers know that you didn't make the farm, but made the tutorial after asking their permission
That discord from Gamers React call rejection was the best thing ever.
Your name looks familiar…
I have a feeling that they would've threatened him or something along that line
No way your here too?
@@Jinx07 don't jump to conclusions like that, it's always what causes rumors.
@@qwart22 Same reaction and they're part of the 20 redstoners challenge video
I said this before and I'll say it again:
It's ridiculous how CZcams let these thieves get away with stealing contents from people like Mumbo Jumbo and 95% of the time get away with it but removes the dislike because "to stop harassing small CZcamsrs" BS.
Removing the dislike still makes no sense. Their reasoning is ridiculous.
@@theunknownonetuo2033 youtube rewinds💀
@@rjyo1236 They'll never admit that it was one of the reasons T_T
I mean, dislike button is quite a big deal in removing negativity spread in controversial topics, so I partly understand the reason. It is removing negativity in videos that *truly* deserves it, though, which is different story.
@@theunknownonetuo2033 yeah💀
Hear me out…
Steveee percent. Have a timer running to see how long it takes you to create an original flashy Minecraft contraption, then split, with the second segment being how long it takes for Steveee to steal it.
The polite side of me wants to say "poor stevee", but he deserves this comment, 100%
Well he steals from every one his entire community is based of stolen Co tent
This might be a joke, but its an actual fun idea
Aight time to get a world record babyyyyyyyyyy
Lol
make more redstone contraptions to make steveeee dont have time to build it
ShulkerCraft has responded, their comment shouldn't be too hard to find. I encourage you read the replies and not just what ShulkerCraft said, as it reveals a lot about their level of honesty in this matter.
Op
Hi
im pretty sure they deleted it lmao
@@fohziee9021 not deleted
I have a copper farm I built from a ShulkerCraft video and it was from it that I realized they don't actually know what they're doing and will change minor details from other creator's builds with major consequences, like saying something's safe to AFK while it has flaws that allow you to be killed in multiple ways. Definitely stay away from their tutorials, in my humble opinion.
fantastic video!
also i now see how immature my comment response was to that guy who stole from Kwipla lol. Will try to be better in the future!
@@mysticat Derpy Jhomes deserved it tbh
@@mysticat WOW LOL, are you 24 years old?
@@mysticat well he is right though, this website sucks a lot, just like tiktok you can steal anything and get away with it always and even if people notice it won't matter. basically that guy knows about it and just does it because it is easy money
@@mysticat actually I found it cool that you were defending Kwipla from that guy, I think it's useful if big creators like you expose him for what he is doing because at some point derpy jhomes will have to take action for what he has done
The BBlocks' 3x3 title is still misleading because the door opens in 0.85s and not 0.75s, but at least it doesn't claim to be fastest anymore lol
.75 old .9 new .85 newest?
0.7s old, 0.85s current, 0.8s newest
@@avogaado current is best system imo but newest seems more logical lol
@@Gekoloudios I think the current might be the most logical one, it means that a piston movement lasts 0.15s, so it's pretty easy to count the time, especially in 0-tick contraptions.
LMAO
Besides being entertaining, you're getting quite some mileage out of this! I think it's courageous of you to be bold and stand your ground with your claims. Furthermore, you are going the extra mile to help these channels do the right thing by chatting and giving pointers, and not leaving it to a critical youtube video. Amazing!
dico is not ded
pog
@@nieleletronica I mean his uploads still are....
unless...?
I’d rather give my view and comment to an honest person regardless of how it’s delivered
Damn, you are a blast from the past! Hope your doing well!
things I like about this guy:
intro only takes a few seconds.
doesn’t clickbait.
title actually describes video.
actually does research for the video.
yeah im subbin.
worth it.
These are the youtubers i like because
1.They get straight to the point
2.They go deep dive mode for proof,explanations and information
#meetoo
I subbed and liked
That discord call was very fishy, a while ago a good friend of mine posted a video, and I won't go into too much detail, but he somehow added myself and my friend to a discord call, and it had almost the same setup as the one in your video, those people were berating us, screaming slurs and telling us how bad our content is. I don't want to jump to any conclusions, however they seemed like they had rather ill intent, as it is eerily similar to what I experienced. Not to mention, I recognise some of their names/profiles and there seems to be some rather toxic content creators in that call. Anyway, great video, super informative, keep doing what you do best!
Where is that video?
it's a common manipulation/intimidation tactic on discord to gang up on someone in a call/vc to get them to feel bad or make poor decisions, so there is a high likelihood of this being the case i think.
This is also a theory I have about what I think they wanted to do
If I were you, I would play extremely loud noises trough my mic to make them alt f4
@@invertedmind8937 if someone is intimidated by someone minecrafters words they have way bigger problems than a discord call 🤣
I really appreciate you calling out these redstone thieves. I was in a gamers react video and only my Reddit was credited and I have only used it once. I will definitely make my own videos on this topic. Keep up the great work!
You make clickbate titles too. Your "fastest double piston extender" isn't the fastest at all and you leave your comments off so we can't complain...
@@BlackM. I don't see why you need to do this. I also changed it because I didn't have any time for research until today. Thanks for letting me know.
@@TeslaZoom why are your videos made for kids?
@@Kobe_Abogutal I'm not doing comments on my videos so might as well set it to that.
For now...
Hey there, I'm one of the commenters at 0:47 who was supporting Shulkercraft. I was not aware that it was more than a few incidents. I have since renowned myself and joined your side on Shullkercraft. He's definitely not as bad as steveeee, but not too far off, either. Shulkercraft should have done better, and I shouldn't have supported him.
@FootniteM69 True, their videos are high effort, but they still stole, and they should have known better.
@FootniteM69 ok? The main thing is the tutorial not the editing, and the tutorial part is stolen.
shulkercraft is a channel with two people not one
@FootniteM69 you sound like some apologist crap to me. get a grip, there's no ambivalence here, they stole other people's content and get deservedly called out for that. You defending them only outlines your lack of any morals or respect for other people's work.
you wouldn't mind sending me your paycheck every month too right? Since you don't mind people profiting off of the stuff others do, without proper crediting or reimbursement.
@@Flunksqk This. This is the best comment to explain this situation to anyone, even those who are not familiar with youtube and/or gaming at all. I'll use that to explain to my kids why they are not allowed to watch steveee anymore (and don't worry, I will credit you :D)
That Discord group part was so funny to me. I'm sure they were all talking shit about you, and in a heated moment they had the brilliant idea to rope you into a call to gang up on you. After you rejected the calls and they slept on it, they probably collectively realized how petty it was (or they thought you were too chicken) and they ghosted you. Either way, I hope they are very embarrassed, though I must admit that's highly unlikely.
That is kinda what happened though :v
@@CraftyMasterman how do you have no likes
@@user-lh5hl4sv8z I'll drop one
??? how did u even get to that conclusion???
except none of them knew what a time zone was lol
he used the minigame music yaaaaaay
CwaftyMwasterMan
Why u so down mate?
Wow, Derpy Jhomes response made me go crazy lmao
Welcome to CZcams
@@mabeldies2936 yes
Welcome to CZcams
Is there a link to the video with the comment response
well, he's a derp, coming out from his own name
Huge respect for pointing out additional info for stealing
Honestly Derpy Jhomes go far worse than kwipla, before he began stealing from Java people, he went after bedrock people until we came after him and the bow tie man who was unfortunately been stolen from countless times.
I really cant believe I looked up to derpy when I was a child
Same....
That guy too noob at redstone, that he begins his videos saying "This is java edition, I DON'T KNOW if it works on bedrock". Anyone with the slightest bit of redstone knowledge would know that stuff like QC and block spitting are java exclusive features. 🤦🏻♂️
Not surprising given his reply to Kwipla's comment
@@vibaj16 yeah.. hes a really scummy youtuber
That Derpy Jhomes reply is really bs and unfortunately, in the Philippines, plagiarism isn't taken that seriously so people who tend to steal ideas or works from anyone can get away easily. Also, people there don't really tend to fact-check so they really are prone to being tricked. 🤦🏻♀️
Im from the Philippines and we dont accept him🤦
People just don't care about plagiarism in the Philippines. Even I don't, for the sake of not adding too much to my presentation worth 500 words long.
Talking about plagiarism here will just yield you middle fingers.
@@TRD6932 regardless, of how not taking it seriously is "culturized" it's still wrong in the first place
@@TRD6932 I'm sure you are being taught how not to plagiarize, right? Because if you keep doing that, most specially if you're writing thesis, it will bite you in the ass, big time. Plagiarism shouldn't be tolerated, normalized and culturized in the first place. It's still a form of theft. Also, I don't really care if I get middle fingers, I'm already used to Filipino bullshittery considering I am Filipino as well.
@@user-ry6im8ko2c exactly, besides, schools are teaching students how not to plagiarize works of other people.
Man, the production quality just keeps on getting better :D Another super important video, thanks for the update and bringing more attention to this topic!
I really like this style of documentary videos that you have used for this series, great story telling, editing and voice overlay. Can't wait for part 3 :)
damn purple be gaining the attention of major people
I was a subscriber of bblocks when he had around 3k subs. His content was really neat and well made so i was supportive. But when his videos started to blow up, he started to post more and more clickbaity and misleading thumbnails and comments of mine started getting lost in thousands of other comments. And here we are. 2 million subscribers and still using the non-minecrafty stair opening that somehow opens in a diagnol only using redstone in every other thumbnail. Its sometimes suprising how much people change.
these videos are so nice, really polished audio and video, and it's also for a really great cause. excited to see what is to come (whether it is another video like this, or a normal redstone video)
You're doing this community a great service and many people are noticing it! Also, that Discord call was just a bit bizarre.
I don't understand how its bizarre at all. theyre prob playing some dumb group game and needed an extra person to join, and nobody was online except him.
These two videos make me realize how serious copyright is. Thank you for making this video!
my man, your hardwork is just amazin, saw some of your vids, you show the sufferings of the community and try to resolve it, earned a sub, thanks a lot bro!
Love your videos, just found your channel and I’m glad I did
3:16 This is gotta hurt knowing someone is gonna always copy your work, and get more views out of it.
i love these videos keep up the good work on redstone
Dude these vids just keep getting better ngl I watched all ur content it’s all good
This series was actually really helpful for me as a way to plan out how I could best credit other CZcamsrs as someone who wants to start making minecraft videos. I mean, that and anything that exposes shulkercraft im down for.
Really cool and informative video, ur vids are really well made and well explained, you gained a sub :)
I love how he defined his friends keep this good work
Amazing video, I was waiting for gamers reacts response
The créme de la créme of this video is the subtitles. It just makes the video a lot more interesting, and I WANT to fucking understand the narrator's words. Has anyone pointed out how good the subtitles are yet?
your voice is so soothing
Derpy Jhomes is a Pilipino and as a one myself Derpy is not that different from almost everyone else regarding to the internet. Philippines internet culture is very toxic. There's a lot that can be said to Pilipino content creators or our internet culture over all but it just makes me more ashamed of my nationality.
Agree but not all
@@itsakill1992 if you read what blockshift has stated, none of it generalizes that every Filipino in the internet is the same. It just so happens that most of them are
Yeah same, but not all Pilipino creators are like that
@@netheriteshovel1526 yea but a large sum are, as I try to justify stolen redstone people tend to use their nationality as an excuse, and almost all of that nation is blind to what potential small redstoners had having mumbo the center of attention when it comes to redstone. This is coming from a Filipino Creator and I have seen worse in other media platforms especially tiktok
@@EmmanuelPlayz its giving us Filipinos a bad reputation because of these "content creators"
I had no idea until the first part of the video and the second part of the video. This certainly shifts my view on CZcams Redstone building tutorials. Thanks.
I'm glad you made these videos!
Man I am saying this, that underrated youtubers like you deserve more of almost everything so yeah I am a new viewer in your channel and that's a sub from my side keep up the good work and don't give this content. Love this content and about to be best viewer of all time.
Small CZcamsrs ( and big CZcamsrs ) deserves to be credited for the work they put into their designs.
Absolutely. You’d think with how those clowns often don’t credit the person, it would be difficult to do
That’s true.
You are doing great work, keep it up
thank you for elaborating on shulkercraft! i will make sure i do my research next time i want to build a farm :)
At this point, if these tutorial creators actually start asking the original creators if they can make a tutorial on their farm, they're mostly gonna get a no due to their history of stealing redstone
It hurts so much when you find out you were once a fan of a redstone thief.
Nice video!
That video is how I found your channel so hey now a part 2 is cool
I hope these videos give more recognition so people can start watching what was originally created instead of what is stolen giving the youtubers who stole less views, and making them stop stealing from others
My estimation is that they will 1: say sorry and do absolutely nothing after saying sorry, 2: they say sorry and credit form now on
Now lemme watch to see if I’m right
Oh some of them actually credited wow
A good redstonner and farm maker 'Logicalgeekboy' who have made many good design.
Shulkercaft copied this does and gave credits almost 4-5 design were copied.
Thier videos performed well than Logicalgeekboy's.
Atlast he told them not to copy or showcase any of his design again but the Shulkercaft are still coping his build.
Please support him 🙏🙏
When LGB commented on Shulkercraft's video, all he received was a ton of negative comments from SC fans.
Bruh, you deserve some more love from Minecraft community, because you did amazing job exposing those CZcamsrs
4:08 the thumbnail is a representation of what happens when you build it wrong
4:39 is that the intro of "the bee movie"?
0:30 hey that's a familiar frog
that's a good one, keep up the great work
I like your videos because it have good quality and most importantly, subtitles
3:08 mumbo jumbo actually made a triangle door 4 years ago
3:13 MYSTICAT LMAO
I really appreciate you highlighting this. I wasn't aware of how wide spread video theft was in the minecraft community. I definitely will look a little deeper at the videos I watch and if someone gives credit to the original uploader I will purposely go watch their video instead.
Thanks for this! People really need to be held accountable!
I once accidentally watched a bootleg trident farm tutorial, and it didn't even work cause the idiot who stole it didn't mention the biome.
your voice is amazing btw
GREAT VIDEOOO KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK!!
Its great, really. Finally seeing some people change up their ways, its good. This may be a start of a new revolution, if people start doing these more often.
Thanks for bringing light to this matter I made redstone builds sometimes(I don't make videos)and I know how hard it is to come up with a design from scratch it's really aweful that you guys grind that much hours and then someone just reuploads your video and doesn't even credit you.Hope this stops
I don't really view BBlocks' thumbnail as clickbait, it looked like it was just meant to display a setpiece of a piston door in the middle of opening and it doesn't really make it look more enticing to me, but I think it's really lazy to not just do a picture of the actual door in the middle of opening instead of a weird setpiece.
By what I have seen in this video: you are a legend!
Btw, love this partially internet historian style in the middle!
Love how you change the music for the youtuber
3:02 he deleted the comments on that video, all comments left are positive and kids asking for shoutout smh
I'm a gamers react fan and I'm glad he actually was understanding and started crediting people!
With this you definitely earned my sub. Very cool Video
Insanely well made video!
Really nice to see actual accountability finally happening. It hasn't happened to me but I know I'd be upset. Gg
The tech/redstone community is growing. And with videos like this, people will think twice before stealing a design. They should know that there are concerned people who are ready to expose their scumminess.
Waiting for Part 3 🙂
Amazing video!
Purpledragonnuke i love CZcamsrs who take time and make really good videos, and you even changed many peoples mind! KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK
7:04 that is so freaky idk why with the pfp
Mango will be proud of you ❤️
Great video!
Thanks for making youtube a better place
if Derpy Jhomes makes his OWN tutorials, maybe Kwipla can copy them and if he comments just have him say "welcome to the youtube world :)"
At 4:24 there's a guy saying hello
The part with the Discord call and you clicking the reject button multiple times then switching to do not disturb is very relatable xD
Thank you for talking about this problem. The thieves are getting so much credit for free. I spend a lot of time designing my circuits and it feels really unfair.
I love how everyone refers to Shulkercraft as "him" but in reality theres multiple people contributing to the channel
You are the Minecraft DJ cook
Yooo another Dj cook fan
I just found this channel and my mind died in the first second
I have all the respect for you redstone gods I also want to be very good at redstone just to feel compete in myself but I am afraid of uploding my own Redstone designs that are petty good but I dont want anyone to still it.
Finally people are showing how evil other CZcamsrs can be
Damage was done, slimy as it was, I am very glad that you at least got some responses. My channel may be very slow to grow but that is because I have a conscience...I would never do what they had done. Very unethical behavior on their part. I continue to pass on this information with the people I collab with so they can also pass it along. I still hope that these unscrupulous channels get what they deserve...instant kharma. Thank you for keeping us informed and for all you and the guys you collab with do 😊👍
eating popcorn whilst watching this, nobody needs to know this but im putting it here anyway
As long as You ( Puplers ) are correct in the blaming. I for one, love the fact that you are calling out these people. Making Vods are hard enough to make. When they are your ideas. That makes it even harder of a pill to swallow! I get a lot of my build ideas from great content creator here on CZcams. But I don't make Vods out on CZcams and clam them to be mine. I just use them in my game play. And I still tell people whom I get the build from. So as long as you keep up the great work. I'll stay around!!
2:00 the same goes for every single Ianxofour which are explained BETTER in the original videos. MUCH BETTER
Fun fact:Gamers React acctually got things submitted by viewers and some people clips and gives gamers react a clip without the original owners permition so basicly sometimes its not the youtubers fault but its their viewers fault
Its still Gamers react's responsibility to go through and give ALL credits where they are available to be given, even if they are submitted by fan's.
Yo, I dont mean to be weird but i love ur voice!
You sound soo soothing :)
also, your skin is really cool.
These videos gave me a lot to think. I'm an average Minecraft player who uses a lot of tutorials from those guys, cuz I don't have much time to actually design my own farm models.
After seeing this, I can't help but feel kinda guilty of copying farms in my world. In a way it encourages me to take time to create my own designs, but the tutorials are pretty handy some times.
I understand all the arguments and totally agree with them, but when I want to build a mega complex gold farm for example, some times i don't even have the actual knowledge to understand the explanation video.
Guess the best way to make part of the technical community is actually making technical stuff yourself. (Which segregates the community in a way, but that's something else)
The Hasanabi's of Minecraft. Hope this series continues. Thanks for explaining the Shulkercraft thing in more detail, I've dealt with some of the shulkerstans in the past (defending Ilmango and how it removes views from his channel etc) and it wasn't particularly pleasant - just got too exhausting in the end.
@@PYBR0 Hasan steals content from other content creators and profits off of it without crediting the original creators. As was the case with JayExci's videos.
Good vid.Also i still defend shulkercrafts if do people check description maybe they go to the maker and if the maker stealed the redstone maybe he did put the creator or redstone maker so bassicaly he puts the maker .
But i agree in his old vids he didnt put credits
Good vid.
You really don't get anything from being mentioned somewhere in the video description. I don't get why you would defend someone that got big by ripping people off.
There's unfortunately nothing you can do if somebody decides to steal your minecraft build and make money with it, but that doesn't mean it's right. I never agreed to my work being used on his channel.
if someone is already 20seconds into the SC copy-paste video, are they REALLY gonna go to the description and click through to the original creators video and start watching that instead? cmon. adding some "credit" in the description or even on screen isnt really the point here. besides, they built their channel on copying farms. only in the last year or so theyve also diluted the content with clickbaitey junk videos about infinite diamonds? superflatworld? wow. amazing technical redstone channel eh?
end of the day, theyre just repackaging someone elses hard work and creativity. if the original farm design video didnt exist, SC would have nothing at all to work with. no amount of "production quality" would work as theres no content there in the first place
its a shame that shulker did like this, prolly better would been for them to contact you for potential partnership since apparently for some people his tutorials are easier.@@ilmango
Yooo hypee I love this idea
8 love how at 0:38 the bee just banishes itself to the shadow realm
What about BBlocks stealing MagmaMusen's video design? I know it isn't related to redstone but thats art, a thing that shouldn't just be copied.
If gamers react is friends with Baba I'm concerned 6:55
dang why do you have 53 k subs? you are an amazing redstoner and i use your videos to troll all of my friends. i seriously hope you get even more popular than you already are. anyways have a good day!